Chapter Text
For the first time in a long time, Billy's actually feeling excited about Christmas.
It helps that it's all on his own terms this year. No Neil to put a damper on things, no Susan and her enforced jollity. Just him and his own place and whatever the fuck he wants to do.
It turns out that, when he's not being forced to enjoy someone else's idea of a holiday, Billy can actually feel quite festive, and when that's coupled with Billy's new mantra of, 'Fuck it, I survived, I'm gonna do what the fuck I want,' well then, Billy could almost call himself jolly.
His new place isn't exactly luxurious- just a one bed in the shitty part of town- but he’s done his best, with what limited budget he has left after actually buying the place, to spruce it up. He’s decked his hall and his living room and even his kitchen, and he’s even managed to get a few strands of lights to hang outside. Just a few, nothing spectacular, but enough to make him smile when he had to make a late night dash to the store and he came back to them shining out in the darkness.
The tree has been the hardest thing. Not the tree itself, that had been easy. Billy had chosen an artificial one, green, this time, rather than metallic. It wasn't exactly a skyscraper but it was definitely an upgrade from the tiny table top one of the previous year, and Billy had to move the coffee table into his bedroom in order to squeeze it into his living room, but it was worth the sacrifice.
He’d had to build up to decorating it though. If it hadn’t been for Max needling him, tutting every time she came over and saw the bare tree, grousing about how weird it was and then finally threatening that if he didn’t get his act together she and El would see to it that it was decorated to their tastes instead, Billy’s pretty sure he’d still be staring at bare branches even now. With her threats of bright pink tinsel and Wonder Woman themed baubles ringing loud in his ears, Billy had finally dug out the shoebox he’d been keeping safe for over a decade, pulling it out from right at the back of the top shelf of his closet, safe and hidden even here, in his own place, and carried it with shaking hands into the living room. He’d spent a good hour just looking at the few items inside, seeing them with fresh, older eyes, stroking his fingers over each one in turn, and then he’d arranged them on his tree, the stained, satin bell dangling from the lowest branch, the one-winged cherub nestled somewhere in the middle, while the red wooden horse had pride of place near the top.
It wasn’t enough, Billy knew, the tree seemed to look even sadder now, the few ornaments looking lost amidst all the branches, and Billy had been half tempted to pack the whole lot away, tree included, and pretend he’d never tried.
But he didn’t.
Although it still didn’t look right , there was something comforting about having the decorations there, finally back where they should be. There was a thrill in it too, seeing the precious items that he’d rescued and kept so safe over the years finally on display. It was scary too, of course, and it’d been a few days before he’d been able to stop checking that they were still there every morning, but little by little, he started to enjoy it.
And then, one by one, other decorations started to join them. He knew it was Max. Max and her cronies. They weren’t exactly subtle. They’d come round, a whole pack of them, and one of them would corner Billy, distract him with some inane question or meandering story, while the others giggled away in the living room and, by the time Billy managed to shoo them all out of his house, the tree would be dotted with a selection of colourful baubles or strands of tinsel or length of popcorn garland eve, or more than one occasional, some hideous little movie tie in. A Gremlin or a Care Bear or something Billy didn’t even recognise. There were good ornaments too, mixed in amongst them. Tiny, delicate crystal cats and big, velvety stars and other, more grown up choices that Billy figured had been stolen from the kids' parents, ones that he probably should've returned, but instead Billy played along with their games, pretending not to notice and, bit by bit, the tree started to look OK. A few more days, and it was better than OK. A few days more, and Billy could even say that it was good.
He started baking too. It had been a spur of the moment decision. Something to keep him busy, when he’d woken up from a nightmare and needed to do something anything to distract his still swirling mind from clinging on to the fear. He’d not had much in, but he had butter and sugar and flour and Joyce’s housewarming present had been a stack of recipe books so that was enough.
He’d measured and mixed and shaped and patted and swore and scowled and poked and sighed and grumbled and tipped more than one shitty batch into the bin and by the time the sunlight was filtering through the thin, gingham curtains, Billy had filthy counters, aching hands and a whole empty pantry. But he also had a home that smelt of cinnamon, a dining table covered in plates of cooling cookies and a great big smile on his face.
Even the best batches didn't turn out quite as good as his Mom's ever did, but they were decent enough that Billy found himself boxing them up and handing them over to the people who, over the last couple of years, had welcomed him into their lives.
Max got a good selection of course, and El and the rest of the brats, even though he made sure that the Wheeler kid mostly got the raisin ones.
He even made some for Maggie in the hospital.
And Joyce and the Chief. They got the best looking ones. Billy had even bought a set of special Christmas boxes for them and spent a while perfecting his bows.
And then there’d been Steve.
Billy had spent a long time second guessing himself with that one. In the end, he decided not to go for the formality of the box, and thought he'd offer up a casual invitation for Steve to come over and hang on Christmas day, and leave a tempting plate of cookies out on the table in the living room, ready and waiting for Steve if he wanted them.
It wasn't like the invitation would be something unusual. They were friends now, after all, close enough that Steve knew where Billy kept the good glasses and he had a usual spot on Billy's third-hand, slightly sagging couch when he came round to watch a movie. So it wouldn't have to be any more than that. Just two buddies spending a holiday together. But still, Billy hadn't quite been able to force himself to ask Steve.
Not yet.
And now it was Christmas Eve. Time’s officially run out. He’s got no choice but to swallow his fear and do it.
It's not like Steve's hard to find. He's been grousing about being landed with the Christmas Eve shift since Thanksgiving, grumbling about how busy it would get and how stressed and noisy all the customers would be, sulking about how he’d be stuck there until midnight, probably even later once he’d tidied and closed up, and generally being an insufferable drama queen about the whole thing.
So Billy makes his way to Family Video.
—
The moment he steps into the store, Billy can tell that Steve's worst fears about the shift have been realised. The store isn't too busy right now, but there's plenty of evidence that it has been. Steve’s hair is lank, flopping into his eyes in that way that Billy knows means he’s been running his hands through it, tucking it behind his ears over and over again, the way he does when he starts to get stressed. There’s also the fact that there’s a whole ton of returned tapes in small little piles at the side of him, rather than placed in the one huge tower that Steve always attempts when he’s had some down time, desperate to beat Robin’s record of twenty-three high before it tumbled.
It looks like it’s been one hell of a morning. But Billy can also see that Steve’s handling it. He’s got this. He’s smiling, and it looks real enough at first glance, but even from the doorway, Billy can immediately spot that it doesn’t reach his eyes and that there’s no tell-tale crinkle of Steve’s nose to give it away as the genuine article. Steve’s also got his customer service patter going in full flow, commenting positively on all the films that he’s putting through the register and as Billy fights his way through a crowd of whiny kids to get to the counter he catches the tail end of Steve gushing about Suspiria to some Gothic looking chick.
“So this guy, this Argento? Trust me, he’s a genius. The way he uses colour? You gotta see it. It’s like, yeah it’s horrible, but he captures the beauty too. And, the soundtrack? Oh, you’re going to love it.”
The girl doesn’t seem impressed, taking the tape and heading back out without even a thank you, but Billy still feels a stab of annoyance when he sees the way that Steve’s watching her leave. He shoves his way in front of the next customer in line, ignoring the guy’s feeble protest, and leans over the counter, waving a hand in front of Steve,
“Argento? Really, Harrington?” he smirks, “Cause I swear it was only yesterday that you thought that was a type of pasta.”
“You saw that, huh?” Steve groans, reaching out to gently push Billy over to the side and ringing up the next customer without even looking at them, “It sucks, man. I really thought I had something there. She gave me this look earlier, this, like, wink thing, and I coulda sworn she was flirting.”
“Nah she’s not your type,” Billy says, trying not to sound as bitter as he suddenly feels, “That wink was probably just an allergic reaction to all that eyeliner. And a Smiths shirt? She’s just gonna bring you down. You don’t want that.”
Steve nods, “Yeah, no, yeah, you’re right. And, ugh, she’d want to watch that kind of freaky shit all the time, right? Like, she wouldn’t have gone with me to see Top Gun , would she?”
“Definitely not,” Billy shakes his head, “She’d’ve been bitching all the way through. Nah, girls like that only want it if it’s black and white or French. ”
“Ugh,” Steve shudders, and then he grins. A proper one. One with a nose crinkle and everything, “Guess I dodged a bullet there, then. And hey, at least you went halves on the popcorn.”
Billy snorts, not wanting to think too hard about that particular night. Sitting right next to Steve in The Hawk, crammed in close on the shitty seat, their hands colliding more than once in the bucket of popcorn.
It would’ve been an exquisite torture on its own, without needing the volleyball scene.
It was one of the best and worst nights of Billy’s life.
He’s still definitely not thinking about it when Steve serves the last customer in line, and turns back to Billy.
“It's just, ugh, the holidays, man, y'know? Feel like everyone's all, like, loved up.”
And then he slumps down, his head thumping onto his arms, letting out an extended sigh.
“That bad?” Billy asks.
"You won't believe-" Steve pushes himself back up onto his elbows, sliding his fingers through his hair and tugging at the roots before tucking a strand behind his ears, "-ugh, you will not believe the day I've had."
"It's eleven fifteen," Billy states, and Steve ignores him.
“The day I’ve had,” he repeats. “We rented out our third and final copy of Rudolph by ten twenty. Do you know how many people have asked for it since then?"
Billy leans his back against the counter, one foot up, turning away so that Steve can’t see his amused smile, "I imagine you're gonna tell me."
"Seven, Billy. Seven . With the three who managed to get it, that makes ten people who wanted to watch Rudolph today. Ten people. Ten.”
“Kudos to your kindergarten math teacher there, Harrington.”
“It's Christmas Eve, holy shit , just turn on the TV, any station, any time, trust me you're gonna see Rudolph. And if you don’t? Wait five minutes, he’ll come prancing along like an asshole."
Out of the corner of his eye, Billy can see Steve’s exasperated hand gestures, and he stifles a laugh, turning it into a muffled cough, before he arranges his face into an exaggerated expression of sympathy.
“Oh poor you, Stevie, having to actually do your damn job.”
To his credit, Steve seems to realise how dramatic he’s being. He pushes himself fully upright, reaching out for one of the stacks of returned tapes and starts sorting them into piles for reshelving, "Hopefully it won't be as bad tomorrow ," he says, and it takes Billy a few seconds to connect the dots.
“Tomorrow? Seriously? You’re working Christmas Eve and Christmas? Is that even allowed?”
Steve shrugs, "Probably not, but Keith's being an asshole. And anyway, it just makes sense. Robin's got some family thing this week, new guy's got a kid of his own. What have I got? And it's not bad. Double pay, at least. And it saves me from another Harrington party so, win-win?"
"Oh." Billy tries not to let the disappointment show.
"Oh?" Steve asks.
"Nah, it's nothing, I was gonna see if you might wanna hang tomorrow. But you're gonna be busy so, yeah, it's fine.”
Steve's face drops, his eyes doing that big, Bambi thing that makes him look like a kicked puppy.
“Bills!” he whines, “I would’ve done that. I didn’t know! You never said! Shit. Think I can get Keith to switch back? Dress up as the Ghost of Christmas Past or whatever and scare him into taking the shift?”
“Can’t hurt to try,” Billy says, but then Steve’s face suddenly lights up with a grin.
“Hey, look, what if you come here ? Stick around and bug me like you always do? ‘S not like this place is gonna be heaving, right? Not on Christmas Day, surely? People have got, like, family shit to do. Or church or whatever. So we could probably, I dunno, we could get away with sticking on a movie in the back room and I can sneak out some of whatever catering Mom’s ordered in for the party, and we can do our own thing?”
“Yeah, that sounds-” Billy starts, but Steve’s already shaking his head.
“Nah, it’s OK, I guess you have proper plans, and you’re gonna want to be with Max. But, hey, look, it doesn’t matter if you can’t. I get it, but let me- hang on- let me get…”
And then Steve’s gone before Billy can stop him, dashing off to the backroom and emerging with a gift wrapped box.
“Just in case you can’t make it tomorrow, or if it gets too busy or whatever, lemme give you this. There’s kinda…there’s a part of it you’ll probably want before tomorrow anyway.”
He thrusts the box into Billy’s hands.
“OK?” Billy asks, trying to figure out what Steve means. “Should I open it now then?”
Steve thinks for a minute before nodding, “Yeah, actually, you probably should cause, shit, this is gonna need an explanation.”
Billy gives him a quizzical look, his fingers already peeling back the paper, and Steve smiles sheepishly, "Remember you said about breaking your favourite mug?"
Billy does remember. It’d been about a month ago, when the broken mug was the shitty cherry on top of a fucking atrocious day, one of his bad ones where his old injuries started playing up again, his hands alternating between a burning ache and a tingling numbness, until a sudden shockwave of agony gripped him and he’d dropped the mug he’d been holding, shattering on his kitchen floor and drenching his toes in scalding hot coffee.
Billy hadn’t dealt with it particularly well. He’d yelled, a lot, and he’d thrown a different, perfectly innocent mug at the wall and then done what he could to clean up the mess, doing his best even though his hands had still been cramping, and then he’d tried to change his socks, another process which took way fucking longer than it should due to the fact that his fingers wouldn’t listen to his brain, and then even though there was no reason to, even though part of him wanted to do nothing more than curl up on the couch and not leave the house for a week, he’d found himself pulling his boots on over bare, slightly red feet, and limping his way over to Family Video, not quite trusting himself to drive.
Because he’d wanted to see Steve.
Steve had, of course, been worried. And that’s when the whole story had spilled out. By that point, Billy had gone through his usual stages of emotion, the initial anger and tears of frustration giving way to a melancholic grumpiness, leaving him feeling utterly sorry for himself, so he knew he’d definitely whined about it way too much and he hadn't even realised that Steve was listening.
But clearly he had.
Billy’s got the proof right in his hands, a large, lightweight mug with the face of Animal from the Muppets on it, and big cartoony letters declaring “I’m such an Animal before I’ve had my coffee!”
He looks up at Steve who is definitely blushing, “Look, ok there was this shop that had, like, a whole rack of these. And they're tin or something, so if you drop it, it won't break. Or, at least it shouldn't. The guy at the shop said it probably wouldn't, unless you were, like, actually trying to break it. And even then-"
Steve stops himself, holding up his hands and taking a deep breath, "Look, I know it probably seems odd. But I saw this one and I thought about…well…that Animal impression you used to do? It kinda…yeah-" Steve reaches up, scratching at the back of his head awkwardly, "-I thought it might be…OK? Kinda funny?"
Billy's dumbstruck, the memory of that exact impression flooding back. It had been back in the summer, right back at the beginning of Billy becoming a regular presence in Family Video. Steve had started it all off. Billy had walked in on him mid way through teasing Robin about something, switching between an uncanny Kermit impression and a slightly ropier Miss Piggy one, while Robin pointedly ignored him, loudly announcing Billy’s presence, apparently in the hope that it would shut Steve up.
It hadn’t.
Steve had greeted Billy in the Kermit voice and Billy had responded with a terrible impression of the only Muppet he could think of on the spot. Animal. Really, it had been terrible. There wasn’t a lot to even the best of Animal impressions, so Billy’s ended up being nothing but a ton of growling and a drum solo slapped out on the tapes stacked up on the counter, complete with a cheek straining grin, but something about it had obviously tickled Steve because he’d doubled over with laughter, re-emerging from underneath the counter with tears in his eyes, unable to speak for a good thirty seconds as he gasped for air.
So Billy had done it again. And again. And to Robin’s absolute horror, it became a whole thing. For what seemed like the entirety of that summer, whenever Steve and Billy were together, there was bound to be a moment where one of them would randomly start talking in a Muppet voice. Billy stuck to Animal but, Steve, it turned out, had a whole repertoire. Nothing quite matched his Kermit, but his Fozzie and his Swedish Chef were definitely up there, and he could even carry on an entire Bunsen and Beaker conversation by himself.
Billy couldn’t quite remember why the whole thing stopped. He figured it probably had something to do with the time Steve had started greeting the customers with Muppet impressions too, not realising that Keith was standing behind him, but Billy couldn’t be certain. Not that it mattered, it had just been one of those things, pure, dumb teenage boy fun that they both should’ve been too mature for, but that both of them still enjoyed.
It had been fun.
Billy stares down at the Animal mug, trying desperately to conjure up the voice again. It’s the correct response, he knows that, acknowledge the jokey side of the gift, the shared memory. But Billy can't. Everything is sticking in his throat.
He's absolutely and utterly floored.
The dickache of a crush he's been harbouring, repressing, for a whole year now springs right back up. Because it’s so nice. So fucking nice. Steve’s bought him something so damn thoughtful once again and Billy feels like an asshole but he also feels like someone’s stuck a pump into his heart and blown it up to three times its usual size and he can’t stop smiling and his mouth is all dry and he can hear his pulse in his ears and his stomach is fluttering like crazy.
And that’s not exactly new, he's always been a sucker for Steve.
He's always known there was something there, a flame that he’d been kindling. It had been lust at first sight that night at Tina's Halloween party only a few years ago, and while there'd been the seed of something deeper underneath, Billy thinks that he might be been OK, might've just about been able to keep that seed unwatered, kept it buried in the harshest, most unforgiving of soil until it withered and died without fully taking root. But then Steve ended up being a bigger part of his life than Billy ever could have imagined. They became friends. And that was harder. A hell of a lot harder. Bit by bit, he got to see every side of Steve. The smooth talking charmer; the slightly bitchy ex-King; the dorky babysitter; the caring, compassionate friend; the brave, determined protector.
He got to see Steve and know him and see all the wonderful parts of him and he fell in love.
How could he not?
Billy fell head over heels, ass over tea kettle, heart and soul, madly and stupidly in love.
And he'd been doing so well, so damn well at ignoring it, giving nothing away, only letting himself indulge late at night, torturing himself by replaying every conversation and interaction, picking them apart and daring himself to think what if and maybe, reveling in fuzzy, golden lit dreams of the possibilities, only to regret it all in the harsh light of day when reality can crashing down and Billy realised just how pathetic he had been.
And then Steve would do something sweet or dorky or the light would hit him just right or he'd get all passionate about some movie Robin had made him watch or he'd offer out half his candy bar to Billy like it was no big thing or he'd sulk when he lost the coin toss for who was fetching lunch or he’d give Max some sincere dating advice. Nothing major, nothing special, just something so Steve.
And Billy would fall head over heels all over again, his resolve weakening each and every time. And now he thinks he's finally snapped. There's no way he can hide it.
"Pretty funny, Stevie," he manages, and it comes out gruff enough that Billy thinks Steve might just be fooled into thinking it's Billy's attempt at the impersonation. He buys himself a little more time by pretending to be examining the mug. The inside of it is stuffed with red tissue, and when Billy pokes it, he can tell that there’s something else in there, all wrapped up. He reaches in, his fingers grasping around the lurking thing, a squishy lump encased in layers and layers of tissue paper and the moment he pulls it out, Steve's face goes on a whole journey.
"Oh shit! That? That’s the thing you probably want before Christmas. If you even want it at all. And it’s one hundred percent Max's fault. Blame Max. She's been going on and on about your tree? How you hardly had any ornaments? So, yeah, she made everyone promise to get you something. Not as your actual gift, she made that pretty clear too, and, yeah OK, that whole plan was probably meant to be a secret but, dude, I am not taking full responsibility for that thing."
Billy's been unwrapping as Steve's been rambling, and, almost as if it was planned, he removes the final layer at the exact moment that Steve finishes talking. It's a tree ornament alright. Not that Billy would have guessed that at first. It's a ball of spiky pinky-orangey-red fluff, with a slightly askew felt mouth stitched onto the middle, complete with jagged felt teeth, underneath a pair of equally lopsided eyes and a bulging orange blob of a nose. Two spindly arms emerge from either side clutching tiny wooden drum sticks, and that's what finally gives it away.
"It's Animal!"
"Yeah!" Steve sighs in relief, "I thought it was cool when I first saw it, but then Robin was like, 'It doesn't look anything like Animal,' and I asked a few customers and, well, yeah. Most of them agreed with her. Some of them could tell though. After a little prompting."
"Nah, course it's him," Billy grins, holding the ornament up and letting it spin around on its red and black thread, "It's awesome, Steve, thanks."
Secretly, Billy has to agree with Robin, but he's more than thankful for the distraction that the ugly thing caused and there is something oddly charming about it.
"Max's idea," Steve says.
"You're the one that chose him though, right?"
"Well, yeah, ok, yeah that's true." Steve tips his head slightly to the side, pursing his lips like he's thinking about it, "But, hey, how could I resist? He's loud and damn he can be annoying but he's sweet really. Kinda cute, too. Gotta say, I like him."
Steve's not looking at the ornament. His eyes are locked on Billy's. There's the usual warmth there, but with a hint of something else. A hint of a tease, almost like a gauntlet being laid down, but with a playful edge.
And Billy knows he's in even more trouble than before.
He's saved from having to stutter out a reply, as the shop door opens, and their moment of peace seems to be over, so as Steve turns to deal with the new influx of customers, Billy packs the furry Animal back inside the mug, nestling him cosily into his nest of paper, and heads out.
There's a plan forming. A dumb one, probably, but Billy can't shake Steve's words and the look in his eyes. Because Billy's had similar looks to that one directed his way before. He knows how they usually end.
And, fuck it, Billy nearly died. He survived a literal nightmare. He's been through hell. He can do this.
He races home. But before he sets about putting his plan into action, he takes the time to put the Animal decoration on the tree. There's not a lot of space any more, not after the kids' donations, but there's a gap near the top, close to the little red horse.
So that’s where Billy puts him. Red with Red.
They look good together, and Billy stands back and admires it. He’d thought the tree looked good before, but now he knows it. It looks complete.
—
Billy waits until late before enacting his plan. He bides his time, even as the nerves grow, but by ten thirty he can’t wait much longer, and by ten forty-five he’s back at Family Video. This time, Steve seems a lot more chilled. His hair is less chaotic, and Billy knows he’d made use of the travel sized hairspray that he keeps in his rucksack, and the shop itself seems neat and orderly. Even the stacks on the counter have all been reshelved.
“How long’s it been since the last customer?” Billy asks, trying to sound nonchalant.
“Dunno,” Steve shrugs. He gestures to the back room, where Billy can see the flickering colours of the television set, “At least all of Gremlins , and about a quarter of Merry Christmas, Mr. Lawrence which, lemme tell you, definitely not a feel good festive classic. There might’ve been a ten minute snooze in there somewhere too.”
Billy smiles, “Sounds like no one’s gonna miss you if you take off early then?”
Steve’s brow creases, “I dunno, I mean…we’re meant to be open until twelve. What if someone comes?”
Billy already has that covered. He reaches into the satchel slung over his shoulder, pulling out a piece of paper.
“ Sorry We’re Closed, Christmas Miracle In Progress ?” Steve reads, and Billy can feel a flush of embarrassment as he hears the words aloud, especially in Steve’s slightly incredulous tone. He tries to push through it.
“Yeah, look, it’s…it’s kind of a joke. And that way people won’t mind. Or they’ll assume, I dunno, you had to close early cause of a register issues or plumbing or something. Look, just…I have an idea. Something I want to do. And it…it has to be now. Tonight. Before midnight.”
Steve still looks unsure. So Billy takes a deep breath, “Please?”
It’s enough. Steve’s eyes widen in surprise, and he nods, taking the note from Billy’s hand and sticking it up on the glass door. He makes quick work of getting the rest of the store closed up, and before too long they’re both in Billy’s car.
“OK, so, this is a kidnapping, right?” Steve asks, as Billy steers the car away from town, “Or a prank? Revenge? Cause I don’t know what-”
“Shut it, Stevie,” Billy says, but he keeps his tone soft. “It’s…it’s something. A gift.”
“Dude, you didn’t have to get me anything. Especially not, y’know, abduction.”
Billy rolls his eyes, and Steve drops the joke, reverting back to his usual chatter about his days and his customers and how he so nearly beat Robin’s record this time but he knew that even if he did she’d never believe him and, really, Billy needs to start coming in more so that he can have a witness to that kind of amazing feat.
But Billy’s hardly listening. His heart is hammering in his ears with every mile he drives. He glances at his watch, watching the time slip away, tapping his hand on the steering wheel in a fast-paced, staccato rhythm that bears no relation to the smooth Christmas music that Steve’s found on the radio.
Eventually, Billy finds where he needs to be. He’d scouted it out again earlier, noting the landmarks in the daylight, knowing that it’d be nigh on impossible to find in the darkness unless you knew exactly what you were looking for. Even with his prior preparation, he still almost misses it, and he has to slam on his brakes, shooting an arm across the passenger seat and catching Steve before he hurtles into the dashboard.
“Shit, sorry,” Billy mutters.
“Seriously, Bills, what’s going on?” Steve peers out of the window, and Billy knows he’s taking in the nothingness all around. The sheer pitch blackness that comes from being surrounded by encroaching hills and towering forests and with absolutely no light, save for the glow of the Camaro’s headlights, “This is, uh, yeah. I’m, uh, I’m not sure I like this, man. I think you’ve gone wrong somewhere, cause there’s nothing here. I don’t get why we- oh shit, are you…?” Billy sees the sudden flash of fear on Steve’s face, the weight of a particularly bad penny dropping, “Is it happening again? Are you OK? Billy? Are you…are you still you ? Do you need me to help?”
Billy realises what Steve is asking, and what he suspects with a sickening lurch.
But he’s not running. He’s not even trying to run. Steve's sitting here, in the middle of nowhere, with a guy who he thinks might be harbouring another one of those fucking nightmare creatures in his head, and he’s not even fucking running.
He’s sitting there and he’s asking if Billy needs help. Because he cares. Because he’s nice like that. Because he’s good and brave and strong and protective and Billy just can’t hold back any more. He shakes his head, reaching out to catch Steve’s sleeve.
“No, I-” Billy’s voice catches, and he swallows, “I’m me, I’m good. I promise. I just…we need to be here. Or, well, not here but-” he points out of the window, “-up there. There’s a track and just…just trust me. Please.”
“OK,” Steve says easily, and Billy knows that if he dwells on that, on how easily Steve believes him, then he’ll get lost in it. So he doesn’t dwell. He turns the car and guides it carefully up the winding track through the forest.
And then they’re there. Right where Billy needs to be. He’s not even sure where he is, not really, but it’s a place he found by accident and filed away. A place where no one else ever seems to be.
They’re on top of a hill, right on the edge of the town with the whole of Hawkins is spread out before them. Billy’s seen it before, of course. Sometimes even as late as this. But never like this. Never on Christmas Eve.
It’s even better than he hoped.
The town is full of light, every neighborhood with its own particular pattern. The crowd pleasing displays of the town square, complete with the huge tree; the neat order of Loch Nora contrasting with the more haphazard choices of Cherry Lane, and everything in between. Everywhere Billy looks, there’s a different style of Christmas display, riots of colour and sparkle and twinkling lights shining out into the night.
It's magical.
He turns to look at Steve, who's taking in the sight with a look of amazement on his face.
“Oh wow!” Steve whispers beside him, “Yeah, OK, man, I’ll give you this one, that’s awesome.”
Billy's heart gives a kick at the genuine joy in his tone. Steve gets it. He likes it. He isn't just humouring him. Billy did something good here, something right. He made Steve happy, and damn it feels good to have that kind of effect.
They sit for a while, taking turns to comment on the details they notice, Steve nudging Billy with an elbow and pointing out locations he knows, the houses of childhood friends or a hardware store that used to sell toys, while Billy focuses on the displays themselves, spotting when two houses have obviously bought the exact same decorations, or laughing at some unintentionally phallic looking arrangements.
Billy gets so lost in the ease of it, the simple pleasure of sharing in the joy of the lights, that he almost forgets the rest of his idea until a slight growl from Steve's tummy brings him right back.
“Oh, hey, shit, you hungry? Cause, there’s this too,” Billy says, reaching into his satchel and pulling out a Thermos and a small Tupperware box, “I know there’s no way it’s gonna be as good as your Grandma’s but, hey, maybe it’s something?”
Steve’s eyes go wider than Billy’s ever seen them as he takes in the items in Billy’s hands, zeroing in on the flask.
“Holy shit, dude, holy…is that hot chocolate?”
“Peppermint hot chocolate,” Billy clarifies. Steve reaches out eagerly, his hands starfishing like a toddler reaching for a rattle, and Billy hands the Thermos over with a chuckle, “But be careful cause I used- ”
But Steve’s already taken a huge gulp, and Billy winces in sympathy, “-Schnapps.”
Billy knows he’d been a little heavy handed with the alcohol, but he’s pretty sure that Steve’s just being dramatic when lets out a wheezing gasp.
"Jesus, Bills! You bring me out here to get me wasted? Gonna end the night sprawled on your backseat with my panties round my ankles and a sore head?" Steve's laughs at his own joke, sniffing at the rim of the flask before he takes another, more cautious sip, "Cause I don't know what you've heard, but, uh, I'm not that kind of girl."
Billy feels his heart drop. He hears what Steve’s saying, but he also hears what he means with it.
And he’s read this wrong. So wrong.
He’s fucked up. He’s made a mistake. He’s let his own stupid dreams get the better of him. Those late night what ifs and maybes . The dumb, naive hope that should’ve been beaten out of him years ago.
He’s fucked up, he’s really fucked up.
Billy turns away, trying desperately to hide his face, but it’s too late. Steve’s already noticed. His joking smile falls away and a frown wrinkles across his forehead. He reaches out, catching at Billy’s arm and pulling him back around.
“Hey, shit, man, sorry, I'm…I'm being an asshole. You're doing the nicest thing anyone's ever done for me in, I dunno, in ever, probably, and I'm being a dick about it. I'm sorry Bills. This is good, OK, really good. I’m just a lightweight now that I‘m getting old.” He tugs at Billy’s sleeve, then slides his hand down to tap on the lid of the Tupperware, “Come on, what’s in here? You got more goodies?"
Billy’s not sure if he can talk. His heart is still hammering fit to burst, more now that Steve’s fingers are so close to his own. He peels back the lid of the tub, and the warm, cinnamony scent of the cookies fills the air.
“Oh!” Steve’s gasp this time is one of delight, “Holy shit, these look incredible. Did you make these?”
Billy shakes his head, “Yeah, uh, I had a go. They’re not…some of them went kinda weird, the shapes, but they should be OK to eat.”
Steve’s already diving in, pulling out the first cookie he can see, “Oh damn, you weren’t joking about the shapes! What the hell is this supposed to be? A dick?" He snorts as he holds it up, "Holy shit, it is! Dude it's even got a vein." Steve runs his finger along a wobbly blue line of icing, sounding absolutely delighted.
"It's an icicle ," Billy huffs, grabbing it from Steve and turning it the right way up, "That's the shine of it."
"Oh yeah, yeah, alright, whatever you say. An icicle, sure ." Steve takes a bite anyway, his moan of satisfaction rumbling through the car and going straight to Billy’s dick. “Damn, I don’t mind what it’s meant to be. Dick, icicle, whatever, man. This is delicious, OK? I’m putting in an order for, like, twenty more of these. At least. They’re exactly like my Grandma’s, I swear.”
“Really?” Billy says, his eyebrow raising, and Steve’s smile turns wry.
“OK, maybe not exactly. The icing is a little different, I guess, and, uh, I gotta say, I’m pretty sure she never made dick ones.”
—
It’s a good night, Billy thinks as he munches down on the second to last cookie. Even if this is all he gets, it’s been a damn good night. He’s here. It’s Christmas Eve. He’s got lights and cookies and a warm feeling in his chest that he knows isn’t all down to the Schnapps, because he’s barely managed to wrangle the flask away from Steve since he first got hold of it.
He’s happy. Content. He could probably learn to live with this, if this is all he gets.
But then he thinks about Steve’s look earlier. The playfulness. The challenge. He thinks about other things too. Other times. Other comments. Other moments.
Maybe it’s not all he’s going to get. Maybe he could try. Go for something better than good, for once.
He turns to Steve.
He looks good, even in the harsh, unflattering interior light of the car. Even with cookie crumbs all around his mouth, the remains of the last cookie caught in the slight moustache he’s cultivating above his top lip. Even in his dorky Family Video polo.
Steve looks so good.
“I, uh-”
“I like your earring,” Steve interrupts, “I meant to say it earlier. It’s cute.”
Billy looks up at his reflection in the rearview mirror, and Steve’s comment makes a bit more sense. He’d forgotten that he’d switched out his usual dagger for something more festive. An early gift from Max, delivered with an unspoken but clear as hell, "I dare you," as she watched him unwrap it with a shit eating grin that he's pretty certain she learned from him.
It's a candy cane, made out of teeny-tiny red and white beads that he recognises from one of Max's long neglected crafts kits. Probably the exact kit he'd caught her giggling over with El not that long ago.
“Cute?” Billy asks and Steve shrugs.
“Yeah, cute. But I think I prefer the, uh, the dangly one," Steve wiggles his finger near his own earlobe as he tries to describe what he means. "The…the dangly one with the sword and, like, a few beads on it? Always thought it makes you look-"
Billy readies himself for the insult. The slur. Neil had said enough of them, when Billy first came back with a fresh stud in his ear. He doesn't think Steve will say it with the same bite, the same cruel hiss, but Billy thinks hearing it at all from Steve will hurt him more than Neil's words ever did.
"-pretty."
Billy had steeled himself for a world of things.
But there was no world, no fucking universe, in which he could have ever been prepared for that, and it feels like every single ounce of breath leaves Billy's body in a choked gasp. Steve's one, single word sends him reeling out into the stratosphere, dizzy in a way that he's never felt before.
Steve's saying more, stumbling over his words, getting redder and redder, but Billy can't hear him. There's only one word in his ears, echoing over and over, taking root in cells and synapses and doubling, tripling, multiplying until it's all he can think about.
"-kind like Rob Lowe" Steve finishes.
And, ok, that’s definitely something else that Billy wants to think about. His giddy thought process grinds to a breaking halt as he processes Steve's words, "Rob Lowe? Seriously?"
Steve just shrugs, "Yeah. Kinda. I see it. And, uh, and yeah. That earring. The dangly one. I can't…I’m like…totally obsessed when you wear that. Cause I can only think about how I kinda wanna, like, touch it. Tap it. Like…I dunno…like a cat with a piece of string."
A bark of surprised laughter erupts out of Billy at that exact visual, and Steve’s chuckling a second later.
“Yeah, I know, it’s so dumb. I let it slip to Robin and she’s never let me live it down.”
Billy doesn’t know quite where the surge of bravery comes from, but it feels like the universe is giving him the most blatant sign it can. He'd be a fool to ignore it.
"Go on then, Harrington,” he says, “Touch it. If you really want to."
Steve blinks, staring at Billy. And then he does. He flicks the earring with a finger nail, a tiny, satisfied smile on his face as he watches it swing.
Billy can feel the slight tug of it on his lobe. But there’s a bigger pull, right in his gut, like someone’s yanking him forward.
Steve’s close. So close. His hand is still right by Billy’s ear. It wouldn't take much for Billy to lean into it.
So he does it.
He closes his eyes and he lets his head tilt and it takes nothing, and everything at all.
Steve catches him. Holds him.
“I, uh, I kinda want to do something else too."
Billy's breath catches in his throat. Steve can't mean… He doesn't…That's not how...
Things like that don't happen to Billy.
But Steve's hand slides to rest on his cheek, the tips of his fingers curling into the roots of Billy's hair, and he's waiting, his eyes flicking down to Billy’s lips.
"Do it," Billy urges. Because he needs to know.
And Steve does.
He leans in, eyes closing, and presses his mouth against Billy's in the softest, most chaste kiss Billy's ever received.
Billy has kissed a lot of people. A lot . But he's never been kissed like this, by someone he actually wants to kiss him. And no one's ever kissed him like Steve is kissing him, soft and sweet and delicate, taking their time like he's something to savour.
He's kissing Billy like Billy matters.
Billy sinks into it. He loses himself in it, in the feel of all of it. Steve’s hand on his face and Steve’s lips on his and the taste of cinnamon and cookies shared between them and Steve’s body so close and warm and there, within easy reach. So Billy reaches. He has a hand on Steve’s arm and he pulls, just a little, a hint of a suggestion, and Steve moves with him, closing the space.
It’s awkward, there’s a centre console between them and the angle is wrong and the light is harsh.
But it’s good. It’s great. It’s wonderful. It’s perfect.
Eventually, much too soon, Steve draws back, letting out a shaky little whoa and a laugh,
"Oh wow,” he murmurs, “Wow. And hey, I always wanted to kiss Rob Lowe."
"Oh really?" Billy smirks.
"Nah," Steve shakes his head, "Least not until I saw you.
“Charmer,” Billy tuts, and Steve’s smile turns from soppy and dopey to mischievous as he reaches out with his finger, quick as a flash, and taps it with a 'boop' onto the tip of Billy's nose.
"I actually did always want to do that though," he says, cupping Billy’s face again, "That button nose of yours. Used to drive me crazy whenever you'd do that scrunchy face when you got annoyed." Steve pulls away, and Billy misses his touch already. As Steve moves his hand down, back to his lap, Billy reaches out to catch it. He takes Steve's hand. Squeezes it. And Steve squeezes back, lacing their fingers together.
They sit like that, holding hands and looking out at the lights, Steve's body warm and close, his head tilting until it's resting against Billy's shoulders.
It all feels so good. So right. And Billy knows that, before too long, they'll have to get back. But he doesn't see a need to rush.
Because, for now, it's Christmas Eve in Hawkins.
And it’s perfect.
