Actions

Work Header

We Can Be Heroes, Just For One Day

Chapter 2: The Doppelanger Theory

Summary:

Steve and the party meet Caroline. Dustin and Mike propose a theory about Billy.

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

Chapter 2: The Doppelganger Theory

 

When they arrived at the station Steve instructed all the kids, who had insisted on coming along, to stay in the car. He’d only planned on bringing Max, but it was just too much for him to try and argue with the other five, so they’d all piled into his car.

“Steve what if it’s a trap?” Mike protested.

“Really Wheeler? You think I can’t handle myself?”

“He did knock out a Russian,” Dustin pointed out.

“Thank you, Dustin. Besides, she’s just a kid, how much danger could I really be in?”

Lucas opened his mouth to tell him exactly how dangerous teenage girls could be, but Steve cut him off.

I’ll be fine. Now do what I say, all of you shitheads stay in the car.”

Steve pushed open the door, relishing the burst of heat as he held it open to let Max in first. 

“Hey, Steve. Thanks for coming down on short notice.”

“It’s not a problem. Where is she?”

“She’s waiting in the chief's office. It sounds crazy but her story is rock solid from what I can tell.”

“I’m glad you called. I wouldn’t count out her story yet, Max at least seems to think she could be legit.”

Callahan led them down the hall to where Hopper’s office had been. It sent a pang into Steve’s heart to see his name half scraped off the door.

“She’s right in here. Take your time and shout if you need anything.”

“Thanks, Phil.”

Before opening the door, Steve turned to Max.

“Do you wanna come in or wait for me here?”

“I’ll wait. But you’ll get me if you need me right?”

“Of course kiddo.”

Steve left Max in the hall and stepped into the office closing the door carefully behind him. The girl was sitting uncomfortably in a hard plastic chair across the small room. She definitely looked like she could be related to Billy, wavy blonde hair and big blue eyes. She didn’t have the harshness to her face that Billy had, but that could have just been the difference in the way they were raised. She scuffed the toe of her shoe across the dirty laminate floor, only looking up at the click of the door.

“Hey kid, my name is Steve.”

“Did you know Billy?”

“Yeah, I did. But before we get into all of that, can you at least tell me your name?”

“Caroline Hargrove. Did you know my brother?”

“Yeah I knew him,” Steve sighed and slid down into the seat next to her. “But I wouldn’t say we were friends. We didn’t really like each other to be honest.”

“Yeah, Billy never was great at the friends thing.”

“So what’s your story kid? How did you end up in Hawkins? How did you even know where to look for Billy?’

“My story?”

“Yeah. Start from the beginning.”

“I don’t think you’d believe me if I told you.”

“Trust me, whatever you think you’ve seen or heard, I’ve seen and heard weirder. Just tell me and I’ll decide if you’re lying.”

“Okay. Billy and I were born three years apart. I’m fifteen. My dad, Neil, didn’t want another kid, but he gave in to my mom. He never really paid attention to me, I was just there. But Billy, well he paid a lot of attention to Billy. He was always pushing him to play sports, baseball, football whatever. Billy never liked it or cared about it really. He always loved surfing and he was pretty good from what I remember. Our mom used to sneak us down to the beach when Neil wasn’t home. Neil used to yell a lot, especially at Billy, about everything, even when it wasn’t his fault. I think I remember him hitting him a few times. I know he used to hit my mom. He used to call Billy names and make fun of him. Then one day, we left. Just me and my mom. She left Billy behind and that was the last time I saw him. Mom and I moved up north and stayed with her parents. Then she died a couple of years later when I was seven. I never heard from Billy after that. I tried to write him a few letters when I got older but I guess Neil got them before Billy could see them. My grandparents told me that Neil got married again and then they moved here to Hawkins. I didn’t hear anything else until almost six months ago when I found out that Billy died in a fire at Starcourt Mall. I always thought that was a little weird, but I knew virtually nothing else about Billy’s life. Then three nights ago I had this really weird dream. Billy showed up at my house and he looked like hell. He was dirty and bleeding. It looked like someone had ripped his chest wide open. He told me that I had to find him and save him. He said, “He’s gonna find me”. Then I woke up and the lamp by my bed started flickering. After that, I knew I needed answers, so I came to Hawkins to find out what really happened to my brother.”

“Wow,” was all Steve could think to say.

“Look I know it sounds crazy. But it was like some horror movie shit. Weird dreams and flickering lights. I don’t believe that my brother actually died in a mall fire. If stuff like this is happening to me, there’s got to be something weird going on right?”

“You know what? Two years ago, I would have thought you were absolutely batshit. But some crazy stuff has happened in this town in the past couple of years. Stuff that blows what you're telling me out of the water.” Steve paused and then stood up. “Come with me, I have some people I want you to meet.”

When Max saw them coming, she removed her headphones and looked at Steve.

“Max, this is Caroline. Caroline, this is Max, Billy’s step-sister.”

“Hi,” Caroline tucked her hair behind her ear.

“Hey,” Max looked up to Steve. “What’s going on Steve?”

“Let’s go get the other kids and Caroline can explain everything.”

“Please tell me more crazy shit isn’t happening in this town?”

“I would but I know you don’t like being lied to.”

Steve led Caroline out to his car and motioned to Dustin and the rest of the kids to get out. They stood all together looking at him expectantly.

“Guys this is Caroline Hargrove, Billy’s sister. Caroline this is Dustin, Lucas, Will, Mike, and El.”

A chorus of greetings fell from the kids, but they all looked at Caroline suspiciously, as if her face was about to split open to reveal some sort of alien, which was a justified sort of fear considering that things like that had actually happened to them.

“Okay Caroline, tell these guys everything you just told me."

"I sound like a crazy person Steve. There's no way that all of you don't think I just escaped from the looney bin."

"Trust me they’ve heard stuff way crazier.”

She proceeded to tell the entire story over again, mostly skipping over the part of their childhood that Steve had insisted on hearing, and jumped into the stuff they really needed to hear. When she was finished Dustin slumped against the car and let out a low whistle.

“That’s wild,” Lucas said. 

“So you think that Billy might be alive somewhere?” Max asked. 

“I don’t know. All I know is that what I saw was way too realistic to be some sort of dream.”

“Upside down,” El said.

“Wait what? Upside down, what does that mean?” Caroline questioned.

“I guess we have some stories of our own.”

 

*****

When the other six kids finished telling her their experiences over the past two years Caroline’s head was spinning.

“So let me get this straight. You,” she said pointing at Will. “Were kidnapped by a dungeons and dragons character and trapped in an alternate reality where Hawkins isn’t actually Hawkins these guys got you out. You,” she pointed at El this time. “Are a walking science experiment, except you lost your powers when the “mind flayer” killed my brother? The rest of you help hunt these monsters and he’s your babysitter. Did I get that right?”

“Yep that’s about it,” Lucas agreed. 

“Pretty damn close. Good job new girl,” Dustin said. “Except Steve isn’t our babysitter, he’s our mom.”

The rest of the kids giggled and Steve rolled his eyes.

“Yeah yeah, very funny shithead.”

“That story was great and all, but I’m still not sure what it has to do with Billy or the dream that I had. If it was a dream.”

“Well, Billy was possessed by the mind flayer, which comes from the upside down. And when something that's in the upside down is near, or it’s trying to communicate, it makes lights flicker, the power does crazy stuff. Energy surges and shit, but that's not important. What I'm trying to say is that maybe when the mind flayer killed Billy, he didn’t actually die and he’s trapped in the upside down,” Mike theorized.

“But I watched Billy die Mike. I felt his heart stop,” Max said sadly.

“What if it was a doppelganger? You know a second version of Billy. Maybe, the mindflayer created a clone and that was the Billy that we saw here in Hawkins.” 

“So the original Billy, the real Billy, is trapped in the upside down or whatever and he was using the lights to try and get my attention? He was trying to talk to me?"

“Possibly. And the dream you had might not have been a dream,” Dustin paced back and forth as he mulled their theory over. “What if Billy somehow got into your mind, like a psychic connection? El has done it before.”

“I have powers. Billy didn’t.”

“So how do I get Billy to talk to me again? And how do I know what he’s trying to say?”

“When I was trapped in the upside down, my mom used Christmas lights and painted letters on the wall to know what I was saying. I could hear her and I figured out what to do to get her to see me. If I could hear her then, maybe Billy can hear us now too. Maybe we could go back to Starcourt and try and get Billy to talk to us.”

“Good idea Will.”

“Okay, but even if Billy is still alive and we figure out where he is, how do we get to him?”

“We go in.”

Notes:

Comments and kudos are always appreciated. You can find me on Tumblr at strxngehxrringrove