Sorry, you need to have JavaScript enabled for this.

 

Actions

Work Header

i hate you some, i love you some, i love you when i forget about me

Summary:

After that night in November, Billy is willing to cut his losses, let sleeping dogs lie, and finally leave Steve Harrington alone. Easier said than done, especially when Harrington asks him to be his math tutor.
—
or, the gratuitous post season 2 AU that no one asked for.

Notes:

(See the end of the work for notes.)

Chapter 1: no one knows they can never get that close, guesses at most

Chapter Text

The morning after his fight with Harrington, Billy came home with bruised knuckles and a dried bloody nose. When his dad found out that Billy had gotten into a fight with the son of one of Hawkins’ biggest business moguls, he did him one better. That night, as Billy lay groaning into his bedsheets with the pillow clutched tightly over his head, he wondered if Steve Harrington was doing the same.

Billy wondered a lot about Steve Harrington, actually. When he saw him across the cafeteria his first day of school, he had wondered who the fuck is that? And after Tina’s Halloween party with that disastrous first meeting due to Tommy H’s shit-talking and the nerves running under his skin, he wondered will we ever have a normal conversation? And then last night, even, Billy had wondered just what is Harrington’s deal?

Steve Harrington seemed to take up a lot of room in Billy’s mind. Last night had been the boiling point of his newfound obsession finally coming to a head; seeing Harrington at that house had felt like fate. Nothing had occupied his mind more than King Steve since he got here. The pretty boy who had fallen hard; the pretty boy who Billy kept stealing furtive glances towards in the showers. He wasn’t looking there or anything, there was an unofficial code of conduct in the locker rooms, but he couldn’t help but notice the way the water droplets left silvery streams across Harrington’s creamy pale skin.

The same creamy pale skin he bruised last night. God, Billy was such a piece of work he surprised even himself sometimes. If Billy had any hopes of finally getting on good terms with Steve Harrington they were surely crushed after last night. Count on Billy’s dad to extend his influence in every part of his life; the mood that had felt like poisonous black tar was one of the worst memories from last night. Count on Billy’s rotten luck with the universe to somehow bring about the series of events that led to the explosion last night.

Harrington being at that creepy ass house with those kids was still something that he had a hard time wrapping his head around, especially the fact that Max fucking injected him with something, but Billy’s temper had more than exceeded the normal reaction warranted for the situation. The beef with the Sinclair kid was mostly his own projection; just the unfairness of the situation that Max could literally get away with everything, and the second that Billy even thought about stepping out of line his dad would come down on him hard. It wasn’t the kid’s fault but seeing the two of them rally against him together had made his envy turn into wrath.

Now he had to deal with the aftermath. The pillow only seemed to press the ache blooming across his face, but it was the only form of pain he indulged in after the morning he had had. Neil had gone to town, operating under the excuse of teaching Billy a serious lesson, boy; truthfully, Billy knew it was a convenient reason to really lay into him without worrying about anyone asking too many questions. The only other people who would know better would be Neil Hargrove, Steve Harrington, and Max with her ragtag group of friends. That list also coincided with people who thought Billy was a waste of air and space.

Which had seemed like it would suit him fine. Having Steve Harrington loathe him was easier than waiting on one of those thousand-watt smiles he graced Wheeler with occasionally in the hallways. It didn’t matter that even the thought and idea of it made it feel like his gut was roiling in stomach acid, it was just something that was going to take some getting used to. Last night it had been easier than breathing to hit Steve over and over; his blood had been pumping and everything down to his toes was jonesing for a fight after that humiliating lesson with his dad right before he was supposed to go out. It was afterwards, when he was cold and sore and lonely, when he took his sorry ass home and realized how the euphoria had changed to a rotting sickness, eating him up from the inside. It didn’t help that he also knew his ass was about to get handed to him on a gleaming, silver platter.

When Neil was smashing the side of his head into the wall separating the kitchen and living room over and over and over, he wondered if Steve Harrington’s whimpers had sounded the same. Wondered if Steve’s voice had gone all high and pathetic, wondered if his breath had hitched in an uncontrollable reaction to so much pain. Billy hadn’t heard a single thing when he was beating Harrington, couldn’t even hear his own voice over the roaring of his blood in his ears.

Later, when he was the one getting beat, he made all those noises and wondered if his dad heard him at all, or if his blood roared too loudly in his ears to register anything too. That was like dousing himself in a bath of cold water, and even hours later when he was lying in bed he couldn’t stop shaking at the thought. He hated his dad, that was a fact he had made peace with a long time ago. What he hadn’t made peace with yet was just how similar he was to Neil Hargrove. Part of him wanted to believe that it was directly a result of his upbringing; but deep down he knew the curse of Neil Hargrove ran in his veins and down to his bones. Sooner or later he’d fuck up every area of his life; finally come full circle when he would turn into an angry, violent drunk. It was something that seemed inevitable in his conclusion but doling out that kind of violence after being on the receiving end of it for so long gave him no satisfaction.

 Instead, it proved that he truly was no better than his dad at his core, and that was the worst part of it all. He was supposed to be smart; he was supposed to actually have some kind of a future, one that didn’t include his dad or any of his qualities. Hating Steve Harrington and beating him to a pulp because he couldn’t face his own issues he kept under lock and key would only poison him from the inside. Steve Harrington didn’t deserve that, no matter how Billy desperately wished he could transfer those feelings into that conviction. Going any further would just cement the fact that the apple didn’t fall far from the tree, and Billy had reached his quota of unnecessary violence for now.

No, for now Billy would let Steve Harrington have an easy rest of the year. It was still November, but Billy knew when it was time to peacock and when it was time to be a chameleon. If he owed anyone anything in this shithole town, it was an easy ride for Steve Harrington. Billy just needed to keep his head down and his nose clean for the rest of the year. Not that that would be easy, but Steve wouldn’t have to worry about any Billy-shaped problems at least.

~

School was exactly as draining as he thought it would be, with the added benefit of it getting twisted that Harrington had won their little brawl over the weekend. Not that Billy could blame them for the confusion; Harrington looked bad, but after a good ol’ discipline session by his dad Billy looked worse. It was like some twofer Harrington got without Billy even having to hand it to him, some of his popularity given back after being crushed by Billy’s initial introduction.

Billy was treated normally at first, but as the day progressed and his mood got worse, he could see the image starting to shift in people’s eyes. Billy, the newest coolest guy who talked a lot of shit but got beaten to a pulp by former King Steve, who was ascending back to royalty as the day went on. Billy didn’t blame them; he could only be so hostile to everyone until it finally stuck, and people were getting used to his whole schtick. Being from California wasn’t even able to save your reputation if you were a big enough asshole, and Billy definitely hadn’t been holding back since the second they arrived. It was due time for the polish to wear off; for people to realize that Billy really just didn’t belong anywhere, let alone dinky little Hawkins. Here ya go, Billy wanted to present to Steve, wrapped it all nice and special for ya. Let him have his popularity back.

He was fine on his own. Even when he had been surrounded by friends in California, he had been on his own. There was always going to be some divide; some kind of veneer used to shield the picture underneath. There wasn’t room for boys like Billy to have friends that knew details about him, that knew all the nitty gritty of what happened at home, and especially the why. No one had ever even bothered pretending to want to know, and so it was just easy to keep his dark secret heart safe and locked away.

Smoking in his car during lunch seemed like it would feel pathetic, but Billy had been aching for a cigarette since first period and he hadn’t been able to spring out of the building fast enough come lunch time. There was no question that he wouldn’t be sitting with Tommy H and his hyenas, Tommy had made eyes over him over Harrington’s shoulder before school by the lockers, and the sneer alone was enough to register as unwelcome in Billy’s mind. Billy knew when to pick up a hint. When he had slid into his seat in English moments afterwards, his hands were already sliding to the pocket of his jean jacket in search for his cigarettes from some form of twisted muscle memory.

Steve Harrington notably hadn’t made any big splashes today, aside from his initial confusion and then acceptance as being the winner in his and Billy’s showdown. Billy himself had kind of hoped for some glance at the old King Steve once again reclaiming his throne, but the only thing Harrington gave him was the most searching, scathing look across the hallway. It had made Billy feel cowed enough to drop his eyes and start shuffling to his first period. Shame or guilt wasn’t something he commonly let himself feel, but when it came to Steve Harrington there was a lot Billy wasn’t in control of.

He was on his third cigarette in twenty minutes, partially because the buzz helped with the hunger of skipping lunch and partially to calm him down before the math class he shared with Harrington. Of course, Bumfuck, Indiana didn’t have BC Calculus, so Billy was forced into taking another year of AB Calc, which had been easy the first time around back home, but pure torture the second. Billy didn’t talk that much in that class anyway, preferring to keep his head down and coast with a straight 95 through the class, but even being silent in the same room as Steve Harrington was making his stomach do backflips.

However, it seemed Billy had nothing to worry about in math. There were maybe a couple minutes, right after the bell rang and everyone was getting situated, where Billy could feel Harrington’s eyes hot on the side of his face. He had kept his expression schooled blank and opted for staring straight ahead. After twenty minutes of not retaining anything their teacher was lecturing on, Billy snuck a quick glance Harrington’s way. Harrington was busy staring down at the worksheet in front of him, brow pinched in what looked like confusion and irritation. It looked like it would hurt his eye to have his brow so furrowed, seeing as Billy’s face hurt every time he so much as sniffed.

The relief over no confrontation didn’t seem to last long, though. Later, when Billy was skipping basketball practice at the end of the day and thinking about the extra hour he had to himself since he didn’t have to pick up Max, that was when Harrington accosted him.

And he literally physically accosted him, waiting where Billy had breezed through the double doors, grabbing him by the lapels of his denim jacket and shoving him hard against the brick wall he had been leaning on moments prior.

The initial shock and pain of it had left Billy uncharacteristically breathless, the tender parts of his back screaming in protest as they met the brick wall. The bruising was worst in the middle of his back; his dad had had him on the ground and whimpering like a dog, and the stone-cold wall dug into it in the most biting way. Harrington coming after him after school shouldn’t have been that much of a surprise, but Billy somehow hadn’t been expecting it.

To his credit, Harrington didn’t let up or pause a bit, just ran his eyes over Billy’s face and kept his grip steady where he still had the denim clutched between his fingertips. The expression on his face was one of pure revulsion, something that made Billy ache more than the pressure on his wounds.

“Listen here, Hargrove,” Harrington said with such an intensity it sounded like he wanted to spit at Billy, “I see you come near those kids or hear about you doing anything  to them and I’ll make you want to look this bad. Got it?”

It wasn’t the most well-said threat by any means, and Billy could tell it probably took the whole day for Harrington to build up the courage and confront him head on. Any doubts he held about the surety of Harrington’s claim, though, were extinguished by the look in his eyes as he delivered it; like Billy was the smallest creature on Earth that he had no problem crushing underneath his shoe. It was eerily similar in concept alone to the expression his dad always wore when disciplining him, and that was enough to make Billy shiver out of his hold.

“Cool your jets, Harrington, Maxine already gave me my own medicine.” He groused back, trying to shake off the alien discomfort that was building.

And Maxine had delivered on getting her comeuppance. They'd had a whisper-shout argument in his bedroom the morning he came back, but that hadn’t been enough for her. Half an hour later, when everyone was gathered around the kitchen table, Maxine had loudly announced that last night Billy had beat up Steve Harrington, and then Maxine had looked on in horrified shock as Neil had decided to dole out Billy’s punishment then and there rather than sending her to her room as usual. Halfway through, when Billy had almost been rolling on the ground trying to squirm away from his dad’s kicks, he had glanced up to see her face pale as a sheet. What the fuck did you think was happening? He wanted to ask, wanted to laugh at her, but there had been blood in his mouth, and he was only able to gasp at that point. Max hadn’t spoken to him or even looked at him for the rest of the weekend, and this morning she still gave him the silent treatment on the drive to school.

Point was that Billy already knew where he stood with Max. Don’t fuck with her or face the wrath of whatever she could wrangle, which so far seemed to have him flat on his ass two for two.

Harrington didn’t look satisfied, though, and when Billy tried to shoulder past him Harrington stuck out a hand and shoved him sideways back into the wall. Billy hissed in pain uncontrollably, doubling over for a second to clear the bright pain away from his eyes. Billy rounded on Harrington; hackles raised.

“Listen, pretty boy, keep shoving me around—”

“Or what?” Harrington looked dangerous, his eyes were glittering black, “You're gonna beat me up again? I bet I could take you right now, in the state you’re in.”

Billy agreed with him. The way the fire was starting to burn under his skin at Harrington’s close proximity was starting to make him overheat, making him feel like he was shorting out.

“Yeah, I reckon you could,” he finally decided on indulgence, “Why don’t I let you get one slug in for free? I’m having a hankering for it.”

Harrington looked thrown for approximately one second, before making good on his word and clocking Billy with a solid punch that felt just as equally fulfilling and terrible. He underestimated Harrington’s hook, and ironically his feet weren’t planted enough for the force, so he ended up falling onto the soft grass in seconds. It felt like jumping back into his bed at home after a session with his dad, and for one second he let himself close his eyes and pretend he was wrapped up in his sheets instead of being surrounded by the soft yellow grass of the school lawn.

There was silence, just the sound of Billy’s labored breaths in his ears. Finally, Harrington spoke up, “There’s something seriously wrong with you, Hargrove.” before walking away.

The relief he felt at Harrington’s departure was telling, but something he wasn’t surprised about. The dual sensation of wanting to be the center of Steve Harrington’s attention while also wanting to not get wrapped up in Steve Harrington was something he had struggled with since his first day here, and he still hadn’t made any progress.

It had felt good to rankle Steve’s nerves at first, get under his skin in a way that only Billy really seemed to know how. It was something he recognized he did with his other past conquests; pull the ponytails a little before becoming the sweetest guy on the playground. It was different this time around, though. This time, Steve Harrington hadn’t so much as glanced his way, even when he was at his most annoying. The lack of acknowledgement had lit a fire in Billy’s veins; if Steve Harrington was going to ignore Billy, Billy would just have to show him how impossible that was.

And of course, it had ended with violence, just like everything else in Billy’s life. All he was ever capable of was taking hits and doling them out in return. He could recognize the tell-tale sensation of restlessness under his skin, nerves frayed at the edges, quick to anger and quick to throw the first hit. Hitting Steve hadn’t felt satisfying, though. It was easy, but not satisfying. It was easy to be hurt and then want to make others hurt just because you were, and Steve’s ignore Billy routine had made him lash out in the worst possible way.

Max was silent when he picked her up from school. She noticed the fresh bruise Harrington had given him right away; eyes running over it and mouth opening slightly before she shut it determinedly closed. That was fine with Billy, he didn’t need Max’s comfort; he especially didn’t need her pity.

He didn’t know where her head was at, where her head had been. What had she thought all those nights she heard the tell-tale thumps in the kitchen? Did she not get the same shivers down her spine every time Neil spoke? Or when he narrowed his eyes even a fraction? No, Max never had any reason to be afraid, Neil had never given her any thought to be. Billy guessed he shouldn’t hate her so much for that, it just served as another reminder that Neil was able to infiltrate every part of his life and make it sore.

Even though she kept sneaking worried glances at him through the corners of his eye, she still stayed silent the entire ride back, not even complaining every time he opted for speeding through yellows instead of slowing down. As some sort of a thanks, he let Rock the Casbah stay on the radio and pretended not to notice her fingers tapping in time with the music.

His dad wasn’t home yet, but Susan was lounging in the living room with a magazine. Billy barely paid her a second glance before beelining for his room and thinking about crashing into his bed after one of the most exhausting days he’d had in Indiana yet.

~

Weeks went by without any change. The leaves fell off the trees, the chill started to pick up, and Hawkins, Indiana stayed the same.

The static quality of his life was something Billy was acutely aware of. It felt like Indiana had made him stagnant: there wasn’t anything to do that didn’t remind him of how much his life had hit a lull. Back home, on nights like these when his face throbbed something awful and he had too much lightning trapped under his skin, he would cop an X from Jimmy and go swimming at night while he rolled. Either that, or he would drive around the streets of Encinitas for hours; every building near the pier was always well lit even past midnight, and it was comforting to drive with the windows rolled down and be able to feel the breeze or listen to snippets of conversation that would drift in and out. Neil was fine when Billy would go out after a “lesson” sometimes, he knew that Billy was like a pressure cooker. Had to let some steam out sometime or risk blowing the whole place up. Indiana didn’t have any of that, but it had streets he could still cruise down, no matter how biting the wind was when he rolled down his windows.

It was a horrible drain on gas and his allowance, but it was the only thing he had.

However, it was one of these nights that he ran into Steve Harrington.

The situation itself was purely a fluke, a blink-and-you’ll-miss-it moment. Billy had been doing his usual circuitous route around Hawkins and had accidentally turned down Northlake into Loch Nora. Usually if it was day time he would slow down to stare at all the mansions that lined the neighborhood, but he never came at night since it was kind of out of the way and none of the houses would be lit up. He hadn’t been paying attention tonight and had ended up having to take such an abrupt right turn he monetarily mourned the suspension in his car.

The neighborhood was kind of closed off, a creek bed and surrounding trees made for a natural kind of barrier between that neighborhood and the one that sat right behind it. It was there, parked on the grass near an opening in the trees for the creek, that he saw Steve Harrington’s red Beamer.

Before Billy could think about what he was doing he had rolled to a stop and threw his car into park. A quick glance at his watch and he could see it was 12:47, about ten minutes before he had planned on driving back home. He hesitated for maybe a second before deciding to throw caution to the wind and got out of his car to approach the Beamer.

Upon closer inspection, there was no one in the vehicle. It was turned off, but when he yanked on the driver’s handle, he was surprised to see that it was unlocked. Something like unease started to build in his gut. Harrington had some kind of weird penchant for doing stuff at night that Billy would probably never understand, but there was just some part of him that had to make sure that nothing actually bad was happening. Call it his further penance to Steve Harrington.

The opening between the trees to the creek seemed to be the most obvious place look since the Beamer was parked so close, but for the life of him Billy couldn’t imagine any reason why Harrington would feel the need to explore the creeks by his house past midnight on a school night, no less. There was another part of Billy that was wondering why he was even bothering to look for Harrington; but it was just in Billy’s nature to keep gravitating back to what caused him the most pain. Harrington could hate the sight of his arrival, but if he was in trouble there was no way Billy was backing down at this point to investigate. The bizarreness of the situation was starting to get under his skin.

He stumbled through the opening, keeping his hands in front of his face to catch any stray branches in the dark. “Harrington?” he called, not bothering to keep his voice down.

No answer. The hill going down to the creek was steep, but the ground was dry, so he was able to keep from stumbling. The sound of fallen leaves cracking under his boots seemed to echo in the resounding silence.

He was walking aimlessly toward the creek bed when he started to smell the heady scent of a joint.

“Harrington?” He called again, sure now that Harrington had to be around here somewhere.

This time he got an answer back in the form of a sputtering cough and a panicked, “Hello?”

Billy spotted where he was now: sat on a rock overlooking the somewhat calm water. The light wasn’t any good, but the moonlight illuminated through the trees enough to catch that hair, and Billy would know those locks from anywhere. Harrington scrambled to his feet and tensed up when Billy came into sight.

“Hargrove?” He sounded confused, but not scared.

“The one and only.” Billy intoned. “Whatcha’ up to?” He didn’t know why that was the first thing he went with, but there was something in the guarded way Harrington was standing that made Billy want to try to act casual.

Harrington dithered. “Oh, ya know . . . just—uh. Hanging out?”

Billy snorted. Maybe Harrington really wasn’t getting up to anything crazy in the middle of the night, but the perpetual guilty tone in his voice wouldn’t do him any wonders in the long run.

“What about you?” This definitely didn’t come across as casual, like Steve was suspicious that Billy had actually followed him here. Which, technically he did, but not in the way Harrington thought.

Billy opted for casual yet again. “Just doing my nightly rounds and happened to see an abandoned BMW on the side of the road.”

Harrington seemed to accept his answer then, his demeanor relaxing somewhat. He took a hit off the still-smoldering joint in his hand before tentatively offering it to Billy.

Surprised, Billy stepped forward and took a hit. It wasn’t anything too good, but all the weed in Hawkins didn’t stand to what he’d had in Cali. Besides, a joint at 1 a.m. was a joint at 1 a.m., and beggars couldn’t be choosers. Harrington waited until Billy passed the joint back.

“Making your rounds?”

Billy shrugged, even though it was dark, and Harrington probably couldn’t see him. “Just driving around town.”

“Past midnight?”

“I could ask you why you’re chillin’ by a fuckin’ creek past midnight . . .”

Harrington huffed out a laugh at that one, passing the joint back to Billy. Billy could hardly believe he was sharing a joint with Steve Harrington in the middle of the night. Billy and Harrington had mostly steered clear of each other (which, in Billy’s case was really pretending that he wasn’t tracking every move Steve made from the corner of his eyes) since that initial confrontation after school. Every so often he thought he could see Harrington staring at him in their math class, but Billy didn’t dare look his way for fear of being caught out. He usually chose to smoke in his car for lunch nowadays, and he was sure Harrington appreciated having his spot back in the cafeteria.

They passed the joint back and forth, the silence wasn’t awkward, but they also seemed to be wary of disturbing it. Billy kept searching for things to say, but every time the words came to his lips, he would lose all steam and let them die out. Billy, who usually always had something to say, was drawing a complete blank.

After the joint ended and Harrington stepped it out into the ground, they both stood there for a second. Billy noticed air puffs coming from both of their mouths and only just then considered the cold night. His denim jacket had been just fine in California, but it was no match for the incoming Indiana winter.

Harrington was the first to break their silence. “So . . . why’d you lie about the fight?”

It was one of the last things Billy had expected, and the weed was starting to make his head fuzzy. “What?” was what he eloquently responded.

“I mean, why did you let everyone think I won?” Harrington was facing him full-on now, and in the dark his eyes looked completely black. “I know I got some hits in, but not many. Not enough to have actually made your face look like that.”

Billy shrugged uncomfortably, wondering why Harrington just couldn’t let some things be, especially when he ended up benefitting from it. “I dunno man,” he said starting to feel on edge. Out here, surrounded by the darkness with the babbling creek in the background, Billy felt like there weren’t any walls up. Felt like Harrington could see right through him, and he itched to get back to the safety of his car. He hated how transparent he was sometimes, always when he least needed it. “Figured it was the least I could do after—ya know.”

It felt like a cop-out to the highest degree. Harrington seemed to buy it anyway.

“Right,” he continued, and Billy tensed even more, if it was physically possible, "So then who did you get into a fight with that night?” He gave a pause before narrowing his eyes. “Actually, who did you get into a fight with tonight?”

Billy’s fingers itched to instinctually touch his lips and nose where both had been split hours earlier. He had a good patchwork assortment of bruising currently swelling on his upper back, but Harrington couldn’t see those. To be honest, the pain had mostly disappeared from his mind when he had first spotted the BMW. Now, however, the reminder had them throbbing in time with his pulse, which was now rabbiting.

He resorted back to the usual bravado used to deter anyone from anything. It included a sly grin, tongue poking through his cheek, and a casual, “Wouldn’t you like to know, pretty boy?”  pretty boy always seemed to roll off his tongue so easily when Steve Harrington was involved.

Harrington flushed, but didn’t rise to the bait. Instead he crossed his arms over his chest. “I mean, that is why I’m asking. I would like to know.”

“And why is that?”

“So, I can send them a thank you card.”

Billy barked out a laugh. Picturing Steve Harrington thanking his dad for beating him was a sick kind of funny that made his head spin and his chest hurt. It only served to prove as a reminder that Billy really did fuck up everything in his life. For a second, he thought about cracking a joke about how Harrington was eager to come home with him, but he knew better than that. He settled on, “I’ll pass the message next time I see him.”

Harrington, who had had a canny eye on him this entire time, didn’t seem to know what to say to that. Billy was wondering why Harrington was worrying his pretty little head over why Billy’s face had been roughed up. Billy had thought he had done enough at school boosting Harrington’s reputation, but apparently there were still some loose ends he’d need to take care of in order for Harrington to finally let go.

“Listen,” he started uncomfortably, already knowing what he was about to say was going to feel like torture to get out, “I just wanted to . . . I’m sorry.” He finished lamely. “I was having kind of a rough night, and I was really fiending for a fight.” Harrington’s eyes were wide in the moonlight. “Anyways, I shouldn’t have taken it out on you.” His apology hung in the air.

Harrington looked nonplussed; his mouth still slightly open from when it had fallen at the beginning of Billy’s little speech. Feeling suddenly exhausted and extremely embarrassed, Billy ended the moment with a two-finger wave, “Welp, that’s my cue.” and turned on his heel.

God, he should have never even stopped for Harrington’s stupid Beamer. If Harrington decided to disappear into the woods leaving his fancy-ass car abandoned on the side of the road, that was his prerogative. If Harrington needed anything, was ever in trouble, he already had a support system in the form of Byers, Wheeler, and the group of middle-schoolers he always seemed to be toting around in his car. Harrington didn’t need Billy Hargrove of all people to check in and make sure he was okay, especially when moments ago he had talked about thanking the person who rearranged Billy’s face.

It just served as a painful reminder that in the grand scheme of things, Billy really had no one. Harrington had a weird assortment, sure, but at least he had people. One of those people being Max, which was a sick play of irony that she gave a shit about a total stranger more than her stepbrother. Not that he really deserved Max’s support anyway, but god it got tiring waking up every day and knowing that everyone in the house probably hated him. Even back in California Max had been somewhat of a loner: something she and Billy shared in common. Now, she had a tighter group of friends than Billy ever thought he could have, and that was just another thing that sat uncomfortably under his skin the more he thought about it.

Billy could only hear the dull roar of his pulse in his ears and the almost overwhelming crunches and snaps of detritus under his feet. Harrington came thundering into view, clutching at Billy’s shoulder to catch up with him. He accidentally dug his thumb into one of the tender spots on his back and Billy nearly keeled over in pain. Steve must have taken his hiss of pain to be threatening and dropped his hand immediately.

Billy swayed on his feet, startled a bit by how quickly Harrington had appeared. Harrington was blocking his path back up through the trees now, facing him head on and giving Billy shivers that had nothing to do with the steadily declining temperature.

“Woah, woah, dude,” Harrington sounded placating. “You just caught me off guard. I wasn’t expecting it, was all.”

Billy didn’t know what to say. Harrington continued before he could formulate a response. “I . . . I kind of figured.”

Now Billy was lost. “What?”

Harrington seemed to search for the words. “I mean, I had kind of figured you were in a bad mood that night. I sort of realized physical violence was your go-to when you’re stressed.”

It was an accurate read, but one that left Billy uncomfortable knowing Steve Harrington could pin-point it so well. “Oh yeah? And how did you figure that?” It sounded too defensive already and Billy wished he could grab the reigns for this conversation.

Harrington gave an easy shrug, not bothered at all by Billy’s developing prickly tone and attitude. “That day after school when I confronted you. You were literally begging me to hit you.”

Billy remembered. Not one of his finest moments, maybe, but at the time nothing seemed sweeter than Steve Harrington’s fist across his face. He didn’t think Harrington would have paid that close of attention, or that he would even think about it enough to be able to draw his own conclusions about Billy. For the life of him he couldn’t figure out what to say. Billy’s silver tongue was uncharacteristically silent. The whole conversation was throwing him through a loop.

Harrington seemed to take pity on him. “So, yeah. Um. Good talk.” His hand clapped so abruptly on Billy’s shoulder that he jumped out of his skin. Harrington took an involuntary step back. At least it confirmed that there was still some part of him that feared Billy.

They stood there for a second, regarding each other in the overwhelming silence. Finally, Billy was able to get his head screwed on correctly and fumbled a response. “Well, I’ll be seeing you, then, Harrington.” And went to step around him.

He had gone maybe three or four steps before Harrington called after him, “You know you can just call me Steve, right? It feels like a shitty spy movie when we just call each other by our last names.”

Billy gave him a snort to cover up the words dying in his throat. He felt hot all over. Maybe it was nothing to the other boy, but getting the privilege to call Harrington “Steve” was something that made him feel breathless. All he had wanted from the beginning was Steve’s attention, and while he hadn’t gone about it in the best way at first, he was getting it now. It was a heady feeling that also signaled danger.

Because this was the thing: good, all-American, red-blooded straight boys didn’t get so excited over getting the first name privileges of a fellow classmate. Who happened to be a guy. Who also happened to be the fixture of Billy’s obsession since arriving in Hawkins. There were things Billy knew about himself; things that he had just accepted so long ago that he would have to bury and hide and stow away indefinitely, and this was one of those things. In California it had been easier, there were way more laid-back surfers and open-minded stoners there than there were in a bumpkin town like Hawkins. Over there if you just so happened to kiss one of your buddies that was straight, they either brushed it off easily or gave you hell for it for a couple weeks.

 Not that Billy even took those risks all that much back in California, anyways. He had the irrational belief since he was about five that somehow his dad could read his mind. It was one of those things that made Billy terrified of his father; worried that one day Neil Hargrove would just look him in the eyes and know his son was a faggot. Billy’s dad always had a way of finding things out, and this was something Billy was determined to take to the grave with him if need be.

But then the move to Hawkins happened, and then Billy had seen Harrington in the hallways that first day of school and thought, Oh fuck. One glance at Harrington’s pretty pink lips and his shiny helmet of hair had had Billy in a tizzy before first period even started. So, he had reacted the way he knew was the best: immediate defense along with a bad attitude. Billy had to nip it in the bud before it became out of his control. And of course, that’s when it really spiraled out of control; peacocking on the court and flirting in the fucking showers like he had a death wish. Of course, to him it was all flirting, to Steve it was entirely antagonistic. Story of Billy’s life.

He had never expected anything to come of it, though. He knew when to cut his losses, and after beating the shit out of him it seemed like Steve Harrington fell under the category of losses to be cut. Billy never thought anything could have been salvaged from it, but here was Steve proving him wrong.

Steve was still waiting for some kind of a response. Billy guessed if he really wanted, he could throw a nasty grin and an even nastier insult back, really solidify Steve’s dislike for Billy, but that didn’t feel satisfying. Steve was willing to offer an olive branch when Billy was the one who beat his face in. It felt like going back to square one if he did that; like all this progress was for nothing.

So instead, he swallowed his nerves and took the gesture for what it was. “Steve,” he tried, testing it out. It was a different feeling saying it out loud rather than constantly repeating it in his head. Steve mistook his tone for some kind of tease, because he just scoffed lightly in response.

“Alright, then, Steve,” Thoroughly enjoying both how the name rolled of his lips and how the night had gone, “Catch you on the flipside.”

~

That night didn’t change much for a while. Billy still saw Steve everywhere, especially in their shared math class, only this time there wasn’t that underlying degree of tension or hostility under the surface. The few times they managed to catch each other’s eye there was only a simple nod of acknowledgment exchanged. It technically wasn’t much, but it was already lightyears better than what had been going on between them before, and something in Billy’s chest had loosened each time they made eye contact and it didn’t end in derision or conflict. He treasured every glance of Steve’s chocolate eyes to his own but was careful to hoard them to himself. There wasn’t much interaction past that.

The first semester ended without any fanfare, and winter break hit with a startling tenacity Billy had no preparation for. The only thing he had that could really cut through any windchill was his leather jacket, and that really wasn’t doing all that much. Billy, who had never seen snow in his life before Hawkins, was now getting an up close and personal viewing every other day.

Tensions fizzled out between him and Maxine. Earlier on in December he had dropped a new skateboard on her bed while she had been out with the dweebs. They had already been inching towards some kind of tentative truce, but after this gesture they were starting to make progress. Billy suspected part of her newfound acceptance of him was due to the fact of his dad’s more frequent at home presence. Life as a construction manager during the winter had less opportunities in Indiana than it did California, and as a result Neil Hargrove was home most days of the week. Billy suffered the consequences.

Neil was getting more comfortable “disciplining” him in front of Max and Susan since that initial incident after that night in November. His dad being home all the time combined with the fact that he had to also see Billy’s ugly mug there created the perfect storm. His dad took his work frustrations out on Billy, and Billy had no choice but to bear the brunt of it and wait for the next round.

Most of winter break was spent holed up in his room, either curled in the fetal position or rereading his books. He was in such bad shape most of the time he didn’t feel like leaving the house and getting gawked at.

It was a direct contrast to Max, who had been going out almost every day to hang out with her little group of friends. A lot of times when she would ask permission, she would cast her eyes at Billy. He knew she probably thought he was some kind of pathetic freak to feel sorry for, and oh how the mighty had fallen. But she was right, Billy had to admit, he was such a depressing sack lately even he could feel it; but he was unable to stop it.

He still ended up driving her everywhere and picking her up. It was some kind of satisfaction on Neil’s part; to know that Billy had nothing to do except cater to Max and her carpooling desires. Most times he would spot Steve outside of the arcade, or at one of the geek’s houses when he would pick up Max, but they never gave any more than that tentative nod. Towards the end of the break Billy’s dad’s work situation wasn’t improving, and he spent the tail end of the break hunched over in his room with the lights off. Steve started to be the one to pick Max up and drop her off, and Billy never left his room even when he could hear the Beamer pull up out front. Max never directly said anything to him about the situation at home, but those last two weeks she would sometimes slip in just to place some rubbing alcohol and cotton wipes into his room, or even better, a Ziploc of some of Susan’s pain medication from her wisdom teeth removal.

The week before school started Billy’s dad finally got another long-term gig and was out of the house again for most of the day in the days following, which gave Billy all the respite he needed.

The second semester was due to start soon, and Billy was looking forward to it like another night with his dad: not in the least bit. A new semester would still reek of the same bullshit; distantly Billy wondered how angry his dad could get at him. It seemed like there was something different to Neil now, like every move Billy made just made him angrier and more resentful. Billy felt like they were building to something, and he wasn’t looking forward to what that was supposed to mean. The only plan he had going forward was to keep his head down and coast through the rest of the semester, get a job over the break, then hopefully he would be gone by the end of the summer. Every day until then was just trying to live, trying to dodge a hit that might just go too far. The new job helped loosen his dad’s frustration, but Billy knew that he would erupt eventually. He always did.

The only difference was now Max was an eyewitness, and she seemed to be expecting something too. Every time his dad’s eyes cut across him for too long, she would tense up at the kitchen table, bracing like she was the one who was about to get hit. Max wasn’t afraid of Billy anymore; but now she had a bigger person to fear. She could see firsthand what Neil was capable of.

By the time they were supposed to go back to school, Billy had already settled deep into his “don’t bother me” bog and was determined this time to keep Max out of it. While he didn’t exactly enjoy her fear and hatred, it was a great deal better than the sad looks she would send his way after every disparaging comment his dad made. Billy didn’t want Max’s comfort, or whatever she was foolishly trying to offer. It made him grit his teeth that he had shrunken in size to her eyes. There was no taking it back at this point, though, Maxine had already gotten an eyeful and had been able to draw her own conclusions. And Billy was pretty downright pathetic most times when he would just retreat into his room and choose to quietly whimper through the pain instead of doing much else.

The morning they were driving back to school for their first day after break, Max finally laid all the cards out on the table.

“I know you probably still hate me, or whatever,” She said, out of the blue and startling Billy a little with the sound of her voice.

“Huh?” he flicked the volume dial down a couple of notches.

“I’m saying, I know you still hate me. But I don’t hate you anymore.”

He sighed. It was too early for this. “Max, I don’t hate you. I never did.” He could feel her skepticism even without looking at her. “Do you think if I hated you, I would have got you a new skateboard? Apologized to your little boyfriend?” And yeah, that had taken a chunk out of his pride.

Max had been alright with the skateboard, but he could tell that she still hadn’t fully forgiven him yet. Three days before school started he finally snapped at her in annoyance to get her stupid walkie-talkie out; over the static he had delivered a painfully awkward apology to Sinclair that had left literal radio silence from the other boys and only a squeaky, “Okay!” from Lucas. As far as Billy was concerned, he had atoned for all his sins.

“Yeah, I know that now, but I didn’t before. Not when you were threatening to mow down my friends.”

He rolled his eyes. Max could be so dramatic sometimes it just reminded him that she was still a thirteen year-old-girl. “I wasn’t going to actually do it. Just my way to show brotherly love.”

“Yeah, well I think you got your wires crossed.” When he looked over now, her nose was scrunched, and her eyes were cast out the window. “You act like a raging douche half the time.”

He gave a scoff. “I know that, miss priss.” He tightened his hands on the wheel and refused to stray his eyes from the road. “It’s just how I am sometimes.”

“I don’t think so.”

He whipped his head to fully look at her this time. She was staring defiantly back as if to question him. Yeah? What of it?

“Oh really.”

“I think your dad’s a real raging douche; and that turned you into a slightly-lesser raging douche.” It was so matter of fact it made his eye twitch. Max saw his dad beat him down a couple of times and suddenly she was an expert on everything that went on in his head?

It took all of his self-control not to punish her by speeding up the car. The only thing stopping him was the fact that his suspension was already shitty and wearing down, and the last time he had had to abruptly stop while speeding the tires had gone out of place a little bit. If he had his way, they’d be careening toward 80 by now.

Max noticed the tension in his hands and rolled her eyes. “Oh, calm down, it’s not like I can say anything.” At that she glumly looked away.

Billy took a deep breath and then took another second to really look at her. She seemed like she was being sincere, although he couldn’t figure out why she was telling all of this to him now. He had been fine with their unspoken truce earlier, and there was just something disconcerting about the way she was bringing the subject up out of nowhere.

“You know you actually can’t say anything, right?” He tried to make eye contact so he could let her know how serious he was being. “You can’t say anything to anyone, even your little dweeb friends.”

Max crossed her arms over her chest in a huff. He could see the beginning stages of Mad Max begin to trickle through; and it brought an odd sort of comfort. “Duh, Billy, I’m not some total fucking idiot.” It was the confirmation he needed, but she continued. “I just—don’t know how you deal with it.”

“I deal with it just fine, Maxine.” This conversation was wearing him down. All he had wanted was a nice, stress-free drive to school, and he hadn’t been able to smoke a single cigarette on the ride thanks to their little chat. “Why do you even care, anyways?”

“Because it’s not fair!” Mad Max had finally burst. “It’s not fucking fair!”

Billy looked at her like she was a loon. She continued on, undeterred. “It’s not fucking fair that-that- he just beats you, and—you- you just have to take it.” She was shaking now at this point, and distantly Billy wondered if he should give an attempt at calming her, but she was taking deep breaths before he could reach out.

“I get why you were so douchey all the time, is what I’m saying,” she finally said after a moment. “I would probably turn into a major bitch if I had your dad.”

“You already are a major bitch, Maxine,” he said, trying to diffuse the odd energy that was crackling between them. “Anyways, don’t worry about that stuff, Maxine. Just focus on yourself and you’ll be fine.” And it was good advice, the more Max kept her nose out of Billy’s business with his dad the less of a chance she would get entangled in it as well.

She still wasn’t saying anything. “Max,” he tried to not sound pleading, “You gotta keep your nose out of it.”

“Yeah, but if I keep my nose out of it, what’s gonna happen when it gets really bad?” Her voice started to get small. “You didn’t leave the room for three days once. What next?”

He had no response for that; witty or otherwise. Billy kept driving and distantly realized he was pulling into the junior high parking lot, much nearer to their destination than he had realized. Once again, he felt like the conversation had pulled the rug out from under his feet and couldn’t for the life of him understand why Max was choosing to actually talk about this. There was an unspoken agreement that they didn’t acknowledge what went on in the Hargrove house past 9 o’clock and hearing her thoughts on the matter was starting to make him feel nauseated.

Max wasn’t supposed to worry about these things; she was supposed to just turn a blind eye to what was going on and continue as normal. If there was any disruption in Neil’s schedule or routine Billy shuddered to think of the consequences. There was only so much defiance and prodding he could take from Max before Billy was sure Neil would have his own limitations, and he didn’t even want to think of the dynamics of the house changing for the worse. He didn’t know what he would even be able to do if they did, after all, Billy was incapable of much help after getting a good beating from his dad. There would be no way to protect anyone. The only way he could hope to do it would be to remain in the forefront of Neil’s temper.

“Max, just don’t worry, okay?” He repeated and tried to give a tone that brooked no further arguments but was uncomfortably aware of how close to tears Max was getting. He felt the need to soothe her somewhat. “He would never go for you or your mom, you guys are a part of his perfect family.” And that was completely true, Neil would never even fathom laying a hand on his newfound daughter and loving wife, just his degenerate of a son. Max and Susan represented all the good parts of his life; while Billy served the purpose of reminding him how badly his first attempt at a family went.

Max just sniffed. “That’s not what I’m worried about, you rockhead,” she said miserably, “What about you?”

They were at the sidewalk directly from the mouth of the school. Max was opening the door and shuffling out before he could try to get another word in. He didn’t even know what word he could try to get in. She immediately converged to her friends; and at the sight of her stuffy, red face they shot looks of pure hatred through the windows of the Camaro. Billy sped off. He was sick of taking the blame for everything.

Part of him desperately itched to just call the day a bust and skip, but Susan would be home and when the school would inevitably call, he couldn’t confidently say that she would vouch for him.

He accepted that he would just have to have a rotten day and started his first cigarette of the morning as he drove to school. He opted for parking further away than usual, leisurely smoking his cigarette and letting the wind wash away the smell of smoke. The cool air felt good on his skin for once, and he was happy to report no visible bruising for his first day back. Small victories.

Everyone was mostly absorbed with catching up with their friends, so Billy didn’t have to make any unnecessary interactions that would only serve to heighten his irritation. His overall absence from parties and kickbacks over the break had definitely taken its toll; he was missing his usual cronies gathered around his locker when he came in. Tommy and Carol were still sticking to their guns from last semester—which was that Billy was now considered Uncool. It was understandable. You could only be a douche for so long and combine that with getting your ass handed to you by King Steve of all people knocked you down a couple of pegs on the totem pole. As for first day backs went, it was pretty okay, if not just a depressing reminder of how monotonous his life had truly gotten.

Math class was the only notable part of his day, with Steve choosing to sit next to Billy instead of across the classroom where his usual unofficial seat was.

Billy looked up, startled. Steve was just casually putting his books back into his backpack when he looked up and caught Billy’s eye. Steve offered him a friendly grin, then went back to organizing his binder.

Since Steve was pretending this was completely normal, Billy wasn’t going to say anything. The only times him and Steve had seen each other over the break were those pockets of time they would spend in their respective cars waiting for the kids to come out of the arcade. He never even looked out the window when Steve started picking up Max later.

Sometimes Billy even wondered whether that conversation by the creek bed had happened at all, yet here was Steve confirming it with a single friendly glance. The bad mood Billy had been stewing in all day was starting to lose some steam and Billy decided that if Steve could play it cool, so could he. At least Steve didn’t have the mind reading abilities his dad seemed to have.

The girl whose seat Steve sat in tried to raise a fuss at first, but a look from Steve had her huffing away across the classroom to his original seat. Billy uselessly tried to calm his racing heart and pay attention to their teacher at the front.

Not much happened for the rest of the class, but every so often Billy could feel Steve glance his way. Or, more accurately, towards his worksheet. Well, that at least made more sense. Billy fumed at himself for being so stupid to think that Steve sat next to him because he wanted to, not because Billy had one of the highest grades in the class and Steve seemed to be incapable at any subject. It left a sour taste in his mouth and he felt his initial anger flare up again. The shitty day had gone form bad, to infinitesimally worse. Even though his mood made an uncomfortable comeback that almost left him vibrating in his seat, he still moved his left arm so Steve would have a better view of his work. It was the least he owed him, after all.

The bell rang and Billy was one of the first out of the class. Pretended he didn’t hear the squawk from Steve, who was most likely going to ask if he could see Billy’s homework tomorrow. Lunch had been cigarettes in the car with the heat blasting, and the buzz from the nicotine was starting to turn his empty stomach. Basketball season was over, and Billy didn’t feel like signing up for whatever winter sport Hawkins High had to offer; it seemed like there was always a sore spot or tender muscle in Billy’s back these days.

He was planning on giving himself a neat forty-five minutes to smoke the joint in his car before he would leave to pick Max up. He decided he would pass out in his bed the second they got home after the taxing day.

Instead, Steve ambushed him again exactly as he did last time, only this time when Billy breezed out the double doors Steve jumped from the wall instead of pushing Billy up against it. It still looked too similar to the first time and Billy ended up tensing on instinct. And the hits keep coming, he miserably thought to himself. Metaphorically and physically.

But Steve didn’t seem to have that idea in mind, because he immediately held his palms open in surrender. “Woah man, I’m not trying to start anything, if that’s what you’re thinking.”

Billy eyed him distrustfully, wondering why Steve was being agreeable to Billy of all people.

He stood there for a second, shifting between his feet and waiting. Steve seemed like he was searching for the right thing to say, before anxiously running a hand through his ridiculous hair.

“You, uh, got a minute?”

Billy nodded, didn’t trust his voice. Steve nodded at that, unconsciously mirroring him. “Sweet. Here, let’s go to my car.”

And that was how Billy found himself trailing behind Steve to get in that luxurious red Beamer he found at the side of the road all those weeks ago. This would be the first time he actually sat in Steve’s car. The light leather interior was something to marvel a bit over, and he stroked the side of the seat with his thumb to feel the cool, smooth material. Steve cleared his throat and Billy guiltily shoved his hands in his lap and looked back around. Steve looked more nervous than Billy felt.

“So, here’s the thing. I’m bad at school. Like, really bad. Like, so abysmally bad that I’m about to fail this math class and have to take it again in the summer. Don’t get me wrong, I suck at literally almost every other subject too, but I failed the exam for the first semester. That, combined with the fact that I’ve been rocking a straight 65 the entire last semester means that I have to pick up the slack this semester if I even want a chance to graduate.” He finally took a deep breath in and his eyes sought out Billy desperately. God, Harrington knew how to talk. The words had come out a mile a minute and he hadn’t taken a breath in between words at all. If Billy attempted even half that speech at that speed, he would get mush mouth in seconds. “That’s where you come in.”

“Listen, Harrington,” Billy cut in, scratching his jaw uneasily, “If you wanna copy off me—”

“What? No!” Steve looked aghast. “I want you to tutor me.”

Billy gaped. “Tutor you?”

Steve looked at him like he was thick now. “Uh, yes? What part of ‘I fail this math class and I have to take it again in the summer’ did you not get?”

“What makes you think I can tutor you?” Billy challenged, still thrown by the left turn Steve’s confrontation had taken.

“Because you’re one of the smartest kids in the class? I know you do pretty well in your other classes, too,” He was trying to catch Billy’s eyes now, which were directly pointed through the windshield. “I need to actually understand the material, or I’m just gonna end up failing the final exam anyway.”

“Okay,” Billy allowed, “But why me? Isn’t Wheeler some sort of brainiac? Isn’t there anyone else in the class you’d wanna actually get help from?”

“Yeah, I’d rather not ask my ex to help me with my math homework, no matter how good of terms we’re on. It’s kind of degrading, dude.” He fixed Billy with a look. “Besides, you’re the only one in the class I do wanna get help from, why else would I be asking you?”

Billy scrubbed a hand over his face and felt like he had stumbled through some alternate universe. “I don’t know, man, I would just assume you don’t wanna get tutored by the guy that beat your face in.”

Steve waved his hand in a “forget about it” gesture. “Eh, that’s in the past. I thought we squashed that beef that night all those weeks ago when you decided to come looking for me by the creek.” He now had a smirk on his face. “Anyhow, I’m supposedly the one who beat your face in, if you remember.”

Steve seemed to be completely serious about both their reconciliation and the favor he was asking of Billy. Steve didn’t want to just cheat off him; he was willing to actually spend time with Billy in order to get a better grade. It was kind of sad that these were the depths that had to be sunk to in order for Steve Harrington to seek out his presence, but Billy wasn’t going to let that get him down too much. Besides, spending the entirety of winter break by himself had made him kind of desperate for contact outside of those living in his house. If Steve was willing to put up with Billy for a couple hours to improve his grades, he wasn’t going to talk him out of it.

Steve was waiting on an answer, his leg bouncing up and down uncontrollably. Billy decided to take pity. “Alright, Steve, sure. I’ll tutor you in math.”

“Thank fuck dude,” Steve almost groaned. Billy felt a flash of heat run down his neck. “My dad has been riding my ass about this grade for—well.” He cut himself off. “Thanks.”

Billy itched to keep them in the car for as long as possible. A conversation with Steve was better than any old joint in his glove compartment. “Your dad strict?”

Steve made a so-so gesture with his hand. “Eh, he’s a hardass when he’s home, but seeing as he’s not home most of the time it’s pretty easy to deal with. Math is just kind of his thing, so he doesn’t understand why it’s never been mine.”

Billy couldn’t relate. Neil Hargrove didn’t have a mind for numbers or for literature, and as far as he knew his dad had probably barely gotten by in the swamp school he had been raised in. The only thing he could give his dad was his knowledge of history; Neil was known to impress a group of people with the facts he could rattle off the top of his head. It made sense, his dad always like to talk about the past and repeating itself.

“So, what is your thing?” Because it didn’t seem like Steve was that academically inclined. Not that Billy knew the guy’s report card or anything, but Tommy had yapped his ear off enough about Steve in the first semester for him to glean some information.

“Um, I don’t know honestly. But I know it’s not math.” And Steve didn’t even look ashamed at all by the admission. “What about you? Your folks get onto you about grades?”

The implication behind folks made Billy shift uncomfortably in his seat. He was aware that if he staunchly corrected Steve on Max being his step-sister right now that could open up an avenue into questions about Billy’s own mom. He wasn’t in a good enough mood to jump into that right now. Instead he settled on, “Nah, they don’t get onto me for my grades too much.” Which was true. Neil never had to worry about Billy’s grades, it was just everything else in his life he seemed concerned with.

“Oh yeah, I forgot. I’m talking to the resident genius of Hawkins.” Steve rolled his eyes.

“Excuse me?” Billy quirked a brow. “What makes you think that?”

“Hello? It’s all Nancy talks about, how you’re gunning for valedictorian right under her nose. It completely drives her crazy, I’m gonna be honest.”

Now it was Billy’s turn to roll his eyes. “I’m not gunning for jack shit. If I just so happen to make better grades than Wheeler . . .”

Steve crowed with laughter. “God, I wish she could hear this right now. She’s studying as we speak, and you’re clowning on her and her poor efforts.” His shoulders were shaking.

His laughter was infectious, and Billy felt the corners of his mouth tug into a smile before he could stop himself. God, he had been going about it all wrong before. There was nothing better than a Steve Harrington smiling at you; Billy should have approached with honey instead of vinegar in the beginning.

“Well, I guess I’ll let you go. Gotta pick up Dustin in a bit, I’m sure you gotta pick up Max, too.”

A glance at the clock told him Steve was correct. He only had like twenty minutes now to smoke that joint, but he knew he’d be riding the high from this conversation for the rest of the night, at least. “Right, gotcha. When did you wanna meet up, I guess?”

Steve smacked his forehead. “Shit. I literally forgot the point of the conversation. Right, so, my house is almost always available, but if you didn’t wanna drive I could come to yours.”

Billy was nodding before he even finished the sentence. “Nah, we can do it at yours, my house is too packed.” In the small Hargrove house four people felt like suffocation, five and he knew he’d be listening to every creak and noise anxiously.

“Okay, that’s cool. Listen, man, I’m not gonna lie: I’m like ridiculously bad at math. As in, you’ll probably need to reteach me some stuff.” At this Steve started to look a little uneasy. Admitting he was bad at a subject Billy was good at was obviously difficult to him, and Billy passed the opportunity up for teasing where he normally would have taken it.

“Alright, then. So, you wanna, like, meet up a couple days after school a week?” He felt uncomfortable asking, like Steve would somehow be able to tell that Billy wasn’t exactly doing this out of the kindness of his heart. It felt kind of skeevy to agree to tutor Steve just because he had a crush on him, but he figured if Steve got a good grade out of it at least they were both benefitting.

But Steve just looked relieved. “Yes, perfect. If you’re cool with it, we can do Tuesday and Thursdays?”

Billy was more than cool with it. “Sounds like a plan.” Two days a week after school with Steve sounded like the reward for something he didn’t even know he did. The math part would be easy; it was the playing it cool part that he would have to watch out for. There was no way he could let Steve know how eager he was to get some one-on-one time.

He shook a cigarette out of the pack from his pocket and lit it before Harrington could say anything else. Today was Monday, they were already going to be meeting tomorrow. Billy had to make an exit so he could spend the rest of the afternoon turning every word from this conversation over in his head. It was better to make the getaway now than to wait for Steve to kick him out if his car. “See you tomorrow, pretty boy.” He exited the vehicle.

Max was suspicious of his lingering grin when he picked her up, but she probably attributed it to the skunky smell still lingering in the car. She wrinkled her nose in disgust and made sure to roll the window down all the way, trying to air out before the smell could stick to her clothes. At least she was still thinking; Neil would absolutely hate it if her clothes smelled like smoke or otherwise. Billy couldn’t be bothered to care much, though, tomorrow he was tutoring Steve Harrington.

Billy didn’t mind the breeze; the combined buzz from his joint plus the wholly satisfying interaction with Steve after school had him tapping his steering wheel energetically with the beat of his music. He was even being nice and playing KC and the Sunshine band for Max, who had eyed him distrustfully at first before deciding not to look a gift horse in the mouth. His sunny state-of-mind stuck all the way to his arrival at home, where Susan was the only one in the house currently. He didn’t know what she was cooking but it smelled good.

He collapsed into bed with a manic grin on his face. He went from having one of the worst mornings to such a blisteringly bright afternoon he didn’t know what to do with all the leftover euphoria. The weed was making his eyes feel a little heavy, so he went ahead with his original plan of passing out. Neil dragged him out of bed by his hair for dinner, later, but not even that was enough to dampen his mood.

~

Steve’s house was nice. House was actually an understatement, the place was actually one of the McMansions located in Loch Nora, which shouldn’t have been a surprise considering where he had found the BMW parked that night. Billy drove behind Harrington the entire ride over and had wondered more than once why he was so obsessed with someone who drove so slowly.

The entire bottom floor could fit probably two Hargrove houses, and it was kind of spooky to imagine being here alone all the time. He told Steve as much, to which the other boy snorted and said, “You have no idea.”

While Billy would kill to have the house fully empty once in a while, something about Harrington’s house just felt . . . cold. The house reminded him of a museum almost, like there was no one living in it. That didn’t seem like that would go over well, though, and Billy was already walking on eggshells. When it came to Harrington it seemed like the best course was to probably run his thoughts through a filter before sharing them with him.

They parked it in the dining room. The room was bathed in warm light, and in the corner sat an elaborate china cabinet that held crystal cutlery in it that was probably worth more than Billy’s existence. The dining table was long and elaborately decorated; but the directions were from fall and most of them were covered in a fine layer of dust. There were some family pictures hanging on the wall and on some shelves, and Billy wished he had his glasses so he could get a better look without seeming too obvious about it. Before now he hadn’t even realized how badly he needed to see a picture of Steve as a kid, and he made silent plans that sooner or later he’d get an opportunity to get a good look.

Steve paid the stylish set-up no mind and folded back the autumn-leave embroidered table runner. They spread everything out on the table and set to work. Billy was nervous to begin at first, but Steve was quick to point out how even today’s lesson had completely flown over his head which got them to it pretty quickly.

Steve hadn’t been exaggerating about how behind he was. Billy found himself slowly inching back further into the material they’d covered so far, and Steve could never confidently say he remembered everything they’d learned in past units. Once they figured out the foundations to build on, they’d be able to move through the work through it more steadily. Billy still had some old graded quizzes and homework sheets he’d taken home back in California, and he brought them with him for some extra practice runs. Steve raised his eyebrows at the cluster of papers meticulously pinned together by a paperclip he had snagged from Max’s jar on her desk. It hadn’t occurred to Billy that that might come across as overeager, and he hated that he had shown his cards too early. There weren’t any explanations he could think of that didn’t sound defensive.

There hadn’t been anything to be defensive over, though, because Steve didn’t comment on them after all. Billy sat them to the side and told himself he’d just leave them in his backpack for the other sessions.

It wasn’t just a lack of knowledge on Steve’s part that held him back, but rather a lack of knowledge plus the inability to use the knowledge he already had. Billy noticed that Steve had a habit of mixing the numbers in the questions, and Billy often had to rewrite the equations in the margin so Steve could keep checking back. He also noticed that Steve completely avoided word problems if he could help it; every time they would attempt one they would sit in an awkward silence until Billy would read through the problem and point out what properties represented what. Harrington had made comments here and there about how his English grade was suffering as well, and Billy wondered if his class was also working through the same books as Billy’s. Steve seemed to avoid anything longer than two sentences if he could help it. Billy didn’t feel comfortable saying any of his observations to Steve, though, he was afraid it would come across as just him being a dick again.

For what he lacked in initial understanding he made up for in willingness to learn. Once Billy would go over something a couple of times, along with writing the equations in bold off to the sides, Steve would be able to wrap his head around what to do. He had a good predisposition for plugging in numbers and working them until he got the answer, but it was just a matter of checking his work along the way to make sure he was still on the right track. He groaned as Billy explained it.

“Yeah, I know, I know. Sometimes the numbers just mix up or I remember them wrong, and then I’m sat there looking at four completely different answer choices than the one I got and—”

“That’s why you just gotta write the equation in the side,” Billy insisted, “Every time you get confused you just look back to it to make sure you’re still doing good.”

Steve scrubbed a hand over his face. “Yeah, okay sure, but then halfway through the test when someone looks over at my sheet they’re gonna think, ‘damn, Harrington needs to write his shit in big letters so his big, dumb, brain can read?’ It’s sad enough that I have to basically fucking underline it to see it in the first place.”

“Well, funny that you think anyone will be looking at your sheet during a test,” he said, trying to diffuse the tension. Steve snorted and slugged him in the shoulder. Billy continued on, though, aware that academics was somewhat of a sore spot with the other boy. “Anyways, everyone does stuff to help them understand shit. Even brainiacs like Wheeler. Probably especially brainiacs like Wheeler.”

“Not you!” Steve was quick to say. “You literally sit there and finish the homework before she’s done with the lesson. You use like, one paper for scratchwork.” Billy wondered when Steve had been watching him closely enough to see that. “And here I am, having to bold and underline shit because my mind is too stupid to remember it. Or understand it the first time I read it.”

“Harrington, no one understands shit the first time they—”

Steve rolled his eyes so hard Billy felt tempted to tell him they’d get stuck that way. “Yeah, okay, says the genius. I haven’t seen you drawing boxes around questions.”

Billy shook his head and went to grab his backpack. Steve’s had shot out and gripped his wrist hard. He was proud that he didn’t show any visible reaction, but the heat from Harrington’s hand was making his heart race. “Wait, man, I wasn’t trying to—”

“Calm down, Harrington,” he grunted, shaking his wrist free and proceeding to rifle through his pack for his English folder. When he found what he was looking for he shoved it under Steve’s nose.

“What is this?” his pretty brow furrowed. Billy tried to keep his mind on the subject at hand rather than going down a rabbit hole analyzing Steve’s face.

“My English work. Look at the margins.” In all the packets of homework there were notes scribbled over almost every available inch. “Every time I get through a paragraph, I have to write what happens in it right next to it. Sometimes it’s hard to remember what happens, or what it means, so I always have to write it down so I can get my thoughts together.”

Steve was still looking at his notes. Billy scratched his jaw self-consciously. “Listen, man, everyone has to, ya know, make accommodations. It just depends on how you learn.”

Another beat passed. Steve didn’t say anything, and Billy’s neck started feeling hot under his collar. Once again, he’d been too transparent in Harrington’s presence and he was sick of feeling foolish. He went to pluck the papers from Steve’s hands, but he kept a firm grip on them. Billy gave him a look, starting to feel his insecurity turn into anger. “Harrington. I’m trying to help you out here. If you—”

“No-no, I’m just. You know you’re like, super smart, right?” He waved the papers. “Billy, we’re not even in the same league. You have to take notes because you actually have, like, ideas running through your head. I don’t even want to tell you what I got on my last English essay.”

Billy tried to cut in, but Steve fixed him with a glare. “Don’t even try arguing with me. It’s different. This is like . . . you trying to curb how smart you are. I’m, like, trying to accommodate my stupidity.”

“You're not stupid, Harrington,” he said forcefully, hoping that using his last name would take away from some of the sincerity he was painfully bearing. “Chris O’Malley is stupid. Fucking . . . Jenny Hampshire is stupid. Trust me, you’re not stupid. The only reason why I’m acing this class so well is because I’ve taken this class before. Do you know how many people can’t write stupid essays?”

Steve still didn’t look convinced. Billy soldiered on. “Listen, man, school is just doing busy work. No one even likes school; I guarantee you half the class right now needs to draw boxes around the questions. You just gotta figure out what works for you and just keep going with it. Don’t fix it if it ain’t broke.”

Finally, Steve let himself deflate with a sigh. He tossed the pencil back onto the table, where they both watch it roll toward the middle centerpiece. “Yeah, okay. You’re right. Not like I’m gonna do anything with calculus in my life.”

“What do you wanna do, Harrington?” Billy was curious, Tommy had told him a little bit about Steve’s dad’s business enterprise but that didn’t seem to be something Steve would get into. You had to have a mind for numbers to get any business degree, and if Harrington couldn’t get high school calculus there was no way he’d stand a chance in a college statistics class.

“Uh-h-h, I honestly couldn’t tell you. I used to think I’d probably work with my dad’s company, but now I’m not so sure.” He started to look a little cagey. “I don’t know. I’m still thinking. What about you?” The last part sounded accusatory.

“Mechanical engineer.” Billy said matter-of-factly. The guidance counselor back in California had planted the idea in his head after he had seen Billy’s test scores for physics, along with all the accelerated-learning math classes he had taken since freshman year. Working on his Camaro and his dad’s last car had given him an anatomical mind; and most times he was itching to take things apart just to have the satisfaction of putting it back together again. It was ironic considering him and Steve’s tumultuous relationship.

“And how do you know that’s what you wanna do?”

He shrugged. “Someone told me I’d be good at it. I’m good at physics, and I like math pretty okay so I figured that would be the way to go.” It was kind of an understatement; that afternoon Billy had driven to the nearest local library to pick up different books on engineering to see if there had been any worth the what the counselor had said. Once he’d found mechanical engineering, it was the sort of thing he kept close to his chest in fear that his dad would somehow take it away from him too.

“See!” Steve seized upon the end of his statement. “You’re good at something and you also happen to like it. I don’t even know what I would be good at.”

“Daycare?” Billy offered, half joking. If there was anything Steve seemed to excel in it was keeping his patience around a group of rowdy thirteen-year old’s. Billy knew for a fact that he got the best deal of them; there was no way Max could scream his ear off for an entire ride no matter what kind of mood she was in.

Steve slugged him in the shoulder again. The tense mood had dissipated, and Billy almost sighed in relief. He was afraid after this disastrous first tutoring lesson Steve would tell him to never come back; Billy hadn’t expected a full-on existential crisis to hit while they were going over derivatives of polynomials. An irrational part of himself had been afraid that Steve would throw his hands up and say, “I quit!” at some point or kick him out for overstepping into his business.

A glance at the ornate clock on the wall said that it was 7:48, and while Billy’s dad knew that he would be studying with a classmate and wouldn’t be at dinner tonight, it still gave him the compulsory stab of fear seeing that it was past 7 and he wasn’t home. Being almost an hour late to a family dinner even in the hypothetical sense was enough to send a tiny shudder through his shoulders. Steve took that for Billy being antsy to get home and started gathering his stuff. “Sorry for keeping you man, I didn’t mean to talk your ear off.”

"Nah, it’s cool.” Billy tried to sound natural to counteract how quick he had been to disagree with Steve.

The moment was done, though, and Billy knew when it was time to make a quick getaway. Any longer and he’d just end up irritating Harrington by clinging around like shit to a shovel. He had to keep reminding himself that Steve had chosen him to tutor because he had one of the highest grades in the class, and also that the other “smart” kids were probably too weird for even denounced King Steve to lower himself to communicate. Billy was the Devil he knew, and Billy shouldn’t be so quick to believe that they were steering toward something like friends. Billy didn’t have actual friends, and he didn’t have friends that were like Steve Harrington either. It was a bit of a wake-up call, but it was also the cold douse of water he’d needed.

Driving back home the closer and closer he got to his house the more he started to feel that tension creep up his spine. Even though it had gotten kind of charged in the end, Billy realized the entire time he’d spent tutoring Steve at his house was the first time in weeks he’d finally felt relaxed. The heater had been on, the room had been bathed in a yellow-ish light, and there weren’t any background sounds of the T.V. or his dad’s antique radio droning on. Not only that, but there had been some kind of illicit thrill in being in a home that was completely devoid of parents. Billy felt his dad’s looming presence over his shoulder every waking second he was at home. He was careful to not play his music too loudly in his room, or accidentally slam a door in fear of retribution. While the Harrington household was creepy in its detachment, there was something comforting in the silence that swept the whole house. Steve had also had every room lit up that he could see, and that was another oddity that kind of added to the feeling of comfort. God forbid Billy leave the light on in his room while he was at school; if Neil found out there would be hell to pay.

No, tutoring Steve Harrington was no hardship as far as Billy was concerned. Twice a week he’d get to pop over to reteach math and he would get the payment of a couple hours away from his house and an infinite amount of moments to gaze at Steve without the other boy looking. It was almost too good to be true, which made Billy nervous. Usually when something was good for him, the universe had a funny way of taking it back from him tenfold.

Billy parked his car in the driveway and sat there for a second, catching his breath. The second had gone on too long though, apparently, because the porch light flicked twice. He wondered how his dad possibly had the time to stand by the door and wait for his Camaro’s lights to shine through the living room window, but he made sure he didn’t stall in turning his car off. It wouldn’t do him any good to make his dad impatient.