Actions

Work Header

Oh, You Pretty Things

Chapter 36: Don’t You Know

Notes:

Warnings: referenced abuse, pretty strong self loathing, standard Billy stuff

The alternative title to this chapter is just ‘Boys Monologuing.’

Chapter Text

Maybe breaking the silence just to say he hates Max’s mom wasn’t Steve’s best idea, but the look that Billy gives him after he says it—eyes soft, suddenly unguarded—makes him think that maybe it wasn’t his worst idea, either.

Billy seems to catch himself, because he snaps his attention back to the road, looking away from Steve, splaying his hands across the dashboard and tapping out something. Billy has nice hands—strong, calloused, with long fingers—hands that had been in Steve’s hair, on his hips, less than twenty hours—JESUS, Steve has got to pull it together.

“She could be worse,” Billy says, still fixated on the windshield, and Steve has to try to think about something other than Billy’s hands.

“What?”

“Susan. She could be— you know, she’s annoying as shit, but she’s gonna leave him. She’s gonna protect Max. I mean...” he shrugs, looking over his shoulder at something unseen. “More than my mom did, so, ya know.”

Steve scoffs. “Yeah, not sure your mom is the gold standard of moms, so not sure comparing Susan to her helps Susan’s case.”

“Hey, FUCK you,” Billy spits out immediately, venomous and spiteful, his face completely rearranging from the somber, soft spoken person he’d been two seconds ago. “My mom loved me, so just- FUCK you, man.”

Steve’s clearly made a misstep, and Billy’s obviously having a rough day, but, shit, Steve got bitch slapped by Billy’s dad this morning AND he watched Billy believe lies about himself AND he listened to Susan cry while Billy and Max watched out for themselves, so Steve’s had a bad day, too. He should let this go, though, he should let Billy just rest, just for a moment.

Fuck it.

“You can’t- protecting your kid is just bare minimum shit, okay? It’s not— I’m sorry, man, I’m not trying to say she didn’t love you,” (I’m sure she did, how could she not, how could anyone not love you, why is this HAPPENING to Steve right now), “but, I mean, what’s the point of loving someone if you’re not going to at least try to protect them when you can? Look at Joyce!”

It occurs to Steve suddenly that he has no idea how caught up Billy is. Surely Max filled him in, right? Surely he knows everything. But, at the same time, Billy went from being flayed to being hospitalized to laying on his bedroom floor in pretty rapid succession, and at no point did Steve check in to see ‘hey, has anyone filled you in yet on the monster that possessed you?’ There’s not time now, though, because he needs to make this point. He can do it later.

“Three times now—three times AT LEAST—that woman has gone pretty much nuts trying to protect Will and Jonathan and El, and I mean—she fought RUSSIANS, man, to try to protect them, and I think- I think that’s what you do, when you love someone. I think you protect them.”

Steve once barged into the house of a boy he’d just bullied and beaten a monster with a baseball bat. Steve had once carried that same baseball bat in a tunnel full of demodogs, sure he was about to die, to try to make sure some twelve year olds made it out alive. Steve had tackled a grown man that he hated this morning, because he tried to hit Max. That’s what love is, right? It has to be. That feeling in his chest, that instinct to put himself between something awful and something vulnerable—if that’s not love, what is?

Billy’s staring at him, and Steve can’t tell if he’s angry or not. His eyes are cloudy, and his jaw is set. “Not everyone can be selfless all the time, Harrington. Sometimes all you can do is protect yourself.”

“Maybe,” Steve says, “but that’s sure as fuck not what you do.”

Billy squints. “What the fuck are you talking about?”

“You protected El, at Starcourt. We all saw. And you- man, this whole time, you’ve been obsessed with keeping Max safe, even when you guys are screaming at each other and stuff. That’s what- how many times now have you told me you’re trying to keep Neil from hurting Max? From hurting Joyce? Dude, we were going to run away” -holy shit, they had been planning to run away together, and it feels like a million years ago but it was yesterday- “just to feel like Joyce was safer. So don’t give me that bullshit, because...” Steve pauses, trying to collect his thoughts and suddenly realizing that maybe he doesn’t know what love is. “You’re a better person than your mom was, Billy, you’ve already proven that. I know she loved you. I know Susan loves Max. But you can—they could’ve done more.”

Something shutters off in Billy’s face, and he looks away from Steve again, starts tapping on the dashboard again. “Nah,” he whispers, “I’m not- I always wanted to be like my mom. Everyone likes her. She never yelled, you know? Never got mad. Nice to everyone. Never even- and Neil was such an asshole to her, sometimes, just because he could be, and he always said I was too much like her, but I’m not, you know? ‘Cause I’m not- I don’t know how to be like that. I’m just,” he takes a horrible, shuddering breath, “I’m like Neil, really. And that’s why- you can’t blame her for leaving me, and you can’t blame Susan for watching out for just Max, because- they knew. I’m not like my mom. I’m like Neil.”

Steve suddenly feels like he can’t breathe, and he grips the steering wheel tight, tries to focus on the ride and fall of his own chest.

When Steve doesn’t say anything, Billy continues, somehow even smaller than before: “I killed a lot of people, man, and even before that, I- you were there. You know I’m like my dad. I’m not- you’re right, about Joyce, about Max, about all those stupid dumbass kids. They should be protected. But don’t- my mom and Susan did what they had to, you know? Don’t think less of them, just because- I’m not Max, man. I’m not any of Joyce’s weird ass kids. I don’t- it’s different.”

For the second time today, Steve frantically pulls off the side of the road, and for the second time today, Billy responds with a “what the FUCK, Harrington,” but Steve doesn’t care about any of that.

“You can’t fucking SAY SHIT LIKE THAT!” Steve says, and he scares himself with how quickly he transitions into screaming, with how fast his heart is pounding, with the way his knuckles are white on the steering wheel. “You can’t- what the FUCK, Billy?”

Billy eyes are narrowing, and he’s getting angry, Steve can tell. “Harrington, what kind of BULLSHIT are you on-”

“No, Billy, listen to me! Goddamn!” Steve slaps the steering wheel with the heel of his hand, accidentally hitting the horn, and something about the sharp noise brings him back for a moment, to the situation, and that maybe the people he WANTS to yell at aren’t in this car, and maybe yelling isn’t the best way to explain all of this. He holds his hand to his chest for a second, a dull pain from where he’d hit the steering wheel already subsiding, taking a breath while he can feel the weight of Billy’s eyes on him.

Steve breathes in, breathes out, and slowly turns so that he can face Billy, and Billy has already shifted in his seat so that his whole body faces Steve and his body is braced partially on the dashboard, and he looks wary, and he looks confused, and Steve feels like crying.

“Billy,” he says, as softly as he knows how to, “I’m sorry, I shouldn’t have- God, I feel like I keep fucking up, you know? I’m sorry. I shouldn’t have yelled, I’m not mad at YOU, I just-”

“I don’t care if you yell at me,” Billy says, still seemingly genuinely confused but bordering on defensive again. “What is your PROBLEM-”

“You don’t deserve any of this shit, okay? And you’re not- Jesus fucking Christ, you are not Neil. I mean it, you’re better than your mom, you are, you’re better than Susan, and you’re not- man, how can you even say that? That it’s okay for them to let you get hurt? That you’re not- like, what the hell? You don’t deserve this. People should have been protecting you this whole time. You are- I know you were a dick, I was THERE, you BROKE MY NOSE, and that’s not- you were a KID, Billy, and they’re your parents, they’re the people who are supposed to keep you safe, and you can’t act like- they didn’t protect you because they’re bad people, okay? Not ‘cause you didn’t deserve to be protected. You deserved to be safe, just as much as Max, just as much as Will, just as much as Eleven- you were a KID, I don’t care if you were an asshole. So don’t say shit like that, that you’re like your dad, that you understand why your mom and Susan didn’t help. It’s not different, okay? You were a kid, and you’re still...people can’t just hurt you because they want to, Billy, you deserve better than that.” Steve gets so lost in his own words that it’s hard for him to focus on anything other than his own heartbeat pounding, and Billy’s face has undergone ten different mood shifts while he’s been talking, but it’s landed on that one from earlier, the one that’s soft and confused and less guarded than any Billy Steve’s ever really seen that wasn’t crying in the floor.

“Harrington,” Billy starts, and his voice is cracking, and he looks like he’s trying to physically disappear into the seat of the car, “I killed a shit load of people, okay? It was- I don’t know if you guys have run the numbers, yet, but it was a lot. Heather, Steve, I let it kill Heather. And kids, and old people, and Heather is DEAD, so don’t give me that bullshit, about me being like the kids, because I-”

“That wasn’t YOU, Billy, you were flayed-”

“And what the FUCK do you know about that?” Billy snaps. “I was supposed to kill Karen, and I didn’t, so I was able to fight, and after that, I just didn’t fight hard enough, okay? Those people DIED because I didn’t fight hard enough, and the last thing they saw was ME, okay? The last thing Heather saw was ME.”

“That wasn’t you,” Steve says, and his chest hurts, and he can remember the pure panic of the kids thinking Will was possessed by a monster, of not knowing what was their friend and what wasn’t, and he remembers seeing a Billy that wasn’t Billy and a Billy that was Billy, and he remembers El holding Billy’s face like he was a child and something human coming back to him. “No one could’ve fought that thing, and it’s not your fault. It wasn’t you, it was the Mind Flayer.”

“SUCH A STUPID FUCKING NAME!” Billy screams, and he’s crying now, and there’s a vein on his forehead. “You guys and your stupid nerd games give everything STUPID FUCKING NAMES, AND YOU DON’T KNOW SHIT! It PICKED me, okay? It KNEW. It picked me, because it knew who I am, and what I am, and that- it knew, okay? It knew everything about me and it PICKED me.”

“It picked you ‘cause you were there,” Steve whispers, and he’s crying, too, and he’s trying not to, because this is getting ridiculous, how much he and Billy cry in cars now. “Same reason it picked Will: you were there.”

“How can you know that, though?” Billy asks, the anger gone as quickly as it came, exhaustion taking its place. “Because, I...it was me, Steve, no one else. It picked me, and why else would it, if not because-“

“You were there, Billy, that’s the only reason.” Steve doesn’t know why it picked Billy. He doesn’t know if it’s because Billy was strong or because he was charismatic or because he’s got a feral streak or if Steve’s right, and it’s because it was the closest living body it could find when it needed one. But he knows it wasn’t why Billy thinks it was; it’s not because Billy somehow deserved it. Billy’s chest is heaving, now, and he’s frozen against the car door, still watching Steve. “Billy, you...you don’t deserve all this shit, and I mean it, and...look at the people that love you, man, look at Max, look at Joyce. They’re two of the best people I know, and, I mean, Max is terrifying, and she’s a little nuts, and she was- she was gonna fight her MOM for you today, she’s literally spent every day since Starcourt trying to keep you safe. And Joyce, she’s only known you for what, two weeks? And she loves you, you know she does, and she was there, Billy, she knows what happened at Starcourt, and she still...she’s basically adopting you, yeah? Because she knows that’s what you deserve, and she LOVES you, and Max loves you, and they wouldn’t- you’re not what you think you are, Billy, you’re someone that people love, and you’re someone that should be loved, and none of this—not your mom, not your dad, not Starcourt—is because you deserve it.” There are tear tracks running down Billy’s face still, and he looks scared, almost, and Steve feels so desperate in this moment, needing so badly to know that Billy can understand or believe any of what’s he’s saying. “And I- Billy, in the last week, I’ve completely changed my life around you, and never once have I wondered if you deserved it. I’ve wondered if I’m losing my mind, and I’ve wondered if I was good enough for you, and I’ve wondered if I was doing the right thing to help you, and I’ve wondered if I even know you, but never—not once, I swear to God, not once—have I ever wondered if you deserved to be safe or not. I’ve known, man, since the moment I saw you in your room, that I’d do whatever I needed to to help keep you safe, and now, now I’m in love with you, or whatever, and I still—I don’t know what the hell is happening, dude, but I know that whenever I’m around you...people love you, Billy. And that’s what you deserve.”

“You’re in love with me?” Billy echoes softly, and Steve shrugs.

“Or whatever.”

And then Billy has the audacity to snort, as if they’re not both crying, as if Steve hasn’t just confessed something important. “Jesus Christ, Harrington, it’s been a week and ONE kiss, you’ve really gotta get your shit together.”

“Yeah, I KNOW,” Steve snaps back, but he can’t help from grinning, too, and Billy’s face goes from a smirk to a full blown smile.

“Everything I was saying, Billy, I meant it. What happened wasn’t your fault. And- people should’ve been watching out for you, man. And people love you now, and...yeah. I just need to know that you believe any of that.”

Billy watches his face likes he’s looking for something, eyes flickering back and forth. He runs his tongue over teeth, but Steve’s not even sure he’s conscious he’s doing it. After a moment, he nods curtly. “I know Max loves me,” he says tersely, “and I believe Joyce when she says it, and I believe you, too. And I know- I would never let Neil do this shit to Max, so I know- yeah. That’s all I can give you, right now.”

Steve nods back. It’s not enough—he wants Billy to believe all of it, he wants Billy to know he didn’t deserve any of this, that the Mind Flayer wasn’t his fault—but it’s a start, and he’ll spend the rest of his life teaching Billy to believe the rest of it, if he has to.

“I really want to kiss you right now,” he confesses, and Billy says, “yeah, I want that, too.”

This kiss is different than the last one—it’s softer, it’s easier, it’s more sure. Steve loves him, he knows it.

After a second, Billy says, with his face half buried in Steve’s neck: “We really need to go, I don’t want- We gotta get back to Joyce.”

“Yeah, yeah I know,” Steve whispers, but all he wants to do is hold Billy, forever. “I’m really- I’m really sorry we had to leave Max, man.” Billy makes an awful noise, and Steve’s own breathes are ragged.

‘You have to protect him,’ Max had whispered in his ear right before they left. ‘He has to have someone who cares about him being safe.’ Steve knows that, though, and Steve’s going to spend the rest of his life making sure Billy knows it, too.

xxx

When Joyce sees Billy and Steve pull back in the driveway, something unwinds in her chest, and it’s all she can do not to cry.

They’ve all been frantically packing since the boys and Max left, and she’s called her cousin and explained that, yes, they need to move NOW, not next week, please, and all of the kids are here, now, running around and shoving Will and El’s things in boxes—poor El, she barely even had time to move in—and their voices just make it so much more obvious that Max ISN’T here, that Max should be here, that the kids are missing a part of themselves. And there have been tears on everyone’s part and Nancy has somehow provided car loads of cardboard boxes, and when ever Nancy moves Joyce can see that she still has the pistol tucked into the back of her jean shorts. (“Why do you have a GUN?” Mike had screamed, and Nancy had screamed back “oh, GROW UP, Mike.) And in the chaos of it all, Will had looked at her, Will, her sweet, sweet Will, and said, when no one else was listening: “I’m glad we’re leaving. I- I still get scared at night, here.” And she’d hugged him and her heart had broken that all of her children are so scared and so traumatized and so, so good at the same time.

And when Steve and Billy pull back into the driveway, her heart breaks again with the same feeling, and all she can think is: they’re home.