Actions

Work Header

Oh, You Pretty Things

Chapter 4: Put On Some Clothes, Shake Off Your Bed

Notes:

Warnings: mentioned child abuse.

Again, thanks for the feedback!! I’m hoping that later I’ll have the time to reply to individual comments, but right now just know that I really appreciate it!

Chapter Text

For as long as she’s known him, the question “how’s Billy?” has never actually meant “how’s Billy?” That was one of the first things Max learned about living with Billy Hargrove.

In the beginning, when her mom asks “how’s Billy?” what she means is: “how’s our new family? Are you okay? Are you going to forgive me yet?” And Max always says “he’s fine,” because she doesn’t want her mom to cry again.

When the girls at school suddenly all want to be her friend and they ask her “how’s Billy?” what they mean is: “is being your friend going to pay off? Is it worth being friends with you to see your stepbrother?” And Max always says “he’s fine,” because she knows it’s boring.

When Neil asks her “how’s Billy?” what he means is: “what has Billy done wrong today?” And Max, one time, in the beginning, said “he’s being an asshole.” After that, though, she always just says “he’s fine,” because she may hate Billy, but she hates the way he looks at her, scared and betrayed, even more.

When her new friends ask her “how’s Billy?” what they mean is: “are you safe?” And Max always says “he’s fine,” because she’s not scared of him, not anymore. Not after she swung a bat at him and not after she listened to his dad beat the shit out of him the same night.

When Steve asks “how’s Billy?” though, with no inflection and no bitterness, she doesn’t know what he means. What she knows, though, is that she can’t tell him the truth, because she’s afraid everyone else in the room will say “good,” and she can’t take having to fight for Billy right now. So she just nods and says “he’s fine,” because that’s what she always says. And Steve looks a little disappointed, and she wonders if he’s disappointed because Billy’s fine or because he can tell that she’s lying.

xxx

Neil isn’t happy about the wrecked Camaro. He isn’t happy about the hospital bills, either. He also isn’t happy that both of his children had been at a mall involved in some huge scandal when they were supposed to be at the 4th of July celebration. And he most definitely isn’t happy with the explanation that Billy and Max give him.

They both tell him exactly what they’re supposed to, of course. Before Billy leaves the hospital, everyone is prepped extensively by men in suits about exactly what to tell people about their involvement. It‘s a good story, too, about an electrical fire and falling beams and brothers who were just trying to look out for their sisters and kids who were at the mall because they had been promised free ice cream and ice cream workers who were trying to celebrate Independence Day with their friends. None of it matters, though. Billy knows that even as he’s being quizzed and drilled and signing papers pledging him to secrecy. Because Neil always -always, always, every time, no matter what- knows when Billy is lying to him. Without exception.

And when Billy and Max walk out the hospital doors, and they see Neil standing there talking to men in suits, his eyes locked on Billy’s face, Billy just turns to Max with his best shit eating grin.
“Told you, Maxine,” he says in the singsong voice he used to use when he was about to do something like try to run her friends over. “You shoulda just let me die.”

Max, however, just refuses to accept that Billy dying wouldn’t actually be that bad of an end to Billy’s story, at least not in his mind. She seems to think, for some reason, that the world will be better if he stays alive for right now.

And so, for the first week that they’re home, Max refuses to leave Billy’s side. At first, he thinks it’s because she’s still a little scared. And he can see it, too- she’s jumpy at little noises, she hugs her mom way more than she used to. Every night, she tells every single one of her little nerds goodnight before she can sleep. (Of course, she says things like “hey, Mike, shut the fuck up so I can go to sleep,” and “goodnight shitheads,” but her face is a lot more revealing than her voice). Max, Billy guesses, is just staying close to him because he’s the only participant of that night that she can be in close proximity to 24/7.

Billy is wrong, though. He realizes this after a few days. Yeah, she may be sticking close to him because she’s still shell-shocked, but there’s more to it than that. She’s trying to save him. She’s trying to save him from Neil.

It’s this weird thing their family does- pretending no one knows about the relationship between Billy and Neil, when, obviously, everyone knows. Susan’s watched Neil hit him before, for Christ’s sakes. He shares a bedroom wall with Max. It’s a whole thing, though. Neil may know that Max damn well knows that he beats his son, but he never hits Billy in front of her, because it would too permanently shatter the illusion. Hell, even Billy and Max have never talked about it, even if she’s bringing him bandaids and he’s bleeding on his floor. It’s just how it works. And Billy has always hated this about the Hargrove/Mayfield family, because it’s always reminded him that no one can never know the truth, ever, even if they already do.

Now, though, Max isn’t using it to keep Billy trapped. She’s using it to protect him, and that- well, that’s never been done before. It’s not gonna work, though. Like, yeah, it’s working in the short term sense, and Neil hasn’t even touched him since he got home. But, long term, it’s gonna backfire. Billy can see it. He knows his dad better than Max does, and he knows that Neil isn’t cooling down- he’s working up. And when he finally gets his hands on Billy? Well, he’s had a lot more time to think about just how angry he is.

Billy tries to explain this, on the eighth day. He hasn’t been able to talk much since that night at Starcourt. Just can’t find any words worth saying. And Max, who has never had problems with silences before, now can’t bear more than a second of quiet. For days now, every waking moment has been filled with the sound of Max’s voice. He’s not annoyed, though, because it gives him something to focus on. Because in those few seconds of silence, the places his mind goes when he doesn’t have anything to focus on? Well... Max should’ve just let him die.

Now, though, he finally speaks, cutting her off in the middle of an hour long explanation about how to do a certain skateboard trick.

“Max.” His voice sounds tougher than he remembers it, and she stares at him with wide eyes like he’s a ghost. “You’re gonna have to leave me, at some point.”

Her face -which has always been way, way too expressive, like, goddamn, Maxine, not everyone needs to know every emotion you feel as you feel it- first looks scared, then upset, and then angry. She answers with resolve.

“No, Billy, Neil will-“

He cuts her off, because he doesn’t want to hear her finish the sentence. “Max, listen to me. I know Neil. I’ve been doing this for awhile. And I- listen. It’s not like you can stay in the same room as me for the rest of our lives. And it’s usually a lot better in small bursts than one big moment. And right now? We’re building up to one helluva big moment.”

Her whole face crumbles, and she looks so guilty, and that’s not what Billy wanted, so he sighs and says the first thing that comes to his mind. “Max, I killed a lot of people. You don’t need to feel bad for me.”

She looks away from him, and says in the most neutral tone he’s ever heard from her: “Yeah. I know. But you saved my best friend.”

 

Max listens and leaves, eventually. Goes to Harrington’s house, of all places. And Neil is ready.

And when Neil finally lets him know how he feels? Well, a lot has happened in the last two weeks. And when Neil tells him he’s more trouble than he’s worth, Billy’s not gonna pretend that he doesn’t agree. And Billy’s not gonna pretend that Neil’s fists don’t feel a little bit like atonement.

xxx

When Steve asks “how’s Billy?” he means: “how’s Billy?”
And when Max says “he’s fine,” she means: “he hasn’t left his room in five days and I think he might be dead.”