Actions

Work Header

songbird

Chapter 2: Broken Wings

Notes:

In terms of updates - basically there may or may not be a Christmas chapter (there is), so I'm trying to space out the chapter updates evenly between now and then. This one's coming a little early, but there will be a new chapter every 6 days or so.

Thank you so much to everyone who commented!! I'm going to go and reply to everyone, but I'm really glad you guys liked it! It made my day reading all the excitement for this - these characters and this AU have kind of consumed by brain, so there will likely be even more fics after this. Stay tuned!

Hope you enjoy the update!

(Also, you can imagine Jack however you want of course, but I've been picturing him as a young Matthew Daddario, for reference)

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

 

It’s October 13, 1985. Columbus Day weekend. Mom and Neil decided to take a trip to Indianapolis to see Aunt Grace, leaving Max under Billy’s careful supervision. It’s Sunday, so they won’t be back till tomorrow.

Max doesn’t care about any of that, really, it’s just—Billy hasn’t left his room since Friday night, as far as she can tell. She knocked a few times but no answer. She tried to open his door anyway last night, but it wouldn’t budge, which means he’s lodged the desk chair under the handle (Neil took his lock away two weeks after they moved in).

It’s been three days and Billy’s door won’t open.

She thinks about calling someone, but The Party’s still uneasy about her since what happened in August, her last ghost trip. She’s tried to convince them it was a joke to limited success. Since she still won’t tell them the truth, they’re at a standstill. They talk to her at school (mostly Will and Dustin, who can’t seem to help it) but she hasn’t been invited to a movie night since.

She could call Chief Hopper, but she’s still mad at El, and besides, she doesn’t want to get the police involved. Billy would be so pissed if he really was fine, and if Neil found out, he’d be—not pleased.

She could call Will’s mom, who offered to help her whenever you need, sweetheart, but that seems like a lot, too. She doesn’t need help. She just—doesn’t know what to do.

It’s been three-hundred sixty-five days since the worst thing she’s ever done, and she’s just worried about what it could mean, that she hasn’t heard anything since Friday. That Billy hasn’t come out to eat or drink or yell at her, or even use the bathroom. She just—doesn’t like what that could mean.

She doesn’t want to worry, because Billy’s the worst. She wants to listen to Joni, to hear Jack say her name a million times on that dumb tape and just one last time in person, too. She wants to go back three-hundred and sixty-five days, slap a hand over that Max’s mouth, shake her until she can’t speak, and say shut up, shut up, you stupid asshole, you’ll ruin everything, like always.

But none of that’s really possible, so she does the only thing she can think of that is.

“Harrington residence,” says the voice on the other end when Max finally gets the number right. She thought she memorized it, but it took a few tries.

“Steve? It’s Max.”

“Max?” Steve is instantly alert. “Where are you? Is everything okay?”

“Oh. Yeah.” It’s not like she’s in trouble or anything. “I mean, I’m at home. Everything’s—fine." 

“Okay. Uh, Dustin’s not here right now?”

“That’s okay, I’m not—that’s not why I called.”

“Okay. What’s. . . going on, Max?”

“It’s—it’s dumb, never mind. I’m sorry I called—”

“Max—”

“Billy’s in his room,” she says in a rush before she really does hang up, because Billy’s going to be so mad when he finds out she told Steve about this. “He’s been in his room a really long time, like, days. Mom and Neil aren’t here, and I tried to open his door, but it’s locked, and I tried the window from the outside, but that’s locked too, and the shades are down, so I can’t see inside. It’s just, he hasn’t come out and—I don’t know what to do.”

There’s a long pause on the other line. Max twists the phone cord around her finger and waits for Steve to say it’s not his problem, that she should call Hopper, that she should just wait it out.

But then Steve says, “Okay. I’m coming over, okay? You said your—parents aren’t home?”

“Yeah. They won’t be back till tomorrow.”

“Okay. I’m coming, now, alright? Max?”

“Yeah?”

“It’s good you called, okay? I’ll be there soon. Everything’s going to be okay, Max.”

 

*** 

 

“Everything’s going to be okay, Max.”  

“What do you mean?”

There was something awful about how still Neil was, his hands flat on the kitchen island. His breaths were measured and even, like he was counting the seconds between them.

He didn’t answer her, just kept going on in that too-steady voice, “Thank you for telling me. You’re a good girl. Your mother raised you right. It took a lot of courage to tell me this.”

The hairs on Max’s arms were standing up. Neil was supposed to get angry. He was supposed to throw things and call Billy a no-good punk, he was supposed to ground him for weeks and take his car away and make him miserable. He wasn’t supposed to be so calm or say so many good things about her all at once.

“Do you know where he is now?” Neil asked.

“Billy?” Max said, trying to stall, to figure out whether to tell the truth or not because something was really wrong. The tether keeping ghost Max from floating away was getting looser every second.

“Yes. Are they together now, Maxine?”

“I—I don’t know.”

“I think you do.”

“Yeah—I think so.”

“Where do they go? Where do they go when they’re together?”

Neil was just going to go get them. He was going to go find them and yell at Billy in front of Jack, probably call him a bunch of names, and Billy would be super mad and say awful things back, and Jack would finally realize what an asshole Billy was. That was all.

“They go to the park, sometimes, the dugouts by the baseball diamond. And, sometimes under the pier, by the hotdog stand.”

“That’s very helpful, Max. Thank you.”

“Are you going to go get them now?”

“I think I better call that boy’s parents first, let them know what their son is up to. What was his name again?”

“Jack. Jack Quincy.”

“Thank you, Max. Why don’t you go to your room for a little while. I just need to make this call.”

 

*** 

 

It’s weird to see Steve standing in her living room, like seeing a dog on its hind legs. He doesn’t seem curious about the house, though, doesn’t stop to look at anything. He just walks down the narrow hall and goes right to Billy’s door, even though Max never said which one it was. Maybe it’s obvious. Maybe there’s a mean, glaring aura around it she can’t see. Steve shakes the handle a few times, but it doesn’t budge, just like when Max tried thirty other times today.

With two knuckles, Steve knocks solidly on the door. “Billy,” he says, which is weird, too, because Max doesn’t think Steve’s ever said that – it’s always shove it, Hargrove and fuck off, Harrington the few times Max has seen them interact.

“Billy, it’s me, Steve. Uh.” Steve glances at Max where she’s just behind him, like maybe he forgot she was there. “Max is here. But that’s it, okay? It’s just you and me and Max. You don’t have to let me in, just, knock or move something in there so we know you’re okay.”

Steve actually presses his ear to the door, and it’s that, more than anything, that makes Max pause. Steve looks really worried, she realizes. Not curious, or frustrated, but really, really worried, as if it were Dustin behind that door.

Steve listens for a long time before he takes a step back, presses a hand flat against the wood and pushes a little, like he’s testing it.

“You’re not going to break it are you?” Max asks, alarmed. Steve would never do that, she doesn’t think, but nothing about this is normal. It feels like, just now, anything could happen.

“No,” says Steve, “Just checking. You said you tried the window?”

“It’s locked.”

“Show me?”

So, Max takes Steve out the back door, around the side of the house, and stops by Billy’s window. The shades are drawn just like when she tried to open it this morning, in a fit of desperation.

Steve doesn’t hesitate, just braces two hands under the wooden slat where the lock would be on the inside. He pushes up hard and shakes it at the same time. After a few tense seconds of nothing but the wind blowing through dead leaves and Steve’s panting breaths, it creaks open an inch, and then another. He lets go of the top part and pushes up from the bottom, until there’s enough space for somebody to crawl through.

“It’s not locked,” he says, “It just sticks, sometimes. The—uh, the wood shrinks and expands with all the cold fronts. My window’s the same.” He tacks on the last part like that’ll explain how he knows just the right way to jimmy open Billy’s window, as if that makes any sense, as if Max is still a thirteen-year-old idiot who doesn’t know shit.

“Okay,” she says, because she doesn’t want to think about it right now. She wants to know whether there’s a living person in that room or not, but she doesn’t want to check herself.

Luckily, Steve says, “I’m going in, okay? You go back in the house, and I’ll open the door from inside.”

So, Max watches Steve shimmy ungracefully through Billy’s window, getting all caught in the blinds, hears him land with a thump and a muffled curse, and then she turns and walks quickly toward the backdoor. She doesn’t want to know why he knows how the window works. She doesn’t want to hear if Steve screams at what he sees.

She goes back inside and waits by Billy’s door. Part of her wants to press her ear against the wood like Steve had, but she also doesn’t care that much. If she did, she would’ve floated away by now.

Even without listening too hard she can still hear vague murmurs, like Steve is talking maybe. At least there’s no screaming, yet.

After endless minutes, the door gives a lurch like Steve’s un-wedged the chair and then it sort of rocks open, sticking a little from being closed three days. Steve slips carefully though the crack and then shuts the door behind him, so Max can’t get a look inside.

“It’s okay,” he says, which is Max’s least favorite word ever.

“Is he dead?”

“What? No—he’s fine. I mean, not fine, but. Look. Why don’t you—go hang out in your room for a little bit?”

Why don’t you go to your room for a little while.

“No,” says Max.

“Okay? Then, maybe, go watch something? It’s just—I’m gonna try to get him to shower, and he probably doesn’t want—”

“He doesn’t want to see me, I know,” Max finishes, because it’s why he’s been holed up in the first place, because it’s been three-hundred and sixty-five days since she killed the only person Billy’s ever even liked.

“Uh, I think it’s more that he wouldn’t want you to see him like—this, but. Just. Go watch TV, okay, Max, please?”

So Max watches Cheers reruns with the volume up just enough to seem loud, but low enough that she can still hear Billy’s door creak open again and Steve say, “It’s just across the hall, just a few feet, you’ll feel better, I promise, come on, Billy.” Then the bathroom door opens and shuts, and the shower turns on, and Max doesn’t hear much after that. She hears enough to know that the door doesn’t open again to let Steve out. It doesn’t open for a whole episode and a half.

 

 

 

Three hours after Max called Steve in some misguided worry over Billy that’s never going to happen again, she’s sitting on the floor of the living room, learning against the couch, and watching some MTV Top 20 countdown that she’s already seen. From the floor, because Billy’s taking up half the sofa the way he always does with his stupid boy sprawl. Usually Max can fit at the other end, but Steve’s there now, pretending to watch the TV but really watching Billy the whole time, as if they both can’t tell.

Except, maybe Billy can’t. His eyes are sort of glazed over and he hasn’t complained once about the countdown, even though he always hates half the songs. He doesn’t say a word about it now, just stares at Mark Goodman with blank eyes.

When video four is fading into the hundredth Doritos ad, Max feels a nudge at her back and turns. It’s Steve poking her with his foot. He raises an eyebrow and mouths, hungry?

Max nods and flicks her gaze to Billy, realizes what the weirdness is about. He’s slumped down, asleep, his head an inch away from Steve’s shoulder, their knees touching from where Billy’s sprawled himself all everywhere.

Steve catches her eye and nods like they’re thinking the same thing, even though they really, really can’t be. He jerks his chin at the kitchen, so Max gets up and watches as Steve gently eases away from the boy who almost beat him to death a year ago. He doesn’t look scared. He looks—

Max goes to the kitchen and opens the fridge, pretends to consider the options even though it’s empty, like it’s been all day. She just needs something else to look at.

“Hey,” says Steve softly.

“There’s nothing to eat,” says Max, not softly at all, because she doesn’t care if Billy wakes up, he should, he’s been sleeping for three whole days.

“Okay. . .” Max doesn’t care if he’s confused at her tone. She doesn’t want to look at him. “Do you want to get pizza? Or, we could go to the diner and bring something back.”

If Billy wants to eat, he should wake up and drive them there, since that’s his job. Max doesn’t say that, though. She stares at the buzzing white bulb in the back of the fridge and breathes in deep.

It’s not Steve’s fault. He’s just a nice guy, who cares about people, which isn’t something she’s used to seeing. So, maybe she’s just got it confused with—other things. He had a girlfriend after all, didn’t he? Mike’s sister. Even if they aren’t together now, it counts.

“Sorry,” says Max. She’s been trying to be better, and she really shouldn’t piss Steve off when he’s one of, like, three Party members still talking to her. And he’s only honorary. “I’m just tired.”

“It’s been a long day,” Steve agrees, like he has any idea how long October 13th even is. “So, pizza? I’m buying.”

“Yeah, okay.”

 

 

 

“Is Tony’s okay? I know it’s not Rico’s, but it’s closer, plus I don’t think Rico’s is open this weekend.”

Max stares out the window, but there’s not much to see in the deep, Indiana dark. There aren’t that many street lights out here. She always wonders how many people drive off the road.

“How’d you know about Billy’s window,” she says, and she can’t even blame it on some other Max, really, just on the mean thing still burning in her stomach. Steve’s a nice guy. Maybe he gets that look on his face for a lot of people, but he still knew how to work the window just right.

“It’s like I said, I mean, mine sticks the same way, it’s these old houses, and the cold—”

“You knew which room was his. I didn’t tell you when you came in, but you knew.”

Steve glances at her, and then right back at the road, like a responsible driver. Billy would’ve glared till she looked away first.

“Yeah,” says Steve. “Okay, me and Billy are—friends, I guess. I’ve been over once or twice, while your family was out.”

“When.”

“Um. In the summer, that weekend you went to visit your cousin’s lake house or something.” They went to stay with Aunt Grace’s son, John, who’s sort of rich now that he’s a lawyer. Billy wasn’t allowed to go for reasons Max didn’t ask about. A weekend away from him was a gift she didn’t want to look to closely at. That was in June.

What kind of friends, Max wants to say.

“Billy doesn’t have friends,” she says instead, because it’s true.

 

*** 

 

“Billy doesn’t have friends.”

The boy laughed like it was the funniest thing he’d heard all day, even though Max wasn’t making a joke.

“Shut the fuck up, Maxine,” Billy said and flicked his hair out of his face in irritation. It was so stupid long now, it made him look like a girl. Max hoped Neil made him cut it.

“Man,” said the boy, smirking in Billy’s direction. “I like her. What’s your name again – Maxine?”

“It’s Max.”

“Max, cool. Hey, can you keep a secret, Max?”

Max shrugged, so the boy moved away from Billy’s side and sort of leaned down. He was really tall.

“Me and Billy,” he said in a fake whisper, loud enough that Billy could still hear, “we’re not really friends. I just let him hang around me, you know?” He raised his shoulders, all what can you do and smiled like she was in on the secret. Then he stood straight again and finished in a normal voice, “But you seem pretty cool, Max. Mad Max. What do you think, terminal crazy? You wanna be friends with me?”

He talked weird, like he was famous, like maybe she owed him a favor, but he was letting it slide.

“I don’t even know your name,” she said.

He laughed really big again, and his eyes almost disappeared, all crinkled at the edges. He had a wide mouth, green eyes, and white teeth. He was pretty much the nicest looking guy she’d ever seen outside TV.

“Jack,” he said and stuck out his hand like a politician. Feeling under some spell, she shook it. “Jack Quincy.”

“Fuck,” said Billy, “Are you girls done yapping? We’re gonna miss the bus.” Billy had his permit, but he wasn’t old enough to take the driving test yet, and every time he said the word bus now it was like a curse word. Max rolled her eyes, and when she looked up Jack was rolling his, too.

“Take a chill pill, Billie Jean,” he said, and then he reached out and tugged on one of Billy’s blond, Shirley Temple curls, smiling so wide his cheeks looked ready to split. Max felt a cold start in her stomach, knowing what Billy did to guys who pissed him off, to anyone who even talked about his hair, let alone touched it.

But Billy didn’t push Jack or call him a stupid fucker, he just scoffed and dropped his cigarette, crushed it with his boot even though it was barely half gone. 

“Whatever,” he said, and he didn’t even say it mean.

Jack must’ve seen some dumb expression on her face, because he looked at her and winked. He’s just jealous, he mouthed, and when he caught Billy staring, he winked at him, too.

“I can feel it in the air, Mad Max,” said Jack, even though he was looking at Billy. “You and me, we’re gonna run this town.”

 

***

 

“Yeah, well,” Steve says, still looking at the road. “I don’t really have friends, either.”

“What?” That’s not true, and Max would know, because she’s the one whose only friends probably don’t consider themselves her friends anymore. “You have—Dustin. And The Party. And, Will’s brother.” She realizes it’s not a great list and wracks her brain for someone else. “What about Tommy?”

Steve looks away from the road again, so she must’ve really surprised him. “How do you know about Tommy?”

Max knows about Tommy because there were a few weeks last year, right before the second worst night of her life, where Billy wouldn’t shut up about it. It was all King Steve this and King Steve that, and some guy called Tommy H. who was gonna help him bring that Harrington fucker down.

“Dustin told me,” she says, because she doesn’t like thinking about that suddenly, why Billy was so caught up.

Steve sighs, loud, like a girl. “Right. Tommy isn’t really talking to me anymore. And, I’m not talking to him. And, yeah, I’m friends with The Party, but I’m also their babysitter.”

“Lucas is gonna be fifteen in a month,” says Max, because they don’t need fucking babysitters, and she wishes more grownups would get that. Not that Steve’s a grownup.

“Yeah, and I’m nineteen, Max. I shouldn’t even be hanging out with you guys.” Nineteen? That can’t be right. That’s like—old, old. Like, almost twenty, old.

“Billy’s seventeen,” she says. Maybe Steve shouldn’t be hanging out with him either.

Steve’s eyes leave the road again. “Billy turned eighteen in June.”

Max does the math and realizes they’ve been in Hawkins a year now. Billy had to have had a birthday sometime. She never remembers when it is because they don’t do anything special. Max doesn’t think Billy’s ever had a cake the whole time she’s known him.

So, then, “How do you know that?”

“Because we’re—we hang out, I guess. I don’t—sleep, that well, anymore. Sometimes I just drive around town, you know, to clear my head. I guess Billy does the same thing. We bumped into each other a few times.”

What, Max wants to say, in your cars?

“Jonathan and Nancy are busy a lot with school, and Tommy’s still a dick. You guys are cool, but sometimes I want to talk to someone who was born in like, the sixties, you know?”

She doesn’t. “And you picked Billy?”

Steve shrugs. “He’s not so bad.”

Max wants to say, he almost killed you and he’s only had one friend his whole life and he’s dead, but then Steve pulls into Tony’s Pizza Palace, and that’s not the kind of thing you can say in front of other people. 

 

 

 

“Yes, Mom. I got it. Okay. Bye.” 

Max hangs up the phone and goes back into the living room. She checks the bathroom, her bedroom, looks out the window at the backyard, and even opens the front door again to make sure. Steve’s Beamer is still in the driveway, just like the last time she checked, but he’s nowhere in the house.

Last night, after they’d eaten their way through a large pepperoni and watched way too much Cheers, Steve had told her to go to bed, if she wanted, that he’d stay the night to keep an eye on things, if that’s okay with you? I’ll stay on the couch, and I’ll be gone before your parents show up.

When Max got up and didn’t see Steve, she thought he’d left. It was only when she took out the pizza boxes that she noticed the car. It isn’t a big house. It didn’t take her long to check once, twice, and a third time just to be sure.

It’s noon now, and Mom and Neil will be back in an hour.

Max stands in front of Billy’s door and places a hand against the wood like Steve did yesterday, just checking, pushing against it to see if there’s any give. Nothing. She takes one big breath in and turns the handle—if it opens and Billy’s awake, he’ll be so pissed, but considering how much he’s been sleeping the past few days, maybe it won’t be a problem.

It doesn’t matter anyway. The door doesn’t budge.

Max stands there in the narrow hallway of her house and feels like it’s all she’s done for days. This was supposed to be her long weekend, too, and all she’s done is stand in front of this fucking door and imagine what’s on the other side.

She wishes she hadn’t called Steve. She wishes she’d let Billy rot.

She puts her ear against the door and thinks about Steve with his ear against the door, his stupid, worried eyes, and his voice in the car last night when he said, he’s not so bad.

Despite how good she’s tried to be, the ugly, churning thing comes back so easy.

She bangs on the wood with both fists, again and again and again, as hard as she can, and screams, “Get up! Get up! Get up!” until the door swings open. Steve’s eyes are wide with panic.

“What?” he gasps. “What is it, what’s wrong?” It’s only when he realizes that she’s not bleeding or being chased by a demodog that he seems to notice the fury shaking her bones. 

“Max—” he starts, but she pushes past him into the room before he can come up with another dumbass excuse.

Billy is a mound of blankets, his stupid blond hair sticking out the top to let her know it’s him. She runs at the bed and uses her momentum to shove at him, hard, and he falls with a satisfying thump on the other side.

“Max, what the fuck!”

At first, she thinks that’s Billy, but it’s just Steve from somewhere behind her, trying to grab at her arm. She dodges him and rounds the bed to get a better look. Billy hasn’t even moved. She yanks the covers off him and—the sound he makes is like nothing she’s ever heard, almost a whimper. She might feel bad about it later, but right then, it just makes her feel good.

She stares at the boy on the ground, his eyes rimmed with purple, his permanently split lip and his tangled hair, and can’t believe, even two minutes ago, she was afraid of him. He’s nothing. She wants to say something smart and biting and awful, she wants words that’ll make him dirt, but there’s a hand on her shoulder before she can think of anything—

“Max!”

Steve looks scared, which isn’t as good. He’s a nice guy. Which reminds her—

“I hope he kills you this time,” she says to Billy.

Then she twists out of Steve’s grip and leaves, slams the door behind her. It rings out like a gunshot, probably heard for miles in the Indiana air.

 

 

 

 End Part I 

 

 

 

Notes:

This might be making explicit what (I hope) is obvious, but Max's feelings around Billy/Jack's relationship are complicated by her own crush on Jack, and Billy/Steve's relationship is in the shadow of that. But she has also been brought up in a homophobic environment, and that's going to color her thinking, too. She'll learn! None of her opinions are my own ofc, just wanted to make that clear!

Hope you enjoyed!