Actions

Work Header

Let Your Heart Be Light

Summary:

Billy never expected a lot at Christmas. He knew better than to expect a house shining with decorations, or a huge pile of presents underneath a real tree.
But there was always joy: Christmas cookies in the oven, Christmas records playing in the living room, Christmas movies on the television.
And, most importantly, Christmas lights on Christmas Eve.

Until his Mom left.
And the joy went with her.

Notes:

Dear Giftee! I am so so so sorry that this is so much longer than I planned! I totally understand if you don't have time to read all of it (or any of it!) but as soon as I started writing this it just GREW!
If you DO manage to get through it, I hope you like it! I had such fun writing it (and OK, maybe fun isn't the best word when you see what I put our boy through, but I swear he gets his happy ending!)

Warnings for: Billy's not so great childhood with Neil. Physical and emotional abuse (not overly explicit but just in case)

This fic is in two parts. Billy in California (Past Tense) and Billy in Hawkins (Present Tense). It just felt right to write it like that.

Chapter 1: California: Happy Golden Days of Yore

Summary:

Billy never expected a lot at Christmas.
Not even when he was a kid. 
While all the other children in his class were getting excited about their huge Christmas trees and the visits from doting grandparents and all the goodies that Santa would be bringing, talking eagerly about Buggy Racers and Evel Knievel bikes, Billy had heard enough late night arguments- the raised voices across the hall barely muffled by the blankets over his head- to know that there wasn't a lot of money and that things were 'tough', and so he knew better than to expect a house shining with decorations, or a huge pile of presents underneath a real tree. He also knew that there wouldn't be rooms full of chattering family members all llining up to pinch his cheeks and coo over how taller he’d gotten.
There wasn’t really anyone else. Just Billy and his Mom and his Dad.
And that was enough. Because his Mom still found ways of making it special. Magical.

Chapter Text

Billy never expected a lot at Christmas.
Not even when he was a kid. 
While all the other children in his class were getting excited about their huge Christmas trees and the visits from doting grandparents and all the goodies that Santa would be bringing, talking eagerly about Buggy Racers and Evel Knievel bikes; Billy had heard enough late night arguments- the raised voices across the hall barely muffled by the blankets over his head- to know that there wasn't a lot of money and that things were 'tough', and so he knew better than to expect a house shining with decorations, or a huge pile of presents underneath a real tree. He also knew that there wouldn't be rooms full of chattering family members all lining up to pinch his cheeks and coo over how taller he’d gotten.
There wasn’t really anyone else. Just Billy and his Mom and his Dad.
And that was enough.

Because his Mom still found ways of making it special. Magical.

It would all start sometime in mid-December, when Billy would arrive home from school to find the aluminum Christmas tree standing proudly in the living room. It was a scrappy, crooked thing not much taller than Billy himself, and that shed glittering fibers over the carpet, so many that Billy would still find them clinging to his slippers way into February. It was ugly, certainly, but there was something mesmerising about the way that its silver branches reflected scenes from the television in the corner of the room, sending colourful lights cascading in every direction, and it got even better when Neil would emerge from the basement carrying a large box of decorations in his arms with Billy’s mom following behind, a much smaller, much more battered, cardboard box in hers.

It was Billy’s dad’s job to sort out the outdoor lights and, while he did that, Billy and his mom would sit cross-legged on the floor sorting through the smaller box, the one that contained the special decorations. The important ones. Each one just as well worn as the tree, packed with love and care between layers of red and green tissue paper until Billy's eager fingers plucked them from their nests and hung them haphazardly on the tree, his Mom watching with pride, telling him the story of each one. The mismatched baubles collected over a year of travelling; a trio of glittering cherubs that were once a set of seven, the others shared out by Billy's mom to her school friends on the Christmas after they all graduated, tokens of love and unheeded reminders to reach out over the holidays, to keep in touch; the satin drums and bells that Billy's mom had made herself, part of a home economics project, her uneven stitches still holding up after all these years. There was even a little red heart, a token of love from Billy’s dad to his mom, given to her in the same box that contained the ring she wore on her left hand. 

And finally, there was the one ornament that Billy's mom insisted on placing herself, a stout, red wooden horse with a painted swirly harness and saddle. It was clearly his Mom’s favourite, and she always spent a little time stroking it with one careful finger right before she positioned it on the highest branches, the ones just above Billy's curls, looking at it longingly as she explained that it had been handed down from her grandmother, the matriarch of a family across the sea that Billy had yet to meet.
Bit by bit, the tree grew more and more colourful. It was loud and garish- messy really- and Billy liked that about it, the audacity it had to be so brightly chaotic, that sent a thrill up Billy’s spine every time he saw it.

Nothing else was quite that extravagant, but Billy’s mom still filled the rest of the days with Christmas cheer. She’d stand at the kitchen counter for hours, with Billy beside her with his own scaled-down mixing bowl and wooden spoon, measuring and stirring along with her in near-perfect unison, copying her every action right down to the way she'd tuck a wayward curl behind her ear right before sticking her hands in the dough to shape it. Between them they'd make batch after batch of cookies, filling their small house with the mingled scents of cinnamon and vanilla and, on more than one occasion, the acrid scent of thick, black smoke. His Mom would leave the decorating to Billy, cleaning up the kitchen around him as he drizzled icing over the cooling cookies, and then, once all his clumsy attempts at artistry were complete, she’d pick out the best ones and box them up, ready to be handed out to friendly neighours and the ever-cheery mailman.

There was always music too, a constant stream of Christmas songs from the record player in the living room, Ella Fitzgerald and the Beach Boys and the dulcet tones of Elvis Singing the Wonderful World of Christmas , and Billy would giggle with delight whenever his Mom was taken by the rhythm of a particular track and would swoop him up in her arms to dance with him around the room, the two of them laughing as they twirled amongst the dapples of sunlight scattered around the room, their movements reflected hundreds of times in the shining branches of the aluminium tree.


Sometimes she’d dance with Billy’s dad when he came in from work, planning it out so that he’d walk in just as something slow and sultry was beginning to play, and Neil would laugh and shuck off his jacket- letting it droop over the back of a chair in the way he always told Billy off for doing- and he’d pull Billy’s mom into his arms and sway her around the room.
Sometimes.
But more often, Billy’s dad would storm in instead, not even wiping his shoes on the mat, treading dirt over the floor as he wrenched the needle off the record with a scratch, hissing to Billy’s mom about how the whole damn neighbourhood could hear the caterwauling, and how he hoped she’d done something more with her day than spinning around the house like a damn lunatic.
Billy would get sent to his room then. It didn’t matter whether or not he’d had dinner. He didn’t like that.

But sometimes Billy’s dad would dance. And that was good. 


There were movies too. Billy’s mom would scour the television guide every day for any mention of anything even vaguely Christmassy, and she’d tune right on in, gushingly just as excitedly as Billy as a Claymation Rudolph scampered across the screen, or wiping the back of her hand surreptitiously over her cheeks as two lovers reunited against a backdrop of falling snow. Billy’s dad joined them too, sometimes. He shook his head at most things, rolling his eyes at others and quite often turning off the television before the film was even halfway done, but sometimes, just sometimes, a movie would catch him in the right mood, and Neil would sit himself right down on the couch and chuckle along with them.

So it wasn’t a lot, but it was nice. Nice enough.

Billy absolute favourite part came on Christmas Eve, right before his bedtime when he was freshly bathed and cosy in his fleecy pyjamas, just after he’d picked out a cookie for Santa and left it with a glass of milk by the fireplace. That was when his Mom would bundle him up into the car and take him out to see the Christmas lights strung up around the neighbourhood. It was something she did when he was a baby, she always reminded him, because he’d been a fussy little thing who much only ever wanted to nap on her chest, with his tiny shell of an ear right over her heart, or when he was riding in the car, with the purr of the engine lulling him to a deep sleep. 
Over the years, Billy’s mom had perfected her route, navigating her way to the best displays, driving until the houses got bigger and bigger, their columns and balconies providing ample space for woven ropes of lights, their sweeping drives and manicured lawns dotted with tastefully arranged winter scenes. And all the while, Billy would be kneeling up on the passenger seat, his eyes eagerly scanning the road ahead, pointing excitedly and breathless with excitement whenever a particularly extravagant display caught his eye.


They’d drive for what seemed like hours, until Billy had stopped kneeling and bobbing up and down, and his breathless voice had turned slow and sludgy with sleep. And that’s when Billy’s mom would whip out the ace up her sleeve, maneuvering the car up a dirt track, up and up a steep ascent until they emerged right at the very top of a hill with the whole town spread out below them. It was the only way to see some of the bigger houses, the ones with twisty-turny driveways and skyscraping hedges keeping them well hidden from the road, and if the promise of some spectacular Christmas lights didn’t rouse Billy, well then the cookie that his Mom passed him certainly did the trick. It was always the biggest one of all the batches they’d cooked, and she’d keep it safe for him, hidden away in a tin in the cupboard, and then handed over right when Billy needed an extra little boost of sugar.

Billy would shuffle over, inching closer and closer to his Mom until he was pressed right up against her side, dropping cookie crumbs onto her boots as he chattered enthusiastically about the houses he could see, trying to pick his favourite between the one with a garage that was bigger than the entirety of Billy’s own house, or the one with the funny shaped pool.
He’d always ask his Mom too, ask her which one she liked and why, and even though she’d shake her head at first, saying how lonely it must be to live so far from any neighbours, she’d soon get just as excited as Billy himself, almost leaning out of the window to point at a particularly nice house and exclaim, “Oh Billy, just look at that one! There we go, that one. If I have to pick."

And Billy would say the same thing. Every year. The same reply. 

“When I’m big, Mommy,” he’d say, through a mouthful of cookie crumbs and icing, “When I’m grown up and have lots of money, I’ll buy that one. You can live with me too if you want to.”

And every year, his Mom would laugh, a tinkly sound that sounded like bells in the night air, and say the same thing back, "That sounds nice, baby, real nice. I'd like that."

And Billy would nod and smile, and even though he knew he was too big to do it really, he’d lean over and let his head drop against his Mom’s chest, spilling crumbs onto her blouse as he made his plans and murmured them aloud,

“And at Christmas we’ll have a big tree. So big. It’ll touch the roof. The upstairs roof!  And we can decorate it together. You can untangle the lights, and I'll go up the ladder. I don't mind going up the ladder. We’ll need a ladder…”

His eyes would droop, and he’d nuzzle in even closer, his Mom’s familiar honeysuckle perfume surrounded him like the warmth of her arms, and the next thing Billy would know, he’d be waking up in his own bed on Christmas morning.

And that was nice. Real nice.
While it lasted.

Chapter 2: California: All Our Troubles

Summary:

Billy knew that he shouldn’t curse. But he couldn’t help thinking it. Not when he heard the words coming from his Dad’s mouth every few days, his hand grabbing hold of Billy’s collar or his arm or his face and pulling him close to hiss the words out in his hot, acrid, alcohol- tinged breath.

It was shit. Everything. Ever since that bitch left them, everything was shit.

Notes:

Extra warning here for Neil Hargrove being an absolute ass in this- Physical and emotional abuse.

Chapter Text

But then Billy's Mom left.
And, for a long time, nice seemed like a distant dream. Nothing was right. The house got messier. Billy’s clothes got dirtier. Neil got angrier. Things started to get forgotten. Special days stopped being special.

Billy had to dig out his old too-tight Halloween costume from the back of his closet, but it only took one glance in the mirror, one look at a spaceman with white pants that rose above his ankles, and a slightly squashed cardboard jet pack with flaking silver paint, before he ripped the costume off and threw it to the floor in a huff, calling Halloween stupid and spending the night ignoring the trick or treaters that hammered on the door. 

Thanksgiving consisted of little more than a couple of Swanson dinners, the plastic-y ready meals half heated and dumped out into an unappealing sludge on Billy’s plate. The only thing Billy was thankful for that day was that Neil ended up falling asleep on the couch before he could find some reason to be mad at him.

Billy knew that he shouldn’t curse. But he couldn’t help thinking it. Not when he heard the words coming from his Dad’s mouth every few days, his hand grabbing hold of Billy’s collar or his arm or his face and pulling him close to hiss the words out in his hot, acrid, alcohol- tinged breath. He'd repeat them, late at night, spitting them out as he curled himself up in bed, knees tucked to his chin, angrily scrubbing tears from his cheeks.

It was shit . Everything. Ever since that bitch left them, everything was shit .

Christmas seemed to be going the same way as everything else. There’d been no mention of it from Neil, even when the lights started going up around the neighbourhood and old Mrs. McCrae down the street offered Billy a dollar if he’d go up the ladder and help her hang some plastic icicles from her one-story porch, Neil’s made no comment. Billy lasted all the way up to the twentieth of December before he finally cracked. He waited until his Dad was in a good-ish mood. Or, at least, when he’d walked in without slamming the door, and done nothing more than sink down in his armchair with a beer in his hand. That, for Billy, was as good as it was going to get. So that was when Billy dared to ask.

"Dad? What about our tree?"

Neil’s gaze didn’t budge from the television, "What tree?"

“The Christmas tree.”

“What about it?”

“Well…it’s…are we going to decorate it? It’s Christmas soon and…”

Billy trailed off. Neil wasn’t listening. So Billy tried a different approach. 

“There’s still lots we need to do. We haven't made any cookies. Santa always gets a cookie. And Mom always gives some to the postman and he says it makes his Christmas. And we-"

"Stop whining, Billy." Neil was listening now. And although he still wasn’t looking, his eyes had narrowed in a warning that Billy really should have taken notice of.

He didn’t. 

"-but it's Christmas. And we haven't done anything . We haven't written cards and we haven't-"

“Billy. Stop. Whining.” If Neil’s eyes had been a warning, then his clenched teeth were a flashing red danger sign, but Billy had kept it all bottled up for too long, and he couldn’t stop himself, as much as he wanted to, and he was so close to the end of his argument. The real point of it. His one, last, tiny clinging hope.

“But Mom loves Christmas. And maybe if we put some lights up she'll-"

Within a second, Billy's head jerked to one side. He didn't understand it. There wasn't any pain, not at first, just the shock of his body lurching over, the way he went from standing to being sprawled on his back, and all Billy could see, all he could focus on, was his Dad's hand, hovering in the air, right where Billy's cheek had been.

His Dad was staring at it like it didn't belong to him.

Billy stared at it like that too. 

And then it started to hurt. There was a flash of scalding heat along his cheek, a prickly, itchy burn, but, more than that, there was a pain inside of Billy too. A growing sick feeling, a wrong-ness. A hurt that began to rise up inside him and Billy tried, tried as hard as he could, to swallow it all back down past the aching lump in his throat, but it was too much, too much of a big hurt for someone small, and he couldn’t hold it back anymore. The moment he blinked, the dam burst, and Billy felt hot, sticky tears running down his already scalded cheek. 

And still, Neil said nothing. 

He just stared; looking at his hand, but seeming to see through it. It was only when Billy’s breath hitched, when that first little whimper broke past his pressed together lips, that Neil’s attention turned back to his own son. 

"Go to your room," he muttered.

"Dad?" The word cracked in half in Billy's mouth and splintered into painful shards. There was a beat. A moment of silence. A held breath between the two of them. A moment that felt like a precipice.

Then Neil raised his hand again. And Billy flinched. And then he obeyed. 

He woke up the next day to find half the silver tree sticking out of the trash can, a path of broken ornaments leading up to it, shattered baubles and crushed cherubs littering the yard like some kind of twisted Hansel and Gretel breadcrumb trail. The satin bells were all torn, soaking up the gross garbage water at the bottom of the can. The tiny heart had been crushed into even tinier pieces; shards that tore at Billy’s fingers when he reached for them desperately, biting into his skin until his fingertips were dotted with tiny pin pricks of blood.

The small cardboard box was there too, spilling out its reams of red and green tissue that had all failed in their one job of protecting Billy’s mom’s decorations from harm.

Billy salvaged what he could. The wooden red horse had, miraculously, escaped most of the harm. There was a tiny chip in the paint, but its fall had been cushioned by a pile of squished down Swanson boxes , and so Billy carefully tucked it away into his pocket, his thumb stroking gently down its nose. There were others too, one cherub was there at the bottom of the trash can, one wing smashed but everything else intact, and there was one satin bell that Billy thought could be fixed with a wash and a few stitches. 

He knew better than to mention any of it to his Dad. Billy squirreled away the few decorations he’d saved, tucking them into a shoebox in the depths of his closet, and he pretended that he’d never seen the rest.

And that was that.

Christmas got closer and closer, but nothing changed. Their house remained the only one on the block without any decoration, save for the few cracked baubles still littering the front yard, the living room stayed tree-less and the only thing heated up in the oven was tray after tray of frozen dinners. Christmas Eve came and went like it was any other day, and Billy was sent to bed just like it was any other night. But he tried, just once more, standing by the arm of Neil’s chair, bathed in the light of the television, 

“Dad?” 

Neil’s grunt was all the acknowledgement that Billy got. He twisted his fingers in front of him, shifting awkwardly from foot to foot as he tried, desperately, to pluck up the courage to ask what he wanted to.

“It’s… it’s Christmas Eve. Do we…can I have a cookie? To put out for…for Santa?”

Neil turned to him. There was a beat of silence, another one of those heavy ones, where Billy could feel the world about to tip, and he braced himself, planting his slippered-feet against the carpet and closing his eyes, readying himself for the hit. 

But this time, there was no pain. And Billy opened his eyes to see Neil still staring, his lips twisted into a sneer.

“Santa?” Neil shook his head, “You still believe in that baby stuff? At your age? Grow up, Billy. God knows you’ve gotta do it sometime. Join the real world.”

And that was it. Neil turned back to the television, and Billy took himself off to bed. Just like every other night.

But just as he reached the doorway, Billy paused, looking back at his father in the armchair, and he was shocked to see just how Neil’s expression had changed. The sneer had gone, replaced with a sad sort of frown, and there was a lost, almost broken, look in his eyes that made Billy feel wrong, like he was looking at something he shouldn’t be allowed to see, so Billy backed away quickly, padding across to his room.

It was dark in there. His bed was made, neat as a pin as it always had to be. His books stacked in size order on the shelves, his toys all in their places.
Billy knew he should go straight to bed. He didn’t want to think of what might happen if his father found him dawdling, but instead, Billy padded over to the window. He pulled the curtains open. And he looked out at the neighbourhood. At the lights on the house opposite. The multicoloured flashes of the chunky bulbs around Mrs. Álvarez’s windows and the mesmerising twinkling of the rope lights that criss-crossed over her roof.

He stared and stared at them , grinding his teeth, scowling so hard that the lights blurred.

Chapter 3: California: Out of Sight

Summary:

Next year was better.

By next year, Neil and Billy had settled into some sort of a routine, a new way of being a family. Of sorts.
There was still a tension in the air and a sense of wrongness in every corner of the house, and Billy’s heart still leapt into his throat at the thrum of an unfamiliar engine outside, or at the scent of honeysuckle perfume lingering in the aisle at the grocery store, but things were starting to settle. A new normal was taking hold. Between them, Billy and his Dad were finding ways to make it work. Ways to make it bearable.
Maybe Billy stayed in his room more than he used to, maybe he laughed less than he did before, maybe his Dad got meaner and maybe it didn’t exactly feel good.

But it was getting better.

Notes:

More Neil asshole-ness, be warned.

Also, I played fast and loose with Billy and Max's ages, and the whole timeline! Canon doesn't give us much, and Runaway Max (the tie in novel) only confuses things further so I went with what suited the plot best!

Chapter Text

Next year was better.

By next year, Neil and Billy had settled into some sort of a routine, a new way of being a family. Of sorts.
There was still a tension in the air and a sense of wrongness in every corner of the house, and Billy’s heart still leapt into his throat at the thrum of an unfamiliar engine of a car slowing down outside, or at the scent of honeysuckle perfume lingering in the aisle at the grocery store, but things were starting to settle. A new normal was taking hold. Between them, Billy and his Dad were finding ways to make it work. Ways to make it bearable.
Maybe Billy stayed in his room more than he used to, maybe he laughed less than he did before, maybe his Dad got meaner and maybe it didn’t exactly feel good.

But it was getting better .

The year after that, they even decorated. Billy had been surprised when his dad came home with a brand new tree. Aluminum, like the old one, and just as short, a near-perfect copy, really, if not for the uncrumpled branches. Neil had bought decorations too, a couple of boxes from the store on the corner. Nothing extravagant, just a couple of foil garlands to drape over the doorframes, and an ugly plastic Santa to stand on the yard.

“We don’t want to be the only house on the block without anything,” Neil said, as he unboxed everything, “Wouldn’t do to look out of place with the neighbours.” 

They weren’t exactly perfect. The plastic Santa tipped over every night with even the slightest breeze, and the garlands never quite hung right, always seeming to droop. The new tree shedded even more metallic shards than the old one, and Neil would yell when he trod on them with bare feet, often blaming Billy for not sweeping them up, shoving him to the floor and not letting him have dinner until he'd picked up every single sharp strand one by one, until by the end of it, Billy’s fingers were red raw and his stomach was growling.

So it still wasn't good. Not exactly. But it was something . And on the nights when Neil wasn't tired or angry or snappy, then sometimes he'd sit with Billy on the couch and they'd watch TV together and the lights on the screen would reflect off the shining branches and cast out into the far corners of the room, and it almost felt like it could be good. Soon.
Christmas next year followed a similar pattern. And so did the one the year after that.
It never quite felt the same as before. It never really did feel good again.
But it started to feel OK.
Billy was happy with OK. 

—

But then Neil married Susan. And, after years of muddling through, everything changed again. Suddenly, an OK Christmas wasn’t good enough. Not for them. Not for the girls . Billy got that message loud and clear with the sudden arrival of the tree. A big tree. A real tree. A whole ceiling-scraping, needle-dropping giant of a tree that seemed to take up all the space in their living room.

He’d gasped as soon as he’d walked into the house, and Susan had beamed at him, her hair mussed and speckled with pine needles, "Isn’t it nice, Billy? Max and I picked it out this morning. I always think that it's not Christmas without a real tree. Just the smell of it, that's Christmas to me."

She’d smiled even more then, a sickly-sweet, simpering one that she aimed right at Neil.

"You're not wrong," Neil nodded back, "Never could hold with all that shiny metal crap that people went in for. Nothing compares to the real thing. And the bigger the better, of course. No point otherwise."

“But we already have a tree-”

“And now we have a better one,” Neil said, the calmness of his voice at odds to the way his hand landed heavily on Billy’s shoulder, fingers digging painfully into Billy’s skin, “So perhaps you could show how appreciative you are by cleaning up the mess in the hall? Those needles get everywhere.”

Billy felt the anger rise, but he held his tongue, just about, and he kept on holding it for the rest of the week. He held it while Max and Susan baked cookies together, both of them shooing him away when he lingered in the doorway; he held it when Susan took over the Christmas card writing, signing each one with a flourished ‘From the Hargroves’; and he even held it when he was halfway through watching one of his Mom’s old favourite Christmas movies, one with romance and songs and a dancing squirrel, and Max walked in and changed the channel, grumbling about it being ‘for babies’. 

He held his anger in for days, swallowing down the hateful words that he wanted to yell, pushing them past the lump in his throat until they sank into the pit of his stomach and churned away in there, rolling in acidic bile. He spent so long holding his tongue that he ended up biting his lip until the skin cracked and flaked, and when he felt like he couldn’t hold it any longer, he shut himself in his room and he turned on his music, loud enough to drown out Susan's Christmas records trundling round and round on the record player in the living room, and he screwed his hands into fists until his nails cut into his palms and he buried his face into his pillow and he screamed. Neil noticed, of course, and he’d been quick to haul Billy out from his room, grabbing him by the collar of his shirt and hissing at him that he'd better wipe that sulky look off your face before I do it for you, and, when Billy’s forced smile wasn’t good enough, Neil had made good on his promise. An ill thought out plan, really, as Billy’s smile looked even worse when paired with a split lip.

But still. Billy just about managed it. He might not have exactly played happy families, and he definitely wasn't always able to stop himself from sniping at Max, but he did his best and he made it all the way until Christmas Eve with only a couple of ‘reminders’ from Neil. He made it through most of the day too, even though Maxine had done nothing but whine and complain about wanting to see her Dad, or wanting to watch a particular movie that wasn’t even on the damn TV, or wanting to go out and get some more decorations because there was an ugly bare space around the back of the tree that no one would even seen.

Billy seethed and fumed and scowled, but he kept it to himself as best he could. He kept it in all the way until dinner, in fact, dragging himself to the table and forcing himself to swallow down a few forkfuls of Susan’s bland, lumpy mashed potatoes along with a whole’s day's worth of simmering resentment, only for the absolute last straw to come as Maxine to took one look at the heaped bowl of steamed carrots set down in the middle of the table, and turned her big, ugly, sulky face towards her mother and asked,

"Did you save one for Rudolph?"

Susan’s dismayed face had been enough of an answer for them all and she’d barely even started on her apology before Max had erupted, a yell of pure fury that turned into a pitiful screech as Max shoved her plate to one side, almost toppling Neil’s water glass, and banged her hands on the table and shouted,  "We always put one out, we have to! It’s what we always do and it’s not fair if we don’t."

Billy winced as Max's voice got louder, and Susan looked over at him with an apology on her face, "It's just hard for her, without her Dad."

Billy bit his tongue.
He tasted blood. 

He glared at Max.
At her red face, at her hands screwed up into fists and her blotchy face and the one foot she stomped on the floor.
She looked just like a little kid. A toddler, mid tantrum.

And it wasn’t fair. Because Max was the same age that he was when Neil told him that only babies believed in Santa, maybe even older, and she was stomping her foot over a stupid fucking carrot and her Mom was just standing there, wringing her hands and babbling about going to the store because God Forbid her precious daughter had to deal with an ounce of disappointment. It was pathetic, and Billy wanted to shake her, to tell her to shut up. He needed to. Because Neil was sitting right there, just across from Max, with his arms folded and his mustache twitching in that way that Billy knew to watch out for.
Max was whining and Neil didn't like whining.
So Billy needed to make her stop. 

He leaned right over to her, grabbing hold of one of her tiny, clenched fists as soon as it hit the table top. The shock was enough to startle her to silence, and Billy took advantage of the sudden quiet.

"Don't be a baby," he hissed, "Santa's not even real."

There was a gasp from Susan, but Billy ploughed on, “Stop making a fuss. It’s just a stupid carrot for a stupid pretend reindeer. No one gives a shit .”

“Billy?” Neil’s voice was calm and quiet, and Billy froze immediately, loosening his grip on Max’s hand, hating her for the way she pulled it towards her chest, running a finger over the slight red marks where his fingers had been.
He hadn’t even hurt her. He just needed her to shut up. And she had. It had worked.

“Come with me, son,” Neil said in that same tone, and Billy could do nothing but obey, following his dad out of the kitchen and down the hall, until they were both in Billy's bedroom, two oak doors and a whole corridor away from Susan and Max.
It felt a lot further. 

The crack of his Dad’s hand across his cheek wasn’t unexpected, but the depth of the hatred in Neil’s eyes felt new to Billy. 

“That’s your sister in there,” Neil waved a hand towards the kitchen down the hall. He still sounded calm, but now Billy could hear the tautness in his voice, the barely hidden fury beneath the surface, “Your sister . Family. Is that any way to treat family?”

Billy’s gaze dropped to his feet, and he shook his head, wincing when Neil cupped his chin, jerking his head up painfully, Neil's fingers squeezing hard.

“I said, is that any way to treat family?”

“N-no,” Billy stammered, “No, Sir.” 

Neil's fingers dropped from Billy's chin, but Billy still kept his head in the exact same position. He knew better than to move. 

"No." Neil shook his head, "No it isn't." His hand went to his belt, "And it's about time you learned that. You’ve been pushing her buttons all day, and it needs to stop.”

The belt whistled as Neil slid it through the loops of his pants, “Stay quiet,” he ordered, “Susan doesn't need to hear this."

Billy closed his eyes, and then he obeyed, already tugging at the hem of his shirt, pulling it up and over his head and holding it in his hands, twisting the material around his fingers tightly as Neil raised the belt.

There was a hiss of air as the leather strap cut through the air, and then a meaty smack as it landed right on the pale, freckled skin right in between Billy's sharp shoulder blades, over and over again.

And Billy bit his tongue until it bled.

—

When they got back to the dinner table, there was no sign that Susan had heard anything at all. Max was sitting back on her chair, picking at the remains of her dinner with a disinterested expression, while Susan was staring into space with a faint, unreadable smile on her face. 

"All sorted," Neil declared, as he strode in, rubbing his hands together like he was trying to remove dirt from them, "Billy will go and fetch a carrot."

His comment shook Susan from her trance, and she stood up, brushing some non-existent crumbs from her skirt, “Oh no, Neil, no, it’s late and it’s dark out, I can-”

“Sit.” Neil’s tone was hard as nails, and Billy's stomach swooped when he heard it directed at Susan. He held his breath, waiting to see what she'd do, a tiny glimmer of hope rising.

Maybe she'd push back. Maybe she'd argue. Maybe she wouldn’t make him go.

But Susan didn't push back. She didn't argue. She sank back into her chair and nodded, just once.

Satisfied, Neil nodded back, “Billy will go because he needs to make amends for his behaviour. Don’t you, son?”

Neil's hand was on Billy's shoulder, fingers squeezing, his thumb brushing right where Billy knew there would be the start of a raised, red welt. 

"Yes, Dad." 

“He doesn’t mind at all, do you?” 

“No, Dad.”

And then Neil laughed, "After all, we can't have that reindeer going hungry, can we Maxine? Not if he’s going to pull that sleigh all over the world tonight," he chuckled again, sounding so genuinely fucking nice that it made Billy's stomach ache for a whole other reason. There was a twist deep down in his gut, some long forgotten place, a place of Christmas records and cast off jackets and light hearted Christmas movies which you laughed at even when you didn’t get the jokes, because the two people sitting either side of you were laughing too.
Billy forced the feeling back down. He watched Max’s face instead, taking in the way she grimaced at Neil’s attempt at humour, wondering if she saw through him, if she knew who Neil really was, who he could be, behind the charm.

Billy felt a stab of admiration for her. Maybe Max wasn't so bad, after all.

He waited to see what she'd do. 

But then she shook her head, staring down at her plate, a mirror of her mother. And Billy hated her all over again.

"There we go, Billy," Neil said, "If you run, you might make it back in time for dessert."

Billy heard the warning there loud and clear. He bent down to grab his shoes, but before he could put them on, Neil's hand was on his arm, and Billy was being shoved out the door, his knees stinging as they hit the gravel of the driveway.

The door was shut behind him before he'd even stood up. 

Billy knew it wasn’t the worst punishment. The night was warm enough, even without a jacket, and the shop really wasn’t far away. He just had to turn left out of the house and it was a ten minute walk away.
He could make it in less than five, if he ran. 

But, instead, Billy turned right. He walked and walked. Ten minutes turned into twenty. Into thirty.
He walked until the houses got bigger. Further apart. They grew garages. Porches. Balconies. Heated pools. Sweeping driveways. They disappeared behind imposing fences and sky scraping hedges.

He'd be late back, he knew. The shop would be closed. He wouldn’t have a carrot. He'd be in trouble. But he didn’t care.

It was Christmas Eve, and all Billy wanted to do was look at the lights.

Chapter 4: California: If the Fates Allow

Summary:

Neil got better. But he also got worse.

To Susan and Max, he played the ideal husband and father. He was charming and funny; he took Susan on dates and danced her around the living room, swaying to the music on the radio. He spoiled Max with gifts- toys that she was too old for, or that she found insipid,or frilly dresses that got shoved to the back of her closet and never worn.
He smiled. He laughed. He almost seemed happy.

But Billy could see the flimsiness of Neil’s mask, especially when it started to slip. And when Billy was around, it slipped a lot.

Chapter Text

Neil got better. But he also got worse.

To Susan and Max, he played the ideal husband and father. He was charming and funny; he took Susan on dates and danced her around the living room, swaying to the music on the radio. He spoiled Max with gifts- toys that she was too old for, or that she found insipid, or frilly dresses that got shoved to the back of her closet and never worn.
He smiled. He laughed. He almost seemed happy. 

But Billy could see the flimsiness of Neil’s mask, especially when it started to slip. And when Billy was around, it slipped a lot. His father’s strictness became even more severe, until he was pulling Billy up over the slightest thing, finding fault with everything he did, ruining whatever pockets of freedom and happiness that Billy had found with an almost malicious glee. Billy had long gotten used to his Dad shoving him up against the shelves in his bedroom, but there'd been a new, sickening shock when Neil had deliberately stepped on one of Billy's tapes, one that had fallen to the floor when Billy's back collided with the sharp edge of the metal shelving. Neil had smirked at the horror that flittered over Billy's face when he heard that crunch of plastic. It'd been the first time Billy had broken position in a while, his head jerking down from where Neil had placed it, and he'd not been able to conceal the groan of anguish as he saw the album crushed under Neil's foot. It was only one of a few that he’d had- tapes that he’d saved for or been given as a gift from his friends or, on a couple of occasions, stuffed into the elastic of his sock as he walked out of Tower Records- all of them loud and vibrant and offering Billy a taste of a whole different world.

One of the few things that had been Billy's. 

Neil had waited, pausing for a beat to look right into Billy’s eyes, and then he pressed down again with his foot, the case of the tape shattering completely, leaving the cassette inside vulnerable to the unceasing pressure of Neil’s boot as he drove his heel down, over and over, until the plastic was shattered and the ribbon inside spooled out over Billy’s carpet.

"You know what happens when you make me angry, Billy," Neil said, that smirk still evident on his lips as he turned away to walk out of the room, "Things get broken."

As with all things, Billy had soon learned to deal with that. He’d learned to keep anything of importance to a minimum, and to keep those few items well hidden, in the pockets of his jackets or in the depths of his closet, places where Neil wouldn’t think to look.
But he couldn’t hide his car. And Neil seemed to take pleasure in that fact, holding it over Billy’s head whenever he could, not caring that Billy had bought the Camaro himself, taking whatever jobs he could find around the neighbourhood, scrimping and saving and making deal after deal with the guys at the lot, putting hours and hours of work into the car until they took pity on him and signed it over to him.

Neil didn’t give a shit.

He made sure that Billy knew that his car came with conditions. Expectations. If Max needed to be somewhere, Billy would be driving. If groceries needed fetching or errands needed doing, Billy would be the one using up his gas. If Susan needed picking up after a night out with her friends, Billy would be the one staying up late to go get her. And if Billy didn’t act responsible enough, if he didn’t get round to a chore quickly enough, or complete it to Neil’s exacting standards, or if he was even a few minutes late for dinner, whatever the reason, Neil would take great delight in forcing Billy to hand over the Camaro’s keys, tossing them up and down in his hand, or leaning in to tap them against Billy’s cheek, all while he made his usual speech about the importance of respect and responsibility. 

The only thing Neil hadn't been able to take away from Billy were his friends.

Not that he approved of them, not at all, the group of slackers and stoners and sluts and sissies that had all taken Billy under their wing, and he certainly did what he could to keep Billy from seeing them. Most of Billy's punishments started to culminate in him getting locked up in his room, Neil making good use of a latch he’d picked up from the hardware store in town. But Billy was always one step ahead.

The window frame in his room had always been shitty and loose, and Billy soon became thankful for it, the ease with which he could lift the glass panel from the frame and shimmy his body out, dropping almost silently onto the lawn below and scurrying away, under the cover of darkness, down to the beach where he spent most of his time, the breath that he'd been holding all day was lifted from his body at the very first hint of sea salt on the breeze. There was always a fire there too, ranging from a shitty little thing contained by rocks to a raging bonfire leaping out of an old metal bin, depending on who was there to get it started, and Billy would feel the anger and frustration that had been steadily building inside him disappearing into the night sky like the flickering sparks that rose up with the smoke.
And he wouldn’t be alone. There was no great fuss heralding his arrival, just a chorus of casual greetings, a joint slipped between his fingers and a crush of familiar bodies around him as he slipped into the conversation seamlessly.
It was where he belonged. Where he wanted to be. Where he could be himself.

It was his escape. His place. His family. His one fucking crumb of sanity. 

And Billy had naively thought that Neil had no way to take it from him. And maybe he hadn't. Until fucking Max was peeking out of her window on the one night that Billy took a dumb risk. 

He'd not even been doing anything, not really. But Max had seen him illuminated by the flickering porch light, she'd looked out and seen Billy and rather than mind her damn business like she should have learned how to do by then, she'd kept on looking. Billy's still not sure exactly how much she'd seen, whether she'd spotten Billy sneaking out and that had been enough for her to rat him out, or whether she'd seen more, whether she'd caught sight of the ugly Chevy sedan idling on the corner, or maybe she’d even seen the boy in the driver's seat and the way Billy had smiled at him and how he'd pulled Billy towards him and the way their lips had met and how-

It didn't matter what she'd seen. Because it was Billy who'd been stupid. He’d gotten complacent and careless and he knew better, he definitely knew better.  And he should've begged, he knows that now, the moment that Max had told him that she'd seen him, he should've begged her to keep quiet instead of threatening her. 

Because she didn't know, she hadn't lived with them long enough to know how the game was played, she was still acting like they could be a regular brother and sister. Getting on each other’s nerves. Winding each other up. Tit for tat. And she'd gone straight to Neil.
And that had been that. 

Chapter 5: Hawkins: We'll Have to Muddle Through Somehow

Summary:

So far, a Hawkins Christmas Eve is just as shitty as a California one.

Shittier, probably, because it’s fucking freezing everywhere.Shittier too, because in Hawkins, Neil’s boss and a ton of his co workers go to church after dinner on Christmas Eve. Which means that Neil also wants to go to church after dinner on Christmas Eve. Which means that Susan and Billy and Max also have to go to church after dinner on Christmas Eve.

But Billy really fucking doesn’t want to go to church after dinner. So he doesn’t eat dinner. He doesn’t even come down for it.

Chapter Text

Billy tries not to think about it any more. What he had. What he’d lost. He’ll be back there soon enough, he knows.
The first week, the one where Susan was scurrying around trying to get them both enrolled in school, when they’d been forbidden from leaving the house and Billy hadn’t even been allowed to leave his room, he’d grabbed a ballpoint pen and etched the first of what would become a growing series of tally marks in the baseboard behind his bed.
He runs a finger over them most nights, shoving his hand down the gap between the mattress and the wall, inching his fingers down and down until they reach the deep grooves in the wood. He can’t really see them, not without ducking his head under the bed, but he knows them well enough. Some days, he feels like they’ve been scratched into his skin anyway, sixty-two gouges.
A bit of him lost every single day.

It had been almost Halloween when they arrived. Now it’s Christmas Eve.
And, so far, a Hawkins Christmas Eve is just as shitty as a California one.

Shittier, probably, because it’s fucking freezing everywhere.Shittier too, because in Hawkins, Neil’s boss and a ton of his co workers go to church after dinner on Christmas Eve. Which means that Neil also wants to go to church after dinner on Christmas Eve. Which means that Susan and Billy and Max also have to go to church after dinner on Christmas Eve.

But Billy really fucking doesn’t want to go to church after dinner. So he doesn’t eat dinner. He doesn’t even come down for it.
He stays sitting on his bed when Susan calls. And he stays sitting on his bed when Max bangs on the door. He stays sitting when she shoves the door open and stand in the doorway and tells him to stop being an attention-seeking idiot.
He stays sitting when Neil shouts and shouts.
He stays sitting when Neil comes to the door and says much the same as Max but with a lot more anger in his tone. 
He stays sitting as Neil stares him down, and he even stays sitting when Neil finally shakes his head and turns away.

Billy doesn’t eat. He barely even moves. He listens to the clatter of crockery and he ignores the clench of hunger in his stomach and he stays sitting on his bed the whole time.

He even stays sitting when he hears the scrape of Neil’s chair and the tread of his footsteps. And this time, Neil doesn’t stay by the door. This time he walks right into Billy’s room stepping over the threshold and standing over Billy with ice in his eyes.
And Billy sort of wishes he wasn’t sitting any more.

“You're coming to church." Neil says. It isn’t a question. 

"No I'm not.” It's stupid of him. Reckless. But sometimes Billy can't help but do that, when Neil's clearly on the edge, can't help but give him the shove he needs to topple right over. It's going to happen anyway, may as well be on Billy's terms.
It’s a win. Of sorts. The only kind Billy’s likely to get.

Neil surges forward, his hand fisting in Billy's shirt, tugging him up and off the bed, and Billy regrets it all instantly.

"Dad, I-"

"What have I told you about that attitude?"

"I didn't-"

Neil slaps him once, hard enough to make Billy's teeth clack together, and then he grabs hold of Billy's chin, tilting it up.

"We're a family now, and this is a new start for all of us, especially you. So you will come to church and you will sit and you will sing and you will smile. You will behave ." He punctuates the words with a series of sharp jabs of his index finger, right into Billy's chest, "What will you do?"

Billy hates the word. Hates saying it. Hates feeling like a fucking little kid being put in time out. But he supposes that fits. Because his Dad knows just how to make him feel small. Weak. Vulnerable. 

"I'll behave," he croaks, pushing the words out past a growing lump in his throat. 

"I'm sorry?"

"I'll behave…sir."

“Damn right.”

Neil lets go of him, and Billy has to hold himself back from falling back onto the bed.
He grits his teeth, forcing himself not to push Neil any further.
It’s over. It's done.

Or at least it should be. Because Neil is turning around. He's turning around and that means he's done.

But then he pauses. 

"This is an important night. A special one. It won't do to have you showing us up. So-" Neil's hand goes to his belt, his fingers already working at the buckle. "-maybe you need something to keep this lesson fresh in your mind."

Billy’s teeth grind together even harder, “Dad-” he bites his tongue to stop himself saying anything else. It won’t work, he knows it, begging won’t work. It might even make Neil madder. Billy needs to stand there and take it like a man. Take what he’s earned. He swallows against the ache in his throat, setting his jaw, his eyes lock on to his father’s fingers as they begin to work the belt out through the loops of his pants.

Billy's trembling fingers go to the buttons on his shirt.

Muscle memory.


There's a timid rap of knuckles on the doorframe, and Billy and Neil’s heads both whip up in perfect sync to see Susan standing there. She looks nervous, but then she always looks nervous nowadays, so Billy can’t be sure how much she’s heard. Her expression gives nothing away and Billy wants to scream at her to get out, to let him get punished without a fucking audience. 

But he also wants her to see it. He wants her to have to witness what's happening and see who Neil really is and finally do the sensible thing and take Max and just run and leave him and his Dad alone. And deep down, right down, there's some desperate, pathetic part of him that wants her to stop it. A hope he should’ve shed a long time ago. One that he never should’ve had in the first place.

Susan hovers there, perched on the threshold of Billy’s room. She looks right at him for a moment, and her expression could pass for concern if Billy didn’t know any better, and then she looks at Neil.

"Neil? Honey, I think…maybe it's OK if Billy does stay home? Only Max isn't very well and I don't like the thought of leaving her alone-"

Billy winces. Be careful what you wish for , he tells himself.

"Dad," he says, desperate to draw Neil's attention back to him and away from Susan. Away from Max and how she's messing up the plans. But Neil's already rebuckling his belt, fingers smoothing at his shirt to hide the motion. 

"That's a shame, Susie," he says with a shake of his head, "Poor kid. Sick on Christmas Eve. Still, these things can't be helped. I thought she looked pale at dinner." He nods curtly at Billy, “Of course Billy will keep an eye on her.”

And then they’re both gone, Neil sweeping Susan out of the room without even a backwards glance to check that Billy’s in agreement. Billy’s tempted to shout after him, to argue and complain until his dad is forced to turn back around and finish what he started instead. Because Billy hates this, the way the fear and adrenaline are all surging around his body with no place to go. It leaves him on edge and jittery, and even when he tries to sit back down on the bed, he can’t stop his foot from bouncing or his fingers from tapping over and over again. He can feel it, the tension that never properly diffused, the ghost of Neil’s anger so potent and ever present, long after Billy’s heard the front door close and the rumble of Neil’s truck fade away over the horizon.
Billy still can’t relax.
He needs to do something.

In the end, the something turns out to be sorting laundry. Not that there’s much to do, little more than a heap of socks and a few ratty gym shirts, and it’s definitely not enough to distract him from hearing the patter of Max’s footsteps a few rooms away, or the way they get closer and closer until they stop right outside his door.

He calls out to her without even looking up,  "Don't you dare puke in here."

“Huh?” Max seems genuinely confused, and when Billy looks up at her, she’s got a chocolate Santa in her hand, already decapitated.

“What the hell, shitbird? Thought you were sick?”

"Nope," Max pops the 'p', looking far too pleased with herself, "I told mom I had cramps." She waves the half-eaten chocolate in his direction, “Knew she wouldn't ask any more.”

Billy grimaces, lobbing a pair of balled up socks at her head, "Ugh, that's gross, Maxine."

"It's not gross. It's biology," she rolls her eyes, and Billy can see the flicker of mischief in her growing smirk, "Gross would be if I said something like 'it's like a whole jar of strawberry jam exploded in my jeans' or if-"

"Jesus Max!" Billy claps his hands to his ears, groaning in disgust, "Shut the fuck up, what's wrong with you?" 

Max's chuckle is damn near maniacal, and Billy throws another pair of socks at her just to get her to shut up.

"I don't really have them," she says, catching the socks one handed and throwing them back, "but I didn't want to go to stupid church, sitting there listening to some boring guy drone on and on about all that bullshit-"

"Yeah, alright, Nietzsche, cool it." Billy keeps his tone cool, but he turns his head to hide the smile. He waits a bit until it fades and when he looks back, Max is still there, lingering. 

“I’ve still got those videos I borrowed” she says, picking at the bright red foil around the chocolate as she talks, “I think Dustin’s Mom’s taped, like, every single Christmas movie they’ve ever shown on TV cause he gave me tons. There’s The Grinch and that Charlie Brown one and there’s at least three versions of Rudolph.”

She doesn’t say any more, so Billy doesn’t respond. He refolds a shirt that was already fine. Moves a pair of jeans from one pile to another, needlessly. He moves them back.

Max shuffles her feet, “We could watch one together. If you want to?”

“I’d rather shit in my hands and clap,” Billy says, still not looking at her.

“Ugh!” A ball of red foil hit him right in the ear, and he turns to glare at Max. She glares back, arms folded. There’s a scowl crossing her face, but there’s still a hint of a hurt expression underneath it, and Billy suddenly sees the offer for what it actually was.
An olive branch. 

He feels a little guilty at that. Because they'd been trying. Both of them. To be better. And so he stops folding. He takes a breath. He picks up the red foil and smooths it out, running his fingers over the creases until it's flat again. "But we could go for a drive?"

Max perks up at that, "Yeah?"

"Yeah. Say you needed some fucking, girl supplies or whatever so I took you to the store. Midnight run for Max's Maxi Pads."

"Now who's being gross?" Max pulls a face at him, but Billy can see the flicker of a smile at the edges of the grimace, and he shrugs.

"Thought it was biology? But, yeah, we could, I dunno, grab some food and maybe go look at some Christmas lights on the way or whatever?"

“Not much to see around here,” Max shrugs. She’s not wrong, Billy has to admit, there’s definitely not much in the way of spectacle on Cherry Lane.

“Yeah, well, we'll take the long way round then. Out near the rich side of town. Anywhere with a couple of Reagan signs out front oughta have a decent display." 

Max nods, and then she smiles, and it isn’t long before them two of them are bundled up in the Camaro, Billy navigating by hazy memories of house parties until he finds himself in Loch Nora.
There’s surprisingly little to see here, either. There are none of the ostentatious displays that Billy would have been seeking out back in California. Here everything is expensive, sure, but it’s all so neat and orderly, almost as though each house had followed the same tick sheet. A smattering of lanterns along the path tick , a single line of icicle lights on the front porch tick , a tasteful row of illuminated reindeer pulling an illuminated sleigh tick .

“Well this is a bust,” Billy grumbles. He’s trying not to let the frustration show but, really, he’s pissed. He'd only had a piece of toast for lunch, so with him skipping dinner he’s fucking hungry, and they drove an extra ten minutes to get out here, and it’s at least another ten back to anywhere with decent food that might actually be open tonight, and that’s without accounting for the shitty traffic signals and the Christmas Eve gridlock and the fact that it’s starting to snow, and his car does not handle well on ice anyway and- 

"That's Steve's place," Max interrupts his thoughts, pointing over towards one of the houses, a weirdly proportioned, grey-panelled box of a building.

"Figures he'd love somewhere like this,” Billy leans forward, creeping the car further down the driveway lit by the exact same parade of Victorian style lanterns as everywhere else they just passed, “God it's an ugly ass house."

Max shrugs, "Got a pool though," she says, a little too smugly for Billy's liking, "Heated."

Part of him wants to snap at her, remind her that back home they used to live right by the beach and that they didn't need a heated fucking pool because the ocean was right there and it was always warm enough to go for a swim in it and if she and her Mom hadn't come along and fucked everything up then maybe they'd still be back there and maybe Billy would still have-

But he stops himself. He swallows down the rising fury. Because he's trying. He's trying not to do that anymore. Not to be like that. And he might not have the beach, but he has his car and he's out of the house and it's Christmas Eve and he's looking at the lights.

So it's OK. He's OK. 

"Figures," he says again, a little tightly. He feels the anger ebbing, just a little. He stares out at Steve’s house again, noticing how, even without all the decorations, Steve's house would still be lit up like a Christmas tree. There’s a light on in every room downstairs and the shadows of a whole room of bodies move behind the curtains, while the twinkling lights cascading over the roof reflect off the shining bonnets of a dozen expensive cars.

It looks like a party, but before Billy can ask Max if she knows anything, the door opens and a figure slips out, and a whole other question falls from Billy’s lips before he can stop it.

"That Harrington?"

But Billy already knows the answer. He'd know that form anywhere, even from this distance, even through the haze of a misting up windscreen. Beside him, Max leans forward, rubbing a porthole in the condensation on her window to squint out into the darkness, and Billy does the same, both of them taking in the sight at the same time.

Steve is standing on the doorstep, back pressed against the wood with a cigarette in his hand, staring out into the night. He’s illuminated by the Christmas lights, somehow looking golden even in the cold white of the plastic snowflakes that dangle just above his head, and he looks nice, real nice , Billy thinks, dressed in a smart, bright red sweater and a pair of tight fitted khakis, but there's no joy on his face, no sign that he's been involved in whatever merriment is clearly occuring inside.

He looks lost. Sad. 

Max must notice it too because, without even a word, she's scrambling out of the Camaro and scampering up to him, and the moment Steve catches sight of her, his face erupts into a big, bright smile. It's just a quick thing, the big beam, before it softens into something fond and slightly crooked, but Billy is struck with a sudden, desperate desire to have that smile directed at him. 

He shakes the thought away as soon as it comes, forcing himself to think of Steve's face the last time Billy had any real influence over it, how he'd left it bloodied and bruised and broken, and a wave of guilt crashes into him, twisting in the pit of his stomach until his feels nauseous with it. He forces himself not to stare at Steve anymore. Instead he hunkers into his seat, shuffling down low enough that Max and Harrington are hidden by the dashboard, and all Billy can see are the Christmas lights on the roof of Harrington's house, and the way they catch on the light flurry of snow that's starting to fall all around, making it all sparkle.

He lets his eyes unfocus until the whole thing becomes a meaningless blur.

It’s soothing. Hypnotising. 

There's a murmur of sound from the radio, a familiar Christmas song playing soft and low. The Camaro’s engine is just as familiar and comforting as it thrums under him, finally running hot enough to allow the heater to blow out a steady stream of dusty smelling warm air.
Billy is warm. He’s safe. And for the first time tonight. Hell, for the first time in a while, Billy feels a little of the tension leave his body as his eyes drop closed. Just for a little while.

He jerks back up when the passenger door opens, letting in a blast of cold air and a stream of curses from Max, uttered from behind chattering teeth, and a smell. A heavenly fucking smell. Something sweet and a little spicy and so delicious that Billy's mouth starts watering and he's pretty sure he's drooling like a cartoon wolf sniffing out a pie. His stomach growls loudly. Embarrassingly. He hunches his body over to try and muffle the sound, but Max must’ve noticed, because she’s holding out a cookie, one of many that she’s got in her lap. 

They look just as good as they smell. All different shapes, Christmas trees and reindeer and snowman and bells, and all decorated beautifully with intricate swirls of icing and studded with tiny silver balls or meticulously placed sprinkles, and Billy can tell that they’re not store bought. These cookies have been made with love.
He stares at the one that Max is holding out for a little too long, because she ends up thrusting it into his lap. 

"Here," she says, already taking a bite of her second cookie, "Steve said there's one for you too, and to tell you ‘Merry Christmas’"

The statement is enough to stop Billy caring about the mess of crumbs that fell out of Max’s mouth when she said it, even the ones that she’s accidentally grinding into the floor mat with her boot.

"Why?" he asks.

"I dunno," Max says through another mouthful of crumbs, "'s Steve, he's nice." 

As if that answers everything. Maybe it does.

Billy takes a tentative bite of the cookie in his hand, wary of a trap, but as soon as he gets the first taste, he's desperate for another. It's everything the scent promised and more. Buttery and crunchy with that perfect blend of cinnamon that spreads over his tongue, warming him from the inside out. Billy closes his eyes in bliss. It tastes like Christmas.  Just for a second, he's right back in the kitchen in the house back in Cali, baking cookies with his Mom. 
It tastes like happiness. 

When he opens his eyes, he's looking right out of the now demisted windscreen. He can see Steve clearly now, and he's back to looking lost, the bright smile from before completely vanished, looking down at his feet with his shoulders hunched, so before Billy pulls away, he presses his foot down onto the accelerator, jerking the wheel so that the front of his car veers down Steve’s driveway, the front tyres crossing the threshold at an angle, pointing the driver’s side of the car towards the house. It’s little more than a slightly messy turn, a squeal of rubber that has Steve’s head darting up. The moment he does, Billy winds down his window and raises the bottom half of his cookie up in a salute.
He holds it there for a moment, and then Steve gives a little wave, the cherry of his cigarette bobbing in the darkness, and smiles.

It's not a big beam. It's not really soft or fond. But it's a smile directed at Billy.
It's nice. 

Chapter 6: Hawkins: Faithful Friends Who Are Dear to Us

Summary:

There’s still quite a few hours until Billy actually gets to properly experience the thrill of the Hawkins Memorial Hospital festivities, but Max had been full of the spirit of Christmas for the last week or so, and Billy’s room had not been spared her attention. There’s what seems like a whole mile of paper chain made from cut up strips of old Teen Beats and Metal Hammer draped around his bed- Tommy Lee and Ozzy bumping cheeks with Ricky Shroder and Simon Le Bon; there’s a whole stack of Tupperware containing Max and El’s disastrous attempts at festive baking and there’s even a tiny tabletop Christmas tree drooping under the weight of the two full sized baubles that the girls had optimistically hung from its spindly branches.

It’s definitely nothing spectacular. But Billy can’t help but feel a thrum of warmth whenever he looks at the decorations around him. And then he starts to feel even warmer when he hears a familiar squeak of sneakers in the corridor, and catches sight of Steve Harrington coming in to view, slightly red faced with the effort of pushing a huge TV cart along in front of him.

Chapter Text

Billy wonders what it says about his life that the Christmas he’s going to have to spend in the hospital is shaping up to be one of the nicest that he’s had in a while. 

Not that it’s actually Christmas yet.

There’s still quite a few hours until Billy actually gets to properly experience the thrill of the Hawkins Memorial Hospital festivities, but Max had been full of the spirit of Christmas for the last week or so, and Billy’s room had not been spared her attention. There’s what seems like a whole mile of paper chain made from cut up strips of old Teen Beats and Metal Hammer draped around his bed- Tommy Lee and Ozzy bumping cheeks with Ricky Shroder and Simon Le Bon; there’s a whole stack of Tupperware containing Max and El’s disastrous attempts at festive baking and there’s even a tiny tabletop Christmas tree drooping under the weight of the two full sized baubles that the girls had optimistically hung from its spindly branches.

It’s definitely nothing spectacular. But Billy can’t help but feel a thrum of warmth whenever he looks at the decorations around him. And then he starts to feel even warmer when he hears a familiar squeak of sneakers in the corridor, and catches sight of Steve Harrington coming in to view, slightly red faced with the effort of pushing a huge TV cart along in front of him.

Billy catches his eye, looking away when Steve smiles back, desperately trying to swerve his brain away from the connection it's so eager to make. That maybe Steve's presence has more than a little to do with the whole nicest Christmas in a while thing.

He’s been there since the first day that Billy was allowed visitors.
At first he was just the kids’ grudging chauffeur, dropping off Max and El and whichever of the other dweebs tagged along at their heels and offering Billy an awkward waggly fingered wave at the doorway every time.
And then, after a month or so of little more than dorky waves, it just so happened that Steve was the only one in earshot when Billy had one of his moments. His funny turns . His fucking waking nightmares , as he preferred to call them, seeing no point sugaring that particularly turd of a pill. Because Billy’s brain was messed up and sometimes it threw him right back into the horror show that had been his life over summer, and he would act like a fucking pussy, freaking out and sobbing and pissing himself with fear, sometimes all too literally, and it was absolutely fucking humiliating and of course Steve had been the one to see it, of course the girls had wandered off somewhere, of course Steve was right fucking there.

But he’d been good. Soothing in a way that Billy hadn’t thought he’d be capable of, and that he wasn’t entirely sure he deserved. Steve wasn’t like the nurses with their cold hands and robotic platitudes, Steve stumbled over his words and rambled on about basketball games and Billy’s tattoo and some girl they both apparently had class with, someone that Billy couldn’t even remember, and he sang a few bars of some shitty Bon Jovi song and even did a little air guitar and it was awful and loud and painfully dorky and it worked .

That was the thing.
It worked.
Steve had managed to pull Billy out of his head, and he didn’t even care that Billy’s first action was to tell him to shut the hell up. Harrington. Jesus Christ, that wailing is making me miss the coma.
Steve had just laughed, and gone on a whole other tangent about how he knew Billy was a Bon Jovi fan because, Come on, man, everyone’s a fan, dude this one just came out, you’re only grouchy cause you haven’t heard it properly.

And from then on, Steve had unofficially graduated from waggly fingered chauffeur to full-on daily Billy visitor. Which is why it makes some sense that he’s here on Christmas Eve. But it doesn't quite explain the television set. 

“You worried about missing Jeopardy, Harrington?” 

Steve offers little more than a sarcastic laugh, distracted by trying to figure out how to get the television set working, and Billy sits up in bed, trying to figure out what’s going on. He spots a small pile of tapes on top of the VCR player, Christmas movies, most of them for kids, and he shakes his head, “ Did you seriously steal this thing from the kids' ward? On Christmas Eve? Jesus, Steve, that’s some Grinch shit."

"Shut up, no,  Max had an idea-"

"Blaming kids now? Wow, you really don't wanna be on Santa's nice list, do you?"

Steve scowls at him, but there’s a smile not far behind it, “Hey, look, it’s gotta be past those kids’ bedtime by now. No way they’re gonna get better if they’re up all night watching TV. If anything, I’m helping them.”

Whatever quip Billy is about to fire back with is interrupted by Max running through the door, a massive bowl of popcorn in her arms, a trail of kernels spilling behind her like some modern day Hansel and Gretel.

“I did it!” she grins eagerly, flopping down onto Billy’s bed and shoving his feet to the side to make room, “I don’t think the nurses even noticed me using their microwave.”

“Where’s the bowl from?” Steve asks, eyeing it warily, “You checked it first, right? It’s not, like, one of those ones they give to the old guys when they can’t hobble to the bathroom? Or the ones the give to the pukers? It’s not, shit, it’s definitely not a puke bowl?”

“I rinsed it out,” Max says, and Billy sees the gleam of mischief in her eye, “I mean, I guess it did smell kinda funky but everything in this place smells kind of funky, right?”

Billy can’t help the bark of laughter that escapes the moment he sees the disgust on Steve’s face, and Max is joining in only a second later, giggling so much that the bowl in question is in danger of tipping out all over Billy’s bed. 

“Are you done?” Steve asks, still standing by the television, his hands on his hips in a stance that Billy has become more than a little familiar with. 

“Uh-oh,” he stage-whispers, tapping Max with his foot, “Daddy’s mad.” 

Billy’s brain catches up with his mouth the instant the words are out of it, but it’s too late. He knows he’s blushing, a full face worth, right up to the tips of his ears, and there’s a matching redness spreading along Steve’s cheeks.

Luckily, Max doesn’t seem to notice. She speaks through the sudden tension in the air, “We don’t have long,” she explains, “It sucks, but I promised Mom I wouldn’t stay too late tonight. You know what she can be like, she still wants to do, like, the stocking present and the carrot for Rudolph. All that stuff. So we’ve probably only got time to watch one.”

“One…what?” Billy asks, trying to work it out. 

“One movie,” Max rolls her eyes, “Obviously. You haven’t seen any this year, so we’re bringing them to you. Or well, one of them. So make it a good one.”

Billy doesn’t quite know what to say. Max is looking at him, looking more and more worried with every second of silence that passes, and so Billy forces himself to nod. 

“Yeah, that, um, that’ll be…that’s a good plan, squirt. I’ll let, uh, I’ll let you pick though. Go on.”

While Max sorts through the collection of tapes, Steve comes over, and Billy doesn’t realise what he’s planning to do until he’s doing it. There’s a gap on the bed, not a huge one, but just big enough for Steve to sit down. And he does. He sits himself down in the space right next to Billy’s hip, so close that Billy can feel the warmth of his body through the thin hospital sheets. So close that Billy is aware of every single breath Steve takes. So close that Billy doesn’t have a fucking clue which movie Max picked in the end.
He can’t concentrate on anything else right now. 

—

"I gotta pee,” Max mutters, somewhere around the halfway point of the film.

“Want me to pause it?” Steve asks. He’s got the remote in his hand, finger already hovering over the button, but Max waves him off. 

“Not like I’m going to be missing any riveting plot,” she picks a popcorn kernel from her hair, flicking it over at Billy as she walks out of the room.

Steve pauses the movie anyway. 

“I think I could probably recite this from memory, y’know,” he says, “Seriously, no wonder I could never remember shit like, when the Civil War started or how to do long division, cause my head is already packed full with every single line from Rudolph the Red-Nosed goddamn Reindeer.” 

“Well, hey, it’s a classic,” Billy shrugs, “Not sure I’d be that passionate about it but whatever floats your boat, Harrington.”

“Not like I had a choice,” Steve shrugs, but there’s a sadness in his eyes, “When I was a kid, Mom was always crazy busy at Christmas. Soon as it got to October she’d already be sorting some fund raiser or dance or party or whatever, or writing out a whole stack of cards, like, three foot high, so as soon as school let out, I’d get shoved in front of the television with a pile of juice boxes so I didn’t bother her. She even had a whole stash of tapes, probably as tall as me now, all these Christmas movies she’d recorded over the years, so there was no risk of me ever running out of shit to watch. Swear we had four copies of Rudolph, all the same except for the ads. And Charlie Brown. And, oh, this super weird one about a dancing squirrel and-"

A memory stirs, right in the back of Billy’s mind, "Holy shit! I know the one you mean!" 

"No way!"

"Yeah, he was wearing a kilt, right? I have no fucking idea what the hell it was about, but there was definitely a squirrel in a kilt."

"Yes! Oh man, that's the one!"  

He looks utterly delighted, just for a moment, and then his smile drops, “So, yeah, Christmas movies. Not, uh, not a big fan.” 

“No shit,” Billy says. “You almost make my Christmasses look good."

Steve looks chastened, his eyes drop to his lap, and he drums the fingers of one hand over his knee, "Yeah, no, you're right, I'm being dramatic. It, uh, it wasn't too bad. Christmas Day is better, I guess." He looks back up, face tight, "Mom usually has a headache, so we're kinda low-key. Play a few games, go for a walk. That sort of stuff. And we get to have breakfast together so, yeah, that's nice." He shrugs, his face falling again, and Billy isn't convinced one bit.

"Nice? Gotta be honest, it sounds kinda lame, Steve-o," he jokes, nudging Steve with an elbow, "I always thought that you rich guys had, y’know, big fancy-ass parties where you wear ball gowns and sing carols around the piano and pretend not to hate each other, something like that.” 

Steve laughs, his whole face lighting up with it, “Oh we have something like that, definitely. Well, there’s a party. Yeah, my, uh, my parents throw this huge one every year and they invite, like, the whole of Loch Nora and and a ton of guys from Dad's work and the country club and so the house is full of well, assholes. Boring drunk assholes, mostly.” Steve laughs, but there’s not a lot of humour in it, “I didn't used to mind so much when I was a little kid, not really, Mom'd.wheel me out and I'd be, y'know, my adorable self and everyone'd coo over me for ten minutes and I'd, I dunno, parrot some dumb joke I overheard on a Robert Klein record or whatever and they'd fall over themself laughing and then I'd get sent off to bed. "But, uh, yeah…it didn't last long. That whole cute little kid thing."

There's a sadness in Steve’s eyes again, and a couple of frown lines between his brows,  but before Billy can make a joke, can try to do something to try and put the grin back on Steve’s face, Steve is doing it himself. His mouth quirks back up and he’s off reminiscing again.

“But it was OK cause my Gramma, my, well, yeah, my Grandma, she comes too. My mom's mom. She's from out of town, I don’t get to see her that much the rest of the year, not really, but she'll fly in for a few days and she'll bring a whole suitcase of cookies that she's made. I swear she'll have, like, one nightgown and one dress and the rest of her luggage would be cookies. And they'd all be perfect, not a crack or a broken bit of icing or anything. It's like witchcraft. And Gramma, she doesn’t, uh, she didn’t like the parties. So even though she was meant to be, like, putting me to bed or whatever, reading me a story, instead she’d let me sneak into her room and we’d sit together and we’d watch the same movies I’d already watched a few days ago, but it was…I dunno, I guess it was kinda nice watching them with her. Different. And we didn’t really watch them properly, I guess, we’d just talk or she’d tell me stories or whatever. And she would make this, like, peppermint hot chocolate and so we eat our way through a whole tin of her special cookies and drink the hot chocolate.”

Billy can’t take his eyes away from Steve’s face as he talks. The sadness that had been clouding his expression has entirely disappeared, his smile growing steadily bigger and bigger as Steve loses himself in the recollection. His tongue darting out at the mention of the cookies and hot chocolate, licking his lips before he carries on talking, 

“And even when I got older, like, fourteen, fifteen? Like, when I was meant to start joining in with the party properly, like an adult, getting to know all those business assholes or being introduced to whichever random daughter of her friends Mom wanted to set me up with, even then Gramma still knew how to sneak me away, just for a little bit. She's got this knack of knowing when I'm having a hard time, like when my Dad starts being a dick about how I'm getting on in school or something, she’ll just, like, appear at my side and basically rescue me.”

Steve chuckles fondly, a far away look in his eye. He's happier than Billy's seen him for a long time. There are pink spots on his cheeks, and a proper sparkle in his eyes. He looks younger, more like an eager little boy than the teenager who’d seen far too much.

"She has this clever way of doing it, acting all doddery and insisting that she needs me to help walk her to her room or something, and then the moment we get out of sight, she’ll be jogging into the kitchen to grab the cookies. She doesn’t really eat them any more though, not now. Not, uh, not for a couple of years. She, uh, she gets kinda tired, I guess, so she'll just talk with me for a bit, and then she'll say something about how I looked bored at the party and she'll give me a wink and point at her window -cause she always has the guest room on the ground floor- she'll point to it and tell me to sneak out. Every year. She'll give me the rest of the cookies and be like, 'Go on, off you go, and share the rest these with your girlfriend .' It doesn't even matter if I've told her I'm not dating anyone, she'll still insist that I must have a sweetheart, someone to kiss under the mistletoe, and that I should go have fun. And, oh shit! Yeah! I remember one time I told her I was gonna go to Tommy's house, cause, well, that was the only place I could think to go, and I didn't even think about how it must've sounded, but I swear she didn't even blink. She just smiled and told me that a sweetheart is a sweetheart and she hoped Tommy liked the cookies." 

Billy waits for a second, but there’s nothing more to come, and so Billy lets out the bark of slightly nervous laughter that he’d been holding in, "Damn, Harrington, she sounds great. Wild. Chick after my own heart.” 

Steve laughs at that, a proper, hearty laugh, one that thrills Billy to hear it. He basks in it, in the ripple of the follow up giggle that comes after, and in the way that Steve seems to be looking at him, his eager little smile still right in place.

“I’d warn her about you,” Steve says, “But knowing her she'd wanna sneak out with me to come meet you.”

“Hey, if she brings a tin of those cookies along? I’m hers. Go on, Stevie, get your ass back home and tell her I’m waiting." 

Suddenly the bright grin falls from Steve’s face. It’s replaced almost instantly, but the new smile is small and pained and as soon as he sees it, Billy's kicking himself. He prepares himself for the worst, especially when Steve ducks his head, rubbing at his nose with his thumb, but then he swallows and sighs, 

“No, she, uh, she didn’t come this year. It’s for the best. She’s getting kinda old to travel now. She found last year a bit too much, and she ended up going to bed before the party had even started, and then she stayed in bed for most of Christmas too. So…yeah, it's uh, it's for the best. I'll go and see her in the New Year.” 

Steve shrugs, trying to seem casual, but their conversation trails off, leaving an uncomfortable silence in its wake. Billy glances desperately to the door, hoping to see Max on her way back, but the corridor is empty.

"My mom made cookies too," he says, needing to do something to chase away the awkward atmosphere.

He’s not sure if it’s working. Steve’s smile is still that small looking one, and he’s got one knee tucked up to his chest, one arm wrapped around it, looking small and lost, but Billy pushes on anyway. He looks down at his fingernails, picking at the non-existent dirt underneath them, and lets the words fall out.

"We, uh, we didn't have a lot of money, so Christmas was never a big thing," he starts. "But Mom tried. A lot. To make it special. She wanted to give gifts to a lot of people and, well, we couldn’t exactly buy anything decent so she’d bake. And I’d help. And she’d bag the cookies up, all fancy like, tied with ribbons and shit, and we’d go out delivering them. It wasn’t a lot but I think people liked them. Or the thought, at least.”

It all comes out in a rush, and Billy looks up as he pauses to draw breath. Steve’s looking at him, his eyes big and searching, and there’s the beginnings of a smile on his face. Small but real.
It’s almost too much, too much to be directed at him, and Billy wants to look away but he also doesn’t. He wants to keep looking at Steve and he wants to make that smile even bigger and he wants to keep talking about his Mom because it’s been so long since he did, so long since he could .
So Billy keeps talking. 

“And she, uh, she’d take me out on Christmas Eve to see all the lights. That was our thing. Since I was a baby, like an actual baby, it’s what she did. And it was a whole thing, cause there were a few neighbourhoods near us, the proper rich ones, all gated and shit. Massive fucking houses with doctors and lawyers and I think some old movie stars lived around there too, not quite Beverly Hills but, y’know, it may as well have been for a dumb kid like me, and we’d go see all the displays. There was one place that had a whole damn sleigh and reindeer thing set up on their roof, all colourful flashing lights. I still remember that. But my mom liked the simpler ones more, just lights. And I…yeah. I kinda get that now. And she’d take us to this-" 

They’re interrupted by the squeak of the door. Max scurries in, glancing behind her as she pulls the door closed.

“They, uh, they noticed that we took the TV,” she says. Her face is red, the kind of red it gets when she’s in trouble. “They’re not, like, properly mad, cause I explained it all, and Maggie was there, the nice one, and she said it was a sweet idea so, yeah, I think we’re OK but, uh, we should probably get going like, well, now. Before they come kick us out for real.” 

She’s looking at Steve as she says it all, so it comes as a surprise when Billy feels the sudden weight of Max’s arms around his neck, her popcorn scented hair getting all over his face and in his mouth as she holds him tightly, almost burrowing in to his chest. 

“I’ll see you tomorrow,” she says, “I promise. Neil says maybe after dinner but I’ll skate here myself if he’s being an asshole about it.”

“No you won’t,” Steve shakes his head firmly, “C’mon then, Max, let’s get this show on the road.” He reaches down to the floor and picks up her jacket, throwing it over at her, “Billy, good to see you, man. Hope you have a good Christmas tomorrow. I’ll try to swing by, OK?”

And then they’re both gone.

For a moment. Billy’s about to sink into his pillows and close his eyes and try to get his head around what exactly happened this evening, when the door squeaks again and he looks up to see Steve looking sheepish.

"Not gonna get far without these," he grins, stepping into the room and scooping up the car keys he'd left on the table by Billy's bed, giving them a jingle in the air before he turns to leave again.

It's just a comment. And it's so dorky. It definitely shouldn't be making Billy feel like this, all warm and fuzzy and soft.
But it is.
Billy knows why.
And he knows that he's utterly screwed.

—

Billy’s mostly asleep when the door squeaks again.

He's drifting, his brain a jumble of memories of his Mom and Christmas lights and freshly baked cookies all mingled with dancing squirrels and Claymation reindeer and then crashing together with images of Max and Steve, real life happenings mixed up with Billy's own imaginings- the sensation of Max's skinny arms wrapping around him in a hug turning into thoughts of Steve's body warm against his- but he jolts to full awareness quickly, expecting to see one of his nurses. For a large part of his recovery he’d needed waking up the the middle of the night for additional meds, but even though he should’ve been used to it, he never did lose that initial pang of fear when he’d sense someone walking into his room, or when he’d catch sight of a strange figure silhouetted in the doorway.

But instead of Maggie or any of her team of night nurses, it’s Steve. 

Billy wonders if he's still dreaming. He's had ones that start like this before, he just tried not to think about them, but Steve does nothing more than give him that wiggly fingered wave, “Oh hey, shit, sorry man, I didn’t mean to wake you.”

“No, you, uh, you didn’t,” Although his mind is racing, Billy’s voice is still slow and thick and heavy, exposing his lie, “I was just dozing.”

Steve steps over the threshold, a bundle in a winter jacket and a thick, woollen scarf, layers that he'd shedding as he enters in a way that is definitely more like some of Billy's more interesting dreams. He stops by Billy's bedside, picking up the little clock that sits on the table and tilting it into the light to read the face.

"Oh good, not quite midnight, still Christmas Eve. I'm not too late." 

"Late?" Billy asks, his voice a little more human now. He shuffles himself to sit up properly, trying not to notice the way that Steve's hand is already there, shoving a pillow behind his back, "It's not even Christmas, you're early."

"Yeah, uh, no, I mean, um. I got… I got you a present."

Billy scrunches up his nose, "You already got me a present." None of this is making sense. Maybe he is still dreaming. Because Steve definitely had, only a few days ago. Billy had unwrapped it the moment Steve had handed it to him, not even thinking to save it until later, tearing at the wrapping until he found himself staring down at the colourful squares of a Rubik's Cube, and the confusion must have shown on his face because Steve had almost fallen over himself in his haste to explain.

"Yeah, ok, so it's kinda…it's dumb, I know, but I saw Dustin with one a few days ago and I thought, I dunno, it might be something to help with your hands? Like, all those exercises you have to do? The therapy thing? And it's something to take your mind off being here, right? Something fun? I mean, don't ask me, I've never been able to do one without peeling off the stickers so I don't get the appeal, but I figured it might make a change from old magazines. Or, y'know, if you hate it then hey, it's something to throw at that bitchy nurse who makes you turn your music off." 

Billy picks up the half-finished cube from where he'd hidden it away in the gap between his mattress and the bed rail, holding it up in the air as proof, but Steve just waves it away. 

"Yeah, ok, well, I got you something else too." He reaches into his backpack and pulls out a whole handful of lights. A bundle of them, the green plastic wire wrapped round and round itself in a ball. "So, before? When you said you used to go look at the lights on Christmas Eve? Well I figured, hey, how about this year I bring the lights to you?"

He holds them up again, a big, eager smile on his face, and Billy's chest starts to ache. 

Because here's Steve, looking like a damn ray of sunshine, dangling the promise of Christmas Eve lights in front of Billy, not realising the weight of what he's holding, what he's offering. And for Billy, with his mixed up memories still fresh in his mind, it's almost too much. 

"Huh?" is all he manages, and he shakes his head, trying to organise his thoughts enough to say something more substantial, anything , and Steve's face falls. It's quick, just a flash of sadness before he's smiling again, but this one is tight and forced.

"Yeah, no, it's…I get it, it's dumb, a dumb idea. You’re tired, you should sleep, I'm sorry, I don't know what I was thinking coming back. I'll, uh, I'll see you tomorrow, yeah? Probably. I'll, uh, shit-" Steve's hands are shaking as he tries to stuff the lights back inside the backpack, the wire of them catching on the zipper every time he tries to close the bag up. 

"Harrington," Billy eventually manages, even though it comes out a little choked, "How long til midnight?"

"Um… I, uh, I dunno-" Steve checks the clock again, "Seven minutes. Why?"

"Better hurry up then." 

Steve's smile grows, until it’s settled back into the eager one. The sunshine one that suits him so well. He sits himself down on Billy's bed, back in the exact close-oh-so-close space he'd been in earlier, and sets to untangling the lights. Billy stays silent, watching as Steve's fingers work out the knots and kinks in the wire and then, as the lights start to unspool, one by one, something around Billy's heart starts to loosen too. Something sharp and ugly that had been there so long, that Billy had stopped noticing its presence until right now, now that he's suddenly faced with the absence of it. 

The something, the barbed wire like thing, had been weakening its hold for a while, he knows that. Max had started the process, and El too, the love of the two girls teasing the edges of it away, pulling it bit by by, slowly enough that Billy could adjust each time, but it had always still been there, deep down, as much a part of Billy as the curls in his hair or the blue in his eyes.

But, with Steve, it's not slow. It's not gentle. It feels like it’s been ripped from him, this blockade, this barrier, this wall. Ripped from him and flung aside, shattering into pieces so small that Billy will have to scramble to reconstruct it. This time, the release is almost painful, the sudden surge of emotion and feeling rushing back to a space that had been void of them for so long. It's like pins and needles, only a thousand times stronger, strong enough that Billy gasps out loud and Steve's fingers stop moving immediately, the lights dropping into his lap as he reaches out for Billy instead. His fingers ghost over the back of Billy's hand and Billy tries not to gasp again.

He doesn't succeed.

Steve's touch becomes firmer. A whole hand now, sliding up Billy's arm and grasping firmly, "Billy? You OK, man? You hear Santa coming or something? Sleigh bells on the roof?" 

Billy manages a weak chuckle. He's still adjusting. Still hurting, just a little, but in a good way now, the feeling becoming more like a rush than a pain.

"Nah, it's fine, I'm good. All good. How're those lights looking?"

"Nearly there," Steve says, returning to the bundle in his lap. Billy mourns the loss of his hand, but within a few seconds Steve is off the bed entirely, the wire of the lights draped over one arm as he dashes around round and round the room, weaving the strand of lights in between the bars around Billy's bed, draping them up and down over furniture, winding them around the stand for Billy's monitor and even dragging the visitors' chair across the floor so he can get them criss crossing across the ceiling and curling around the ugly florescent bulb hanging the the middle.

He works fast, and it seems like only seconds before he's standing by the wall, the plug in his hand, seeking out an empty socket.

"Just don't go unplugging anything important, OK?" Billy jokes.

"You don't still need the oxygen, right?" Steve quips back, pulling out the plug for the stereo in the corner of the room and replacing it with the one for the lights.

And Billy gasps again. 

The room illuminates with what looks like hundreds of tiny lights, delicate little things sparkling like fireflies. The spool hadn’t looked like much in Steve’s hands, but in action it’s magical. These lights are pretty. Classy. Clearly expensive. They emit a softer glow than Billy's used to seeing, and every inch of the room seems to shine with a golden haze.

Or maybe that's just Steve. Steve who's standing there, smiling that crooked little smile. He glows. He's fucking glowing. And Billy's newly exposed heart is aching at the sight of him like that, golden and glowing and so so good.

“Oh hey! They actually look pretty good!” Steve nods in satisfaction at his handy work, and then he’s sitting back down in the space so close to Billy, “What time is it? Did we make it?” 

Billy checks. The clock beside the bed still shows a minute until midnight. 

It's Christmas Eve and Billy's finally found his light. 

Chapter 7: Hawkins: Have Yourself A Merry Little Christmas Now

Summary:

He's always been a sucker for Steve.
He's always known there was something there, a flame that he’d been kindling. It had been lust at first sight that night at Tina's Halloween party only a few years ago, and while there'd been the seed of something deeper underneath, Billy thinks that he might be been OK, might've just about been able to keep that seed unwatered, kept it buried in the harshest, most unforgiving of soil until it withered and died without fully taking root.  But then Steve ended up being a bigger part of his life than Billy ever could have imagined. They became friends. And that was harder. A hell of a lot harder. Bit by bit, he got to see every side of Steve. The smooth talking charmer; the slightly bitchy ex-King; the dorky babysitter; the caring, compassionate friend; the brave, determined protector.
He got to see Steve and know him and see all the wonderful parts of him and he fell in love.

How could he not?

Billy fell head over heels, ass over tea kettle, heart and soul, madly and stupidly in love.

Notes:

Here we are! If you made it through, well done and thank you so much! I promise that our boy gets his happy ending and his golden boy, and here's where it all happens!

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

For the first time in a long time, Billy's actually feeling excited about Christmas.

It helps that it's all on his own terms this year. No Neil to put a damper on things, no Susan and her enforced jollity. Just him and his own place and whatever the fuck he wants to do. 

It turns out that, when he's not being forced to enjoy someone else's idea of a holiday, Billy can actually feel quite festive, and when that's coupled with Billy's new mantra of, 'Fuck it, I survived, I'm gonna do what the fuck I want,' well then, Billy could almost call himself jolly. 

His new place isn't exactly luxurious- just a one bed in the shitty part of town- but he’s done his best, with what limited budget he has left after actually buying the place, to spruce it up. He’s decked his hall and his living room and even his kitchen, and he’s even managed to get a few strands of lights to hang outside. Just a few, nothing spectacular, but enough to make him smile when he had to make a late night dash to the store and he came back to them shining out in the darkness.

The tree has been the hardest thing. Not the tree itself, that had been easy. Billy had chosen an artificial one, green, this time, rather than metallic. It wasn't exactly a skyscraper but it was definitely an upgrade from the tiny table top one of the previous year, and Billy had to move the coffee table into his bedroom in order to squeeze it into his living room, but it was worth the sacrifice. 

He’d had to build up to decorating it though. If it hadn’t been for Max needling him, tutting every time she came over and saw the bare tree, grousing about how weird it was and then finally threatening that if he didn’t get his act together she and El would see to it that it was decorated to their tastes instead, Billy’s pretty sure he’d still be staring at bare branches even now. With her threats of bright pink tinsel and Wonder Woman themed baubles ringing loud in his ears, Billy had finally dug out the shoebox he’d been keeping safe for over a decade, pulling it out from right at the back of the top shelf of his closet, safe and hidden even here, in his own place, and carried it with shaking hands into the living room. He’d spent a good hour just looking at the few items inside, seeing them with fresh, older eyes, stroking his fingers over each one in turn, and then he’d arranged them on his tree, the stained, satin bell dangling from the lowest branch, the one-winged cherub nestled somewhere in the middle, while the red wooden horse had pride of place near the top. 

It wasn’t enough, Billy knew, the tree seemed to look even sadder now, the few ornaments looking lost amidst all the branches, and Billy had been half tempted to pack the whole lot away, tree included, and pretend he’d never tried.
But he didn’t. 

Although it still didn’t look right , there was something comforting about having the decorations there, finally back where they should be. There was a thrill in it too, seeing the precious items that he’d rescued and kept so safe over the years finally on display. It was scary too, of course, and it’d been a few days before he’d been able to stop checking that they were still there every morning, but little by little, he started to enjoy it.

And then, one by one, other decorations started to join them. He knew it was Max. Max and her cronies. They weren’t exactly subtle. They’d come round, a whole pack of them, and one of them would corner Billy, distract him with some inane question or meandering story, while the others giggled away in the living room and, by the time Billy managed to shoo them all out of his house, the tree would be dotted with a selection of colourful baubles or strands of tinsel or length of popcorn garland eve, or more than one occasional, some hideous little movie tie in. A Gremlin or a Care Bear or something Billy didn’t even recognise. There were good ornaments too, mixed in amongst them. Tiny, delicate crystal cats and big, velvety stars and other, more grown up choices that Billy figured had been stolen from the kids' parents, ones that he probably should've returned, but instead Billy played along with their games, pretending not to notice and, bit by bit, the tree started to look OK. A few more days, and it was better than OK. A few days more, and Billy could even say that it was good. 

He started baking too. It had been a spur of the moment decision. Something to keep him busy, when he’d woken up from a nightmare and needed to do something anything to distract his still swirling mind from clinging on to the fear. He’d not had much in, but he had butter and sugar and flour and Joyce’s housewarming present had been a stack of recipe books so that was enough.
He’d measured and mixed and shaped and patted and swore and scowled and poked and sighed and grumbled and tipped more than one shitty batch into the bin and by the time the sunlight was filtering through the thin, gingham curtains, Billy had filthy counters, aching hands and a whole empty pantry. But he also had a home that smelt of cinnamon, a dining table covered in plates of cooling cookies and a great big smile on his face.
Even the best batches didn't turn out quite as good as his Mom's ever did, but they were decent enough that Billy found himself boxing them up and handing them over to the people who, over the last couple of years, had welcomed him into their lives.

Max got a good selection of course, and El and the rest of the brats, even though he made sure that the Wheeler kid mostly got the raisin ones.
He even made some for Maggie in the hospital. 

And Joyce and the Chief. They got the best looking ones. Billy had even bought a set of special Christmas boxes for them and spent a while perfecting his bows. 

And then there’d been Steve. 

Billy had spent a long time second guessing himself with that one. In the end, he decided not to go for the formality of the box, and thought he'd offer up a casual invitation for Steve to come over and hang on Christmas day, and leave a tempting plate of cookies out on the table in the living room, ready and waiting for Steve if he wanted them.

It wasn't like the invitation would be something unusual. They were friends now, after all, close enough that Steve knew where Billy kept the good glasses and he had a usual spot on Billy's third-hand, slightly sagging couch when he came round to watch a movie. So it wouldn't have to be any more than that. Just two buddies spending a holiday together.  But still, Billy hadn't quite been able to force himself to ask Steve.
Not yet. 

And now it was Christmas Eve. Time’s officially run out. He’s got no choice but to swallow his fear and do it. 

It's not like Steve's hard to find. He's been grousing about being landed with the Christmas Eve shift since Thanksgiving, grumbling about how busy it would get and how stressed and noisy all the customers would be, sulking about how he’d be stuck there until midnight, probably even later once he’d tidied and closed up, and generally being an insufferable drama queen about the whole thing.

So Billy makes his way to Family Video. 

—

The moment he steps into the store, Billy can tell that Steve's worst fears about the shift have been realised. The store isn't too busy right now, but there's plenty of evidence that it has been. Steve’s hair is lank, flopping into his eyes in that way that Billy knows means he’s been running his hands through it, tucking it behind his ears over and over again, the way he does when he starts to get stressed. There’s also the fact that there’s a whole ton of returned tapes in small little piles at the side of him, rather than placed in the one huge tower that Steve always attempts when he’s had some down time, desperate to beat Robin’s record of twenty-three high before it tumbled.
It looks like it’s been one hell of a morning. But Billy can also see that Steve’s handling it. He’s got this. He’s smiling, and it looks real enough at first glance, but even from the doorway, Billy can immediately spot that it doesn’t reach his eyes and that there’s no tell-tale crinkle of Steve’s nose to give it away as the genuine article. Steve’s also got his customer service patter going in full flow, commenting positively on all the films that he’s putting through the register and as Billy fights his way through a crowd of whiny kids to get to the counter he catches the tail end of Steve gushing about Suspiria to some Gothic looking chick.

“So this guy, this Argento? Trust me, he’s a genius. The way he uses colour? You gotta see it. It’s like, yeah it’s horrible, but he captures the beauty too. And, the soundtrack? Oh, you’re going to love it.” 

The girl doesn’t seem impressed, taking the tape and heading back out without even a thank you, but Billy still feels a stab of annoyance when he sees the way that Steve’s watching her leave. He shoves his way in front of the next customer in line, ignoring the guy’s feeble protest, and leans over the counter, waving a hand in front of Steve, 

“Argento? Really, Harrington?” he smirks, “Cause I swear it was only yesterday that you thought that was a type of pasta.” 

“You saw that, huh?” Steve groans, reaching out to gently push Billy over to the side and ringing up the next customer without even looking at them, “It sucks, man. I really thought I had something there. She gave me this look earlier, this, like, wink thing, and I coulda sworn she was flirting.”

“Nah she’s not your type,” Billy says, trying not to sound as bitter as he suddenly feels, “That wink was probably just an allergic reaction to all that eyeliner. And a Smiths shirt? She’s just gonna bring you down. You don’t want that.” 

Steve nods, “Yeah, no, yeah, you’re right. And, ugh, she’d want to watch that kind of freaky shit all the time, right? Like, she wouldn’t have gone with me to see Top Gun , would she?”

“Definitely not,” Billy shakes his head, “She’d’ve been bitching all the way through. Nah, girls like that only want it if it’s black and white or French. ”

“Ugh,” Steve shudders, and then he grins. A proper one. One with a nose crinkle and everything, “Guess I dodged a bullet there, then. And hey, at least you went halves on the popcorn.”

Billy snorts, not wanting to think too hard about that particular night. Sitting right next to Steve in The Hawk, crammed in close on the shitty seat, their hands colliding more than once in the bucket of popcorn.
It would’ve been an exquisite torture on its own, without needing the volleyball scene.
It was one of the best and worst nights of Billy’s life. 

He’s still definitely not thinking about it when Steve serves the last customer in line, and turns back to Billy. 

“It's just, ugh, the holidays, man,  y'know? Feel like everyone's all, like, loved up.” 

And then he slumps down, his head thumping onto his arms, letting out an extended sigh.

“That bad?” Billy asks.

"You won't believe-" Steve pushes himself back up onto his elbows, sliding his fingers through his hair and tugging at the roots before tucking a strand behind his ears, "-ugh, you will not believe the day I've had."

"It's eleven fifteen," Billy states, and Steve ignores him.

“The day I’ve had,” he repeats. “We rented out our third and final copy of Rudolph by ten twenty. Do you know how many people have asked for it since then?"

Billy leans his back against the counter, one foot up, turning away so that Steve can’t see his amused smile, "I imagine you're gonna tell me."

"Seven, Billy. Seven . With the three who managed to get it, that makes ten people who wanted to watch Rudolph today. Ten people. Ten.”

“Kudos to your kindergarten math teacher there, Harrington.” 

“It's Christmas Eve, holy shit , just turn on the TV, any station, any time, trust me you're gonna see Rudolph. And if you don’t? Wait five minutes, he’ll come prancing along like an asshole." 

Out of the corner of his eye, Billy can see Steve’s exasperated hand gestures, and he stifles a laugh, turning it into a muffled cough, before he arranges his face into an exaggerated expression of sympathy.

“Oh poor you, Stevie, having to actually do your damn job.”

To his credit, Steve seems to realise how dramatic he’s being. He pushes himself fully upright, reaching out for one of the stacks of returned tapes and starts sorting them into piles for reshelving, "Hopefully it won't be as bad tomorrow ," he says, and it takes Billy a few seconds to connect the dots.

“Tomorrow? Seriously? You’re working Christmas Eve and Christmas? Is that even allowed?”

Steve shrugs, "Probably not, but Keith's being an asshole. And anyway, it just makes sense. Robin's got some family thing this week, new guy's got a kid of his own. What have I got? And it's not bad. Double pay, at least. And it saves me from another Harrington party so, win-win?"

"Oh." Billy tries not to let the disappointment show.

"Oh?" Steve asks.

"Nah, it's nothing, I was gonna see if you might wanna hang tomorrow. But you're gonna be busy so, yeah, it's fine.” 

Steve's face drops, his eyes doing that big, Bambi thing that makes him look like a kicked puppy.

“Bills!” he whines, “I would’ve done that. I didn’t know! You never said! Shit. Think I can get Keith to switch back? Dress up as the Ghost of Christmas Past or whatever and scare him into taking the shift?” 

“Can’t hurt to try,” Billy says, but then Steve’s face suddenly lights up with a grin.

“Hey, look, what if you come here ? Stick around and bug me like you always do? ‘S not like this place is gonna be heaving, right? Not on Christmas Day, surely? People have got, like, family shit to do. Or church or whatever. So we could probably, I dunno, we could get away with sticking on a movie in the back room and I can sneak out some of whatever catering Mom’s ordered in for the party, and we can do our own thing?”

“Yeah, that sounds-” Billy starts, but Steve’s already shaking his head. 

“Nah, it’s OK, I guess you have proper plans, and you’re gonna want to be with Max. But, hey, look, it doesn’t matter if you can’t. I get it, but let me- hang on- let me get…”

And then Steve’s gone before Billy can stop him, dashing off to the backroom and emerging with a gift wrapped box.

“Just in case you can’t make it tomorrow, or if it gets too busy or whatever, lemme give you this. There’s kinda…there’s a part of it you’ll probably want before tomorrow anyway.”

He thrusts the box into Billy’s hands.

“OK?” Billy asks, trying to figure out what Steve means. “Should I open it now then?”

Steve thinks for a minute before nodding, “Yeah, actually, you probably should cause, shit, this is gonna need an explanation.” 

Billy gives him a quizzical look, his fingers already peeling back the paper, and Steve smiles sheepishly,  "Remember you said about breaking your favourite mug?"

Billy does remember. It’d been about a month ago, when the broken mug was the shitty cherry on top of a fucking atrocious day, one of his bad ones where his old injuries started playing up again, his hands alternating between a burning ache and a tingling numbness, until a sudden shockwave of agony gripped him and he’d dropped the mug he’d been holding, shattering on his kitchen floor and drenching his toes in scalding hot coffee.
Billy hadn’t dealt with it particularly well. He’d yelled, a lot, and he’d thrown a different, perfectly innocent mug at the wall and then done what he could to clean up the mess, doing his best even though his hands had still been cramping, and then he’d tried to change his socks, another process which took way fucking longer than it should due to the fact that his fingers wouldn’t listen to his brain, and then even though there was no reason to, even though part of him wanted to do nothing more than curl up on the couch and not leave the house for a week, he’d found himself pulling his boots on over bare, slightly red feet, and limping his way over to Family Video, not quite trusting himself to drive.
Because he’d wanted to see Steve.

Steve had, of course, been worried. And that’s when the whole story had spilled out. By that point, Billy had gone through his usual stages of emotion, the initial anger and tears of frustration giving way to a melancholic grumpiness, leaving him feeling utterly sorry for himself, so he knew he’d definitely whined about it way too much and he hadn't even realised that Steve was listening.

But clearly he had.
Billy’s got the proof right in his hands, a large, lightweight mug with the face of Animal from the Muppets on it, and big cartoony letters declaring “I’m such an Animal before I’ve had my coffee!” 

He looks up at Steve who is definitely blushing, “Look, ok there was this shop that had, like, a whole rack of these. And they're tin or something, so if you drop it, it won't break. Or, at least it shouldn't. The guy at the shop said it probably wouldn't, unless you were, like, actually trying to break it. And even then-"

Steve stops himself, holding up his hands and taking a deep breath, "Look, I know it probably seems odd. But I saw this one and I thought about…well…that Animal impression you used to do? It kinda…yeah-" Steve reaches up, scratching at the back of his head awkwardly, "-I thought it might be…OK? Kinda funny?"

Billy's dumbstruck, the memory of that exact impression flooding back. It had been back in the summer, right back at the beginning of Billy becoming a regular presence in Family Video. Steve had started it all off. Billy had walked in on him mid way through teasing Robin about something, switching between an uncanny Kermit impression and a slightly ropier Miss Piggy one, while Robin pointedly ignored him, loudly announcing Billy’s presence, apparently in the hope that it would shut Steve up.
It hadn’t.
Steve had greeted Billy in the Kermit voice and Billy had responded with a terrible impression of the only Muppet he could think of on the spot. Animal. Really, it had been terrible. There wasn’t a lot to even the best of Animal impressions, so Billy’s ended up being nothing but a ton of growling and a drum solo slapped out on the tapes stacked up on the counter, complete with a cheek straining grin, but something about it had obviously tickled Steve because he’d doubled over with laughter, re-emerging from underneath the counter with tears in his eyes, unable to speak for a good thirty seconds as he gasped for air.

So Billy had done it again. And again. And to Robin’s absolute horror, it became a whole thing. For what seemed like the entirety of that summer, whenever Steve and Billy were together, there was bound to be a moment where one of them would randomly start talking in a Muppet voice. Billy stuck to Animal but, Steve, it turned out, had a whole repertoire. Nothing quite matched his Kermit, but his Fozzie and his Swedish Chef were definitely up there, and he could even carry on an entire Bunsen and Beaker conversation by himself.

Billy couldn’t quite remember why the whole thing stopped. He figured it probably had something to do with the time Steve had started greeting the customers with Muppet impressions too, not realising that Keith was standing behind him, but Billy couldn’t be certain. Not that it mattered, it had just been one of those things, pure, dumb teenage boy fun that they both should’ve been too mature for, but that both of them still enjoyed.
It had been fun.

Billy stares down at the Animal mug, trying desperately to conjure up the voice again. It’s the correct response, he knows that, acknowledge the jokey side of the gift, the shared memory. But Billy can't. Everything is sticking in his throat. 

He's absolutely and utterly floored. 

The dickache of a crush he's been harbouring, repressing, for a whole year now springs right back up. Because it’s so nice. So fucking nice. Steve’s bought him something so damn thoughtful once again and Billy feels like an asshole but he also feels like someone’s stuck a pump into his heart and blown it up to three times its usual size and he can’t stop smiling and his mouth is all dry and he can hear his pulse in his ears and his stomach is fluttering like crazy.

And that’s not exactly new, he's always been a sucker for Steve.
He's always known there was something there, a flame that he’d been kindling. It had been lust at first sight that night at Tina's Halloween party only a few years ago, and while there'd been the seed of something deeper underneath, Billy thinks that he might be been OK, might've just about been able to keep that seed unwatered, kept it buried in the harshest, most unforgiving of soil until it withered and died without fully taking root.  But then Steve ended up being a bigger part of his life than Billy ever could have imagined. They became friends. And that was harder. A hell of a lot harder. Bit by bit, he got to see every side of Steve. The smooth talking charmer; the slightly bitchy ex-King; the dorky babysitter; the caring, compassionate friend; the brave, determined protector.
He got to see Steve and know him and see all the wonderful parts of him and he fell in love.
How could he not?
Billy fell head over heels, ass over tea kettle, heart and soul, madly and stupidly in love.

And he'd been doing so well, so damn well at ignoring it, giving nothing away, only letting himself indulge late at night, torturing himself by replaying every conversation and interaction, picking them apart and daring himself to think what if and maybe, reveling in fuzzy, golden lit dreams of the possibilities, only to regret it all in the harsh light of day when reality can crashing down and Billy realised just how pathetic he had been. 

And then Steve would do something sweet or dorky or the light would hit him just right or he'd get all passionate about some movie Robin had made him watch or he'd offer out half his candy bar to Billy like it was no big thing or he'd sulk when he lost the coin toss for who was fetching lunch or he’d give Max some sincere dating advice. Nothing major, nothing special, just something so Steve.

And Billy would fall head over heels all over again, his resolve weakening each and every time. And now he thinks he's finally snapped. There's no way he can hide it. 

"Pretty funny, Stevie," he manages, and it comes out gruff enough that Billy thinks Steve might just be fooled into thinking it's Billy's attempt at the impersonation. He buys himself a little more time by pretending to be examining the mug. The inside of it is stuffed with red tissue, and when Billy pokes it, he can tell that there’s something else in there, all wrapped up. He reaches in, his fingers grasping around the lurking thing, a squishy lump encased in layers and layers of tissue paper and the moment he pulls it out, Steve's face goes on a whole journey. 

"Oh shit! That? That’s the thing you probably want before Christmas. If you even want it at all. And it’s one hundred percent Max's fault. Blame Max. She's been going on and on about your tree? How you hardly had any ornaments? So, yeah, she made everyone promise to get you something. Not as your actual gift, she made that pretty clear too, and, yeah OK, that whole plan was probably meant to be a secret but, dude, I am not taking full responsibility for that thing."

Billy's been unwrapping as Steve's been rambling, and, almost as if it was planned, he removes the final layer at the exact moment that Steve finishes talking.  It's a tree ornament alright. Not that Billy would have guessed that at first. It's a ball of spiky pinky-orangey-red fluff, with a slightly askew felt mouth stitched onto the middle, complete with jagged felt teeth, underneath a pair of equally lopsided eyes and a bulging orange blob of a nose. Two spindly arms emerge from either side clutching tiny wooden drum sticks, and that's what finally gives it away.

"It's Animal!" 

"Yeah!" Steve sighs in relief, "I thought it was cool when I first saw it, but then Robin was like, 'It doesn't look anything like Animal,' and I asked a few customers and, well, yeah. Most of them agreed with her. Some of them could tell though. After a little prompting."

"Nah, course it's him," Billy grins, holding the ornament up and letting it spin around on its red and black thread, "It's awesome, Steve, thanks." 

Secretly, Billy has to agree with Robin, but he's more than thankful for the distraction that the ugly thing caused and there is something oddly charming about it. 

"Max's idea," Steve says. 

"You're the one that chose him though, right?"

"Well, yeah, ok, yeah that's true." Steve tips his head slightly to the side, pursing his lips like he's thinking about it, "But, hey, how could I resist? He's loud and damn he can be annoying but he's sweet really. Kinda cute, too. Gotta say, I like him." 

Steve's not looking at the ornament. His eyes are locked on Billy's. There's the usual warmth there, but with a hint of something else. A hint of a tease, almost like a gauntlet being laid down, but with a playful edge. 

And Billy knows he's in even more trouble than before. 

He's saved from having to stutter out a reply, as the shop door opens, and their moment of peace seems to be over, so as Steve turns to deal with the new influx of customers, Billy packs the furry Animal back inside the mug, nestling him cosily into his nest of paper, and heads out.

There's a plan forming. A dumb one, probably, but Billy can't shake Steve's words and the look in his eyes. Because Billy's had similar looks to that one directed his way before. He knows how they usually end.

And, fuck it, Billy nearly died. He survived a literal nightmare. He's been through hell. He can do this.

He races home. But before he sets about putting his plan into action, he takes the time to put the Animal decoration on the tree. There's not a lot of space any more, not after the kids' donations, but there's a gap near the top, close to the little red horse. 

So that’s where Billy puts him. Red with Red.
They look good together, and Billy stands back and admires it. He’d thought the tree looked good before, but now he knows it. It looks complete. 

—

Billy waits until late before enacting his plan. He bides his time, even as the nerves grow, but by ten thirty he can’t wait much longer, and by ten forty-five he’s back at Family Video. This time, Steve seems a lot more chilled. His hair is less chaotic, and Billy knows he’d made use of the travel sized hairspray that he keeps in his rucksack, and the shop itself seems neat and orderly. Even the stacks on the counter have all been reshelved. 

“How long’s it been since the last customer?” Billy asks, trying to sound nonchalant. 

“Dunno,” Steve shrugs. He gestures to the back room, where Billy can see the flickering colours of the television set, “At least all of Gremlins , and about a quarter of Merry Christmas, Mr. Lawrence which, lemme tell you, definitely not a feel good festive classic. There might’ve been a ten minute snooze in there somewhere too.”

Billy smiles, “Sounds like no one’s gonna miss you if you take off early then?” 

Steve’s brow creases, “I dunno, I mean…we’re meant to be open until twelve. What if someone comes?”

Billy already has that covered. He reaches into the satchel slung over his shoulder, pulling out a piece of paper. 

“ Sorry We’re Closed, Christmas Miracle In Progress ?” Steve reads, and Billy can feel a flush of embarrassment as he hears the words aloud, especially in Steve’s slightly incredulous tone. He tries to push through it.

“Yeah, look, it’s…it’s kind of a joke. And that way people won’t mind. Or they’ll assume, I dunno, you had to close early cause of a register issues or plumbing or something. Look, just…I have an idea. Something I want to do. And it…it has to be now. Tonight. Before midnight.”

Steve still looks unsure. So Billy takes a deep breath, “Please?” 

It’s enough. Steve’s eyes widen in surprise, and he nods, taking the note from Billy’s hand and sticking it up on the glass door. He makes quick work of getting the rest of the store closed up, and before too long they’re both in Billy’s car. 

“OK, so, this is a kidnapping, right?” Steve asks, as Billy steers the car away from town, “Or a prank? Revenge? Cause I don’t know what-”

“Shut it, Stevie,” Billy says, but he keeps his tone soft. “It’s…it’s something. A gift.”

“Dude, you didn’t have to get me anything. Especially not, y’know, abduction.” 

Billy rolls his eyes, and Steve drops the joke, reverting back to his usual chatter about his days and his customers and how he so nearly beat Robin’s record this time but he knew that even if he did she’d never believe him and, really, Billy needs to start coming in more so that he can have a witness to that kind of amazing feat.
But Billy’s hardly listening. His heart is hammering in his ears with every mile he drives. He glances at his watch, watching the time slip away, tapping his hand on the steering wheel in a fast-paced, staccato rhythm that bears no relation to the smooth Christmas music that Steve’s found on the radio.

Eventually, Billy finds where he needs to be. He’d scouted it out again earlier, noting the landmarks in the daylight, knowing that it’d be nigh on impossible to find in the darkness unless you knew exactly what you were looking for. Even with his prior preparation, he still almost misses it, and he has to slam on his brakes, shooting an arm across the passenger seat and catching Steve before he hurtles into the dashboard.

“Shit, sorry,” Billy mutters.

“Seriously, Bills, what’s going on?” Steve peers out of the window, and Billy knows he’s taking in the nothingness all around. The sheer pitch blackness that comes from being surrounded by encroaching hills and towering forests  and with absolutely no light, save for the glow of the Camaro’s headlights, “This is, uh, yeah. I’m, uh, I’m not sure I like this, man. I think you’ve gone wrong somewhere, cause there’s nothing here. I don’t get why we- oh shit, are you…?” Billy sees the sudden flash of fear on Steve’s face, the weight of a particularly bad penny dropping, “Is it happening again? Are you OK? Billy? Are you…are you still you ? Do you need me to help?”

Billy realises what Steve is asking, and what he suspects with a sickening lurch.
But he’s not running. He’s not even trying to run. Steve's sitting here, in the middle of nowhere, with a guy who he thinks might be harbouring another one of those fucking nightmare creatures in his head, and he’s not even fucking running.
He’s sitting there and he’s asking if Billy needs help. Because he cares. Because he’s nice like that. Because he’s good and brave and strong and protective and Billy just can’t hold back any more. He shakes his head, reaching out to catch Steve’s sleeve.

“No, I-” Billy’s voice catches, and he swallows, “I’m me, I’m good. I promise. I just…we need to be here. Or, well, not here but-” he points out of the window, “-up there. There’s a track and just…just trust me. Please.”

“OK,” Steve says easily, and Billy knows that if he dwells on that, on how easily Steve believes him, then he’ll get lost in it. So he doesn’t dwell. He turns the car and guides it carefully up the winding track through the forest.

And then they’re there. Right where Billy needs to be. He’s not even sure where he is, not really, but it’s a place he found by accident and filed away. A place where no one else ever seems to be. 

They’re on top of a hill, right on the edge of the town with the whole of Hawkins is spread out before them. Billy’s seen it before, of course. Sometimes even as late as this. But never like this. Never on Christmas Eve.
It’s even better than he hoped.
The town is full of light, every neighborhood with its own particular pattern. The crowd pleasing displays of the town square, complete with the huge tree; the neat order of Loch Nora contrasting with the more haphazard choices of Cherry Lane, and everything in between. Everywhere Billy looks, there’s a different style of Christmas display, riots of colour and sparkle and twinkling lights shining out into the night.
It's magical. 

He turns to look at Steve, who's taking in the sight with a look of amazement on his face.

“Oh wow!” Steve whispers beside him, “Yeah, OK, man, I’ll give you this one, that’s awesome.” 

Billy's heart gives a kick at the genuine joy in his tone. Steve gets it. He likes it. He isn't just humouring him. Billy did something good here, something right. He made Steve happy, and damn it feels good to have that kind of effect.

They sit for a while, taking turns to comment on the details they notice, Steve nudging Billy with an elbow and pointing out locations he knows, the houses of childhood friends or a hardware store that used to sell toys, while Billy focuses on the displays themselves, spotting when two houses have obviously bought the exact same decorations, or laughing at some unintentionally phallic looking arrangements. 

Billy gets so lost in the ease of it, the simple pleasure of sharing in the joy of the lights, that he almost forgets the rest of his idea until a slight growl from Steve's tummy brings him right back.

“Oh, hey, shit, you hungry? Cause, there’s this too,” Billy says, reaching into his satchel and pulling out a Thermos and a small Tupperware box,  “I know there’s no way it’s gonna be as good as your Grandma’s but, hey, maybe it’s something?” 

Steve’s eyes go wider than Billy’s ever seen them as he takes in the items in Billy’s hands, zeroing in on the flask.

“Holy shit, dude, holy…is that hot chocolate?”

“Peppermint hot chocolate,” Billy clarifies. Steve reaches out eagerly, his hands starfishing like a toddler reaching for a rattle, and Billy hands the Thermos over with a chuckle, “But be careful cause I used- ” 

But Steve’s already taken a huge gulp, and Billy winces in sympathy, “-Schnapps.” 

Billy knows he’d been a little heavy handed with the alcohol, but he’s pretty sure that Steve’s just being dramatic when lets out a wheezing gasp. 

"Jesus, Bills! You bring me out here to get me wasted? Gonna end the night sprawled on your backseat with my panties round my ankles and a sore head?" Steve's laughs at his own joke, sniffing at the rim of the flask before he takes another, more cautious sip, "Cause I don't know what you've heard, but, uh, I'm not that kind of girl." 

Billy feels his heart drop. He hears what Steve’s saying, but he also hears what he means with it.
And he’s read this wrong. So wrong. 

He’s fucked up. He’s made a mistake. He’s let his own stupid dreams get the better of him. Those late night what ifs and maybes . The dumb, naive hope that should’ve been beaten out of him years ago.
He’s fucked up, he’s really fucked up. 

Billy turns away, trying desperately to hide his face, but it’s too late. Steve’s already noticed. His joking smile falls away and a frown wrinkles across his forehead. He reaches out, catching at Billy’s arm and pulling him back around.

“Hey, shit, man, sorry, I'm…I'm being an asshole. You're doing the nicest thing anyone's ever done for me in, I dunno, in ever, probably, and I'm being a dick about it. I'm sorry Bills. This is good, OK, really good. I’m just a lightweight now that I‘m getting old.” He tugs at Billy’s sleeve, then slides his hand down to tap on the lid of the Tupperware, “Come on, what’s in here? You got more goodies?"

Billy’s not sure if he can talk. His heart is still hammering fit to burst, more now that Steve’s fingers are so close to his own. He peels back the lid of the tub, and the warm, cinnamony scent of the cookies fills the air. 

“Oh!” Steve’s gasp this time is one of delight, “Holy shit, these look incredible. Did you make these?” 

Billy shakes his head, “Yeah, uh, I had a go. They’re not…some of them went kinda weird, the shapes, but they should be OK to eat.” 

Steve’s already diving in, pulling out the first cookie he can see, “Oh damn, you weren’t joking about the shapes! What the hell is this supposed to be? A dick?" He snorts as he holds it up, "Holy shit, it is! Dude it's even got a vein." Steve runs his finger along a wobbly blue line of icing, sounding absolutely delighted. 

"It's an icicle ," Billy huffs, grabbing it from Steve and turning it the right way up, "That's the shine of it."

"Oh yeah, yeah, alright, whatever you say. An icicle, sure ." Steve takes a bite anyway, his moan of satisfaction rumbling through the car and going straight to Billy’s dick. “Damn, I don’t mind what it’s meant to be. Dick, icicle, whatever, man. This is delicious, OK? I’m putting in an order for, like, twenty more of these. At least. They’re exactly like my Grandma’s, I swear.”

“Really?” Billy says, his eyebrow raising, and Steve’s smile turns wry.

“OK, maybe not exactly. The icing is a little different, I guess, and, uh, I gotta say, I’m pretty sure she never made dick ones.” 

—

It’s a good night, Billy thinks as he munches down on the second to last cookie. Even if this is all he gets, it’s been a damn good night. He’s here. It’s Christmas Eve. He’s got lights and cookies and a warm feeling in his chest that he knows isn’t all down to the Schnapps, because he’s barely managed to wrangle the flask away from Steve since he first got hold of it.
He’s happy. Content. He could probably learn to live with this, if this is all he gets. 

But then he thinks about Steve’s look earlier. The playfulness. The challenge. He thinks about other things too. Other times. Other comments. Other moments.
Maybe it’s not all he’s going to get. Maybe he could try. Go for something better than good, for once.

He turns to Steve.
He looks good, even in the harsh, unflattering interior light of the car. Even with cookie crumbs all around his mouth, the remains of the last cookie caught in the slight moustache he’s cultivating above his top lip. Even in his dorky Family Video polo.
Steve looks so good. 

“I, uh-” 

“I like your earring,” Steve interrupts, “I meant to say it earlier. It’s cute.” 

Billy looks up at his reflection in the rearview mirror, and Steve’s comment makes a bit more sense. He’d forgotten that he’d switched out his usual dagger  for something more festive. An early gift from Max, delivered with an unspoken but clear as hell, "I dare you," as she watched him unwrap it with a shit eating grin that he's pretty certain she learned from him.

It's a candy cane, made out of teeny-tiny red and white beads that he recognises from one of Max's long neglected crafts kits. Probably the exact kit he'd caught her giggling over with El not that long ago. 

“Cute?” Billy asks and Steve shrugs. 

“Yeah, cute. But I think I prefer the, uh, the dangly one," Steve wiggles his finger near his own earlobe as he tries to describe what he means. "The…the dangly one with the sword and, like, a few beads on it? Always thought it makes you look-"

Billy readies himself for the insult. The slur. Neil had said enough of them, when Billy first came back with a fresh stud in his ear. He doesn't think Steve will say it with the same bite, the same cruel hiss, but Billy thinks hearing it at all from Steve will hurt him more than Neil's words ever did. 

"-pretty."

Billy had steeled himself for a world of things.

But there was no world, no fucking universe, in which he could have ever been prepared for that, and it feels like every single ounce of breath leaves Billy's body in a choked gasp. Steve's one, single word sends him reeling out into the stratosphere, dizzy in a way that he's never felt before.

Steve's saying more, stumbling over his words, getting redder and redder, but Billy can't hear him. There's only one word in his ears, echoing over and over, taking root in cells and synapses and doubling, tripling, multiplying until it's all he can think about.

"-kind like Rob Lowe" Steve finishes.

And, ok, that’s definitely something else that Billy wants to think about. His giddy thought process grinds to a breaking halt as he processes Steve's words, "Rob Lowe? Seriously?"

Steve just shrugs, "Yeah. Kinda. I see it. And, uh, and yeah. That earring. The dangly one. I can't…I’m like…totally obsessed when you wear that. Cause I can only think about how I kinda wanna, like, touch it. Tap it. Like…I dunno…like a cat with a piece of string."

A bark of surprised laughter erupts out of Billy at that exact visual, and Steve’s chuckling a second later.

“Yeah, I know, it’s so dumb. I let it slip to Robin and she’s never let me live it down.”

Billy doesn’t know quite where the surge of bravery comes from, but it feels like the universe is giving him the most blatant sign it can. He'd be a fool to ignore it.

"Go on then, Harrington,” he says, “Touch it. If you really want to."

Steve blinks, staring at Billy. And then he does. He flicks the earring with a finger nail, a tiny, satisfied smile on his face as he watches it swing.
Billy can feel the slight tug of it on his lobe. But there’s a bigger pull, right in his gut, like someone’s yanking him forward.
Steve’s close. So close. His hand is still right by Billy’s ear. It wouldn't take much for Billy to lean into it. 

So he does it.
He closes his eyes and he lets his head tilt and it takes nothing, and everything at all.
Steve catches him. Holds him.

“I, uh, I kinda want to do something else too."

Billy's breath catches in his throat. Steve can't mean… He doesn't…That's not how...
Things like that don't happen to Billy. 

But Steve's hand slides to rest on his cheek, the tips of his fingers curling into the roots of Billy's hair, and he's waiting, his eyes flicking down to Billy’s lips.

"Do it," Billy urges. Because he needs to know. 

And Steve does. 

He leans in, eyes closing, and presses his mouth against Billy's in the softest, most chaste kiss Billy's ever received.
Billy has kissed a lot of people. A lot . But he's never been kissed like this,  by someone he actually wants to kiss him. And no one's ever kissed him like Steve is kissing him, soft and sweet and delicate, taking their time like he's something to savour. 

He's kissing Billy like Billy matters.

Billy sinks into it. He loses himself in it, in the feel of all of it. Steve’s hand on his face and Steve’s lips on his and the taste of cinnamon and cookies shared between them and Steve’s body so close and warm and there, within easy reach. So Billy reaches. He has a hand on Steve’s arm and he pulls, just a little, a hint of a suggestion, and Steve moves with him, closing the space.
It’s awkward, there’s a centre console between them and the angle is wrong and the light is harsh.
But it’s good. It’s great. It’s wonderful. It’s perfect.

Eventually, much too soon, Steve draws back, letting out a shaky little whoa and a laugh, 

"Oh wow,” he murmurs, “Wow. And hey, I always wanted to kiss Rob Lowe."

"Oh really?" Billy smirks.

"Nah," Steve shakes his head, "Least not until I saw you. 

“Charmer,” Billy tuts, and Steve’s smile turns from soppy and dopey to mischievous as he reaches out with his finger, quick as a flash, and taps it with a 'boop' onto the tip of Billy's nose.

"I actually did always want to do that though," he says, cupping Billy’s face again,  "That button nose of yours. Used to drive me crazy whenever you'd do that scrunchy face when you got annoyed." Steve pulls away, and Billy misses his touch already. As Steve moves his hand down, back to his lap, Billy reaches out to catch it. He takes Steve's hand. Squeezes it. And Steve squeezes back, lacing their fingers together. 

They sit like that, holding hands and looking out at the lights, Steve's body warm and close, his head tilting until it's resting against Billy's shoulders.

It all feels so good. So right. And Billy knows that, before too long, they'll have to get back. But he doesn't see a need to rush. 

Because, for now, it's Christmas Eve in Hawkins.
And it’s perfect. 

Notes:

Thank you so much for reading!
I hope you have Happy Holidays 💕

Chapter 8: Epilogue: Make the Yuletide Gay

Summary:

Billy thinks he might finally have worked out the ingredients needed for his perfect Christmas Eve.

And yeah, ok, it's been a while. It may have taken him until he was thirty-fucking-two, but Billy thinks it's been worth the wait to get all the details exactly right. 

Notes:

A (very) last minute addition of a cheeky little epilogue! But really, how could I resist? These boys absolutely deserve every kind of happy ending.

Chapter Text

Billy thinks he might finally have worked out the ingredients needed for his perfect Christmas Eve.

And yeah, ok, it's been a while. It may have taken him until he was thirty-fucking-two, but Billy thinks it's been worth the wait to get all the details exactly right. 

It starts with waking up next to Steve. Waking up, in fact, with an armful of Steve, because that guy is a cuddly sleeper and his habits haven't changed in over a decade, even after they switched out the double bed for a California King size. 

Because it's Christmas Eve, and neither of them have anywhere to be, waking up next to Steve leads nicely into some unhurried petting, Billy's hands exploring every inch of Steve's body, his fingers curling into the curls of chest hair, a thrill of a whole different kind surging through Billy's body when they catch upon the metal pendant nestled there. It's familiar, having been worried between Billy's fingertips for years before he even met Steve, but for the last few years it's been clasped around Steve's neck instead. 

Some mornings, Billy can get lost in that thought, about what it means, and he'll twist the ring on his left hand- the silver one that looks plain and unassuming on the outside, but that has an engraving of two interlinked hearts on the inside- and think about the Christmas morning that Steve had given it to him, nestled in a velvet box and wrapped up in at least twenty layers of paper, Billy alternating between laughing and cursing as he tore his way through them.

But Billy doesn't think about that today. 

Today his fingers move lower, teasing at Steve's nipples before reaching either further to stroke over Steve's tummy- softer now a result of Billy's prowess in the kitchen and the many, many lazy days spent doing little more than pottering around their town- before Billy's fingers are dipping under the waistband of Steve's plaid pyjama pants, running through the coarser patch of hair there, Billy taking his time, waiting until Steve's mouthing against his neck, alternating lazy kisses and sleepy moans that soon turn into pleas for more. 

And more is exactly what Billy gives. Always. Until Steve's sated and smiling and reaching down to return the favour.

It's a good way to start the day. And Billy was going to change the sheets anyway. 

Eventually, Billy peels himself out of Steve's still cuddly embrace and heads into their bathroom. He takes his time cleaning himself up, and by the time he's fresh and dressed, Steve's already busy in the kitchen, Billy's sweatpants from yesterday hanging low on his hips and two mugs of coffee in his hands. Muppet mugs. It's not the tin one of years ago, although that one is still safely stowed in the cupboard, because now they have a whole set of large, porcelain ones, acquired mug by mug over the years they've been together, a running joke that always drew a smile on birthdays or Christmases. 

Billy still tends to favour Animal. 

—

They don't have much to do today. The house is pretty much all ready for Christmas, and for the influx of visitors they know they'll be getting over the holiday. 

The fridge is heaving with food and drink, there's candy out in decorative, Christmas-tree shaped bowls all over the place, and the cupboards are packed with snacks and nibbles, or stacked with Tupperware boxes filled with cookies of all shapes and sizes, Billy having finally perfected Steve's Grandma's secret recipe, the one she'd handed to Billy directly, the paper as delicate and crinkled as the skin on her tiny, frail hands, telling him, in no uncertain terms, to make sure that her Steve always had his cookies in time for Christmas. 

Billy had promised he would. And he's kept that promise. 

The huge, real tree in the living room has been decorated for a few weeks now, absolutely bustling with baubles and tinsel and ornaments of all shapes and sizes, a mismatched collection that's grown along with their relationship, items collected on holidays or given as gifts. Kitschy in-jokes like the Taz in a Santa hat, or the Scrappy Doo or the surfing Santa, as well as more seriously toned ones, like the whole rainbow of hearts to celebrate an anniversary. 

There's a whole matching set of fancy glass ornaments, a gift from Mrs Harrington and so expensive that Billy is always tempted to secure them to the branches with clips or rubber bands, just in case their lazy lump of a cat, Meatloaf, found a hitherto untapped source of energy and found herself attracted to them. They glisten and gleam in amongst the much cheaper ones that Billy had acquired from the kids, all those years ago. That collection they'd snuck in, small signs that people cared. That people were looking out for him, even if he wasn't entirely ready to accept it. He treasures them, each and every one, Care Bears and crystals alike. 

And of course, his Mom's old decorations are mixed in there too, the bell and the cherub and the horse no longer looking lost and lonely but, instead, looking familiar. Festive. Over the years, Billy's told Steve the stories of them, the same tales his Mom used to tell but with his own embellishments- the daring rescue from the garbage can, the way Billy had kept them hidden and safe. Steve always listens, even when Billy's voice goes whisper-soft, and when Billy stops, even if the story isn't finished, Steve will gently reach out and take his hand, and together they'll find the best spaces for the treasured items. 

Even after all this time, they've never quite got round to buying a tree topper. They've looked, certainly, weighing up stars and angels and other potential candidates. But nothing has ever beaten the current contender for the top-most branch. The ugly, fuzzy, now rather frayed and still utterly perplexing Animal decoration.

Somehow, it just looks right.

The rest of the house is just as spectacular. The shelves are heaving with Christmas cards, garlands are draped around the staircase and the fireplace, the kitchen cupboards are bordered with sprigs of holly, any conceivable remaining space has been filled with kitschy ornamental Santas or elves or penguins, a whole hodge podge of holiday cheer, and the outside is, if anything, even more jolly. Years worth of Billy's bargain hunting in the January sales had meant they had a whole array of outdoor lights and illuminated decorations. Too many, really, for the space, because it's not even a big house, not really. It had seemed massive to Billy when he first saw it, but much of that was just the character features. The charm. The architectural touches that remind Billy of so many of those huge mansions he'd gazed out at on Christmas Eve. In reality, it's easily one of the smallest on their block, sized somewhere between Billy's childhood house in California and Steve's childhood house in Hawkins. Even so they still have to set aside an entire day to get everything set up, Steve traipsing up and down ladders, clambering over the angles of the roof, balancing precariously on the porch railings or leaning perilously out on the balcony, getting everything in place before the two of them stand back, Steve's arm slung around Billy's shoulder, and light the whole place up. 

To Steve, it's already perfect.

To Billy, there's still one thing missing. Nothing major, just the slightest niggle of dissatisfaction. An incredibly petty one, but a niggle nonetheless. 

He spotted it a few days ago. The gap. A little pocket of missed opportunity. A few feet of unlit, undraped space that makes up the archway over the gate to the backyard. It's hardly noticeable in the day time, the archway covered in a thick carpet of bare vines, all of which spring into budding bloom in the Spring, but Billy had noticed it the other night, the one part of their house that was unadorned, and it became all he could think about. He'd had a go at sorting it, rifling through the few leftover boxes of lights, the old ones that hadn't made the cut this year, but nothing they had left was suitable, all the wrong colours or shapes or with smashed bulbs. So Billy had filed it away as an issue for next year, something for him to solve at another time.

To his credit, Billy was pretty sure he'd only mentioned it once or twice to Steve, and even then it'd been in an off-hand maybe next year we should… kind of conversation. But Steve had apparently been listening, had taken it on board, because only yesterday he'd returned from a 'surprise errand' with a brand new box of lights in his hands.

He'd made a whole thing of it, making Billy close his eyes before he'd handed them over with a Surprise and a totally dorky jazz hands reveal, launching into an explanation, starting out buzzing with confidence, eyes bright with it, the self doubt creeping in as he spoke until he ended up sounding awkward and uncertain, one hand coming up to run self-consciously at the back of his neck. 

"So, ok, I'm pretty sure these are the right ones, the same ones from before, the ones we have around the garage? I knew they'd have them somewhere, and I remembered that hardware store a few towns over, y'know, the place where we got the bird feeders? And it took a little finding, cause they were, like, right in the back, but they're the ones, right? I know they changed the picture on the box, but I had a look inside and even got the guy in the store to plug them in and I can't see a difference so, yeah? I think they'll match?"

And as eager as Billy had to set them up that very day the moment he'd opened the box and clarified that, "Yep, Stevie, this is it! Holy shit, you found 'em! You did it!" He'd been more eager to make sure that Steve knew just how damn grateful he was. 

Billy finds the box of lights in the living room, on the coffee table underneath Steve's underwear from yesterday. He holds them up with a grin, the Calvin Kleins still draped over them.

"Wanna do these today, Stevie?"

"Lights or laundry?" Steve quips, his second cup of coffee already in his hands, and Billy throws the underwear at his head, hitting him square in the face. Billy's still chuckling as Steve throws them back, "Lemme get dressed and I'll give you a hand." 

—

By the time Steve returns, sweatpants traded for right jeans and a well fitted reindeer pattern sweater, Billy's sitting on the couch, the lights pooled out in front of him as he picks through them one by one.

He looks up as Steve approaches, waving the tangled wire in the air with a growl, "Fuck, 's like them sell 'em with the knots built in."

Steve leans right into his space from over the back of the couch, a teasing smirk on his face as he tugs at the loose end of wire, "Come on, Bills, you got this, the little bunny goes round the tree and-"

Billy bats Steve's hand away with a growl, "This little bunny'll be going up your damn ass in a minute."

Steve isn't daunted, he hooks a leg over the couch and climbs over, sliding down beside Billy and taking hold of the other end of the lights, his fingers carefully twisting and untwisting. Between them, they make short work of it, and it isn't long at all before the curl of wire is straightened out, the bulbs all hanging neatly. 

And then there's nothing left to do but hang them. 

That part is a well-rehearsed dance.

"Guess I'm going up the ladder?" Steve asks, already putting his foot on the first rung. 

"Hell yeah," Billy nods, reaching out to squeeze Steve's butt as he climbs up, "Means I get the best view from down here."

Steve gets the lights in place easily, weaving them around the branches before scrambling down the ladder to stand next to Billy.

"You ready? Let's fire 'em up!" Steve's got the control in his hand, an eager grin spreading across his face.

"You do the honours, Stevie." Billy waves a hand, and Steve presses the button.

The house erupts in a symphony of lights. Billy knows he should be used to it by now, but the novelty of it has never really worn off. As always, he fills with a sheer, giddy, childish delight of seeing the house he loves all lit up and the new addition of the bulbs woven around the archway branches, that extra little touch that Steve went out of his way to find, means that Billy's heart feels just that little bit warmer than it usually does. 

Billy looks over at Steve, all bathed in the glow. He looks golden again, he always looks golden, and he's smiling. Not big and eager anymore. This time it's the soft one. Fond. Slightly crooked. And Billy smiles too. Just as soft and fond. 

"Satisfied?" Steve says, slinging one arm around Billy's shoulder and pulling him in close to press a kiss against his temple, "You happy with it all now?" 

Billy takes it all in. The lights. The house. Their house. Their home. He rests his head against Steve's.

"Couldn't be happier, darlin'. Really."