Actions

Work Header

Prayers to Broken Stone

Chapter 11

Notes:

Trigger Warning: this chapter contains thoughts of suicide, as well as some other generally disturbing images and themes. Still PG-13 in its rating, but if you are sensitive to such things then please proceed with caution.

Chapter Text

Its head came up at the clang and clatter and it took off, body hunched low to the ground as it sniffed out its prey. It smelled gold and power, wool and earth. It smelled fear. Fear that stank in the sweat of the creature, newly sprung when it had wrapped its claws round the quarry and brought it close. 

The scent weakened even as it pursued and it snarled and snapped in fury, gnashing its teeth at being so eluded. Once the sound of clanging gold ceased, the trail faded all but entirely— its senses were not yet so keen that it could track by scent alone, but that would change. In time it would become huge, growing into size and power that would make its enemies quake.

There was no trace of its prey amongst the gold: the scent was cold, so it stormed away from there, prowling back up the stairs to the camp hidden amongst the platforms. It sniffed at the site, smelling charcoal and meat, the sharp tang of mint that puzzled its senses and masked its prey’s scent. The source was a vial of oil and the creature kicked it aside its fury, where it smashed on the stone below. Then it returned to the door of the treasury, where it had first lost the trail, and ducked out into the halls.

It followed the remnants of the scent trail as if it were a golden thread winding through the halls, noting with frustration how it became dimmer with each minute. It passed through long corridors and across bridges suspended over darkness. A chair sat in the middle of the great chamber, a stalactite reaching from the vault above to touch it like a benediction. It was carved from an obelisk of stone, and in the center was crowned with a single empty socket. The creature spared this only a glance.

It hungered for gold.

The scent waned further in the great open halls, the wind from deep within the earth muddling and confusing the trail. It was no tracking hound to pick up even the faintest odor, nor could even the keen eyes of a hawk have tracked bare feet over barren stone. It turned on its heels, surveying the halls for some sign of its prey. Pathetic dead things crouched in corners, the slow decay of time reducing their bodies and clothes to dust. It ignored them. They were of no use even to feed upon.

Its thoughts were instead filing with visions of fresher meat. Of falling upon its prey, descending from the heights, first blows to the hamstrings and neck, immobilizing and killing it in seconds, the taste of salt and iron. Or it could choose to be slow, to drag the pleasure out. It could seize its treasure before the prey’s dimming eyes and laugh as it did so, though it remembered little of why this would be, save that its prey was a thief and had something it desired. Already it could taste the blood on its lips and throat, and its claws curled at the thought.

Hours it searched. It tore rotting wood from rusted hinges, scoured rooms piled with the long dead, but the scent was cold. The siren call of the precious golden object was silent, as if it had returned to sleep after rousing itself only briefly. Still the creature wandered in hopes of rediscovering the scent, in and out of rooms without a care for their purpose.

The night had come and gone when it first began to feel ill at ease. There was a sound in its mind, like a bird beating its wings against a closed window. It stood in a room lined with great shelves like walls, filled with burnt paper and cracked clay. It had caught a scent here, faint as starlight, of the precious golden treasure that had escaped its grasp. The stacks called to it, for they held many hiding places where its prey might go to ground. The scent was maddening, tantalizing, and just out of reach.

But then the pain began. It gave a low, whimpering groan and clutched its head. There was a sound like glass breaking as it stumbled out of the library. Awareness was returning, memories dropping into its bloodthirsty mind like tesserae, building a mosaic that, piece by piece, turned hunger to sickened horror.

Yet one memory did not replace another. Would that it had. Instead it only filled in the blank spaces between them. First there was the headache, but the nausea that followed was no result of illness.

Thorin came awake in a body twitching with agony and a mind dripping horror. He remembered standing within the crater, sensing something that did not belong there, thinking it was the claw of Bilbo’s theory. He remembered tracing the scent back, back, like following a golden thread, to Bilbo. He remembered the thread snapping tight, pulling at him, pulling at his mind until he stood outside of himself. Then it was no longer Bilbo in front of him but a thief, prey that must be pursued. Devoured. Then Bilbo vanished, somehow, into the air itself but the gold thread did not. It tugged at him, at his soul itself, and the creature had known it must give chase.

The trickle of memories became a torrent, images flooding his mind without mercy. Of looking upon his dead kin and wondering if he might feed upon them, jaws champing through crumbling bones and blood turned to dust in their veins.

Thorin fell to his knees, retching. No flames this time, only the chemical bile and whatever remained of the meal from the day before. Only a day? The memory mocked him, of the warm fire and the savory meal that made the sickness no longer seem insurmountable. Of gentle hands and quiet laughter, and Bilbo…

Thorin gagged again as the memory fell into place: memories of what end he had planned for Bilbo. Torturing him and stealing the treasure he carried, before Thorin would turn his claws upon him and watch with delight as those eyes clouded with death.

He retched again, and in a sudden, cold-sweat soaked moment of clarity, Thorin wondered if this would always be his family’s lot. Would his line always be cursed to devour their own over trinkets, blood dripping from their jaws even as their fingers grasped for more, for jewels and gold and lordship, like a spider that ate its young?

Thorin hunched over, stomach twisting, and saw Thrór struggling in his arms as he dragged his grandfather from the treasury. How he had turned on his grandson after, wrath blazing in his eyes, swinging his fists, his teeth bared like an animal. Was it not only fitting then that he should follow that path? To destroy the living in order to lock hands around dead, cold metals and crystallized minerals? Fitting that they lose what they love, they who are not fit to carry it?

What good were his visions of glory now? He, who had dreamt of reclaiming Erebor for his people, returning to them the works of their hand, now he clung to the gold himself as Smaug had, had threatened the lives of his companions if they did not obey him. And look what he had become. The monster that haunted the halls of Erebor. Who had he once been? Where was the prince who had dreamed of home?

Thorin could no longer see him. He could not see anymore where his own thoughts began and the alien ones, dripping with blood and gold, ended. He was falling, melting into the creature that consumed his flesh and he could feel it, that distant roar of the wind when there was not a breath in the air, and knew it for the wings of its coming. Distant still, but for how much longer? How long until he fell to it again, and woke with Bilbo’s blood on his claws and the flesh of his own people in his belly?

Thorin would not sit idle and wait for an answer to this question. There was a blade he remembered well among the hoard. A silver poniard without edge, only a wicked point that he had seen punch through the finest steel plate armor.

A blade well suited for his final service to Erebor.


Bilbo slept in the library, leaving the ring on through the night. The gray mist swirled like morning fog and he knew soon as he woke that he was not alone.

He shifted, silent and creeping, to look over the edge of the alcove where he’d made his bed the night before. The stone around his resting place was scorched black and scrawled with claw marks, and he hoped it wasn’t too much of an omen. A gold statue had once made its home here, before Smaug dragged it off to the hoard. With any luck he’d fair better.

A figure detached itself from the shadows below, moving through the dust and fallen shelves, head turning this way and that at he sampled the air. Then his head turned and he looked up. Thorin’s face was caught in one of the chains of golden light that fell from the tiny points in the ceiling high above and Bilbo’s heart sank at the sight. The black scales now covered his back, shoulders and chest. Only a pale spot over the heart remained of the skin on his body, as far as Bilbo could tell. Of his face it was as if he wore a half-mask, the left side dark with black scales, the right side still the face Bilbo knew, but the scales wrapped around Thorin’s throat like a collar, disappearing into his beard. His eyes glinted even in the sunlight, until he passed again into darkness.

Bilbo eased back into the alcove, pressing against the cold stone wall and out of sight. He could hear the ruffle of crumbled paper and scrape of claws from Thorin’s steps as they paced this way and that. Then a terrible, whimpering groan and the steps were moving away again, back to the door, and were gone.

Bilbo released a long, shuddering breath but did not yet dare move from his hiding place. He must soon though: there had been no time to bring his pack and while the road had trained him to go a day, perhaps two, without collapsing from hunger it would mean failing reflexes, fuzzy thinking, and weakness of body that he could ill afford. He could not outlast Thorin, even without the curse. He must make his move, and soon. He had to get back to the door, to get out and find Gandalf. There was only one problem: with only the hidden door left for getting out of Erebor, he would have to get past Thorin and the treasury first.

A simple matter, he told himself. Hobbits were light and quick on their feet, and he was invisible to boot. It was only a matter of slipping by Thorin now as he had before.

Then again, nothing on this journey had ever been simple.

An hour more he waited before breaking from his hiding place, spending the time until then drifting in and out of a doze to save energy. Once out in the hall he found the nearest fountain, drinking his fill of the icy mountain water that still flowed through the city. It took the edge off and cleared his head, though he could feel, like a slowly descending blade, hunger as it teased at the edge of his senses. He had until sunset before that tease became a distraction.

Bilbo tried the other doors first: the great entrance hall, and the parapet where they had gone out to meet Thranduil and Bard, what felt like a lifetime before. All were closed off, locked down by slabs of stone that had fallen across the entrance: the defense mechanism of the mountain that Thorin had triggered, of no use against a dragon all those years before, but certainly impossible for a hobbit to pass. There may have been more exits, but Erebor was vast and he did not like the idea of becoming lost somewhere in its depths. No, he’d rather face Thorin than that. He felt a strange unease at the thought of those darkened caverns, at the memory of lantern eyes and the creeping creature that made its home beneath the Misty Mountains. How easy it might be to put on the ring and slink away, down into the depths…

Bilbo shook his head to clear it of the image, having no time for such odd musings. His thoughts was haunted enough as it was. There was no company now to keep his mind from dwelling on the bodies that lined the halls and rooms of the city. Mummified by time or charred by fire, at first they frightened Bilbo to his marrow, his imagination conjuring images of the risen dead, watching him as he passed, appearing in doorways or from behind darkened corners, reaching for him with crumbling fingers.

But he was a kindly soul, and it was not long before they only made him sad. There were so many, and too many of them were children, clutching mothers or each other in their final moments. There were rooms where corpses were piled by the door in their last effort to hold back their doom. It made him sick, and it made him angry, and not for the first time since the fire-drake fell over Laketown he felt a fierce satisfaction at the creature’s death, more than simple relief. He thought then too that he understood something more of Thorin’s rage. The thought of a dragon attacking his beloved Shire… His stomach roiled for he could see it all too clearly, the Party Tree burning, firing raining down from the sky. Bilbo shook his head once, then again violently for he felt he might be ill. He forced himself onward until he came to ceilings that vaulted like the sky itself, and found himself in the throne room. There, he froze.

Thorin stood before the throne.

It meant that, beyond him, the way was clear. Bilbo could make a dash now, through the treasury and up the stairs to the hidden door. There would be no way for Thorin to stop him, he could be free of these halls and down in the camp before noon.

Yet something drew him aside, drew him forward. The fell energy which had given Thorin size, that made him seem a monster in dwarven form, was gone. Thorin’s shoulders were bowed and he was hunched forward, holding something in his hands as he gazed up at the throne. Bilbo crept forward up the stairs and down the long path, telling himself he still had a good head start should he need to run. After all, Thorin could not see him.

“I know you are there, Bilbo,” Thorin said. Bilbo’s breath caught and his heart thundered as he stilled. “I smell you. Strange, that after so long on the road, and after so many foul things have befallen us, you still carry the scent of your home. Pipeweed and earth are not so common down here. I would know you in the dark.” He turned, exposing the good side of his face as he looked back. All life had fled his eyes. “I would know you if I were blind.” His brow drew together as if from some inner agony. “There is no need to hide; you will soon be free of this place. I ask only that I may look upon you one last time. It… seems I am always asking you for what I do not deserve.”

It was then Bilbo saw the silver poniard in Thorin’s hand. It had thin, edgeless blade with a deadly point that was now pressed to the soft spot above Thorin’s heart. Even as all wisdom and better sense told Bilbo this was a ploy to make him reveal himself, the sight of the blade drowned those voices out in a rush of terror. Bilbo dragged off the ring off and clenched it in his hand.

Thorin’s eyes widened as he appeared. “Even now?” he breathed.

“Thorin, please. Whatever you’re about to do, stop it,” Bilbo said, advancing a step. He held his hands open and flat in front of him, the ring pinched between thumb and forefinger.

Thorin’s expression closed. “I spent all the night and morning hunting you, all because I heard a golden voice calling to me, naming you my enemy,” Thorin said, his voice hollow. “You were right to flee.”

“No, no I wasn’t. I should have stayed instead of running like a…  I should have helped. Better yet, I should never have brought you back to the gold, Thorin. I am as much to blame here as you,” Bilbo said.

“It was as good a plan as any…” Thorin said but Bilbo was already shaking his head violently.

“It was a terrible plan. It was the worst… we should have just forgotten it entirely. Thorin, I wanted the plan to fail. I wanted you to admit we needed Gandalf. It was a trick, and I’m sorry. Please just… tell me you’re angry with me and put that away. There’s still time.” Anger did indeed fall over Thorin’s face, some of that suspicion that had darkened his eyes when they spoke of Bilbo’s theft, but then it simply… dissolved, swallowed by exhaustion, and that haunted shadow returned.

“Time?” Thorin echoed. “Had I found you I would not only have killed you. I would have tortured you. Devoured you.” Bilbo swallowed and Thorin’s eyes caught the movement, and became empty and horribly blank. “I have befouled the halls of my fathers, imagined…the dead….”

Thorin looked up then, the good side of his face pale and sickened. Then the horror fell back, pushed away, and in its place was a sort of weary resolve. His voice became gentle. “Tell me, is that ring the manner in which you saved us from Thranduil’s dungeon, and many times beside?”

Bilbo nodded, feeling cold and sick, desperate to keep Thorin talking if only to stay his hand another moment longer. “I found it in the goblin tunnels.”

“My clever burglar, ever resourceful,” Thorin murmured fondly.

Bilbo took another step forward, but despaired of reaching Thorin before he plunged the sword into his own heart.  “I would give it to you freely, if you would only stop this.”

Thorin stilled at his words, then shook his head and turned his gaze back to the sword in his hand. “I do not wish it. Keep it, and let it not be said that Thorin Oakenshield became no better than Smaug in his final hours.”

“No one will say that,” Bilbo said desperately, edging forward. Thorin’s back stiffened at his words, his hands tightening around the hilt.

“No, they will not.” Thorin looked away then, up at the great throne. As he did something in his expression changed, became at once noble and at peace. He looked up with something approaching awe at the great stone chair before him, the tension easing from his shoulders, as if remembering where he was, what had been gained and what had been lost in the taking of it, all encapsulated in the throne before him, and the sword in his hand.

“Farewell, good thief. I go now to the halls of waiting to sit beside my fathers, until the world is renewed. I go with sword in hand, falling in defense of my home, if not in the manner I once thought.” A drop of blood welled beneath the silver point and trailed down his skin, a shock of red against the gray and black of his body, until it was lost amongst the scales. 

“Stop!” Bilbo cried, taking a step forward. “Thorin, please wait. Let me fetch Gandalf, let me bring him here. He will break the curse, I know it. It’s not too late.” Closer now, Bilbo could see the edge of Thorin’s face, saw him smiling.

“Always your advice is good, and it is my own folly that I choose to ignore it. There is no shame in having failed in this errand, not when it was doomed from the start.”

“You don’t know that,” Bilbo insisted.

“I do,” Thorin said, his head lifting. “This curse is the work of the Enemy, the first and greatest Enemy, and there is no power left on Middle-Earth that can match him. It was foolish of me to think otherwise.”

Bilbo shook his head in denial, for he remembered laughter by the fire and the scent of mint, how the fell light had dimmed from Thorin’s when he looked at Bilbo. “I don’t believe that. If you had been so certain you would have done this before. You would never have searched for a cure with me, or come with me to find the claw.”

“It was as good an attempt as any and you, my burglar, always do seem to find a way out of impossible situations,” Thorin said, and his smile changed, no longer so sad. The smile touched only half his face, but it brought with it a light like the sun breaking through a storm, and Bilbo’s heart shuddered and cracked in his chest. The first tears welled in his eyes and, for a moment, blurred Thorin from his sight before they made their burning trails down his cheeks.

“Then let me try once more, please, just once more,” Bilbo said, his voice breaking.

Thorin shook his head. “There is no time. Once the sickness has consumed me I will not care for you, or my kin, or even the mountain, only for claiming the treasures of these halls. I will be a servant of evil. Let me die instead as I am.”

“I can’t do that, I can’t!” Bilbo choked and tried coming closer again but Thorin turned, holding up a hand.

“You no longer need to fear for me, Bilbo, only let me go. I would not have my last sight of you be your tears.”

“No,” Bilbo said, biting off each word. “I will never forgive you if you do this, Thorin, never as long as I live. Put the sword down.”

Thorin’s expression became grim. “Then perhaps I have found the one thing you cannot forgive.”

Thorin readied the sword, and something snapped within Bilbo and he found himself running. He slipped the ring onto his finger, barely registering Thorin’s look of surprise at his vanishing again. Thorin had only just managed to turn around when Bilbo slammed into him, driving his shoulder into Thorin’s stomach, sent the sword flying from his hand at the impact.

The two tumbled forward and he heard the crack as Thorin’s head hit the floor. A shudder ran through Thorin’s body and his eyes rolled in his head as he went limp. Bilbo snatched the sword from the ground and threw it as far as he could. It flew, streaking silver, end over end through the air before disappearing into the abyss beyond the walkway, like a shooting star vanishing into the night.


Here the stone images
Are raised, here they receive
The supplication of a dead man's hand
Under the twinkle of a fading star.