Actions

Work Header

Oh, You Pretty Things

Chapter 21: All the Strangers Came Today

Notes:

Warnings: mentioned child abuse

Here you go- hope you guys like it. Stay safe <3

Chapter Text

No one says anything once they’re back in the car. Billy is pale from exertion, and there’s a tremor in his hand, and his T-shirt is drenched with sweat. Robin and Dustin sit in the back, faces grim, and Steve grips the steering wheel so hard he thinks he can feel a blister forming.

It was easier to get down the hill than it was to get up, but Billy had a hard time staying upright. Steve HATES this hill. He HATES this fucking hill where only bad things happen and where he has to listen to people assume he only wants sex out of them and where he has to wait to hear if everyone he likes is dead and he HATES hearing Max cry. He hates hearing Max cry, and, frankly, he’s heard way too much of it.

Steve will never forget what Max sounded like when she screamed over what they thought was Billy’s dead body. He will never forget what she sounded like when she found Billy in his room, bloody and broken. And he will never forget what Max sounded like, pleading and sobbing, over a crackling walkie talkie while no one responded to her.

No one says a word in the car. No one says a word except for Dustin, who, as he gets out of the car, turns to Steve and says solemnly, “I told you he was a fucking bastard.”

xxx

Billy walks straight in the house and to the bedroom when they get back. He’s clearly in pain, arms wrapped around his ribs, and he doesn’t even look at Joyce.

Steve follows a second later, his cheeks red and his jaw set.

“I have to take Robin to her house, okay? I mean I don’t have to, but she- I- I told her- and Billy-“

“Steve.” Joyce says firmly, and he looks at her with a face that acutely reminds her that he must be so, so tired. She doesn’t know what happened out there—she thought contacting Max was a good thing, thought it meant something that Billy was so determined, thought it meant something good. Steve’s face tells her she was wrong.

He gestures towards the direction Billy disappeared. “I- I can’t be around him right now. I’m sorry. I know I’m a bad person, I just...I can’t look at him, okay? Not right now.” Steve’s voice cracks, and he shakes his head. “I know...I know I’m not...I know I’m a bad person, I can’t-“

“Steve,” Joyce says again, placing a hand on his arm. “You are not a bad person. Just go, okay? Take Robin home. You’re not...you’re fine.”

Steve nods wearily, clearly not hearing a word she’s saying. He reminds Joyce of Jonathan, sometimes, something she never would’ve guessed before this week, something she’s sure Jonathan could never see. But all the old self loathing, the exhaustion, the constant turmoil- Steve has a pretty face. He hides it all better. Joyce wants to hug him, wants to let him cry again. But Steve has Robin, and Billy is alone.

“Take as long as you need, Steve.”

xxx

Steve feels sick to his stomach he’s so mad and so guilty and just...God, did Billy really think Steve was just helping him so he’d get to kiss him? Steve should never have even touched his face (that was what saved him, though). What had Steve done? Was Dustin right? Was this Billy? Someone who made his stepsister cry while they all listened and then let her scream and sob without answering? Who turned off a walkie talkie without even flinching while a fourteen year old begged him to talk to her? Did Steve help Billy up that hill just so he could be the person Steve swore to Nancy and Dustin he wasn’t? (Billy is not the person they think he is, he can’t be, this is a different Billy, who says his dad hates him and cries on the floor and lets Steve help him up a hill). God, how many Billys are there? Steve thinks he knows Billy? It’s been less than a week and Steve has seriously considered kissing someone who once attacked a middle schooler and broke a plate over Steve’s head and, JESUS, what the FUCK is WRONG-

“Steve. Steve. Steve. Dude, Harrington. Talk to me.”

Robin is staring at him, and, shit, Steve’s already halfway to her house.

“You okay there, Steve?”

“I shouldn’t have dragged you into this.” Steve says with a heave. “I shouldn’t have—God, Robin, I get you mixed up in the worst stuff, and-“

“HEY.” Robin slaps at his arm. “Listen! You don’t get me involved in stuff, okay? I do. I chose to help you translate. I chose to look for Russians. I chose to come to your house, I chose to come see you when Nancy asked me to. I chose. I’m not- I’m the one involving myself, not you. So don’t-“ she laughs, but it’s forced. She’s worried, he thinks. “Don’t think so highly of yourself.”

He nods.

“Good. Okay. So. Talk to me.” She instructs, her voice a bit softer.

He breathes in deeply. The sun’s going down. This time yesterday he was looking for Billy. This time yesterday, he hadn’t even thought about kissing anyone yet. This time yesterday, Billy still could’ve died.

“I don’t know what I’m doing,” he whispers, and he’s alarmed to hear it leave his mouth, to realize how real it is. “I don’t know what I’m doing, and everything is wrong. I don’t know who Billy is, and I don’t know who Max is, and I’m trying to help them, and I can’t do a damn thing right. He just- what happened up there? I don’t know what the fuck that was! And every five minutes, that’s how it is. I think I’ve got a handle on it and then I don’t, I’m totally wrong, and he’s not who he was two minutes ago, and I can never get it right. Every damn thing I do is wrong.”

“Steve,” Robin says softly, “I haven’t been here for all of it, but you’re not...it’s not all wrong. That’s clear.”

“No, you have no idea. I’m an IDIOT, Robin, a fucking idiot, and I...I don’t know what I’m doing.”

Robin presses her lips together for a second, eyebrows knit. She sighs. “Do you know how many people know I like girls?”

Steve sputters. He has no idea where this is going. “What- I- I don’t know-“

“Four, Steve. My older sister. Amber, from school. A girl I kissed at summer camp when I was fourteen. And you.”

“I-“

“Do you know why, Steve?”

“Cause you thought we were about to be killed by Russians and I was hitting on you. And we were high.”

“No. Well, I mean, yeah. It’s doubtful I would’ve told you without the Russians. But. Listen. It’s ‘cause I trust you. Because even if you’re an idiot and a jackass sometimes, you’re a good guy. And you try to do the right thing. You might not always know what’s going on, but...you’re doing your best. You always are.”

Steve sighs. Robin is so smart and so funny and so much better than him and she doesn’t even know and...ah, what the hell? “I almost tried to kiss Billy last night.”

Robin’s eyebrows shoot up. “You what?”

“I almost tried to kiss Billy last night. I thought about it. And he knows.”

Robin is quiet for just a second too long, and Steve grips the steering wheel even harder. Finally, she snorts.

“Well, shit.”

xxx

Joyce brings Billy soup and water, and he looks at her the same way he does every time she hands him food—surprised and suspicious and sorry, all at once.

“I need to rewrap your ribs, if you’ll let me.”

He nods silently, slowly but diligently taking his shirt off. He can do it without help now, but it’s clear it still hurts him. He’s quiet as she unwraps his ribs and checks his back for infections, quiet as she rewraps his ribcage. It’s not until she’s almost done that he says, in a voice she’s never heard before:

“Are you-“ he breaks himself off, cheeks blushing, wincing.

“Am I what, Billy?”

He shakes his head, but she waits.

“Are you mad at me?”

There’s a weight on her chest, pressing and cracking. “No, sweetie, of course not-“

“They all are. You should be. I was...I made Max cry again. On purpose. I...” he shakes his head again, eyes shut. “You should be.”

She has no idea what happened up there. No idea why Steve was upset, no idea why Billy is crushed. But she can guess. “Billy, I’m not mad.”

He opens his eyes and jerks his head, venom in his voice. “They don’t...they don’t know what it’s like. The things you have to do. And I thought...I was wrong about Neil. I know now. And I- they have NO idea what it’s like.” He spits the words out, and looks at her with shining eyes and a clenched jaw. “You do what you have to.”

She nods. “I know.” Her jaw juts forward and she tries to hold all the anger back, but she knows the look on Billy’s face. Knows the feeling in his chest. “I know what it’s like.”

The fire drains out of him, and he nods, his face already softer. “I know you do.”

She lays a hand on his shoulder, looks into his eyes. “I could never be mad at you, Billy. Not for this.”

And, finally, Billy Hargrove breaks.