Actions

Work Header

when stars come falling from the sky

Chapter 4

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

Christmas Eve sneaks up on Billy and bites him on the ass.

It’s ugly outside. Dark and foreboding with slow-moving grey clouds getting ready to make it a white Christmas. It’s one of the coldest days of December so far and Billy is not in a good mood.

He’s been busy at work because cars break down at the height of summer and winter, and Billy has two precious days off. Today and tomorrow, and that’s it. That’s all he gets and he stupidly agreed to go to a party this evening. At a house with bad memories, filled with people with even worse histories, and Billy has to face Susan.

Not that that’s a hardship, but he hasn’t spoken to her or Neil since he bailed.

Billy is already nervous and it’s barely six-thirty in the morning. The phone rings when he’s staring at the counter in the kitchen with a half-finished mug of hot coffee, and Billy might fly into a rage if he didn’t know it was Robin.

“It’s not even seven.”

“And yet, you are wide awake.”

“What do you want?”

“Come over.”

“You fuckin’ kidding me?”

“Uhh, no? I’m serious. Come over.”

“Is Steve there?”

“Oh, honey. Steve’s way meaner than you’ve ever tried to be if you wake him up before his alarm clock.”

Billy sighs and rubs his eyes. “Yeah, fine. Whatever. What am I coming over for?”

“Oh, you’ll see.”

“You know I don’t like surprises, man.”

“I hand you a bag of surprises literally every time I see you and you like them plenty. I’ll come pick you up if you don’t want to drive.”

“No fuckin’ way,” Billy says firmly. “You keep that Buick parked. I’ll be there in fifteen, man.”

“Love ya so much, boo.”

Billy hangs up on her. “Love you too,” he mutters before downing the rest of his coffee. He packs on layers in his bedroom and tidies his hair until he’s satisfied being in public with it.

Robin lives by the mall, and the roads are salted, but Billy is in a sour mood. He’s going to obsess about the Christmas party so much that no one will want him there. Maybe he should do it on purpose and get out of it because Max will be fine without him.

He blasts hard rock and doesn’t care about the hour.

Billy nearly slips on the walk to Robin’s front door, which doesn’t make him feel any better. He doesn’t have to knock because it swings open and Billy raises his eyebrows at Robin in vividly red pajamas with Christmas trees on them. She laughs after he grimaces and tugs him inside.

It’s warm and smells like coffee and cinnamon. Mister Buckley grunts at Billy from the living room, his usual form of communication, and Missus Buckley is buzzing around the kitchen.

“Are those cinnamon rolls?” Billy asks.

“I am making the best cinnamon rolls you’ll ever taste,” Robin promises. “The icing is staying warm on the stove.”

Billy walks over to inspect it and smiles at Carrie as she plants a kiss on his cheek. “Morning, Mom,” he says and peers down at a pot loaded with smooth icing. “It’s got orange peel in it.”

“And two orange slices,” Robin says and squeezes Billy around the middle from behind. She drops her chin on his shoulder. “You’re gonna be blown away.”

“I don’t know where she gets these ideas,” Carrie says, adjusting her large, round-framed glasses that make her eyes look two sizes too big. “She said it’s not unheard of, but it’s unheard of to me.”

“I’ve never heard of orange cinnamon rolls,” Billy says. “They from your tree?”

“Do you have to ask? Course they are,” Carrie laughs. “One of the few less exotic things we grow out there.”

“Uuugh,” Robin groans. “Eggplants and turnips are not exotic, Mom. I’ve told you a thousand times.”

Carrie holds out her hands, shrugging. Her wild ash-blonde hair is even frizzier than usual. “But who makes them grow? Who makes them grow so well, huh?”

“Got a green thumb, Mom,” Billy says. “You’ve both got the magic touch.”

“Look at you being a mediator,” Robin says as she pulls away and twirls around. “Those babies smell ready.”

It does smell good if a little sweet. A lot sweet. And there are fucking Christmas decorations everywhere—on every goddamn surface. Not a single inch outside has Christmas lights because they put everything inside.

Just the way the Buckleys are. Billy didn’t know what to do with himself the first few times he was here—he didn’t want to come in and meet the parents and pretend they were a couple. But best friends apparently fly in this household, Robin’s mother is pretty awesome, and it feels like escaping the harsh reality of the real world.

Carrie told him to call her Mom his third time over, and Billy cried about it when he got home, but no one has to know that.

She loves Steve just as much, but she calls Billy special, which Steve apparently doesn’t have the honor of. Billy wears it proudly.

Mister Buckley, or David, works the graveyard shift, so if he’s not working or sleeping, he generally doesn’t care about what’s happening. Laughs with his wife like a pair of maniacal evildoers before he goes back to grunting and Billy marvels over it every time.

They’re not entirely normal, but they’re good people.

Maybe they are normal and trying to be that is where everyone else gets into trouble.

The cinnamon rolls are massive, and Robin has a giant gravy boat filled with orange-tinged icing for them, as hot and steaming as the cinnamon rolls. They’ll probably kill Billy, and he thinks it might be sooner than expected as he watches David pour enough on until there’s no roll left.

After David takes his plate to the living room, Robin and her mom snicker. They’re chatterboxes, but something about early morning on Christmas Eve makes it softer. Or they’ve got their mouths full.

Probably both.

The cinnamon roll is sickly sweet, but the orange zest and a squeeze of juice help curb it a bit. It’s really good, something that seems right for today, but Billy hopes Robin doesn’t make them again until next Christmas.

Coffee, gardening, cooking, town gossip of the strange variety, and a whole lot of laughs. That’s usually found at the Buckley table, but Billy feels less like he has to keep his guard up. Not because of Robin or Carrie, but any time Billy steps into someone else’s home, he’s always had his guard up. Plastering on a grin, charm, politeness, all while it ached and burned and felt wrong.

Billy still does it to get his way, but that’s different than being in someone’s home for something personal. All his friends back home—their parents liked him, too, until Neil came around and talked too much or hit Billy too hard and rage and soul-tearingly deep anguish seeped out.

They liked him until they heard about his growing reputation and didn’t want his influence on their kids like they weren’t doing the same shit Billy was. But he had the fucked up family, so it was easy to pin it on him.

Billy has carried that his whole life.

Meeting someone out of this world who chipped away at his defenses and planted a garden was the only way he could get out. The garden has thorns surrounding it, but it’s easier to breathe, to traverse and let people in as much as he lets people see what grows.

Robin has been doing her work on him, and it’s been for good. Billy can sit at this table and be himself—honesty, raunchy, a scoundrel, funny, charismatic, and a little bit vulnerable.

Carrie—Mom—thinks Billy is hilarious, and most times, Robin shakes her head and looks over it hearing them cackle together, but that’s what she gets going around improving lives.

Still, there’s vulnerability here, and Billy talks about his mother, Susan, Max, sometimes Neil. Not too much, but some, and Carrie looks at him with her big blue eyes and sweet smile, and it makes Billy immensely uncomfortable, but maybe a bit loved too.

“What’s something you’ve always wanted for Christmas?”

“My two front teeth.”

“What’s the second something?”

Billy smiles and shrugs. “I never gave it much thought,” he says. “Too worried about everything else. Presents ended a couple of years before my mom hitched a ride outta my life. Can’t even remember what they were.”

“So, maybe we don’t get you something you might’ve wanted then,” Mom says and winks owlishly at Robin, who chuckles. “What about now?”

“Brand new Camaro.”

“Don’t say that,” Robin mutters and sips on coffee. “She might do it with all the money we don’t have.”

“Cars aren’t presents, my dear,” Carrie sighs. “You boys buy them for yourselves. Not a thing?”

“Not a thing,” Billy laughs. “I’m good. Got everything I need.”

“Hmm,” Carrie hums, as displeased as Robin always sounds. “I’ll think of something.”

Robin laughs. “Well, while you’re doing that, Mother dearest,” she says, grinning at Billy. “I’m gonna give him mine.”

Billy holds out his hands. “Are we doin’ presents? Since when? I told you no fuckin’ way,” he says. “I didn’t get you anything.”

“You see how he is when you try to be nice?” Robin complains. She stands up and walks around the table, grabbing Billy’s hand and pulling him. “C’mon, Hargrove! Work with me! Down the hall!”

“Fuuuck,” Billy complains and stands. “Thanks for the coffee, Mom.”

“Anytime, sugar plum.”

Billy lets Robin drag him down the halls of the house to her room. It’s very purple but definitely pleasant, and she put the stars back on her ceiling. It’s kind of bare otherwise—a messy desk, a plain dresser, dark plaid comforter on her bed. But Billy has seen the mess of her drawers and closet and thinks it’d make him jittery to see it again.

Fortunately, he is full of fat and sugar, so he sits on her bed and watches Robin open the back of her closet just a bit. She peers at him as if she’s gauging how he’ll react and Billy grimaces.

“You buy me a few more sweaters and long johns?”

“You could so use the long johns. I’ve seen your lips go blue. Genuinely scared me to death,” Robin says. She points at him. “You have to wear this. But only once. Well… twice.”

Billy leans back on his hands, raising his eyebrows. “Yeah?” he asks dully. “You pull out a Santa outfit and I’m burning it in the fireplace, man.”

Robin laughs. “While that would be a very amusing sight,” she says, smiling, “not quite.”

She pulls out a long white… thing. It looks silky with pointed ends, and Billy isn’t sure what he’s looking at until he recognizes Hawkins High’s green in a thin stripe around the whole thing.

“Is that a fuckin’ sash?”

Robin tosses it over herself and smooths it down. “It’s an honors sash, honey,” she says. “Should look super familiar.”

Billy smiles blandly. “Sure fuckin’ does,” he says. “Where’d you even get that?”

She shrugs and sits down next to him, pulling it off and holding it gently in her lap. “You have to promise not to think I’m weird for this,” Robin says. “Okay?”

“Babe, you’re way past weird.”

“William.”

“Oh, no. Not William.”

“Yes, William. Shut your mouth.”

Billy mimes zipping his lips and Robin nods gracefully.

“So,” she says. “I was, of course, there to cheer dingus on for graduation. And some other friends. And we all knew these meant honors. Hargrove, William. More than half the school erupts in cheers and the other half is dead silent. Your smug ass strutted across that stage with one of these on. Surprise of the century and only because our teachers cared more about your education than your stupid, silly little game with popularity.”

Billy sighs as he stares at her. “Uh-huh. I remember it pretty well,” he says. “Hard to pick everyone out, but Steve’s got the hair. I saw his face and, sugar, that made my whole night.”

Robin chuckles. “Oh, I know. I very much do,” she says. She runs the material through her fingers. “Why didn’t you keep yours?”

“The robe? That thing?” Billy asks and shrugs. “Neil, man. It would've been ruined if I came into the house with accomplishments, let alone good ones. Kept that shit to myself because I was eighteen. Threw it in the trash outside of the gym.”

“Mhmm,” Robin hums. “I know you did. I saw you do it. I thought… he can’t just throw that away. Not after working his ass off for it in secret somehow. Can’t discard the evidence.”

Billy stares at her, then the sash. “Are you saying that’s the one I wore?” he asks. “No fuckin’ way.”

“Steve thought I was literally insane. But I dunno. I had to have it. It just felt wrong to see it go when someone’s blood, sweat and tears made it,” Robin says. “I forgot it was stuffed away until we became friends. Really, until you told me about how you kept your grades up. Then I remembered.”

“You dug it out of the trash and kept it?”

“It was sitting on top of the trash, okay? I’m not a raccoon. I have standards. But yes, I kept it,” Robin says loftily. “And I’ve put lots of TLC into this because it got super stained in those short few minutes in that lone trash can. Good as new. I’m not sure if you saw it or not, but they put your initials on the back.” She grabs the end and flips it over, pointing. “Faded now, but you can still see them.”

Billy remembers seeing them the day they gave it to him. He held that thing in his hands in the bathroom for thirty minutes and tried not to cry. A little sash didn’t mean anything in the grand scheme of life and he hated himself for a few minutes. That he was proud, that he’d done it when no one thought he could—but it wouldn’t matter at home.

So, Billy wore it proudly and ditched it immediately after.

The idea that Robin and Steve saw him do it while he didn’t notice them is strange. It’s a weird pit in Billy’s stomach and he doesn’t know how to describe it. Robin holds it up, and Billy takes it, running his fingers along it.

There’s proof of his hard work and growing up in a lot of corners of Hawkins if Billy takes the time to look around.

He smiles and glances at Robin. She’s wringing her hands and seems nervous, so Billy throws his arm around her shoulders and plants a kiss on the side of her head.

“Out of this world, babe. Love you more every minute for it.”

“Aww,” Robin chuckles and snakes her arms around Billy’s waist. “Love you too, boo. You don’t have to wear it. I just ask that you keep it for a while.”

“Think I will,” Billy mutters and squeezes his eyes shut. “Thanks, Robin.”

“Mhmm.”

They stay like that for a long time. Voices down the hall catch their attention because it’s Carrie and someone else that’s definitely not David because that guy’s voice could shake mountains if he used it.

“Oh, no,” Robin says. “Oh, my.”

“—swear I have enough. Swear it on my life. Yes. Thank you. Thank you very much. Okay, bye-bye—”

They watch Steve nearly stumble into the room because he used his elbow for the door, and he’s holding a plate with a massive, steaming cinnamon roll and a coffee mug hanging on for dear life.

Billy glances at Robin, and she shrugs, holding up her hands as if to say, you thought he wouldn’t be here?

“Aww, man!” Steve says once he sets the mug down. “You gave him the sash! I didn’t think you’d ever do it.”

“You’re ruining the moment, dingus. Christmas was a perfect choice.”

“Kinda was,” Billy says and pulls the sash on. “I’m gonna go to that party and wear this. Knock the socks off Missus Wheeler.”

“Gross. Truly. Disgusting.”

“Karen?” Steve laughs as he sits on the floor. He looks tickled pink by the giant cinnamon roll and starts cutting into it. “Why Karen?”

Robin shakes her head. “We keep this from you to protect you, Steve. Your poor, little, virgin baby ears can’t hear it.”

“Can’t, man,” Billy agrees. “We want you to grow up without pain.”

Steve sighs and shakes his head, looking at the ceiling. “Alright, fine,” he mutters and stuffs a bit in his mouth. “I’ll ask Nance.”

Robin laughs. “Oh, lover boy. That’d just lead you down a dead end.”

“The Wheeler boy doesn’t know it either.”

“What the fuck is happening? Merry Christmas, by the way. Can’t even say Merry Christmas Eve before the insults start rolling in,” Steve complains. “I wore my best pajamas, man.”

Billy tilts his head as he looks Steve over. “Diggin’ the snowflakes, man. Real cute,” he says and grins. “Robin didn’t tell me there would be a pajama party.”

Steve shrugs. “Well, yeah,” he says and smiles at Billy. “You wouldn’t have come. But the honors sash isn’t that bad.”

“It’s something,” Robin agrees.

“This is what I’m gonna use when I commit murder.”

“It has your initials on it, honey.”

“I might feel a little bad about it.”

Robin and Steve laugh.

Billy watches them start chatting excitedly about cheer and snow and whatever Joyce’s party has that nowhere else does. Comfort, Steve said, but Billy isn’t entirely sure what that means.

He mostly watches Steve talk and put down a cinnamon roll in his blue Christmas pajamas. That stomach thing Billy gets kind of feels like the pit Robin made him feel. Not quite the same way, but it’s strange. A pit is usually gaping wide and filled with nothing, but that’s not how Billy feels.

Billy doesn’t know what he feels beyond good. Because he does feel that—complete in a way no one else has made him feel. But Robin and Steve’s versions are still different and they make him feel weighed down.

He’s felt weighed down his entire life, but it’s not the same.

Weight.

Not a gaping pit.

Hefty weight of something new and unusual to Billy, sitting in his gut like an ever-present thing that doesn’t seem to leave anymore. Carrying the weight of someone’s love.

Or someone’s heart. Billy’s heard that said somewhere, but he couldn’t remember if you asked, and they might’ve meant it differently than it feels.

Billy already went through something when he realized Robin was a genuine friend. It was a bit of an emotional upheaval and realizing he likes Steve Harrington has been one too.

Just in incredibly opposite ways.

Robin hangs on or leans against Billy as she chats with Steve, and Billy watches him and thinks it’s… fuck, it’s different.

Yeah, Steve made him burn up once already, but Billy doesn’t want that. The shock of finding out shot his mind to exactly one place, but Billy isn’t thinking of that now as he watches Steve hold his chest and laugh with Robin, nearly wheezing.

Billy misses what’s funny, but he doesn’t mind.

Maybe the party won’t be so bad with these two assholes.

Robin leaves after a while to start the beginning of a dish she’s going to take to Joyce’s. She’s afraid it’ll be a miss because there’s a lot more pressure, but Steve and Billy are sure she’ll be fine if Carrie stays out of her way or doesn’t touch the nutmeg.

Steve hops up and collapses back on the bed at Billy’s side. “I swear they only know how to do extra large in this house. Four batches of muffins, eighty cookies, massive cinnamon rolls. Cheese balls in scores,” he sighs. “That thing is gonna keep me going until four.”

Billy chuckles. “Sounds about right,” he says. “You usually come over on Christmas Eve?”

“Yeah,” Steve sighs. “Third year now.” He yawns and scrubs his eyes before resting his hands behind his head. “Glad to see you here, man. She’s been talking about it for two weeks.”

He looks away and smiles. “Always the life of the party, babe,” Billy says and lies on his back next to Steve. They stare up at the stars on the ceiling. “No pajamas, though.”

“Well, yeah. I mean. It would’ve been over before it started if she asked,” Steve says. “Still gotta watch our moves. Plan every step carefully. Plan Bs and Cs if shit goes wrong.”

Billy rolls his eyes. “Make it sound like I’m a time bomb, man.”

“I didn’t say it.”

“Ahh, fuck off,” Billy says and smiles after Steve chuckles. “I was gonna say no to all of this and it isn’t either of you two who get to claim credit.”

“Oh? Who then?”

“Maxine.”

“Max asked you to be there?”

“She said she wished I was. So, I didn’t have a choice anymore.”

“Hmm. Is she okay?”

“Same shit, different day. She’s fine, Mama Bear,” Billy says. “She knows I got her back.”

Steve smiles and glances at Billy. “Yeah, she does,” he says. “Selfishly, I’m still kinda glad she convinced you.”

“Yeah?” Billy laughs and looks at Steve. “Still making your whole year?”

“You know it, baby.”

“So, are we talkin’ this last year? ‘Cause there aren’t many days left. Or is this gonna be rolling into the new year?”

“...hmm. How about both? Not many days left. Could go either way. So, both.”

“Alright. I like that idea. Any time you guys get mad at me, I get to remind you I already made your whole year.”

“I take it back.”

“Too fuckin’ late.”

“Yeah, well, smarty-pants. We’ll see about that.”

Billy laughs. “Smarty-pants, huh?”

“You’re wearing the honors sash,” Steve says, gesturing at Billy. “One of the mysteries of the universe.”

“Robin never told you?”

“Uhh. Nope. Wait, did you buy it or something?”

“Hmm,” Billy hums, displeased. “This is why they call me smarty-pants, Stevie.”

Steve smacks Billy’s arm. “You know what kinda smarts I’ll have forever that you won’t?”

“The ignorance is bliss kind?”

“Hilarious. You’re hilarious,” Steve sighs. “I’ve got people smarts. Customer service smarts.”

Billy looks at Steve, raising an eyebrow. “Pretty sure those are the lowest of the low, babe.”

Steve waves his hands. “No, no. No! Jesus. Lowest of the low,” he mutters. He scoots closer under they’re shoulder to shoulder and holds up his hands. “You’re not thinking about it. Not big enough. This is what Robin and I come up with when we’re bored out of our minds at work. But, what if, like… every single lowest of the low disappeared? Every single cashier behind every single register for everything.”

“I think I’m gettin’ what you’re cookin’ up.”

“See. Just imagine it. No more rented movies. No more groceries. Literally, no food. No household shit, no gas, no new cars, no bus or train or subway tickets… no flights. Just. Gonezo. What do you think would happen?”

Billy squints. “Complete anarchy,” he says. “Or the collapse of civilization as we know it.”

“Boom, baby!” Steve says, clapping his hands together. “So, you know. If you wanna look me in the eye and call me the lowest of the low again, you can do that. But I know. Hoo, I know. Something you’ve never even thought of ‘cause the lady bagging your groceries or the dude filling up your tank might have it easier, right? Trust me. They know what would happen too.”

Billy smiles as he looks at the stars on the ceiling, then Steve. “Gotta hand it to you, Steve. That’s not somethin’ I ever thought about, but you’re right. You keep civilization going at Family Video.”

“Damn right,” Steve says, smiling. “I have something for you too.”

“Ahh, fuck. Don’t say that. I didn’t know we were doing the presents thing. That stopped years ago.”

“Perfect time to start up again,” Steve says, reaching into his pajama pocket. He pulls out something small until Billy reluctantly holds his hand under Steve’s.

He drops it in Billy’s hand, and Billy looks at it, squinting and turning it over in his hands.

It’s a rock. Weirdly smooth on one side and more jagged on the other. It’s pretty, Billy supposes. For a rock. Slate grey with white veins running through it.

“Hmm. Is this a magic rock?”

Steve chuckles. “No. Maybe. Who knows? I was collecting rocks and it stood out. Made me think of you for some reason. What better way to give the cheapest gift possible, so you don’t gotta be uncomfortable.”

That stomach thing is back and Billy really could do without it. His heart is pounding for no good reason because it’s a goddamn rock.

“I’ll cherish it until my dying day,” Billy says and laughs after Steve grins. “You collect rocks, Stevie? Never took you for the type.”

“I am absolutely not. The kids had a science project or whatever. Behind the school, in those woods back there. Mister Clarke wanted a chaperone and who did they fucking volunteer? Me. On my day off. Collect rocks but, like, rocks that stood out, especially dark or light ones. I kinda just grabbed whatever and threw pebbles at Dustin’s back until he lost his shit.”

Billy laughs, holding his stomach. “Jesus fuckin’ Christ, Stevie. They got you wrapped around their fingers. It doesn’t help that you keep saying yes to everything.”

“Shut up. No, no. I totally don’t. I put my foot down. I tell them I’ve got bills to pay these days and I’m not at their beck and call. I’ve got a social life with actual adults.”

“How’d that go over?”

“They laughed. Sure, Steve, and rolled eyes everywhere. I dunno. Told them I was serious, and they kept giggling, so I went home and almost threw the radio in the trash.”

“Robin would’ve dug it back out.”

Steve laughs and knocks his elbow against Billy’s. “Yeah, well. Probably. Man, that was so weird. We were sitting in my car and there you were, stomping to the trash and ripping that thing off. I thought she was insane when she leaped out and grabbed it. Or that maybe she wanted the material for her mom or something. Then we both forgot about it until you came around. She’s been meticulously cleaning it back to its shiny old self.”

Billy watches Steve as he speaks and rolls the rock in his hand. “That is more than fuckin’ weird. Kinda glad she did, though. I look good in it, right?” he asks and flicks the end of one side.

“Yeah, man. You totally do. I think white fits you.”

“Yeah? Think I should wear an all-white suit with one of those silky shirts that have designs on ‘em?”

“That look is specifically reserved for fat, bald guys with golden chains around their necks, spotty facial hair, and cigars hanging out of their mouths.”

“Think you just described half the population at the derbies.”

Steve chuckles and looks at Billy. “It’s just not you, man. You seem to know what to wear to look good anyway.”

“Have you been checkin’ me out, ascot boy?”

“Maybe. It’s difficult not to until you open your mouth.”

“That hurts my feelings, sweetheart. I thought I made you laugh.”

“There are pros and cons to everything.”

Billy smiles and shakes his head. “You’re gonna see at this Christmas party drinkin’ spiked eggnog, chatting with Missus Wheeler, harassing Max to embarrass her, and probably getting into a brawl with Hopper,” he says. “I’m gonna be irresistible.”

“Yeah, mhmm. All of that is gonna get me hot under the collar. Definitely, especially brawling with the police chief.”

“He only wrote me a ticket one time. I was hot, man. Steam was about to come out of my ears. Then I looked at it and it was just a piece of paper that said grow the fuck up.”

“Jesus,” Steve laughs. “See, he knows you. He’s just looking out for you.”

“That’s my point. Everybody likes me, Stevie. Some of ‘em even get hot under the collar.”

Steve hums. “Yeah, I suppose so. What if it’s a lot more than hot under the collar?”

Billy bites his lip as his heart starts thundering. The weight in his stomach shifts a bit.

“What kinda more?”

They look at each other and Billy thinks he might actually die. Fuck, this has been too easy with other people, but he feels a little sick, and his heart is pounding so hard it hurts. Steve Harrington would cause a heart attack and Billy wouldn’t even blame him.

“Okay, so,” Robin says, pushing the door open. “The mad science has begun. Look at you two, daydreaming.”

They’ve already moved away from each other, and Billy blinks at Robin, not sure if he wants to kill or kiss her.

“We were talking about rocks.”

“Yeah, rocks.”

Robin squints between them. “I suppose when you’re under my roof, you talk about anything,” she says. “Come try this!”

Steve and Billy sigh and follow Robin out of her room. Billy feels a little cold and it doesn’t help that Steve walks a couple of paces ahead. Billy might admire the view, but he’s too busy thinking about missed chances and pressing his fingers tight against the rock in his pocket.

The kitchen smells like pineapple and something more robust but homey.

“Mother!” Robin shouts, waving her hands. “Step away from the bowl!”

“I was admiring it, Red Robin,” Carrie says and shakes her finger, the many bracelets around her wrist jangling. “I didn’t touch it.”

“Then why do you have the vanilla open? Hmm? Answer me that, lady.”

Carrie holds up her hands and leaves the kitchen, giving Steve and Billy long stares as she does.

Billy cackles and walks to the counter, looking at a large mixing bowl. “Is that cake batter?”

“It so is. And it will make the softest, most pillowy sponge you’ve ever had in your life. Try it,” Robin says and hands Billy and Steve spoons.

“Ahh, not a fuckin’ cake,” Billy mutters. “This isn’t my kinda treat.”

“You are, like, the only person in the world that doesn’t like cake.”

“She’s got a point there,” Steve says and dips his spoon in the batter before popping it in his mouth. “Whoa! Did not expect that!”

“What is it?”

“Fucking try it, man.”

Billy sighs and gets a little batter on his spoon. He sucks it off with a pop just to see Robin shake her head. It’s a punch of rum after that.

“Jesus fuckin’ Christ. You put the whole bottle in there?”

Robin chuckles. “It’s gonna soak into that cake. Trust me. That batter was hard to get down,” she says. “Okay, so, the second part.”

She leads them to another kitchen counter and grandly waves her arms at a casserole dish. Cake dish.

Steve’s hand presses against Billy’s back with the lightest touch possible and he nearly drops the spoon, but he tries not to draw attention to himself. Just leans back a little.

Ignores his racing heart.

“Pineapple upside down rum cake,” Billy muses as he looks at the pineapple slices layering the bottom. “What’s the brown sauce?”

“Dark caramel with a teensy bit of rum in it to caramelize the top before I flip it. To help it along, anyway. The lightest sponge, the richest top, the sweet and tangy pineapple soaked with rum and caramel. It will be a hit. I can feel it.”

“Hmm,” Billy hums. “You know, I do kinda like rum cake.”

Robin chuckles and wraps her arm around his upper back and her cheek against his shoulder. “I remember, honey,” she says. “So, do you think you can stomach this one?”

Billy smiles and squeezes her waist. “I think I might be able to. Just for you, sugar.”

“Just for you, boo.”

Steve raises his eyebrows as he looks between them. “What’s the rum cake story?”

“Nunya,” Robin says. “I’ll let Billy tell you.”

“Maybe later,” Billy laughs and winks at Steve. “Your girl has me down.”

“Yeah. She’s good at that, huh?”

“The best, man.”

“You are both so sweet,” Robin chuckles, and she kisses their cheeks. “Okay, next on the agenda. Bread rolls. I’m talking the fluffiest, most golden rolls you’ve ever seen in your life. They might not make it to the party.”

Steve claps his hands. “Bring it on, baby.”

“You can help me roll them. Billy’s definitely kneading.”

Billy flexes his arms. “I got the power, babe,” he says and waggles his eyebrows at Steve. He gestures at his shoulder. “Robin says you have definition right here. Nowhere else.”

Steve looks at Robin, unamused as she laughs. “Robin. Robin!  Jesus. A man takes his shirt off one time,” he mutters. “I’m lithe, okay? Athletic. Slim but solid. I don’t attract people for boring sex for no goddamn reason.”

“Oh, my dear,” Carrie says as she sneaks into the kitchen in a low crouch like Robin might turn her wooden spoon on her. She grabs a bowl filled with who knows what out of the fridge. “That isn’t right. You’re too young for boring.”

“I know!” Steve says, throwing his arms in the air. “But I’m handsome, right?”

“You’re the James Dean of the eighties, honey.”

Billy leans into Robin’s shoulder as she howls with laughter and he cackles. Steve points at both of them before rolling his pajama sleeves up and clapping his hands together.

“Alright, baby! Bring on the bread rolls.”

Billy isn’t sure how it happened. He left the house to escape Max and El glaring at him and drove the backroads with the window down and radio up. Then he saw someone waving their arms for help on the side of the road and the last thing he wanted to do was stop.

Then Robin was a permanent fixture in his life, and Billy didn’t agree to that, but he loves her all the same. Steve Harrington thrown into the mix wasn’t supposed to happen either. They were keeping it hidden for a reason, but it turns out the guy is forgiving and not what Billy thought he was because he never let Steve have the chance to be himself.

Now he likes him. Billy can’t deny that either, and seeing Steve mixing dough together, breaking a sweat just like he did with meatballs, flour smudges on his cheeks and pajamas… fuck, Billy feels a whole lot that he shouldn’t.

It’s dangerous, yeah, but not nearly as much as it could be. Steve had to come around accusing Billy of being queer just so he could get some advice because he’s queer too. Billy hasn’t given him any, and he doesn’t think he will—Steve keeps looking at him and Billy looks back.

Billy thinks he could drag Steve to a quiet part of the house and kiss him and Steve would be just fine with that. Whatever was gonna happen in Robin’s bedroom probably would’ve been similar, but that got interrupted. Billy might be afraid they’ll never find that again, but Steve keeps bumping elbows or standing shoulder to shoulder with Billy, and it makes every inch of him burn.

He’s never felt like this before and it’ll probably be a shock every time he realizes it.

The cake looks pretty great, though. Good enough to eat. Robin wonders if it might’ve been too much rum after all, but the smell throughout the house reminds Billy of when his mom would make it and even as a kid, before he knew what rum was, he loved it. He doesn’t smell the pineapple unless he gets close, but Billy is a big fan of pineapple too.

Between the cake, bread rolls, and helping Robin write a dozen Christmas cards, afternoon creeps up on them before they know it. Steve is forbidden from helping with the cards, and he complains about Billy’s handwriting being freakishly good for twenty minutes, but that just makes Billy like him more.

Steve leaves earlier than Billy because he has to help his mom with something before he gets ready for the party. Robin’s car is big enough to pack everything in—and a million more things—and she offers to pick them up on her way there, but Billy turns her down because he needs an escape route.

A Christmas Eve party is not his usual thing. Parties, yeah, and holiday parties too. But not a regular party where people their age are in the minority, just like the kids. And Billy has to think about the kids, too, because even if Steve promises to keep them out of his hair, he thinks Steve will fail as badly at that as saying no to the shitheads.

Billy is about to head out the door at two when Carrie stops him.

“My dearest troublemaker,” Mom says and pinches Billy’s cheek. “I thought of something.”

“I already don’t like where this is headed.”

“For Christmas,” Mom says and swipes her thumb over her nose. “I think best in the attic when the snow gets too high for the garden.”

“Uh-huh,” Billy says suspiciously. “Did you hit the dealership when we weren’t lookin’?”

Mom laughs. “Cars are boys’ toys, dearest,” she says. “I found it in the attic. I don’t know how it got out of the trunk it was in. But it was sitting in a ray of winter sunshine like it was waiting for you.”

Billy grimaces as she reaches into her pocket and hands him an incredibly old watch. It’s a silver face, but rectangular rather than round, and the leather strap is worn and cracked. He turns it over and sees looping, faded initials on the back.

B.B.

“How old is this thing?”

“My grandfather was a man of fine taste, you see,” Carrie says. “Gave it to dear old Dad, who didn’t like the look of it. Handed down by generations. I would’ve given it to Robin if I didn’t trust her to break it five minutes later.”

Billy nods. “Good thinking, Mom,” he says and grins. “Why’re you giving me an old family heirloom?”

“You might not be a Buckley, but you’re a William, and so was my grandfather. He liked Bill better,” Carrie says and pats Billy’s shoulders. “What else is it gonna do but gather dust and end up in a garage sale or thrown out to sea with my ashes?”

He laughs. “That’s the right way to go, man,” he says. Billy squeezes his eyes shut as she pinches his cheek again. He looks at her and doesn’t know why his eyes sting. It’s an old, busted watch, but it’s meant something to a couple somebodies. “Thanks, Ma. I’ll keep you and Pops going, huh?”

“That’s the spirit,” Mom says and winks owlishly. “Enjoy yourself tonight, Bill.”

They both grimace.

“Doesn’t ring right, does it?”

“It really fuckin’ doesn’t,” Billy says. “William is better.”

“What a single consonant can do, huh?”

Billy laughs and plants a kiss on her cheek. He thanks her again before he heads home. The snow doesn’t bother him one bit—not until his tires slip a little on the ice-covered hole in his parking spot.

He curses at it, then walks up the stairs to prepare for his worst nightmare.

Maybe not his worst nightmare.

Definitely still a nightmare.

Billy knows how to make himself look good, but he’s not sure about the grey sweater. Well, he is because he definitely looks good in it, but he doesn’t look entirely like himself. The black leather jacket and boots help, but Billy is wandering into Christmas cheer where everyone else will be feeling holly jolly.

He sighs and tugs his sleeve back to look at the watch on his wrist. He’ll have to see if anyone can get it to start ticking again, but he kind of likes the long rectangle. Kind of likes a family heirloom that has nothing to do with the name Hargrove and squeezes his eyes shut for a while. He pats his pocket and feels the rock Steve gave him.

A fucking rock, but Billy already feels antsy at the idea of not having it on him.

He’s fucked, and he had no choice in the matter, which is worse.

The sash gets hung on his closet door.

Billy gets to the Byers household twenty minutes after four because he wants to avoid the crowd and maybe not look at the house too closely. Thankfully, he has to park down the street because Billy thinks if he parked in front of it, he’d turn around and leave.

Not that it feels much better walking up to the door. There’s a sign taped on it that says don’t bother knocking, but it makes Billy queasy. He opens the door and walks into heat, noise, and Christmas tunes playing from somewhere near him.

Fucking Christ. The twinkling lights hung everywhere might be worse than in the Buckley household. Something Christmas-y is in every corner, and it smells like cinnamon, baking ham, and the sweetness of a fire crackling somewhere.

The goddamn people.

Everyone looks like they’re trying to shuffle between greeting each other and getting drinks, finger foods, launching into ramblings about the weather.

One of the kids turns the corner and comes rushing to the door before he stops in his tracks. He blinks up at Billy, his eyebrows slowly raising.

“Ohh… what the hell are you doing here?”

Billy squints at him. “Which one are you?”

“Dustin Henderson,” Dustin says slowly. “We met briefly.”

“I don’t remember.”

“You and Steve share the same selective memory of that night, I see.”

Billy shakes his head. “Yeah. Sorry ‘bout that. Where is he? Or Robin?”

Dustin frowns, pointing over his shoulder. “Both in the kitchen, I think,” he says. “Are you supposed to be here?”

“Got an invite, man,” Billy says and jostles his head over his baseball cap until Dustin swats him away.

He walks into the crowd of people and a few glance at him with surprise. Nancy and Jonathan are friends with Steve these days, and Nancy’s eyes get all big, but that’s on Steve if he didn’t tell her.

Hopper is not hard to spot as he stands in front of the kitchen doorway and his arm jerks out to block it as Billy tries to slither by him.

“Hey, kid,” Hopper says and sounds genuinely perturbed. “What’re you doing here?”

“I was invited, man,” Billy says. He’s uncomfortable because two people he doesn’t know are blinking between them. “Can I please get by?”

“El told me you moved out,” Hopper says slowly. “Got a place of your own?”

“You can have my address when you pull me over next.”

“Yeah. Yeah, that’s when I’ll get it,” Hopper says dryly. “Keep shaping up, kid. It looks good on you.”

Billy smiles blandly until Hopper chuckles and moves his arm. He walks by and into the kitchen, seeing Steve and Robin at the counter, facing away from him. They’re both gesturing emphatically as they stand over Robin’s dinner rolls, and Billy tries to walk to them, but a short woman slides in front of him.

She points at him. “Which one are you?”

“Uhh,” Billy manages. “Billy.”

“Billy! Okay. Gotta remember that. Too many goddamn people in my house,” she says. “I guess that’s my fault for inviting them. You’re Steve and Robin’s friend.”

Billy glances over her head and sees Steve and Robin grinning at him. “Yup,” Billy says and holds out his hand. “Billy Hargrove, ma’am.”

“Joyce Byers. Easy on the Byers,” Joyce says, and her smile is kind. “Welcome to the chaos. Can you carry a bowl of pretzels?”

“Pretty sure I can manage that,” Billy laughs. “It’s Steve you gotta watch out for.”

“Oh, he’s fine. It’s Robin,” Joyce whispers and winks before hurrying back to the oven.

“To think I made dinner rolls and a cake. To think!” Robin says and shakes her fist at Joyce. “And I woulda made more if it hadn’t been for these meddling kids!”

Steve laughs next to Robin, and Billy tries not to stare at him, but he looks good in that red sweater. When he laughs hard enough for his nose to scrunch up. Billy grabs the bowl of pretzels before he can be caught gawking and walks back into the living room.

It takes him a few minutes to determine where he should fucking put it because every surface is covered.

“Over here,” someone says.

Billy glances over and sees Jonathan shuffling a few things around on the finger-foods table. He sets the pretzels down and they glance at each other from the corner of their eyes.

“Hey, man,” Billy says. “Sorry about a few years ago.”

Jonathan huffs a laugh. “It was a few years ago,” he says. “Steve and Robin talk about you nonstop these days.”

Billy grimaces. “They do?”

“Yeah,” Jonathan says and smiles, looking like he thinks Billy should know better than to ask. “Of course they do.”

He has no fucking idea what to say to that, but thankfully Jonathan doesn’t stick around. Billy turns, intending to hide in the kitchen with his friends or at least fucking say hi, but he comes face to face with Max.

“I cannot,” Max says slowly, “believe you actually came to the Christmas party.”

“You wished it, man. Every kid gets a wish on Christmas.”

“Yeah. Literally none of mine have ever come true.”

Billy laughs. “Mine neither,” he says and grins. “Look at you, Maxine. You sparkle.”

Max grimaces and looks at her red and gold sweater. “El picked it out for me and I picked hers out,” she says. “It’s a little… too sparkly. But I like it.” She sighs and points over her shoulder to the living room. “Lucas likes it more.”

He glances at the living room and sees the other five sitting around. Billy remembers Lucas just fine and he’s definitely staring. He jumps a little when he sees them and turns away.

Billy laughs. “Fuckin’ hell, Max. When’d you get a boyfriend?”

“He’s not my boyfriend!” Max hisses. “Boys are gross.”

“Yeah, we are.”

“Did you bring anyone?”

“Who the hell would I bring here? I came with somebody.”

Max blinks, then raises an eyebrow. “You don’t have any friends here.”

Billy whistles. “Man, are you wrong about that,” he says. He shrugs after she frowns. “I got friends, kiddo. Better deal with it.”

“Okay, soo… can anyone else see them?”

“Fuck, man,” Billy laughs. He plucks her sleeve. “Go back to your friends, Sparkles. Where’s Susan?”

Max rolls her eyes. “Becoming best friends with Missus Sinclair, I guess. They’ve been chatting in the hallway for thirty minutes,” she says, gesturing at a doorway.

“That’s good, shitbird. You doing okay?”

“Yeah, asshole,” Max says, looking away to hide a smile. “I’m doing okay. Promise.”

“Good. Beat it.”

They bump arms as they walk by each other. Billy walks into the kitchen before anyone else can stop him and sees Steve and Robin setting out large plates, napkins, and plastic cutlery.

“Jesus fuckin’ Christ,” Billy mutters as he stops next to Steve. “You said avoid or chat. There’s no such thing as avoid.”

Steve chuckles and shrugs. “Packed house, man,” he says and looks at Billy with a smile. “Did you say hi to Max?”

Billy isn’t sure if the grey sweater was the right choice or not as Steve eyeballs him, but it makes him feel a little tingly anyway.

“She thinks you guys are imaginary friends.”

Robin laughs. “How do you know I’m not?” she asks. “I could be an illusion.”

“Ehh,” Steve says. “You played the French horn for four years in front of the whole school. You’re not that powerful.”

“That you know of.”

“Girl’s got powers, Stevie,” Billy says. “We see it at least twice a week.”

“Um, literally four times a week for Steve.”

“Alright, alright. Powers,” Steve says and holds up his hands. “It’s mostly the food, though, because, you know.” He gestures at her.

Robin raises her eyebrows, holding up a plastic knife. “Finish that sentence, lover boy. I dare you.”

“I gotta double dare on this one, babe.”

“Jesus,” Steve mutters and grabs a handful of napkins to add to the towering pile. “Can’t take you two anywhere. Actually, I’m super looking forward to that cake. And the rolls. Dude,” he adds and looks at Billy. “We shared one. Greatest dinner roll you’ll ever have in your life.”

“That’s right, dingus. Don’t you forget it.”

Billy smiles as he glances between them. He sees Joyce open the oven, and the ham looks wider than her, so Billy helps her with it. They start stacking the kitchen with dishes various people have made and Billy doesn’t think he’s ever seen anything like it.

There might be enough people here to eat everything, but it’s a lot of goddamn food. Even when he went to his grandparents’ place, it was small because his mother didn’t have siblings. No cousins, no sister at that point.

Just a bunch of miserable bastards sharing dried-out ham or turkey, unseasoned potatoes, and other things he hated. His mom’s rum cake was the highlight, and so was the extra long hug she’d give him on those nights like she knew how bad it felt.

She did. Just another reason why she left and never looked back.

There’s a line around the food that moves slowly, and Billy is stuck in front of the kids, who keep whispering about him like they think he can’t hear them. Steve snaps his fingers at them a few times, and that only works for about a minute, but it tickles Billy and makes him fall a bit more.

Steve, Robin, and Billy find a corner in the living room, so they don’t have to suffer the parents or random people Billy doesn’t think he’s ever seen in Hawkins. They tell Billy who they are while they eat; some guy named Murray, who lives a quarter mile down from Joyce. Eccentric but funny. Argyle, Jonathan’s friend from his failed attempt at IU, also originally from California.

Billy does not think they’ll get along even with a shared interest.

Some guy that’s tall and handsome, whispering with Hopper at the table. That stumps them, and Steve muses that he might be a fed, but Billy knows Hop doesn’t have friends in high places.

The Wheelers are here, and Robin and Billy shake their heads about it but still don’t tell Steve when he demands to know. Can’t go ruining the image of a perfect family for him and Billy steers as far away from Missus Wheeler as he can.

Robin’s parents don’t come to these even if they’re invited because, apparently, some people think they’re strange, and Billy would love to talk to those people, but Robin won’t let him. Still, he wishes they were here. Everyone would realize Carrie brings the party with her.

Billy is nervous about Susan, though, and doesn’t know what to say to her. He saw her sit at the table next to Missus Sinclair and Billy isn’t sure if she’s seen him or not.

“It’ll be okay,” Robin says gently after she catches him looking. “She’ll be happy to see you.”

“Yeah? You think so? I don’t know, sugar. What if she feels worse than Max did?”

“Max would’ve let you know that already,” Robin chuckles and knocks her shoulder against Billy’s. “She’s gonna be happy you got out.”

“Didn’t help her do the same, though.”

“Something tells me that would’ve been impossible. Right now, anyway,” Robin says and rubs Billy’s back. “And it’s not your responsibility. You told me that kinda thing happens really slow or really fast.”

Billy nods. “It does,” he says. “Fuck, man. It really does. I want it to be fast.”

Robin smiles. “Yeah. I think you all do,” she says. “She’s got so many what, when, and hows to answer.”

“I know,” Billy sighs. “I thought about convincing her to get a house with me. Combine our incomes and it would’ve worked. I don’t think it would’ve worked in a lot of other ways.”

“You have a right to be on your own too, boo. You’re doing okay,” Robin says. “Maybe when you venture off west into the sunset on your way to San Diego, they’ll be with you.”

“Wait, what?” Steve asks, sitting up more and leaning over to look between Billy and Robin. “San Diego? Did I hear San Diego?”

“God,” Robin mutters. “You are such a boy. This guy and his mashed potatoes. He could bathe in them.”

“Yeugh,” Steve says. “No. No, no. I could eat a moderately sized plateful of them. Why’re we talking about San Diego?”

“Mind your business,” Billy says. “Get back to makin’ love to your potatoes.”

Steve sighs. “You better not be moving back to San Diego.”

Billy laughs. “Oh, yeah? Why’s that?”

Steve shrugs and waves a forkful of mashed potatoes. “We’ve got shit to do next summer.”

“I’m not saving your ass from any forest creatures.”

“Yes, you are.”

“The fuck I am.”

“Honey, you have to. Look at him. He’s so fragile. Practically made of glass.”

“Okay, let’s not exaggerate—”

“Maybe I should give you a test run, Stevie. See how easily you break.”

Steve coughs and flushes from neck to cheek, hitting his chest a few times. Billy grins as Steve shakes his head with exasperation, and Robin rolls her eyes between them.

She stuffs a piece of ham in her mouth, muttering boys, and, well.

She’s not wrong.

Christmas Eve parties do not end after dinner. They do not end after endless chatting with people Billy probably won’t see again for a year. They do not end after dessert, which is at least pretty fucking tasty—Robin’s cake is spectacular, a big hit, and she’s bodily removed from the table by Murray, who wants to know her secret.

They whisper in the corner until he holds up his hands and looks at the ceiling as if he’s hearing the word of god.

Billy thinks he’s weirder than Carrie and Dave.

Parties do not end even after everyone’s been at the spiced eggnog a few too many times and the children are reduced to behaving like seven-year-olds. But Max is having the goddamn time of her life, Susan still hasn’t separated from Missus Sinclair and now her husband, so Billy supposes he can’t blame them.

Everyone starts cheering when it snows because it’ll be a white Christmas, but they seem to remember that means they have to drive in it. That’s apparently when Christmas parties end, but Steve and Robin volunteer to help Joyce and Jonathan start cleaning up.

Billy thinks he’d feel guilty if he took off, so he cleans up in the living room while they tackle the kitchen. The kids are loud as hell, and Billy glances at them a few times, wondering how Steve does it.

They’re opening Robin’s Christmas cards and reading the silly or strange things she wrote to them out loud. Mike is halfway through his before Max snatches it from his hands.

“Hey, what the hell—”

“Why is this your handwriting?!” Max screeches and looks at Billy with horror.

“Got me mistaken for somebody else, squirt.”

“Billy. This is your handwriting.”

“Nope.”

“Billy.”

“Why would I ever write a fuckin’ Christmas card?”

“It’s signed Robin, but this is your handwriting,” Max says accusingly. She looks horrified still and leans back on the couch, handing Mike the card. “I can’t believe you’re friends with Robin and Steve.”

“Super weird,” Dustin says. “Didn’t see that one coming.”

“Hey, hey, hey!” Steve’s familiar, annoyed voice shouts as he claps his hands. He stops next to Billy. “Where are our manners?”

Max points at him. “How long have you been lying to me?”

Steve scoffs. “Lying to you? Jesus! Never.”

“Withholding the truth is lying,” El says with a tired smile. “Friends don’t lie.”

“Okay, first of all,” Steve says, planting his hands on his hips. “I am not your friend. I am your guardian. And chauffeur. And nanny. Not a friend to you shits. Withholding the truth is sometimes just not letting a bunch of assholes into your business.”

Billy smiles. “Couldn’t have said it better myself, Stevie,” he says and claps Steve on the shoulder. “How can you stand ‘em, man?”

Dustin and Max flip him off, but Steve waves dismissively.

“Every once in a while, they’re decent with redeeming qualities,” Steve says. “Be safe getting home, huh?”

Mike wrinkles his nose. “We’re with our parents.”

“Yeeeah,” Steve says slowly. “You still say… you know what, never mind.” He holds up his hands. “Come on,” he adds to Billy. “In the kitchen.”

Steve squeezes Billy’s wrist, and Billy follows him, wishing he could chase his hand. Too good to be possible, and it’s bullshit, but maybe Steve wouldn’t mind a quiet room alone again.

The kitchen is still pretty packed with people. Robin is continuing to blow Murray’s mind with her magical food touch, and Joyce and Hopper are a little cozy, which Billy will definitely remember to ask about.

But Susan is standing in the corner of the kitchen with Missus Sinclair. Her eyes are bright and lively, she’s got a big smile that Billy sees way more on Max, but that’s where she gets it from. She looks happy and maybe that won’t last much longer, but it’s something.

Sometimes having friends is all it takes.

Susan looks at Billy and her smile falters. It makes his stomach turn, but maybe it’s not bad. Susan still smiles, but she seems fond and relieved to see him.

Billy isn’t sure what to make of that, but Susan walks to him and wraps her arms tight around him. It’s easy to hug her back, and the smell of her perfume and the laundry detergent is so familiar it’s almost overwhelming. Too many bad memories are associated with those things, but Billy squeezes his eyes shut and thinks about where they’re standing. She’s made a leap, and he’s made a bigger one, but he hopes she continues.

“Are you doing alright?” Susan asks and pulls back a little, sniffing. “You have everything you need?”

“Yeah,” Billy says hoarsely and clears his throat. “Yeah, I do. Sorry I didn’t say anything.”

“Oh, baby. One of my biggest hopes was that you wouldn’t,” Susan says and pats Billy’s cheek. “I hope you don’t mind, and I know it may not be my place to say… but I’m proud of you, Billy. You’ve come so far.”

Billy bites the inside of his cheek and digs his fingers into his jeans so he can feel the rock Steve gave him. “I don’t mind if you say it,” he says. “Thanks, Susan.”

“Should’ve been saying it a lot more,” Susan whispers and squeezes Billy’s arms. “Happy is a good look on you.”

“Yeah?” Billy asks, smiling. “It’s a good look on you too.”

Susan nods and sniffs. She pats his cheek again and doesn’t say anything more—they’ll see each other again because it’s not like either of them are going anywhere.

Some of the resentment and bitterness Billy felt toward her disappeared a couple of years ago, but more does tonight too.

Billy walks into a quiet hallway and brushes the back of his hands against his cheeks. He sniffs and scrubs his eyes. Billy has three moms; maybe one won’t ever be called Mom, and one might never meet him on that golden strip of sand, but Billy still has them.

A hand touches his back, and Billy expects to see Robin, but it’s Steve.

“Hey,” Steve says. “You okay?”

“Yeah,” Billy says and cools the urge to get defensive. To shove Steve away. He doesn’t want to do that anymore. “I’m alright. Different, you know?”

“Yeah. I know,” Steve says and smiles. “Good different.”

“It is,” Billy chuckles. “Still a little strange, I suppose. The whole night was.”

“Ahh, come on. You can’t tell me you didn’t have a good time.”

“I didn’t have a good time.”

Steve shakes his head. “I’m supposed to be the bad liar,” he says. “You’re failing pretty hard, Hargrove.”

“Hmm,” Billy hums. “Guess I better get this silver tongue back in shape. Maybe a good workout.”

“Jesus,” Steve laughs. “Yeah? And how are you gonna do that?”

Billy grins and tilts his head. “Let me show you,” he says. He takes Steve’s hand and glances down the hall before dragging him into an admittedly tiny bathroom. Easy to firmly shut and lock the door, though.

“Hoo,” is all Steve manages to say before Billy cups his cheeks and kisses him.

The bastard seems shocked for a hot minute, but maybe the bathroom at a Christmas party full of people he’s friendly with wasn’t Steve’s idea. But Billy isn’t going to wait anymore and it’s worth it—fuck, it’s worth it a thousand times over when Steve finally relaxes into it. When his kiss turns as hungry as Billy’s, and they’re pressed tight together, Steve’s back up against the wall.

“You fucker,” Billy whispers after they part to breathe and he trails kisses down Steve’s jaw.

“Totally… totally not what I thought you’d say right now,” Steve says breathlessly and his fingers dig into Billy’s back.

Billy chuckles. “If I kissed you the night you came over and called me queer,” he says quietly into Steve’s ear. “If I kissed you instead of coming close to burying you, would you have let me?”

“Jesus,” Steve says. “Uhh. Yeah. I mean, yeah. Listen. I have completely lost my ability to flirt with anyone and that was the best I had.”

“Scared the shit out of me, man,” Billy laughs and gently bites the skin of Steve’s neck until he hisses. He pulls back to look at him and quirks an eyebrow. “You had me burning up that night, babe.”

“Oh,” Steve says and licks his lips. “Well, I guess that makes two of us.”

“You don’t gotta bribe me with cheese balls to cool me down anymore.”

“Good to know,” Steve says and grins. “I know a few ways I can cool you down.”

“You wanna come home with me?”

“Yes. Wait. No. It’s Christmas Eve, man. If I’m not there in the morning, I’m gonna fucking hear it from the old man,” Steve complains. “Can I come over after we do the awkward breakfast and gifts thing?”

Billy smiles as he watches Steve. “Yeah, Stevie. You come over then and we’ll cool down together.”

“Okay,” Steve sighs. “Deal. Fuck, man,” he adds with a sigh as he looks Billy’s face up and down. “You can’t look at me like that until I do.”

“Way too late on that one, sweetheart,” Billy says and slides his hand under Steve’s sweater, squeezing his hip.

He leans in and kisses Steve again, who seems agreeable, and it’s no supply closet, but goddamn, is it something.

They leave the bathroom a while later after straightening themselves out. Robin is washing dishes, and Billy walks to her, glad the kitchen has emptied out beyond Hopper, Joyce, Murray, and El. Billy winks at El and she smiles, her eyes crinkled—friendliest she’s ever looked.

That’s Billy’s fault, but he hopes he’s making up for it.

Robin raises her hand and Billy smacks it before diving into the dishes with her.

“Knew it would happen.”

“Uh-huh.”

“I called it.”

“To who?”

“My mother.”

“Ahh, fuck. You fuckin’ didn’t.”

“I so did.”

“How’d she know the first time I met her?”

“Oh, honey. I’ve told you so many times. That open shirt and dangling earring. That sass when you realized you didn’t have to say yes, ma’am, no, ma’am. The super, super aggressive way you told her we weren’t dating.”

“C’mon. I wasn’t aggressive.”

“I believe your words were—to be exact—fuck, no,” Robin says loftily. “Like I was the least desirable person on the planet. It hurt. I could’ve cried if I didn’t see my mom trying not to burst.”

Billy sighs. “I don’t like the nose detectors the pair of you have,” he says. “She had me down the minute I walked in the door.”

“She sure did. I had you down the minute I sat in your car.”

“After you thought I was gonna murder you.”

“I did not think that. I thought you would torment. Taunt. Leer. Maniacally laugh as you left me alone on that dark, scary road.”

Billy looks at her and smiles flatly. “Should’ve.”

“Oh, honey,” Robin chuckles. “You’ve never loved a girl more.”

He shakes his head. “Nope. I haven’t,” Billy says. “That’s not a high bar considering you’re the only one, sugar.”

Robin leans against his shoulder. “Get back to me once you start making more friends. I gotta introduce you to the people in Marion. And Vickie! We are still working magic together.”

“You spent two hours with her.”

“Magic, Hargrove!”

“Fuckin’ magic,” Billy mutters, setting a plate aside. “Steve says you took him to a bondage party.”

Robin bursts into laughter. “I told him. I told him not to open the door. I literally said those words and what did he do? He opened the door. God. Don’t you grin. You are just as bad,” she says. “I tell you don’t touch it, you touch it. I tell you don’t look at it, you look at it. You and Steve are obviously from the same planet.”

Steve sidles up to them and plants his hip on the counter on the other side of Robin. “And which planet is that, Robin? No, no,” he says after she mimes zipping her lips. “You have to say it. I know you want to.”

“There are children present. We will not behave as if we are one of them.”

“You’re still a teenager, sugar. You’re allowed to say Uranus.”

“I’ll soak you with this filthy water.”

Billy smiles and looks at Steve. “How do you like Uranus?”

Steve chuckles and shakes his head. “You know, I always preferred Pluto. Bit of an underdog, but he’s still kickin’, baby.”

“Fits you,” Billy agrees. “Where am I really from?”

Robin and Steve exchange glances before looking at Billy and saying, “The Sun.”

He’ll take that.

It’s almost ten by the time they leave. The longest party of Billy’s life, definitely not the most fun, but he can’t deny it was fucking rewarding. Joyce invites him back anytime, which Billy won’t take her up on, but it’s still kind. Hopper tells him he’s got eyes on Billy as soon as the road thaws, but two can play that game.

He’s taking Max home, so Billy hugs her at the door, and when she says Merry Christmas, he says it back.

Robin hugs Billy for a long time under Joyce’s porch. She pushes almost everything back into place with each tiny squeeze and Billy breathes her in and wonders how he ever got through life without someone like her.

“See you tomorrow?” Steve asks as they watch Robin hurry down to her car.

“See you tomorrow, Steve,” Billy says and grins. “Lookin’ forward to it.”

“Best Christmas on record.”

“You know it.”

Steve squeezes Billy’s hand before he meets Robin at the car. It’s coming down pretty good but not wholly unsafe to drive in. He watches them go before Billy sighs and walks to the Camaro.

He looks down the street at Joyce’s home and doesn’t think it’ll ever be a place of comfort and peace. Not all the way, but making good memories… Billy can’t complain about that. Not anymore.

They feel too fucking amazing to pass up.

Billy holds onto the rock all night, except in the shower, and sets it on his nightstand when he crawls into bed. He stares at it through the dark and smiles before he sleeps.

It’s right back in his hand in the morning and Billy doesn’t know why. It’s a fucking rock, but Steve gave him this rock. Steve was helping the kids collect rocks for a science project and he thought of Billy when he saw it. Fuck knows why, but he did, and Billy can’t seem to put it down.

He does stuff it in his pocket when there’s a knock on the door, but the watch on Billy’s left wrist helps him feel calmer.

He belongs here, man. Right now, he really fucking belongs in Hawkins.

Billy lets Steve in, and as soon as he’s out of his coat, they’re wrapped around each other. But it’s not a kiss—it’s a solid embrace. Even tighter than the one Robin gives Billy when he needs it. More than her mom, Max, Susan, anybody that’s ever hugged Billy.

Everything that Robin couldn’t fit quite right settles into place with Steve in his arms.

Steve kisses Billy, and it’s soft, gentle. Not the kind Billy usually gets and it feels like something is exposed between them. Their hearts, maybe, or the vulnerability that makes Billy tremble.

But Steve kisses Billy and holds him tight.

“I don’t got anything to give you for Christmas but me, Stevie.”

“Funny,” Steve sighs. “That’s all I want for Christmas.”

Billy smiles and turns his chin up, and Steve readily obliges with a kiss that Billy’s gonna remember for the rest of his life.

A lot of shit still has to be worked out in Billy’s life. His family, his future, California. Billy wants Steve to meet Grandma Antonia and see her garage. But those can be handled in baby steps if he wants them to be.

Curbs, steps, staircases, hills, mountains.

Billy will gladly climb them all with Steve by his side.

Notes:

I hope you enjoyed it! Thanks for reading!

I'd love to hear from you. 💜