Actions

Work Header

Prayers to Broken Stone

Chapter 12

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

Thorin awoke unable to move. Even the act of raising his head drew an answering tug at his wrists, and he tried to force himself forward only to be dragged back. He opened his eyes, and shut them again quickly as a blinding light assaulted him, sending pain like a knife through his skull. Thorin went still; eyes screwed shut, breathing shallowly through his nose as he tried to take stock of his situation. He could feel vaguely, as if through thick leather armor, that a rope bound his wrists to either side of him, and with a clever knot at that, for when he pulled at one hand, the other was pulled away in the opposite direction.

The present had not yet filtered back and he thought nothing of the thick covering on his arms, only wondered how he might break the ropes. There too was the question of who had done this, and when he had been captured, and where he had been imprisoned. A wave of nausea roiled over him, like standing on the deck of a tossing ship, and his vision sparkled behind his eyelids. 

“Thank goodness you’re awake,” said a voice softened by relief. Thorin’s head jerked up and he felt the hard tug at his shoulders and arms pulling him in either direction. He finally managed to open his eyes and squinted at the blur of blue that sat before him against gray stone. A cave? And…his burglar. Yes, the voice had been Bilbo’s. Some of the panic left Thorin then, for if Bilbo was there then already there was hope.

“How came we here?” Thorin mumbled, his tongue thick in his mouth and a taste like charcoal at the back of his throat.

“It’s all right. We won’t be here long. I just wanted to make sure you woke up. That was a nasty knock on the head you took there.” There was a watery quality to Bilbo’s voice, as one being cheerful despite recent tears. Thorin tried to open his eyes wider but the dizziness struck again and he flinched.

“How long until we can escape? Or are you bound as I am?” Thorin said. He heard a faint sound like a hiccough.

“No, I am free,” Bilbo said and never had Thorin heard such misery in his voice.

“Then unbind me so we may both leave this place,” Thorin said. His vision was clearing now, and though he twisted against the ropes he felt no pain against his wrists; a small blessing. There was something about the shape of the room they were in: dark on either side, with stone upon the floor and steps leading away. He was seated on something hard, a chair of some sort and of dwarven height for his feet were settled on the ground before him. He had seen a room like this once, from this vantage point too, long ago.

“I’m sorry, I can’t,” Bilbo said, and his voice broke. “I must go, but I will be back with help.”

“Where are we? You have not answered my question.”

“Oh, Thorin, I’m sorry…” Bilbo finally released a sob, strangled as if had been hard suppressed, fought off and fought down through every word he spoke, finally breaking free. It rose in Thorin an answering fear and he knew he must look, though the dim light strike his eyes like a blow. He forced them open, peering at his surroundings.

Great stone pathways stretched before him and the ceiling arched above, supported by enormous pillars taller than any tree. The halls of his fathers, the halls of his childhood. He knew this place, this dais, for many times indeed had he stood upon it.

He sat upon the throne of his grandfather. Bound there, rather, and the rope was knotted around the back of the stone chair. Above him the empty socket of the Arkenstone shadowed the stone like a missing eye. Bilbo knelt at his feet, looking up at him, his eyes bright and red-rimmed from crying. And all came rushing back.

“There was nowhere else and I was afraid you would hurt yourself when you woke up.” Bilbo wrung his hands as he spoke. “Now if you could just wait here while I go for help—”

“Did you do this to mock me?” Thorin said, his voice soft and dangerous.

“I—what?” Bilbo said. He had half risen to his feet and now stared, stopped in his tracks.

“I remember now. What I have become. What I was prepared to do, rather than dishonor the memory of my fathers, allowing a dragon once more into these halls.” Thorin said. “And you placed me on the throne.”

“There was nowhere else!” Bilbo protested. “What could I have done, dragged you down to the dungeons? Put you in a wheelbarrow?”

“You might have cast me into the darkness and let me die as I wished,” Thorin shot back. “Instead of defiling my grandfather’s seat!”

“When will you get it through your head that I’m trying to save your life?”

“When will you understand that I do not wish it? Do you think this is a kindness?” Thorin hissed. “Do you think you are aiding me by continuing this cursed existence? Look at me!” He pulled forward against the ropes and Bilbo flinched away. “I will not allow another monster to rule beneath the mountain!”

“And you won’t have to!”

“I will! This will be my legacy if we do not end this now. Soon my will shall no longer be my own. I cannot know when this madness will strike again or what I will do when it comes upon me. With every hour it draws nearer—do you not understand? There is no hope for me!” Thorin said in a pained snarl.

Bilbo faltered and looked at Thorin as if seeing something in the far distance, something receding with every moment. “Then what would you have me do? I cannot release you, or help you in ending your life, nor will you accept help in saving it. So, what would you have me do? What do you want?” Thorin took a deep breath, abjurations and commands coming to his mind and poised upon his lips…

…And fell away.

They say the dying may speak truth long hidden, at a time when all secrets and pride cease to have any meaning. So then fell Thorin’s many walls of silence, the cloak of solitude required of leadership that may have always in part been a crutch. He would have reached out then to run a hand down Bilbo’s face, to raise his chin and bid him look at Thorin in those final hours while he still bore his own face. Yet bound as he was, he could not, and so only spoke with what gentleness remained in him. “I want you to stay with me. Until the end.”

As Thorin met Bilbo's eyes he willed him to understand this final request, the depth of necessity and shame that brought him to it, and as he did so a change came over the hobbit. Bilbo’s shoulders fell as if a great weight had been dropped upon them.

Bilbo swayed, and when he looked up a tear glinted in his eye and he seemed dazed, his voice trembled as he spoke. “Then I will stay,” he said, and settled, almost fell, down upon the steps, half facing Thorin as if he could not bear to look upon him. He took several deep breaths and for a moment there was only silence filled with the promise of many words as yet unspoken. It was a fragile silence, and across it a bridge of understanding, that if Bilbo were to leave or Thorin snap the ropes that bound him there would be no going back. There was little time left, Thorin could feel it in the hardening of his skin and the cold turn of his thoughts, which longed even then for the gold.

But for now they had this, and the silence, and when the harshness of Bilbo’s breathing eased he settled back onto his hands and looked out over the throne room. “It is very grand, even now,” Bilbo said and turned his face a little so Thorin could see his profile. “Funny, I know very little about your life. It must have been a wondrous thing, to grow up here.”

“It was,” Thorin said quietly, and once he may have lapsed into silence and brooding then, remembering the days of Erebor when it was a great city and not a tomb.

Instead he discovered in himself a desire to speak, and it seemed a spark had been lit there, in the dark. He found it mattered to him, that there be one who remembered his life as he had known it, not with titles or deeds. And it seemed very strange to him, who had so long defined his life by those measures. What did the histories care that he had loved his grandfather, save that that filial duty drove him to take up an oaken branch as a shield in battle? What care did they have for the first time he had seen fireflies as a child and thought they were stars? None. So he had never told these things, these small and unimportant things in the life of an exile.

“I was born the eldest, though I have no memory of being alone. My brother, Frerin, was there from my earliest recollection. I am told my name was the first word he spoke…”

These things did not matter, in the great sweep of deeds in Middle Earth. And yet Thorin found himself telling them to Bilbo Baggins and found that it mattered to him that there should be one who heard these tales, that there be one who lived to remember them.


Two days passed in this way.

Occasionally Thorin would doze upon the throne, his head nodding on his shoulder. but his rest was brief, as if he was forcing back the periods of unconsciousness, knowing how few waking moments remained. At first, Bilbo had been able to convince Thorin to take meals along with him. He dared not risk leaving long enough to fetch wood for a fire, but there were plenty of apples, cheese, and waybread to keep them fed, though never in so satisfying a manner as that first meal.

Except with time they found Thorin could no longer eat, and by evening of the second day it was clear that the needs of Thorin’s body had simply…stopped. There was no longer any denying it, when he graciously accepted an apple Bilbo offered him, but then only held it, looking so long and silently at the shadow of his own form in the polished surface that eventually Bilbo accepted it back.

“All the more for you,” Thorin said, his forced smile not enough to cover the shadow in his eyes.

“I don’t need it that badly,” Bilbo said. It was the last they spoke of the matter. Both knew that dragons had no real need to eat; one such as Smaug could not have survived at that size even if he ate a herd of cattle a day. It was gold and fell magics that sustained them, and Bilbo felt in himself a desperate desire to scream, to find some way to rebel as he watched the daily needs of Thorin’s body dwindled and the beloved form Bilbo knew faded into the disease of his skin.

In those final days Bilbo found he could not go long without touching Thorin. At first the contact was casual, or accidental. As he leaned against the throne for their conversations his hand would brush Thorin’s. Another time, he had scooted nearer to rest his back against the stone and accidentally leaned against the soft fabric of Thorin’s trousers. He had started and moved quickly, but Thorin had not stopped him and Bilbo had settled back only a few inches away.

Once, while they were discussing the utter perplexity (to dwarves, at least) of giving away gifts on one’s own birthday, Bilbo’s hand brushed Thorin’s as he gestured to illustrate the many branches of the Shire family trees, and lingered. Thorin watched him from beneath lashes barely visible now against the dark stains of the scales, and his hand had move incrementally, as much as the rope would allow, until his fingers had entwined with Bilbo’s.

“You are no longer frightened, are you?” Thorin murmured. Bilbo’s breath seized in his throat, and he clenched his hands tighter around Thorin’s.

“I see nothing to be frightened of,” he said, and Thorin nodded, his eyes drifting back down to their hands. The soft, pink flesh of Bilbo’s hand, stubby fingers with short nails, wrapped around broad strong dwarven hands now armored as if with charred steel, the claws lending an inch of length to make the fingers seem unnaturally long. But what he said was true: he was no longer frightened.

Instead Bibo’s heart ached at the memory of sword-callused palms and rough, tan skin. The rest of Thorin’s body had been very pale, or so he had seen in these past few days. Dwarves were loathe to go without their many layers of clothing and armor, Thorin especially, and so only his face and hands were burnished by the sun and wind. Bilbo imagined he too must be unrecognizable from the soft creature he had been when he ran out his door. Though Bilbo was often outside in the Shire, he had not been callused by anything more severe than gardening tools. How much had changed.

Change was not something he wanted to think about anymore.

“Remind me to tell you the story of my coming of age. Fine and fertile ground for blackmail it is, but I trust you not to hold it against me,” Bilbo said lightly.

Thorin looked up with sudden interest. “Do tell.”

“Oh no, I’ve been talking over an hour, it’s your turn now while I have something to drink.”

“Very well.” Thorin laughed. “Let me tell you then of my sister’s wedding, I can assure it is very much the same...” 


Three days since he had bound Thorin to the throne. Three days of passing the time by exchanging stories, each telling the other of his life, starting with childhood. They had found in each other a mutual love of fireflies, an adventurous mother and in Thorin’s case a sister as well, who had eloped with a dwarf of a different clan. Not only that, but a dwarf so far below her station he would not have been allowed within ten feet of a princess had they not been in exile. Bilbo confessed the strictures were not quite so severe in the Shire, for there was no codified rank or nobility, but still he understood how a family might frown upon such a match.

They stayed away from such subjects as Gandalf, Elves, or the quest itself. Bilbo thought at times that he would dearly love a quill and ink to set down Thorin’s tale, for at almost two-hundred years he had seen much that was only distant history for Bilbo, many marvels and adventures that made his own life in the Shire seem quit stodgy and dull by comparison. Comfortable, Bilbo might once have said, and free of trouble, but he found that he no longer thought of it that way.

“My life too might have been quite dull had things gone differently,” Thorin pointed out, and there was no resentment in his voice. “Even on the road there were many days of boredom. Despite our exile, I was still held to certain standards, and not excused from my duties. I can assure you, tedium takes on new meaning after a fortnight of presiding over the same drawn-out property dispute from dawn until dusk.”

Neither did they speak of the present. If Thorin’s wrists ached, bound as they were to the throne, he did not complain. Neither did Bilbo leave the throne room, even when the second pack of supplies still waited back in the treasury. He had only fetched the first with some hasty supplies, including the rope, when Thorin was still unconscious from the blow, not daring to take more time or be weighted down.

In this manner they reestablished some measure of trust. Thorin did not attempt to break his bonds and injure himself, though Bilbo knew well that he could, and Bilbo did not leave Thorin’s sight to summon help Thorin did not wish to have. Those three days bought some understanding that wasn’t there before. Some peace came to them too, and Bilbo thought he would not mind the hard stone, the cold food, or general discomfort if he may only tarry there a little longer, listening to the deep rumble of Thorin’s voice.

Yet both knew time was not theirs.


Bilbo was drowsing when it happened, his back against the foot of the throne, his cheek pressed to the inside of Thorin’s knee. The warmth had lulled him, and he had taken comfort from the fact Thorin could not move without his knowing. Thorin in turn had not protested, saying only that it was practical that they should share body heat.

“It is time, Bilbo,” Thorin said. Bilbo blinked the sleep from his eyes, and realized guiltily that he had left a drool spot on the soft fabric of Thorin’s pant leg. Then Thorin’s words filtered through the haze of waking and the pleasant fog of slumber was dispersed by the cold, leaden feeling that dropped into the pit of his stomach.

“Time? Time for what?” he said, though he knew: there must be an end, that they could not hold back the world and time itself with pleasant conversation. Still there was that part of him that wished to delay it, even for a few more moments.

“Bilbo, look at me,” Thorin said, and there was a gentleness to his voice, a tenderness that told Bilbo all he needed of what lay before. It was the voice of the deathbed.

With great reluctance he stood and turned. As he did so he promised himself that he would not flinch at the sight, that he could give this if nothing else. He was glad of it, for even with this resolution in his heart a gasp came to his lips, choked back, at what he beheld.

Of Thorin’s skin there was almost no sign. A gray and flaking patch was still there above his heart, and over his right cheek. All other places were covered now by shining obsidian scales. The talons had lengthened in the night, and rested in scratched grooves that dug deep into the arms of the throne. At first Bilbo thought Thorin’s hair and beard were yet untouched, but closer now he could see that it thinned in patches along his left jawline, and that soon the rest would follow suit as the scales thickened. Thorin held himself hunched forward as much as his bindings would allow, the hardening scales stealing from him his upright form: the spines too had lengthened along his back.

His eyes flickered up to Bilbo and he saw that they were strange now, and fell, the pupils narrowed like those of a cat’s, the iris extending so little of the whites remained. They burned with an inner light, blue as the heart of a flame, and the world tilted as Bilbo looked into them. It took almost physical effort to pull his eyes away but, once freed, his gaze fell upon Thorin’s arms. Perhaps it was only the effect of the scales, but the forearms seemed harder, broader, as if they were gaining new muscles. Though Thorin still kept a dwarven form Bilbo could no longer deny the signs. Soon the new changes would set in, the wrenching of bone and muscle as the curse tore Thorin apart and rebuilt him.

All of this stuck in Bilbo’s throat and he could only manage to say, “You are changing.”

Thorin nodded. “It is coming. I will sleep once more, and when I awake it will be upon me. When that happens it will take my…my mind with it.” All this he said in a calm and measured tone, but the last words were strangled and choked off and he looked away. “Bilbo, I am afraid.”

Bilbo’s throat seized and he felt as if his heart would break in two. There was still so much waiting to be said. Words of comfort, one last attempt to offer help, hidden thoughts that began upon the Carrock and had been forgotten on the wall and only just remembered. All fell away, because they must, because here at the end of it all they were stripped down to no more than who they were: that was all that was needed, all that could be done and all that would never be. He put his hand over Thorin’s and this time there was no need to ignore the claws, for he no longer saw them.

“I am here.”

Thorin turned his hand, threading his fingers through Bilbo’s. Black scales stood out in sharp relief against the soft skin. “Amrâlimê,” Thorin murmured.

“What does that mean?” said Bilbo.

“I cannot say, and there is no time to teach you,” Thorin answered with a wan smile.

“Cannot?”

Thorin’s smile faded. “There would be no kindness in it.” His hand closed, spasmed, around Bilbo’s. “They are words I would have liked to say many times, over many years, if I could. Words written on the heart.”

A wild impulse came over Bilbo, something desperate and Tookish and later he would curse his Baggins side that it held him back, that all he did was lift his hand and brush it against the side of Thorin’s face, the place where the scales had not yet spread. Then he drew Thorin close, and pressed their foreheads together, feeling the feverish warmth of the dry, smooth scales, and the gentle brush of breath against his lips. Another heat was building behind Bilbo’s eyes, and his throat constricted such that he could barely breathe.

Bilbo heard a soft intake of breath and felt Thorin tremble against him, so faintly it might have been his imagination. Thorin pressed closer, their noses brushing, and Bilbo’s hand tightened around the nape of Thorin’s neck, fingers tangled in the mane of his hair. No more could he do, no more could he bring himself to do over that gulf so wide and filled with so much that was silent. Thorin went still beneath his touch and his lips parted and it seemed in that moment he may bridge that gap.

Then Thorin released a shuddering breath and drew away.

“Do not let my kin see me like this,” Thorin whispered his eyes finding Bilbo’s, his words replacing whatever other he might have spoken. Bilbo’s lower lip quivered and he nodded, not daring to speak. A look of peace swept over Thorin’s face at this assurance and he closed his eyes, his breath slowing into the deep, even fall of sleep.

He did not stir again, even when Bilbo squeezed his hand in return. The patch on Thorin’s chest beckoned and he knew what he must do to keep his word but he had not yet the heart to do it. A little longer, just a little longer, he told himself.

The mad Tookish side had its moment then, but too late, always too late, when Bilbo threw his arms around Thorin’s bowed shoulders and curled up in his lap. He leaned his head against Thorin’s chest and listened, dazed, to the strong, steady beat of his heart. The sound distracted him from the empty ache that was blossoming inside him like a wound, such that he did not even notice the first tears as they made their burning trails down his face.

Then, unbidden, a choked sob tore through Bilbo and he buried his face against Thorin’s chest and wept, until his eyes were red and his voice was hoarse.

 


Is it like this
In death's other kingdom
Waking alone
At the hour when we are
Trembling with tenderness
Lips that would kiss
Form prayers to broken stone.

Notes:

Translation: Amrâlimê - My love

This chapter has an alternate, explicit version here in "Lips that would kiss", chapter 2.

This chapter has fanart!
Prayers to Broken Stone Bilbo & Thorin by closetshipping

We'll Be Counting Stars by Akahime4

Thorin by drakyrna

This story has a trailer!
ϟ Prayers to Broken Stone [hobbit fanfiction] by Sansael

Bilbo's POV has a playlist:
I am here (for you)

Thorin's POV has a playlist:
No hope for me