Chapter Text
The nice thing about this time around, Steve thinks -and, yes, he knows it’s horrible to think anything about this situation is nice, not when people are dead and a literal 30 foot monster was involved- is that he doesn’t have to process it alone. And, yes, he had Dustin last time, but it was different. Because last time (and, God, this was so embarrassing) he wasn’t just processing a monster- he was also dealing with having his heart fucking ripped out and shredded, and Dustin wasn’t much help with that. So, for the most part, he had been alone. (And, yes, Nancy had wanted to talk to him about the monsters, to see if he was okay, but he couldn’t even really look her in the eyes then).
This time, though, he has Robin. Which is, honestly, incredible. Having Robin as a best friend is, in some ways, better than having Nancy as a girlfriend. Nancy, he now realizes, had truly believed that he was stupid and emotionally stunted and had just accepted it. (To be fair, he had accepted these things a long time ago). Robin, though, for whatever reason, is under the impression that he just lets himself be stupid and stunted and that he could, actually, be a lot more.
So Robin pushes him. She doesn’t let him pretend he wasn’t scared, she doesn’t let him act like he doesn’t have a lot of theories about what exactly the Russians were doing with the Upside Down. She forces him -literally forces him- to talk about what he was thinking about when the Russians were interrogating him (embarrassingly enough, he had been trying to time out how long it was until Dustin should be above ground again. And he had been thinking about Robin, and if they were hurting her or not. And he had even thought, just a little bit, about his mom). He feels, for the first time, like he isn’t shoving all of the monster stuff into a tiny corner of his brain. He’s actually thinking about it.
The downside of having Robin to go through it with, of course, is that Robin has questions. Hundreds of questions. Thousands of em. Questions that he, in the last three years, has never even thought to ask.
So that’s how they ended up here, for the third time in the two weeks since the mall attack, at Steve’s house, sitting in the living room with all the brats scattered around them. (All the brats minus El and Mike, that is. El hasn’t left the Byers house since the attack, and Mike spends most of his time consoling her. Steve can’t imagine- every time he thinks about Hopper, his throat constricts, and he barely even knew the man).
“Okay, so the flickering lights mean-“
“Presence in the Upside Down. We think.”
“We’ve never really tested it.”
“Well, I mean, Will pretty much-“
“Yeah, but it’s not like it was consistent! Ergo, we’ve never tested it.”
All of the nerds basically trip over themselves to answer Robin’s questions, each answer escalating to a shout before it’s over. Robin, for her part, just nods like she’s actually getting all of this. Hell, Steve thinks, she probably is.
“Okay and the demodogs are just baby Demogorgons?”
“Yeah, we think.”
“Are they birthed? Or hatched?”
“Unsure.”
“I spit Dart out.”
“Demogorgon isn’t, like, the scientific name.” Steve feels the need to interject. “It’s a-“
Robin cuts him off with one of the most condescending looks he’s ever seen.
“I know what a Demogorgon is.”
All of the boys look at her like she’s Mother Mary incarnate, and Steve just gives up.
“Which, in a way, is way more embarrassing for you than it is for me.” He retorts, but she’s not even listening. She’s too busy asking about if the demodogs have humanoid characteristics.
The boys seem genuinely thrilled to answer all of these questions, and Steve realizes that, to them, even though they’ve almost died way too many times, there is a part of this that is still utterly fascinating to them. They have all this knowledge that almost no one in the world does, and they’re never allowed to talk about. Robin’s their dream. (She stays away from questions about the Mind Flayer, though, at least when Will’s around. That one’s a little too fresh and a little too awful to poke and prod with him in the room yet.)
Max, though, is uncharacteristically silent for many of these meetings. It can’t be that she doesn’t have opinions- Steve has seen her around these boys enough to know that she can and will hold her own in a screaming match. And she’s smart, too, so it’s not that she’s like Steve, who feels like anything he theorizes will automatically be proven wrong. It’s almost like...well, it’s almost like she’s in a whole different world while they’re talking. She’s physically with them, yes, but she just stares into the distance for most of it, furrowing her brow and frowning. She even passes up more than one opportunity to absolutely roast Dustin alive for saying something even Steve knows is absurdly stupid. (For example, at one point, Dustin posits that, maybe, Dart sought him out on purpose because the Demogorgon had been impressed by his fighting spirit in the first attack).
He asks Lucas about it, when they’re alone in the kitchen, trying to see if she’s okay, but Lucas just stares at him. “Me and Max aren’t like you and Nancy or Mike and El,” he says, the tone of his voice making it clear what exactly he thought about couples like that. “We don’t tell each other every thought that pops into our heads. And she’s fine. I mean, her evil stepbrother was just possessed by an even more evil monster, and he almost killed us, like, a hundred times, so there’s that shit. But she’s fine.”
“Has she said anything about Billy?” Steve asks, but Lucas shakes his head.
“Just that he’s leaving her alone.”
There had been a period of Steve’s life when he found it almost impossible to stop thinking about Billy. Every night, before bed, he wondered what would have happened if Billy had killed him. (He’d be dead, obviously, he knew that, but he wondered how people would’ve reacted. He wondered how Nancy would’ve reacted.) In the hallways, at school, when he saw Billy coming, he looked the other way. Every time he talked to a girl who wasn’t Nancy, he heard Billy’s voice in his head. “Plenty of bitches in the sea.” When his mind wandered in his class, he would find himself thinking about the fact that he’d almost died twice in one night, and that one of the causes was literally sitting in the same classroom as him.
Billy left him alone, though. Literally never even looked sideways at him after the night he almost bashed in his skull. And, over time, Billy just sort of faded from Steve’s mind. Other stuff became more important- getting into college, not getting into college, finding a job, slinging ice cream. Steve just stopped thinking about him.
It had probably been months since the last time Steve had thought about Billy Hargrove when Steve crashes into the Camaro. And, at first, he literally doesn’t even think twice about the fact that Billy’s there. Of course Billy is somehow there. He has a knack for showing up on the worst nights of their lives. Steve is so unsurprised to see Billy trying to kill Nancy, actually, that he initially doesn’t even realize that Billy is a part of this. He assumes that, like last time, Billy had just shown up with a blood lust when they all really had much bigger things to deal with.
It doesn’t take long, though, for him to realize that he was very, very wrong. Billy’s more than involved in the situation. Billy is the situation.
And then Billy, who had just minutes ago tried to kill all of them, is some sort of goddamn hero. And then Billy’s almost dead, and then it’s all over again, just as quickly as it had all started. (The others, Steve eventually learns, had had more of a heads up than the Scoop Troop that the Mind Flayer was back. For him and Dustin, though, there was no warning at all, just a thirty foot monster made out of human goop.)
And now, for the second time in his life, Steve finds himself unable to stop thinking about Billy Hargrove. He just keeps thinking about how lost and quiet Will was for months after the Gate was closed, about how fragile he had seemed. And he keeps trying to imagine Billy even remotely resembling that. Steve doesn’t think he’ll every forget the look on Billy’s face when the Mind Flayer was about to devour him- how terrified he looked, how he had closed his eyes like he was ready. He can’t forget the way Max screamed over Billy’s body, either, in those moments where they all thought he was dead and it was, genuinely, one of the worst sounds Steve had ever heard in his life. And he keeps thinking about himself, too, last October, when he felt like he had to deal with this all alone and there was no one to talk to and everything hurt (and he had only been dumped and almost killed, not possessed, too).
And, yeah, the guy almost killed him, but after everything that he saw at Starcourt, that’s hardly the first thing Steve thinks about when he thinks about Billy Hargrove. And so, after talking to Lucas in the kitchen and listening to Robin ask another dozen questions that are so nerdy it’s almost cringeworthy, Steve finds himself saying, almost without meaning to, “hey, Max, how’s Billy?”
And Max absolutely freezes.
