Chapter Text
Next year was better.
By next year, Neil and Billy had settled into some sort of a routine, a new way of being a family. Of sorts.
There was still a tension in the air and a sense of wrongness in every corner of the house, and Billy’s heart still leapt into his throat at the thrum of an unfamiliar engine of a car slowing down outside, or at the scent of honeysuckle perfume lingering in the aisle at the grocery store, but things were starting to settle. A new normal was taking hold. Between them, Billy and his Dad were finding ways to make it work. Ways to make it bearable.
Maybe Billy stayed in his room more than he used to, maybe he laughed less than he did before, maybe his Dad got meaner and maybe it didn’t exactly feel good.
But it was getting better .
The year after that, they even decorated. Billy had been surprised when his dad came home with a brand new tree. Aluminum, like the old one, and just as short, a near-perfect copy, really, if not for the uncrumpled branches. Neil had bought decorations too, a couple of boxes from the store on the corner. Nothing extravagant, just a couple of foil garlands to drape over the doorframes, and an ugly plastic Santa to stand on the yard.
“We don’t want to be the only house on the block without anything,” Neil said, as he unboxed everything, “Wouldn’t do to look out of place with the neighbours.”
They weren’t exactly perfect. The plastic Santa tipped over every night with even the slightest breeze, and the garlands never quite hung right, always seeming to droop. The new tree shedded even more metallic shards than the old one, and Neil would yell when he trod on them with bare feet, often blaming Billy for not sweeping them up, shoving him to the floor and not letting him have dinner until he'd picked up every single sharp strand one by one, until by the end of it, Billy’s fingers were red raw and his stomach was growling.
So it still wasn't good. Not exactly. But it was something . And on the nights when Neil wasn't tired or angry or snappy, then sometimes he'd sit with Billy on the couch and they'd watch TV together and the lights on the screen would reflect off the shining branches and cast out into the far corners of the room, and it almost felt like it could be good. Soon.
Christmas next year followed a similar pattern. And so did the one the year after that.
It never quite felt the same as before. It never really did feel good again.
But it started to feel OK.
Billy was happy with OK.
—
But then Neil married Susan. And, after years of muddling through, everything changed again. Suddenly, an OK Christmas wasn’t good enough. Not for them. Not for the girls . Billy got that message loud and clear with the sudden arrival of the tree. A big tree. A real tree. A whole ceiling-scraping, needle-dropping giant of a tree that seemed to take up all the space in their living room.
He’d gasped as soon as he’d walked into the house, and Susan had beamed at him, her hair mussed and speckled with pine needles, "Isn’t it nice, Billy? Max and I picked it out this morning. I always think that it's not Christmas without a real tree. Just the smell of it, that's Christmas to me."
She’d smiled even more then, a sickly-sweet, simpering one that she aimed right at Neil.
"You're not wrong," Neil nodded back, "Never could hold with all that shiny metal crap that people went in for. Nothing compares to the real thing. And the bigger the better, of course. No point otherwise."
“But we already have a tree-”
“And now we have a better one,” Neil said, the calmness of his voice at odds to the way his hand landed heavily on Billy’s shoulder, fingers digging painfully into Billy’s skin, “So perhaps you could show how appreciative you are by cleaning up the mess in the hall? Those needles get everywhere.”
Billy felt the anger rise, but he held his tongue, just about, and he kept on holding it for the rest of the week. He held it while Max and Susan baked cookies together, both of them shooing him away when he lingered in the doorway; he held it when Susan took over the Christmas card writing, signing each one with a flourished ‘From the Hargroves’; and he even held it when he was halfway through watching one of his Mom’s old favourite Christmas movies, one with romance and songs and a dancing squirrel, and Max walked in and changed the channel, grumbling about it being ‘for babies’.
He held his anger in for days, swallowing down the hateful words that he wanted to yell, pushing them past the lump in his throat until they sank into the pit of his stomach and churned away in there, rolling in acidic bile. He spent so long holding his tongue that he ended up biting his lip until the skin cracked and flaked, and when he felt like he couldn’t hold it any longer, he shut himself in his room and he turned on his music, loud enough to drown out Susan's Christmas records trundling round and round on the record player in the living room, and he screwed his hands into fists until his nails cut into his palms and he buried his face into his pillow and he screamed. Neil noticed, of course, and he’d been quick to haul Billy out from his room, grabbing him by the collar of his shirt and hissing at him that he'd better wipe that sulky look off your face before I do it for you, and, when Billy’s forced smile wasn’t good enough, Neil had made good on his promise. An ill thought out plan, really, as Billy’s smile looked even worse when paired with a split lip.
But still. Billy just about managed it. He might not have exactly played happy families, and he definitely wasn't always able to stop himself from sniping at Max, but he did his best and he made it all the way until Christmas Eve with only a couple of ‘reminders’ from Neil. He made it through most of the day too, even though Maxine had done nothing but whine and complain about wanting to see her Dad, or wanting to watch a particular movie that wasn’t even on the damn TV, or wanting to go out and get some more decorations because there was an ugly bare space around the back of the tree that no one would even seen.
Billy seethed and fumed and scowled, but he kept it to himself as best he could. He kept it in all the way until dinner, in fact, dragging himself to the table and forcing himself to swallow down a few forkfuls of Susan’s bland, lumpy mashed potatoes along with a whole’s day's worth of simmering resentment, only for the absolute last straw to come as Maxine to took one look at the heaped bowl of steamed carrots set down in the middle of the table, and turned her big, ugly, sulky face towards her mother and asked,
"Did you save one for Rudolph?"
Susan’s dismayed face had been enough of an answer for them all and she’d barely even started on her apology before Max had erupted, a yell of pure fury that turned into a pitiful screech as Max shoved her plate to one side, almost toppling Neil’s water glass, and banged her hands on the table and shouted, "We always put one out, we have to! It’s what we always do and it’s not fair if we don’t."
Billy winced as Max's voice got louder, and Susan looked over at him with an apology on her face, "It's just hard for her, without her Dad."
Billy bit his tongue.
He tasted blood.
He glared at Max.
At her red face, at her hands screwed up into fists and her blotchy face and the one foot she stomped on the floor.
She looked just like a little kid. A toddler, mid tantrum.
And it wasn’t fair. Because Max was the same age that he was when Neil told him that only babies believed in Santa, maybe even older, and she was stomping her foot over a stupid fucking carrot and her Mom was just standing there, wringing her hands and babbling about going to the store because God Forbid her precious daughter had to deal with an ounce of disappointment. It was pathetic, and Billy wanted to shake her, to tell her to shut up. He needed to. Because Neil was sitting right there, just across from Max, with his arms folded and his mustache twitching in that way that Billy knew to watch out for.
Max was whining and Neil didn't like whining.
So Billy needed to make her stop.
He leaned right over to her, grabbing hold of one of her tiny, clenched fists as soon as it hit the table top. The shock was enough to startle her to silence, and Billy took advantage of the sudden quiet.
"Don't be a baby," he hissed, "Santa's not even real."
There was a gasp from Susan, but Billy ploughed on, “Stop making a fuss. It’s just a stupid carrot for a stupid pretend reindeer. No one gives a shit .”
“Billy?” Neil’s voice was calm and quiet, and Billy froze immediately, loosening his grip on Max’s hand, hating her for the way she pulled it towards her chest, running a finger over the slight red marks where his fingers had been.
He hadn’t even hurt her. He just needed her to shut up. And she had. It had worked.
“Come with me, son,” Neil said in that same tone, and Billy could do nothing but obey, following his dad out of the kitchen and down the hall, until they were both in Billy's bedroom, two oak doors and a whole corridor away from Susan and Max.
It felt a lot further.
The crack of his Dad’s hand across his cheek wasn’t unexpected, but the depth of the hatred in Neil’s eyes felt new to Billy.
“That’s your sister in there,” Neil waved a hand towards the kitchen down the hall. He still sounded calm, but now Billy could hear the tautness in his voice, the barely hidden fury beneath the surface, “Your sister . Family. Is that any way to treat family?”
Billy’s gaze dropped to his feet, and he shook his head, wincing when Neil cupped his chin, jerking his head up painfully, Neil's fingers squeezing hard.
“I said, is that any way to treat family?”
“N-no,” Billy stammered, “No, Sir.”
Neil's fingers dropped from Billy's chin, but Billy still kept his head in the exact same position. He knew better than to move.
"No." Neil shook his head, "No it isn't." His hand went to his belt, "And it's about time you learned that. You’ve been pushing her buttons all day, and it needs to stop.”
The belt whistled as Neil slid it through the loops of his pants, “Stay quiet,” he ordered, “Susan doesn't need to hear this."
Billy closed his eyes, and then he obeyed, already tugging at the hem of his shirt, pulling it up and over his head and holding it in his hands, twisting the material around his fingers tightly as Neil raised the belt.
There was a hiss of air as the leather strap cut through the air, and then a meaty smack as it landed right on the pale, freckled skin right in between Billy's sharp shoulder blades, over and over again.
And Billy bit his tongue until it bled.
—
When they got back to the dinner table, there was no sign that Susan had heard anything at all. Max was sitting back on her chair, picking at the remains of her dinner with a disinterested expression, while Susan was staring into space with a faint, unreadable smile on her face.
"All sorted," Neil declared, as he strode in, rubbing his hands together like he was trying to remove dirt from them, "Billy will go and fetch a carrot."
His comment shook Susan from her trance, and she stood up, brushing some non-existent crumbs from her skirt, “Oh no, Neil, no, it’s late and it’s dark out, I can-”
“Sit.” Neil’s tone was hard as nails, and Billy's stomach swooped when he heard it directed at Susan. He held his breath, waiting to see what she'd do, a tiny glimmer of hope rising.
Maybe she'd push back. Maybe she'd argue. Maybe she wouldn’t make him go.
But Susan didn't push back. She didn't argue. She sank back into her chair and nodded, just once.
Satisfied, Neil nodded back, “Billy will go because he needs to make amends for his behaviour. Don’t you, son?”
Neil's hand was on Billy's shoulder, fingers squeezing, his thumb brushing right where Billy knew there would be the start of a raised, red welt.
"Yes, Dad."
“He doesn’t mind at all, do you?”
“No, Dad.”
And then Neil laughed, "After all, we can't have that reindeer going hungry, can we Maxine? Not if he’s going to pull that sleigh all over the world tonight," he chuckled again, sounding so genuinely fucking nice that it made Billy's stomach ache for a whole other reason. There was a twist deep down in his gut, some long forgotten place, a place of Christmas records and cast off jackets and light hearted Christmas movies which you laughed at even when you didn’t get the jokes, because the two people sitting either side of you were laughing too.
Billy forced the feeling back down. He watched Max’s face instead, taking in the way she grimaced at Neil’s attempt at humour, wondering if she saw through him, if she knew who Neil really was, who he could be, behind the charm.
Billy felt a stab of admiration for her. Maybe Max wasn't so bad, after all.
He waited to see what she'd do.
But then she shook her head, staring down at her plate, a mirror of her mother. And Billy hated her all over again.
"There we go, Billy," Neil said, "If you run, you might make it back in time for dessert."
Billy heard the warning there loud and clear. He bent down to grab his shoes, but before he could put them on, Neil's hand was on his arm, and Billy was being shoved out the door, his knees stinging as they hit the gravel of the driveway.
The door was shut behind him before he'd even stood up.
Billy knew it wasn’t the worst punishment. The night was warm enough, even without a jacket, and the shop really wasn’t far away. He just had to turn left out of the house and it was a ten minute walk away.
He could make it in less than five, if he ran.
But, instead, Billy turned right. He walked and walked. Ten minutes turned into twenty. Into thirty.
He walked until the houses got bigger. Further apart. They grew garages. Porches. Balconies. Heated pools. Sweeping driveways. They disappeared behind imposing fences and sky scraping hedges.
He'd be late back, he knew. The shop would be closed. He wouldn’t have a carrot. He'd be in trouble. But he didn’t care.
It was Christmas Eve, and all Billy wanted to do was look at the lights.
