Actions

Work Header

Oh, You Pretty Things

Chapter 23: Look Out at Your Children

Notes:

Warning: Mentioned child abuse

That’s right, guys, three chapters in three days; also known as: I’m quarantined and putting off final papers all at the same time.

A heads up, for people who have been following the story: I think we’re roughly 2/3s of the way through now, if my chapters continue to be roughly the same length. I’m starting to feel bad about tagging this fic as Steve/Billy- I never thought we would get this far and they’d only be thinking about kissing. It’s just how it worked, though— the more invested I got, the more that plot line became the least important one. It’s still there, I swear, and there will still be more to come, but I wanted to try to be honest about where Billy is and the kind of headspace he’d be in and whether or not he’d be able to take on anything romantic right now. I like how it’s turning out, so far, but I do apologize if you feel like there was some false advertising there.

This chapter’s a bit different, I feel like— you guys are getting a lot of monologues here. I hope you like it, though. As always, it was a joy to write. (Also, holy shit, the title lines up again. What are the odds?)

Chapter Text

Max isn’t stupid, okay? She knows how Billy is, how Billy can get. She’s not stupid. She doesn’t suddenly think that he hates her again. She had just been...caught off guard. She’d been so happy to know he was okay, and she’d thought he would be happy, too. (Maybe she is stupid). Max knows Billy doesn’t always say what he means, though. Knows he’ll be mean if he thinks it will scare people into doing what he wants.

Billy doesn’t hate her (he can’t, right?). He just doesn’t want her to come home—and it doesn’t take a genius to figure out why that is. (Max had known, just for a second, when Neil and Susan asked if she knew where Billy was, that it wouldn’t be as hard to fall out of Neil’s favor as she used to think). Billy’s trying to be the good guy again, she thinks. That’s what she figures, at least. She’s not stupid.

But she just can’t stop crying. She keeps trying, but she can’t, and she’s just laying in the floor like some sort of BABY, crying and crying. She doesn’t want to be here. She wants to be with Billy, wants to able to look at his face and know he’s okay, wants to tell him to his face that she’s not backing down. She wants to see Steve, wants to see him look at Billy with that face he makes sometimes, the face he makes that lets Max know that she’s not the only person in Billy’s corner. She wants to be with Joyce, who never makes her feel childish and always listens and never pretends nothing’s wrong. She wants to be with Lucas. She wants to be with El. She would even take Mike at this point. She just wants to be in Hawkins.

She wants to be in Hawkins, and she wants to be in California, with no monsters and no Russians and no Neil (but Billy would still be with Neil, even in California). Even when Neil was there, though, when Billy was there and he was awful, California was...it was bigger. They could breathe there.

She’d never wanted to move. Billy’d wanted to even less. He’d screamed at her when they found out, told her it was her fault, and she’d screamed at him, too, told him he ruined everything. Told him she hated him. He’d screamed it right back.

Hawkins was...Billy had always been awful. But Hawkins made him worse. Hawkins made them all worse—it made Billy angrier, made Neil crueler, made her mom quieter. (It made her angrier, too. Put this feeling in the pit of her stomach that made her feel like Billy, made her feel like her dad).

She made friends, though. People she liked. People she loved, even if she couldn’t say it. She got a BOYFRIEND. But Billy...she and Billy started to get better, yeah. She wasn’t scared anymore, and he took her seriously, and they were better. But Billy was getting worse. He couldn’t breathe in Hawkins. He never actually smiled—he smiled to get stuff, smiled so women would flirt, smiled to be cruel, never because he was happy. He wasn’t...she thought he would run away, eventually. Thought he would have to. And she kind of thinks he was planning on it, even though they’ve never talked about it. She thinks he was going to leave for college and just never come back. Just so he could breathe.

And then there had been even bigger monsters and horrible, horrible things and they were all going to die and then they had lived and then Neil had almost killed Billy, anyways, and now Max doesn’t know what comes next.

She just wants to make sure Billy gets the chance to breathe again.

After she’s cried so much she’s sick to her stomach, she does something she hasn’t done since her mom married Neil: she goes to her mom’s bed. Her mom isn’t there; she’s still talking to Linda—Max can hear them, laughing about some high school memory—and Max wonders why she’s the only one who understands the danger Billy is in, the only one who cares that he may not even live long enough to run away. Max has come damn close to losing Billy too many times now, and she just wishes, that, just one time, there’d be someone to cry with her about it. (If Billy knew how much she’d cried about him in the last month he’d tell her she was pathetic. He’d call her a whiny little bitch, probably. He’d tell her he’d killed people—cry over them, instead).

Her mom finds her, eventually. And, for once, her mom doesn’t tell her to stop. She just crawls in bed with Max and holds her, and then Max starts crying all over again, and her mom brushes her hair with her fingers while Max sobs.

Eventually, when Max has nearly cried herself to sleep, her mom says, in a low voice: “I...I had no idea what they were like, Maxine. I knew...Neil told me Billy was trouble, told me it was hard to parent a kid whose favorite parent had abandoned him. And I...I sympathized with that. But I didn’t know...I didn’t know what Billy was really like. Didn’t know how angry he was. Didn’t know how he talked to Neil, didn’t know how he’d treat you. And I didn’t...” she sighs, presses her lips to Max’s forehead. “I knew Neil could be angry. But everyone gets angry with their children, sometimes, and Billy had so many problems, and I...I didn’t realize. What it was all like. And then it was too late, and we were married, and Neil...he’s so good to us, Max.”

“Mom-“ Max starts, voice cracking, but her mom shakes her head.

“It’s not enough. I know. And I never would have...I did so much to try to get you away from angry men, do you know that? I didn’t want you to grow up around angry men. And now...now, Max, all I can think about is how much I’ve failed you.”

Max sniffles, and her mom is looking teary, too, and Max feels like everything in the world is wrong. “I know Billy used to be...I know I used to hate him. But I don’t anymore. And he...Neil could kill him, Mom. Neil might kill him.”

Tears start running down Max’s mom’s face, and she hugs Max tightly. “All I ever wanted to do was keep you safe.”

Max pulls away from her mom and pretends not to see how hurt her mom is, pretends not to notice how much her mom needs her. “I’m safe, Mom. But Billy’s not. And he- his mom didn’t keep him safe. And neither did his dad. And he- he needs us.”

“The safest thing for you is to just stay here, and let them-“

“Mom!” Max yells, and her mom flinches. “It’s safest for us, but Billy- we HAVE to go back, we HAVE to. He cannot be alone in that house if Neil finds him, he’ll die, Mom, Neil will-“

Her mom looks at her, understanding setting in. “I knew you knew,” she whispers. “I knew you knew where he was.”

There’s a dull roar in Max’s ears, and she feels her stomach bottom out. “Mom, I don’t, I-“

Her mom shakes her head. “I knew he couldn’t have left on his own, knew you...you’re like your dad sometimes, Max. You don’t sit quietly in the background.”

“You can’t-“ Max is going into a full on panic, and all she can think about is Billy. If her mom tells Neil, and Neil calls her friends, it’s just a matter of time before something-

Her mom takes both of Max’s hands in hers. “I’m not going to tell Neil. We’re just going to stay here, with Linda, as long as we can. We can- we don’t have to be involved, Max. We can let them work this out.”

“But MOM.” Max is trying not to scream, but it’s hard, and she feels so useless and so angry and so scared all at once. “BILLY. Billy needs me, needs us, needs someone-“

“You’re my daughter, Max, and this time I’m going to protect you, I-“

“Who’s gonna protect Billy?”

Her mom looks at her like her heart is breaking and Max feels a full body shiver run through her. She rips her hands away from her mom, scrambles back from her. “I hate you,” she whispers, but her mom just nods.

“You’ll be a mom, one day, and you’ll understand-“

“Billy needs a mom! Billy needs someone! Billy needs- he could DIE and it’s YOUR fault and I HATE you!” Max stops trying to not scream. “I HATE YOU! YOU’RE GONNA KILL BILLY! You married Neil and you moved us to Hawkins and now you’re just gonna let Billy die and you- I HATE you!”

Max’s mom is sobbing, now, but Max doesn’t care, she just has to get out, has to get away, has to find a way back to Hawkins. She runs out of the bedroom and down the stairs and tries to block out her mom’s face and tears and-

She runs straight into Aunt Linda. Linda has to grab her to keep from falling over, and her eyes go wide as she looks at Max, puffy and tear streaked. She glances up the stairs, where Max’s mom can be heard crying, and looks back at Max, mouth twisting. “Well,” she whispers, and she looks like she understands something, understands something maybe even Max doesn’t. “I think we should go on a walk, don’t you?”

xxx

Billy wishes Max was here, which is bullshit, because there’s also nothing he wants less than for Max to be in the vicinity of Neil. It’s selfish, okay? He knows that. And it’s bullshit. But yeah. He wishes Max was here.

He wishes Max was in on this, wishes his last interaction with her hadn’t involved him ignoring her while she cried. He wishes...that was probably his goodbye to Max, he thinks. That was goodbye. Him being an asshole, her crying. If everything works out, if he gets what he wants, if he gets to leave and Max stays away...it’s fitting, probably. That their last interaction is a bad one. They’ve had like, what, three good interactions, total?

Max will hate him forever if that was goodbye. And that’s fine, Max can hate him all she wants. He’s just trying to be enough here.

He and Steve stay up talking all night. He hadn’t...he hadn’t meant to tell Steve everything. Shit, there’s a lot he still hasn’t said. But he had just wanted, this one time, for Steve to get it, for Steve to understand that he was trying, here, he’s just trying to be enough.

And when he had told Steve all of it, told Steve more than he had ever told a living soul, Steve had just taken it, and said, once again, that he was staying.

Billy doesn’t get Steve. He never has. He doesn’t think Steve gets Steve, if he’s being honest. What is it he’s always saying? That he’s a goddamned idiot? It’s true, clearly. And however stupid Steve is, Billy’s worse, ‘cause he keeps buying into it, keeps hoping Steve will come back. And Steve keeps coming back.
It’s this cycle of idiocy, this thing Steve and Billy have going—there’s no reason for Steve to stay and there’s no reason for Billy to hope he does and yet here they are, two dumbasses, sitting on a porch that neither of them own and smoking a whole pack of cigarettes.

Steve talks, too. He says he’s staying and then he smokes a cigarette and a half in silence before he opens his mouth and says, in words that run over each other:

“Shit, Hargrove. I have no idea what I’m doing. That’s what I was telling Robin out there. And I- I never know what I’m doing. I used to. Back in high school. It was all so easy, you know? Hawkins is...it’s not hard to be successful in Hawkins. It’s not hard to know what you’re supposed to do. And then I met Nancy, and I just did everything I was supposed to do to keep her, but I fucked it up, and I didn’t get into college, and...I never know what the fuck I’m doing Hargrove. And I...you ever get those moments, when you’re playing basketball? Where everything lines up and you just get it? Like, you know where everyone is without looking, you know what you have to do to be perfect, but you don’t even have to think about it, it just happens. And you’re right, every time. You never have one of those moments and it end up being wrong, you know? I just...I never get those anymore. Recently, it’s like I only get those moments when I’ve got a baseball bat and a monster to beat up and it’s the right thing to do because it’s the only thing I can do. But, this last week...every time I’ve thought about backing out I’ve had one of those moments. And I’ve known I had to stay. I don’t know what the fuck I’m doing, Billy. And sometimes, when...But it’s the right thing. It’s gotta be. It wouldn’t...you think I’m batshit, don’t you?”

Billy realizes that he’s been staring at Steve with his mouth half open. He clamps it shut, runs a tongue over his teeth. “Fuck, Steve. I didn’t know people got that feeling when they WEREN’T playing basketball.”

Steve looks at him with wide eyes. “Really? You don’t get those?”

“I used to, back when I surfed. But not...not like that.”

“You just never know what to do?”

“I mean, when that thing- the monster thing- when it-“ there’s a shiver running down Billy’s back, but he ignores it. “You know. Then I always knew what I had to do, all the time, cause it told me. But not... I don’t know, man. I just do whatever won’t kill me.”

Steve is watching him intently, searching his face for something that Billy doesn’t have. “You saved El. In the mall.”

Billy shook his head. “I didn’t...you guys have no idea how many people I killed. Helped kill. I don’t know. I...I didn’t know what I was doing. I was just trying to do something that might make it stop.”

Steve sighs, runs a hand through his hair. “Whatever it was, it was fucking brave. And you-God, I thought you were dead. And do you know- when I hit you with the car? I didn’t even check to see if you were breathing. And you- God, I thought you were dead then. I thought you were dead last night. I- you gotta quit almost dying on me, Hargrove, it’s making this whole rivalry thing really hard.”

Billy can’t help but laugh. “You wish you could have a rivalry with me, Harrington. Wish you were half the shit I am.”

Steve snorts. “Get your act together, Billy. One minute you’re talking about a death wish, the next you’re talking about what hot shit you are- how the hell am I supposed to know if we’re fighting or not?”

“We’re always fighting, Harrington.”

Steve laughs back, and, Billy’s smiling at him, and, God, this is what Steve’s gut is telling him to do? Steve thinks his only right option is to stay? Billy’s never...the right option is never to stay. He knows that. Staying has never worked for anyone. But...Joyce says she’ll never be mad at him, and Steve says he’s gonna stay. Billy shouldn’t...things work out better when people don’t like Billy. It’s just the way it goes. But he’s selfish, still; he’s always been full of bullshit.

It’s better when people don’t like him.

It’s safer when people don’t like him. But this- it’s bullshit. But it doesn’t feel half bad.