Chapter Text
Billy has never been enough. Billy has never even been almost enough. He doesn’t even know what enough looks like, just knows he’s never come close—never been strong enough, never been tough enough, never been man enough.
Never been enough to not be scared of his dad, never been enough to get someone to stay. Never been enough to fight off being possessed by monsters, apparently, though that had hardly been a concern before last month.
Billy has just never been...anything, really. Never been good. Never been anything other than angry. He knows he’s not likable. He doesn’t care. He knows he’s not lovable. No point in caring about that, either—if he couldn’t get his parents to like him, it doesn’t seem likely anyone else would. Billy is fine with all of this. He doesn’t need to be enough for anyone. Billy is fine being angry, and he’s fine being disliked. It works for him.
But when Joyce looks at him and says she’ll never be mad at him...well, she’s the only person in the world who’s ever felt that way about him. And all of the sudden he realizes that, maybe, he wishes he could be enough, just once.
xxx
There’s a moment where Steve thinks about spending the night at his house. He’s mad at Billy, and he’s frustrated, and he has to process a, like, three hour conversation with Robin, which is just a lot more than he was ready for, and he has to find Dustin tomorrow to apologize, and he just doesn’t really want to look at Billy’s face right now.
He thinks about going home. He should go home. It’s weird, right? That he’s not sleeping at home? It’s weird. Steve should go home, to his real bed, to his real house, with a pool, and his own shower, and stop sleeping on the world’s worst couch. It just makes sense. Steve should go home.
Steve doesn’t go home.
xxx
Steve’s not coming back to the Byers’. Billy accepts this the moment Steve left. He saw the look on Steve’s face; he knows what anger looks like. He finally cracked Steve, and Steve finally gets it now. Steve’s not coming back.
It’s okay. Billy doesn’t need Steve to come back.
It’s okay.
At 11:00pm, Steve comes back. And Billy, for the second time that night, realizes that he wants to be enough. He wants to try to be enough.
xxx
Steve hasn’t been asleep for thirty minutes before he is woken up by someone shaking his shoulder. His first thought before his eyes are even focused is that Billy left again, and his heart is racing the moment he wakes up.
But it’s not Joyce shaking him, and it’s not Will or Eleven or even Jonathan. It’s Billy.
“Harrington. Take a smoke with me.” Steve stares at him, and Billy rolls his eyes. “You can be pissed all day and back, just come out here, okay?”
And then he walks out onto the front porch like nothing’s wrong.
Steve waits for a second. He’s mad at Billy—he is; even if it’s the wrong thing to be. Anyone who heard Max crying like she did would be mad at Billy, especially when Max has been killing herself trying to take care of him all week. But...well, Robin said a lot of stuff. And he said a lot of stuff. And it’s Billy, which means something now, even though it never did before.
Billy’s already started smoking by the time Steve gets outside, and he holds the cigarette in the corner of his mouth while he offers Steve the pack. It’s easy for Billy to look cool, Steve thinks. And he gets it. It used to be easy for him to look cool, too.
“You’re pissed,” Billy says casually as Steve lights a cigarette.
“Yeah.” Steve replies, not really looking at him. There’s no point in lying. He’s not as angry as he was five hours ago. But he is tired. He is frustrated. He doesn’t know what’s going on.
Billy nods. He looks away from Steve, and Steve turns to watch him again. His face is better, a little, with his black eye faded and his various cuts and scratches turning into dark scabs. He still looks fucked up, but he’s not covered with dried blood anymore, and that would help anyone. (He had been on the floor on a mattress for a week before Steve and Max got to him. He had laid there in his own blood for a week).
“Neil hates me.” Billy says, and even though it’s something that he’s already said and something that seems obvious, Steve can tell it takes a lot for Billy to say. “He hates me, and...” he waves a hand towards his own body, ears red. “You can see what that looks like.” He clears his throat. “And I- he’s always hated me. My mom-“
His voice and face are so unlike anything Steve has ever seen before (how many Billys are there?), and Steve can feel it in his stomach, feels nauseous and sad and fucked up all at once. “Billy, you don’t-“
“Let me talk, Harrington. Fuck, just- I’m gonna say this shit. So shut up. Listen.” He inhales sharply, scrunches his nose and shakes his head. “Neil has never liked me. He just doesn’t. He liked my mom, okay? He did. He liked her more than me. But then, I don’t know. She liked me. She was great, ya know? And she liked me.” (Moms are supposed to like their kids, Steve wants to say. But his own mom hasn’t talked to him in two weeks and Billy had just told him to shut up). “And Neil- Neil hated that. They had fights, ‘cause of me. He stopped just getting mad at me—started getting mad at her, too. And he...” Billy jerks his head again, takes the cigarette out of his mouth and stares at it. “He would hit her. I don’t know. It was fucked up, man. And so she left.”
Steve’s stomach drops. He doesn’t know where he thought this story was going, but he didn’t want to hear this. It’s the story that makes sense, yeah, but he had still hoped this wasn’t the actual story.
“And Neil—that’s the problem, okay? He hates me. When people like me, everything just gets messed up and he hates them, too. And it’s been...Max and I never liked each other. I know that you’re all for middle schoolers and that shit and whatever, but I didn’t want Max in my house. And she didn’t want Susan to marry Neil. And, Jesus, NONE of us wanted to move to fucking INDIANA. We didn’t like each other. God, she hated me. I hated her. And it was...Neil thinks Max is funny. He thinks she’s got personality, you know? He likes Susan. He likes Max. He’s always telling me to a better brother. Always telling me to I need to have more respect. Take more responsibility.” He sneers the last few words, face contorted. “That night? When I fucked up your face? God, he was pissed. Thought he was gonna break my neck at one point. Couldn’t breathe. And it—I don’t know.”
He finishes off his cigarette, snubs it into the porch step. Steve is trying to keep his face neutral, trying not to embarrass Billy, trying not to look as sick as he feels.
“This only works when Neil likes Max, okay? And Neil only likes Max if Max doesn’t like me. And now, she....” he runs his tongue along his teeth, worries at his lip. “I realized it last night. When I was walking there. If he knew? That she helped me? That she’s doing all this? He’d hate her. And she’s...she’s a tough little fucker, but she can’t take a beating. Not like the ones Neil gives. And it’s never just once for him, ya know? He doesn’t hit you once and never do it again. That’s what I used to think. That’s what my mom used to think. We were wrong. Once it starts, it... Max can’t come home, Steve. I don’t care if she hates me. I don’t care if she cries.” He looks at Steve, his eyes blurry and angry and exhausted. “I don’t care. She can’t come home.”
Steve tries to find words, tries to react to what all has just been said. There’s something in the air, something heavy, something real, and he knows—can feel it instinctually, can feel it in his bones—that all of this is a truth that’s never been said before.
“You can be pissed, Harrington. But do you get it? If I go home, he’ll kill me. If I don’t go home, he’ll kill Max.”
Steve can feel it, now: the inevitable truth of all of this, the hopelessness of where they’re at. “What are we gonna do?”
Billy lights another cigarette. “No fuckin’ clue.”
Steve watches him, watches his jaw tense up and his fingers tap on his leg. Steve doesn’t know who Billy is. Steve doesn’t know Billy, and maybe that’s not as important as he thought.
“I don’t know why I’m here, Hargrove.” Billy looks at him with raised eyebrows, and Steve taps his cigarette. “You keep asking, and I keep giving shitty answers, ‘cause I don’t know. But I am here. And I’m staying.”
Billy looks at Steve with a face Steve doesn’t know, and says, so softly Steve thinks he imagined it, “Good.”
