Actions

Work Header

Let Your Heart Be Light

Chapter 5: Hawkins: We'll Have to Muddle Through Somehow

Summary:

So far, a Hawkins Christmas Eve is just as shitty as a California one.

Shittier, probably, because it’s fucking freezing everywhere.Shittier too, because in Hawkins, Neil’s boss and a ton of his co workers go to church after dinner on Christmas Eve. Which means that Neil also wants to go to church after dinner on Christmas Eve. Which means that Susan and Billy and Max also have to go to church after dinner on Christmas Eve.

But Billy really fucking doesn’t want to go to church after dinner. So he doesn’t eat dinner. He doesn’t even come down for it.

Chapter Text

Billy tries not to think about it any more. What he had. What he’d lost. He’ll be back there soon enough, he knows.
The first week, the one where Susan was scurrying around trying to get them both enrolled in school, when they’d been forbidden from leaving the house and Billy hadn’t even been allowed to leave his room, he’d grabbed a ballpoint pen and etched the first of what would become a growing series of tally marks in the baseboard behind his bed.
He runs a finger over them most nights, shoving his hand down the gap between the mattress and the wall, inching his fingers down and down until they reach the deep grooves in the wood. He can’t really see them, not without ducking his head under the bed, but he knows them well enough. Some days, he feels like they’ve been scratched into his skin anyway, sixty-two gouges.
A bit of him lost every single day.

It had been almost Halloween when they arrived. Now it’s Christmas Eve.
And, so far, a Hawkins Christmas Eve is just as shitty as a California one.

Shittier, probably, because it’s fucking freezing everywhere.Shittier too, because in Hawkins, Neil’s boss and a ton of his co workers go to church after dinner on Christmas Eve. Which means that Neil also wants to go to church after dinner on Christmas Eve. Which means that Susan and Billy and Max also have to go to church after dinner on Christmas Eve.

But Billy really fucking doesn’t want to go to church after dinner. So he doesn’t eat dinner. He doesn’t even come down for it.
He stays sitting on his bed when Susan calls. And he stays sitting on his bed when Max bangs on the door. He stays sitting when she shoves the door open and stand in the doorway and tells him to stop being an attention-seeking idiot.
He stays sitting when Neil shouts and shouts.
He stays sitting when Neil comes to the door and says much the same as Max but with a lot more anger in his tone. 
He stays sitting as Neil stares him down, and he even stays sitting when Neil finally shakes his head and turns away.

Billy doesn’t eat. He barely even moves. He listens to the clatter of crockery and he ignores the clench of hunger in his stomach and he stays sitting on his bed the whole time.

He even stays sitting when he hears the scrape of Neil’s chair and the tread of his footsteps. And this time, Neil doesn’t stay by the door. This time he walks right into Billy’s room stepping over the threshold and standing over Billy with ice in his eyes.
And Billy sort of wishes he wasn’t sitting any more.

“You're coming to church." Neil says. It isn’t a question. 

"No I'm not.” It's stupid of him. Reckless. But sometimes Billy can't help but do that, when Neil's clearly on the edge, can't help but give him the shove he needs to topple right over. It's going to happen anyway, may as well be on Billy's terms.
It’s a win. Of sorts. The only kind Billy’s likely to get.

Neil surges forward, his hand fisting in Billy's shirt, tugging him up and off the bed, and Billy regrets it all instantly.

"Dad, I-"

"What have I told you about that attitude?"

"I didn't-"

Neil slaps him once, hard enough to make Billy's teeth clack together, and then he grabs hold of Billy's chin, tilting it up.

"We're a family now, and this is a new start for all of us, especially you. So you will come to church and you will sit and you will sing and you will smile. You will behave ." He punctuates the words with a series of sharp jabs of his index finger, right into Billy's chest, "What will you do?"

Billy hates the word. Hates saying it. Hates feeling like a fucking little kid being put in time out. But he supposes that fits. Because his Dad knows just how to make him feel small. Weak. Vulnerable. 

"I'll behave," he croaks, pushing the words out past a growing lump in his throat. 

"I'm sorry?"

"I'll behave…sir."

“Damn right.”

Neil lets go of him, and Billy has to hold himself back from falling back onto the bed.
He grits his teeth, forcing himself not to push Neil any further.
It’s over. It's done.

Or at least it should be. Because Neil is turning around. He's turning around and that means he's done.

But then he pauses. 

"This is an important night. A special one. It won't do to have you showing us up. So-" Neil's hand goes to his belt, his fingers already working at the buckle. "-maybe you need something to keep this lesson fresh in your mind."

Billy’s teeth grind together even harder, “Dad-” he bites his tongue to stop himself saying anything else. It won’t work, he knows it, begging won’t work. It might even make Neil madder. Billy needs to stand there and take it like a man. Take what he’s earned. He swallows against the ache in his throat, setting his jaw, his eyes lock on to his father’s fingers as they begin to work the belt out through the loops of his pants.

Billy's trembling fingers go to the buttons on his shirt.

Muscle memory.


There's a timid rap of knuckles on the doorframe, and Billy and Neil’s heads both whip up in perfect sync to see Susan standing there. She looks nervous, but then she always looks nervous nowadays, so Billy can’t be sure how much she’s heard. Her expression gives nothing away and Billy wants to scream at her to get out, to let him get punished without a fucking audience. 

But he also wants her to see it. He wants her to have to witness what's happening and see who Neil really is and finally do the sensible thing and take Max and just run and leave him and his Dad alone. And deep down, right down, there's some desperate, pathetic part of him that wants her to stop it. A hope he should’ve shed a long time ago. One that he never should’ve had in the first place.

Susan hovers there, perched on the threshold of Billy’s room. She looks right at him for a moment, and her expression could pass for concern if Billy didn’t know any better, and then she looks at Neil.

"Neil? Honey, I think…maybe it's OK if Billy does stay home? Only Max isn't very well and I don't like the thought of leaving her alone-"

Billy winces. Be careful what you wish for , he tells himself.

"Dad," he says, desperate to draw Neil's attention back to him and away from Susan. Away from Max and how she's messing up the plans. But Neil's already rebuckling his belt, fingers smoothing at his shirt to hide the motion. 

"That's a shame, Susie," he says with a shake of his head, "Poor kid. Sick on Christmas Eve. Still, these things can't be helped. I thought she looked pale at dinner." He nods curtly at Billy, “Of course Billy will keep an eye on her.”

And then they’re both gone, Neil sweeping Susan out of the room without even a backwards glance to check that Billy’s in agreement. Billy’s tempted to shout after him, to argue and complain until his dad is forced to turn back around and finish what he started instead. Because Billy hates this, the way the fear and adrenaline are all surging around his body with no place to go. It leaves him on edge and jittery, and even when he tries to sit back down on the bed, he can’t stop his foot from bouncing or his fingers from tapping over and over again. He can feel it, the tension that never properly diffused, the ghost of Neil’s anger so potent and ever present, long after Billy’s heard the front door close and the rumble of Neil’s truck fade away over the horizon.
Billy still can’t relax.
He needs to do something.

In the end, the something turns out to be sorting laundry. Not that there’s much to do, little more than a heap of socks and a few ratty gym shirts, and it’s definitely not enough to distract him from hearing the patter of Max’s footsteps a few rooms away, or the way they get closer and closer until they stop right outside his door.

He calls out to her without even looking up,  "Don't you dare puke in here."

“Huh?” Max seems genuinely confused, and when Billy looks up at her, she’s got a chocolate Santa in her hand, already decapitated.

“What the hell, shitbird? Thought you were sick?”

"Nope," Max pops the 'p', looking far too pleased with herself, "I told mom I had cramps." She waves the half-eaten chocolate in his direction, “Knew she wouldn't ask any more.”

Billy grimaces, lobbing a pair of balled up socks at her head, "Ugh, that's gross, Maxine."

"It's not gross. It's biology," she rolls her eyes, and Billy can see the flicker of mischief in her growing smirk, "Gross would be if I said something like 'it's like a whole jar of strawberry jam exploded in my jeans' or if-"

"Jesus Max!" Billy claps his hands to his ears, groaning in disgust, "Shut the fuck up, what's wrong with you?" 

Max's chuckle is damn near maniacal, and Billy throws another pair of socks at her just to get her to shut up.

"I don't really have them," she says, catching the socks one handed and throwing them back, "but I didn't want to go to stupid church, sitting there listening to some boring guy drone on and on about all that bullshit-"

"Yeah, alright, Nietzsche, cool it." Billy keeps his tone cool, but he turns his head to hide the smile. He waits a bit until it fades and when he looks back, Max is still there, lingering. 

“I’ve still got those videos I borrowed” she says, picking at the bright red foil around the chocolate as she talks, “I think Dustin’s Mom’s taped, like, every single Christmas movie they’ve ever shown on TV cause he gave me tons. There’s The Grinch and that Charlie Brown one and there’s at least three versions of Rudolph.”

She doesn’t say any more, so Billy doesn’t respond. He refolds a shirt that was already fine. Moves a pair of jeans from one pile to another, needlessly. He moves them back.

Max shuffles her feet, “We could watch one together. If you want to?”

“I’d rather shit in my hands and clap,” Billy says, still not looking at her.

“Ugh!” A ball of red foil hit him right in the ear, and he turns to glare at Max. She glares back, arms folded. There’s a scowl crossing her face, but there’s still a hint of a hurt expression underneath it, and Billy suddenly sees the offer for what it actually was.
An olive branch. 

He feels a little guilty at that. Because they'd been trying. Both of them. To be better. And so he stops folding. He takes a breath. He picks up the red foil and smooths it out, running his fingers over the creases until it's flat again. "But we could go for a drive?"

Max perks up at that, "Yeah?"

"Yeah. Say you needed some fucking, girl supplies or whatever so I took you to the store. Midnight run for Max's Maxi Pads."

"Now who's being gross?" Max pulls a face at him, but Billy can see the flicker of a smile at the edges of the grimace, and he shrugs.

"Thought it was biology? But, yeah, we could, I dunno, grab some food and maybe go look at some Christmas lights on the way or whatever?"

“Not much to see around here,” Max shrugs. She’s not wrong, Billy has to admit, there’s definitely not much in the way of spectacle on Cherry Lane.

“Yeah, well, we'll take the long way round then. Out near the rich side of town. Anywhere with a couple of Reagan signs out front oughta have a decent display." 

Max nods, and then she smiles, and it isn’t long before them two of them are bundled up in the Camaro, Billy navigating by hazy memories of house parties until he finds himself in Loch Nora.
There’s surprisingly little to see here, either. There are none of the ostentatious displays that Billy would have been seeking out back in California. Here everything is expensive, sure, but it’s all so neat and orderly, almost as though each house had followed the same tick sheet. A smattering of lanterns along the path tick , a single line of icicle lights on the front porch tick , a tasteful row of illuminated reindeer pulling an illuminated sleigh tick .

“Well this is a bust,” Billy grumbles. He’s trying not to let the frustration show but, really, he’s pissed. He'd only had a piece of toast for lunch, so with him skipping dinner he’s fucking hungry, and they drove an extra ten minutes to get out here, and it’s at least another ten back to anywhere with decent food that might actually be open tonight, and that’s without accounting for the shitty traffic signals and the Christmas Eve gridlock and the fact that it’s starting to snow, and his car does not handle well on ice anyway and- 

"That's Steve's place," Max interrupts his thoughts, pointing over towards one of the houses, a weirdly proportioned, grey-panelled box of a building.

"Figures he'd love somewhere like this,” Billy leans forward, creeping the car further down the driveway lit by the exact same parade of Victorian style lanterns as everywhere else they just passed, “God it's an ugly ass house."

Max shrugs, "Got a pool though," she says, a little too smugly for Billy's liking, "Heated."

Part of him wants to snap at her, remind her that back home they used to live right by the beach and that they didn't need a heated fucking pool because the ocean was right there and it was always warm enough to go for a swim in it and if she and her Mom hadn't come along and fucked everything up then maybe they'd still be back there and maybe Billy would still have-

But he stops himself. He swallows down the rising fury. Because he's trying. He's trying not to do that anymore. Not to be like that. And he might not have the beach, but he has his car and he's out of the house and it's Christmas Eve and he's looking at the lights.

So it's OK. He's OK. 

"Figures," he says again, a little tightly. He feels the anger ebbing, just a little. He stares out at Steve’s house again, noticing how, even without all the decorations, Steve's house would still be lit up like a Christmas tree. There’s a light on in every room downstairs and the shadows of a whole room of bodies move behind the curtains, while the twinkling lights cascading over the roof reflect off the shining bonnets of a dozen expensive cars.

It looks like a party, but before Billy can ask Max if she knows anything, the door opens and a figure slips out, and a whole other question falls from Billy’s lips before he can stop it.

"That Harrington?"

But Billy already knows the answer. He'd know that form anywhere, even from this distance, even through the haze of a misting up windscreen. Beside him, Max leans forward, rubbing a porthole in the condensation on her window to squint out into the darkness, and Billy does the same, both of them taking in the sight at the same time.

Steve is standing on the doorstep, back pressed against the wood with a cigarette in his hand, staring out into the night. He’s illuminated by the Christmas lights, somehow looking golden even in the cold white of the plastic snowflakes that dangle just above his head, and he looks nice, real nice , Billy thinks, dressed in a smart, bright red sweater and a pair of tight fitted khakis, but there's no joy on his face, no sign that he's been involved in whatever merriment is clearly occuring inside.

He looks lost. Sad. 

Max must notice it too because, without even a word, she's scrambling out of the Camaro and scampering up to him, and the moment Steve catches sight of her, his face erupts into a big, bright smile. It's just a quick thing, the big beam, before it softens into something fond and slightly crooked, but Billy is struck with a sudden, desperate desire to have that smile directed at him. 

He shakes the thought away as soon as it comes, forcing himself to think of Steve's face the last time Billy had any real influence over it, how he'd left it bloodied and bruised and broken, and a wave of guilt crashes into him, twisting in the pit of his stomach until his feels nauseous with it. He forces himself not to stare at Steve anymore. Instead he hunkers into his seat, shuffling down low enough that Max and Harrington are hidden by the dashboard, and all Billy can see are the Christmas lights on the roof of Harrington's house, and the way they catch on the light flurry of snow that's starting to fall all around, making it all sparkle.

He lets his eyes unfocus until the whole thing becomes a meaningless blur.

It’s soothing. Hypnotising. 

There's a murmur of sound from the radio, a familiar Christmas song playing soft and low. The Camaro’s engine is just as familiar and comforting as it thrums under him, finally running hot enough to allow the heater to blow out a steady stream of dusty smelling warm air.
Billy is warm. He’s safe. And for the first time tonight. Hell, for the first time in a while, Billy feels a little of the tension leave his body as his eyes drop closed. Just for a little while.

He jerks back up when the passenger door opens, letting in a blast of cold air and a stream of curses from Max, uttered from behind chattering teeth, and a smell. A heavenly fucking smell. Something sweet and a little spicy and so delicious that Billy's mouth starts watering and he's pretty sure he's drooling like a cartoon wolf sniffing out a pie. His stomach growls loudly. Embarrassingly. He hunches his body over to try and muffle the sound, but Max must’ve noticed, because she’s holding out a cookie, one of many that she’s got in her lap. 

They look just as good as they smell. All different shapes, Christmas trees and reindeer and snowman and bells, and all decorated beautifully with intricate swirls of icing and studded with tiny silver balls or meticulously placed sprinkles, and Billy can tell that they’re not store bought. These cookies have been made with love.
He stares at the one that Max is holding out for a little too long, because she ends up thrusting it into his lap. 

"Here," she says, already taking a bite of her second cookie, "Steve said there's one for you too, and to tell you ‘Merry Christmas’"

The statement is enough to stop Billy caring about the mess of crumbs that fell out of Max’s mouth when she said it, even the ones that she’s accidentally grinding into the floor mat with her boot.

"Why?" he asks.

"I dunno," Max says through another mouthful of crumbs, "'s Steve, he's nice." 

As if that answers everything. Maybe it does.

Billy takes a tentative bite of the cookie in his hand, wary of a trap, but as soon as he gets the first taste, he's desperate for another. It's everything the scent promised and more. Buttery and crunchy with that perfect blend of cinnamon that spreads over his tongue, warming him from the inside out. Billy closes his eyes in bliss. It tastes like Christmas.  Just for a second, he's right back in the kitchen in the house back in Cali, baking cookies with his Mom. 
It tastes like happiness. 

When he opens his eyes, he's looking right out of the now demisted windscreen. He can see Steve clearly now, and he's back to looking lost, the bright smile from before completely vanished, looking down at his feet with his shoulders hunched, so before Billy pulls away, he presses his foot down onto the accelerator, jerking the wheel so that the front of his car veers down Steve’s driveway, the front tyres crossing the threshold at an angle, pointing the driver’s side of the car towards the house. It’s little more than a slightly messy turn, a squeal of rubber that has Steve’s head darting up. The moment he does, Billy winds down his window and raises the bottom half of his cookie up in a salute.
He holds it there for a moment, and then Steve gives a little wave, the cherry of his cigarette bobbing in the darkness, and smiles.

It's not a big beam. It's not really soft or fond. But it's a smile directed at Billy.
It's nice.