Chapter Text
Chapter One: The Arrival
It was dark. It was home, but it wasn’t at the same time. Home didn’t have strange black vines that covered the ground, or strange dust that floated into his lungs and choked him. Home had that little redheaded pain in his ass and his loud music and angry father. Somehow, he thought, even that was better than this. He fought to breathe as foreign particles threatened to suffocate him. I‘m going to die here, he thought. He didn’t know where here was, just a strange, manipulated version of his home.
“Help me.”
*****
She couldn’t sleep. The obnoxiously red numbers of her alarm clock read 2:55. Caroline tossed and turned in bed, unable to turn her brain off long enough to get a few hours of sleep.
3:00.
She saw him everywhere. Blond curls, blue eyes. For years she had remembered him as the boy he’d been the last time they saw each other. Chubby cheeks, missing one of his front teeth. She almost wished she could go back to that, instead of the face in the newspaper article that she had discovered.
Almost six months ago, her brother had died in a mall fire somewhere in Indiana. She had no clue how that had happened, but when the news reached her she was devastated nonetheless. They hadn’t seen each other in almost eight years, but Billy was still her brother, and she still missed him.
Suddenly, there was a loud rap on the front door. Followed by another frantic knock. Who the hell was knocking on her door at 3 am? This was the west coast, she’d witnessed enough craziness to not be fazed by much, but knocking on her door in the middle of the night was fairly uncommon.
The constant pounding continued until she made it downstairs and yanked open the door. There, on her front porch was Billy, dressed in dirty clothes, alive but looking worse for wear, blonde curls matted with blood and sweat.
“Billy?” She whispered.
“Caroline,” He collapsed to his knees in front of her.
“Billy, how did you get here? What happened to you.”
“Caroline you have to help me. I don’t know how much longer I can do this.”
“Billy, what are you talking about? Come inside, get cleaned up and we can talk about this.”
“He’s going to find me. You have to help me, Caroline.”
“Billy, who is He? What’s happening?”
She bolted up in her bed, breathing hard. There was no Billy. Just the dim light from the clock. She reached over to turn on her lamp, looking around her room for any signs that her brother might have actually been there. That it wasn’t all a dream.
The lights flickered once. Then twice. And then it stopped.
*****
The town of Hawkins had been strangely quiet for the last six months. Steve thought of the quiet as a blessing, but he was also worried that he and the remaining members of the party might get too comfortable. However, he didn’t see that happening yet as they all continued to look over their shoulders at every sound and sleep with one eye open and the lights on.
The kids had been eerily somber since July, which made sense with everything going on. Despite his understanding, Steve desperately wished things could go back to some semblance of normal, if not for the kids' sake then for his. He hated to see them like this.
Thankfully, of their moods had improved somewhat when the Byers and El had shown back up in town for Christmas and decided to stay through the new year, but all six of them still seemed to have a tiny rain cloud of gloom hanging over them most days. Especially Max. No one could really blame her. She’d lost her big brother and with that, her only source of protection from her tumultuous home life. Regardless of how much of an asshole Billy had been, it became clear in the months following his death that Billy had been protecting her. And with her protector gone, no one was there to stand between her and Neil.
The first time they’d gone toe to toe was in September, just after all of the kids had started school again. She’d found Neil packing Billy’s things into boxes, most of them labeled donate. She’d lost it on her step-father, who had declared it was time to move on, screaming at him, asking how in the hell he could move on so soon after losing his only son. She’d even asked if he ever even loved Billy.
Neil had stormed off that night and never came back, leaving Susan and Max with a house and bills that they couldn't afford. When the bank seized their small, comfortable house on Cherry Lane, they moved into a tiny, rundown trailer park off Curly. Max hated it there, but she wasn’t willing to abandon her mother like Neil had, no matter how many offers she had from her friends for a place to crash. However, she had asked Steve to hold on to the things she’d managed to salvage from Billy’s room, and on nights when Susan was working her second job or was too drunk to know she was gone, Max slept in one of Steve's guest rooms, surrounded by what she had left of her brother.
After the aftermath of Starcourt, all of the kids felt more comfortable when they were all together and Steve’s too big, too empty house was the perfect gathering place for all of them. They had the loft upstairs set up for D&D campaigns and the pantry and fridge were always stocked with their favorite snacks. Even their parents didn’t mind the frequent sleepovers, sympathetic to the fact that their young kids had been through too much and trusting Steve to look out for them, almost making him part of their families.
For Christmas, all of the kids had gone home, but when Dustin’s mother found out Steve would be alone, she’d demanded more than offered, that he spend the holiday with them.
Their normal routine had resumed after Christmas when they’d had a late family dinner of sorts with Joyce. However, the events of that dinner had taken Steve’s hopes for any semblance of normal and shattered them.
The phone rang once they were all stuffed and sprawled across the couches and floor watching the assortment of Christmas movies Steve and Robin had brought from Family Video.
Joyce answered and her brow furrowed with confusion as the person on the other line spoke.
“Hey Steve,” she called, hand cupped over the receiver. “It’s Phil from the police station. Said he needed to talk to you about something weird.”
Each of the six kids snapped their attention to him at the word “Weird”.
“I’m sure it’s nothing guys. Let me handle it.”
“Hello?” Steve took the receiver from Joyce.
“Hey, Steve. It’s Officer Callahan.”
“Hey, Officer. What’s going on?”
“Look, Steve, I told Joyce this was a weird one.”
“I’m sure I’ve heard weirder. Try me.”
“Okay, there’s a kid from California at the station claiming to be Billy Hargrove’s sister. I don’t know much about the guy but I thought maybe you’d know something.”
“What the hell? Hang on a second, let me talk to Max. Stay on the line.”
“Alright.”
“Hey Max, can you come here for a second?” Steve called.
“What’s up Steve?” Max chewed on her lip anxiously as she leaned against the wall next to him.
“Officer Callahan said there’s a girl at the station claiming to be Billy’s sister.”
“What?”
“Yeah, I know. Did he have any other siblings that you know of?”
“Actually yeah. I’m pretty sure he did have a little sister, but he never talked about her. I just saw of picture of her once. He kept it in the inside pocket of his jacket and it fell out once, I picked it up and asked him about it but he snapped at me and wouldn’t answer. I asked my mom later and she said that Neil had a daughter but he told her that she died when she was little. I never heard anything else about her after that.”
“Well if she’d dead she’s not in Hawkins.”
“But why would anyone just show up claiming to be Billy’s long-lost sister that no one even knows about?”
“Do you think she’s worth checking out?”
“It couldn’t hurt.”
“Hey, Officer Callahan?”
“Yeah, I’m here Steve.”
“Keep her at the station. Max and I are on our way to check it out.”
“Alright, I’ll see you soon.”
The line clicked as Phil hung up.
*****
Hawkins, Indiana was an even shittier place than Caroline had imagined. Honestly, she hadn’t expected much from a town she’d never even heard of, but on sight, it was even more underwhelming. It seemed that a permanent rain cloud covered the town, leaving it grey, dreary, and cold.
If she was honest, she didn’t have much of a plan upon her arrival. The original plan had been to track down Neil, but a call to the address found in the phone book confirmed that he’d fled town months ago, which put her back at square one.
She decided the police station was her best next choice. In towns like this, people tended to know everyone, so someone there was bound to know something about Billy.
The old door creaked as she pushed on the wood. Blessedly the station was slightly warmer than outside, but it was still drafty. She pulled her jacket tighter around herself as she approached the desk.
Seated behind it was a man with the name “Callahan” emblazoned on his front. He glanced up at Caroline as she came in and seemed to do a double take.
“Hey, kid. Can I help you with something?”
“I’m looking for someone. My brother.”
His brow creased as he studied her more closely, “Did you just move into town or something? I don’t think I’ve seen you before.”
“Something like that. Look, I just came to get some answers.”
“Okay kid. Let me see if I can help. What’s your brother’s name?”
“Billy Hargrove.”
“Kid, I don’t know what you’re trying to pull but Billy Hargive died in July.”
“My name is Caroline, not kid. And I know that Billy is dead, I’m just looking for answers. I haven’t seen him since we were kids and I came here to find someone who might have known Billy and be able to clear some stuff up.”
Callahan seemed to think it over for a moment and then picked up the phone, “Wait here for a minute.”
