Actions

Work Header

Oh, You Pretty Things

Chapter 26: They Belong to You

Notes:

Warnings: child abuse, mentioned homophobia, panic attacks

Okay guys I’m done with the semester so I have hopes to start rolling with this again. This is so fun for me to write, and I can see so clearly in my head how it all plays out, so I’m hoping I’ll be able to finish it up in the next couple of months (but who knows?) As always, y’all’s feedback is the best and I appreciate people actually reading this. I hope you like it!!

Chapter Text

Billy is not a good person. Max has always known this, in the same way that she’s known her dad isn’t a good person and Neil isn’t a good person and her mom is someone who tries to be a good person. It’s not a judgement call, it just...is. Billy is mean and angry and ugly, and he’s just always been that way.

He was horrible, at first. He would scream at Max if she got in his way; he would say ugly things to Max’s mom just to see if he could make her cry. He was rude to girls and he got in fights with boys and when he drove, he drove like he hoped he was the only person who made it off the road alive. Max hated Billy, and Billy hated her, and Neil hated Billy, and Max’s mom loved Neil, and Neil liked Max, and it was all...simple. Horrible and unbearable, but simple. There was one enemy in the house, and it was Billy. It was easy to track. And, yes, Neil was mean to Billy, but Billy...Billy made Max’s mom cry. All the time. And Billy hated Max, and he hated Neil, and if Max was big enough to humiliate Billy, she’d probably do it, too.

It wasn’t...it’s easy, now, to see that maybe she was wrong, and it was never actually simple, and maybe Billy wasn’t the only bad guy, but. At the time? She never questioned it.

There was this one time, in California, when... well, Billy was supposed to babysit, and he didn’t, which was good with Max. And she wanted to learn this skateboard trick, but she didn’t want her neighbors to see her, because sometimes they made comments about her being a tomboy, and the comments didn’t bother her, but they did bother her mom, and her mom was really having a bad week with Billy, so Max thought she would do it inside- what was the worst that could happen?

The worst that could happen, apparently, was a broken window.

Billy came in less than two minutes after the glass shattered, and he looked at her, and at the window, and back at her, and his face turned red and his eyes looked black and she felt sure that he was going to do it, he was going to actually kill her this time. She started to make a run for her room, but he didn’t chase her, didn’t do anything.

The blood drained from his face and he wasn’t red anymore, he was so pale he looked like a corpse, and his hands were shaking as he lifted one up to his throat, and he was gasping for breath, and, for a second, Max thought he was dying. And then he fell to his knees and started throwing up, but nothing was coming out, he was just dry heaving, and his whole body was shaking and his face was so, so scared that Max forgot that he was about to kill her and ran to him.

He pushed her away immediately, still heaving, bracing himself with his elbows. “Don’t touch me!” he growled, but he wasn’t scary at all. “Go to your room!” He said, and Max didn’t move, and he shoved at her again. “Go!” he yelled, but there were tears in his eyes and he rocked back on his knees.

Max was scared. Terrified, actually. And so she left him, even though she knew she shouldn’t, because she didn’t know what was happening and she didn’t know what to do. Max ran to her room and waited for her mom to get home.

When Neil got home, he took one look at the window and he yelled at Billy, even when Max’s mom told him it was Max’s fault, and he called Billy all of things Max thought Billy was: a bad son, a bad brother, irresponsible, immature, a loser. And Billy just stood there with dead eyes and took it, only opened his mouth to say that he wasn’t Max’s brother, he was her stepbrother, and Neil yelled so loud that even Billy jumped.

Billy went to his room after that, and Neil promised Max and her mom that he would take care of this, that Billy would shape up, that Billy was going to start treating them all with respect.

And Max just thought about Billy—pale and quaking and collapsing on the ground—Billy—who took his dad’s screaming without batting an eye—Billy—who told her he’d kill her if she spoke to him again—and she wondered how they were all the same person, and she wondered which one was real.

Billy was awful, though. Billy was not a good person, and he bullied her friends and tried to kill her first boyfriend and tried to kill Steve, who Max didn’t know at the time but seemed NICE, at least, and he was horrible, through and through, to everyone.

She could never shake it, though—the way that Billy looked, scared out of his mind. And that night—that god awful night, when they all almost die for the first time and when Max thinks Billy is going to kill the only people who are nice to her—that’s what she thought about when she listened to Neil kick the shit out of Billy. She doesn’t feel sorry for Billy (she doesn’t she doesn’t she doesn’t), because Billy was AWFUL and Billy was going to KILL them. But here’s what Max thought about: Billy had laughed when Steve hit him, and he had laughed when Max drugged him. He had laughed, and he hadn’t been afraid, not once, not until Max threatened to hit his junk with a bat full of nails and even then, he had been drugged and prone and he had seemed tired, not scared. Billy had laughed.

And when his dad sounded like he was going to kill him, Billy didn’t laugh once. He just said “yes, sir,” and “sorry, sir,” and he sounded small and Max couldn’t hear everything through the wall but she could tell that he was scared. Billy, Max realized that night, was more scared of Neil than he was of a bat full of nails to the balls, and that had to mean something.

Billy was not a good person. But Max...he wasn’t good, but neither was Neil, and Max...Billy would always be a jackass in her eyes. But he might not be the only bad person in her house, and he might not even be the worst one.

Then shit goes down and Billy is ACTUALLY EVIL and then he’s a hero and then he’s dying and Max doesn’t know what any of it means, doesn’t know who’s the good guy here but she knows that the bad guy isn’t Billy, not right now, and here’s what matters:

The next time Billy goes pale and shaking and is terrified, Max doesn’t run away. She stays. And she promises to keep him alive. And that’s what matters.

Billy is not a good person. He never has been. But he’s not bad, either. He’s just scared. Billy is scared. And Max feels like she’s the only one that can see it; the only one that can tell that Billy isn’t good because he’s using all of his energy to be scared. He’s trying to stay alive and they’ve all been out here, wondering why he was so mean, as if he didn’t live in a houseful of people that hated him and wasn’t terrified every second. Billy is mean, and he is ugly, and he has been awful. But he’s...there’s more, now, and Max can see that, and so can Joyce, and so can Steve.

Max just wants someone other than her to want Billy to be safe; she wants someone other than her to see Billy for what he is. And when Steve Harrington calls her on the walkie talkie and says, quietly, that he’s going to run away with Billy, that he’s not going to let Billy get hurt again, that he’s not going to let Billy starve, Max realizes it’s not just her anymore. Steve sees Billy, and Steve is going to keep Billy alive, and Steve isn’t going to run away when Billy gets scared. Steve is like her.

“You have to take care of him, Steve,” she says, and there are tears in her eyes. “You have to...he can’t be alone. And sometimes he gets angry and sometimes he gets...his hands shake? And he can’t breathe? And you have to...he needs someone with him, okay? He can’t...I told him I would keep him alive. So please, just...he HAS to stay alive, even when he doesn’t want to, okay? Could you...promise me, Steve. Say it.”

“I’ll take care of him, Max, I promise.” There’s a pause on Steve’s end. “I’m gonna...I’m gonna take care of Billy. I am.”

Max nods, even though Steve can’t see it, and she feels so, so sad and so hopeful all at once. “Tell him that he...he should’ve said bye to me. He’s a coward. And I...tell him I said to just stay alive. And don’t be an asshole.”

Max’s mom walks in the room, and Max turns off the walkie talkie as quickly as she can. She doesn’t...she doesn’t THINK her mom would tell Neil, but she wants to be sure.

Her mom’s face is puffy and tear-streaked, and she sniffles. “Max,” she whispers, “we need to talk.”

xxx

 

Harrington comes back to the house looking like he’s hasn’t slept in weeks, and Billy wonders if that’s how he looks, too. He feels like it. Feels worse, actually.

He gets in Steve’s car before Steve can get out, ‘cause he needs to intercept Steve before Steve can talk to Joyce, needs to start talking to Steve before Steve has the chance to talk about Max. And so Billy just launches in, not giving Steve the time to say a word.

“Plan’s not gonna work, buddy. Too many variables. I’m not going down for kidnapping you. So I’m gonna- you’re gonna stay here. I’m gonna go. It’s better.”

Steve looks at him and his face transitions quickly from shock to hurt to anger. “Not gonna happen, Hargrove. You don’t have money, you don’t have a car, and you have absolutely no charm. You’re not making it without me. I’m going with you.”

“Don’t be a dumbass. You have plenty of chances to get out of Hawkins on your own- don’t tag along on mine.”

“Fuck you, Billy, you’re not leaving without me.”

Billy slams a hand on the dashboard, and Steve flinches, which Billy appreciates.

“You don’t tell me what to do, I do. I’m calling the shots here. And I say I’m not running away with you, princess.”

Steve looks at him and blinks slowly. The anger bleeds out of his face, which is not a good sign for Billy. “You’re scared,” he whispers. “You think Neil’s gonna find you and hurt me?”

“I’m not scared.” Billy growls, and it’s so stupid it’s laughable, as if Harrington hasn’t spent the last week watching Billy be scared out of his damn mind.

“Man, why? What- he hasn’t found you yet, okay? And you’re right. We need to get the hell out of here before he finds Joyce. But...I’ve killed monsters with a baseball bat, okay? I’m not scared of him. And...do you really think he’s gonna follow you? If he hasn’t found you yet, is he actually gonna track you down?”

I’m not scared of him, Billy’s mind replays, and he sees red for a second. It’s easy, sure, to not be afraid of Neil when you don’t grow up under him, when you don’t know that breathing wrong can get you a black eye, when you don’t look into your dad’s eyes and know he wants you dead. It’s easy to not be scared, sure, but Steve doesn’t... “Fuck you, Harrington.” Billy hisses, climbing out of the car. “I’m not going anywhere with you.”

Steve scrambles after him, still talking. “What happened? This morning you were- I can do this! We can do this! This isn’t... what HAPPENED?” He’s starting to yell now, and there’s an edge of desperation in his voice. Billy wonders if everyone inside is watching, if they’re all listening. “Last night you were FINE and now you’re...what is going on? What happened?”

What happened, of course, is that Billy realized he and Steve were two dumbasses who thought they could pretend that they didn’t want to kiss and that that would make it okay to hold hands and run away together and for Steve to basically pledge his life to Billy and that they could act like Billy wasn’t BILLY but this other nice, soft person Steve had created and not... Billy can’t say any of that. He turns on Steve again, spinning on his heel, and he licks his teeth, nice and slow, and he grins in the way he knows everyone hates.

“God, Harrington, I get it. Listen: I don’t care if we run away together. I’m not gonna suck your dick, and, honestly, I’m a little tired of having to deal with this whole thing. I’m leaving. You’re not.”

Steve doesn’t even look angry, the asshole. Just tired. And disappointed. “So we’re back to this, then? Don’t you ever feel like...Jesus, Hargrove, you are the WORST. You know that, right? Just...I am so sick of this shit. You’re nice and you’re different and you’re honest and then the second one of us picks up on that you revert back into being a fucking ASSHOLE like that’s gonna make us all forget... Jesus Christ,” his voice drops into a whisper, and Billy realizes that Steve must be scared people are listening, too, “I said I’m staying and I fucking meant it. Quit trying to push me away ‘cause you’re scared.”

It’s a low moment for Billy, but he can’t help it. He shoves Steve with all his weight, and Steve goes flying, and this is familiar, isn’t it? Steve on the ground in front of the Byers, Billy losing his shit? Some things never change. “Told you to plant your feet,” he says, just like last time, and Steve stands up tall, eyes blazing.

“This is what that looks like now.” He hisses, and he reaches out and takes Billy’s hand, and Billy wants to rench it back, because people might SEE, but he doesn’t. Billy’s heart rate goes off the fucking charts and he stops feeling angry so quickly it’s horrifying. “Either we go together or we don’t go at all. That’s all there is to it. I’m not...I’m planting my feet, okay? You’re not gonna convince me not to.”

Billy’s breathing hitches. “Get back in the car,” he whispers.

“What?”

“Get back in the car.” He jerks his head towards the house. “I don’t want them to hear.”

Steve nods, and then they’re back in the car, like a couple of idiots. They both stare at the house for a second, and Billy tries to get his breathing under control, and he realizes that Steve knows this, and that Steve is letting him regain control, that Steve is letting him take his time. Billy cannot stand Steve.

He reaches out and grabs Steve’s hand. “Joyce thinks we’re gay.”

Steve makes a face. “What? Why?”

Billy looks pointedly at their hands and Steve’s eyes go wide. “Oh. Right.”

“I can’t run away with you, Steve. I can’t...you don’t know who I am, and you don’t know who Neil is. There isn’t...this isn’t a situation that turns out well for you. And I don’t...God, Harrington, I don’t want to be a bad thing that happens to you, either. Just...let me do this.” Billy feels desperate. He feels like...it’s like he knows, and he’s standing on the edge of a disaster, and Steve is just jumping off the edge and only Billy can see it.

“You don’t have money, and you don’t have a car, and I...this turns out good for me, Billy. Even if it doesn’t, I don’t... Max told me to take care of you. And I promised her I would, and even...even if I hadn’t promised, I would’ve wanted to. I’m not...you think this doesn’t turn out well for me? Trust me, rotting in Hawkins and wondering if you’re alive turns out worse.”

Steve’s hand is cold. Billy interlaces their fingers, and Steve grips his hand tightly, and Billy...they’re idiots.

“I’m not doing this ‘cause I want you to suck my dick.” Steve whispers, face twisting. “I’m doing this ‘cause... I never know what to do. But when I hold your hand I feel like I kind of do. And when I think about leaving you, I know not to. And that’s all there is to it.”

Billy grips Steve’s hand tighter. “When I was...eleven? Ten? Jesus, I don’t know. Neil was dating Susan but hadn’t married her yet. I- I didn’t want a new mom, ya know? I definitely didn’t want Max. And I...Neil was gonna get a new family. I thought he’d be happy. I thought...whatever. I left. I thought he wouldn’t care. He did, actually. Cared a hell of a lot. And when he found me, I...I didn’t walk for a week. Not that I could’ve, if I wanted to. He tied me to a radiator, just to be sure. And I...I got it then. He doesn’t care if I live or die. But he doesn’t...it’s the living without him that gets to him. He doesn’t want me to be happy somewhere. That’s why he’ll look. That’s why he’ll find me. He hates me, Steve, and I don’t want...if he thought I was gay? He already thinks that, I guess, but if I- if he knew? That I ran away with a boy? He’d kill you, okay? Just to make sure I saw. And...I won’t do that. Not to you. We were gonna leave to protect Joyce and Max, right? And I’m telling you that I’m gonna watch out for you, too.”

When he looks over at Steve, there are tears in his eyes. He wipes at them angrily, gnaws at his lower lip. “I hate him,” he whispers.

“Yeah, me too.”

“He wouldn’t find us, Billy.”

“But I’d always be wondering what would happen if he did.”

“That will be me, though, if you go without me, and I’ll-“

“You’ll get over it.”

“I won’t. And Max won’t. And Joyce- you can’t be alone, okay?”

Neither of them have mentioned the gay thing, Billy realizes, and neither of them have contended it at all. Steve isn’t even...

“Steve?”

“Yeah?”

“Remember when I told you I’d kill you if you thought about kissing me again?”

“It was like two days ago, so, yeah, I’d say it’s etched in pretty deep.”

Billy exhales. “You still thinking about it?”

Steve looks down at their hands, still interlocked. “All I think about anymore,” he whispers, “is if you’re safe or not. The other shit- it’s just side stuff. It’s not what matters.”

Billy nods. And then he leans forward and kisses Steve Harrington.