Chapter Text
A list of things Steve wants to say to Susan Hargrove:
1. He was right there
2. He was right there and you left him
3. He was right there and I had to come climb through his window and pull him out your house and take him to a woman who had every reason to hate him and that was the only way he could find someone to care
4. He was right there and you never thought to tell him he wasn’t pathetic or that he was good or that he didn’t deserve this or that someone should take care of him or that—
5. You let a fourteen year old do it
6. You let a FOURTEEN YEAR OLD-
Billy emerges from the house, a crying Susan behind him. Billy looks stable, or, at least, relatively stable, considering that most of his interactions with Steve have been anything but. Steve’s chest aches a little at the sight of him, and all he wants to do is hug him, to hold him, to tell him he loves him. (He LOVES him? Jesus Christ, Steve is such an idiot. Robin is going to kill him, and he’ll deserve it). He pushes that last thought from his mind as forcefully as he can and shoves his hands deeper into his pockets.
Billy nods to him, briefly, and Susan takes her place next to her sister, who wraps an arm around her shoulders and whispers something in her ear. Billy looks at them, and opens his mouth to say something, but, after deep breath, he closes it again, looking furtively to Steve. Jesus Christ, Steve loves him.
“Billy,” Max whispers, and Billy snaps his eyes towards her, his mouth opening again. Billy and Steve need to leave now; everyone here knows what needs to happen. It’s not fair, though, Steve wants to yell, they shouldn’t have to separate. Susan should have to live with this, not Billy. Not Max. The pain of separation shouldn’t be on them. But Max has to separate from someone, at the end of the day, and Susan is her mom. Which is shit, isn’t it? Max deserves a better mom. Max deserves a mom that wouldn’t- that doesn’t- Max loves her mom, and Steve feels sick.
“Hey bitch,” Billy says in a quiet voice, and both of the women jolt a little while Steve fights back a grin. “We need to talk, don’t we?”
“Don’t call me that,” Max retorts, but she has a small smile on her face. “And yeah. I guess so.”
xxx
They leave Steve with her mom and Aunt Linda, which feels like a mistake, but she trusts her aunt to keep any bloodshed from happening. She brings Billy to the guest room where she stays when she comes to Aunt Linda’s, because it’s separated enough that no one can hear anything they say through the walls and she doesn’t have to worry about her mom.
As soon as she shuts the door behind her, they both start talking as quickly as possible.
“Listen, Maxine, if anything happens, at all, you HAVE to-”
“You’ll call me, right? You can’t run away, okay? You HAVE to-”
“And I will come find you, but you can’t tell anyone-”
“I swear to God, Billy, I will NEVER forgive you if you-”
She refuses to let him determine the course of this conversation, but it occurs to her that she has no idea what he’s been saying, and the look on his face tells her he’s similarly lost. She pauses. Sometimes, she thinks, she’s so used to fighting with Billy that she forgets there’s other forms of communication. When she goes quiet, he shuts up immediately, looking at her with a crease between his eyebrows.
She points at herself, suddenly feeling like El. “I go first.”
He looks like he’s about to disagree, but she talks over his moment of hesitation. “Listen, Billy, you’re my brother, okay? And I know—it’s stupid—you’ve BEEN my brother, but that’s when you were my stepbrother, but now you’re my—you’re my BROTHER, because it doesn’t matter, yeah? That our parents aren’t the same? Because Steve and Dustin, they’re brothers, and they don’t even live together, and we- you and I- you’re my brother now, okay? You can’t back out of that. So when you leave, you have to—I mean it, Billy, I’m gonna be so mad at you—you have to STAY my brother. And you have to call me. And you have to- you have to REMEMBER me, okay? Because I’m your- I’m your- “ she can’t say it, because she’s on the verge of crying, tears hot and angry behind her eyes, something made out of cement lodged in her throat.
Billy stares at her, his eyes huge and intense, and his whole body is on edge, the way it used to be right before he snapped. She sniffs, trying to rein all the emotions back in, but Billy, after a moment, whispers, in a voice that’s equally shocked and steady: “you’re my sister, Max, of course you are.”
Something inside of her breaks. Billy’s arms are around her in an instant, and he holds her head to his chest, and she sobs, real, angry sobs, and she hates that this has happened twice in one day, now, that she can’t pull it together when Billy’s the one with the awful dad.
“What the fuck, Max, you thought I was gonna just go and never talk to you again?”
She sniffs, and his shirt really must be covered with her snot by this point today. “You said that last time, you said I should never talk to you again, and I don’t WANT to do that, Billy, I don’t-”
He takes her by the shoulders and pushes her back, holding her at arms’ length so he can look into her eyes. “I was being an asshole, okay? Because I didn’t want Neil to hurt you. You ARE my sister, Max. Fuck, you’re the only one in this family worth a shit. You’re...that’s what I was trying to say, okay? If anything happens, anything at ALL, with Neil, or with your mom, or with anyone, call me, and no matter what, I’ll come get you, okay?” His voice is determined, and there’s some grit to it. “I mean it. I’ll come get you, and we’ll leave this whole fucking family behind, okay? I know your mom- she loves you, and you love her. But if she EVER- I don’t care what happens, you got that? You have to call me.”
She nods, and he shakes his head. “You have to say it, Max.”
“I’ll call you. If anything happens. I’ll call you.”
He wraps her in a hug again, and, so briefly she almost thinks she’s imagined it, he kisses the top of her head before stepping back from her again. “Good,” he says, his voice suddenly scratchy, and he rubs at his eyes. “We’re gonna- we’re gonna have to go.”
“I know,” she says around the pain in her chest. “And you’ll be- it’ll be good, and you’ll be happy with them.”
He looks at her, uncertainty in his eyes. “Happy?” he echoes, and Max realizes with a jolt that she’s not sure if she’s ever seen him happy before. She’s seen him excited about something, she’s seen him having fun, but happy...
She reaches out and takes her hand in his. “You asked me, remember? When I took you to Will’s house? You asked me what I wanted from you.”
It takes a second, but he nods. “You said to stay alive. And not be an asshole.”
She snorts. “Well, obviously, that was stupid, because you’re always going to be an asshole.” He grins a little, and she takes a deep breath. “But now what I want is...I just want you to be able to breathe, you know? And then, when you can do that, I want...I want you to be happy, Billy.”
Something that she can’t identify shifts in his face, but he nods, solemnly, his hand still in hers. “Max,” he starts, voice a little shaky, “if you hadn’t been there-”
“Yeah, but I was.” She clears her throat. “Because I’m your sister.”
xxx
Max hugs Steve before they leave, and whispers something that Billy can’t hear in his ear, and then she says, with a frown, “Look, obviously I don’t want anyone to know this, but I will miss Dustin,” and Steve laughs and says “yeah, yeah, I’ll make sure he knows.”
Brothers, Max had called Dustin and Steve, and that word bounces around in Billy’s head a little bit until it’s his turn to say goodbye to Max, AGAIN. They don’t hug this time, while he’s standing outside of the car, but she nods at him and says, a crooked smile in place, “see you later, asshole,” and he nods back and says “back at you, bitch weasel.”
He doesn’t say goodbye to Susan. He doesn’t feel like he needs to.
It takes a few minutes for either him or Steve to talk after they start driving, but then, right as he’s about to say ‘so how was Linda’ Steve says: “God, I’m sorry, I know she’s Max’s mom, but I fucking hate her so fucking much. I mean, JESUS.” He slams a hand against the steering wheel, and there’s a million things for Billy to say right now, a million things he needs to communicate before they’re back in Hawkins. But all he can think, looking at Steve now, is that happy suddenly seems like an attainable goal.
