Actions

Work Header

when stars come falling from the sky

Chapter 3

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

The following night, after Steve has his time with Robin, Billy drives to her place to pick her up. He waits outside the car for her, hands stuffed in his pockets, wishing he had a cigarette.

A heater would be nice too.

Robin hurries out of the door and straight to him. She engulfs Billy in a tight hug and it’s a lot easier to hug her back than Max. It probably shouldn’t be, but Max doesn’t know him like Robin.

She squeezes him tight until it feels like things are being squished and maneuvered back into place. Robin keeps hold of him for a long time, and Billy knew Steve would spill because he forgot to tell him not to.

But it feels easier this way.

Billy takes her to his place after and sits on the couch while she explores every inch of the apartment.

“Okay,” Robin says as she comes out of the bedroom and holds her finger in the air. “I love it. I love everything about it. I want one. I want one of my own. But I work at Family Video, so I’ll just have yours. And I get to cook you fresh food and we are so going to bake together. I will be over at five-thirty every Sunday and we will bake.”

He rests his arm on the back of the couch and his chin in his hand. “If that’s what you wanna do, sugar,” Billy drawls. “Five-thirty, my ass.”

“How early do you think I get up to come see you at work?”

“That’s on Wednesdays.”

“Wednesdays and Sundays are food days,” Robin says and collapses next to him. “We’re gonna make so many things. Dump them all on Steve after.”

Billy laughs. “Put a little meat on his bones.”

“His arms have definition,” Robin says and gestures at her shoulder. “Like in this one specific area, they do. He’s a runner, honey. You’re the lifter. And you guys could never switch.”

“You think I can’t fuckin’ run?”

“Oh, I’d love to see it. Show me what those lungs can do when you put smoke in them every other hour,” Robin says. “Steve’s clean. He’s unspoiled. But he probably couldn’t lift.”

Billy hums. “I’d like to see him try, though.”

“Just like he’d probably like to see you hit the track,” Robin chuckles. “Lover boy told me you guys spent two hours together on Saturday.”

“I did not enjoy it.”

“You are such a good liar. It does not work on me.”

Billy laughs. “You sure about that?” he asks. He shrugs. “Yeah, Harrington isn’t all bad. You don’t gotta tell me you were right, babe. I already know it. We aren’t gonna be friends.”

“Oh, honey,” Robin says and smiles sympathetically. “You’re already there.”

“The fuck we are.”

Robin sighs. “Literally pulling teeth,” she mutters and waves her hands. “Fine. I’ll pretend you don’t have plans.”

Billy raises his eyebrows. “You don’t have to pretend. We did not make plans for a damn thing.”

“No?” Robin asks and tilts her head. “Hmm. Maybe he’s springing them on you, so I should stop talking.”

“You’re the only one allowed to spring anything on me,” Billy says and points at her. “Don’t let him get it twisted.”

“God. Boys. You literally cause me so much pain,” Robin says and hops off the couch. “If every boy disappeared tomorrow, women would rejoice.”

Billy sighs. “How you gonna repopulate the planet?”

“A lifetime spent with only women and so, so many lesbians? We would die happy. Let the aliens have earth after. We wouldn’t care,” Robin says. She roots around her tote near the door. “So, something special,” she adds, walking over with a bag. She shakes her head at him when he raises his arms. “You are an actual child.”

Billy wiggles his fingers until she hands over the bag. He opens it and looks inside, squinting. “Chocolates?” he asks and looks at her. “You made chocolates?”

“I made the best goddamn chocolates around. So, Uncle Huey lives out west, right? Turns out they have, like, an actual chocolatier in town. Who knew? So, the most gourmet shit you’ve ever had in your life. But they sell baking chocolate and chocolate bars, and, honey, I have never seen anything more magnificent in my life. You know what they also sell?”

“Hmm,” Billy hums and smells the chocolates. They pack a punch of dark chocolate and that’s more tempting. “What else do they sell?”

“Chocolate liquors. Which are disgusting, by the way,” Robin says. “But it gave me an idea. They made these chocolates filled with caramel that were amaaazing. God. I could’ve died. Anyway. Idea.”

“These are dark chocolate caramels with booze.”

“They are drippy caramels in a chocolate shell. With booze.”

“Babe,” Billy sighs and grabs one. “I might ask you to marry me.”

Robin laughs. “I know. Coolest chick around. Steve and I already have a marriage pact.”

Billy side-eyes her before popping the chocolate into his mouth. It’s a big, sudden mouthful of rich, sweet caramel almost immediately cut by bourbon. He’s not into rich things—but that’s usually heavy cakes, pies, and brownies.

Except for the chewy crust left on the pan. Billy will eat that.

“What’s the verdict?”

Billy licks his lips and looks at her. “Give me a few minutes alone and I’ll let you know.”

“Awful. So awful,” Robin laughs. She lays back on the couch and Billy lifts the bag so she can put her legs on his lap. “Good. I’m glad. I didn’t even tell Steve about those.”

“All for me?” Billy asks mockingly. “Feelin’ bad for me, sugar?”

“Um, no? Hello? I am in love with this apartment and I’m so happy for you,” Robin says. “But moving sucks. Talking to people about moving sucks. I get why you didn’t tell anyone. And I know it was difficult with Max. Draining. Super proud of you, though. So, the chocolates are merely your welcome home gift and something to relax with.”

“Man, if you say so,” Billy says and grabs another, smiling. He pops it into his mouth and leans back, lightly drumming her legs. “That’s what I’m fuckin’ talking about right there.”

“Mhmm,” Robin hums, smiling. “You’re welcome, you’re welcome. I’m always on the money, I know. When do I get my first sleepover?”

Billy laughs and wipes the corner of his mouth. “You bring some clothes?”

“Yes, actually. I did.”

“Stay over then.”

Robin holds up her hand and Billy smacks it.

“Right on. You’re the man,” Robin says. “Guess what?”

“You asked Vickie to hang out.”

Robin narrows her eyes. “Steve told you.”

Billy cackles. “Goes both ways now, sugar.”

“Ugh,” Robin mutters. “Whatever. Okay, so, I totally did. I didn’t mean to, either. It just bubbled to the surface like a wordy, blobby monster. I almost yelled it. She looked totally freaked. But I asked if she wanted to go to the mall ‘cause I have so much Christmas shopping to get done, and I think that distracted her from being freaked because she also has so much Christmas shopping to get done. So. We’re totally going Christmas shopping together.”

“Proud of you, babe. You conquered that small hill.”

“Are you serious? I skipped the whole staircase and small hill and went for the big one. No flirting. At least, not any flirting known to man, but she seems to like me anyway. So, you know,” Robin says airily, “I deserve congratulations. My favorite kind.”

“Ahhh, fuck,” Billy says and rests his head on the back of the couch. “Orange chicken, extra on the orange. Double of egg rolls. Pork wontons.”

“You have to say your part too.”

Billy shakes his head. “Yui Shan spicy chicken. Double of spring rolls,” he says. He watches Robin pump her fists and chuckles, slapping her legs. “Move your ass. I’ll call ‘em.”

“I love you more than the moon and stars, boo.”

“More than home, huh? Must be doing something right,” Billy says and gets up. He walks to the kitchen to grab the phone and he’s glad he got it set up on Friday.

Robin buzzes around him to look in his cabinets as Billy orders Chinese food and wonders when the last time he had a friend sleep over. Probably when he was seven, if he had to guess, and it’s a bit unsettling to think about.

Good, too, because this is Robin. Billy wouldn’t choose anyone else.

Maybe they’ll get up at five-thirty, but they’re working adults now, and that’s just the way it’s gotta be.

——

Robin doesn’t have anywhere to be until Joyce’s party. Billy asks her three times so he remembers and doesn’t show up at the video store and gets roped into hours of good conversation with Steve Harrington.

She looks at him with faint, exasperated amusement, but Billy firmly ignores that.

He gets Max a key to the apartment before the office closes that Monday. Billy doesn’t go inside because it’s apparently volatile, but he meets Max down the street to give it to her. Everything is okay, just lots of yelling and general nastiness, but that’s nothing new.

Neil has had a lot to say about Billy, but that’s good. Billy hopes he keeps at it.

They’re swiftly coming up on winter break and Max will live at Hopper’s. The guy has to be thrilled about it, but whatever. Billy is paranoid each evening he gets home from work or hanging out with Robin, and the first time he realizes Max was in his place sets his nerves on fire.

But she only left him a smiley face on a notepad on the coffee table Billy bought a couple of days ago. Signed her name, thankfully, but Billy is relieved to see it. He doesn’t blame her for coming to sniff around, anyway, and he’s glad she did.

The next time she’s over is the day before winter break. Billy only knows it because a beer is missing from the six-pack in his freezer and his stomach twists on itself. He could kill her when he finds it in his pantry, but it’s better than anything else. Billy complains about her to Robin, but she thinks Max only misses him and says to deal with her impish ways.

So Billy will deal.

Robin also reminds Billy that the invite to Joyce’s Christmas party never left the table. It’s been haunting him, so he knows that well, but he stands by every reason he has not to go. Christmas spent alone sounds much better than any other Christmas he’s ever had, and Robin hums with displeasure, but she doesn’t push.

She sics Steve on Billy instead and he thinks that was their plan all along.

Billy could kill her when he opens his door on Saturday morning and sees Steve Harrington on the other side. Steve looks prepared for whatever Billy has for him, but he holds up a brown bag like a peace offering.

“Never in a million fuckin’ years are you gonna get me to trust whatever you put in there,” Billy says, leaning against the doorway.

Steve sighs. “It’s from Robin, man. I’m a good cook, you know. Not a baker. Cooker.”

“It’s just called a cook, babe.”

“Jesus,” Steve says. “It’s snowing. May I please come in? It’s literally snowing.”

Billy glances out of the door. “Kinda looks like you’ve got cement over your head.”

“I swear I will throw these away.”

“Then we both suffer.”

“Dude. Please.”

Billy groans and steps aside. He shoves Steve in when he lingers so he can close the damn door. “Fuuuck,” Billy sighs. “I’m not going to that party, Stevie.”

Steve wanders into the kitchen and sets the bag down. “Sure. I mean, that’s your choice,” he says and opens the bag. He pulls out what looks like a tiny brown-creamish ball. “These are supposed to be cream your pants good.”

“What is it?” Billy asks and walks closer. He leans his hip on the counter and squints. “Those are pecans.”

“Super finely chopped pecans. She called them cheese balls.”

“Cheese balls.”

“You know. Magical, cream your pants cheese balls.”

Billy laughs. “She said you love everything she makes, man. Give it a try,” he says. “I don’t trust cheese balls.”

Steve holds it up before popping it into his mouth. It must be smooth, for the most part, and Billy watches Steve’s eyes flutter shut. He hits the counter with his fist a few times and Billy raises his eyebrows.

“You creamin’ your pants?”

“Fucking try it, man.”

“Hmm,” Billy hums skeptically. Steve grabs a second one before he can get his first and it’s pretty cold. Straight out of a refrigerator. Tiny bits of pecans are stuck to… yeah, cream cheese, now that Billy smells it.

It smells faintly sweet, but there’s a brownish tinge to the cream cheese that makes him think of cinnamon. Billy doesn’t know how to feel about that, but Steve’s obviously eating ambrosia, so he takes a bite.

Definitely cream cheese. Not cinnamon. Brown sugar. Powdered sugar, probably, to make the cream cheese sweeter. And there are a bunch of mini chocolate chips in it. Billy doesn’t trust it off the bat, but he should always trust Robin because that chick is right no matter how much he fights her.

It’s a pretty fucking good cheese ball.

They put the bag in the fridge after they realize they’ve eaten nearly half of them. Steve digs around in his pocket and slaps a note on the counter, bending over it.

“She told me I couldn’t read this until after we tried them,” Steve says. “Okay. So, it’s normally a… dip. A sweet dip. Pretzels, fruit, wafers. But she threw in some brown sugar to give it, uh, depth and made it bite-sized. Enjoy,” he adds as he reads Robin’s note, “and don’t eat them all at once because they’re super bad for you.”

Billy laughs and leans against the counter as he does. “Fuck, man. I swear this girl is trying to fatten me up for a ritualistic sacrifice,” he says and grins. “When I first met her, I never would’ve thought she could do anything but burn water.”

Steve grins at Billy. “Yeah. I mean, that wasn’t my first impression. She was a little scary and standoffish, actually. But that’s because she harbored anger toward me from school. Then I met the real Robin. Hoo,” he says. “She’s awesome. I think if her brain isn’t constantly moving with new ideas and all the… baking and cooking, she wouldn’t know what to do with herself.”

“I think you’re right,” Billy says. “She’s a fuckin’ handful, man. But when she’s cool, she’s really cool, huh? Convinced Vickie to go Christmas shopping, though.”

“Growing up like the rest of us. Work, romance,” Steve says. “I can buy beer legally now. She has her own car! Jesus, man. Almost two goddamn years and I had to drag her around Hawkins. Two years! And what does that thing do six months later?”

“Dies on the side of the road.”

“Dies on the side of the road. Just like I told her it would. She said I’d be bossy and mean if I went with her to the lot to pick something out,” Steve sighs. “And she came back with that thing. And now?”

“The Buick, man.”

“The damn Buick,” Steve mutters, glaring at the wall. “She wants to go camping in that thing for the fourth of July. Get away from the noise and parties. Camping. In the middle of the woods with the Buick that has huge, open windows everywhere.”

Billy rests his chin in his hand, smiling as he watches Steve. “You can cover ‘em, babe,” he says. “No one says you can’t.”

“I’d still know. Like, I’ll definitely still know we’re surrounded by glass in the middle of the woods.”

“You scared of the boogeyman, Stevie?”

Steve huffs. “Why shouldn’t I be? Do you know what’s out there?”

“Man, that’s your expertise.”

“Literally no one knows. And we don’t speak of it if we see it.”

“You serious?”

“Yeah, man,” Steve says. “You see something move that’s not normal or hear weird noises at night? Don’t say a damn word.”

Billy stares at him before he sighs. “So, it’s probably deer,” he says. “Deer come out at night most. Coyotes do too. Coyotes sound fuckin’ weird. You goddamn superstitious midwesterners,” he adds and opens the fridge to grab a beer. He hands one to Steve. “You should hear Max encouraging that shit.”

“Oh, buddy. Do I,” Steve laughs. “They haven’t caught on yet that she’s doing it on purpose, but she gets them going, doesn’t she? It’s true, anyway. So, I’m working up toward camping.”

“First, it’s a year with Vickie. Now half a year to get you in a sleeping bag in the woods.”

“Don’t make it sound worse.”

“Sitting in front of a bonfire was one of my favorite things,” Billy says. “They’re a good time and good at making you sleepy.”

They walk to the living room, sit on Billy’s couch, and Steve hums skeptically.

“Yeah, but you probably went home after a bonfire.”

“Dozed a lot and woke up with the sunrise,” Billy says, shrugging. He opens the beer and sips a bit of foam from the top of the can. “Risked waking up with a cop’s flashlight in your face. So, you could have it worse, Stevie.”

“Mhmm,” Steve hums. “Dragged off kicking and screaming, never to be seen again definitely sounds better.”

“Man, you sound like Robin.”

“I know,” Steve says, throwing up his arm. “I don’t believe this shit. My backyard is the woods. I just don’t like camping. I like toilets. But she gets me paranoid when she starts talking about it. I never cared before. I took a lot of girls to Lover’s Lake and Skull Rock in the middle of the night.”

Billy grins. “That make-out spot?”

Steve nods, pointing at Billy. “That’s the one. And I still don’t really have a problem with it. It’s when Robin starts going on and on and we’re already in the damn forest. Then a normal noise happens and she gets me freaked out.”

“I’m very much enjoying this picture, Stevie,” Billy laughs. “She’s scaring you on purpose. She doesn’t talk about any of that with me.”

“Yeah, well. I’m gullible or whatever,” Steve says, shrugging. “Except with the kids.”

“The fuckin’ kids,” Billy mutters. “When are you gonna settle down with one of those girls and have a few? You’re even good with ‘em during the terrible twos.”

“I dunno,” Steve says. “I’ve never actually lived with the terrible twos. Except Nance’s little sister, but not for long.” He shrugs. “I think I should probably find something better than the video store first.”

Billy knocks his knee against Steve’s. “You’re young, man. Date. Have fun,” he says. “Worry about income and houses later.”

Steve wrinkles his nose. “Yeeeah. Yeah, okay. But,” he says, raising his eyebrows, “I don’t want to just date.”

“Ahh. Steve Harrington is lookin’ to settle down.”

“It’d be nice, man. Getting laid is getting boring.”

“That ain’t right.”

“Nope,” Steve says. “It’d be nice to have more.”

Billy shakes his head. “Why are you having trouble? You’ve got Robin on your side. She’s a good wingman even if she never takes her own advice.”

Steve chuckles. “That’s definitely true,” he says and rubs the back of his neck. “I dunno. It’s different now that I want something serious. New territory, man. Robin tells me I’m looking for the wrong person, but she collects a bunch of queers. She’s even got some in Marion.”

“And they’re not the right type of people,” Billy says. His chest feels tight and uncomfortable and he’s not sure he likes how easily Steve throws out the word queer. He wears it proudly when he can, and obviously Steve’s trustworthy with Robin, but it still feels strange. “For you.”

“Apparently, a lot of girls like both. Did not know that until recently,” Steve says. “We don’t do that in Hawkins.”

“Most places don’t do that, Stevie,” Billy sighs. “You’d be surprised how freaky sex gets, man. Not just about what someone’s got down their pants.”

“No, no. I know. I mean, I’ve learned a lot. Robin took me to a party in Indianapolis that ended up having like a bondage thing. There’s a whole fucking world I didn’t know about.”

Billy cackles and slaps his knee. “Fuuuck. No way did she take you there.”

“I swear it, man,” Steve laughs. He grins and shakes his head. “Shock of my life. Not what I’m into, but… Jesus. Seriously. Jesus Christ.”

“Maybe you Indiana assholes like to have a real party now and then,” Billy says and waggles his eyebrows. “You’ll find your girl, man. Don’t worry about it so much.”

Steve shrugs. “Yeah. Except, I dunno if I will.”

“Fucking hell, Stevie. You will.”

“Maybe. I dunno.”

“I fuckin’ swear, man. I’m not gonna walk King Steve, the ladies’ man, through how to get a girl.”

“I know how to. Why do you think getting laid is boring? Because I’m getting laid!” Steve says, gesturing emphatically. “But it’s boring. That’s the point.”

Billy groans. “It won’t be boring when you’ve got the right person. Even I know that.”

Steve sighs. “Okay, look,” he says, holding up his hands. “What if it’s more than that?”

“Solving riddles isn’t my thing.”

“What if I like both?”

Billy grimaces. “Both what? Boring sex and no sex?”

Steve sighs again as he looks at Billy. He hops up and walks into the kitchen, coming back with the bag of cheese balls. He sits down and opens it, holding it in his lap, and Billy stares at him.

“What if I like both?”

“Both what, Harrington?” Billy asks. “Man, I’m gonna take those and throw ‘em at you.”

“We aren’t wasting Robin’s delights,” Steve says. He points at Billy. “Both.”

“Both,” Billy repeats dully. He stares at Steve as Steve’s eyebrows rise higher and higher on his forehead. Billy blinks and feels the floor drop out from underneath him. “Oh.”

Cold sweat, rapid heartbeat, primal fucking fear. Steve’s comfortable telling Billy this for a reason and the reason is likely Robin Buckley. But she knows not to tell people about him better than anyone and it’s a real good way to ruin a friendship if someone slips up.

Steve frowns and holds the bag closer to Billy. “Don’t get mad.”

“You aren’t gonna fuckin’ smooth things over with some goddamn cheese balls, Harrington!” Billy barks loudly enough for Steve to cringe. “What the fuck, man?”

“Hey. Just listen to me for a second,” Steve says. “Robin collects queers.”

“So, what?”

“You didn’t exclude yourself from that.”

“Do I have to spell out that my favorite pastime is making girls wet?”

“Jesus. No,” Steve says. “Still didn’t exclude yourself. And you become best friends with Robin, like, instantly. She collects queers.”

“Are you callin’ me a queer?”

“What the hell would that make me then?”

Both. Steve likes both. Guys and girls, and isn’t that a fucking trip? Billy doesn’t want to believe him because their past makes him defensive. He wants to believe Steve is lying so Billy will spill and it’ll make him the pariah Robin always fears.

But that was school and this is now. Robin does collect queers—as genuine friends and failsafes because they have to have them if they become pariahs. If they can even do that, which is difficult as hell, but not a bad idea to surround yourself with people who understand.

Who live the same way.

Steve Harrington being into guys is still trippy. And he knows Billy is, too, though he’s still suspicious Robin told Steve.

“So, you’re saying,” Billy says, “because Robin and I get along, it makes me queer. You and her got along the same because you like both. She collects queers. So that makes me one.”

Steve shrugs. “Does it?” he asks. “I didn’t ask her. I just thought about it.”

“Why’re you telling me?”

“Because I’m looking for the wrong person,” Steve says. “And sex isn’t interesting anymore. Not right now. I know a couple of other guys, but they’re… you know, they hide it really well. If I asked, they’d probably forget we used to jerk each other off in the supply closet at school. They love god, women, and making babies now.”

“Jesus fuckin’ Christ, man. What the hell do you need me for? To ask what?”

“Help,” Steve says. “Tips. Robin’s not that great with guys. Throw me out in the snow or whatever you want to do. We help Robin, so. Maybe you can help me.”

Billy stares at Steve before he yanks the bag out of his hand. He stuffs a cheese ball in his mouth and chews it moodily. “You could’ve fuckin’ asked for my advice without telling me you suspected or knew, Steve,” he says through a mouthful. “You gotta be careful. Now I’m gonna be paranoid for months.”

“I’m sorry. I’m very new to this. What, you think I’m gonna tell someone? Jesus, man, I like dudes, too. I don’t care that you know.”

“Liking dudes is what landed me in Hawkins.”

Steve blinks. “Wait, what? I thought it was the expelling thing.”

Billy shakes his head. “Nope,” he says. “Found a guy back home. Really liked him. We got found out and Neil packed us up and brought us here. Lost our entire lives because I wanted the wrong person. That’s the shit that happens when the wrong people find out you met the right person.”

He’s quiet for a while. “Fuck, man. I’m sorry,” Steve says. “That’s fucked. He’s a piece of shit.”

“Yeah, man. Welcome to my world.”

“I’d rather be your friend and hear what you have to say about, like… any of this. Good and bad. I’d rather do that than fucking tell anyone. I lose you and I lose Robin that way. No fucking way. That’s not me, Hargrove.”

Billy knows it’s not. He knows that’s true, but that won’t stop the paranoia. He’s angry, too, because he doesn’t want anyone else coming to the same conclusion. No one knows unless Robin trusts them with herself, but Billy supposes Steve might’ve cottoned on to that eventually.

Other people will too.

Most likely gays, but still.

“I know it’s not, Stevie,” Billy mutters. “It’s difficult. I ruined my whole family’s life. I’ve got plenty of tips, though. Learned a lot in California. We’ll go through the rundown next time, though.”

“Sure. No problem. I’m sorry. I am really sorry,” Steve says and stands. “Thanks for listening. I forgot why I was here.”

Billy smiles and glances up at Steve. “You don’t gotta leave, ascot boy. Sit your ass back down,” he says. “Still a big fat no to Joyce’s party.”

Steve sighs and slumps onto the couch. “Alright then. Guess I gotta convince you,” he says and claps his hands. “I’m slowly but surely learning what entices you.”

“Yeah?” Billy laughs. “What’s that?”

“Robin’s food, mainly. But being comfortable,” Steve says and smiles. “You like being comfortable.”

“Doesn’t everybody?”

“My comfort level doesn’t match yours,” Steve says. “And… no matter who is there, Joyce’s place is for comfort.”

Billy waves his hand. “Got uncomfortable memories there.”

“She rearranged the whole house. Upgraded a couple of things. It’s totally different,” Steve says. “You have to forgive yourself for that one, Billy.”

He blinks at Steve and frowns. He wants to say a lot of things to that—he never felt sorry, or he doesn’t have to forgive himself for anything or that Steve’s way off base. But it’s what Billy thinks about when he entertains the idea of going to Joyce’s.

“It’s not just you, man.”

“I know,” Steve says. “Believe me when I say that as soon as I declare you cool and Max affirms that, it’ll be forgotten. Promise.”

“You think it’s that easy?”

“I know it is.”

Billy shakes his head and looks at the blank wall across from the couch. He needs to get a TV, but he’s been enjoying the silence so much he’s in no rush. Hearing Neil blast a television all of his life makes Billy wonder if he’ll ever get anything but a stereo for a long time.

He looks at Steve. “What about everyone else?”

“I dunno. Kind of like any party, I think. Avoid or chat,” Steve says. “It’ll be fine. You’ll make Robin’s whole year.”

“What about yours?”

“You know what, Hargrove? Mine too.”

Billy smiles and shakes his head, handing the bag back to Steve. “Put these away before we eat more,” he says. “We need real food for lunch. You got any plans?”

“Nope. My objective was to get you to agree to the Christmas party no matter what.”

“Which you haven’t accomplished yet,” Billy says and stands. “You’re on thin ice, Stevie. You like pasta?”

“Oh, baby. I’m made of pasta as much as Robin is made of stars.”

Billy laughs and gestures for Steve to follow. “Good,” he says. “I wanna try somethin’ new. I could use your help.”

“You’re looking at the cooker right here.”

“Hmm. Never mind. Stay out of it and watch.”

Steve laughs. “Shut up and show me what you want to do.”

Billy does just that.

Following Robin’s tips and tricks, because the girl has a whole lot of them, Billy and Steve make spaghetti sauce and meatballs. She swears on adding some chorizo to the meatballs and breaking a few apart into the sauce. Not a big kick, but mildly spicy spaghetti is new and unusual to Steve.

Billy’s heard of dishes like it, but it still seems weird.

He thinks he could laugh for days watching Steve break a sweat mashing ground beef, chorizo, an egg, and spices with his bare hands. Easier, but Steve apparently doesn’t make meatballs, and Billy has to hand it to him.

There are a lot of them.

Parchment paper is a thing of beauty. They line the meatballs up on the largest counter space Billy has, which isn’t much, and look over their work with red-stained hands.

“Those look killer.”

“Hmm,” Billy hums. “You got a couple monsters there, Stevie.”

“Huh?” Steve says and looks at where Billy’s pointing. “Oh. Easy fix.”

Billy watches him do it and smiles after Steve claps his hands. “You earned a shiny A for effort, babe,” he says, looking at Steve. They’re pressed shoulder to shoulder. “Let’s hope they hold up in the oven.”

“I aimed for loose but not too loose. I think I got there,” Steve says. “My hands are gonna be red for a week.”

“Stop burnin’ so much rubber, man.”

“Jesus,” Steve mutters, but he’s laughing. “I keep forgetting how classy you are.”

“Aww, babe. No one’s got you beat. Not with the ascots and fine china with sugar spoons,” Billy says, grinning as he watches Steve look up at the ceiling. “Do they call ‘em tea cakes?”

“I do not know. Truly,” Steve says. “Jesus. My mom got into an English phase. Tea all the fucking time. The tea parties. The food. They went to London for three weeks and she was stuck for, like, six months. It’s all dinner parties otherwise.”

“What’s a dinner party like?”

Steve shrugs. “I dunno. Talking. Lots of talking. Lots of wine before, during, and after. Decorative tables. Classical music. They mostly talked about work and my dad mostly told me to keep my tie straight. It’s bogus, though. I stopped going to them the second my mom was comfortable blaming my social life, so I never even got to drink chiantis, cabernets, sweet rieslings, or port after dinner. I missed out.”

“Fuuuck, man. You missed out on an early death,” Billy says and grins after Steve chuckles. “You can buy port all on your own.”

“Yeugh. Have you ever tasted port?”

“Spit it out the second it hit my tongue.”

“Me too. The worst,” Steve says and shakes his head. “See, high society or whatever you want to call it? It’s all fake. No one likes anything about it. It’s popularity points. They’re all just as miserable as everyone else.”

Billy shrugs. “I believe that,” he says. “At least you got a nice house to stew in. Pretty car to impress people with.”

Steve smiles wryly. “That nice house was a lonely place with my parents gone every few weeks. Business trips or traveling the world. They figured I’d like to stay in Hawkins rather than see, I dunno, Rome,” he says. “Kinda blew, actually. I think the car was to make up for some of it. Like, past, present and future because they keep taking off and I have to watch our big, nice house again.”

He peers at Steve and recognizes the bitterness hidden behind humor. The dry twist of Steve’s lips. Wasn’t all sunshine and daisies for Steve Harrington, either, and Billy gets that.

Doesn’t feel like comparing apples to apples anymore.

Parents like to leave scars. Most of ‘em do, as far as Billy is concerned, and the rare ones like Robin’s parents create a kid that works magic. Changes people for the better with humor, a sweet smile, gentle advice or comfort, and many, many different foods.

Billy might call her an angel, but that’d offend her. She’s made of stars, after all, and from out of this world. He loves it when she calls herself spacey because that’s definitely not what it means, but that’s Robin’s language.

He looks at Steve and supposes they’re also learning each other’s languages. Suddenly, unexpectedly, but not so reluctantly.

“What kinda stuff did you do when you were alone? When you were a kid, I mean, before keggers came around,” Billy says. He asks because he’s curious, but he also wants to hear Steve talk.

Steve’s expressive, yeah, but when he gets to talking, his voice goes lower, and there’s less inflection unless you’re really listening. He’s open and honest, though, never a downer, always with something funny to say.

He’s got raw meat juice on his hands as he makes a strangling motion meant for one of the kids, but that probably fits.

Billy watches him, stomach tight with something unfamiliar beyond the fluttering he feels. Dangerous to feel it and not what Billy wants. But he keeps listening to Steve and pokes and prods with questions. Anything to keep him talking because it feels like some of the last few weeks of constant worrying are seeping off Billy’s shoulders.

They watch the meatballs cautiously and make sure the sauce is okay. It all takes a couple of hours and they’re starving by the time they clean up and sit with overloaded plates on the couch.

Steve is careful not to get sauce on anything, but the napkin tucked into his shirt is too much.

“Shut up. I’m gonna throw this meatball at you.”

“Do it, babe. I’ll take another.”

Steve shakes his head and stuffs a large bite in his mouth. “This is fucking amazing. I wish I knew how she gets it right every time.”

“It could be the fiftieth time when she finally hands us one of those brown bags.”

“Hmm,” Steve hums, narrowing his eyes. “True. And happy accidents. This is no happy accident, though. It’s tasty.”

“Tasty,” Billy agrees.

Too many cheese balls and meatballs and noodles, but Billy feels good. It’s warm in the apartment, and he’s enjoying food with a friend—never would’ve imagined it being Steve Harrington, but he remembers Steve saying something similar about him by Lover’s Lake.

It feels like a lifetime ago, but it really wasn’t.

“When did you know you liked both?” Billy asks after they’ve cleared their plates and are basking in digestion.

“Hmm?” Steve hums, sounding like he’s dozing. “Oh, uhh. I lied to myself about it for about six months in Freshman year. And, you know. Gym puts a lot of pressure on a kid. Started to accept it, but I thought it was wrong and whatever. Near the end of Sophomore year, I caught this kid looking at me. He was in my year, but I didn’t know him. I got to know him. A little.”

“Jerking each other off in the supply closet doesn’t leave a whole lot of room for talking,” Billy says with an amused smile. “Bet you didn’t talk outside of that.”

“Yup. We didn’t,” Steve sighs. “I know the risks, too, Billy. It lasted longer in the first few months of my Junior year with another guy. Then I saw Nance. Super cute, way smart, and I kind of wanted it more serious, I guess. Stupid high school brain serious, anyway, ‘cause I fucked that up. She deserved better and now she has better.”

“Sounds like you’re over it.”

“I mean. It’s been three years, so, yeah,” Steve chuckles. “There aren’t a lot of supply closets lying around Hawkins, so it’s mostly been girls. I figure I’ll click with one eventually, but broadening my horizons, as Robin puts it.”

“She’s not wrong. Better to have all the options,” Billy says. “Might have to go to Marion now and then.”

“Not looking forward to that again, honestly,” Steve sighs. “Did you do that?”

“What? Supply closets?” Billy asks. He grins after Steve nods. “Couple of times. Riskiest was my coach’s office during big games. No one was in the school. The office had a narrow window with blinds on it. The risk made it better.”

“Jesus Christ,” Steve laughs. “Seriously?”

Billy smiles. “Seriously, babe,” he says. “Stupid, but exciting for a kid with hot blood.”

Steve shakes his head. “California has this place beat a thousand times over,” he says dryly. “Was it San Francisco?”

“Nah, man,” Billy laughs. “Way north from me. Went there a few times, though. I was in San Diego. Not far from the border. San Francisco has a different atmosphere. Pretty cool, but not somewhere I’d wanna live. I just wanna be back on my beach.”

“You’ll get there,” Steve says. “You said in just a few years.”

“Two or three, yeah. Long time away,” Billy says. “I know I will. Miss it, though.”

“I don’t blame you. I mean… the beach, obviously. Volleyball. Surfing. Your Abuela’s garage and food. People you actually like. Guys,” Steve says and smiles. “I’d follow you if I knew anything about that kind of life.”

Billy shrugs. “Got the best to learn from, man. And since you hang out with my fuckin’ sister all the time,” he adds dryly, “you got more than one of us. You’d look good at the beach, Stevie.”

Steve rubs the back of his neck. “Yeah? You think so? I dunno. Like a fish out of water even if I’m in the water.”

“I like that image,” Billy says, smirking after Steve lightly shoves him. “You, me, and Robin, huh? Get us some tail while we’re there.”

“Vickie, too, if things work out. So, probably no tail for Robin.”

“Ahhh. Vickie. You ever talk to her?”

“Nope. Robin forbade it.”

“She did,” Billy mutters. “Not sure what we’ll have on our hands soon.”

Steve laughs. “I have a feeling we’re gonna have another friend, Hargrove,” he says. “Even if we have to drag you kicking and screaming along with us.”

“Hmm,” Billy hums, displeased. “We’ll see about that.”

“Mhmm,” Steve hums back, patting Billy’s knee. He gets up with some trouble and grabs their plates, taking them into the kitchen. “Time for some cheese balls?”

“Don’t ever fuckin’ talk to me about those again.”

Steve chuckles. “Thought so,” he says and rinses the plates off. He washes his hands and walks into the living room. “I should probably go before it starts coming down any harder. I’m sure Robin will see you tomorrow. Thanks for letting me stay over.”

“Anytime, babe,” Billy says and stands. He stretches and follows Steve to the door. He opens it to glance outside while Steve puts on his shoes, and whistles. “Good luck.”

“Don’t say that, man,” Steve mutters. He grabs his coat and yanks it on, looking at Billy. “Well. Robin will let you know if I die too.”

Billy winks and squeezes Steve’s side. “It’s the ice that’ll get you, from my understanding.”

“Sneaks up on you when you least expect it.”

“Kinda like those creatures in the forest.”

Steve shakes his head and sighs after Billy snickers. “See you at Joyce’s party.”

“Keep dreaming.”

He walks outside and down the stairs very carefully. Steve glances back at Billy through a sheet of heavy snowfall and grins. “Robin’s not the only one that makes magic happen. Remember that.”

Billy wiggles his fingers until Steve gets downstairs. He watches him get in his car before he shuts the door and rubs his hands together. Steve has already mostly cleaned the dishes, but Billy finishes them and crawls under a thick blanket on the couch with a book.

He stares at the words for a while, then sighs and looks at the ceiling.

Thinking about inviting Steve to stay all night just like Robin had only spells trouble.

But now that Billy knows a lot more about Steve than he ever imagined, he thinks it’s gonna stick. It doesn’t help the stomach issue or the way his heart pounds, but slowly and surely, the thought that Steve Harrington is into guys settles in Billy’s blood.

He doesn’t like the way it burns.

Robin is at work or else Billy would call to complain. But what could he say? Steve likes guys and it’s got him burning up?

Not in a million fucking years.

——

On Wednesday, after Robin sends Billy home with pumpkin muffins—no chocolate chips—Billy walks through the door and sees Max sitting on the couch.

She scares the shit out of him, honestly, and Billy nearly drops the bag and his keys. But he can see she’s upset, so he sighs and locks the door. Billy walks to her and hands her the bag.

“Gimme a sec.”

He’s not sitting on his couch while his clothes have grease and grime covering them.

Billy slumps next to her after changing and watches her peel off small bites of a muffin. “What happened?”

“Nothing,” Max mutters. “Not to me.”

“Susan?” Billy asks quietly. He’s already starting to see red and a flare of anger roars up in his chest.

Max sighs. “He screamed at her for hours today,” she says. “I hate break. I don’t know why he takes two weeks off. Just to torment us while we’re home more, I think.”

“Probably exactly it, kiddo. Why’s he screaming at her?”

“Mom,” Max says slowly and grimaces, “accepted Joyce’s invitation to her Christmas Eve party.”

Billy blinks at her before he sighs and tips his head back against the couch. “Without his permission.”

“Yup,” Max says. “She’s still going to cook on Christmas and whatever. They go out with friends. It’d look good to keep up appearances. But I think he knows that, like, all the good people will be there. Along with Mom not asking permission. I’m already going. And I don’t know. I don’t know why it took me so long to think about it, but I came out of my room and asked if it was about Joyce’s party. Like I hadn’t just heard them yelling about it. Anyway, I told him I told Joyce we were already going.”

Billy grimaces. “How’d that go over?”

“Not too great. But, like, he shut up. Said some nasty stuff and locked himself in the bedroom,” Max says. “But if he decides to keep up appearances or whatever, he’ll be there.”

“Nah. He won’t.”

“How do you know?” Max asks, looking at Billy.

She doesn’t ask with the usual defensiveness or the tone that suggests he’s an idiot. Maybe because Billy knows more about Neil, but she’s also been dealing with him for six years.

“Too many eyes. Someone might catch him looking at her wrong. He’s always looking for mistakes, but you made this one,” Billy says. He smiles a little after Max’s shoulders slump. “You would’ve already known how bad it was if it was gonna be bad. Neil isn’t into the party shit. Just convince your mom to stick to her word.”

“But so many things could still go wrong.”

“Yeah,” Billy says. “I’d worry more about Christmas day.”

“Gee. Thanks.”

“I’m not there anymore to make it as fucked as it’s been, Max.”

“He complains about you literally all the time. Especially over dinner.”

“Misses me.”

Max rolls her eyes, but she’s smiling. “Yeah, well. I’m gonna come here if it goes bad.”

“Don’t threaten me with exactly what I told you you could do.”

She laughs and wipes her nose. “Okay. Fine. I just hope I didn’t get Mom in more trouble.”

Billy squints a little. “I don’t think you did,” he says. “Besides. Chief’s gonna be there.”

“So?”

“Neil’s on his best behavior around El for a reason. And you two have him on his toes, huh? He knows it’d be worse with Hopper.”

“Hmm,” Max hums. “I guess so. I hope so. Kinda wish you were there. Not at the house!” she adds hurriedly. “Just, you know.”

“The fuckin’ Christmas party?”

Max shrugs, looking at her knees, and Billy stares at her. He sighs and looks at the ceiling—if Billy thought the decision would be made for him, it’d be by Robin. He has no idea why Max wants him there, but it’s been decided.

One peaceful Christmas was all Billy asked for and he can’t even get that.

“Maybe I’ll come down the chimney.”

Max snorts and laughs. “You’d definitely be the Grinch,” she says and grins after Billy tugs on her braid. “Thanks, Billy.”

“Uh-huh. Stop touching my shit, man.”

“You thought I drank your beer, huh?”

“I knew you were fuckin’ around.”

“Sure. I bet you did.”

“Almost gave me a heart attack.”

Max laughs. “Don’t worry. I’ll wait until I’m fourteen like you did,” she says and hops off the couch. “Okay. I’m going to the house, but Hopper is picking me up in an hour, so it should be okay.”

“Should be. Don’t have too much fun.”

“Yeah, never,” Max says, smiling. She runs to the door and grabs her backpack before glancing back to wave at Billy.

He watches her leave and sighs. “Fuuuck,” Billy mutters and drags himself off the couch. He grabs the phone off the kitchen counter and dials Robin’s number. “Hey, Missus Buckley. Is Robin home? Yeah, she gave ‘em to me this morning. …yeah, I know the difference between cinnamon and nutmeg. Huh? Glad she tossed ‘em then. No, you are getting better, Mom. Nutmeg starts burning if you have too much of it. I know because Robin accidentally put one of your nutmeg cookies in with the cream cheese ones and I almost died.”

There’s some rustling before Billy hears Robin’s groan.

“Oh my god, Mother. Stop asking everyone about the nutmeg! I told you already. Billy doesn’t know up from down.”

“Thanks, man.”

“Forgive her,” Robin says. “She is from the opposite end of space.”

Billy laughs. “Yeah, man. She is,” he says. “Max was here when I got home half an hour ago.”

Robin hums with concern. “Yeah?” she asks. “What happened?”

“Neil,” Billy mutters. “Guess Joyce invited Susan to the party. And him. Susan said yes before asking and you know how that shit goes. Anyway, Max said she wished I was gonna be there.”

“Ohh,” Robin says and there’s a smile in her voice. “We should celebrate Christmas by burying Neil alive in the middle of the woods. Steve is the perfect lookout. But I suppose that means you’re coming to the Christmas party.”

Billy sighs and rubs the bridge of his nose. “Yeah. Got no fuckin’ choice now,” he says. “You have to dismember the body, so animals lick the bones clean.”

“Oh, horrible. Awful image. Let’s do it,” Robin says. “I’m glad you’re coming, boo. Steve got you halfway there and Max clinched it.”

“Harrington didn’t get me halfway anywhere.”

“Oh, uh-huh. Totally. I mean, you just made my spicy spaghetti together and ate my cheese balls. Bonded for hours. Steve literally told you he’s been gay the whole time.”

“Jesus fuckin’ Christ, man. I almost lost my shit.”

“Yeah, he told me. Thought you were going to dismember him. But believe it or not, honey, I didn’t say a word about it. He dropped that bomb on me too.”

“He’s bad at this.”

“So bad. But you bonded. Got you halfway there.”

Billy sighs and looks at the ceiling. “Cheese balls did a little somethin’ too.”

“Everyone loves my balls. Don’t you forget it.”

He rests his chin in his hand and smiles. “Never will, sugar. What do I gotta wear to this party?”

“That grey sweater I bought you because you were sorely lacking in sweaters.”

“I don’t like sweaters. Doesn’t feel natural.”

Robin chuckles. “Trust me on this one, honey.”

“Fuuuck.”

Notes:

Boys.

I'd love to hear from you! 💜