Actions

Work Header

i hate you some, i love you some, i love you when i forget about me

Chapter 4: when you feel cold, i'll warm you, and when you feel you can't go on, i'll come and hold you

Notes:

wheeeeeeew sorry about the long wait! with holidays this chapter kind of got the best of me, for a while i was jsut sat there stumped and unable to write. hope you guys enjoy!

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

Steve keeps a constant vigil by Billy’s side most of the night. Which, he didn’t really mean to at first. After a couple hours of anxiously hovering over Billy and kidding himself, he finally accepts the inevitable and parks it into the plush armchair right next to the couch.

Billy looks peaceful sleeping. Well, about as peaceful as someone who’s broken two fingers and maybe cracked some ribs can sleep. For the first hour or so after he put Billy on the couch, Steve cleaned so thoroughly and methodically he had to physically stop himself from picking up the Comet and heading up to hit the upstairs bathrooms. To go upstairs would be to lose sight of Billy, which really isn’t in his immediate plans right now.

The puttering at least stopped the shaking in his hands that had been building since he had gotten his first good look at Billy in the diner. After that, he had sunken into the armchair and committed to watching over him. He stayed awake, a little bit because he was afraid if he drifted off, he would wake them both up with his screaming after a nightmare. Mostly, though, it was because he was afraid Billy would randomly need something in the middle of the night, and he might be in too much pain to get it for himself. Or what Steve knew was probably his first instinct; randomly sneaking off without saying a word.

He ended up stewing in his own misery for most of the night. If his mind wasn’t on the what, it was on the why, who, or how. He knew Billy would be just as evasive as the night before. Steve also knew that a good night of sleep would make it easier for Billy to come up with a believable lie. So, Steve was prepared to wait. Not for a long time, hopefully a couple days at most, but he would bide his time to get the answers he wanted. For now, he would play along with whatever bullshit Billy would come up with.

Sometime around five, when it was still dark and moody outside, Billy shot up from the couch. He had woken up so abruptly, gasping in big, huge gulps of air, that Steve nearly startled out of his seat. Billy wildly looked around the room, before finally landing on Steve and sagging for a second. Steve saw relief in Billy’s eyes, before it was quickly replaced with unease. So, he was probably remembering the night before.

Hs chest wasn’t moving as rapidly up and down, now, and he gave a grimace before holding his uninjured hand to his torso. At the sight, Steve got himself back into gear and left to go get some of that Tylenol Billy had taken the night before. He also poured a water for him, blushing abruptly at the memory of what Billy had said to him the night of the party, when he’d done almost the exact same thing. A slurred, well, well, looks like I’ve got two tall glasses of water. Steve had blushed deeply then, too.

All those thoughts left the window, though, when he came back into the living room to see Billy attempting to stand.

“Sit.” He ordered immediately, impressed with how firm his voice sounded and how Billy obeyed without protest. He looked chastened, which wasn’t a look he saw often on Billy, and suddenly felt bad for barking out a command.

He gave Billy the pills and the water. Steve watched him swallow the pills down, making sure that Billy drained the whole glass of water as well. God knows he probably had the headache of a lifetime, and water would at least do something. He should’ve asked Mrs. Reynolds for a thorough aftercare plan, not that he was even able to think that far ahead at the time. Last night he had weighed the consequences: leaving Billy injured and untreated or risking whatever happened when Mrs. Reynolds inevitably told Steve’s parents why he randomly knocked on her door on a Saturday night. She had been a godsend, but Steve was still too dumb to remember to ask what he should do the next morning. Billy still looked rough. And the only thing Steve was really doing was forcing him to drink a full glass of water.

It felt kind of strangely intimate, just watching Billy drink his water down like a hawk, but Billy didn’t say anything about it. Didn’t even look Steve’s way, just kept his eyes shut and chugged the glass. He looked like he was dying of thirst, but it was still painful to swallow it all down. His hurt hand lay at his side, the bulky splints from probably the general pharmacy standing out starkly against the rest of his hand. When Billy was done drinking, Steve carefully sat back down in the armchair, afraid that any sudden movement would spook him back into leaving.

“So,” he started, when it became clear by Billy’s silence that he was going to have to be the one to break the tension. “How are you feeling?”

It was still dark in the living room, but there was a light in the hallway illuminating them. The slab of golden light filling the room set Billy’s face into a warm glow, which looked odd against his dark bruises. He could see Billy’s face twist up before he gave a dry snort.

“Never better.”

That was what he had expected. It didn’t make him any less irritated with Billy’s tight-lipped response. “Right. Well. Sorry for asking, seeing as you’re obviously in great shape.” He felt a little ungenerous.

That made Billy wince, wearing that cowed look on his face again. Steve had a difficult time keeping a hard heart about it when Billy looked so tame. “Billy, I didn’t…”

“No, it’s okay. You’re right. M’sorry.” Billy scratched the back of his head, right where a bunch of curls were knotted up from last night. He looked unsure of himself, totally out of his depth, and Steve couldn’t even be the lifeline he needed.

Steve didn’t reply, wondering if Billy would now fill the silence. It was his turn to do so. When Billy uncomfortably cleared his throat, Steve counted it as a win. “Last night, things just got… out of control. I’m good though. Swear.”

He left it there. Steve raised his eyebrows after a moment, realizing that this was truly all Billy was going to offer. Not that he really expected Billy to gab his ear off or give him a tell-all, but the paltry sum he got was barely any crumbs. It just cemented the idea forming at the back of his mind more.

“I’m assuming this is all you’re gonna give, right?” He asked drily. Might as well play it cool. “And if I ask any more, you’re just gonna shut me down?”

This time the look Billy gave him wasn’t the same as the other ashamed ones. It was sheepish, and he could see in the line of Billy’s shoulders that he was relieved Steve didn’t seem to be taking it seriously. “Probably, yeah.”

Steve spread his hands on his knees. “Okay, then. I’ll just bite my tongue.” He didn’t want to outright lie to Billy, though, so he added, “For now.”

Billy at least seemed more at ease now that Steve had agreed to “drop it”, and Steve felt a little bad for deceiving him. In the long run, though, Steve felt justified. If Billy wasn’t going to let him help, then he’d just force his help on Billy.

“What times’ it?” Billy asked.

“Just after five.” He wondered what had jolted Billy awake in the first place. “You can sleep in a little more, if you want.” He offered. Steve tried not to think of how it was an excuse to stare at Billy’s sleeping face for a couple more hours.

But Billy shook his head. “Nah, I better go. Gotta sneak in before the old man wakes up.” When he said this his eyes snapped to Steve’s before flickering away. It made sense, but…

“Won’t he see you got into a fight anyway?” He could understand Billy trying to hide the injuries from his dad, but it wasn’t like the injuries weren’t noticeable.

Billy shrugged a shoulder tensely. “Doesn’t matter. I’ll figure it out.”

Once again, it was like pulling teeth. He sighed, “Okay, lemme grab my jacket and keys.”

He looked Billy over, still in the white tee from last night. There were drops of dried blood at the collar, and there was another rusty stain partway down. He was surprised more hadn’t gotten on the shirt. When he had first seen Billy in the diner, the sight of his bruised and bloodied face had made Steve almost nauseated at first. The rain had done an okay job of smearing most of it off, but in the middle of the night the cut on his eyebrow had torn a bit, again, and Steve had to use an iron will to keep himself from standing over Billy and dabbing at his wounds.

Just staring at the brown blobs was kind of making him sick again. “You wanna borrow a jacket?”

Billy shook his head. “Nope. Just be sure to blast the heat.”

Steve kept it toasty the entire drive. The ride over was silent; with Billy choosing not to break the quiet, and Steve unsure how to, since Billy was being so close-lipped. He could see Billy out of the corner of his eye, hunched in on himself and brimming with anxiety. It made Steve feel even worse for him, seeing his palpable stress. He wondered what Billy would tell his dad. Wondered what Billy usually told his dad whenever this happened.

At the junction to turn on Billy’s street, he felt a hand shoot out and grab his wrist. He willed himself not to flinch, instead pressing down on the brakes and turning to face Billy.

Billy wasn’t looking at him. “Just stop here.” His voice was wooden.

Steve wanted to protest, since it was still pretty chilly in the mornings, and he didn’t want Billy exerting any more effort than he needed. He still stopped, though, because he knew when it was useless to protest. Billy was already hopping out before he rolled to a complete stop at the sign. He just started off into the still dark morning, not even bothering to turn back or give a cheeky wave.

Instead, when Steve stayed parked there to make sure Billy got to his house okay, he watched as Billy haphazardly took off his splints and shoved them into the back pocket of his jeans.

Steve wanted to floor it, wanted to shove the splints back on, and walk up with Billy to the stoop to demand Billy be brought to a hospital, or clinic, somewhere. All he could do, though, was sit in his car and watch as Billy slouched on the front porch. The door didn’t open. Billy took to leaning on the wall. When he spotted Steve still at the mouth of the street, headlights blazing, he waved him away with an annoyed look. Steve drove off, feeling rotten to the core for doing so.

~

Billy doesn’t show up to school Monday morning.

Everyone is all buddy-buddy with Steve again, since he made an appearance at the party Friday. The party feels like forever ago, and all the smiles he gives back sit false and wrong on his face. A couple people ask him about Billy. He was so trashed, most of them say, what happened? Steve just thinks, buddy, I’d like to know too.

Nancy and Jonathan try to talk to him during lunch, but he spends it watching the parking lot from the courtyard trying to will the Camara roaring up. It doesn’t.

Math class comes next and Steve sits in his usual seat. Ironically, since it’s the week before spring break, they’re not covering any new material in class. Steve spends the entire class period glancing at Billy’s empty seat right next to him while the rest of the class reviews.

Tuesday is the same, the only difference is that Steve’s desperation mounts new levels. He drives by Billy’s house after school, and sees the Camaro still parked in the driveway. For a split second he thinks about knocking on the door and asking to see Billy himself, but he loses his nerve. It seems like the type of thing Billy would beg him not to do. 

He decides to move forward with his plan. Later that night, he calls the Henderson household and offers to take Dustin to and from school tomorrow, A.V. Club included. Dustin is a little confused when he shows up Wednesday morning, but his excitement outweighs any suspicion over Steve’s sudden appearance. Steve feels bad that he’s doing this for nefarious reasons, but something’s gotta give.

Steve drops Dustin off at the middle school and lingers in the parking lot long enough to see Max get dropped off in a dinky, brown Corolla. That answers his question if Billy will show up at all today. He waits until the Corolla has turned out of sight, before jumping out of his car.

“Max!” he calls across the parking lot. He’s uncomfortably aware that he’s a high school senior calling out for an eighth-grade girl in public and makes the decision in his mind to have this go as quickly as possible. Knowing Max and her ability of evasion makes him a little skeptical it’ll actually go that smoothly.

Max whips around, face scrunched up in irritation before she sees Steve. At the sight of him, her face drops from annoyance to nervous. It reinforces Steve’s will just a little more to have this conversation. She stops where she’s at, and Steve jogs to meet her.

“Hey, Steve,” she says casually, almost a little too casual. She shifts from foot to foot.

He sees Will and Mike standing off a little further, where Dustin has now joined them. When Dustin turns and sees Steve is still there, he makes to come over again but Steve waves him away before looking back at Max.

“We need to talk about Billy.”

Max just tucks her hair behind her ears, even though there’s no strands loose. “What’s up?”

“Are you joking, Max?” His eyebrows are a mile up his forehead. He knows she’d had to have taken a good look at Billy by now. “Has anyone taken him to a hospital yet? He begged me not to.” He tacks on.

She gapes at him, eyes narrowing and running over his face. “Wait, you know?”

“What, that someone beat him to a pulp Saturday? Was it supposed to be some secret?” Going off the expression on Max’s face, the answer is yes.

Why keep it a secret, though? What’s the point? You’re missing something, stupid.

She’s staring at Steve like she’s trying to get a read on him. Even though they’re not related, Billy and Max’s eyes are only shades apart in that startling, searching blue. They both had the same way of pinning those wild eyes on you, where enough exposure made you wanna take a step back. Even now, Steve resists the urge. “Do you know who beat Billy?”

Her tone is measured, like she’s testing him rather than asking an actual question she needs answers to. He almost wants to tear his hair out in frustration. Why is she being so difficult?

“Max, do you know?” He has to ask. He immediately gets his answer when Max’s face visibly closes off, another move that seems like it’s been directly lifted from Billy.

When she doesn’t answer, he steps forward. “Max, please. You have to tell me. I have to know who did this to him.”

“I can’t tell you!”

Her voice is firm, but she’s no match for an overcome Steve. “You wanted me to check on him sometimes, remember? That’s what you asked me.”

Silence from Max. Just more of her looking gloomy and shifty, glancing back over to where he knows the boys are waiting and watching.

His hands are around her arms now, not squeezing but trying to make sure she stays planted there. “I’m trying to look out for him, I’m trying, but I can’t when you guys keep stuff from me.”

She’s not even looking at him, even though he’s only a couple inches away. He’s barely resisting the urge to give her a good shake. It’s hard not to grow frustrated, especially when she’s the one who asked him to do this in the first place. “Why won’t you tell me, Max? Who is it? Do they go to our school?”

Max still doesn’t answer, just shaking her head back and forth, and it takes Steve a couple of seconds to realize her body’s practically vibrating in his hands. Her face is getting red, again, just like that night in the car. “Max…” he tries to say, but he’s already too late.

In an almost jarring comparison to Billy waking up just three days ago, she’s gasping in these gulps of air that look like they hurt more than they help. Steve’s been on the receiving end of a panic attack enough to know what the beginning of one looks like, but the shock of being the one to cause it has him dumbly forgetting everything to do during one, and he numbly releases her arms from his grip. She sways a little bit, still sniffling and trying to get a good breath in. Steve, in his stupidity, clumsily reaches for her again.

Max backs away, though, and this time he can see her furiously blinking the tears out of her eyes. The hard, mean look that she’s tried to make her default since arriving is back.

Steve can tell when a battle is lost but tries anyway for her sake. “Max, I-I’m sorry, I wasn’t trying to make you upset. I’m just—” I’m just trying to help doesn’t seem like a fair statement when he’s brought Max to tears in the middle of the fucking school parking lot.

Of course, that’s when he sees Dustin, Will, and Mike approaching, this time with Lucas leading the pack.

“Max?” Lucas is hovering, off to the side. “You okay?” he tries to step forward.

She’s not having any of it, though, and backs up from Lucas as well. “Get the fuck away from me!” she says to no one in particular. Her tone isn’t angry enough to hide the cracking at the edges. It’s just another imitation of Billy, Steve realizes, to jump to the defense when emotions are on the line. It almost makes him hysterical thinking about it, though, and he resists the urge to badger her one last time.

Before anyone can say anything else, she pushes past all of them to speed-walk towards the school. Will recovers the quickest, and rushes to catch up with her. Mike and Dustin stand there, awkwardly, while Lucas turns to face Steve.

“What did you say to her?” He demands angrily. “Why was she so upset?”

Most of the kids are going in at this point, and distantly Steve is aware that he’s really having this happen in a middle school parking lot. He wishes that he had just kept his trap shut and never went ahead with this stupid idea in the first place. He just had to try, had to see if he could get any answers whatsoever.

He considers making a run for it. Would probably be pathetic as all hell, but at least he’d be safe in his car from whatever dressing down he’s about to receive. Lucas is inescapable though.

“I can’t tell you,” he says at last, because if anything’s clear it’s that everything Billy and Max adjacent is under wraps.

That’s not a good enough answer for Lucas. Steve doesn’t blame him: he’s been given that one a couple times now and can agree it’s annoying as fuck. But he’s not about to air Billy’s dirty laundry to a bunch of middle schoolers that hate him, so it’s all Steve can offer now.

“What the hell, man?! Why—”

“Lucas, it wasn’t as bad as it looked. I just…” He trailed off, unsure of what lie to even say at this point. They all saw him arguing with Max, and they all saw her walk away upset.

“Oh really? Then what was it? She was crying and you were the one who—"

“Stop!” Dustin interjects. “Maybe Steve had a good reason.” He doesn’t look like he fully believes it either, though, and looks pretty unsure when he regards Steve. “Right?”

Steve opens his mouth, not really sure what he’s gonna answer but wanting to give something to assure them that he’s got a good reason for seemingly harassing Max. Luckily, the ten-minute bell goes off, and Lucas curses and gives one last hateful glare Steve’s way before retreating with Mike. Dustin looks like he wants to say something else, but at the last minute changes his mind and follows the others.

He stands there, brooding and sulking, and finally cuts his losses. On the way to his car—still running—he kicks a rock, irked. He’s gonna be late for first period. It doesn’t matter, it’s not like he’ll be paying attention for the rest of the day. Instead, he runs it all over and over and over again in his head.

He can’t stop thinking of what both Billy and Max have said to him. That first time, in the car, Max had hopelessly said, I wish I could tell you. Saturday afternoon, before everything went to shit, Billy had said, I can’t man! I just can’t tell you!

Steve doesn’t even bother meeting up with Nancy and Jonathan for lunch. Instead, he takes a page out of Billy’s book and spends it in his car. He’s craving a cigarette like no other right now, and it figures it would be the only time Billy isn’t there to offer him one. Both of their words just keep twisting and twisting in his head, intertwining until they sound like the same layered, eerie voice. What can’t they both tell him? He’s dumb, but not dumb enough to be able to ignore when certain things overlap.

He’s barely present for the rest of the school day, at least mentally. Between thinking about Billy, thinking about Max, and absolutely dreading driving Dustin home from A.V. Club, he ends up in one of the shittiest moods he’s had in a while.

Billy isn’t there to play basketball with him after school. Not that he really expected them to play this week, anyway, but after not having a tutoring session last night Steve just feels disappointed. Billy was the break in the monotony he had been coasting through the past year, and without Billy here he suddenly feels lonelier than before, which is really saying a lot. He dribbled the ball in the gym after school anyways, Billy or not, but when it’s just him in the gym it feels like the ball echoes off the floor louder than it ever has.

He purposefully takes a little longer than usual to get to the middle school, in hopes of maybe avoiding some third degree from the kids. It works for the most part, all he really gets is a passing glare from Lucas through the windshield that he valiantly ignores, but when Dustin slides in he can tell that he’s about to be in for it.

When Dustin doesn’t immediately talk like he desperately wants to, Steve knows he has to say something.

“So, about this morning… um, I know it looked bad.”

Dustin stays silent. Steve resists the urge to fidget in his seat. He shouldn’t be intimidated by a damn middle-schooler, but he can’t explain the antsy feeling any other way.

He takes a deep breath and tries to continue. “Look. I don’t know what Max told you, but… I wasn’t trying to, ya’ know, hurt her. I was just trying to… get some answers.”

“About Billy, right?” Dustin asks without looking at him.

Hearing Dustin say Billy’s name almost jolts him. “Uh, I—”

“I heard you. Well, we all kinda heard you, technically. You were kind of acting loony, there.”

He glances at Dustin. Dustin is too busy staring out the window to look back. He doesn’t know what to say here to make Dustin feel better. Part of him desperately wants to tell it all, wants to lay the facts bare and have Dustin help him deduce what’s really going on.

But that’s too much to ask of a middle-schooler. Last time they talked about… well, Billy, it was obvious Dustin was still freaked after that night all those months ago. He was afraid Billy was just going to beat Steve’s face in again. Ironic, given what Steve’s been mulling over the past few days.

Not for the first time, Steve wishes he weren’t such a shitty liar. You’d think growing up a privileged, snotty, rich boy would somehow make him a world-class bullshitter, but his face is so open that it’s no wonder how everyone always knows when he’s hiding something.

“Dustin,” he finally decides to try to take the reins on this thing. If anything, just so that Dustin will get that sad look off his face. “I know I freaked you guys out this morning. And that was my bad. Something… stressful is just going on right now, and it made me stressed. But I still shouldn’t have acted like that this morning.”

Now Dustin finally turns to face him. “What has you so stressed about Billy?” At Steve’s hedging look, he continues, “No, seriously. I thought he was just tutoring you. Now you’re shaking Max in the morning and interrogating her about her evil step-brother.”

He winces. Yeah, not really one of his finer moments, but at the time he was just so at the end of his tether that it had felt like the only way to get through to her. “Did Max say anything?”

Dustin narrowed his eyes. “No. She didn’t say anything at all, and then she skipped A.V. Club. Lucas doesn’t even know why. And don’t think I didn’t notice you avoiding the question. So why were you acting like a crazy person this morning? Was that the only reason why you wanted to pick me up?”

God, it’s too much to think about while he’s driving. They’re only about ten minutes from Dustin’s, but he pulls over to the side of the road anyway. This time when he turns to face Dustin, he makes sure to face him head-on, with full eye contact. Dustin at least senses the serious mood Steve’s giving off and keeps uncharacteristically silent.

“Billy and I are… well, we’re friends,” he starts. May as well jump in with something that’s truthful. Dustin bites his lip and looks like he wants to interject, so Steve rushes on. “We are. And it’s not just ‘cause of tutoring, or whatever, we’re actual friends.”

He gauges Dustin’s reaction. He looks a little bit disgusted, but he doesn’t try to yammer his ear off about why that’s a bad idea, so Steve considers it some kind of progress.

When Dustin still doesn’t speak, he takes that as the sign to keep going. “Billy is complicated. Right now, he’s going through some stuff, and he’s not telling me anything. I got really frustrated and tried to talk to Max this morning, but as you could see, I went kinda off the deep end.” And because he has to assure Dustin, “It wasn’t the full reason why I asked your mom if I could drive you, I could’ve given any excuse to do it.”

He waits for the fallout. Dustin just looks thoughtful, now, rather than wearing that pinched hurt expression that had been clouding his face earlier. He looks more confused if anything. “Okay, I guess. But I’m not really understanding why you acted like that.”

Embarrassed, he scratches the back of his neck. “Yeah, I don’t know why either, buddy. I just got scared I guess.”

“Scared for Billy?” Dustin looks disbelieving. “How could that be possible? No offense, but he seems like he can take care of himself.”

“You’d be surprised.” He responds drily. When Dustin gives him a really, Steve? look he doubles down. “No, I’m serious. Sometimes things just aren’t what they seem. You should know that more than anyone else.”

Dustin huffed. “Alright. Fine. But that still doesn’t explain why you were acting so weird today. You could’ve just asked her. Or Billy.”

“Don’t you think I’ve tried?” Steve laughed despairingly. Saturday afternoon he had felt so close to finally pulling something out of Billy, only to crash and burn horrendously. “He won’t give me anything. Max won’t either.”

“Oka-ay,” Dustin looked at him like he said something obvious. “Shouldn’t that tell you that it’s not a big deal, then? Or that maybe you should just drop it?”

“It’s not—it’s not that simple.” He ran a hand through his hair fretfully. “Anyway, I don’t wanna get any more into that. But I am sorry for freaking you guys out. I know Max hates my guts now, and Lucas does too, but I really wasn’t trying to be that… crazy. Just lost myself for a bit.”

Dustin looks at him in commiseration. “I’m sure they don’t actually hate your guts. Lucas is just mad. And Max… I know she gets weird about Billy too sometimes. So, she probably doesn’t hate you too.”

Part of Steve wants to immediately ask what does Max say about Billy? But that’d be pushing it too far. He’s only just been able to convince Dustin that he shouldn’t be institutionalized. Asking any more about Billy will just make it sound like everything was a lie.

He drives Dustin the last ten minutes home, happy at least that there’s one relationship in his life that’s going alright.

He gets back home to an empty house. Per usual. Having no one to hang with the past three days makes it feel even emptier, even more like a mausoleum that he sometimes has nightmares about.

The fact of the matter is that Dustin raised a good point. If Billy just didn’t want him to know something, then shouldn’t Steve just drop it?

But he couldn’t. He knew that plain and simple. It was like this itch at the back of his head, constantly aching for him to give attention to it. Billy had wormed his way, somehow, into every crevice of his mind. Any moment he wasn’t thinking about his colossal fuck-up with Max he had been thinking about Billy; what Billy was doing, how Billy looked, how Billy felt. Why was he so obsessed? Why couldn’t Steve just have one thought to himself without it concerning Billy?

It’s like I have a crush or something, the thought came unbidden in his mind. Once it was there, though, he couldn’t get it out.

A crush on Billy? The thought itself seemed ridiculous, but then, why was he fixating on it so much? The truth was Steve almost never stopped thinking of Billy. And seeing as the last time he had had even a fraction of this mounting obsession it had been for Nancy; it wasn’t like it was that crazy of an idea. Nancy had occupied most of his waking thoughts, having him pursue her with a dogged determination he had never given anyone else before. When they were dating his thoughts had been a constant stream of Nancy, Nancy, Nancy, and it had been that way for a bit even after they broke up. Since when did Nancy, Nancy, Nancy, become Billy, Billy Billy?

But it had. Sometime between that conversation in the middle of the night and now, he had become positively engrossed in everything concerning Billy. Infatuated, if he was being completely honest. Steve had always been a sucker for someone who was funny, and after dating Nancy he realized he liked brains on a person as well; two things that fit Billy perfectly.

A lot of things about it made sense, too. Like that weird, hot feeling he got under his skin every time Billy called him pretty boy. Or why he had blushed so hard when Billy had called him a tall glass of water. It also explained the weird nervousness he got every time it was him and Billy in the showers alone. Steve had showered with Tommy after gym for years and had never felt that way before. Every time it was just him and Billy under the showerheads, it was like Steve was aware of every second, every movement, and every inch that seemed to be between their bodies.

Actually, now that he thought about it, he had done some very questionable things; like checking out Billy’s abs and almost getting caught that one morning they ate breakfast, the way his body always got warm wherever Billy had accidentally brushed against him or touched him, his own weird moment when Billy had fallen down on the driveway and Steve had brushed gravel off his cheek. At the time, Steve didn’t know what had made him pause and stare at Billy’s face, but he thought maybe he knew now.

Next, Steve tried to picture what it’d be like to actually date Billy, what it would be like to kiss him. The sudden image of Billy with his tongue popped in his cheek came up and fantasizing about what else it could do almost had Steve choking on his spit as he thought about it. Picturing Billy kissing him made him feel a little hot under the collar and had his heart racing in his chest. Well, that answered that. Having Billy’s attention on him even when they were just hanging out was enough to have him feeling nervous, and even the thought of kissing Billy had him flushed a deep red. Not to mention the rest of the tingle it gave his body thinking of him and Billy in that sort of way.

It felt kind of good to be able to pin down the reason why he wasn’t so willing to back down about Billy, but with that realization came the one of what he was supposed to do now. Yeah, okay, maybe Steve had a massive crush on Billy, but what now? There was no way he was actually going to tell Billy, unless he wanted to either be phased out, had his face pummeled in, or both. He couldn’t very well tell anyone else, either, could hardly picture seeing Nancy and Jonathon at lunch and telling them, Hey, I think I might be a little queer for Billy Hargrove. And there was no way he was even entertaining the thought of telling Dustin unless he wanted everyone else in the Party to know as well. Which included Max. God, this was so fucked.

He didn’t even know if he qualified as queer, seeing as he’d never felt this way about a boy before Billy. The facts were indisputable, though: Steve had a crush on Billy, and Billy was a boy. Therefore, there had to be at least some part of him that was queer. Or maybe he was just Billy-sexual. Either way, he knew it was better kept as a secret.

Him and Billy were already at such a precarious balance right now, there was no way Steve was about to jeopardize that over some crush. Nothing would send Billy further away than knowing his closest friend was having gay feelings for him. So, Steve would just do what he did best: suffer in silence. Whatever Billy was going through right now, he needed someone solid, not Steve overthinking is every move and analyzing whether Billy liked him back or not. No, the least he owed to Billy was to pretend everything was normal. At least he was getting better at that.

Going to bed that night, he wondered what was going on in the Hargrove house. He didn’t think that Max would tell Billy how Steve had rounded on her this morning, but that was maybe some wishful thinking. He hoped she wouldn’t tell, at least to save both of their hides. After all, Billy didn’t know that Max had approached him in the first place those months ago. Not that that really justified the manic way Steve had questioned her this morning, but at least it was something he could grasp onto. Billy would think Steve was a freak even more than usual if Max told him literally anything that had happened today. Plus, it would take away from his whole guess I won’t bother you air he was putting on for Billy’s sake. If Billy had any indication that Steve hadn’t actually dropped the subject of Saturday night, then Steve knew that Billy would find every way in the world to avoid him, which was counter-productive to everything Steve was trying to do.

He listened to his sleep machine pour out those fake ocean waves, and almost felt kind of embarrassed for using them as some kind of placeholder for Billy, but he was too used to them now to change the setting. Instead, he let the rise and fall of the tides coming through the speaker determine the ups and downs of his thoughts for the night.

~

Thursday morning when Steve pulled into the parking lot, he saw the Camaro parked where it usually was. Without a second thought, he swerved in to make sure he got the spot right next to Billy’s car. When he finished parking and got out, he saw that Billy was still sat in his front seat smoking a cigarette. He knocked on the window, and Billy glanced his way before giving him a nod.

He moved out of the way so Billy could get out, and when he did a cloud of smoke came with him. Steve waved it away, coughing from all the nicotine, but stayed where he was standing. In between their cars he was aware of how close their bodies were, and it almost made him squirm out of the way. He stood his ground, though, because there was no way he was gonna let Billy out of his sight now.

Billy looked miles better than he did Saturday night, and even Sunday morning. The bruising wasn’t as dark and frightening on his face, and he hadn’t winced too much coming out of his car. He still had the two splints on his fingers, but the splints weren’t as clunky as the ones before had been so Steve assumed that he had at least seen some sort of medical professional.

Steve was practically brimming with questions, but he knew anything too intense too soon would scare Billy off for sure. And Billy seemed to be looking at him just as closely as he probably was, like he was searching for something on Steve’s face. Briefly, he had the horrifying thought that maybe Max did say something to Billy, until Billy clapped him on the shoulder.

“Harrington, miss me? Hope you weren’t shooting hoops by yourself after school.”

Steve sputtered for a second, mind retreating back to yesterday afternoon when he had been dribbling the ball and moping like a baby. Billy saw his expression, and his face morphed to positive glee.

“No, dude, please don’t tell me you did. C’mon, that’s gonna break my heart.”

He shouldered past a now, honest-to-God cackling Billy, and tried to will his embarrassed flush away. “Yeah, yeah, yuck it up. We’ll see who’s laughing next time on the court.”

Not that he’d actually have anything to show for it. But it was better than having Billy think he was just… sulking by himself. Even though he had been. It kind of stung, though, the way Billy was deliberately playing it like nothing at all was wrong when Steve literally had to get help for him a couple nights ago.

Billy took a couple of long strides to catch up with him. He slowed down, even though his feelings were hurt, because he didn’t want Billy to strain himself. Billy shot him a grateful look when he waited for him to fully catch up.

“Listen, you wanna skip tutoring today? Go do something or whatever?” Billy was staring directly in his eyes.

Steve looked him over. Billy didn’t seem like he was in a bad mood, or even tense at all. Instead, he looked the loosest he had in a while. He didn’t know how it was possible for Billy to look so at ease, considering the state he was in, but Steve wasn’t about to mess up whatever good vibe Billy had going on by bringing up the odd behavior. Besides, having Billy’s full attention on him plus the prospect of hanging out after school were both too overwhelming for him to read into now.

“Alright, that sounds good,” He agreed, trying for casual. Billy saw right through him, though, and the corner of his mouth lifted in a smirk. He didn’t say anything else, just resumed walking with Steve to the entrance, but there was almost a bounce in his step that Steve had a hard time ignoring.

Billy shocked all of them when he came to sit at their table in the courtyard instead of doing his usual lunch of cigarettes in his car. Steve was the first to recover from his shock, scooting down a little so Billy wasn’t so pressed up against him on the seat. Billy moved with him, though, and they still ended up a hair away from each other, something that had Steve inwardly hyperventilating over.

Nancy’s eyes about boggled out of her head, and when she looked at Steve for some kind of solidarity, she lapsed into further confusion when Steve just pretended that it was completely normal. Jonathan at least concealed his surprise the best out of all of them, just a quick widening of his eyes before he timidly returned Billy’s nod and, “S’up Byers?”

Lunch was a little strained, but Billy seemed to be in high spirits no matter how disapproving Nancy looked at him from across the table, and Jonathon was able to play along and start up tentative conversation. Steve had a hard time shaking the grin that kept threatening to overtake his face, tickled by how strangely happy Billy was acting.

They walked together to their math class and Steve had never felt so alive than in that five minutes, walking next to Billy against the crowd of people going opposite directions. They hardly said a word, but the air between them was lighter than it had been in a while. Billy doodled drawings on the side of his classwork that nearly had Steve go faint from fighting laughter, and when they parted and Billy told him he would meet him at Steve’s house he felt like he was on cloud nine.

Billy’s happy mood was due to the fact that it was nearly Spring Break, apparently. At Steve’s puzzled look, he rolled his eyes so hard Steve thought he’d get a headache.

“Um, hello? A week of freedom? Drink all day, party all night?”

“Um, hello,” Steve crowed back, “Do you really think there’s parties every night in Hawkins?”

“Whatever. It will be for me. Whole house to myself until Wednesday.”

“Oh really?” That was news. From what he could tell, Billy had a normal home life; one where his dad or stepmom didn’t leave him alone for an allotted maybe nine months out of the year. “You gonna be throwing the parties then?”

Billy looked at him like he was insane. “Hell no. No way I’m letting a bunch of drunk idiot’s mess around with walls covered in Susan’s valuables. I’d be six feet under.”

They were playing a pitiful game of kick the can. When they had gotten back to Steve’s, Billy had been filled with a restless energy that had no hopes of being fought off. He tried to cajole Steve into passing a football, but Steve was adamant that Billy not do anything to strain his ribs. So, here they were, kicking a can in Steve’s backyard because Steve really couldn’t refuse a lot to Billy.

“What about you? Your parents gonna take you on a fancy trip or somethin’?” Billy lobbed the can his way, all while keeping his hands stuffed in his jacket pockets.

Steve barked out a dry laugh. “Ha. Yeah right. More like they’re taking a trip and leaving me here to play house.”

It was silent. Steve felt his face flush, feeling stupid for saying anything in the first place. He should’ve just said no like a normal person.

Billy toed the beat up can under his sneakers. Steve hoped he would have the same courtesy for Steve when it came to his problems. “Well, we should hang. The rest of my stash isn’t gonna smoke itself.” He finally said after a couple beats of silence.

Steve brightened up at that. “Oh yeah? Count me in, man, you know I can’t resist.”

Billy just gave a rueful grin and geared up to give the can a good kick. It sailed past Steve’s feet, but he couldn’t be even be mad about it, especially when Billy looked so happy yelling, “And Hargrove scores a screamer!”

~

It was the best Spring Break Steve had had in years. Probably forever, if he was being honest; and that counted the year his parents actually did take him on their trip to New York for Spring Break.

Billy’s dad, stepmom, and Max had all left Friday afternoon, kickstarting the break with a positive mood that Billy carried well into the weekend. They didn’t do anything different than what they usually did hanging out, the only difference was now they had all the time in the world to laze throughout the day in between their adventures. For the first time in forever he had gotten the heated pool started, after Billy begged and begged him one of the afternoons.

He thought he’d feel too freaked to get in, and when he first took off the pool cover, he definitely got the chills, but seeing Billy swan dive into the pool jeans and all had quickly put him at ease. And when Billy finally popped his head above the surface and spat water at him, there was little else Steve could do but roll his eyes and jump in afterwards. They ended up using the pool in the days after, Billy always taking the first leap in and never questioning why it always took Steve a minute or so longer to jump in after him.

The pool was both the best and worst thing. Best, because after that first dip Billy started actually bringing his swimming trunks, which meant that he wore nothing but his swim trunks, something that was very distracting to Steve. Worst, because Steve suddenly realized how much he stared at Billy.

What was distracting at first were the bruises that still mottled Billy’s chest, and they always stood out even more harshly whenever Billy would first get out of the pool and his skin would be almost as pale as Steve’s. He always insisted on putting some saran wrap over the splints, so they wouldn’t get wet, and would end up having to force Billy to give him his hand every time just so he could try to maneuver the plastic wrapping around his fingers. He ended up feeling like a grade-A weirdo every time he did it, but Billy never complained, and was actually pretty cooperative once Steve would get ahold of him.

Once he got over that initial shock, though, he had a hard time concentrating on anything but Billy’s body. It wasn’t just the fact that Billy was seriously fit (although that definitely didn’t hurt), it was the way that Billy moved with confidence that really had Steve’s mind reeling. It was like every move was measured and chosen carefully, nothing like Steve’s own flailing limbs and general clumsiness.

Not only that, but there’s a certain way Billy holds himself when he feels like he doesn’t have anything to prove. He’s more carefree, roughhouses a little bit more, cracks more jokes than he normally does. All in all, it’s the most fun Steve’s had in a while. And then of course it has to come crashing down. It only makes sense.

Here’s how it goes: Tuesday night, after a day of major swimming and the general horseplay two teenage guys engage in, they smoke a joint in Steve’s room. Billy’s jaw had dropped when Steve said it was okay, and it had taken smoking the entire first joint to make him finally relax and stop instinctually glancing over his shoulder at every errant sound in Steve’s house. His paranoia had been contagious, and seeing Billy continually nervous had been making Steve secondhand nervous as well.

Once they had the second joint going, Billy had started to loosen up. They had been smoking their way through the rest of his stash pretty generously, but every so often they mixed it in with Steve’s subpar Hawkins weed to make it last longer. He loved the attention and praise he got every time he rolled for Billy and thought once or twice about thanking Tommy for being his guineapig so he and Billy could reap the rewards. When he twisted the tip of the joint off and handed it to Billy for inspection, nothing could stop the butterflies in his stomach when Billy smiled at him like that.

Billy started it, while Steve stood up and went to flip the tape over in the stereo. It was his own mix, and the ribbing Billy delivered over it was more good-natured than actually disgusted. He was in the most agreeable mood he had been in the past couple of days, and with his face and body bruises fading away it was almost like his inner mood was changing his exterior. Steve shook his head, clearing his thoughts. God, the weed had a way of burying him and a lot of times made him notice so much more about Billy than he should have.

The room had been hazy looking, filled mostly with the fog of pot smoke. Steve had cracked open a window for ventilation, but they were so high they kept forgetting to blow it out there and instead blew smoke all over the place. His eyes felt heavy and hot, and his brain had reached that almost-molasses stage that he appreciated every time he slept like a log after smoking. Billy wasn’t much better off; his eyes were even more heavy lidded than usual and the contrast between the glassy red and blue of his eyes made Steve quickly overwhelmed with how many times he caught himself accidentally staring.

Billy was still sat Indian style, body language loose as he used one hand to prop himself up and one had to hold the joint. Once Steve got the right tape going, he went back down to the floor where Billy was currently hogging the weed.

“C’mon man, I gave it to you to start, not finish.” Steve said, wiggling his fingers for it.

Billy just brazenly laughed and handed it over, oblivious to what the sound of his laughter did to Steve’s gut. “Had to check for poison, pretty boy,”

Steve went bright red at the nickname and tried to distract himself by taking a long pull. It was still damp for where Billy had just put his mouth, and when Steve wrapped his lips around it, he acutely tried not to think about how he could qualify it as a secondhand kiss. He went even more red at that thought and tried to will it away so Billy wouldn’t think he was overheated or something. He was already a lightweight when it came to smoking with Billy.

The next song came on and Billy stiffened at the beginning synth beats. “Creedence Clearwater Revival?” He ground out like it was painful.

Steve narrowed his eyes, “Billy, you can’t honestly say you hate every song on my—”

“No,” Billy said forcefully. “No… I like it. Them."

He handed the joint back to Billy, watching how he suddenly took the hits like his life depended on it. Sometimes Billy reminded him of those little wooden string dolls; where you press the button at the bottom and they fall apart, but then the second you release it they’re back up and stiff like they never lost shape in the first place. Billy was obviously distressed right now, and it happened so quickly that Steve had to push past the slowness in his brain to actually talk to him.

“You kinda don’t seem like you like them,” He told Billy, “I can change the song if you want?” He didn’t know how Have You Ever Seen The Rain? could put someone from such a high to a rocky low.

But Billy shook his head. “Nah, it’s not that.” He took an extra-long drag from the joint.

Steve watched him, not moving to change the song on the stereo. This was one of those times where normally he would feel confident in asking what was wrong, but with Billy he could never be sure if that was a good move or a risky one. The weed had him feeling looser, and less connected to reality, though, and there was a false kind of bravery that Steve decided to try to tap into.

“So, what is it then?” He passed the joint back after taking another rip.

Billy’s eyes flicked up to him as he took the joint back, like he was testing the waters. He gave a shrug that was too casual to be genuine, and said in an even more unaffected voice, “My mom really liked them.”

“Oh yeah?” It was the first Steve had ever heard of Billy’s mom, and it felt like he had to grab this moment before it slipped through his hands, “I think my parents like them too. My mom’s a big music snob.”

Billy smiled. “Yeah. So was my mom. She was into rock n'roll, especially the old psychedelic stuff, but she really liked CCR. Said they reminded her of back home. There was always this one song that mentioned a snow cone flavor they had back in Lousiana.”

“She's from Louisiana?”

“Yeah. The band actually wasn't from there, but she always said they just made her remember home. I think she moved to California when she was eighteen. Just packed up a van and traveled the state, living like a total hippie.” He was looking off into the distance, like he could see the memory right there in Steve’s room.

He sent a furtive glance his way, and Steve smiled encouragingly. It made Billy relax a little, when he realized that Steve wasn’t gonna rush him or bombard him with his usual lack of brain-to-mouth filter. Billy took another deep hit, closing his eyes in the process.

When he opened them again, they were hazier than before. Steve wondered whether that was the weed or the subject. Billy startled him by talking again, unprompted. “I got my curly blond hair from her. Hers was like a lion's mane, though.”

It looked painful getting those words out. Billy wasn’t looking at a corner in the room anymore, instead just hanging his head to look at his crossed ankles. He picked at a loose string in the carpet.

Steve tracked the movement with his eyes, wondering what could be the right thing to say. It was a titular moment, one that he could ruin if he said the wrong thing. Of course, he did, anyway, even though he tried hard not to.

“Where is she now?”

Billy shrugged and stopped picking at the carpet. “Who the fuck knows. She ran off when I was ten.”

The mood in the room was dark. Steve didn’t know what he had been expecting, seeing as Susan was Billy’s stepmother and his real mother had never been mentioned up to this point, but it wasn’t that. “You know why?” he couldn’t help but ask.

This time when Billy took a hit, it was a long one that ended the rest of the cherrying paper. He exhaled a huge plume of smoke, and before Steve could fully blink it out of his eyes, Billy was already starting to roll another joint. His fingers were trembling. Steve gently took the paper and grinder from him, surprised when Billy let the items go from his grasp without any fight. Where their fingers had touched there had been only warmth, and Steve thanked whatever God that was out there that Billy was probably too high to notice his constant blush.

While Steve was rolling, Billy answered his question. “My dad. She couldn’t stand him after a while. I don’t blame her.”

Steve snuck a glance up at Billy, noting the hard tone in his voice. Billy still wasn’t looking at him though, just back to staring at a random corner of the room. This time his face had lost that easygoing expression, and in place was a heavy furrow in his brow.

“You and your dad don’t get along?” He asked, trying to get a good mental picture. He didn’t know much about Billy’s dad, but from the tiny bit Max had divulged about him in the car it didn’t seem like there was a lot of love lost between him and Billy. Which, knowing Billy, made sense seeing as he had an issue with about every authority figure Steve had seen him come into contact with.

The most confusing part, though, was why Billy’s mom would just up and leave, especially without him. Steve knew his parent’s marriage wasn’t perfect by any means, but there was no level of animosity between them that ever had his mom contemplating just dumping everything and leaving. And if she did, Steve knew there would have been probably a long-winded custody battle to see who he would live with.

He handed the new joint back to Billy, a little wary for them to still keep smoking after they had done it pretty much all day, but it seemed like the only way to get Billy to open up.

Billy started it off again, doing his usual routine of taking about three hits too many in the process. Steve let him have it though, under the expectation that Billy would be more cooperative if he was high.

And he was. “Yeah, we don’t really get along.” Like he wasn’t even thinking about it, Billy lightly scratched one of his splints with his thumb. When he caught Steve’s eyes tracking the movement, he shook himself out of it and passed the joint.

Steve took it, taking a long hit to rival Billy’s as he thought of what to say next. Billy beat him to the punch with his own question, though.

“What about you?” He nodded at Steve’s bedroom door. “I’m pretty sure I’ve never seen your parents here.”

He gave a low laugh, once again letting the weed loosen up his tongue more than he usually would. “Yeah. Probably not. They’re always gone, so.”

Billy raised his eyebrows. “Gee. Don’t sound so happy about it. I’d kill to have no parental supervision, no one always looking over your shoulder to make sure you’re being responsible.” He spat the last word out like it was a curse.

Steve shrugged. He hated explaining it, overly aware that he sounded like the average rich-kid complaining about problems that no one ever had. “Yeah, it just kind of gets lonely when it’s constantly me just alone up here.”

“Why are they always gone?”

“Work, trips, couples’ retreats, whatever excuse buys them a couple more months away.”

It surprised him how bitter he sounded saying that. He always knew that he resented them for leaving him up to his own devices all the time, but it wasn’t something he usually shared with the rest of the class.

Billy just smoked, staring at him. Steve felt like fidgeting but knew that would be a dead giveaway. He finally passed the joint back over, and Steve took barely a puff of it before he was exhaling. He felt like he needed to take a break from the hits, because all the smoke was getting to his head and making him say colossally dumb things.

He figured Billy would diffuse the tension by cracking something wise, probably about him being spoiled and ungrateful, but Billy surprised him instead by asking, “Is that why you have trouble sleeping? ‘Cause they’re never here?”

Steve blinked, taken aback. He’d never thought Billy had noticed. “How do you know I have trouble sleeping?”

Billy gave him a flat look. “Man, the bags under your eyes are purple on a good day.”

He almost felt them self-consciously, but at the last minute let his hand fall back down. Billy was waiting for him to answer his first question. “No. Well, I guess it doesn’t really help, but it’s not the main reason why.”

Once he said it out loud, he realized how true it really was. Yeah, the Upside Down was the main cause of his insomnia, but for years he had been operating under the false kind of bravado that came with having to be alone for most of the year. The truth was: it did bother him that he was always alone. Always having to be self-reliant. The neat, wonder stage had kinda been left after the second trip where his parents were gone for over a month. Like suddenly realizing it wasn’t as fun anymore, but there was nothing he could do about it now. And sure, he was supposed to be able to fend for himself, being a senior in high school, but he’d never really gotten the chance to not be fending for himself at any moment. Sometimes the idea of having helicopter parents was too good to not fantasize about.

“So why then?”

Billy tore him out of his stupor. Steve could only confusedly ask, “What?”

He was met with another flat stare, this one meaning that he needed to get his head back in the conversation. “Why you have trouble sleeping, hello.”

Steve winced, not really sure how to say it without, you know, saying it. Sometimes he wished so intensely that he could tell Billy what happened that night, sometimes because he kind of felt like he owed him that, and other times because he just genuinely wanted to have Billy in on it. It wasn’t just his secret to tell, though, and without outright permission from the Party there was no way he could back out on that trust.

Not only that, but it wasn’t like this was exactly a common problem amongst people their age. Sure, most people had sleeping problems, but Steve should be on the opposite end of the spectrum; where like every teenage boy he would sleep in excess rather than the spare hours he had been catching whenever he finally succumbed.

Billy read his expression and rolled his eyes before lightly nudging the joint his way. “C’mon, it’s not like it super crazy,” he said, almost reading Steve’s mind, “I have trouble sleeping too.”

Which, that was probably as obvious as it was for Steve. That first day after the break, when Steve had first seen Billy in math class, that was one of the first things he’d noticed. The way that Billy also had those dark circles around his eyes, the way he was no longer the life of the room anymore, but rather just taking up space. There was a difference between being just plain tired and being exhausted. Steve knew both him and Billy fell into the latter category.

“Why do you have trouble sleeping?”

Billy narrowed his eyes. “Nuh uh. You first.”

He dithered for a moment, running a hand through his hair. “It’s… complicated.” At Billy’s disbelieving look, he rushed to continue, “No, seriously. It is. I guess the easy version would be… paranoia? I guess.” Mulling over getting hunted and brutally torn apart by mythical creatures definitely inspired a fair degree of paranoia.

“How?” He couldn’t even blame Billy for asking.

“I dunno,” he tried to search for something to give Billy that would be substantial enough, while also staying between the lines of his boundaries, “Just listening to everything go bump in the night.”

He finally took another hit and passed it to Billy, who seemed to be deeply evaluating what Steve was saying. He thought he’d see an air of suspicion, or some kind of weirded out expression, but instead it just seemed like Billy was lost in thought trying to sift through Steve’s meaning. He didn’t know which one he would have preferred.

“So then what about you?” Steve found himself asking, eager to switch the hot seat, “What keeps you up?”

Billy gave a dark chuckle and took a long hit. Finally, he blew a large cloud of smoke out before turning back to Steve. “Also listening to things go bump in the night.”

Steve, who felt like Billy had mocked him for laying everything out, was offended. Usually, Billy was better at the game than this. “Never mind, man, I— “

“No. I-I’m not joking.” Billy looked earnest in his refusal, which at least loosened Steve back up a little bit, “I just meant it in a different way.”

“What way?”

“Well, what way were you talking about?”

Another question answered with a question. So typical for Billy, Steve wondered why he even tried anymore. He told him so. “God, Billy, it’s like I’m pulling your teeth out with rusty pliers.”

Billy did that weird facial expression again, the cowed one that sat so wrongly on his face. Once again, Steve had felt like he’d made a misstep in the conversation and was quick to try to reverse what he’d just said. “Hey, I didn’t mean—”

“Nah. It’s okay,” Billy shook his head, his blond curls falling in place in front of his eyes. Steve felt suddenly exposed with his own hair all pushed back and his face out on complete display.

“You’re right. It’s just… hard for me to, ‘ya know. Talk sometimes.” Billy was staring off into that middle distance again, unreachable wherever his mind was. “Not just talk, I mean. But to actually say what’s goin’ on. I mean,” he shook his head balefully, another gesture that didn’t suit him right at all, “I know I’m a shitty friend.”

Steve’s glare counteracted what he said next. “You’re not a shitty friend. Trust me, I’ve had shitty friends.”

Billy still didn’t look convinced. Steve wasn’t finished, though, “Yeah, okay, it’s kind of hard to get stuff out of you sometimes, but I know it’s because you can’t… like. Help it.”

“Shouldn’t that tell you something?” Billy asked drily, “Like, shouldn’t that be a clue that I’m probably a shitty friend to have?”

“No! Just means…” He tried to search for an explanation that didn’t sound like it’d come from the seat of his pants. When that didn’t work, he switched gears, “Listen, I have stuff I can’t talk about either. Doesn’t mean that I’m a shitty friend.”

He watched Billy’s face closely, looking for any signs of disagreement or maybe surprise on Billy’s own expression at Steve’s confident assertion that he was a good friend. A good friend of Billy’s. There was no protest, and Steve felt a little triumphant over at least achieving that.

Steve tried to switch the gears of the conversation a little bit, too discomfited by how it was starting to lean towards his own secrets; he didn’t doubt that Billy had issues, but he was sure they weren’t Upside Down level, or even having a major crush on your bully turned best friend level. When he was like this there was no telling what his big mouth what let loose, and he didn’t want to disrupt the easy peace they had maintained since Billy came back to school pretending that nothing was wrong at all.

He took the shortening joint and stubbed out the rest into the ashtray, aware now that any weed they smoked was a waste since they both were already majorly stoned. Billy was usually able to hide it well, but his eyes were always a dead giveaway. Right now, they were lidded and glassy and made Steve have those butterflies again in his stomach, so he tried to avoid looking at him head on.

It was fruitless to try to avoid him, because Billy commanded Steve’s full attention with what he asked next. “Why are you friends with me anyway, Harrington?”

“Is your sunny disposition not enough?”

Billy slugged him in the shoulder. “Wrong answer. You don’t even have a sunny disposition.”

“Okay, okay,” he laughed, summoning up the courage to go through with this, “You’re not so bad when you’re not doing your whole ‘Steve bad, must punch’ bit, plus you’re funnier than Tommy ever was.”

“Pssh.” Billy waved a hand. “As if that’s hard.”

“No, but,” Steve was unable to stop himself, like the floodgates were open the second there was an available space for him to compliment Billy without getting in trouble, “I mean, you could’ve been a dick to me over the tutoring stuff, but you weren’t.”

He paused, feeling a little shy now. For a second, Billy looked so hungry, like he was devouring every word. The look was gone in a second, though, and Steve could only swallow. He tried to rearrange his brain, tried to get it back with the program instead of focusing on Billy’s face. It was hard, though, when Billy was so close and was watching Steve’s own face with an uninterrupted stare.

Steve took the plunge. It was doomed to happen anyway, with the expectant expression Billy wore on his face while staring him down. “You’re a good person, Billy. I know you may not think that, but I do.”

Billy looked away. It was only a shift of the eyes, but Steve could feel the distance Billy was trying to put between them. “A good person wouldn’t do what I do.”

“I know you apologized to Lucas,” he blurted, unable to keep it to himself when Billy looked so self-deprecating, “And you apologized to me, too. I know you’ve been getting along better with Max lately. Just ‘cause you still fight sometimes doesn’t mean you’re a bad person.”

All Billy did was fold his hands over his eyes. Steve was pretty sure he’d never seen him do that gesture and was so unsettled by it he rushed to try to remedy the situation as best as he could. “I wasn’t-I didn’t mean to—”

“No, it’s okay.” Billy said, still behind his fingers, taking in deep breaths. “I know what you mean.”

He finally looked up, and his face showed next to nothing, except for some lingering puffiness. His eyes were still red and glassy, and Steve wondered how much of it was actually the weed and how much of it was because Billy was upset.

Steve was still worried, though, and knew it was written all over his face. Billy huffed out another breath and did a show of rolling his eyes. It was supposed to mollify him, but instead it just made Steve all the more aware of how easy it was for Billy to just brush his problems away. Steve could recognize it because he was guilty of also doing the same. It was just weird watching from the outside, knowing that Billy seemed to be so well versed in it. It was one of those things that he figured was a piece of the puzzle that was unraveling Billy Hargrove, but Steve had no clue where it sat. What it meant.

“Calm down, Steve,” Billy said, unaware of how the switch to Steve’s first name gave him a head rush, just like it did every other time, “The weed’s making me moody. And tired.”

“You could spend the night,” Steve offered without thinking of how eager it made him sound.

Billy paused, looking unsure. “They come back tomorrow. I gotta make sure the house is clean before he comes in.”

“Well, you don’t have to stay all day,” Steve said, even though that’s exactly what he wanted him to do, “You could just dip in the morning. I’m sure they won’t be back before 10 a.m., right?”

“Yeah, I guess so. If you really don’t care.”

“I wouldn’t have offered if I did.” Steve said, trying to go for a casual tone, as if he wasn’t overthinking every word that came out of his mouth. “Besides, I don’t think even you would be able to drive with how much we smoked. I’m not trying to see your Camaro wrapped around some tree on the morning news.”

Billy rolled his eyes again, and finally stood up from his position on the floor. He gave a big stretch, one that was good enough to produce a couple of cracks, and Steve nearly choked at the sight of Billy’s dark blonde happy trail underneath his navel. Steve averted his eyes so he wouldn’t be caught staring.

He put the ashtray with the old joints still in it on his desk. He stretched his own limbs, pulling his hands over his head as he waited for his own satisfying pop. When he finally got it, he lowered his arms and shifted back to face Billy. When he was fully turned, he barely caught sight of Billy’s red face and him turning away, like he was caught with his hand in the cookie jar. There was a weird energy in the air that Steve didn’t feel like naming, afraid that it would make everything turn awkward. He occupied himself with setting up the bed, hyperaware of every movement and breath.

When he got a couple of extra blankets and threw them on the bed, he heard Billy make a choking noise behind him.

“You wanna share a bed?”

His face went hot. “Oh-I mean, I know you’ve slept on the couch the other times, but I figured that was uncomfortable.” The argument sounded weak to even his own ears. Was it so obviously written on his face as well that he wanted to sleep next to Billy? He searched for an out on his embarrassing offer, “I can just move to the—”

“No, it’s okay.” Billy cut him off. His own face was flushed, and Steve wondered if he had felt the sudden overwhelming heat in the room, too. “We can share.”

“Oh, okay, cool.” Steve’s voice had taken a higher pitch he didn’t recognize. “Okay, I’ll just…” he let himself trail off, deciding to pretend to keep getting the bed ready before he made an even bigger fool of himself.

Billy didn’t ask for any pajamas, and Steve worried he would have a stroke if he saw Billy changing into one of his own sweatpants. Instead, Steve made a show of picking up the last of his room, hoping that would be a natural enough opening for Billy to crawl into bed. Steve’s bed. Which was about to have Billy in it. The thought was dizzying. His brain felt like it was going to short out at any moment.

He skipped out on turning on his sleep machine. It was partly because he was still pretty stoned and knew it wouldn’t be that difficult to fall asleep that night. However, the main reason was because he felt… embarrassed, for lack of better word. Billy had talked so much about swimming, about the ocean tides crashing, and a part of Steve was afraid he would get caught out on his massive crush if Billy found out he listened to his own fake ocean every night. Realistically, he knew Billy probably wouldn’t think twice of it or even care, but the possibility was enough to have Steve be extra cautious.

When he was done tidying up the place, or at least pretending to, he turned the light off and chose to stumble through the darkness to his bed. He could’ve turned on the bedside lamp for help, but he was afraid that seeing Billy just lying in bed like he was waiting for him would be too much. He slid down the covers and quilts with a racing heart and shaking fingers. The sheets beneath were cool, but they couldn’t disguise the fact of a warm body right next to him.

Steve laid completely still on his back at first. He was trying his hardest to keep his breathing normal, and not erratic like his pulse. He was stiff as a board, all too aware of Billy just inches away. If Steve were to reach out his hand just a little bit, he’d be touching Billy’s arm. The insane urge to make a move was so disarming that it took nearly all of his self-control not to roll over and do just that.

Billy’s own breaths sounded even, and Steve wondered if he was having just as hard of a time or if he was actually asleep. In the pitch black of the room, Billy felt both nearer and farther than he had ever been.

He desperately wanted to say something: a comment on the obvious palpable tension between them, a question about last Saturday night, or maybe even the insanity of telling Billy something secret, like the Upside Down. The air felt so charged and electric, he almost felt certain Billy would be truthful. But every prospect just made his head thrum, and it all came down to his irrational fear of Billy somehow cluing in and finding out about his crush.

After a couple minutes of deep breathing, he was finally able to calm down and actually feel drowsy. Closing his eyes felt good, soothed the heat that had been burning behind them from the weed. Even though he had felt on edge at first, Billy’s presence next to him somehow soothed him, like the safe point of a lighthouse in the eye of a storm. It wasn’t long until he drifted off.

That’s where it went all wrong. His easy peace and slumber didn’t last long, and before he knew it, it felt like he was suffocating in the dream, breathing in the poisoned air of those tunnels, with only the sound of his thundering pulse in his ears. His limbs felt like lead, slow and too heavy to move as he tried to escape the demodogs he could see at the end of the long hall of darkness. He furiously fought over and over again to just move, hearing the kids behind him urgently chant his name again and again.

When Steve finally woke up, the blankets were kicked onto the ground, and he had sweated through almost his entire shirt. His throat felt scratchy, like he had been screaming for a bit, and his heart felt like it was about to painfully burst out of his chest. His head was spinning, and he was distantly made aware of the fact that Billy was tightly holding his arm and had probably been the one who was saying Steve’s name. For a couple of minutes, he felt like he was underwater, everything seeming muffled, and he was trying to break the surface but unable to. Billy’s grounding hand on his arm made Steve feel real again, and he went from being lost in his nightmare to gradually becoming aware of each of Billy’s fingers coiled tightly around his bicep.

He tried to say something, maybe a fruitless I’m sorry for presumably waking Billy up screaming, but all he could get out was a measly croak. He felt Billy’s other hand tentatively land on his back before he started rubbing it; smooth circles that helped him get rid of the last tendrils of fear.

“Shhh, you’re okay, it’s okay,” Billy’s voice sounded softer than it ever had, and Steve desolately mourned that he had offered for them to share the bed in the first place. What was he thinking? He was lucky Billy was being so kind. He couldn’t hear any anger or judgement in Billy’s tone, only that unfamiliar softness.

The hand smoothly rubbing his back was the last shred holding his terror, and after a couple minutes he was able to get in some breaths without feeling like he was going to hyperventilate. Billy’s grip on his arm had lessened but was still firm enough to keep Steve grounded to reality. The other hand stayed rubbing his back until it wasn’t heaving anymore, and Steve was starting to gain awareness of his surroundings. Namely, Billy in bed next to him, comforting him for the past ten minutes or so as he got over the shakes in the aftermath of his dream.

He cleared his throat, feeling like this time it would work. “Fuck, I’m so sorry,” he ground out, hating the way his voice cracked toward the end.

Coming down from the adrenaline rush his nightmare had given him made him feel wretched, deeply ashamed that the one night he slept next to Billy he had to go and ruin it by having a crazy episode. He buried his face in his hands, unable to even stomach the thought of looking in Billy’s direction. Seeing his face would make the whole thing more real; it was easy to discount his intense night terrors when there was no one else around to witness his screaming and thrashing. Steve wasn’t sure what his parents would even do if they heard him screaming bloody murder in the middle of the night. A quick glance to the digital clock on his nightstand said that the time was 3:32 a.m. It had been just past midnight when they had gone to bed, so it was no surprise to find out he had slept his usual three hours, before doing his usual wake up routine of leftover panic and residual terror.

He was still shaking a little, and with his face in his hands he could feel the tremors still going through him. That combined with the overall memory of the shitty nightmare, and Billy’s continued rubbing of his back like nothing was wrong, and before he knew it Steve could feel warm tears in the palm of his hand.

“Hey, Steve, it’s okay, you’re alright,” Billy’s voice barely cut through his own self-flagellation, and Steve hadn’t even noticed his shoulders were shaking until Billy had both hands wrapped around them, rubbing his thumbs over the knobby bones. The acknowledgment of his freak out was enough to have him almost go down another tailspin, but Billy seemed to sense it and just held on tighter.

He tried saying something else to Billy but knew he would probably only be able to blubber it out, and quit after a few shaky breaths. He kept his face still hidden, though, afraid that if he looked it would break the moment. The fact was, it felt good to have another person there to keep him tethered to his body rather than intrusive thoughts, and even though he was deeply humiliated that Billy had to be disturbed in the process, he was still grateful of his presence. The weight and pressure of Billy’s hands on his shoulders made him feel like he was back in the real world again, not trapped in those seemingly endless tunnels.

One hand gently pried one of Steve’s own away from his face. He fought it a bit at first, but after a couple of seconds of gentle tugging, he finally gave in and removed it. He still didn’t say anything and didn’t look Billy’s way at all.

Billy leaned forward until he was in Steve’s eyeline. The room was still thankfully dark, but there was enough of the light from the window to make Billy’s face seen. The darkness helped take away from some of the intensity, but Steve still gave an involuntary shudder at the fervent look in his eye. Their hands stayed clasped, and Steve was almost shocked at how warm Billy’s was in comparison. Under normal circumstances he’d probably already be flaming red from the gesture, but he could only feel tender relief at finally having someone there to comfort him.

He wanted to say something else, not that he really had any clue where to start, but he wanted to at least explain something. Billy tugged him back to a laying position with both hands before he could start to think. Steve went with it easily, too overtaken with the sensation of Billy honest-to-God tucking him in, adjusting the pillows by his head and all, before putting a steadying hand on his chest.

“You’re good, Steve, just go back to sleep,” Billy’s voice was like warm velvet.

In the darkness it was easy to agree, easy to let his eyes slip shut when he felt the warm weight of Billy’s hand holding him there. Not pressing down but keeping him secure. It was only a couple seconds later when he felt Billy slide back in right next to him, and the bare skin of their arms brushed as Billy got settled in. This time, when they were both lying there, there were no inches between them. Instead, Steve was affected by the zing of Billy’s warm skin against his own.

Billy kept his own breathing measured, and Steve found himself unconsciously mirroring the breathing pattern. Within moments he was falling back asleep, impossibly, but what seemed more far-fetched was the sensation right before he dropped off; the light touch of one of Billy’s fingers against his own.

~

Billy being gone before he woke up usually wouldn’t make him go into a panic attack but considering the fact that the night before he had had to hold and comfort Steve after a nightmare, he figured he probably had a little bit of a right to be scared.

Last night was like a dream within itself, and when Steve woke up, he was momentarily confused. For a second he had completely forgot Billy had spent the night, until he glanced at the burnt joints in the ashtray. Then, everything came flooding back to him, piece by excruciating piece. Not only had Steve embarrassed himself before the nightmare by idiotically suggesting they share the same bed, but then he had to go and ruin that by having another garden-variety nightmare. He couldn’t imagine what Billy thought, sleeping one moment and then being woken up by someone screaming like a banshee right next to you.

And then Billy had literally held him, rubbing his back like Steve was back in the third grade. He might as well have been, with the way he was acting last night. Crying in front of Billy? In what world was that okay? Steve had never even cried in front of Nancy, and there were plenty opportunities to do so.

No wonder Billy had pulled his usual disappearing act in the morning. Steve didn’t blame him. God, how could he be so pathetic? There he was, hours before, trying to come up with an excuse for not being able to sleep, playing it off like it was just something normal. Only to prove himself wrong by having a colossal fuck up of an episode. Billy probably thought he was a certified nutcase now.

The intimate memory of the way Billy’s hands had felt on him afterwards had Steve shivering in place, remembering the steadying feeling that made his head spin at the same time. Steve had slept an additional four hours, like he was feeling that phantom hand holding his chest down steady. The hazy recollection of whether or not their fingers had really touched as Steve had finally drifted off. It made his cheeks go pink, and he wondered if he had succeeded in not only thoroughly embarrassing himself last night, but also exposing a deep part of his secret heart.

Wednesday felt like a blur compared to every day previous, where he and Billy had spent most of the hours together just hanging out and being carefree. The entire morning was spent in a nauseated daze, wondering how he could fuck up something so quickly while also ruminating on how much he had possibly fucked it all up. He knew Billy’s family came back today, so abjectly he knew that Billy would be otherwise occupied, but when it became nightfall and he hadn’t heard a single thing his anxiety kicked into overdrive.

Dustin ended up calling later that night, and they went out to eat at Sally’s where Steve pretended like his mind wasn’t on the past 24 hours and nothing else, and when he dropped Dustin off at his house later on all he felt was restless. The deep sleep he had gotten after his nightmare made him uncomfortably awake longer than he was used to. He ended up cruising the streets later that night, wishing against it all that Billy would maybe be out and driving, but only ended up driving in circles by himself. He pulled through Billy’s neighborhood at one point, confident enough that in the darkness no one would be able to see his car. Billy’s Camaro was parked there, and Steve hadn’t really expected any different.

The next day was much of the same. Steve caught a fretful hour and a half of sleep before jerking awake with the usual thundering pulse, and he was too wired after that to attempt sleep again. He obsessively cleaned his room and the rest of the house, and when that was over with, he cleaned the pool. The phone never rang, there was no pebbles thrown against his window, and there never came that roaring of the Camaro’s engine down the street that Steve had gotten so used to.

It was like he was back at square one, radio silence between them while Steve was just supposed to sit there, helpless. Only, this time it was all because of him. He hated that all it took was Billy disappearing to make him turn into a crazy person again, but even as he thought it, he was unable to stop the way his mind kept working in overdrive trying to figure out what to do next.

The more he kept turning it over in his mind, the more he kept getting irritated. Yeah, okay, maybe he had been a total geek and embarrassed himself, but who was Billy to judge? After Steve had patched him up last Saturday night? He had called his elderly retired neighbor over so Billy could get an impromptu physical, for crying out loud, the least the other boy could do was ignore Steve’s own issues and give him the same courtesy. Ditching him for two days because of a nightmare? Was Steve stupid to think they were much better friends than they were? Answer was probably yes. It hurt so much to admit, but it was yes.

Thursday night had Steve feeling especially crazed, only getting about another two hours of sleep since Wednesday, and had him quick to doing something crazy, like stopping by Billy’s house and demanding to speak to him. He only just barely stopped himself, something at the back of his mind telling him that it wouldn’t be good to go through with. So, he settled for the next best: calling him.

After November, Steve had demanded each of the Party give him their home phone numbers, and parents work numbers, just in case. God knew he would probably be getting into further hi-jinks with the kids, and he always wanted to make sure he was never left high and dry again. Max had given him the home phone and her moms number, with strict instructions not to call if absolutely necessary, Steve remembered it because it was a direct contrast to how Dustin had acted, telling Steve to call any time.

Steve put Max’s warning away at the back of his mind and dialed the number. It was only 7:15, and he knew that there would have to be someone awake in the house, and if Billy wasn’t there at least he knew his message would be passed. Steve didn’t even know what his message would be, and it was only when he heard the phone start ringing on the other end that he realized he probably had to come up with something good.

It answered after two rings. “Hello?” asked a gruff voice. It sounded too deep to be Billy, so it must have been his dad.

“Hi there!” he tried to make his voice sound agreeable, the generic tone he took whenever his parents randomly dragged him to their fancy business dinners. “I was wondering if Billy was home?”

“He is, but we’re having dinner right now.”

Billy’s dad sounded nothing like Billy. Where Billy usually always had an easy tone to compliment his own smoky voice, his dad sounded completely the opposite with the tense way he spoke. There wasn’t an inch of wiggle room there, and even though he was miles away and over the phone, Steve still got the sensation that he was being heavily watched. “Oh, so…” he trailed off, unsure.

“So, he’s not available to talk. May I ask who’s calling?”

“Uh…” He stammered, not knowing why but feeling like giving his name up was the wrong move. “Just a buddy from math class. Was wondering if we had homework.”

“Over the break?”

Steve inwardly cursed. Usually, he was a little bit better than this, but Mr. Hargrove had him tripping over his words, feeling nervous for some reason. “Yeah, um, just trying to make sure. Don’t want my grade to drop or anything.” He forced a laugh. It sounded brittle and fake to even his own ears.

“You’d think someone who cared about their grades so much wouldn’t be waiting until Thursday night to verify homework, but maybe that’s just me.”

Steve’s heart raced. Fuck, this was such a bad idea. Billy’s dad sounded like a real hardass, and here Steve was, just fumbling his way through the conversation. He had to cut it short or else endure further humiliation.

“You know what, now that I think about it, we did have homework,” He blathered into the receiver, aware that his voice had gone to a nervous high pitch. “I’ll just go ahead and. Do that then.”

He hung up before Billy’s dad could say another word and was immediately grateful that he had followed his instinct of not giving a name. Not that he thought Billy’s dad would track him down or anything, but he had certainly sounded way more hostile over the phone than he should have, considering it was just a casual phone call. His heart was still racing after he hung up. Steve couldn’t help but feel like that was exactly the opposite of the smart thing to do, like he had made a colossal fuck up.

He justified it in his mind by reasoning that he wouldn’t have to resort to desperate measures if it weren’t for Billy dropping off the face of the Earth, but it still didn’t sit right in his mind. Part of him was worried that it might somehow affect Billy, his stupid phone call. It seemed like Billy and his dad butted heads about a lot of things, and Steve worried that he may have somehow given Mr. Hargrove even more ammunition.

He tried to imagine what kind of punishments Billy usually got with his dad. Steve’s dad was so detached there were basically no repercussions for him to ever think about, being grounded over the phone really lost its severity when the person doing the grounding couldn’t even enforce it. Maybe Billy had already been grounded, and that was why he was staying away again. It seemed like Billy was always on the precipice of getting in trouble with his dad.

Max had said that they didn’t get along, in fact she had almost scoffed when Steve had first suggested she go to Mr. Hargrove to check in on Billy. The more Steve kept thinking about it the more he became convinced that he had made the complete wrong decision.

He hung the phone up into the socket on the wall roughly, not even caring when the curly wire got tangled underneath. He stomped upstairs and pretended that he wasn’t actually brooding and tried to occupy his time by moving all the furniture around in his room. That lasted about five seconds until he saw the ashtray and was reminded of a different way to pass the time.

There were no more rolling papers left, and all he had was his own weed, but Steve was desperate enough to make it work. He dug the glass piece out of the shoebox under his bed and went to set about smoking the last of his weed. He resisted the strong urge to kick something, maybe throw something at the wall. All he’d have to show for it would be a mess to clean up, and he was sick of cleaning up messes.

The weed at least did the job of taking his mind off things, and before he knew it, he was sprawled on his bed, lighting the bowl and watching the ceiling fan lazily rotate above him. It was almost relaxing enough to fall asleep to, and he was just reaching over to put his pipe on the nightstand to hopefully speed up the process of getting his usual three hours of sleep, when the doorbell rang.

He looked to the clock. It was 10:30. The doorbell rang again, this time more forcefully. Steve got up, looked outside his window, and didn’t see anything. No other car in the driveway. The doorbell rang again.

Steve stumbled to get into action, mind coming up with a million possibilities of what it could be, picturing Dustin at the door holding another fucking dead cat, maybe El with a bloody nose, for one hysterical moment he even pictured Mr. Hargrove there to finish their abruptly ended conversation. He snagged the nail bat just in case.

He rushed down the stairs, hearing the doorbell go off again and again as if the person was just jabbing the button over and over. He gripped the bat tightly in one hand, and hesitantly opened the door in the other.

It was Billy. The bat nearly dropped out of his hands. Billy didn’t give him much time to recover, choosing instead to shoulder past Steve while he stayed hunched in on himself. There was what looked like a fresh bruise over his eye, not on the same side as the one from last time.

“Jesus Harrington, let me through. I was freezing my ass off out there.” His teeth were chattering, even though he was wearing his ridiculous leather jacket. He saw Billy glance down at the bat, before doing a double take and widening his eyes comically. “What the fuck is that for? You get a lot of break ins?”

Steve, who was shocked at the sight of Billy after two days of seemingly being frozen out by him, could only open and close his mouth like a fish. He tossed the bat to the side, and they both flinched at the dual sound of wood and metal hitting the floor. He didn’t know what to say.

Billy looked like he didn’t either. They both just stared at each other in the foyer, both unwilling and unsure to make the first move. Steve was almost convinced this was a hallucination, but even Billy’s California weed wasn’t that strong. Plus, there’d be no way to hallucinate the scent of Billy, the cologne that always seemed to trail after him no matter what. This close, Steve felt like it was fogging up the entryway.

“Uh,” is what he stupidly said after a moment. He shook his head immediately afterwards, trying to clear the cobwebs. He tried again. “What are you doing here?”

Billy just stood there, not saying anything. He scratched at his face a little, and Steve’s attention was drawn again to the new bruise blooming on his face. He wanted to ask about it but knew anything he said would just be a waste of breath. Billy was never forthcoming about those kinds of things.

“I called you,” he said, after a couple more minutes of silence.

“Yeah, I know.” Billy replied, still not looking at him. “You can’t do that.”

Steve narrowed his eyes, his hurt transforming to wrath at Billy’s placidity. “Okay, well sorry for trying to check in. Message received, loud and clear.” He went to walk past Billy, intending to leave him floundering in the hallway, but Billy caught his arm before he could pass him.

“Please, Steve,” It was both the way he looked when he said it and how he said it that had Steve stopping. Now Billy was looking right at him, and the look in his eyes combined with the fresh bruise on his face had Steve’s ire receding a little bit, taken aback at the almost desolate look on his face. “Can we talk? I didn’t mean it the way you were thinking.”

The tender tone and the tired look in his eyes were enough to convince Steve. He drew back a little, looked Billy over, before nodding his head. Without any further words, he went walking up the staircase to his room, and almost took a sigh of relief when he heard Billy’s soft footfalls behind him on the carpeted stairs.

The walk up to his room had Steve’s mind working in overdrive, and he could feel the sweat starting to bead at the top of his forehead and under his arms. Had Billy really avoided him because of Steve’s nightmare? Or had he avoided him because he could tell Steve was a queer and felt things for him? Billy was smarter than his own good, book smart and street smart. There was no telling how many subtle signs and hints that Steve hadn’t even realized he was dropping that Billy could’ve picked up on. His pulse picked up and he could feel it throbbing through his neck.

His room was still cloudy with smoke when he came back up, but Billy just waved it away without paying it any mind. When Steve silently offered the bowl, Billy just shook his head. Steve raised his eyebrows.

“Nah, I gotta focus on what I’m gonna say.” He said, choosing not to look in Steve’s direction again.

Things hadn’t been this awkward between them in a while. Steve had gotten so used to the easy camaraderie and banter that would fall between them usually that he was taken aback more so than usual. Just days ago, he and Billy had been splashing each other in the pool, eating pizza by the T.V. Could one bad night really change all of that? The desperation to fix it all had Steve being the first one to speak, no matter what Billy had said about telling him something.

“Listen, I’m really sorry about that night,” he rushed out. Billy’s face snapped back to him, and Steve could see the confusion written all over his expression. “I know I freaked you out, and I know it was weird after, but I swear I didn’t mean for it to happen.”

“What?” Billy was looking at him like he was crazy, now.

“My nightmare? The freak out afterwards? The way you...” he couldn’t even finish the sentence, afraid how red his face would get if he actually said held me like he was about to. His face already felt like it was a deep red, hot to the touch. He soldiered on though, determined to get it out, “I’m sorry. I know I made things weird. I really didn’t mean to.”

“How’d you think you made things weird?”

Steve shrugged, feeling more and more nervous by the second. He didn’t think Billy could really be this obtuse, which meant it was probably a test. Like if he got the answer wrong or lied Billy would be able to see a flashing neon sign over his head. “Because I… you know why it made things weird.”

“No. Just tell me why.” Billy looked so earnest, it was easy to believe for a second that he really didn’t know why, but then what other reason would he have for ditching Steve only after that night? Billy was better at reading social cues than Steve, and Steve knew his crush was probably seen from light-years away. Billy pretending he knew nothing about it just so he could shove it in Steve’s face later seemed too cruel, but it was also the only option Steve could see him doing. Friends or not, there was no way Billy Hargrove would take this calmly like he was pretending to.

Steve bristled. He was sick of feeling like he was always the butt of the joke, always left out of some grand scheme or idea because he wasn’t smart enough to keep up with the big dogs. Billy pretending to do so made his anger reach a new wrathful level. “Stop that. You know why.”

“I don’t Steve, I really don’t.” And now Billy was starting to look frustrated by Steve, which only served to boil his temper more. If Billy was going to make Steve say it, just for shits and giggles, he’d at least do it on his own terms.

“Because I like you, okay?!”

Immediate silence. So quiet, it was almost resounding. He regretted the words the instant they flew out of his mouth. Billy, who had been in the process of taking a step toward him, paused where he was. His eyes were wide, and his mouth was moving up and down incrementally, like he kept trying to say something but forgot before the words could leave his mouth. His expression was one of such utter shock, that Steve started doubting whether Billy really had been trying to trick him into admitting his crush. That was a horrible train of thought to go down, though, because once he did, he started regretting showing his cards so early.

Billy didn’t say anything, just stayed where he was. Staring at Steve with those wild eyes. Distantly, Steve realized by now Billy should have said something about the jig being up, maybe a snarky comment about how he always knew or something, but he just stayed silent. Steve was having trouble getting oxygen to his brain, and he felt his breaths start to come in shorter and shorter as the panic set in.

“I didn’t mean to, I swear,” he started rambling, knowing it was too late to take his previous statement back but at least trying to get any sort of damage control done, “And that night, I wasn’t trying to… I didn’t mean to—”

“Steve,” Billy cut him off, his voice far gentler than it should be in the moment. That almost scared Steve more than anger, because at least with anger he knew what to expect. Billy being calm didn’t seem to bode well.

“It just- I wasn’t ever gonna do anything, I just—”

“Steve, calm down, take a breath.” Billy’s hands flew to his arms and squeezed. Steve dutifully took in a big gulp of air, not that it really helped anything. He was too thrown off by the feeling of Billy willingly touching him after his confession.

“Billy, I—”

“No, let me talk for a second, okay?”

Steve nodded numbly, already preparing for the inevitable.

Billy let go of Steve’s arms, and ran a hand through his hair, looking like he was going to jump out of his skin. “God, you don’t do anything by halves, huh? Just straight up told me. Jesus, took away all my steam.”

Steve didn’t reply, too afraid that anything he said would break Billy’s calm and make him realize how disgusted he should be in Steve’s presence.

“Listen, Steve, you don’t have to keep tweaking, alright? You’re okay, I’m okay, we’re all okay in here.” He moved to sit down on the bed, and when he saw Steve still standing there, stock still, he gently tugged one of his arms down so he could join him. Steve numbly followed the movement, still anxious that at any moment Billy was going to turn on him.

When they were both sat on the bed, half turned toward each other but not really facing head on, Billy finally spoke up. “I like you too, ‘ya know.”

Steve opened his mouth, about to stupidly define the difference between the way he liked Billy and the way Billy like him, but Billy was already predicting it and shaking his head.

“I mean that way, too.” Billy went pink, the color tantalizingly dusting over his cheeks and the bridge of his nose. “I’ve actually liked you for a while now, so. You know. Not really front-page news.”

Steve’s mind was in shambles as he tried to process Billy’s statement. He still hadn’t gotten over his shock at not being immediately knocked to the ground following his confession, and now… what?

“You what?” Was all he could ask.

Billy rolled his eyes, the familiar gesture making the conversation shift toward a more normal feeling, rather than the Twilight Zone tone it had been in this entire time. “I said I liked you back. Don’t make me repeat it.”

“For a while now?” He asked, brain catching up with he past five minutes.

Billy gave him a quick glance, before shifting his eyes away. “Yes,” he got out.

There was a smile starting to slowly spread across Steve’s face. Billy looked embarrassed. He was almost fully flushed, now, and the uncomfortable way he held his body pointed toward Steve only served to endear him more to the other boy. Steve could hardly believe what Billy was saying. Billy liked him? For a while now?

“How long?” He couldn’t help but ask, unable to keep the satisfaction out of his voice.

Billy caught onto it immediately, though, and shoved Steve in the shoulder with little force. “Oh yeah, yuck it up, not like you didn’t just confess your own feelings not even five minutes ago.”

“Yeah, but five minutes ago I thought you were gonna kill me for telling you, so. Let me have my moment.”

“Fine. Since the first week.”

It took him a second to catch up. Then, when he did, “Wait what? You liked me before Tina’s party?”

“God, yes,” Billy groaned, like it was obvious. “Why else do you think I was always up in your grill, 24/7?”

“I don’t know!” The words burst out of him like a relieved form of glee. “You were literally knocking me down in gym!”

Billy grinned at him, looking a little sheepish. “Yeah, probably laid it on a bit too thick.”

They sat there, both grinning. Steve’s face felt so tight and happy he was half convinced he’d get smile lines from the past two minutes alone. To think that Billy liked him? All this time? Once he started thinking about it, it all started to kind of make sense. Steve had been used to guys challenging him before, but none of them had done it the way Billy had, with a singular focus of making sure Steve’s attention was always kept on them. When he looked back over, Billy was still looking a little bashful, and had that pink tinge still sitting on his face. Abruptly, he realized that they were sat closer than they had been before, with their knees knocking and hands dangerously close to each other. He glanced down at the centimeters of difference between his thumb and Billy’s and when he looked back up, he saw Billy was watching his face avidly.

Billy looked a little out of his depth, like he wasn’t sure what the next move was. That was fine. Steve was willing to take the plunge for the second time that night, emboldened by Billy’s returned feelings and the newfound nerve coursing through his veins. When he started to lean forward, he was close enough to feel the quick nervous puff of air Billy let out fan over his face. He was slow, giving Billy the time to back out if he wanted, but he stayed there. Waiting. He closed the distance.

The first brush of warm lips against his own had him sighing almost instantly. This close, Billy’s scent was concentrated, and that combined with the dizzying sensation of his soft lips on Steve had him feeling like he was being dropped on the deep end of the ocean. If it meant this, Steve was willing to drown.

Billy kissed like he did almost everything else: intensely. Steve had thought maybe he had some kind of leg up, since he had been the one to lean in first, but after a few tentative seconds of lip-locking Billy had taken the lead. He tasted like the Marlboro’s Steve knew he smoked every hour, and a little sweet too, like he had been sucking on some candy just hours ago. Steve opened his mouth easily, content to let Billy do whatever, still in disbelief that he was getting this at all.

They kiss like that, slow and easy, for a while. Steve spends the whole time tracing Billy’s lips, trying to commit it to memory. When Billy tries to deepen the kiss, Steve just lets it happen, too eager and excited to do much else. Distantly he can hear himself gasping a little, and he tries to rein it in by breathing through his nose. Billy is undeterred in his exploration of Steve’s mouth, making Steve’s head spin even more if it was possible. Kissing Billy in his dreams was never like this, it was close, but never like this. There’s nothing that compares to the actual reality of Billy’s lips on his, the way his tongue does that.

He feels one of Billy’s hands grip his waist, and the other comes up a couple seconds later to cup at his jaw. He moves with it, allowing Billy to tilt his head so he can open up just a little more, and this time when he sighs into his mouth Billy is there to swallow it. His own hands come to rest at Billy’s waist, and the feel of firmness instead of soft curves beneath his hands feels much better than it should. Billy’s thumb runs along his jawline, before moving up to cup his cheek. When he pulls away, Steve chases him for a second, undeterred by the way his eagerness is obvious.

They’re both panting afterwards, but don’t break eye contact. Steve searches for something on Billy’s face, maybe some sort of regret, and is relieved to see just pure bliss on it instead. When he gives a smile back, he feels Billy smooth his thumb over his bottom lip, where Steve knows it’s rubbed red and raw. “So.” He says after a minute, when it looks like Billy isn’t going to say anything yet.

Billy just grins back and laughs. “So.”

He looks so good like that, Steve can’t help but rub his own thumbs in the divots of Billy’s hipbones, unable to contain his glee. His cheeks still feel hot. Billy’s are red, too. He reaches up to cup one, the heat in Billy’s cheeks reaching up to his palm.

With that, though, draws his eyes to the other cheek, where the new bruise sits. In the hullaballoo of Steve losing the rest of his marbles and confessing his feelings, he had forgotten that it was even there. He reaches up to touch it with his other hand, but Billy’s face closes off and he flinches back before he can.

“Steve…” He grabs Steve’s wrist before he can bring it to his face. “Don’t.”

“Where’d you get this?” Steve asks softly, fighting Billy’s grip and cupping Billy’s face anyway. This time Billy lets him do it, and when his thumb lightly brushes over the swelling Billy only winces a little bit. The skin beneath feels tight and hot, too, like it’s fresh.

Billy doesn’t answer, but he doesn’t need to. The past couple seconds that he’s finally got oxygen back has Steve thinking back to the beginning of it all, when Billy came over to his house and said he needed to talk to him. “What did you wanna talk about? Was it this?” At this he swipes the thumb softly across the bruising again. This time Billy doesn’t flinch at all.

After a moment, Billy finally speaks. “I meant what I said earlier. You can’t call.”

It’s a slap in the face, seeing as they just made out on Steve’s bed not even five minutes ago. It’s so cold it has him reeling back, hands dropping from Billy’s face and feeling like a grade-A numpty for believing that anything was actually gonna come of this.

Billy sees it all, and grabs Steve’s hands in his own. “Not like how you think, Steve, not ‘cause of that.” He sounds desperate, pleading.

“Then how?” He hates how hurt his voice comes out, but can’t do anything to stop it. The back and forth has him spiraling.

“My dad. He- you just can’t risk stuff like that.”

“Oh. Yeah.” The sudden flood of memory had Billy’s dad floods him with a trepidation. The clipped, intimidating way he spoke over the phone. Steve can’t even imagine what he sounds like in person. “Sorry. I didn’t think it would be a big deal.”

“It shouldn’t be,” Billy looks miserable now, with both of Steve’s hands clutched between his. “But it’s… you gotta understand he’s…”

Billy doesn’t finish. His hands are starting to shake. Steve shifts their hands, so that he’s the one holding Billy’s fingers steady. It’s a 180 from the loose, lax demeanor they’d both had after the kiss. The palpable anxiety makes Steve’s teeth ache. He’s not sure why he feels so nervous all of a sudden, like his body knows something his mind doesn’t, and it hasn’t caught up yet.

“Billy?” he prompts gently. Billy doesn’t look up from where their hands are clasped.

“It’s him.” Is all he says tightly, like it’s painful to drag the words out.

“What?”

“Him. My dad.” Billy glances up at him for a second before averting his gaze again. His hands are trembling like crazy now. “The bruise. That night. The fights. It’s him.”

For a couple blissful seconds, Steve is confused. Then, it all starts to fall into place. Every word Max has said to him about Billy, every word out of Billy’s mouth about his dad, every stolen glance of a bruise or cut or split lip that he’s seen Billy tried to hide; all the moments wrapped up nice and neat with a tight little bow like a Christmas gift.

The realization has him nauseated instantly, afraid he’s about to be sick to his stomach and hurl all over the both of them. Billy’s hands in his own feel suffocating, and he has to push them away while he gets his bearings. Billy’s dad beats him, has been beating him this entire time, and Steve just ate up every excuse without a second thought. Billy’s obviously well versed in hiding this, but God, Steve had been with him for months now, how could he not realize?

He doesn’t realize he’s been hyperventilating until he feels Billy rubbing his back, hand on one of his knees. “Steve,” he pleads, but it comes out muffled like Steve has a pillow over his own head. He tries to get a couple breaths in, but it’s so hard for the first couple of seconds. How could he be so stupid? How could he think Billy got into fights that frequently, when he had never seen anyone else at school sporting the same injuries? Or the way he talked about his dad, like he was always afraid he was looming over his shoulder, how could Steve have just explained that away?

“Steve, please, look at me,” At Billy’s begging, Steve finally gets in the right mind to take a look at him. Billy looks concerned, like Steve’s the one who just admitted to being secretly abused instead of him. He grapples for Billy’s hands again, needed to security and stability of Billy’s warm hands beneath his own.

“I’m good,” he manages, impressed with how steady he’s able to make his voice. It still feels like he’s viewing it all form the outside though, his voice not registering as his own. “Just… gimme a sec.”

Billy gives him all the time he needs, just sits there with Steve’s hands between his own again and looking absolutely wrecked. It’s enough to spurn Steve back into acting normal, the way his hangdog expression sits on his face. It’s baleful enough that Steve feels stupid, having Billy comfort him when the real person suffering here was Billy.

“Billy,” he manages after a couple more seconds, “We have to tell someone.”

“What?” Billy tries to tug his hands out of Steve’s grip, but he keeps them firm. “No, no fucking way.”

“He can’t keep doing this, you can’t keep getting hurt,” his voice sounds more authoritative than how he feels, which is at least some blessing. “We have to tell Hopper, or someone.”

“The Chief of police? Of this small po-dunk town? You think that’s gonna stop my dad?” Billy lets out an ugly laugh. “You think if they couldn’t stop him in California, they’d stop him here?”

The mention of California has Steve’s mind going back to something Billy once said. About being in the hospital right before they came here. “Where you had to go to the hospital after he was done with you?”

Billy doesn’t answer. That’s answer enough.

“No, no fucking way,” he’s fuming now. “There’s no fucking way I’m letting you go back there. You can’t.”

“Hate to break it to you, pretty boy, but I kind of have to.” He hates how defeated Billy sounds, like he’s already given up on this part of his life. “He doesn’t even know I’m here right now; I’ll have to sneak back in later.”

“Billy, you can’t.” The image of Billy climbing in through his bedroom only to get found out and beaten by his dad runs through his mind, bright and vivid. It makes him sick to his stomach. Picturing Billy taking every hit, laying on the ground. That Saturday night his fingers were broken. The visual of the dark black and blue bruises on Billy’s torso had stuck in Steve’s mind still to this day. There’s no way he can just roll over and let Billy go home to that. “You have to—”

“Do what?” Billy asked. “Press charges? So he can drag my ass to court and bring up every mistake, every dumb thing I’ve done just to prove his point? He knows I beat your face in last year. That’d be one of the first things he’d testify, that I was violent and a harm to others.”

Steve flounders, unsure of what to say. Billy continues. “It’s not as simple as you think it is, Steve. My dad thinks he owns me. If he ever found out the truth, he’d bury me so deep I’d never be able to get out. Hell, that’s why he unloaded on me last time.”

He searches for a moment, trying to follow Billy’s train of thought. “Saturday?”

Billy nods. “He found a college acceptance letter in my desk. Took me down for thinking I was better than him, told me I’d never escape. S’why it was so bad.”

“Oh,” is all Steve says, thrown off by the first half of Billy’s statement. Obviously, Billy and him had talked before about plans after college, with Billy confusing all the gears in Steve’s head as he tried to explain what mechanical engineers did, but they hadn’t mentioned anything concrete. Steve knew Billy would be applying to California schools, knew Billy was thankful to be out of there, but never knew the full reason why. Now, the thought of Billy just up and leaving at the end of the summer puts a rotten taste in his mouth, and he shuts it away in favor of giving the support Billy needs right now. God knows Billy has more to worry about than Steve’s feelings getting hurt that he wants to get out of his abusive household.

“Yeah. So. Not happening.” Billy’s hands contrast the hard tone he’s using, with the way they’re rubbing soft circles back into Steve’s hands. It’s almost comforting, if his mind wasn’t on about a million depressing tangents. He doesn’t know how it turned back to Billy comforting him, rather than the other way around.

Billy must be able to tell he’s too lost in thought, because he ducks down until Steve catches his eyes again. “Steve, I’m okay. I can handle this. It’s not forever.”

It’s hardly a comforting thought. Steve doesn’t even want Billy to spend the rest of the week at the Hargrove house, let alone the months it’ll take until school is out. Billy goes on, “Besides, I got you now, right?”

The hesitance in his question bleeds through, and Steve rushes to remedy it. “Yes, of course you do Billy. I just- I just don’t know how I’m supposed to be okay with you going home to this every night.”

Billy shrugs a shoulder. It’s a casual gesture that has no place for the conversation topic at hand. But then, Billy’s always been able to play all the bad stuff off so well. “You just. Gotta.”

Steve sighs, unable to think of what to do or say next. Billy seems like he’s pretty clear on the subject matter, which is don’t mess with it. Steve, who’s never been able to not mess with it, is having a hard time coping right now.

He tries to think of anything comforting, anything at all reassuring to say, but it all feels flat and useless. Billy is still going home tonight. Billy will be beaten again, and next time Steve will know exactly who did it. All he ever kept asking Billy was who did this? but now he wishes he had never gotten the answer. Wishes that it wasn’t the answer.

Instead, he just says, “Stay the night. Here.”

Billy looks at him with that pitying look. “Steve, I—”

“Not the full night,” he agrees, though he wishes that Billy would really take him up on his offer. “I’ll drive you back before he even wakes up. You can sneak back in. But please, please, just stay here for a couple hours.”

He still looks hesitant. The look gives way when Steve tentatively reaches up to stroke his cheek again, and when Billy shivers and closes his eyes Steve knows he’s got his answer. “Okay,” he agrees softly.

This time when they crawl into bed, Steve doesn’t let a single centimeter of space sit between them. With more bravery than he really feels, he gathers Billy up in his arms until it feels like they’re completely intertwined, like they’re stitched to each other’s skin. It’s kind of a comforting thought, thinking about being able to have Billy with him always, there to make sure he never gets hurt again. It’s the kind of sappy thought that he usually tries to banish from his brain before it gets a mind of its own. Tonight, though, it’s all he thinks about, like the safety of his arms being enough to ward away all of Billy’ s own monsters, real and all.

Notes:

so that's it for chapter 4! what do you guys think? like i said before, steve is kind of an easier POV for me to write and hopefully i did him some justice! i should still be sticking to having one more chapter out, and then i might do an epilogue. we shall see lol. anyways, lmk what you think! im dying to hear the opinion on this chapter lol