Actions

Work Header

Oh, You Pretty Things

Chapter 34: And It Looks As Though They’re Here to Stay

Notes:

Warnings: child abuse (verbal and physical); emotional neglect; some suicidal thoughts

This chapter was really hard for me to write. Susan is such a complicated character, and I’ve never wanted to write her off or, alternatively, pretend like she’s some kind of saint. All of the main characters have such different relationships to her, too, and I wanted to be able to understand/explore that while still seeing her as complex. It took me forever to write this and to figure it out, and I hope it works.

Anyways, hope you enjoy the chapter! Happy Holidays :)

Chapter Text

They have to wake Max up when they hit the Indianapolis city limits, though once she gets them to the right exit she ends up being almost no help at all.

“I don’t, just, memorize street names,” she grumbles after they’ve circled yet another wrong street, and Billy rolls his eyes and says: “Jesus, how old are you? You were here THIS MORNING.”

Steve feels a sense of panic, like if he and Billy don’t return to Joyce as soon as possible there will be no way to ward off the impending doom, but he can tell that Billy and Max are reluctant to actually find the house. He can hardly blame them—he doesn’t want to leave Max, and he doesn’t want Billy to leave Max, and he wishes that there was a way to guarantee that Max got to be gifted with a new mother, one who wasn’t Susan, one who hadn’t let her stepson lay bleeding on a mattress for over a week. (He knows that Susan is more than that, that Max obviously still loves her, that it’s all complicated, but in the last week Steve has learned to evaluate people solely on the basis of their relationship to Billy, and if he thinks too much about Susan’s role in all of this he sees red).

For a moment, as he takes another right turn that he’s fairly certain he’s already taken, Steve fights the urge to say “let’s just leave.” He can picture a life so clearly, a life just like this: him and Billy and Max and a car—alone, free, untethered. Him always driving with no destination, Billy and Max always bickering over directions and food and leg space. (What does it say about him, that in his wildest dreams he’s still a glorified babysitter? He’s not sure). They could leave everything behind—dads that are horrific, moms who don’t do their jobs, parents who just don’t care. Towns that you can’t breathe in, places that are haunted by everything evil and dark. Ruined malls full of fucking Russians.

Joyce, who wants to give Billy a home. Nancy, who is willing to kill for Billy. Eleven, who looks at Billy like she understands him. Will, who watches Billy silently but carefully; Will, who might actually one day be able to talk to Billy about what it means to be Flayed. Jonathan, who is willing to give up his life to help someone he has no reason to like.

Steve can’t ask Billy to even consider leaving these people; he can’t justify theoretically encouraging Billy to leave. Billy could still run at the first chance, Steve’s sure of it—he won’t be the one that pushes him. Billy deserves a family, and Steve is going to make sure he gets there. (Billy wants Steve to have the same family; Billy wants Steve to share these people with him. Steve just wants to be wherever Billy is).

“Oh wait, I think this is it!” Max says with the same confidence that she’s had about the last three streets. “Take a left here. I think this is it.”

“Does this look familiar?” Steve asks Billy, who shrugs.

“Fuck if I know,” Billy drawls. “I haven’t been here since...since what, Max, the first Thanksgiving?”

“You were at the first Thanksgiving,” Max replies with a smirk, “and we were never invited back.”

Billy grins from ear to ear, and Steve almost says it again: let’s just leave. But Billy deserves a family, and Steve is being selfish, and Billy needs to, just this once, not run, and-

“That’s Susan’s car.” The shift that comes over the siblings is total in nature and happens in a matters of milliseconds. One second they’re smiling and laughing, and the next they’re quiet and tense, pressed shoulder to shoulder.

“This is the right house,” Max affirms in a stiff voice, and Steve pulls into a stranger’s driveway.

Billy’s breathe hitches as two women appear at the front door immediately, and Max reaches out to open the door but leaves her hand on the handle, fingers frozen.

“Billy...” she whispers, and Billy shakes his head.

“This is a good thing,” he says quietly, “and we’re gonna do it.”

She nods once like a soldier and clambers out of the car. One of the women—Susan, Steve does recognize her, even though the recognition is vague—bursts into tears and half runs to Max, wrapping her in her arms.

Billy and Steve stay frozen in the car, watching as Susan cups Max’s face in her hands, tries to detangle Max’s hair with her fingers. She loves Max, that’s easy to see. Steve wants to get out of the car and scream at her: Billy was right there; Billy was right there and you did nothing; no one told Billy they loved him for seven years.

“I need to talk to her,” Billy says quietly, muscles still tense. “To Susan. I- I have to talk to her.”

Steve nods. “I can go with you.”

“No, I-“ Billy shakes his head, fingers tugging at his shirt. “I need to do it alone. There’s some stuff I have to say that- look, will you...”

“I won’t leave,” Steve says, echoing the promise of the last few days. Billy has to be told that he’s not being abandoned, Steve is starting to understand that, and Steve will say it every hour if it means it will get through to Billy at all.

Billy nods, and then cuts his eyes to Steve sharply. “If Linda says anything about me ignore her, okay? I was, like, a fourteen year old asshole.”

Steve snorts. “Hard to believe you could do worse at fourteen than you did when I met you.”

“That’s fair,” Billy says with a grin. He looks back at Susan and Max, who are both staring at the car window now. He reaches forward and claps a hand on Steve’s shoulder. “Let’s go ahead and do this, then.”

xxx

The last time Billy saw Susan, he’d been laying on his floor, blood in his mouth, Neil standing over him. Neil had stopped yelling a while ago (Neil likes to avoid yelling, when he can, and why yell when being quiet is just as effective?) and he was quietly and calmly explaining to Billy how bad he had fucked up, what a disappointment he is, how he’d ruined the lives of everyone he’d touched. (Neil was just thinking about himself, about Billy’s mom, about Max, about Susan. He had no idea about Heather, or the girl, or all the missing people scattered through Hawkins. He had no idea Billy’s a million times worse than even Neil can imagine). Billy laid on the floor, cradling his ribs, surrounded by all of his belongings, blood in his eyes. Neil could be gearing up to kill him, he thought. This could be it for him.

He closed his eyes, trying to focus on any voice other than his dad’s. What would his mom say, if she was here? (She had known this was coming, and she hadn’t cared. She still left). What would Max do, if Neil killed him? (They could be a happy family, if he wasn’t here. Max, Neil, Susan—they could be a sweet family, who only fought about normal things, who all smiled and hugged and loved each other). Billy couldn’t think of a single reason NOT to die—he was tired of living with this, tired of hearing Heather’s screams in his sleep.

“Open your FUCKING eyes and LISTEN to me when I talk to you!” Neil hooked Billy’s side with the tip of his boot and flipped him over, and Billy let out a half scream into the carpet. “Shut up,” Neil spit, and then he crouched down, grabbing Billy by the jaw to force eye contact. “Do you understand how lucky you are that Max made it out alive? That none of those kids died? Do you realize how many people you endangered, all because you were SELFISH and STUPID?” (Billy was still fuzzy on what all he had done, but he was pretty sure he’d endangered, at the very least, all of Indiana). “The VERY least you can do is take some RESPONSIBILITY for everything you’ve done. You understand me?”

There was a knock at the door. “Yes sir,” Billy mumbled, and his tongue felt thick and slow, and there was blood on his teeth.

“Neil?” Susan asked, cracking open the door. Neil stood quickly, making his way to the door and standing in the gap. She saw Billy, though: Billy saw her face go white, saw her put a hand over her mouth, heard her gasp. “Neil,” she whispered, but it didn’t matter.

Susan saw Billy, and nothing happened, nothing changed. She knew what had happened, and she knew what Billy looked like when Neil was done with him, and she didn’t do anything. At the time, Billy hadn’t blamed her. He deserved it, and she wasn’t his mom, and she was Neil’s wife.

Now, though, watching her hug and cry over Max, something in Billy’s stomach clenches, and his eyes are hot. He doesn’t know what it is, but he thinks of Joyce, cleaning the blood out of his hair, and he thinks of Steve, shoving his body in between Neil and Max. He has to talk to Susan; he has to be sure.

Susan’s face when she sees him is almost identical to the face she made last time she saw him: face pale, hand to her mouth.

“Billy,” she whispers, and her voice sounds just like it did the last time Billy saw her, and his throat tightens. “Billy, please, I-“ she steps away from Max, a hand outstretched, and Billy does a full body flinch.

“Don’t touch him,” Steve growls from behind him, and Billy wants to tell him to calm down, that Susan isn’t bad, she’s just annoying, but his body is frozen. Max slips between him and Susan, chin jutted out, facing her mom. Jesus, she’s a strong kid. Better than Billy ever was, better than Billy ever has been.

Susan starts crying immediately, and Linda moves forward, arms crossed across her chest. Billy watches her for a second, waiting for her to yell at him, waiting for her to tell him to leave. All she does, though, is place a hand on her sister’s shoulder and nod at Billy like she understands something. Billy nods back, feeling some mobility return. He breathes in through his nose, licks his teeth.

“It’s fine,” he calls to Steve over his shoulder, and he places a hand on Max’s shoulder, mirroring Linda, and repeats: “it’s fine.” Max looks at him and he nods, and she gives him a small, sad smile. “I need to talk to your mom,” he says quietly, “alone.”

She nods back. “That’s fine.”

He looks up at Susan and Linda and repeats, in a voice that he hopes is firm: “I need to talk to you, Susan. Inside.”

xxx

Max watches Billy and her mom disappear through the front door, and she clenches her fist at her side. She doesn’t want Billy to yell at her mom; she doesn’t want her mom to cry and act like she never did anything wrong. She doesn’t want them to be alone in a room together, and she’s not sure what Billy wants to say to her mom. Steve moves behind her, puts a hand on her shoulder exactly where Billy had.

“You okay?” He asks quietly, and Max thinks about how angry he had been, only seconds ago, at her mom. Steve had talked to her mom the same way he talked to Neil. He loves Billy; he has to.

Aunt Linda looks at Steve, head tilted. “And who are you?”

“This is Steve,” Max says quickly. “He’s our...” she breathes in deeply, suddenly unsure of the word. “He’s my friend,” she finishes lamely, as if the word ‘friend’ could possibly explain the fact that he’s saved Max’s life before, the fact that he’s saved Billy, the fact that he climbed through Billy’s window because Max asked him to and hasn’t left since.

Aunt Linda smiles, clearly confused. In a voice that’s not unkind but is stilted, she says: “Bit of an age gap between you two, isn’t there?”

Steve moves his hand from Max’s shoulder, shoves both his hands into his pockets. “Me and Billy went to school together. And Max is good friends with Dustin, my- my little brother.”

Dustin would scream if he heard Steve say that; he probably wouldn’t shut up about it for months. Max smiles despite herself, thinking about how annoying Dustin would be if he knew Steve had called him his brother. As soon as he says it, though, Max can’t help but feel like it’s true: how could any biological brother love Dustin more than Steve does? How could any little brother care about Steve more than Dustin does?

“And you and Billy are friends?” Aunt Linda continues, confused smile still in place. Max can understand the confusion: Steve, even in casual clothes and unwashed hair, is still obviously a rich prep, the antithesis of everything Billy has always been.

“Yeah, we’re, um, we’re best friends.”

Max smiles again, but, at the same time, she has to fight the urge to hug Steve. Steve is Dustin’s brother; Billy is her brother; Steve loves Billy; Billy loves Steve; Max is Billy’s little sister now. “He’s been helping us a ton,” Max says, and she’s shocked to hear the words out in the open, to talk about it so openly with anyone, much less someone outside of the Byers’ house. “With Neil. He helped us move Billy, and...” her voice cracks, which is embarrassing. “He’s been helping us a lot. He helped Billy hide.”

Aunt Linda’s face softens, and she nods, lip pursed. “Well, thank you then, Steve.”

Steve has got to be one of the most awkward people Max has ever known; she doesn’t believe any of the shit the boys say about how Steve used to be the coolest person in school. He shifts from foot to foot, hands buried deep in his pockets. “Any time,” he responds, as if saving someone from their murderous dad is a task that Steve is asked to help out with every Tuesday.

Max doesn’t know, though. Steve has saved Dustin’s ass multiple times; he’s fought Russians and monsters; he’s hit people with cars; he came the second Max called. He made Billy want to stay, somehow. Maybe this is just who Steve is.

Max can’t stand the thought of leaving Billy. But she can leave Billy with Steve; she’s known that, even subconsciously, since the beginning. Billy is safe with Steve.

xxx

“Your husband,” Billy says the second they’re alone, determined not to give Susan any sort of head start, “tried to fucking HIT Max.”

Susan, who was already weepy, starts sobbing. Billy has to resist the urge to just scream at her to LISTEN, to understand that what he’s saying MATTERS, but, at the same time, Billy’s spent a good portion of the last 24 hours crying, so it’s not like he has any high ground to stand on.

“Susan, please don’t cry,” he says, and he’s actually surprised by how soft his voice is, by how quickly the anger bleeds out. It must shock her, too, because she looks up from her hands with wide eyes, chin quivering.

“I’m sorry,” she sniffs. “I just didn’t- thank you, Billy, thank you so much, for keeping her safe, for bringing her to me, for calling me, I- thank you, Billy, we’d be lost without you.”

He wonders if she’s forgotten he’s the root of the problem, if she remembers that Max was only in danger because of him. That’s not what he expected her to say, and it takes a moment for him to remember what’s important here. “Listen, Susan, none of that- look. Max isn’t safe near Neil, okay? She’s not. She was before, but now she’s not, and what...” he swallows, and his left hand is shaking. “What happened today? There’s no coming back from that. Max will never be safe around Neil again, okay?”

Susan chokes back a sob, but she nods. “I know.”

“Do you?” Billy asks, and his voice is picking up again, and there’s a bit of an edge to it, but this is too important for him to try to be nice now. “Because before I leave here, I need to know that you understand. Maxine is fourteen, okay? Do you know what happened when I was fourteen?” She knows, he knows that she does, but he says it anyways. “Neil broke my fucking arm. Max doesn’t deserve that. Max cannot be in the same room as him EVER again, okay?” His voice breaks a little, and his chest aches. “She’s just a kid.”

Something passes over Susan’s face, something that Billy doesn’t recognize, something that reminds him briefly of Joyce. “You were just a kid,” she whispers, and his breathe hitches. “You were just a kid, and...I’m sorry, Billy.”

Billy shakes his head. He can’t do this right now. “This is about Max. I’m not- this is about Max. I need you to tell me—I need you to LOOK at me and TELL me—that you’ll never go back to Neil. Because he won’t hesitate. Max HAS to be safe, so you HAVE to promise to never go back to him. You CANNOT let him be near Max again, okay? You’re her MOM.” There’s tears in his eyes, which is horrifying, and Billy doesn’t want to think about it. “You’re her mom; you have to keep her safe.”

Susan stares at him, tears still in her eyes, but strangely composed. Slowly, tentatively, she reaches out a hand and places it on his. “I’m leaving him, I promise. He- he’ll never see Max again.” She sniffs, and wipes at her eyes, letting go of his hand. “I know that you have every reason in the world to doubt me, but- I’ve done this before, Billy. I’ve left a marriage for Max before, and I can do it again. You- you can trust me with this.”

Billy believes her now, and in the set of her jaw and the crease between her eyebrows she looks, every so faintly, like Max. She and Max never talk about Max’s dad—Billy had always assumed he left Susan, if only because he couldn’t imagine Susan ever making an executive decision. Now, though, he’s not sure who Susan is. Susan has always gotten Max out of the house when Neil’s been mad at him; she’s always been the first to make peace between Neil and Billy at the dinner table. Billy had always thought it was because she refused to confront the truth, because she felt awkward being a part of whatever happened between her husband and step son. Now, though, he thinks maybe he had missed the full picture. She’ll protect Max; she always has.

“I believe you,” he says slowly, and he backs up from Susan, makes sure she’s looking him in the eyes. “But listen to me: if you go back to him, if you EVER let him near Max again, I’ll know. And I- I swear to fucking God, Susan, you will never see Max again. I’ll kidnap her, I don’t care, and you will NEVER see her again. I can’t protect her right now, and I trust that you can. But if you can’t? If you decide not to?” He doesn’t pull any of his old tricks: he doesn’t smile with all his teeth, he doesn’t fake laugh. He just stares at her, voice even and low. “If you let Max get hurt, I don’t give a fuck what happens to you. I’ll do whatever it takes to keep Max safe.”

Susan breathes in shakily, but she nods. “If I went back to Ne- if I went back to him,” she says, keeping eye contact with Billy, “I would expect nothing less.”