Chapter Text
Chapter 3: I'm Right Here
He felt like he was dying. His lungs felt like they were full of water. He was freezing. Please find me. Please.
*****
That night all of the kids decided to have one of their massive sleepovers at Steve’s house. After the revelations of the day, no one really wanted to be alone. Steve didn’t blame them, and he opened his house up to them as always. He ordered them pizza and let them watch movies, but at midnight he finally sent them to bed. The boys piled into the room next door to Steve’s, and the three girls went to the guest room that Max usually occupied.
Max lent Caroline an old t-shirt and shorts to sleep in. Once they were in their pajamas and sprawled across Max’s bed, which was somehow big enough for the three of them with room to spare, Max spoke to Caroline for the first time all night.
“So, when your mom left, why did she only take you? Why leave Billy behind.”
“Truthfully I have no idea, I mean I was just a kid but I knew something was weird. She always just told me that Billy couldn’t come with us. I cried so hard when she made us leave him. She always promised she would come back for him, but she never did. I didn’t think it was fair. And it wasn’t.”
“Did you know that Neil was hurting Billy?”
“No, not really. Like I said, I was a kid. But I remember him hurting my mom, and now that I’m older I realize it wasn’t much of a stretch to assume he might be hurting Billy too. Did you know?”
“Not until the end. I saw him yell and get angry but I never saw him actually hurt him like physically. But he was, because of me. Every time I got in trouble, Billy took the fall for it. Now I know why he was so angry at me, and why he blamed me for us having to leave California.”
“What do you mean?”
“When my mom married Neil, he made Billy my personal chauffeur. I don’t know if they were trying to force us to spend time together or what, but part of that was Billy driving me to my dad’s place on the weekends. One time, Billy came back to pick me up and his face was all busted up and it looked like his wrist might have been broken. He just wanted to get me and get out, but my dad made him come inside and let him clean him up. By the time he was finished Billy was freaking out, he was telling me we had to hurry because Neil was going to be mad if we were late. I guess, my dad put two and two together about the whole thing and called the cops. They took us both into the station, but I didn’t know anything and Billy refused to tell them that Neil was hitting him so there was nothing they could do. After that, it was tense for a few days but then Neil told us we were moving. Then we came to the tiniest town in the midwest. I guess so Neil could beat his son in peace.”
“That’s why Billy was so angry. He was hurting,” El said. “In the end, I saw it all. Neil hurting him and his mom. Billy was trying to survive.”
“I know that now. I wish I could talk to him one more time, tell him it’s okay or something.”
“I’m so sorry Max. I’m assuming you weren’t close, but it still hurts like hell, losing someone you care about.”
“No you’re right, Billy and I weren’t really close. I realize now that he was just trying to protect me. But I loved him, even though he was a giant asshole. Even when the mind flayer was possessing him, he was still kind of there. At least he was in the beginning, and I finally saw him for what he really was. A scared kid, just like the rest of us.”
Caroline leaned over and laid her head on Max’s shoulder.
“I know we’re both holding on to the hope that Billy is still alive. That everything I’ve experienced is real and not just some crazy hallucination or nightmare. But at the same time, I don’t want to get my hopes up, in case it turns out to be a bust and Billy really is dead.”
“I know what you mean. It almost seems too good to be true. But if Billy really is out there, I want to do whatever it takes to get him out and back with us where he belongs.”
“Yeah. Me too.”
At that moment, there was a tap on the door and Steve poked his head in.
“Hey, girls lights out okay? I called Joyce, we’re gonna go visit her tomorrow, see what she can tell us that might help us find a way to contact Billy.”
“Okay. Goodnight Steve,” Max said.
“Goodnight,” he replied, flipping off the lights and shutting the door carefully behind him.
*****
She was in the passenger seat of Billy’s car, a blue Camaro that matched the model he’d had on his dresser for years. He was driving too fast and listening to his music too loud. Metallica maybe, it was hurting her ears but she didn’t care, she was with her brother again.
“I missed you, Caroline,” he said, taking his eyes off the road to grin at her. His eyes were just as blue and his smile just as big as she remembered.
“I missed you too Billy.”
He took her hand in his and gripped it tightly. He pulled off the road and turned to look at her. The sky around them was suddenly dark, thunder rumbled as Billy began to speak.
“You have to find me, Caroline. You have to save me,” Black veins trailed up her brother’s neck, his eyes going dark.
“Where are you, Billy? I can’t help you if I don’t know where you are.”
“I’m right here.”
Suddenly, the scene changed and they were standing somewhere underground. Red smoke swirled around them.
“Billy, what is this place? Please tell me what’s going on!”
“He’s coming Caroline! You have to hurry please!”
“Billy! Billy!”
She woke up with Billy’s name on her lips, shaking like a leaf. Max and El were hovering over her.
“Are you okay? What happened?” Max asked, taking her hand and squeezing it tight.
Steve burst into the room, the boys right on his heels. His hair was sticking up in all directions, he looked like he just woke up but he was holding a bat full of nails, ready to swing.
“What’s going on? Is everyone okay?”
“I had another dream about Billy,” Caroline answered. She pushed herself up in bed so that she could look at Steve. He moved into the room and leaned against the wall across from the bed and the boy stayed hovering in the doorway.
“We were in his car and we were driving. It felt like a normal, happy dream. And then all of a sudden something shifted. We were underground somewhere, there was red smoke or something and Billy’s veins were black. He was yelling at me that someone was coming and that I had to hurry. He sounded really scared. Steve what the hell does all of this mean.”
“I wish I knew kiddo. We’re gonna talk to Mrs. Beyers today and we’re going to figure this out. If Billy really is out there, if he’s alive somewhere in the upside down, we’re going to find him. Okay?”
“Okay.”
“Alright, you guys get dressed and eat breakfast, then we’ll go meet Mrs. Byers.”
*****
After breakfast, which mostly consisted of Max and Caroline picking at their food, too nervous to eat anything, and the boys scarfing down their leftovers, Steve and the kids crammed themselves into his car and made the drive out to Hopper’s cabin. He made a mental note to find a bigger car if he was going to be toting seven kids around for another year.
“So what’s the deal with this cabin in the middle of nowhere?” Caroline asked.
The drive had been strangely silent and she was doing anything she could to break through the cloud of tension that had fallen over the group since the morning.
“Hopper, the old Hawkins police chief lived out here. Until all of the upside-down stuff started happening, he was sort of a recluse. Then when we found El, he took her in, and sort of acted as her dad. He kind of had a thing with Joyce too, but, he died last year on the same night as Billy, closing the gate that was opened by the Russians. Joyce kept his cabin and she and Jonathan fixed it up to make it livable for them when they come to visit Hawkins. We all sort of pitched in to help and to come back every once and a while when they aren’t in town to keep it in shape. It’s a nice place now. And it’s safe.”
When they pulled up, Jonathan and Joyce were waiting for them on the porch. Joyce gave all of the kids big hugs, the kind you give people you haven’t seen in years, even though it had only been two days and Jonathan greeted them all with a smile and a wave, throwing an arm across his brother’s shoulders. When Joyce reached Caroline she gave her a long hug, the best hug she’d gotten in a long time. For a minute, it felt like her own mom holding her, instead of someone else’s.
“You must be Caroline, I’m Joyce, Will’s mom. This is my other son Jonathan.”
“ It’s nice to meet you. Steve says you might know something about how to reach my brother?”
“Maybe, I hope so. Why don’t you come inside, we’ll make some cocoa and we’ll talk.”
The kids followed her inside and crammed themselves into the living room. Max and Caroline ended up sitting on the floor, leaning back against the couch. Joyce distributed steaming mugs to them all, then perched herself on the arm of the chair Jonathan was sitting on.
“So Steve told me a bit of the story over the phone, but can you tell me again?”
Caroline started into her story again, for the third time in two days. She felt like every time she explained it, the story got even longer and weirder.
When she finished Jonathan leaned forward and said, “Well that explains why Billy was such an ass.”
“Jonathan,” Joyce scolded, lightly slapping his arm. “So you all believe that the Billy who died here in Hawkins was a clone.”
“A doppelganger,” Dustin interjected.
“A doppelganger,” Joyce corrected herself before continuing. “And that the real Billy is alive, trapped in the upside down.”
“Will said that when he was trapped in the upside down, you used Christmas lights to talk to him. Do you think something like that would work with Billy?”
“It might. But I’m not sure if it would work here. Billy died at Starcourt right?”
“Yeah he did,” Steve said. “Do you think the place where it happened matters?”
“The way the upside down works is still kind of fuzzy to all of us. But from what I do understand it’s an alternate version of Hawkins. Everything that exists here us also there.”
“I was in an alternate version of my house. So I guess it makes sense that Billy would be in an alternate Star Court,” Will ventured.
“But Starcourt burned down,” Max said. “There’s nothing left.”
“Well, the shell is still there. It’s worth a shot right?” Steve said.
“Is it really worth a shot though?”
“What are you talking about Mike?” Max whirled around to stare him down.
“In case I’m the only one who remembers, Billy was a jerk. He threatened Max, tried to hurt Lucas, almost killed Steve, and tried to kill us. More than once.”
“Friends help friends Mike,” El reminded.
“And you’re the one who came up with the doppelganger theory,” Max’s voice has started to raise.
“That doesn't change anything. She’s not our friend,” he pointed to Caroline. “And Billy sure as hell wasn’t.”
“Mike,” Steve said through gritted teeth.
“He’s right,” Caroline spoke up. “I’m not your friend. I’m a crazy girl who showed up out of nowhere claiming that my brother who you all thought was dead came to me in a dream. You have no reason to actually believe me let alone help me.”
With that, she turned and walked out the door. She sat down on the front steps with her head in her hands. She could still hear Steve and the other kids bickering inside. Behind her, the door opened, and quiet footsteps made their way toward her and sat down beside her.
“I know Mike can be a jerk,” Will said quietly. “He’s not great at accepting new friends. You should have heard all the shit he gave Lucas and Dustin when they tried to bring in Max. I don’t know why he’s that way.”
“Have I given him a reason to hate me that much?”
“He doesn’t hate you. You’re just not the kind of person Mike normally welcomes with open arms.”
“What do you mean?”
“Looking at you, you seem like the kind of girl at our school who would turn and walk the other way if we even glanced in your general direction. I know that you’re not like that, but Mike is big on first impressions, unfortunately.”
“I look like someone he wouldn’t be friends with so he automatically doesn’t like me? That’s a little unfair.”
“Yeah, it is. But the others don’t see it the same way. Max loves you. I think she’s glad to have someone who really understands what she’s going through. Dustin, Lucas, and I really like you too, we think you’re cool. I think El does too, but she likes most people who are nice to her. I know Billy was a jerk, but I saw him at the end. He gave up his life so the mind flayer wouldn’t kill El. He sacrificed himself to save us all. Somewhere deep down, Billy was a good guy who deserves to be saved.”
“Thank you, Will.”
“Of course. And no matter what Mike says, if it comes down to it, I’d follow you into the upside down.”
“I’m going too,” Max said behind them.
Both kids turned to see Steve and the rest of the party in the doorway.
“I’m not letting you two have all the fun,” Dustin said.
“You need backup,” Lucas agreed.
“Someone has got to keep you little shits alive,” Steve said with a shrug.
“I’m going,” El said.
They all turned to look at Mike.
“Fine, whatever. I guess I’ll go too.”
“Alright,” Steve said. “Looks like we’ve got work to do.”
