Chapter Text
Tutoring sessions with Billy were . . . surprising to say the least. Earlier in the year Ms. Gardner had sniffed out his ineptitude pretty quickly and had actually recommended Billy specifically to help him out. She said he had an “affinity for numbers”. This had been only days after Billy’s dramatic arrival, and Steve had already heard more than enough of him at that point. The direct confrontation about his poor performance in class had left him in a sour mood. Hargrove had only been in Hawkins for a brief amount of time, but he was already at a better pace with the class than Steve had been since the beginning of the year. One look at Billy Hargrove and he could hardly believe that was supposed to be the math whiz who was supposed to save his average. He’d told Ms. Gardner he’d think about it with no actual intentions to do so.
And then Billy had become a massive thorn in his side. The guy went from being a general nuisance to an actual fixed point of tension in his life. Steve, who had been used to being on top for so long and was still kind of coming to terms with his newfound unpopularity, was not thrilled to be the focal point of all of Billy’s aggression. Even when he was at his douchiest he was never the one to push it too far, and none of his ribbing really ever got that personal. Billy, though, was dark sided. There was a crackling energy that always seemed to follow Billy around, and he wondered whether it was his shitty luck or just the universe outright hating him that made Billy want to take him down so badly. And Billy had taken him down.
He’d never admit it to anyone else, but Billy beating his face in had been the best part of that shitty night. It had been the only human and natural action performed out of all the horrible things that night, and it was something that he at least understood.
Yeah, maybe beating someone bloody and into a pulp because of a misunderstanding was an over-reaction in the highest regard, but if Steve had the choice again he’d face anything Billy Hargrove related over anything to do with the Upside Down any day.
It had also felt good to deal with the human reactions that happened after the event. Steve hadn’t expected to come to school and be hailed the “winner”. To be honest, it hadn’t even occurred to him that there would be any significance with the fight until Tommy had clapped him on the shoulder and said, “Heard you showed Hargrove who’s boss. Good job, man, California had it coming.” Steve had thought it was some elaborate punchline; some weird roundabout way to call him a pussy, but one look at Hargrove had confirmed what Tommy had mistakenly assumed. Billy’s face looked a hell of a lot worse than his, and it boggled Steve’s mind that he had somehow come out on top in the situation.
His initial anger with Billy had far outweighed his confusion, though, and at first it had felt good to confront Hargrove after school. It had felt even better to punch his face afterwards, but then that’s when Steve had taken a good look at him. That night Billy didn’t have much visible bruising, which was a total contrast to how he looked now. Now, there was something about how Billy already looked like a wreck and was asking for more. In that moment, Steve had finally got the first good read on Billy that no one had done yet in Hawkins.
Getting beaten up that night had only felt good because it was a distraction; something that hadn’t kept him tethered to the situation at the time, for good reason. Jonathan beating him up was something he hadn’t meant to seek out; and while he technically hadn’t set out to capture Billy’s wrath, the two had been wholly different. Steve had seen Billy with some bruises, here and there, and wondered what the other boy possibly could be getting into. It was obvious to Billy, getting into fights was his form of distraction.
Only, after Steve had punched him that day after school there hadn’t been any satisfaction or anything like that on his face. Instead, he had just laid there and took it. There was no surprise there, either, like it was something he just had expected to happen. In that moment Steve had felt something like nausea roiling in his gut for giving Billy just what he’d asked for. He had given Billy a wide berth after that, too discomfited by that expression he’d seen on Billy’s face as he laid in the grass.
Then that weird fluke of a night happened and had left him feeling uncharacteristically charitable after the fact. Billy had seemed oddly concerned about why he had been by himself at a creek in the middle of the night but had also been tactful enough to not bombard Steve with questions. Steve, who had had his fill of tactless miscommunication over the past year, had appreciated it for the kindness it was.
Billy jumping out of his skin at his touch, along with the bruises that most certainly spoke of the aftermath of a fight, only served to prove Steve’s theory that Billy turned to violence when he was stressed, or angry. Or maybe just any major emotion that he didn’t want to face head-on. Physical violence seemed to always be the answer to the question, and Steve figured that night in November shouldn’t be taken personally. Antagonism seemed to be burned in Billy’s blood.
He was the only one who didn’t take it personally, though, if Tommy’s attitude could be judged by anything. While he had congratulated Steve that first day, they still hadn’t resumed their friendship after that. Tommy was much warmer to him, though, and seemed to take a particular delight in Steve being the one to give Billy a taste of his own medicine. Billy was noticeably absent from the large table in the cafeteria that Tommy and Carol took up with the rest of their sheep and wasn’t at ant at any of the tables nearby, either. Steve had been pathetically sitting in the courtyard with Nancy and Jonathan, where he valiantly pretended that their hands weren’t clutched tightly together under the table they all shared.
It was obvious that Billy really had rubbed people the wrong way. His snippy attitude seemed to extend toward the whole school population, boys and girls alike. Suddenly the cool dude from California was just the giant asshole that he had always said he was. Steve had wondered how any of them had fooled themselves into thinking Billy was their friend in the first place; Billy seemed like the type to be fine drifting from person to person, sometimes with large gaps of inaction in between. Even when he had seen Billy joking and ribbing with the other boys in the locker room there was still some kind of . . . look on Billy’s face. Steve couldn’t describe it, but he knew for a fact that there was no one in Hawkins that Billy considered an actual friend. Steve didn’t delude himself into thinking an awkward joint shared between them in the middle of the night made them friends, but at least it was a truce of some sorts.
Then, winter break had happened. Steve was the unofficial babysitter/chauffer for the Party, something that he would grumble about in front of them occasionally but would secretly get a warm feeling in his chest about the feeling of being wanted and useful. Every so often when he was carpooling, he would get glimpses of Billy whenever Max was getting dropped off or picked up. Quick glances were shared through their respective cars, but that was all that happened.
Max nervously asking him one afternoon after a movie if they could speak alone came as a bit of a shock. He really never spent time with Max, mostly their interactions were through the rest of the Party. Steve liked her, though, she was the least loud and least annoying of everyone, and when you were on her good side, she could have you in stitches with the mean streak she possessed. It was something that whenever he saw, he thought Billy was probably the same way and that’s who she had picked it up from. The second his mind made that comparison, he realized that that was probably what Max had wanted to talk about.
Billy, who had dropped her off just two hours ago so she could see Gremlin with the boys, looked rough. It seemed like every time Steve saw him, now, his lip or brow was always split. And earlier, even though the tint of the windows, Steve could tell that Billy had been sporting some fresh bruises on his face. He knew that Billy’s quick rise to the top was now toppling hard, as well. While Steve hadn’t been able to gain back his previous ranking of royalty, he was still relevant enough to get the random party invites. Steve had gone to a couple, more out of the fact of sheer loneliness rather than wanting to get back into the party scene, and never saw Billy.
Apparently, he had been dodging invites and parties the entire break, and it was something that made all of the Hawkins’ ant trail of popular kids grit their teeth angrily. They all still craved his approval, even though it was hard won and so rarely given. As far as they were concerned, if Billy wasn’t going to play the game then he wasn’t going to get any part in the winnings.
It didn’t seem like the type of thing for Billy to do, and while Steve really didn’t know Billy when it came down to it, it was still something he found discomfiting.
So, Max had asked if they could talk in private, and Steve was quick to pick up on the anxiety practically pouring out of her. Dustin had looked like he wanted to protest, but Steve shoved him through the open door of the front passenger seat and told him to scram for a sec. Max wasn’t usually one to look this high strung, and each passing second was making him more and more uneasy.
She picked at the loose string on the side of her Converse while Steve waited patiently. He noted her face was wildly pale. At the time, he had thought it was simply a redhead thing, but afterwards he realized she was probably deathly scared to steer towards the subject even tentatively on her mind.
“So, I know we don’t talk much, or like, at all.” She switched to running the pad of her thumb over the patent leather seat, something that he would see Billy mirror almost exactly just a couple weeks later, “But I need to ask you a favor. If you can’t do it feel free to say no.” She said the last part forcefully, communicating with her eyes the seriousness with which she meant.
Steve, who was cautious not to make any sudden noises or movements in fear of spooking her further, only nodded. He was extremely weirded out by the feelings radiating off of Max now, her stress was starting to make him feel a little frayed at the edges too.
“If you can . . . would you be able to pick me up and drop me off sometimes?” She looked like the words were sour leaving her mouth.
Steve felt bad for her. It looked like it had been physically painful to pry those words out, and her face had switched from a pink pale to a bright red flush making its way from her ears to her neck.
“Of course, Max,” he was cautious to not sound overly-nice or understanding; Max seemed to have the most social smarts of the Party and would be able to pick up on any insincerity or dishonesty in his voice. He needed to ask the next part, though, just to quell the curiosity that had been building and building impossibly over the course of the break, “Why can’t Billy drive you anymore?”
Because that was the crux of the matter. Steve’s mounting obsession with Billy was desperate enough to prod the guys’ younger sister for answers. Ever since that night at the creek, Billy had been content to just fade into the background and Steve hadn’t been content to let him do so. Yeah, it had been awkward a little bit after that night where he had embarrassingly asked Billy to use his first name, but he had been determined to give the other boy the space he seemed to so desperately crave. He had thought that after a little bit of recovery time they probably could be more civil to each other. There was this sort of quiet desperation attached to Billy that Steve somehow seemed to resonate with, and he had found himself stealing glances at Billy in calculus to try to catch another glimpse of it. The only time it seemed to come out was when he was in a bad mood, though, and Steve was kind of sick of being on the other end of one of Billy’s moods.
It felt like they had traded spaces, with Billy buzzing in his ear like a fly at first, to now Steve being the one who clung like a gnat. Nancy and Jonathan actively disapproved of his sudden fascination, and he wasn’t stupid enough to let Dustin and Co. know anything about it. Here he was, though, giving Max a tentative version of the third degree just to scratch that itch in the back of his head that always concerned Billy.
It had been the wrong thing to ask. Max’s face went beet red, and Steve watched as her face scrunched tightly in the middle as if she were trying to physically fight back tears. Steve started to panic, distantly aware that they were still in the movie theater parking lot with Dustin standing almost right outside the car, screaming his head off about the movie to the other boys. Having a thirteen-year-old girl that close to tears in his car had been a first, and something he never wanted to repeat.
Max recovered quickly, though, and once she got herself together, she had felt good enough to send a disgusted glare at the crumpled napkin he had offered her from the side pocket of his car. “Ew,” she said, batting it away, “I’m fine.”
But she clearly wasn’t, though Steve was reluctant to point it out in fear that she’d somehow turn on him. It seemed like Max was precariously on the edge of revealing something, and he didn’t want her to get cold feet and end it there.
She was fidgeting in the seat. “He’s had a rough break.” Is what she finally offered in response to his previous question. He encouraged her to keep talking by being silent, aware now that she needed to build herself up to these things. He was afraid of making a misstep, which seemed to be something he excelled at. Running his big mouth was probably one of his worst qualities but was also why he probably got along with Dustin the most.
Being quiet was the right thing to do in this situation, though, because he could see Max slowly start to defrost at the edges.
“I’m really sorry about that night!” She finally blurted into the silence. “When Billy beat you up, I mean.” She bit her lip so hard it looked painful. Like she was trying to still keep something in.
This was where Steve was really taken off guard, though, and didn’t know how to respond. It was hard knowing that probably every word he spoke was being over analyzed, but he still didn’t have clue of what was the right thing to say in the moment. “Uh, Max, you don’t—”
“I know you probably hate him and think he’s crazy person, but he’s not.” She was now vehemently interjecting, like if she didn’t start it now, she never would. “I thought he was a total douchebag for the longest time too, but.... I can’t tell you.” She finally finished miserably. “I wish I could tell you. It would make so much more sense.”
Steve was getting concerned she might start crying again. Max had started to get that watery sheen over her eyes, and it made Steve feel even more out-of-sorts with the conversation happening. “What do you mean? What can’t you tell me?”
“It doesn’t matter,” she said gloomily, staring down at her scuffed shoes now and steadfastly avoiding eye contact. “Billy is just . . . it’s complicated. But I know that deep down he probably didn’t mean to hurt you that bad.”
“Max,” he was still trying to be as delicate as possible, aware that the conversation could turn on its head at any point, “You know Billy’s already apologized, right? I don’t hate him. Although I won’t argue with you on the crazy part.”
She ignored his last statement. “What?!” her jaw was hanging open. Steve thought about making a joke about catching flies but figured now probably wasn’t a good time. She looked completely upended by the information. “What do you mean he apologized?”
God, he forgot how dramatic middle schoolers could be, no matter how Max was probably the most mature out of all of them. “We hashed it out. He explained, said he was sorry, and now we’re cool.” Which wasn’t exactly the truth, but it wasn’t like they had any active beef between them nowadays. Maybe being cool with Billy just simply meant he wouldn’t beat you up. He would take whatever he could get.
“What did he explain?” she demanded.
He was taken aback. “Um, I mean, his like, attitude issues, I guess? He said he had been having a rough night.” Max look stumped at that. “Why? Was there a different explanation?”
Max went right back to nervously fidgeting; yanking so hard on the string in her shoes he wondered if she would pull out a couple of inches of stitching. Tension seemed to be the cornerstone of both her and Billy’s attitudes. She still didn’t answer.
“Max,” he leaned forward, hoping this would make her catch his eye. She did it, but grudgingly. “Is everything okay with Billy? You don’t feel . . . unsafe with him, do you?” Steve hated asking it, but Max was just acting so bizarrely he had to cover all bases.
“No!” She was quick to deny, which made Steve take in a sigh of relief. He had thought that Billy was giving the kids less grief lately, if their loud conversations in the back told him anything. So far, the entire break Billy hadn’t tried to run down any of them with his car and this was considered an incredible feat amongst the boys. He wondered how far Max had really gotten to Billy; that November night while she had been driving Billy’s car, she had savagely sworn revenge and Steve had fully believed her in that moment.
“No!” She repeated, still thinking Steve didn’t believe her. “God, aren’t you listening to me?”
“Max, I’m trying here.” He pleaded, starting to grow desperate, “You’re kind of freaking me out.”
“Look— “She started to say, looking just as comfortable trying to reassure Steve as he felt by being reassured by her. She started differently this time, “I have something else to ask you. It’s another favor.”
“Okay . . .” He raised his eyebrows, trailing off.
“It’s a big one.” She was facing him head-on again. “If you said no to this one, I would understand.”
“Alright, shoot.”
“And you can’t tell any of the Party I asked you this, not even Dustin. Especially Dustin.”
He wavered a little. It wasn’t a matter of him blabbing Max’s secrets to the other boy; but rather Steve didn’t feel right committing to obscuring anything from Dustin. If there was anyone that had been there for him the most throughout the past year, it was Dustin. Pathetic as it was, it was the cold hard truth. Instead he settled on, “Max, you’re making me worried again. What is it?”
But Max was undeterred. “You have to swear you won’t tell them, even if you say no!” She was getting red again.
“Okay, okay! I swear.” At Max’s dubious look he rolled his eyes and spat in his palm, holding it out. She batted it away with a wrinkled nose. “Now can you tell me what this favor is?”
She still looked wary. Steve tried to give an encouraging nod. She blew him out of the water with what she asked next.
“Could you check on Billy sometimes?” Steve had flown back in shock. “I know that you don’t owe me anything, and I know you sure as hell don’t owe him anything... but—I. I don’t know. He’s been really freaking me out over the break.”
“How has he been freaking you out?” He couldn’t imagine what it was like actually living with Billy, and the thought came unbidden to his mind before he could stop it. Rather than letting his mind go down that particular rabbit hole, he turned his attention back to Max.
“I can’t... I wish I could tell you. God!” She angrily smacked the side of the car. At the noise, the boys outside started squawking indignantly. Distantly Steve could hear Dustin saying something about freezing out here, but he knew it hadn’t been that long and he was overdramatic anyways. Max noticed the boys still huddled outside, complaining now, and looked guilty, “Sorry.”
“It’s okay. Don’t mind them, they can freeze.”
She looked at him, still looking unsure but seemingly determined to have the conversation. She took a deep breath in. “He doesn’t ever come out of his room anymore. Usually when things get bad, he just stays in his room for a couple hours, or he goes for drives in his car. His dad’s been taking away his keys at night, lately, and now I go days without seeing him or hearing him. He just lays in the dark for hours. And when he does drive me, he doesn’t even tease me.”
It was a lot of information and Steve hadn’t known which part of it to address first. It took a couple seconds, but he finally got his bearing together. “What do you mean, ‘when things get bad’?” It seemed like the first thing to address. It was in the way Max phrased it, like he was supposed to have information to back it up so he could understand what she meant.
“Steve, he would kill me if he even knew I was telling you all this.” She looked deathly serious, now, and Steve wanted to cry out in frustration. He didn’t know what he was supposed to be getting and not getting. He didn’t know why Max had chosen him of all people for this job, anyways. She wasn’t finished, though. “I promised him. And no one keeps their promises to him.”
And God. Now there was no way he could say no; not when Max said stuff liked that and looked as desperate as she had in this moment. The only thing he could do was agree at this point. “Okay, Max, I’ll try to help all I can, but I really don’t even know what I can do.”
“Just . . . you don’t think he would hang out with you, right?”
He gave her a dubious look. “I mean, I’m sorry Max. He apologized that night and everything but we’re not actually friendly. I just don’t really expect him to beat me up anymore.”
“So, you don’t think you could get him out of the house or anything?”
It had been an odd request, and he felt out of his depth. Max was coming at him with too much information and not enough processing time, not to mention that the information itself was so wholly confusing he needed a minute to wrap his head around it. He wasn’t going to outright tell her no or anything, but he really didn’t see how he could be of any help in the situation. Yeah, Billy didn’t have a lot of friends, but surely there was someone more qualified to help with this?
“I mean, like I said. We’re not really friends right now.”
“Okay, I’m sorry. I thought I would ask.”
She looked so dejected he tried to backtrack a little, “Max—”
“You won’t tell the Party, right? They still hate Billy and would hate me for asking you.” Her face twisted a little. “You don’t hate me for asking you, right?”
“No, Max, of course not.” He said it as forcefully as he could, afraid that she was about to go into a tailspin. He grasped on an errant thought, “You don’t think your dad could talk to him or something?”
“Neil is not my dad! He’s my stepfather.” She had exploded immediately. The breaths were huffing through her noise. He had recoiled a little at her sudden volume. “Besides, he’s the last person—” her eyes cut away quickly to him and she cut herself off just as soon. “Anyways, just forget I asked. It was already too much to ask for the rides.”
She had seemed to fold back in on herself, miserably, and Steve had been sure now that this would be the last he would get out of her. “I’m still good for the rides. But won’t Billy or your stepdad notice that another person is picking you up?”
Max shook her head. “No. Neil will be fine since you’re babysitting everyone else, and Billy won’t care. He’s been in hibernation too long.”
“Okay, if you’re sure.” There had been something about the way she still sat there, anxiously bouncing up and down. Like she wanted to tell him more but was physically holding herself back. “Max, I feel really bad that I—”
“Just forget it, okay? I shouldn’t have even asked.” She was done at that point; Steve could see it in the line of tension in her shoulders. He felt bad for disappointing her but had no idea what it was that she really wanted him to do.
“Max—”
“Please, Steve.”
She had looked so distressed in that moment he had no choice but to accept. “Okay.”
He resolved that he would give the rides to Max, maybe keep a distant eye out for Billy, and hopefully that would be the end of it.
That wasn’t the end of it, though. After that conversation he ran it over thousands and thousands more times in his head. It was all he could think about, actually.
The first time he pulled up to the Hargrove residence to pick up Max he had half-expected Billy to storm out and demand to know what he was doing. It never happened, though, and it never happened every time after he picked and dropped Max off. That first night he had been stalling outside of the house for a little bit, not even sure what he was waiting for, until Dustin had pinched him and screeched, “What are you doing? Do you want him to come and eat us?” Dustin’s favorite comparisons to Billy were along the lines of either an ogre or a troll.
Max herself never brought up that conversation with him again during the break. The boys all assumed she was getting rides from Steve because she didn’t want to have to deal with Billy, and Steve never corrected them. The only indicator there was that she still thought about their conversation was the way she would guiltily glance to the window on the left side of the house, where the blinds were always drawn. Every time he spied her doing it through his rearview mirror, he felt another pang of guilt for not being able to help her out.
Billy didn’t show up to any parties for the rest of break, either, and Steve in contrast found himself attending every single one for at least a couple of hours. He told himself it wasn’t just so he could see if he could get a glance of Billy; and when he never did, he told himself he wasn’t disappointed over that as well. Max had wanted him to forget she ever asked for the favor concerning Billy, but instead Steve found himself fixating on it to an alarming degree.
He thought it might have been because of how lonely he felt over the break. His parents had called on Christmas morning and New Year’s Day, but both conversations had been short-lived and there was poor reception where they had been at the resort in the Alps. Lately whenever his parents would call, he would get a quick jolt of, “Oh yeah!” as if the presence of their existence was something he had to constantly remind himself of.
Being the kids glorified driver was all well and good, but there was still the disconnect of being much older than the Party, and while it felt good to be included on their outings he still was too aware of how little social interaction he was doing in comparison to the rest of his life. There was no beating around the bush: Steve was lonely. Him and Tommy’s friendship had definitely had plenty of questionable moments, but for the most part they had been each other’s millstones, a touchpoint in the center of everything. Nancy had replaced Tommy for a little while, but it was different having a best friend and having your girlfriend be your best friend. While he didn’t have any current animosity towards Jonathon, it was still clear that they were very different people with very different interests. The prospects for just having another friend were pretty bleak.
He could sense his growing desperation mounting as the break went on and on. Like it was building toward something inevitable. He didn’t realize how much he had been obsessing over it until the break had abruptly ended and he found himself catapulted back into high school politics.
Billy’s Camaro wasn’t in his usual claimed spot when he drove in Monday morning, and it didn’t show up for another ten minutes either. Steve was about to cut his losses when walking up to the school he heard the familiar roar of engine. Then, when he finally spied that blue Camaro, he realized that he was in too deep.
Trying to shake his head clear of the fuzz that had just filled it, he scurried into school. The beginning half of the day was spent in a haze; Steve too overwhelmed with his lack of sleep the night before to just jump into lesson plans that day. His eyes felt sticky and hot by the end of fourth period, and he wondered if Nancy and Jonathan would notice if he skipped lunch with them to take a quick nap in his car.
He hadn’t followed through on the nap, though, and spent the lunch pretending to himself that he didn’t see how happy they were and consoling himself by actively scanning the cafeteria and courtyard for any sign of Billy.
Finally, came the moment he had been waiting for. Math class.
Billy was already in the room when he poked his head in, and even with a quick glance Steve could see what Max had been worried about. Billy’s golden California tan had receded over the break; replaced instead by a sickly pale that you got from staying in all the time. Even from across the class Steve could see the way the eye bags sat on his face; deep purple marks that rivalled Steve’s own. Not only that, but Billy’s body was so visibly coiled with tension it looked like it was uncomfortable for him to even be sitting upright. In that moment Steve decided that he would try to figure out a way to come through for Max. He just had to figure out how.
First step had been dropping into the seat next to the other boy. Billy had looked startled, but then dropped his head back down to his own desk even after Steve’s attempt at a friendly smile. He didn’t say a thing the entire period, and Steve found himself glancing over every so often to make sure that Billy was even awake. After glancing once or twice, he realized that part of the reason why Billy was barely moving was because he was done with the homework they were being assigned later tonight. Suddenly, it was like the clouds had parted. Ms. Gardner’s words from the beginning of the year rang back to him, Billy’s affinity with numbers, and he could instantly see the path laid out for him crystal clear.
That wasn’t to say that tutoring went smoothly every time. That first time had been the worst; afterwards, Steve had cursed himself over and over for ruining the night by bringing up his own issues with school, no matter how surprisingly kind Billy had been with him. Things never got as bad as that, but every so often the mood would sour when Steve would get reminded just how inept he was with classes and school in general.
Billy never said anything mean about it, if anything he tried to tactfully navigate around the subject without stepping on any toes. Steve was aware that there was probably a part of Billy that still felt guilty for that night, so he tried to be as easy-going and friendly as possible. Billy seemed like he was immune to Steve’s good nature, though, and always seemed like he was wary of how agreeable Steve always felt.
It took about a month of tutoring to melt through the frost Billy had built over the break. His particular brand of iciness wasn’t dissimilar to his douchey attitude before school had let out, but now he had no one to back him up or vouch for him if he went too far. Steve knew that Tommy and Carol still had bad blood with Billy, and as a result most of the high school had taken to ignoring him on the daily. Steve never saw Billy at lunch, but he always reeked of cigarettes when he got to math class, so Steve figured wherever he was during lunch, he was there alone. Against his better judgement Steve had begun to develop empathy for Billy; he didn’t want to, but it was so easy when the other person had such a similar brand of loneliness to his own.
Finally, around mid-February, he and Billy were veering toward a somewhat tentative friendship. Steve had never pictured himself being in this position back in November, but he also didn’t believe that he’d be passing calculus either. Billy was a patient teacher, and it was obvious that the material came easy to him. He had told Steve that he had taken the class before, but Steve knew that Billy had probably aced it back in California just as he was acing it now. Math was always the focus of their tutoring sessions, but sometimes they’d take a break halfway through and Billy would help Steve stumble through some of his essays for English or quiz him for biology. Billy seemed to be academically gifted in all subjects, but he was quick to deny and clam up every time Steve mentioned it. Since Billy had never prodded about his obvious learning disability, he returned the favor by not pushing him about his smarts.
They had a pretty good rapport at this point, too, Steve finally understanding that you had to wade through the prickly surface in order to get to the smooth core. Billy was obviously intelligent, and with that came a dry humor that often had Steve in stitches; desperately trying to hold in his laughter sometimes so he wouldn’t come across as too dorky.
Tonight, they hadn’t had much to work on, but at this point were too used to meeting up twice a week, so whenever these nights came, they ended up idly working on their homework and shooting the shit. Steve, who had uncharacteristically finished his history assignment during lunch with much needed help from both Nancy and Jonathan, ended up being the one to have nothing to do. Billy, who was probably doing next week’s science homework, noticed almost immediately.
“What,” his eyes were narrowed, and it didn’t sound like much of a question.
Steve guiltily stopped tapping his pencil. “What?”
“’What’ as in ‘What are you doing?’”
He shrugged. “I dunno. I finished all my stuff.”
Billy looked uncomfortable. “Listen, man, just tell me when to dip and I will. You don’t have to wait for me to finish my shit.” He went to snap his book closed.
God, it was so difficult dealing with Billy sometimes. You’d be coasting and everything would be fine, then one wrong move and his hackles were up. Every time Steve had to talk him down from the ledge, he felt like he was soothing a snarling dog. “Jeez, man, I’m not saying you have to go,” and that was the truth, but if he wasn’t telling him to go then just what was Steve doing?
He already knew the answer to that though. And there was no beating around the bush. He had been bracing himself to make an offer for the last week and a half of tutoring sessions but had kept chickening out at the last moment. Billy still looked like he was ready to bolt, though, so Steve knew he had to get to it fast.
“Do you wanna take a smoke break?”
Billy blinked. He looked caught off guard. “Uh, sure, if you want.” He switched to gingerly gathering his things into his bag.
Steve watched on, pretending that this wasn’t a major difference to how they usually spent their evenings. It seemed like most of the time they were content with starting and ending all interactions in the safety of their tutoring sessions, but had had the unprompted thought in his head for a while about maybe . . . extending the invitation. Of course, he appreciated Nancy and Jonathan and their endless support, as well as having Dustin and the others always there to have his back, but Steve hadn’t had his own close friend in a while. And after spending enough afternoons with Billy, he was beginning to think that they really had more in common than they initially thought.
Billy joked about meeting the old King Steve sometimes, but Steve knew that if that Steve met Billy it would either end in the highest of highs or lowest of lows. Sometimes he figured they would have gotten on like a house on fire; Tommy may have been replaced within a short matter of weeks. Other times he thought they would have probably had a worse explosion than what happened back in November. That was based on the fact that the old Steve was a lot less understanding towards fickle and irksome natures. Billy’s ribbing would have been alright at first, but the amount of physical fights he seemed to get into probably would have been the line for Steve. The shit that had gone down with Jonathan had been in a moment of crazy desperate heartbreak, and even in that fight he hadn’t held his own. Funny how he was alright with being friends with people who knocked him to the ground pretty well.
But Steve could tell that under all that tension Billy was just like any other high school kid. If anything, he was wittier and funnier than his other high school companions, and Steve was always down for a good laugh lately. Coupled with the fact that there was still a deep part of him that analyzed his and Max’s conversation, it was the perfect storm for Steve to justify befriending Billy Hargrove.
They walked back to the backyard, Billy assuming to head that way since he usually never smoked inside houses and Steve just willing to let Billy do what he was comfortable with. He didn’t smoke cigarettes that often anymore, but he could at least hold his own enough to not hack up a lung in front of Billy. Although maybe that would be funny enough to Billy to cut the weird tension in the air.
Billy shook out two cigarettes from his pack and offered one to Steve. Steve, who had made the suggestion but had no way to follow through if Billy had randomly forgotten his pack seeing as he usually never smoked cigarettes on his own, took one gratefully. They exchanged Billy’s Zippo to light and Steve took pains to make sure he looked natural while flicking it closed.
“Thanks,” he offered. Billy just nodded and took a drag.
They smoked in silence for a couple minutes. Finally, Steve broke with a, “So do you miss California?”
Billy almost physically recoiled. “Uh, I mean, yeah.”
Steve cursed himself for asking stupid questions, which seemed to be one of his specialties. “Right. Yeah, I’m sure Hawkins is a bore.”
Billy looked cautious. “Yeah, it’s not so bad but. California’s better.” He flicked the end of his cigarette to clear the ash. He seemed to get lost in thought for a couple seconds before offering up, “I lived right by the beach. Sucks that there’s nothing like that here.”
Finally, something Steve could grasp onto. “Oh yeah? That’s cool. I think the closest thing I’ve been to a beach is Lake Michigan.” After sharing that he immediately became aware of how small-town hick he sounded.
Billy thought the same thing too if his grin was anything to go by. “Does Lake Michigan get any tides?”
“Actually, now that I think about it, I’m pretty sure it does? I went there when I was like ten, so most of what I remember was that the water was too cold to swim in.”
“Nah, not the ocean. It’s cold at first, but after a while if you stand still enough, you can feel the sun through the water.”
“Did you ever surf?” Suddenly the thought of Billy hanging ten in some board shorts seemed alien in his mind. Maybe if Billy were wearing denim board shorts or something, or ones in pure black.
Billy was outright laughing now, all previous awkwardness forgotten. “No, maybe once or twice but that wasn’t my thing. I’d just swim far out til’ the water would hit my neck.”
“And wait for the sun through the water?” He couldn’t help but ask.
“Exactly.” Billy’s eyes were so blue and piercing it almost felt like a whoosh! Of breath left his chest when they made eye contact. He was desperate to keep the conversation going.
“What about after that? Your average day in California, I mean.”
He took another drag and seemed to think it out. “Hm. Swim at noon, get lunch on the boardwalk after. Probably get street tacos, or pig out and get the junk food on the pier. After that I’d cruise around town, maybe go to a movie. Most of the time I’d end up driving the half hour to San Diego to waste my time there. That’s where a lot of the live music scene is. There were a lot of clubs and bars that didn’t look too hard if you had a fake. Then, after all that, I’d head home and pass out.”
Steve gaped. “That was your average day?” Hawkins must have seemed like a ghost town. It was hard imagining many places in Indiana that didn’t close after 10 p.m.
But Billy just laughed. “No. Most times I just stuck with swimming and cruising. I did that on the weekends, or a bad day,” he almost seemed to cut himself off abruptly, taking another hit of his cigarette.
At the sight, Steve took his own up for a drag. Almost half of it had wasted away while he was listening to Billy’s description, but he didn’t mind. He just flicked the ash off onto the cement below, like he had seen Billy do moments previous. “Well, Hawkins must seem like a drag, after that.”
Billy gave half of a shrug. Steve was hit by a thought, “Hey, why did you move to California, anyway?”
That was the wrong thing to ask. Billy shuttered almost immediately, and Steve watched it physically and metaphorically unfold before his eyes. Where Billy had been open, easygoing before, he was now back into the Billy with the rough edges and the hard attitude. Steve was painfully aware that there could be another ass whooping in his future—but just as the thought sprung up Billy seemed to uncoil.
It was like the air had been deflated from a balloon. “Eh, a lot of stuff. Mostly with my dad, some with me.”
It was such a non-answer that Steve almost felt like raising his eyebrows encouragingly. He noticed Billy and Max had the same way of revealing personal information: like it was painfully prying it piece by piece from them. He considered it a win that Billy was even entertaining the question.
He seemed to take Steve’s silence as an indicator to continue and looked like he was parsing out the words in his head before he delivered them. “My dad was having issues with the contractors he was working with. He ended up having to switch locations. I got—into a fight, and then we ended up having to leave after that.”
“You got into a fight before you left?” Steve frowned, trying to remember how Billy had looked that first week, and could only remember smooth, tan skin. He shook his head, trying to clear that sudden thought.
Both of their cigarettes were dwindling low, now, but neither of them seemed to notice. It was like the air around them had grown hushed, and Steve would almost think it was Upside-Down related if Billy weren’t right in front of him, the cause of the tension. Billy rolled his shoulders back and seemed to brace for impact. “Nope. Went to the hospital and was all healed up by the time we came over.”
Now Steve did notice his low cigarette, when the heat hit his fingertips, he let out a “Fuck!” and dropped it to the ground before grinding it under his feet. That was the last thing on his mind, though, the way his fingertips still stung. He was still holding onto Billy’s last statement, “You went to the hospital?”
Billy did another of his half shrugs, the ones where it looked casual but where Steve could also tell were supposed to conceal a greater anxiety underneath. He was used to giving them all the time, but never being on the receiving end. Billy seemed determined to always keep things casual and light, something Steve hadn’t noticed until he started making himself look for it.
“No biggie. You never went to the hospital before?”
“Yeah, but I mean, not for that.” Which was true. Even when Billy had done his worst Steve still hadn’t needed to see a doctor. He wondered how messed up someone had to be, especially Billy, to need to get treated for their injuries. “What about the other guy?” it seemed like it was smart to try to make humor of things for now, Billy didn’t seem the type to open his arms and tell all. Especially if he could tell the other person was really paying attention. Steve got the idea that people usually didn’t try to listen too hard when it came to Billy.
This time, he made the right move. Billy gave a smile, and while it didn’t seem as easy or carefree as before, it was still something. “You wouldn’t want to know.”
He wondered how many fights Billy had been in. Steve could probably count on one hand how many fights he had been in, and two of them had happened within the past two years. It just never was his go-to when it came to confronting people; even when he had been a peak asshole, King Steve was rarely the first to incite physical violence. Billy, on the other hand, seemed to exude violence. Steve had noticed over the course of their tutoring sessions just how many times Billy would have an odd bruise here and there, sometimes a split lip. Other times his face would look rough, and every time he saw any of these things happen, he wondered just who in Hawkins Billy kept starting fights with. It had to be someone from the edge of town, or maybe at some of the dicey biker bars that littered the highway. Either ways, it seemed like a hell of a lot of trouble to go out of your way just to seek stress relief in the form of fighting.
“Whatcha thinkin’ about, pretty boy?”
He rolled his eyes, ignoring the flush that came up every time Billy used that nickname. He knew it was good old-fashioned ribbing between guys, but there was still a degree of it that felt personal. He didn’t know why out of all the nicknames Billy probably had in his repertoire he chose to use that one almost every time. Steve felt like dishing it out a little back to him.
“Just wondering why you always seem so down to get yourself beaten to a pulp.” He was sure that Billy probably gave as good as he got, but it was obvious that whoever it was always got a few good hits in.
He grinded his own cigarette under his boot. “Guess that’s one of those wonders of the world, huh?”
Steve stared blankly back at him. Billy rolled his eyes. “God, Harrington, you gotta try to read, like, even a Ripley’s Believe It or Not once in a while.”
“Yeah, yeah,” He rolled his eyes, “Forgot I was talking to the Boy Genius over here.”
“You know, you’re not too bad, Harrington. You’re pretty funny, even if half the time it’s like you don’t mean to be.”
He was flushing again, and this time he didn’t know why. He chalked it up to the sheer weirdness of Billy being nice and decided to leave it at that. “Gee, thanks. You’re not so bad yourself, though.” He gave a grin. “When you’re not trying to beat me up, I guess.”
This time Billy gave a laugh. Steve was happy he’d been able to steer them out of that murky territory that they seemed to be wading in for a while, and Billy seemed content to let the earlier stickiness of the subject be washed away with some good natured banter. Something about him looking so . . . approachable and unconcerned was making Steve want to do crazy things. It was the first time in a while he had been hit with such an impulse, and it was no surprise that it concerned Billy.
“You wanna go get some food?” It was the second dangerous thing he’d offered this evening; and by the look on Billy’s face it was just as unexpected as the first had been.
Billy glanced down at his watch nervously, but said, “Yeah. I mean, if you want to. I just gotta get back by nine.”
Admitting that he had a curfew seemed to draw a painful wince from Billy, and Steve was a little surprised. Someone like Billy seemed to operate on his own time, and he tried to remember if Billy had ever talked about having strict parents. Now that he thought about it, Billy didn’t seem to complain about his dad or stepmom really at all. Maybe following their rules meant that he was on better terms with them, and Steve wondered what if felt like to have parents that actually wanted you home when they were home, instead of not caring at all and leaving you up to your own devices.
“That’s cool, man, we’ve got two hours. I highly doubt it’ll take that long to eat a burger at Sally’s.”
When they were out on the driveway the both of them hesitated for a second. Finally, Steve made the executive decision to beeline towards Billy’s car. It had been kind of an unspoken agreement that they were going to drive in the same car (anything else would be a waste of time and would also be extremely awkward) and since Billy still looked a little unsure Steve figured he could have the home turf advantage. Or, well, home car advantage.
Billy’s car stank of cigarettes and weed, and it made Steve thankful that he had leather seats instead of cloth. Knowing Billy, he probably chain-smoked in this car every waking moment, and even as Steve had that thought Billy was already shaking another cigarette out of the carton. He offered one to Steve, who declined knowing that any more nicotine and his stomach would probably turn.
After fiddling with the heat and making sure the both of them were getting blasted with the warm air, he gestured to the glove box. “Tapes are in there.”
When Billy didn’t elaborate any further, Steve took this to mean that he got the privilege of choosing music. Rifling through the cassettes, he realized that most of these he either didn’t recognize or he didn’t want to subject himself to the noise it would bring. Billy seemed to only like loud rock music. After a couple seconds of digging, though, he struck gold. He popped in The Best of Blondie and covered the radio with his hand so Billy couldn’t see what he was doing. He skipped to the third track and then waited for the fallout.
The beginning drums started and before even two seconds had passed Billy was already glaring at him. “Harrington, out of all the shit you could possibly play, this is what you choose?”
“If you didn’t want me to play it, then why is it in your car?” Steve felt clever firing back.
Billy only rolled his eyes. “I keep that for Max. Figures that you and her would have the same taste in music.”
Steve laughed, “Whatever, don’t get mad at the fact that you’ve probably been called Blondie a million times and now you have an unfounded hatred for her.”
“Unfounded? Wow, that’s a pretty big word. Must have copied it from my English homework.”
Steve smacked him in the arm and was struck once again at how different a place they were at now compared to months ago. In November Steve would have taken that very personally, enough to maybe fire back something biting and insulting back to Billy. Now, he could appreciate the fact that it was easy to tease and easy to be teased. Him and Tommy had never riffed as much in the friendship they had had their whole lives compared to the two measly months Steve had spent with Billy.
The tide is high but I’m holding on . . . I’m gonna be your number one . . .
He found himself bopping along with the beat and humming with the tune. It wasn’t a lie that he liked Blondie, and he wasn’t surprised him and Max had the same taste. Steve was more of a pop, or soft rock kind of guy. Nothing at all like Billy’s taste. Billy, for the most part surprisingly, seemed fine with just letting Debbie Harry sing on in the background. When Heart of Glass came on, though, Billy groaned.
“Okay, now you’re killing me, Harrington. Please change the tape.”
Steve popped open the glove compartment again. “I refuse to listen to anything that deafens me, and I feel like that’s all you have left in here.”
Billy switched to driving with his left hand and reached his right into the glovebox. Steve, who had been hunched over the thing this entire time, withdrew as much as he could so Billy wouldn’t accidentally brush him. He didn’t know why it was so important to do that, and he ended up feeling silly when Billy didn’t attempt anything nefarious. Instead, he dug around the cassettes while casting an eye to the road every so often. “Finally,” he declared.
It looked like just a plain cassette, no artwork, or letters on it displaying an album. It probably shouldn’t have come as a surprise that Billy made his own mixes, he seemed to have very specific opinions about music and what kind of person you were depending on the music you listened to. Steve braced himself for the wailing of a guitar or beating drums, but instead he got Tumbling Dice.
“You like the Rolling Stones?” he asked incredulously. They just seemed a little too . . . girly, for lack of better word, for Billy, no matter the fact that they were probably the “heaviest” rock band Steve listened to.
Billy looked at him like he was dumb. “Of course I do. Who doesn’t like the Stones?”
He shrugged. “I dunno. They just didn’t seem like your scene.”
“My scene is rock-and-roll, Steve,” he said like it was obvious. “The Stones are one of the building blocks of the genre.”
Steve, who was still recovering from the random butterflies he always got when Billy decided to actually use his first name, searched for something witty to say. “I guess I thought they weren’t hard enough for you.” And then cursed himself for not being able to string a complex sentence together. Billy didn’t say anything about the double entendre Steve unknowingly worked into their conversation.
“No, man,” and now Billy was getting into it, “The Rolling Stones are hard as fuck. They’ve got that musicality. Only ones brave enough to start using blues in their songs when they could tell rock was starting to get old and tired. Knocked the Beatles off their fucking high horse, rightfully so.”
He raised his brows. “Damn. Alright, consider me schooled. Do not assume anything about Billy’s music taste.”
Billy seemed to belatedly realize how intense he had been coming across as and scaled back as Steve saw blush creep up his neck. They both opted for listening to the heavy saxophone and guitar in the music. Even the oooh’s of the background singers, or Mick Jaggers smoky voice proclaiming You’ve got to ro-oll me, call me the tumblin’ di-ice, did nothing to break the silence. It didn’t feel that awkward, though, and Steve was content to let the instrumental wash over them. The song faded and switched to a heavy guitar piece he knew was Led Zeppelin, and something more along the lines of what he pictured Billy listening to.
They pulled up to Sally’s and Steve fixed himself with a confident bravado that probably was left over from his King Steve days. He was determined to play this as casually as possible, knowing that any sudden or wrong move could have Billy lapsing back into that uncommunicative state he seemed to enter whenever he was faced with any sort of pressure or stress. Billy seemed like he was content to pretend as well that it was completely normal he was rolling up to a diner with Steve Harrington, of all people, and distantly Steve thought it was funny how delicate they were being with each other. Now that they were in public Billy seemed to want to draw as little attention to himself as possible.
Sally’s wasn’t packed when they came in, but it never really was packed any time. Even on Friday and Saturday nights there weren’t more than twenty-five people at their busiest rush, and Steve wondered how it was able to stay afloat for so long. As far as he knew, Sally’s had been around when his parents were teenagers in Hawkins. It was always a constant, though, and was the number one place he always went to when he was stumped on what to eat for dinner. Usually he settled with the fried chicken sandwich, but since tonight was something of a special occasion, he was fine in indulging in the bacon cheeseburgers that were the most popular item on the menu.
When Missy saw him, she gave him a nod and gestured at him to take his usual booth. It was the one in the corner of the diner, and one of those long rounding corner booths. Steve chose it because when he usually came to sit down, he had the Party with him. The booth was furthest away from the entrance and served as a buffer to protect the other patrons from the sheer volume the kids could sometimes reach. When two people sat in it, though, Steve was aware how weirdly intimate it was to sit in the large booth. It never felt that way when it was just him with Dustin, but somehow with Billy it just felt different.
Billy, for his part, took it in stride and just stretched his legs out under the table. “This your new throne?” he gestured to the ripped red upholstery near his arm.
Steve laughed. “Ha. More like the feeding trough for all the kids.”
Billy nodded at that and picked at his menu. The silence from before still lingered even in the diner.
“Have you ever been here before?” Steve was struck by how quickly the words tumbled out of his mouth. It felt like all he really did was ask Billy questions, and he wondered if sooner or later Billy would notice and get annoyed.
For now, he was fine, though. “I’ve seen it a couple of times, but I never walked in. Seems like the stereotypical joint in this kind of town, though.”
“Yeah, small towns and diners go hand in hand.”
“Along with farms. I don’t think I’d ever seen that many cows in my life until the two day drive it took to get here.” His eyes glittered with mischief, “You ever tip any of them over? Or is that just a rumor you bumpkins use on city folk?”
Steve had to laugh at that. “Can’t say I’ve ever tipped a cow over. But you never know, could happen soon.”
Missy came over and they both got the bacon cheeseburger. Steve got a Mountain Dew and Billy got a water. When she came back with their drinks, he wrinkled his nose at the lime green soda. “You know that’s just gonna keep you up all night, right?”
Wasn’t like it would make any difference. Steve told him as such, “I won’t be sleeping much tonight anyways.”
“You do that a lot?”
“What? Drink sodas past seven o’clock?”
“No, dumbass,” Billy rolled his eyes. It almost sounded fond. But just almost. “I mean, do you not sleep a lot?”
He was uncomfortable with where this was going. Steve was aware that his little insomnia issue probably came across as super weird to anyone not in the know of Upside-Down issues. Regular high school guys like Steve weren’t supposed to only sleep an average of three hours a night, and the little sleep they got wasn’t supposed to be riddled with nightmares, either. He was aware that he was going to have to do some tiptoeing around this subject, which also made him feel a pang of worry. Billy was too perceptive to be able to casually slip things by him.
He opted for his usual casual shrug he had perfected over the last year or so. “Oh, I sleep okay. Just get restless now and then.”
“Then maybe you shouldn’t drink Mountain Dews at night.” Billy sounded so much like a chiding mother Steve had to let out a laugh at that.
“Yeah, I’ll try to keep that in mind.”
A beat passed. Then, “Is that why you were smoking in the woods in the middle of the night?”
He felt like flinching back, but that would be too obvious. Instead he had to keep it cool. Regular teens in high school weren’t supposed to have his degree of anxiety. Billy was waiting on an answer, and his unflinching gaze made Steve resist squirming in his seat. “Yeah, I mean, sometimes I just wanna stretch my legs. So. I just . . . drive around or go for a walk.”
It sounded weird even to his own ears. No normal kid left their house in the middle of the night to drive around or walk in the dark because they were restless. Now he was fidgeting and tearing up the straw wrapper, trying not to think about how strange he must be coming across.
“I do that too, you know,” Billy offered after it was clear Steve wasn’t going to continue. “I told you how I drove around the streets back in California, right?”
“Yeah, a little.” The description of his day still sat in the forefront of his mind, and he figured it was probably something he’d twist over and over in his head tonight.
Billy was nodding. “Over there, not matter what time, the shops and buildings were always lit up. Or, if you drove near the pier, there were these tiny lights they’d hang from the posts. Most of the time I’d just drive for hours at night, because there’s less traffic, but you can still hear everyone who’s out.” He seemed to realize how much he was talking and started trailing off.
But Steve was enraptured. California sounded like some kind of fantasy land, especially compared to dinky old Hawkins. “Dude, come on, I’m trying to live vicariously through you.”
Billy snorted. “It’s nothing that special. Just a couple of lights. But over here, by the time I drive around at night, everything’s shut off. It’s like the whole town goes to sleep at nine o’clock sharp.”
“Yeah, that’s Hawkins for you.” Then it struck him, “Where do you usually drive?”
“I dunno,” Billy shrugged, “Around.”
Steve had to roll his eyes. Sometimes he thought Billy was leagues ahead of him socially, then other times he thought they both had the same levels of ineptitude. “God, Hargrove, you know I’m not trying to mow you down with my car, right?”
Billy flicked his straw wrapper at Steve, who hadn’t noticed he’d been balling it up this entire time. “As if, Harrington. No way you’d sacrifice your fancy Beamer for that.”
Jeez, Billy was good at distracting him from the subject. “Listen, I’m just saying,” he tried to make his voice sound a little more hospitable, “If you ever see my car on the side of the road, feel free to make sure that I’m not dying in the woods.” Is what he settled on. He’d meant to tell Billy that they could maybe meet up sometimes, but then that felt too weird to say out loud. He still wasn’t sure if they were even on “friends” terms yet.
He felt a kick under the table. For a second he was so distracted by the random thought of what it would be like to play footsie with Billy that he barely caught the, “Yeah, alright, If I see your little red BMW I’ll make sure to drop by and say ‘hi’.”
Steve tried not to smile too hard, despite the lingering oddness of his last train of thought. Billy had a good way at picking up what he really meant, and he wondered how it was that there were other times that Billy felt so disconnected. Like he was two different people in a matter of seconds.
Billy seemed content to drop the subject for now, but Steve had an inkling that it was one of those things he would file in his head to bring up at a later time when Steve would be caught off guard by the subject. He had his own inklings about Billy he was keeping squared away, so he figured fair was fair.
It occurred to Steve how odd it would be to see them from the outside looking in: Steve as the former fallen king, and Billy as the recent fallen king. What was it about Hawkins that chewed you up and then spat you back out? Not for the first time he wondered what it would be like to be any place but here; it felt like everyone who lived here was stuck in some sort of vacuum that stopped them from seeing anything else besides what they’d always known. Billy was lucky that he had lived someplace else before, not only someplace else but California of all places. Or maybe that made it worse for him, going from a place brimming with life to a place that seemed to be stuck in the same monotonous cycle.
Even as he could see random other teenagers in the diner, he wondered what they thought at the sight of them both. Him and Billy had lost all their respective cool reputations, and now it probably looked like two sad sacks accepting that they were the new pariahs. Which had been fine when he had had Nancy by his side. When it had been just him it had sucked, knowing that not only did you not have anyone really there for you, but also knowing that all your classmates were laughing at you behind your back. The upside was that now at least Billy seemed to be in the same boat as him.
But it didn’t seem like this high school stuff really got to Billy. He thought maybe Billy would bitch once or twice about his sudden drop from the pedestal Tommy had lifted him onto since he first came onto the scene; yet Steve hadn’t heard a single peep from him concerning anything related to that. He wondered if he should ask Billy about winter break sometimes, but even asking Billy to take a smoke break and get burgers with him had nearly sent him into a tizzy of anticipation and nerves. He had to take baby steps. He had to take baby steps anyway because Billy seemed to spook so easily.
For a while they just let the sounds of them chewing at their burgers fill the silence. Finally, when Steve had wiped his mouth and Billy let out an unseemly belch, Steve figured he had probably pushed it a bit. Billy seemed to be glancing at the clock almost nervously, like he was already impatient to get out of there, and Steve wondered if maybe the whole curfew thing was just an excuse to bunk out early. But he also figured Billy was a big boy, and if he really didn’t feel like hanging with Steve he would say so. At least, that’s what he was trying to tell himself.
Driving back in Billy’s car was different than the drive there. The cassette started almost immediately when he turned on the car, and they both jerked in surprise when Lynyrd Skynyrd began crying from the speakers. Well, Steve had jerked back; Billy completely jumped out of his skin. He noticed that Billy had a bad habit of being surprised. Or maybe just reacting badly to surprises. Not that Steve was really that much better, but at least he had the demodogs as his excuse.
The energy was different the whole way back to Steve’s house; almost like they had just done something against the rules. On the way there they had talked about music. Now, they were letting an ear-splitting guitar solo fill the void. It seemed like a step back, and Steve wondered what it would take to put them back into that easygoing conversation like before. Bringing up music again seemed like it was too obvious what he was doing, and Billy didn’t seem to be in an approachable mood right now.
When they pulled up to Steve’s house, he was disappointed to see Billy was just dropping him off. It made sense, it was almost 8:30 and if Billy was telling the truth about the curfew thing then it made sense for him to want to jet out as quickly as possible. It didn’t stop the nagging thought at the back of his mind that even Billy Hargrove didn’t want to hang with him.
He was a couple steps away from the Camaro when he heard Billy call his name. His first name. He turned around.
“Listen . . .” he seemed to search for the words. “Usually when I drive, it’s around midnight. I don’t know how late you stay up, but I figure it’s pretty late if you were smoking a joint around 1 a.m.”
“Yeah, I stay up late.” Was what Steve dumbly said back. He was surprised by the abrupt turnaround Billy seemed to have.
“Maybe I’ll see you around, Harrington.”
“Uh, yeah, sure,” He felt like he had to reclaim back some brain cells in this conversation before Billy sped off thinking he was a neanderthal. “Maybe you will.”
Billy didn’t say anything else, just squinted his eyes back at Steve like he was trying to see something. After a second, he just nodded and threw his car back in reverse. Steve stood at the end of the driveway, watching the Camaro peel down his neighborhood and feeling like someone had pulled the rug from under his feet; making him lose balance and wondering why it was so hard to keep up.
~
Saturday was a day with Dustin. Dustin had dramatically told him last week that Steve was “pulling away more and more each day,” after Steve had told him point blank that he didn’t want to join their bi-weekly D&D tournaments. While Dustin had huffed and accepted that, Steve had felt that warmness in his chest again and offered to hang out with only Dustin on the weekend. That had immediately perked the other boy up. It was a sad realization that he was truly so starved for companionship that he was excited to spend the day with a thirteen-year-old. On the other hand, though, there was something so refreshingly genuine about Dustin’s enthusiasm. Steve would admit that it felt a little good to be hero-worshipped sometimes, especially since most of the time he felt like there wasn’t any real good parts of him left. Dustin made it easy to forget his stress sometimes.
As if on cue, Dustin let out an inhuman shriek as he looked back and forth between Missy and Steve. Steve, who had literally only good thoughts of Dustin in his head up until now, was reminded again of why it was a poor choice to always surround himself by children. It took them years to learn about volume control. Missy had innocently brought up seeing Steve the other night whenever she was taking their orders, and Steve knew the second the words were out of her mouth he was destined to hate his life for the next couple of minutes. Dustin, for his part, looked outrageously betrayed.
“Who did you bring here?! Anyone from the Party?” The last part sounded accusing.
“Dustin—dude, simmer down.”
“Don’t tell me to simmer down!” And there was the pitch that always had Steve choosing this booth away from everyone else. “Answer the question!”
“It was no one from the Party!” He was quick to assure, “Jeez, boundaries much? You know I’m, like, a real human being with real life friends.”
Dustin raised his eyebrows. “Really Steve? Resorting to lying now? Who was it, then?”
And that was probably even worse. “Um, actually, yeah, it was one of the Party.” He’d rather die on that sword than the one bearing Billy Hargrove’s name.
But Dustin was quick on the uptake. “It’s someone secret,” he was intrigued and leaned forward almost the whole way over the table. “Who was it? Was it some girl? Is that why you’re not coming to the Party meetings? Because you know Mike would find out and tell Nancy? Is it Nancy?!”
“God, no, Dustin!” He didn’t know why his voice sounded so disgusted. “No to all of that, you watch way too much daytime television.”
He wasn’t deterred, though. “But you’re lying! You get all squirmy when you lie!” and sure enough, the second he said that Steve realized he was tearing up his straw wrapper again, so much like the other night that for a moment he lost himself. Dustin seized upon that opportunity. “You have a secret! Why can’t you tell me? At least tell me her name!”
“Dustin,” He groaned, feeling strange that Dustin was unknowingly comparing Billy to a secret girlfriend. “Please, drop this. It’s no one.”
“You know I can just ask Missy when she comes back again, right? In fact, I think I see her over there, let he just—”
“Fine!” He hissed, feeling that this was about to be a bad idea, “It was Billy Hargrove.”
Dustin stilled from where he was halfway out of the booth to wave Missy over. He slowly sat down, looking Steve over. Steve had the distinct impression that he was about to be diagnosed with some kind of incurable brain tumor by the way Dustin was looking at him.
“Steve, I’m worried about you.”
The absolute sincerity in Dustin’s voice had him choking on his drink. After he recovered from a mild coughing fit, with Dustin looking even more concerned about him, he tried to grin showing all was okay. “Thanks buddy, I appreciate your concern, but I’m just fine.”
“No, you’re not! You’re pulling away!” Dustin’s voice was beginning to veer towards that high pitch again. “And now you’re hanging out with the Antichrist!”
“Dude, Billy is not the Antichrist. The. . . Antichrist is the Antichrist.” Yeah, maybe that metaphor got away from him.
Dustin looked similarly unimpressed. “Steve, no offense, but I don’t really value your judgement, right now. In what world do you think it’s okay to hang out with Billy Hargrove?” The way he spat Billy’s name made Steve feel a little incredulous, seeing as Dustin had adopted an actual creature of monstrosity, so it was a little rich hearing about a lack of value in judgement.
“Listen, Dustin,” He tried to be rational, trying to detonate the bomb named Dustin Henderson that was currently in danger of going off, “It’s no big deal. Billy’s just tutoring me for our math class.”
“Then why were you here with him Thursday?”
God, this kid should be a cop, he thought miserably to himself. It was humbling to be continuously outsmarted by a middle-schooler. “What, we can’t eat at all? I’m telling you, Dustin, it’s really not what it sounds like.”
Dustin was still undeterred. “And what’s this about him tutoring you? Am I really supposed to believe Billy is some kind of math genius?”
“Uh, yeah?” He had to no clue what else to say to that. The truth was the truth. “He’s actually pretty good at every subject.”
That didn’t assure Dustin, though. Only made him look at Steve like an alien more. “Steve, you sound crazy. You’re defending him. You’re acting like you’re friends! He beat your face in!”
Missy dropped Steve’s chicken sandwich and Dustin’s mac and cheese. He tried to catch her eye to give her a glare for letting Dustin loose on him, but she wisely kept her eyes pinned to anywhere but the two of them. Dustin ignored his food in favor of leaning forward and spreading his hands on the tabletop.
Steve had to cut this off before he launched into another tirade. “Dustin, calm down. I haven’t been body snatched or anything. Billy has been tutoring me since the new semester, and we’re sort of friends, okay?” He gave a helpless shrug. “He apologized to me; you know. For that night. And he hasn’t done anything really dick-ish lately.”
Dustin seemed to mull that over. He was silent for a moment, before unexpectedly saying, “You know he said sorry to Lucas over the walkies?”
Steve did not know that. Billy barely mentioned anything about the kids, and Steve had figured that he was still taking to heart what Steve had threatened him with that one day after school. “No, when did he do that?”
“I dunno. A couple days before school started. I thought Max forced him into it.”
Steve had to give a laugh at that. “I don’t think anyone could force Billy to do anything.”
Dustin still looked grave. “We didn’t think that he was actually being serious. Do you?”
“Dustin, do you think he’s playing some kind of long con? Why else would Billy apologize?”
“You’re sure he’s not still secretly evil?” Dustin questioned, still looking disbelieving. “No offense, since he’s apparently your new best friend, but there’s something seriously off about the guy.”
“Listen, Dustin, I know how to handle myself, okay? Do you really think if there was a chance of Billy beating me up again I would be willingly letting him into my house?” Dustin looked like he desperately wanted to say something to the end of that statement, so he carried on anyways, “It’s fine. Has Max complained at all about Billy lately? Talked about him being annoying or anything?”
Dustin shook his head reluctantly.
“There. I’m telling you, everything’s fine. It’s probably a good thing to have, like, one single friend who’s not in the middle of everything going on.”
“Well, technically, he’s Max’s step-brother, so one could argue—”
Steve tossed his fries Dustin’s way. That killed the tension for now. The rest of the dinner was spent as if everything was normal, but Steve could tell that the second he dropped Dustin off there would probably be a group discussion via walkie talkie over what Steve had divulged to him earlier that night. He wondered whether Max would tell them what she had asked him over break, but it probably wasn’t likely. Both her and Billy seemed to play their cards to their chests all the time. Steve wished he could be that way, but he felt like everything was always written all over his face. He figured it just went hand in hand with the whole stupid thing.
When Steve’s driving him home later, probably five minutes from Dustin’s house, the other boy finally brings it up again. “I’m not saying you can’t look out for yourself or anything; it was really fucking freaky watching him just keep going at you over and over.”
Steve’s heart clenched. He wasn’t annoyed that Dustin had given him a hard time, it had just been a little disheartening that apparently so many people had so little faith in him. Even a thirteen-year-old. But seeing it from Dustin’s point of view, it probably was more than just really fucking freaky watching some asshole beat up one of your friends. Knowing that there was someone that was trying to look out for his best interests was something he was still trying to get used to, but Dustin was reminding him every time they hung out why he was solid as a rock. “I know, buddy. But I swear there’s nothing to be worried about. I’m not going through any sort of crisis, and I promise you Billy isn’t going to beat me up.”
He believed what he was saying. He just hoped that it was actually the truth, and not just some hopeful manifestation. Dustin seemed to accept that, though, and dropped it for the last time that evening.
When he finally got home, he was feeling uncharacteristically exhausted. It probably had more to do with a day of Dustin being dialed up to an 11 rather than any progress in his sleeping habits. He wasn’t going to waste an opportunity to get some much needed shut-eye, though, and he made sure everything was set up in his room accordingly: drawing the blackout curtains shut (even though it was already dark out, it still felt safer having the windows completely covered), making sure he had just the right amount of pillows and blankets, and setting his sleep machine to the perfect volume. It was methodical. It was crazy. Usually with his sleep machine he set it to the brown noise setting, preferring the deeper pitch rather than the high-toned static that he felt when he listened to regular white noise mode. This time, however, he set it to “ocean tides”, thinking about Billy’s description of swimming out until the water lapped at his neck.
In fact, as he was lying there trying to shut his brain off, he started thinking of the ocean again. It was easy to, with the waves in the background. He tried to picture it from what Billy described, especially the look of sun rays cutting through the water. That time he had been to Lake Michigan he had barely stayed in the water for twenty minutes before running out. He hadn’t been lying when he told Billy how cold it was, but he could also remember his mom telling him how if he just kept swimming he’d warm up eventually. Steve had been too impatient to let himself freeze for that long. Now, the thought of willingly making himself that cold again after fighting the chill in his bones since November, wasn’t something he’d put himself through again.
It was easier to picture himself on the California coast facing the Pacific: crystal blue skies with not a cloud in sight, and the even deeper blue hue of the ocean at the skyline. Walking slowly, cutting through the undertow, moving further and further into the deep end of the ocean. Going all the way up until his neck, like Billy had said. Standing there for a bit, feet planted in the warm sand beneath, letting the rest of his body get swayed by the tides around him. Finally feeling surrounded by that warmth Billy talked about. With the sound of the waves crashing in the background, and feeling toasty under his blankets, he was able to drift off without even realizing it.
~
Falling asleep was nothing like waking up, three hours later. Where he had felt completely at ease shutting his eyes, when he woke again, he was sweating and panting. His heart was racing like he’d just ran a mile, and his blankets lay in a heap at the end of his bed where they usually ended up anyways. It took a couple minutes of measured breathing before he finally felt like he wasn’t gasping for air anymore. So, the usual shitty feeling that came after waking from a nightmare. Three hours was pretty decent compared to how his usual attempts at naps went, and he was reminded why when he finally tuned in to the artificial sound of his white noise machine. He shut it off and tried to shake the panicky feeling that was still left over.
He took a shower, which helped clear up the last of the cobwebs still sticking in his head. The scalding water helped him focus on slowing down his heart rate, and when he was finally done with it all he felt less crappy than before. Not altogether too great, but at least he felt more awake than even just ten minutes ago. He had tried to remember what the nightmare was about when he was in the shower, but just came up blank as usual. He didn’t know if it was better or worse that he never remembered.
It ended up being a quarter to midnight when he finally got his bearing together. He racked his brain trying to figure out what to do before he remembered his and Billy’s tentative agreement just a couple of days prior. Without letting himself overthink it to the point of talking himself out of it, he grabbed his keys and went for a drive.
It took him probably twenty minutes to find the blue Camaro parked in the corner of the parking lot for the only decent shopping center located in Hawkins. Everything was closed, since it was past midnight, but some of the lights in the lot were lit up, giving it an eerie feeling. He slowly inched towards Billy’s car, where he could see the other boy in the front seat: one hand being used to smoke and the other over his eyes. Steve was worried for a second about interrupting, before he firmly told himself to stop being such a coward. Billy wouldn’t have agreed if he didn’t want to. When his Beamer got closer, Billy lifted his hand from his eyes before spotting Steve and giving him a little two-fingered salute. Steve took that as an invitation.
When Billy made no further movements, Steve ignored the sound of his pulse rushing through his ears and parked his car, hopping out and sitting in Billy’s passenger seat. From the immediate smell, he knew Billy was smoking a joint rather than his usual cigarette, and Steve accepted it when Billy passed it his way. This time Billy’s mixtape from before wasn’t playing, instead it was a fast-paced song with squealing guitars that he didn’t recognize.
He itched to turn the volume down, even just a little, but knowing Billy this would be seen as some sort of highly disrespectful move. Billy seemed to be very protective over anything concerning his car. Thankfully, the song ended, but the next one following it was just as loud. Something must have shown on his face, because Billy gave a dramatic sigh before turning the dial down.
“So-o, Steve-o,” Steve was taken off guard by the sound of his name through Billy’s singsong tone, “What brings you to this neck of the woods?”
It took him a minute to catch up. “Oh, ya know, just doing my nightly rounds,” parroting what Billy had said to him months back. He wondered if Billy would get it.
He did. His eyes were narrowed dangerously but his smile wasn’t the usual mean one that went with it. “This time I’m letting you smoke all my good reefer, huh?”
Steve laughed. “Yeah, I guess so.” He took a couple seconds to get a good inhale. It was much smoother than the joint he had been smoking that night by the creek. “Mine wasn’t as good as this, though.”
“That’s for damn sure,” Billy took it from his hands gingerly, “This is from my secret stash.”
“Oh really? So, I’m smoking grade-A California grass?”
Billy groaned. “God, don’t ever say that again. It sounds like you’re a narc.”
Steve rolled his eyes. “Oh yeah, sorry King of Cool. I forgot that being from California made you the guardian of culture.”
Billy gave a cackle at that. Steve rode the high of saying something witty enough to make Billy laugh.
“Good” was an understatement for the weed Billy had smuggled from California. By the end of the joint, Steve was feeling higher than he had in a while, and he thought maybe once he went home he might even attempt to sleep again. Billy hadn’t rolled down the windows at all while they were smoking, so the smoke ended up just building and building until Steve’s eye’s felt red hot. The heat blasting in the car also added to the effect, and Steve ended up feeling hazier than he might have expected.
He craned his neck to get a good look at Billy, the first since randomly climbing into his car, and then it took him a second to process. “Hey . . . is your eye, like, swollen?”
Billy, who had also seemed to be chilling just moments ago, looked back at him. Now that Steve was looking at him head on he could see that he was right, Billy’s left eye seemed to be a little puffier than the other one, and the area around it almost looked a little darker too.
“Nah, I don’t think so.” Billy didn’t even check in the mirror to see. “You’re probably just too high, Harrington.”
“Um, I’m pretty sure a joint doesn’t make you hallucinate.” He waited for Billy to say something, but there was just the sound of the music playing extremely low in the background. Before he could tell his high mind it wasn’t a good idea, he was already reaching to flick on the overhead light.
Billy caught his wrist right before he did, though, and Steve figured his iron-clad grip probably would have hurt more if he weren’t so stoned. “Okay, okay, I got it: don’t fuck with anything in the Camaro without Billy’s permission.”
The grip eased and Steve untangled his wrist from where Billy had had it clutched moments previous. His skin still felt warm right where Billy’s fingers had been, and he chalked it up to the weed making him feel like everything was suddenly over sensitive. Billy, for his part, looked a little spooked at himself for reacting so quickly, so Steve let the slip up slide. He didn’t think he’d actually been in danger of getting his wrist broken by Billy or anything, but it had still been startling to him when Billy had moved that quick; especially since Steve’s everything was moving at a molasses pace currently. He had some pretty good reflexes for a person that seemed to surprise so easily.
“Harrington,” he was jerked out of his thoughts by Billy’s voice. Billy was looking directly at him now, with an expression that was so intense Steve was momentarily taken aback. “I wasn’t gonna hit you, or anything.”
“Oh,” the words seemed to be slowly pulled from him. God, he couldn’t imagine smoking this weed on the regular. Hawkins shit must be like actual grass to Billy, compared. “I knew that.”
Before he could think better, the words were already tumbling out of his mouth. “I don’t think you’re gonna beat me up anymore.” Billy looked like the one being taken aback now. “I mean, I hope you’re not?”
“I won’t, man,” Billy said immediately. He paused a bit, though, “It’s just . . . sometimes it’s the first instinct.”
Yeah, Steve had already figured that out by now. There was no tactful way to say that to Billy, though, so instead he opted for something encouraging. “Well, sometimes that’s useful?”
“No, it’s not.” Billy was glaring daggers through the window past Steve’s head. “It fucking sucks. It’s bad.”
“Well, yeah,” Steve hedged, feeling entirely unprepared to handle where Billy seemed to be headed. “I mean, it’s not—you know, good to hit people. But at least you know it’s bad, right? Some people hit people and don’t care.”
Billy gave an ugly laugh, but at least he dropped it from there. Steve could still feel the tension radiating off of him, though, and it reminded him of Max in his car all those weeks ago. The both of them were so alike in so many ways, but there was no way Steve was going to bring that up now. He couldn’t ever imagine himself bringing up that conversation with Max to Billy willingly, some part of him felt like Billy would either see it as a great betrayal or great embarrassment. Probably both. And then they’d be back at square one.
“Listen,” he started now, feeling the mood dampen with each passing second and determined to not let it stay that way, “If I thought you were an actual bad person there’s no way I’d ask you to tutor me, let alone smoke a joint in your car. You just have, like, impulse control.”
When Billy laughed this time, he could tell it was genuine instead of the mean he had pulled moments ago. He was shaking his head, “Impulse control. I’ll be damned. Maybe you have found your calling.”
Steve raised his brows. “As what? Professional rambler?”
Billy took a cigarette out of his front pocket and lit it up. “No, dumbass, you should be a counselor or something. You seem pretty good at talking people down from ledges.”
“Me? I don’t think so, man.” He laughed, embarrassed because Billy probably thought he was, like. . . sensitive or something. Which wasn’t exactly considered a popular quality amongst teenage boys. “I mean, you helped me out that one night.”
Billy waved that away impatiently with his other hand. Steve could feel the air from the movement whoosh over his face. “Not the same thing. You can actually, like, talk to people.”
“Me?” Now Steve was in disbelief. “You’re the one who got the whole school wrapped around your finger in, like, a week!”
“Yeah, but that’s all fake, Harrington.” Hearing it so bluntly put made Steve jerk back a little. Billy went on,” I’m just a really good bullshitter. As you can see: the second I dropped the act everyone dropped me.”
“Billy, c’mon, that’s not—”
“Ha!” the cigarette was dangling precariously out of Billy’s mouth as he laughed. Steve was so distracted by the contrast of white cigarette wrapping against the red of Billy’s mouth it took him a moment to realize what Billy was getting at.
He shook his head, feeling like there was still some great caveat to this. “Okay, sure, become a shrink. Thanks for the life advice.” It just felt like a highly ironic statement considering the state of his mind currently. Not that Billy knew that, but it still made him feel like a sham.
“Not trying to lecture you, man, just calling it like I see it.” He took a deep inhale, then blew the smoke rings Steve had never gotten the hang of, even when he was at his highest peak of King Steve partying. Watching the wispy little o’s disintegrate away took his mind off things for a moment. He got where Billy was coming from, and it wasn’t really Billy making him feel this way, but the whole thing had just been an uncomfortable reminder of how much he really wasn’t okay. Billy talked about being a good bullshitter, but no one was better at it than Steve Harrington. You could ask Nancy Wheeler if you really needed a confirmation.
Billy must have noticed the souring mood radiating off of Steve, because he felt a nudge. “You good, man?”
For a second Steve thought about lying, doing the whole spiel of lost in thought or whatever he would usually come up with, but he was so sick of that. So sick of not saying anything, never acknowledging it. There was no way he could actually tell Billy the 100% truth, but at least he could do something. Blame it on Billy’s ridiculously good California weed.
“Nah, not really.” The words felt slow and suffocating combined with his cottonmouth, “I think you’re wrong, I think I’m an even bigger bullshitter than you.”
He didn’t need to look over to know Billy was giving him some kind of a look. “I highly doubt that, Harrington.”
He shook his head, already geared up for the rebuttal, “Billy, if you truly knew how much of an act everythi—”
“Steve.” He stopped at Billy’s tone. It wasn’t scary, but the firmness and gravity in tone he used made Steve listen for a second. “I’m telling you right now, however much of a sham you think you are, it’s nothing compared to me.”
Which, okay, Steve had known deep down Billy never actually liked any of the fast friends he had made since arriving in Hawkins, but other than that it seemed like Billy was a pretty authentic person, with a personality that was so big it had to be natural. “I highly doubt that, Hargrove.” he repeated Billy’s words back to him.
“What, you think because everything feels fake right now it makes you bogus, or something? Try having everything in your life feel fake. At least at some point yours was real. I’ve never been real.”
Steve couldn’t tell if it was just the way Billy said it or the way the joint still had his brain fried, but it had him questioning, “What does that even mean?”
Billy, who had dropped off in thought at the end of his last statement, finally seemed to come back into focus. “Listen, man. I talked to Tommy before. I know that some kind of shit happened between you guys, but you were friends at some point. Good friends.” At Steve’s confused look, he groaned.
“What I’m saying, is that at some point you guys were super close. Probably knew everything about each other, right? Went over to each other’s houses all the time, knew lots of shit about him and his family you probably wouldn’t have known otherwise, right?”
Steve nodded. It was true, the decade of friendship he had shared with Tommy had made them entangled in each other lives, which was why it had hurt so much that Tommy was apparently able to shelve all of that just because of a disagreement.
“Alright, well, I’ve never had that. Fake people don’t let other people know everything about them, especially the stuff they wouldn’t be able to keep from them. Maybe you feel you’re like that now, but I guarantee you it’s just temporary.”
It was probably the most he’d ever gotten out of Billy, and also the most genuine. What he was saying made him sound like he was convinced that he wasn’t genuine, though, and it threw Steve’s mind through a loop. “Billy, I don’t think just because you don’t, like , share stuff with people that makes you a fake person. Maybe you’re just selective about who you share it with.”
Billy cast him a look through the side of his eyes. If Steve stared hard enough, he could almost see how Billy’s eye had swollen a little more since when he’d first noticed in the beginning. It didn’t seem like the right moment to bring it up again. “Yeah, maybe.” Was what Billy finally offered.
They sat there for a couple more minutes, Billy just idly smoking his cigarette and Steve’s mind working in overdrive to full comprehend the entire loaded conversation they’d just had. It felt like Billy was being transparent, but Steve just wasn’t able to see something. Just like when he had spoken with Max, he felt like there was just something he was supposed to get here; the thing to make everything click.
Whatever it was, it had him feeling bad for Billy. It was a surprise to find out that Billy had never really had close friends, even in California. Steve, who was now only suffering because it was the first time in years he didn’t have a best friend, felt guilty that he’d taken advantage of something he had just never naturally questioned. It made sense Billy was little rough around the edges at times; he had never had anyone to bounce back on.
“Well, I’m probably not what you had in mind, but I guarantee you there’s nothing you’ll say that could really freak me out.” At Billy’s disbelieving snort, he was quick to protest. “I’m serious, man. I guarantee it. Try me.”
Which, if Billy even knew about just the demodogs alone from last year, he’d probably be thinking along completely different lines. If he actually knew about what went down in Hawkins after hours and in the woods, he probably wouldn’t question Steve’s capacity for surprise much. In the grand scheme of things, sorting through Billy’s complicated emotions sounded like a much easier task than even one hour spent in those tunnels again. And it was a challenge Steve would be willing to accept, looking forward to it, even.
“Yeah, sure Harrington. We’ll see about that.” Billy rolled down his window and tossed the cigarette butt out. While he didn’t seem completely back to normal, he had at least come back from that morose mood he had been sulking in earlier. Second by second the usual Billy was staring to appear again, false confidence and a wicked grin. Now when Steve saw it all he could think about was Billy saying that he’d never been real and wondered how ingrained it must have been to be able to switch it on and off so well.
They didn’t hang out for much later, the joint and hour finally taking its toll on Steve, who had still not recovered since that disturbed nap he had taken earlier. When they parted ways it didn’t feel awkward, just felt kind of raw. Steve wished him and Billy could maybe have a normal conversation every so often, but now seeing how Billy operated he kind of understood. Billy was getting the feel of him, trying to test the waters of Steve’s resolve. Trying to see if he could keep up, keep playing the game.
Steve, who had never backed down from a challenge in his life, was determined to get a good look at the real Billy, the one who Billy himself thought never existed.
He went to sleep that night, still kind of high and dazed, and while he knew that he would probably be waking in a couple of hours screaming, it still didn’t dampen his mood. He felt like he had finally gotten somewhere with Billy, his foot in the door. It was just a matter of time before Billy would let him past the entryway and into the actual heart of the house, hopefully.
