Actions

Work Header

Oh, You Pretty Things

Chapter 25: Don’t Kid Yourself

Notes:

Warning: couple of homophobic slurs, something that may be interpreted as self internalized homophobia

Chapter Text

Here is what Aunt Linda says:

She asks if Max is safe. (Max says yes which has always been true before but suddenly feels precarious now).

She asks if Max’s mom is safe. (Neil loves Max’s mom).

She asks if Max remembers, really, why they had to leave her dad in the first place. (Max does, even if no one thinks she does. She knows her dad was mean, okay? She just can’t imagine that he was worse than Neil).

She asks if Billy’s ever hurt Max. (Max lies. Aunt Linda can tell).

At the end of it, Aunt Linda looks at her and her face looks like Max’s mom’s when Max falls off her skateboard or Neil yells at Billy at the table. “You know you can talk to me, right Max? I’m in your corner. I don’t- your mom’s my sister, Max, but I’m on your side. Your mom and I both want for you to be safe.”

And Max nods, and she’s grateful. She is. She just wants for someone to want Billy to be safe, too.

xxx

In the first iteration of the plan, they don’t tell anyone. This seems logical, at first, because the plan came to Steve like a vision while he was holding Billy’s hand and who was he to question it, really? About two seconds after it’s out of his mouth, though, Steve realizes that his idea may not be as solid as he had assumed. (Maybe it’s not actually an idea at all, something in the back of his mind says, maybe it’s just a wish, a wish born out of how rough the callouses on Billy’s hand were and how tan Billy’s hand looked in his and how many tiny scars and freckles marked Billy’s skin. Steve drowns that voice out).

Billy likes the idea, but Billy likes anything that he thinks helps ensure Max and Joyce’s safety. That’s why he doesn’t want to tell them, at first—he’d rather people be confused than people be endangered. Two minutes in, though, Steve realizes that if they don’t talk to Max and Joyce first, it’s possible they’ll get scared and do something risky anyway. It takes him a few minutes, but he brings Billy around. They have to talk to Max and Joyce, and they have to do it soon, and dragging Billy back up that hill just does not seem wise right now, so Steve has to talk to Max while Billy talks to Joyce, and then everything will be good.

This will work. This is a real plan. This will save Billy.

Steve can barely look at Joyce, he feels so anxious. And Billy’s no better- God, is Billy even going to be able to talk to Joyce? Steve’s not convinced. He can’t even blame him, really. Just last night—no, just an hour ago, actually—he and Billy were openly fantasizing about what it would be like for Joyce to be their mom and now he expects Billy to, what, be completely calm while he throws it back in her face?

(Billy isn’t gonna throw it back in her face. They’re doing the right thing. This is a real plan. This is what saves Billy.)

Steve’s gonna need Robin and Dustin again (actually, he really just needs Dustin, but he wants Robin to be there, too), which is kind of unfortunate, since it means he’s gonna have to convince Dustin AGAIN that helping Billy is a good idea. And Steve wants to see Robin, but so much was said last night (before he even spoke to Billy, before that whole six hour conversation) that he still hasn’t thought through, and he hopes she isn’t going to press him on any of it.

(“What do you think it is about Billy that made you want to kiss him?”
“I don’t know, it just felt... I wanted to.”
“Do you think that’s fair to Billy?”)

God, Robin’s gonna kill him. Dustin’s gonna kill him. It feels very possible that the spirit of Max will physically manifest through a walkie talkie so she can kill him, too.

This is okay. This is a good plan. This is what saves Billy.

xxx

Steve looked at him with these eyes and said “I have an idea,” and Billy had just thought yeah, okay, this is it, because Steve’s eyes looked like that and his hand was warm and Billy had just told him things he’d never thought he could say before.

Billy knows as soon as Steve’s left the house that, actually, Billy is an idiot. There’s something in Steve that triggers just absolute stupidity in Billy, and Billy...

Steve’s plan could work, though. (Could it? His dad’s voice asks. Or is Billy just desperate?)

Steve’s plan is the only one they have, and it’s a plan that saves Max, a plan that protects Joyce, a plan that doesn’t end up with Billy dead. The problem with the plan, of course, is that it doesn’t protect Steve. Billy can work that out, though. He can fix that. This is doable.

(He should be the one to talk to Max, but he can’t, and someone needs to talk to Joyce. Max will never forgive him, and that’s okay.)

Joyce looks at him like she knows something, like she’s on the verge of tears the second Steve leaves. Billy clears his throat. It’s just the two of them in the kitchen, and Billy taps his fingers on the table.

“I need to- Steve and I talked. And we think- He and I are going to- I’m sorry, it’s just-“ none of these words are coming out right and Billy doesn’t know why. He made Max cry just yesterday; why is it so hard to look Joyce in the eyes and tell her goodbye, too? This should be easy. This should be normal. Billy’s starting to feel like he can’t breathe. “Steve and I, we- I- the two of us are- I need to tell you-“ shit, his throat is closing up. What happened to him? How is this the person he is now? (Joyce said she would never be mad at him; Joyce hugged him when he cried.) “Me and Steve-“

“I don’t care if you’re gay, Billy.” Joyce says it all in one breath and then claps a hand over her mouth as if she surprised herself, as if she had said something she wasn’t supposed to.

All of the air leaves Billy’s lungs. “What?” he hisses, and Joyce shuts her eyes with a pained look.

“I’m sorry, I didn’t mean to- I don’t care if you’re gay, Billy. You and Steve are both wonderful people, and I- you don’t have to be afraid to tell me, I’m sorry-“

There’s a dull roar in Billy’s ears. He can feel all the blood rushing to his face and he can’t tell if he’s angry or scared or humiliated. “I’m not a fag,” he whispers, and Joyce looks horrified.

“Billy, no, I-“

He stands up a little too quickly, and he can feel his heartbeat in his throat.

“Steve and I are nothing.”

“I’m so sorry, Billy, I thought you were trying to tell me...” she trails off, waves her hand in the air, her mouth clamped shut. She’s not angry, he realizes, and she’s not upset with him. But she’s right, isn’t she? He sees it all so clearly through her eyes- he can’t stay up all night with Steve and make the kind of plans they’re making and hold Steve’s hand and know that Steve wanted to kiss him (it was a mistake, though) and act like there’s nothing wrong with it, act like he’s being anything other than a dumbass.

He shakes his head. “I’m not a fag,” he whispers again, and he thinks about what would happen if his dad knew he held Steve’s hand, what would happen if he and Steve actually did Steve’s idea. He would die. Steve could die. God, Billy’s an idiot. He looks at Joyce and realizes how futile this all is, how dumb he’s being.

She has tears in her eyes. “I’m sorry, Billy. I didn’t mean to assume.”

She didn’t assume; she just read the fucking room. Billy has never felt more humiliated in his life.

He looks at the ceiling, looks at his feet. He’s wearing someone else’s clothes, for fuck’s sake. What, he just goes to someone else’s house and wears someone else’s clothes and pretends he has a different mom and holds a pretty boy’s hand and acts like he can be something he’s not? He can’t...he wants Steve to stay. He wants Joyce to like him. It doesn’t matter, though. Joyce thought he was in love with Harrington. And he can see why. He’s an idiot.

“What were you trying to tell me?” Joyce asks softly, and he looks down at her. The plan won’t work.

“Nothing,” he replies softly. “Steve and I thought we had an idea, but... we were wrong.”

Billy is gonna have to do this without Steve. That’s all there is to it.

xxx

Dustin whines the whole way there. Billy’s an asshole, Billy sucks, Billy is going to kill Steve in his sleep—all the usual complaints.

Steve wants to justify himself to Dustin, and he wants to have the words to explain to Dustin that, yeah, Billy’s an asshole, but there’s a lot more than that, and there’s a lot of versions of Billy that no one sees, and Steve is starting to see some of them, and maybe none of this has ever been as simple as they thought it was.

He can’t figure out the words, though, mostly because he’s trying to figure out what he’s going to say to Max, what he’s going to tell Dustin and Robin. He considers not telling them, just letting them find out when he tells Max, but it doesn’t seem fair, and it doesn’t seem right.

When he parks the car at the hill, he takes a deep breathe.

“Listen, guys, there’s something I have to tell you before we go up there.”

Robin raises an eyebrow, and Dustin makes some inane comment about how oh, Steve actually can still speak, but Steve just closes his eyes.

“When I get up there, and we talk to Max? I’m gonna tell her-“

“That Billy’s a bitch?”

“Shut up, Dustin. I’m serious.” Steve taps the steering wheel. “I’m going to tell Max that Billy and I talked it over, and we decided the best thing to do is run away.” He breathes in. “Both of us. I have a car, and money from Scoops, and...yeah. We’re gonna leave. Tonight.”

For a horrible moment, no one says anything.

And then they both start screaming at him.

xxx

New plan: Billy runs away alone. He should have done this one awhile ago, but he had been stupid, and when Steve looked at him with dumb eyes and said “I want ya to go. Together. No funny business, I swear, but- you’re not safe here. And I’m not leaving you,” Billy had wanted to believe that this was a real plan that could work.

But Joyce is right. There’s getting to be something between him and Steve that’s just a lot more complicated than Billy would like for it to be, and even if they run away, it doesn’t mean Neil won’t find him, and protecting Max and Joyce is important, but so is protecting Steve. And Steve is getting way too attached, despite Billy’s warnings (and it’s Billy’s fault, isn’t it? Last night Steve said he was staying, and Billy said ‘good.’ What was Steve supposed to do?), and this is just...messy.

Billy can fix this. He’ll run away alone; he’ll hitchhike. (People called the cops and his cops called his dad last time he hitchhiked, but he had been eleven and scared and now he’s seventeen and not the kind of person anyone would doubt got kicked out.)

He’ll tell Steve, when he gets back, not because he wants to say goodbye to Steve, he assures himself, but because Steve will probably try to find him if he doesn’t.

God, Steve is an idiot.

xxx

“YOU’RE WHAT?! ARE YOU DUMB? Did he give you BRAIN DAMAGE? Are you-“

“What is wrong with you? Why would you think that would work? What about YOUR parents, Steve? What about money? Where will you sleep? Is Billy even HEALTHY-“

“HE’LL KILL YOU IN YOUR SLEEP AND NONE OF US WILL KNOW WHERE YOUR BODY IS-“

“Like, I just cannot fathom why this idea is the plan. Why possibly-“

“Are you FLAYED? Did the gate open? Did-“

Robin turns sharply on Dustin. “Dustin,” she says calmly, “can you get out of the car, for, like, two minutes?”

“WHAT? NO! I-“

“DUSTIN!” Robin screams. “Please?”

Dustin’s a little bit scared of Robin, which is the only reason this works. He looks at her, and then back at Steve, and then huffs “I hate you guys,” and gets out of the car. Steve wishes he hadn’t.

Robin turns back to Steve, voice deadly serious and quiet.

“This is not a teenage love story, okay? You can’t... you can’t think you might want to kiss someone and then turn that into the basis for completely giving up your life, okay? You can’t just run away and act like that’s...we’ll never see you again. What if something happens? What if-“ she inhaled deeply. “I know you like Billy. And I trust you. But this is... he doesn’t even like you back, Steve.”

“I know,” Steve says, and he thinks about trying to explain that he doesn’t even actually like Billy like that, but even he knows he’s full of shit. “I- this isn’t about ME, Robin. Okay? This isn’t me trying to be with Billy. This is- Billy isn’t safe here. Okay? He could- he’s afraid he’ll die. I’m afraid he’ll die. And, I’m not- you’re full of bullshit, you know that? You act like you trust me and act like I’m a real person and then I do something and you act like I’m still selfish prick who just does stuff to impress his crushes and- you’re bullshit, Robin. This isn’t about me.”

Robin has tears in her eyes, and he does, too, and Dustin is still sitting in the grass a few yards away looking downright pissed.

Steve clears his throat. “I need to talk to Max.”

Robin nods. “Let’s talk to Max, then.”