Chapter Text
Part II: Steve
It’s October 14, 1985. Steve stands in Billy’s bedroom, listens as another door slams somewhere in the house, and tries to figure out how his life got to be like this. It’s something he thinks about pretty much once a week, though, so it doesn’t take long for him to get over it.
He takes another few seconds and then goes to right the chair he’d pushed over trying to open the door. He’d really thought Max was being murdered. He’d thought Billy’s dad had come home, or more demodogs were loose, or another million other life-threatening things. Turns out it was just Max going absolutely fucking crazy. Dustin told him about some total freak out she’d had back in August, but Steve thought he was just being dramatic, because he’s Dustin.
He scoots the chair next to the wall, but on second thought, pushes it back under the door handle. Safer that way. When he notices Billy hasn’t gotten up yet, he walks back to the far side of the room, slumps against the wall and slides down it, wraps his arms around his knees so he doesn’t do something stupid. He really wants to go over there, to fix the blanket that’s tangled around Billy’s legs and make sure he’s still breathing.
But he’s never heard Billy sound like that before, so he just watches the almost invisible rise and fall of Billy’s chest and waits.
Maybe ten minutes later, Billy says, “Fuck off, Harrington,” from where he’s still lying on the ground.
“You’d like that, huh,” Steve says back, which doesn’t really make sense, but the less he thinks about the things he says, the better chance he has of making Billy laugh. And Billy does, sort of, a weak kind of huff.
This is the part where Billy’s supposed to make some comment about Steve’s way with words, his superior wit, and mad comedy skills, man, you ever think about writing for SNL? But the moment dies and there’s just a heavy silence that grates on Steve’s skin and makes him feel like shit. It’s how he’s felt since he picked up the phone yesterday, since he crawled through Billy’s window and found him like—this.
It’s just—Steve is supposed to be the fucked-up one. When he and Billy started—whatever—over the summer, Steve was the one who jumped at every car that passed, had to have the lights on 24-7, woke up screaming, and couldn’t even be around dogs anymore. Billy was the one who laughed at him and told him to chill the fuck out, Harrington, Jesus, but also the one who changed the lightbulbs when they went out in the middle of night and told probably made up stories about California in a low, raspy voice till Steve fell asleep.
Now, Steve feels like a total asshole. He’s always been bad at this part, which isn’t an excuse, just true. He says the worst things at the worst times, misunderstands even the biggest hints, and is basically the shittiest boyfriend in the world.
Which—doesn’t matter, anyway, because that’s not even what they’re doing. He’s just bad at supporting people, or whatever, and it turns out they can’t both be nutcases at the same time, or else Max might come in and murder one of them. Steve isn’t sure what she meant by that last thing, but it sounded like a threat.
Didn’t Dustin say something about her killing somebody?
That can’t be real. Right?
“I mean it,” says Billy before Steve can go completely off the rails with that train of thought. “Get lost.” Which, fuck him, but also is probably a good idea considering—Steve checks his watch—it’s after noon already.
He really doesn’t want to be here anymore, in this fucked up house, but he also doesn’t want to leave. Not when Billy’s still on the ground like that.
“Get up, man,” he says, instead of something stupid (are you okay, are you gonna be okay, will you come home with me). He doesn’t help him up, just sort of stands there and looks at him the way Billy hates, one eyebrow raised, expectant.
“Shut the fuck up,” says Billy, a good sign. He doesn’t stand, but he sits and presses his back into his bedside table, curls around his knees, and puts his head down on top of them, like just that small movement took the life out of him. His hair is such a mess, even after the shower. Steve’s fingers itch looking at it, he wants so bad just to—
He’d better go.
“I’d better go,” which makes it sound like his idea rather than Billy telling him to fuck off. But he doesn’t just yet. He stares at the chair blocking the doorway and wonders if Billy will have the energy to put it back after he leaves.
“Hey,” he says before he can think about it, because that usually works out for the best. He stands in front of Billy again, who doesn’t look up. “Just, um. Come over? If you want. Later. Or, whenever. Just use the fake rock key, okay?” Billy doesn’t respond, doesn’t even move, which is perfect, really, cause then he can’t see how badly Steve wants to touch him, just to check that he’s still warm. It also means he hopefully doesn’t see Steve climb awkwardly back out the window and struggle to close it again.
He really is gonna go then, except—Max had been so pale before. Clearly furious, but also shaking, the same way she had that awful night last year, when everything was over, like aftershocks of fear. And even if she wants to kill him, she’s still also one of his kids, so.
He smooths over the dirt outside Billy’s window with his shoe and then heads around to the back, hopes Max forgot to lock door. She did. Steve feels like he’s breaking in when he makes it back inside, the narrow hall leading to bedrooms shadowed and quiet.
Max’s door is firmly shut, so he just knocks and says, “Hey Max, um. I’m going now. So. Just—call me if you need anything. I know you’re mad but, you can still call—okay?” He doesn’t expect a reply, but he still sort of hangs around in the hall for a minute just in case she comes out. She doesn’t.
The house is silent as he drives away, oddly dark even in the brisk October sun.
When Steve wakes up later that night, it’s not because Billy’s in his bed again (he’s gotten really good at getting in without shaking the mattress). It’s because of the dream, the big black empty crawling up and taking Dustin and Billy and Max, too. Everyone, and him last so he has to watch.
He used to wake up screaming, but it’s shifted in the past few months. Now he wakes up reaching out, looking for warmth, cause he’s so fucking cold all the time. Billy lets Steve curl his shaking fingers into his shirt and, then, after a beat, lets him slide his hand just under it, to steal the heat from his skin there. Billy runs hotter than anyone, like he’s got that California sun trapped inside him, like he brought it all the way here to Indiana just to keep Steve warm.
It’s a bad night, probably from Max’s freak out or from being in that house, knowing that’s where Billy gets all fucked-up.
Steve is shaking, which almost never happens anymore, and it must be pretty annoying because Billy puts his hand on top of Steve’s, over the shirt, and says, “Easy,” which he only does when Steve is really losing it.
Maybe he’s really losing it. He just wants more, more warmth and more skin under his fingers and more of Billy’s sleep-thick voice saying easy, easy.
“Please,” he says, which isn’t how this works. Whatever they’ve been doing all these months, it’s built on small, wordless things, just offered. Steve’s always thought that asking would be the end of it, that Billy doesn’t let people take from him, he gives what he wants and nothing more.
But it’s going on three in the morning and, Steve hasn’t slept in thirty hours, and something’s wrong that he can’t fix, and he just wants—
“Easy,” says Billy, “Jesus. Take a breath, Steve, come on. C’mere.” Steve was pretty close already, but Billy gets an arm around him and pulls him closer, right up against his side. Steve curls into him, hides his face in Billy’s neck, behind the curtain of his tangled hair, and it’s so good, warm and safe. He wants to be that for Billy, his warm, safe thing, but he doesn’t know how.
“Sorry,” he says, because he’s so tired, and he can’t say, sorry we’re both fucked-up but only you know how to help me, sorry I can kill monsters but just not yours.
Billy rubs the shell of Steve’s ear with his thumb. “Did I ever tell you about the time we went to Disneyland?” he says in his low, sleep-rumble. “Max puked up, like, six hotdogs after Space Mountain.”
Billy goes on about the rides and the food and the Mickey Mouse ears Max made him buy, and Steve sinks into his voice, the weird tilt of his vowels, lets everything go hazy again now that he’s warm.
He’s almost asleep but something’s bugging him, some important thing Billy’s supposed to know.
“Don’t,” says Steve, already drifting. “Don’t go anywhere.”
***
“Don’t go anywhere.”
Billy was dripping blood down his face and his shirt, all over the counter he was sitting on, and if he tried to leave now he’d just trail blood after him, and Steve would have to clean it up.
“I mean it, man, you’re making a mess. Just stay put, okay?”
“Fuck,” said Billy, “really? Cause I was thinking of going for a run, you know? Maybe whipping up something to eat.” He grinned all wide and sharp even though it must’ve pulled at the cut on his lip.
“Fuck off,” said Steve, and then he went to find the first aid kit. He thought he heard Billy laugh as he walked down the hall, like there was anything funny about this. He was so fucking weird. And now he was in Steve’s kitchen, bleeding into his mom’s fancy guest towel that cost, like, forty dollars, all because this was apparently what Steve did now – babysit preteens and fight monsters and patch up assholes who never thanked him for it afterwards.
Steve was pretty sure if Nancy knew about this, about Billy in his kitchen right now, or all the other times, she’d say he needed to find better a way to deal with your trauma, Steve, there’s no shame in talking to someone. But she was busy with her summer courses and Jonathan, and she didn’t get a say in his life like that anymore, so.
“Hold still,” Steve said later, trying to get the butterfly bandages just right. Billy always squirmed during this part, which made sense, cause Steve had to get pretty close to see and he was pretty much breathing all into Billy’s face. But it wasn’t like Steve was forcing him to show up in the middle of the night all fucked-up, so he could just deal with Steve’s shitty first aid skills.
Billy usually closed his eyes, but he didn’t this time, and it was just—weird. Steve hands were shaking as he fit the bandage over the cut on Billy’s forehead, which bled like a bitch but didn’t seem as bad as Steve had first thought.
The normal silence between them was changing, the crazy blue of Billy’s eyes making the air all tense. It went on and on, and Billy didn’t shut his fucking eyes, and Steve was getting drunk with it, his limbs too heavy, his blood too hot.
He fit the last of the butterfly bandages onto Billy’s too-warm skin, but he was in some kind of trance, so he couldn’t keep his fingers from rubbing the edges down again and again even though they were stuck already. He was suddenly so aware that his hands were on Billy’s face, that his skin was so hot, and Billy kept looking and looking and not saying fuck off, Harrington, what’s wrong with you, which Steve wanted to hear, to break this thing holding him hostage.
“Billy,” Steve said, because it was the only thing he could think right now, but it just made everything worse. He’d never said that out loud before, not to Billy’s face. It’s not like they were friends.
Billy’s eyes sort of fluttered and Steve’s breath did something weird in his chest. He was thinking this has to be a dream and he’s so warm and who the fuck has eyes that blue, clearly losing it, which is why he reached to fix the curl of Billy’s hair that had fallen into his face, gotten caught on all the blood and bandages. Steve was just thinking it was as soft as it looked, when Billy jerked back like Steve had hit him. His boots banged against the counter, and something metal fell behind him and clanged loudly, and the trance was finally broken.
“Get the fuck off me, Harrington,” said Billy, which was exactly what he should be saying, but it made something ache in Steve anyway.
“Sorry,” he said.
Billy jumped off the counter and shouldered past him, threw the fancy, bloody kitchen towel into the sink and stalked out of the room. Steve was waiting to hear the front door slam, the Camaro roar to life and drive away, so the sudden peal of laughter made him jump. He followed the sound into the living room, hadn’t realized how shitty and cold he felt about Billy leaving till he saw him watching Cheers, his dirty shoes up on the coffee table, making a mess, but still there.
Steve sunk into the other end of the sofa, leaving plenty of space between them. He didn’t sleep anymore, but knowing Billy was here and patched-up and not mad enough to leave made it easy to close his eyes and drift off.
Billy was gone when he woke up hours later, but the TV was still on and there were three different blankets thrown over him, so for once, he woke up warm.
***
It’s November 29, 1985. The day after Thanksgiving, which Steve planned on spending entirely in sweatpants, watching shitty daytime TV, and waiting for Billy to show up.
Instead, he’s parked outside the arcade in the slowly mounting snow, wondering once again how he ended up the designated preteen-driver. It’s just Dustin, today, though, the rest of The Party getting rides from Nancy and Jonathan. So, he’s going to drive him home as fast as legally possible, get back into bed to get warm, and then Billy’ll show up to make him warmer. It’s the perfect plan, until the passenger side door opens, and someone slides in, someone a little too slight and pale and ginger to be Dustin.
“Uh,” says Steve, because he hasn’t really seen Max since she threatened to kill Billy and maybe him, too. He’s unclear about that still, and it’s not the kind of thing he can ask Billy without ruining the sort of easy thing they’ve got now.
“I told Billy I had a ride,” she says.
“Okay.” They’re just gonna ignore it, then, which is fine by him. “I’m dropping you at home?”
“Drop Dustin off first.”
Before Steve can say something about taking orders from ungrateful fourteen-year-olds, Dustin yanks the backseat door open, already whining, “—called shotgun inside, goddammit.”
“Language,” says Steve automatically, which horrifies him about thirty seconds later, but it’s probably lost anyway as Max says,
“You have to be in sight of the car to call shotgun, dipshit, everybody knows that.” Which is true, but Steve doesn’t like the way she says dipshit, not the good-natured ribbing the boys always do, but with something real and mean underneath. She sounds like Billy, before they were—whatever.
The kids bicker back and forth as Steve pulls out onto the road, and Dustin at least doesn’t seem to notice Max’s stormy mood. Steve gets increasingly paranoid the closer they get to Dustin’s place, though, wondering why Max wanted him to drive her, why she seems so frankly homicidal.
When he slows to stop outside Dustin’s house, he almost wants to come up with some excuse to go in, invite himself to dinner, maybe—it’s not like Mrs. Henderson would turn him away. But Max still needs to get home, and Steve knows very well what can happen when she’s not there on time.
So, Dustin climbs out with a reminder that there’s a party meeting tomorrow Steve, and you’d better show up if you want to keep your honorary status, and then it’s just Steve and Max. It only takes twenty minutes to get to Max’s but it’s going to be the longest twenty minutes of his life if he doesn’t come up with something to say that isn’t, do you still want me dead or are we cool?
Then Max says, “Let’s go to yours,” which isn’t at all reassuring.
“Don’t you need to get home?” Steve knows what happens when Max is late.
“I said I’d be back at four.” The clock on the dashboard reads 2:47.
“Okay. . .”
“I have to tell you something important, and I can’t tell you in front of The Party or Billy or anyone, so let’s just go to yours, okay?”
“Okay,” Steve says again. He’s pretty sure he could take her in a fight anyway, even though she is pretty wily.
Thirty minutes later, Steve is stirring instant hot coco mix into two mugs and wondering, again, how this day got so off course. He’s supposed to be in bed right now, warm, and instead he’s got a pissed-off fourteen-year-old girl in his living room, watching MTV at a near-deafening level and seething.
They’ve been here twenty minutes, and all she’s done is comment on the Christmas decorations Steve’s mom half put up before she left for Monte Carlo—isn’t it a little early? She must’ve lost her nerve about the very important thing he needs to know. That or she’s just trying to make him sweat. Probably the second thing.
Steve’s escaped to the kitchen, but it turns out instant hot coco is ready pretty much instantly, and he can’t hang out in here much longer or it’ll go cold.
“Here,” he says and hands Max her coco. On the TV, Starship sings about a city they built with rock and roll.
They watch the rest of the video, and then two more. Then Max says, “Did Billy tell you about his last boyfriend?”, which is so far from anything Steve was expecting that his mouth hangs open, like an idiot. When Max sees, she rolls her eyes and mutters, “So, no.”
“Max—”
“He didn’t tell you.”
“No, but Max, that’s um. Really something he should tell me, if he wants to. I get that you want me to know, and, like, I appreciate it but—”
“I don’t want you to know so you’ll be jealous or whatever. I want you to know so you’ll stop.”
“Max—”
“You’ll die, okay?” Max nearly yells. The silence after isn’t really quiet, with MTV still blaring in the background. Steve doesn’t know what to do with that, or any of this, so he gets up to shut the TV off even though the remote is right there, just for something to do.
Max drops her mug loudly on the coffee table and hugs her arms to chest, doesn’t look at Steve when she adds, softly, “He’ll kill you, too.”
“Who?” Steve asks, feeling kind of dumb. It’s like a conversation from a dream that he just goes along with because there’s nothing else to do. “Billy?”
Max shakes her head and squeezes herself further into the corner of the couch. Steve doesn’t like looming over her while she looks like that, so he sits back down and almost misses it when she says, “Neil,” just above a whisper.
“What are you saying, Max?”
Teenagers lie all the time. He knows that. They sneak out and they smoke, and they go to parties when they’re supposed to be studying. Max has lied to his face before, probably dozens of times, but he doesn’t think she’d say something like this just to get rid of him, even if she hates this thing he’s got with Billy. As much as he can’t believe her, he doesn’t think she’s lying. She looks really small tucked against the sofa like that.
Max stares at the blank TV screen still buzzing with heat and says, “They were gonna go to San Francisco.”
It’s a conversation from a dream, so Steve says, “Who?”
“Jack was gonna be a teacher, there was this program in San Francisco he really wanted to go to. Billy was gonna go with him even though he wasn’t done with school. He said he’d just get a job or something.”
Jack. El told Mike, who told Lucas, who told Dustin, who told Steve that Jack was the name of Max’s ex-boyfriend back in California. Who she’d killed, apparently. Steve’s getting a better picture of things the more Max goes on, and he really wishes she would stop.
But she doesn’t. “Jack was really smart, you know? He took these classes at the college, for extra credit. He was gonna graduate early, in January, but he didn’t tell anyone because he just wanted to go. They were just gonna go.”
Max is pulling at her hair like she doesn’t know she’s doing it, and Steve doesn’t want to hear any more of this, knows beyond a shadow of a doubt that this isn’t something he’s supposed to know.
“Max—”
“I didn’t want them to go. I just thought they’d get in trouble, like, grounded. I didn’t think—"
“That’s why you told him?”
Max jumps, and Steve is reaching for a weapon, anything, turns to see—
Just Billy, standing in the doorway, his coat dusted with the snow coming down outside. It’s caught all in his hair, which would be kind of nice, except for how he looks like death, like wax, the way he did that day Steve climbed through his window, all the life sucked out.
“Billy,” says Steve, because maybe saying his name will make him look real again.
But Billy’s eyes are trained on Max, who’s sunk even further into the cushions.
“Billy—” she says, too.
“That what you wanted, Maxine?” The taunt in Billy’s tone sends Steve back a year. That’s not the Billy who keeps Steve warm and tells him stories through the night, but the one who smashed a plate over Steve’s head—is that you, Harrington? “You wanted me to spend a few more years in that house, so you told him about us?”
“I didn’t—I didn’t know, I thought—”
“Thought, what? I told you, Max! I told you, over and over—keep your mouth shut. You don’t tell anyone, and then you told the one person who—”
“I’m sorry.” Max is crying silent, awful tears, and Billy keeps stalking closer to the couch in a way that makes Steve afraid of what he’ll do, for the first time in months.
“Billy,” he says again, but neither of them seems to hear. It really is like he’s trapped in a dream, nothing he can do but watch everyone break apart around him.
“You’re sorry?” Billy says, and then he laughs, a chilling thing. “You think that means shit to me? Huh? You think I care that you’re sorry?”
Max changes then, pushes past fear the same way Billy does, straight into fury. Her hands are white, shaking fists. “He was my friend, too!” she yells.
Billy does that thing with his tongue like he’s itching to fight, to feel his knuckles split open on someone’s face. He told Steve once, maybe when he thought he was already asleep, I don’t feel the pain right away, you know, I just get this rush.
“Your friend?” Billy echoes, low and dangerous. “He only let you hang around because of me. Because you’re my kid sister and I told him to be nice to you. You think he was your friend? You were nothing to him.”
Steve watches as each one of Billy’s words lands like a physical blow, Max’s tears starting fresh again. He’s got to stop this, but it feels like he’s trapped in honey or amber—one of those bugs Dustin’s got. He can’t move.
“He was my whole world,” Billy says. Steve hears him like he’s behind glass. “And you got him killed.”
Max crumples into the sofa, curls into a ball, and stutters heaving breaths into her arms. Billy watches with blank eyes, a wax thing again, all his fight gone away.
Steve watches, too, and thinks distantly about the day he was supposed to have, how in some universe (Dustin’s told him there are many), there’s a Steve and a Billy watching shit TV and sharing warmth in bed.
Not this one, though. Steve doesn’t really get lucky like that anymore.
