Chapter Text
Part IV: Steve
It’s just past four in the afternoon on New Year’s Eve, 1985, and Steve’s in that good place, not quite asleep, just letting his whole mind glaze over. With the laugh track from whatever sitcom on TV like white noise, three giant blankets keeping him warm, and his feet tucked snug under Billy’s thigh, it’s just—good. Feels like the kind of day he didn’t think he’d get again, last year, during the worst of it. The whole world outside is cold and foggy with snow, but inside it’s just safe and yellow and slow.
He feels like he could melt into the sofa, maybe float away with the gold-happy filling him up, and he can’t really help the humming sound he makes. When he was younger, and his mom was around more, she used to say he purred like a cat.
Billy huffs a quiet almost-laugh in response and squeezes Steve’s shin. He can barely feel it with all the blankets, but it makes the gold thing inside him grow anyway.
It’s like that forever maybe, or just a long time, and then Billy says, “Steve,” like he’s said it a few times before and Steve didn’t notice.
He tries to say, what, but it comes out more like, “Whum?”
Billy huffs again. “The doorbell, genius. You want me to get it?”
Of course, Steve wants Billy to get it. He couldn’t move right now if the house were on fire. But, while he doesn’t think it’s stayed secret that Billy’s been living here—nothing stays secret in Hawkins for long, except for, like, world-altering shit, and even then, just barely—he doesn’t really want to invite all the gossip that might come if Mrs. Carlton from next door drops by with more homemade jam or complains about the drain in her guest bath again.
He knows they’re safer now. Logically, he knows it. It’s just hard to remember, sometimes, and with Billy on winter break, they’ve just been holed away in here, secret and safe. It has to end sometime, but not right now, not on New Year’s and with everything so warm.
So, even though he wants Billy to get the door, and getting up right now is the fucking worst, he still does it, slipping off the coach and onto the floor with a dull thump. He groans into the carpet for a while, just long enough to make Billy laugh for real, and then he stumbles up and out into the hall.
It’s only when he’s a few steps from the door that he remembers the last person to visit. An anxious prickling starts up at his neck. Maybe things went wrong somehow, maybe Hop’s FBI friends couldn’t help them, maybe the bail went through and Billy’s dad is out—
By the time he’s worked up the courage to grip the cold metal of the doorknob, his heart’s beating wildly in his chest, too loud in his ears. He wishes he had another layer on. He holds a breath and yanks the door open as fast as it’ll go on its ancient hinges, but it’s not Hop on the other side, or Billy’s dad.
“Hi,” says Steve, trying to hide his surprise but doing a pretty crappy job of it.
Max stares at him like he’s being a weirdo. “Hi,” she says.
Steve hasn’t seen her since he took Billy home from the hospital, weeks ago. She cut her hair since then, he thinks, not super short, but shorter. It’s hard to tell with the beanie and giant, homemade scarf wrapped twice around her neck. Her breath billows out in clouds as the frosted air seeps into Steve’s bones. He’s lived in Hawkins his whole damn life, and he’s still not used to how fucking cold it gets in the dead of winter. He wonders how Max can stand it, being from California, which reminds him—
“You didn’t skateboard here, did you?” he asks.
Billy and Max have pretty much the same you’re an idiot look. Steve is overly familiar.
“Uh, no,” she says and waves vaguely behind her. “Jonathan’s taking me home, but I asked him to stop here first.”
Steve notices the car now, at the end of his long driveway. He can’t really see inside with all the glare off the windows, but he waves at it anyway, wonders if Jonathan’s thinking what the hell Max wants at Steve’s.
He hasn’t really mentioned the Billy-staying-at-his-place thing to Jonathan and Nancy yet, mostly cause he hasn’t mentioned the dating-and-pretty-in-love-with-Billy thing yet, and that’s probably a necessary first step. He just hasn’t really decided how to go about it. Seemed easier to hole up for the holidays and pretend like nothing was wrong or new or different, like maybe it had always been Billy-and-Steve in this big house with no one to bother them.
But the holidays are over now, and Max is on his front stoop, and nothing gets by Jonathan, really, so.
“Did you want—” Steve starts, but Max cuts him off, shoves something into his chest.
“This came,” she says in a rush. “It looked important.”
“Oh.” Steve’s hands come up instinctively to grab it—an envelope, bulkier and bigger than the ones bills come in. Heavy, too, like it’s got a lot inside. It takes Steve more than a few seconds to realize that the William A. Hargrove written on the front means Billy, but he did just wake up, so, whatever.
It’s only when he spots the seal in the corner that he really figures it out. The letters are all in a circle, some fancy-ass font, so it takes a second for Steve to read it—University of California.
“Oh, shit,” says Steve.
He can’t believe he forgot.
With the whole Jack thing coming out at Thanksgiving, and the nightmare just a few weeks after, he completely forgot about what was supposed to be Billy’s biggest worry during the winter.
He’d been so weird, for weeks, about it in the fall, only giving Steve little hints about how things were going, when they whispered late at night—stuff the counselor said at school, places he might apply. Once, he even mentioned what he got on the SATs, and even though Steve never took them, he knows enough to know that Billy’s scores were good. He’s so smart, it blows Steve’s mind. Like, he has no fucking clue what Billy’s doing with an idiot like him.
The envelope is really official-looking. That, and Billy’s name all spelled out does something strange to Steve’s chest. William A. Hargrove sounds like someone important, like, someone in a suit, maybe, with a briefcase. Not the guy who watches MTV reruns and throws pretzels at the TV when Mark Goodman is too much.
Steve must be staring at the envelope too long, because then Max says, “Okay. Uh, I’m gonna go now.”
“Wait!"
Max stops with one foot already on the bottom step, turning over her shoulder with another familiar look, what now, asshole?
It’s just—suddenly important, that Max doesn’t leave yet, that she comes inside and sees Billy, safe and pretty okay, all things considered. Those horrible bruises are mostly gone, and the lost, faraway haze he gets takes over less and less.
And it’s just—Steve hasn’t been able to forget the silent, furious glares Max sent him the last time he saw her, and all the things she said before that, when she was still speaking to him—how he had no right to talk about Jack, and how none of this would’ve happened again if it weren’t for Steve.
If you’d just listened to me, she’d said the second time he’d gone to see her, right before they let her leave that tiny hospital bed, if you’d just stayed away, then he would’ve been safe.
That probably wasn’t true, since Billy hadn’t been safe at home for a really long time, if ever, but—
Billy cries out sometimes in his sleep, now—he never did before—and nothing Steve ever does seems to help. Steve thinks about it most then, Max’s voice in his ear saying, if it weren’t for you.
So, it’s maybe because of that, a little, that he wants her to see how much better Billy is, most of the time—how good Steve’s taking care of him.
Don’t you want to see him, he almost says, before he remembers who he’s talking to. Max and Billy aren’t related, really, but they’re kind of the same in a lot of ways, and Steve’s gotten pretty good at tricking Billy into doing things that are so fucking lame, Harrington, Jesus.
“I got you something,” Steve says, all casual, like it’s not a big deal.
“What?” Max asks, suspicious.
“For Christmas—I got stuff for all you guys, but—you’re here now, right? Just come inside for a minute, I’ll go get it.”
She hesitates on the steps, looking back at Jonathan’s car.
“They’re waiting for me. . .”
“I’ll drive you home,” he adds, his casual vibe slipping a little. Billy will never go out of his way to see her, and Max is stubborn, too. They are both so dumb, and those stupid skateboard wheels are, like, his only bargaining chip. “Seriously, it’s no big deal. It’ll take two seconds.”
Max wavers a little longer, and then the promise of a present finally wins out, which, duh. “Okay,” she says. “But I have to be home for dinner, so, like, five minutes.”
“Yeah,” says Steve, “of course, five minutes.”
But then she turns back around and starts down the driveway again. “What are you—”
“My stuff’s in the car, Steve,” she says, and he can’t see her face from here, but he knows she’s rolling her eyes at him, he can hear it.
He goes after her anyway, mostly to say hi to Jonathan, but also to make sure she’s not just messing with him, planning on getting back in the car and driving away, cause that’s something Billy would do.
“Oh my god,” she says, glancing back at him. “Are you following me?”
Steve bites back a grin. “I’m just saying hi.” That look on her face is almost as funny as the one Billy gets when he’s being a dick. It kind of makes Steve forget that she hates his guts. “It’s the polite thing to do, you know, or didn’t they teach you guys manners in California?”
“I have manners,” she says, glaring.
“Oh, yeah?” Steve loses the battle against the laugh bubbling up his throat. With her red coat and red hair and red scarf, she looks like a cold, angry tomato. “Are you hiding them in that giant hat?”
“Shut up,” she says. “You are such a dork. Like, worse than Dustin.”
“Hey,” says Steve, but they’re pretty much at the car, so he doesn’t get a chance to defend himself, or Dustin, who’s kind of a dork, sure, but so is everyone in The Party. That’s what happens when you go around calling yourself The Party. Steve accepted that a long time ago.
The passenger side window rolls down as Max clamors into the backseat.
“Hi, Steve,” says Will, waving a little.
He’s grown a few inches the past few months, but Steve thinks there’ll always be something—fragile about him, something that makes Steve feel like he could claw the eyes out of any person or thing that tries to hurt him. It’s a pretty unsettling feeling, but one Steve’s getting used to.
“Hey,” says Steve. He smiles at Will before Jonathan catches his eyes over Will’s head. He raises an eyebrow in a silent question, and—yeah. Steve guesses he’s got about twenty-four hours, give or take, before Jon and Nancy break down his door with the sheer force of their combined curiosity. He’ll—figure it out later.
“So, uh,” he starts, since Max is just standing next to him now with her backpack slung over her shoulder, no explanation offered. “I got Max something for Christmas, and I thought I’d, uh, give it to her now. Since she’s here, and all. I don’t want to keep you guys, though. I can drive her home.”
Will’s face screws up in confusion, and Jonathan looks like he buys about zero percent of that. Whatever. They’re both too nice to call him on it.
“I got you something, too, Will,” says Steve—distraction tactics.
“Oh,” says Will, smiling again. “Can I have it now, too?”
“Uh, I’ll give it to you later.”
“Did you get me something,” says Jonathan, smirking, that asshole.
“Yeah, yeah,” says Steve. “I got you both stuff—good stuff, too, but, uh, Max has to go soon, so, I’ll give it to you later, I promise, okay?”
“You can bring it to the party,” says Will.
“Right,” says Steve, and then—“Wait. What party?” Max rolls her eyes again.
“The New Year’s party,” Will says. He frowns and then adds, slowly, “It’s—New Year’s today, Steve.”
Steve pretends he doesn’t hear Jonathan laugh at that, barely resists rolling his own eyes. “Yeah, thanks, man, I got that part. What New Year’s party?”
“Um, the one at Mike’s house? The one they have every year?”
Definitely sounds like something Steve should know. Except, he wasn’t here for New Year’s last year. His mom decided two days before Christmas that what he really needed to get out of this funk you’ve been in, sweetheart, was to spend ten days in Bali—ten miserable days, drinking daiquiris alone on the beach with his mom, cause that definitely cured him.
“Right, I, uh, forgot about that.”
“You’re coming, though, right? Mike’s mom gets this, like, fake champagne so we can toast at midnight.”
“It’s sparkling cider,” says Jonathan. He must sense some of Steve’s panic, trying to come up with an excuse for missing a party with literally every person Steve knows, cause he adds, “We should get going. We’re gonna go early, to help set up.”
“Oh, yeah,” says Will, and does a little wave again. “See you guys there.”
Steve and Max watch them drive away for all of thirty seconds before Steve can’t take the fucking cold anymore. He sprints back to the house with Max laughing behind him, taking her sweet time.
When the front door is finally closed against the wind, he leads Max to the living room, only panicking slightly at what Billy’s gonna think about this sort of ambush. Billy’s gone when they get there, though, the TV still on, but the volume turned down low, like he was trying to listen for Steve after he left.
His book’s still there—that fancy Shakespeare shit Billy reads out loud sometimes to make Steve laugh—and other stuff, too, scattered around, hints of the past few weeks. AP textbooks stashed under the coffee table, vinyls Billy rescued from the basement stacked next to the record player. There’s at least two pairs of socks strewn around the room, cause Billy’s got this awful habit of taking them off when he’s hot and never picking them up, even though Steve complains about it, like, sixty times a day.
Steve wonders if Max notices the difference since she was over in the summer, if it’s obvious that it’s not just him living here anymore, but him and Billy—all their stuff mixing together. He wonders for the first time if it’s weird for her, not having Billy at home, if it’s quieter, if she likes it better, or misses him.
He tries to get a look at her face under the brim of her hat and that big scarf, but then there’s a clang from the kitchen, and they both start towards it instinctively.
It’s just Billy, his back to the door, messing with something by the stove. Pretty much every pot Steve owns is out on the counters, plus spices, utensils, random vegetables Steve has no memory of buying. He knows Billy can cook—it’s one of those secret things Steve’s learned that makes his heart feel way too big—but Billy mostly doesn’t bother with fancy, from scratch stuff.
Steve would bet every one of his Christmas presents that Billy came to find Steve when he didn’t come back, saw him and Max down the driveway, and retreated to the kitchen to panic, covering it up like he’s planning some big meal. He’s so dumb.
Steve wants to wrap his arms around Billy’s too-tight shoulders and kiss his stupid face until he calms down. But Max is here, and Billy probably wouldn’t like that anyway, so he just coughs and says,
“Hey, Max is here.”
Max shifts next to him, messing with the strap of her bag. Billy doesn’t turn around, cause he’s an asshole like that, just keeps chopping shit. If Billy was looking at him, Steve would throw the envelope at his head to make him swear and call Steve a fucking dick. But his back’s still turned, and Steve doesn’t like doing that if he’s not paying attention.
He gets closer instead, leaving Max hovering awkwardly in the doorway.
“Hey,” he says again, “Look what came, dick face.” He drops the heavy envelope onto the counter next to the cutting board, where it lands with a solid thwack. Billy’s hands still and his shoulders get even tighter. He stares at the front of it—William A. Hargrove—for a long minute and then shrugs.
“That it?” he says, like he didn’t spend actual months of his life agonizing over this exact moment.
“Oh my god.” Steve hates him so much. “Open it, asshole.”
He raises an eyebrow that mocking way he does, making fun of Steve. “No,” he says.
“Max came all the way here just to give you this,” Steve says, really laying it on and trying to be serious, except, Billy looks so stupid like that and it’s hard not to laugh at his dumb face. “And you’re not even gonna open it? Billy, she is dying to know.”
“Uh,” says Max from the doorway. “I’m here for my present.”
Billy snorts and goes back to cutting peppers—which, when did they get peppers? Never mind, the point is—
“Open it.”
“Sort of busy here, Harrington.”
“God, if you don’t—”
“Jesus, man. I’m gonna open it. Just—later. Go get the fucking present.”
And Steve would put up more of a fight, except, then Billy’s wiping his hands with a kitchen towel, and when Steve turns to look at Max, she’s sitting at the breakfast bar eying the fruit bowl, so maybe now is a good time to retreat and let them talk.
“Fine.” He still hates letting Billy think he’s won.
“What’d he get me?” he hears Max say as he wanders back into the living room.
He wastes some time picking up Billy’s gross socks, straightening the records and the books by the coffee table. He gets legitimately distracted by that Brooke Shields ad that’s always playing, and by the time he’s dug Max’s present out from under the tree, it’s been seven, maybe eight solid minutes—plenty of time for bonding and minimal time for fighting.
When Steve gets back to kitchen, Max is chewing on a piece of pepper and laughing. Billy’s got his half-blank, half-smug face on, which means he just said something funny, but is pretending like he wasn’t trying to be funny. Steve doesn’t bother hiding his grin.
“You get lost or something, man?” says Billy when he sees him.
Steve shrugs and says, “That Arrid ad was on,” mostly cause he’s still pissed Billy hasn’t opened the letter yet, and Billy hates the look Steve gets when Brooke Shields is on TV. It’s not his fault he still likes girls, and anyway, even if he only liked guys, he’d still watch it every time. Brooke’s the most beautiful woman in the world, that’s just a fact.
Billy rolls his eyes and goes back to washing stuff in the sink. Max tilts sideways in her stool, looking at him, expectant.
“Okay,” Steve starts, handing her the store-wrapped gift. It looks a lot better than the one he wrapped for Billy, with shiny, red paper and a perfectly coiled bow. “I thought it was kind of cool, but I still have the receipt, so if you don’t like it, just tell me and we can totally go back and—”
“Man, shut up,” says Billy, peering at him over his shoulder. “You ever let people open shit without your running commentary, or is that, like, tradition for you?”
“Asshole,” says Steve. He mostly can’t help the way it comes out less annoyed than he’d like. “Do I look like I’m talking to you?”
“Tell you what you look like—”
“Oh,” says Max, getting the ribbon loose enough to tear the paper off. Steve feels stupidly nervous until she smiles kind of small and glances up at him.
“Thanks, Steve,” she says.
“You like them?”
Max rubs her fingers along the clear plastic on the box, where the four red wheels peak out. RAT BONES, says the blue font on the front of each one, which Steve thought was kind of weird, but the guy at the store assured Steve these were the nicest wheels we got, man, they’re straight from California.
“Yeah,” says Max. She slides off the stool and hugs him, there and gone, too fast for Steve to even hug back. She rocks back on her heels. “Really. They’re sick.”
“Sick?” Steve echoes, looking at Billy to share this incredible moment of mocking that’s about to happen, but Billy’s eyes are so soft when he finds them, just—extra blue. It throws Steve for a second, makes his throat stutter.
“Yeah, Steve,” says Max before he can go on, rolling her eyes, back to being too cool, or whatever. “Sorry, did you want me to say it Indiana talk? Aw, shucks, Steve, this sure is swell. Thank you, kindly.”
“Oh my god,” Steve laughs. Max is seriously too much for him, she’s funnier than Billy by half. “Are you hearing this?” When he looks back at Billy, his lips are twitching. “Your sister’s making fun of me.”
“Yup,” says Billy.
Steve quirks an eyebrow the way he hates. “You gonna do something about it?”
“What do you want me to do?”
“Uh, defend my honor, asshole.”
Billy stares at him for a beat and the gets a glint in his eyes Steve doesn’t like. “Maxine,” he says, all fake stern. Max’s eyes get big like she’s paying extra attention. “Quit picking on Steve. He can’t help how he was born.”
“How’s that?” Max says, like some cartoon from fifties.
Billy smirks. “A total hick.”
Steve can’t believe this—what was he thinking, getting them talking again? Now, they’re just gonna gang up on him all the time.
“Alright,” he says, after they’ve laughed at him for a while. “I get it, you guys think you’re so fucking cool, just cause you grew up with, like, beaches and the sun. Well, whatever. In Indiana, we have the Indi 500 and we make 20% of the nation’s popcorn. So, you know. You’re welcome.”
Max starts giggling again, which sets Billy off, and then Steve has to join in too, even though they suck, because Billy’s laugh is pretty contagious and also the best sound ever.
“Damn,” says Billy, when he’s caught his breath. “I take it back, man. This is clearly the better state.”
“I accept your apology, and you’re right.”
They kind of just grin at each other for a second, which is maybe too much for Max, cause she mumbles something about the bathroom and wanders out of the room. Billy starts filling a pot with water, so Steve uses the moment alone to finally curl around him like he’s wanted to this whole time. Seeing Billy do stuff in his kitchen makes him feel a weird, warm kind of way, probably cause no one’s ever really used his kitchen much before. It’s been mostly for show his whole life.
He wraps his arms around Billy’s middle and tucks his chin over his shoulder, just breathing him in. He smells like Steve’s soap and Steve’s sheets. When it’s been long enough to make Billy huff, Steve loosens his grip just a little and says, “Whatcha making me?”
“Who says it’s for you?”
“Oh, are you doing things for other people now? Besides me?”
Billy shrugs like, that’s fair, making Steve laugh. He presses his cheek against Steve’s and leans into him. “It’s just chicken and rice,” he says.
“Then what’s with all the vegetables?”
Billy snorts. “That’s how you make chicken and rice, dude. Just trust me. I ever make you shit you didn’t like?”
No, he hasn’t, because Billy can cook, but he seriously doesn’t need the ego boost.
“I guess we’ll see,” Steve says. Billy tries to elbow him in the gut, but he’s pretty predictable so Steve’s already shifted away, laughing. He catches sight of Max in the doorway, who’s got a weird look on her face, like maybe she saw them just now—probably not so great for his big plan to get her to like him again.
“Max,” he says, “You want to, um, stay for dinner? Billy’s making chicken.”
“That’s okay,” says Max, “I mean. Thanks, but I have to eat dinner with my mom, before the party. It’s the only way she’s letting me go.” She tugs at the scarf around her neck for a beat and then adds, “Are you gonna come?”
Steve can feel Billy’s curious stare at the back of his neck, but he doesn’t turn around. “Nah,” he says, trying for casual and mostly succeeding. “I, uh, got other plans.”
Max nods like that’s what she figured. She comes into the kitchen only far enough to grab her bag and then starts to shift backward toward the door again. “I sort of have to go.”
“Right,” Steve says, trying not to feel too bummed. Billy and Max talked for eight full minutes, even laughed. No one yelled or cried, and Max liked his gift. That’s pretty good for something Steve didn’t even plan ahead of time.
He follows her out, stopping in the doorway for one last look at Billy before he leaves. He’s already busy doing stuff, grabbing something green from the counter, like some kind of actual fucking herb. He must not know Steve’s still watching, cause he brings the leaves up to his nose and breathes in deep, eyes falling closed with how good it must be.
Why that makes Steve so warm, he doesn’t know, but he feels it all over, tingling his skin, filling his lungs. He tries to play it cool and starts down the hall, where Max is at the door already, shoving her feet hurriedly into her boots. He makes it about five steps in her direction before he can’t handle it.
“Hey,” he says, “I, um. Forgot the keys in the kitchen. You go ahead, just—meet me by the car?”
Max stares at him for half a beat before she rolls her eyes, not believing him for a second. “Two minutes,” she says as she tugs the heavy front door open.
Steve waits until it bangs shut behind her, then races back up the hall, his socks sliding a little on the hardwood. Billy must hear him coming cause he looks expectant when Steve steps back through the doorway.
“What now?” he says.
“Nothing,” says Steve.
Then he crowds Billy into the counter, cups his face with both hands, and kisses him, hard and deep. Billy makes a soft, startled sound but recovers soon enough, dragging Steve closer by his hips.
It’s just so good—Billy’s steady warmth, and the perfect, heavy press of his hands slipping under the back of Steve’s sweater to rest on his skin. The joy curling hot inside of Steve is a wild, aching thing he never wants to lose.
A long, angry honk sounds from the driveway, and Billy pulls back to laugh, quick and breathless. His hair’s all messed up, even though Steve hasn’t touched it, and his eyes are bright with amusement, so blue it should be illegal.
“Man,” he pants, still close enough for Steve to feel the air against his lips. “What’s up with you?”
“Nothing,” Steve says again, the word muffled by the thumb Billy presses to his grin. Steve kisses it, mostly to make Billy roll his eyes. “I’m just. . . happy.”
Billy’s smirk dims to something smaller, softer. “Yeah?” he says, more surprised than Steve likes, as if he doesn’t know how much better Steve is, every day, cause of him. Steve’s gonna have to work on that.
But another loud honk blares then, so Steve doesn’t have time to come up with something nice and smart to say about all this love that feels too big to fit inside him.
So, he just says, “Yeah,” definitive, hoping Billy will use his mind-reading power to sort out the rest.
Billy swipes his thumb over Steve’s lips one more time and then pushes him towards the door. “You better go before she blows out that horn.”
“I don’t think that’s how horns work, dude.”
“Oh, man, what?” says Billy, stricken, making his eyes all big.
He’s so goddamn dramatic. Steve laughs and backs towards the door. “You gonna have dinner waiting for me when I get home, baby?” he says, to piss Billy off and to see the way he gets all red when Steve calls him that.
Billy flips him off with one hand and wipes at his face with the other, like he can hide his blush that way—what a dork.
“Fuck you,” he says.
“Maybe later,” says Steve and then he darts out of the kitchen just in time to avoid whatever Billy tries to throw at him.
Steve’s grin’s still in place when he slams the car door, even with Max glaring at him like an angry, red thundercloud.
“Find your keys?” she says, dead flat. Steve just smiles wider.
“Yup,” he says and twists the keys in the ignition to prove his point.
He watches the mirror as he backs out of the driveway, but he can still feel Max’s stare. When he gets on the road he glances at her just in time to see her shift her gaze out the window.
“You have something on your face,” she says.
Steve wipes at his cheek until he feels something stuck to it. He tries not to laugh when he sees what it is, because maybe Max is actually mad at him for making out with Billy instead of driving her home, like, that would make total sense. He can’t help it, though. He’s in too good a mood.
He shows her the tiny dot on his finger. “Pepper seed,” he says and then flicks it at her. It’s small enough to disappear instantly, but Max presses her body against the door anyway, trying to dodge it.
“Ugh,” she scowls and then turns wholly toward the window, crossing her arms over her chest.
They don’t speak for a while after that, but Steve’s not bothered. The silence doesn’t feel stuffy or mad, just normal. Still, he’d rather put something on, and maybe letting Max pick the music would get her to loosen her tight grip on her arms a little.
“Do you—” he starts, but Max chooses that moment to speak, too.
“I wanted—”
After a minute of them both just waiting for the other to start, Steve says, “You go first.”
Max keeps her eyes locked out the window and hugs her backpack to her chest, fiddling with the zipper. “I wanted to say sorry,” she starts, awkwardly. “For that stuff I said, at the hospital. I guess—I don’t really think that. I know it didn’t really happen because of you. I mean, Billy—he would’ve got hurt anyway.”
Steve waits a beat to make sure she’s done and then says, “I’m sorry, too.” He keeps his eyes on the road, but he can tell by the blur of red in the corner of his vision that Max turns to look at him. “I’m not sorry I told Hopper, but I’m sorry that I tried to make you do it. I should’ve just told him from the start. You shouldn’t have to get mixed up in this again.”
“What do you mean?” Max asks, and when Steve risks a glance at her, she looks genuinely confused. “I am mixed up in it. It happened cause of me.”
Steve’s bright mood slips away at that. He remembers suddenly the way Max had phrased it before she got mad at him—her panicked, shaking voice that awful night saying, if it weren’t for me.
“I know it feels like that,” he says, trying not to sound so after school special, but not knowing how else to put it. “But, Max, it’s no one’s fault but Neil’s. Okay? I know it doesn’t seem like it, but you’re still a kid. And you were definitely still a kid when this all happened. You didn’t know. You never would’ve told if you’d known what was gonna happen, right?”
“No,” says Max, “I never would’ve—I didn’t think it was such a big deal. Billy always said—but he’s so dramatic, and he lies all the time. I didn’t know.”
“Yeah,” says Steve. “That’s what’s important, okay? And. . .” Steve trails off, wondering if this is gonna push it too far. But he knows that, out of all the people who matter, there’s only him and Billy and Hopper who know just how Max was involved. Steve can’t imagine them saying this, and someone has to.
“If Jack was here,” Steve goes on, trying not to make it obvious how weird he feels saying that name out loud, “I don’t think he’d blame you. I know Billy said all that shit about him not being your friend, but you know how Billy gets when he’s mad—he always seems to know, like, the exact last thing you’d ever want to hear.
“And—he’s told me about California. Not a lot, but—Jack did stuff with you guys all the time, right? Like—you went to Disneyland?”
Steve glances at Max in time to see her head whip up from staring at her lap. Her eyes are wide with disbelief.
“He told you about that?”
Steve’s smile is small and brief. “Sort of, I mean—he never said Jack was there, but he’s told me that story about a hundred times.” Steve shrugs, thinks about the way Billy pauses in weird places, the way his voice gets rough and low. “I can tell when he’s leaving stuff out.”
Max stares at him for a long time and then looks out the window again without saying anything.
Steve thinks maybe he’s gone too far, but he also can’t really stop himself when he’s got more to say. It’s kind of a curse. “Anyway, I just mean—I think Jack was your friend. I think he knew you’d never hurt him, or Billy, not on purpose. I don’t think he’d ever blame you, not in a million years.”
Max is quiet for a while longer, and then she says, almost too soft to hear, “Billy blames me.”
It cuts at something deep in Steve’s gut, because—yeah, that’s probably true. She’s just a kid, and she didn’t know, but Jack was Billy’s whole world. It might be years before he’s ready to accept that it wasn’t Max’s fault.
Instead of trying to explain all that, Steve says, “Billy loves you,” because it’s true, even if neither of them will admit it. Max scoffs, like he figured she would.
“I’m serious. Look. Billy—he’s an asshole, okay? He doesn’t give a shit about people. Like, just, general people, strangers, whatever. But, you’re his sister. Maybe not by like—blood, or whatever, but he calls you that all the time. He wouldn’t do that if he didn’t love you.”
Max is staring out the window again and blinking too fast. Steve really needs to shut up, but he never knows how. “He’ll get it, Max, eventually. He’s just—he’s still really mad, and—hurt, I think. But. He’s getting better. I know you don’t see him that often anymore, but. I really think he is.”
Max says nothing back, and the only sound the whole rest of the way is the Carly Simon playing on 95.1, so sad and slow it makes Steve want to switch it off, but silence would probably be worse.
When he pulls onto Old Cherry Road, he slows down about thirty yards from Max’s house before he remembers there’s no real reason to anymore. But even after he parks right by the driveway, Max doesn’t get out, just sits and messes with the strap on her backpack.
It’s seems like a really long time before she sniffs and says, “I don’t—get it. How he can be with someone else, so fast. But, I guess. If he has to be with somebody in Hawkins, I’m glad it’s you.”
Weirdly touched, Steve says, “Thanks,” but that sounds dumb, so he adds, “Me too.”
Max smiles at that before she finally pushes the passenger side door open. Steve watches her get in okay before he heads back home.
It’s hard to not to speed as he gets closer, wanting so bad to get rid of the heavy sinking in his chest, thinking about all this again, Billy grieving somebody he loved so much. Steve tries to imagine it for a second, how it would feel to lose this warm, gold thing for good, but it’s barely a moment before he has to shake the thought away, too terrible to think about.
When he finally gets back, he stands in the hall for a minute, leans against the front door and tries to call up some of the happy he felt before—he really, really hates how quickly he loses it. Sometimes, it feels like it takes days and days of nice things in a row to build up a mood that good, and then it all slips away with one conversation.
After a few more minutes with no real luck, he drifts toward the kitchen, following some amazing smell and the faint sound of music that means Billy’s got the radio on.
Steve recognizes the song before he gets there—Billy’s got such stupid taste when he thinks nobody’s listening—and he opens his mouth to mock him before he's even through the door, but the sight in the kitchen distracts him.
If it was a mess before, it’s a war zone now, with three steaming pans on the stove, the sink running, and every inch of counter space covered with dirty towels, mixing bowls, and all the stems and shit that comes from using real vegetables.
And then there’s Billy, in the middle of it all, swaying and bopping his head, moving from counter to stove to sink, and back again, like he’s cooked here for years, instead of just the last few weeks.
And it’s so dumb, that Steve even bothered trying to pull it together alone, cause all it takes is one second of watching Billy make a giant fool of himself to spark that warmth again, so easy.
The song hits the chorus, and Billy starts using the spatula he’s got in his hand like a mic. It’s only when he turns that he catches sight of Steve in the doorway, but he doesn’t stop like he might’ve a month or two ago, just smirks and dances toward Steve, grabs his hand to pull him closer.
“You know I'd do anything for you,” he mouths along, gripping Steve’s hips and making him match Billy’s moves, “Stay the night but keep it under cover.”
“You are such an idiot,” Steve says loudly over the music, but Billy just scrunches his face in mock confusion and shakes his head, like he can’t hear him, keeps singing,
“I just want to use your love tonight.” He shifts his hands lower down Steve’s back, like he’s so slick or something, and it’s too much. Steve laughs in his face, but Billy doesn’t seem to care. He presses the next line into Steve’s lips, “I don't want to lose your love tonight.”
Steve makes sure he can’t sing the rest, because it’s embarrassing, and also cause there are seriously better things he can be doing with his mouth.
At the table later, when Steve’s finishing his second helping of seriously crazy good chicken, Billy kicks at the leg of his chair and says, “So, what party?”
Steve’s got his mouth full, so all he manages back is, “Hmm?”
Billy raises his eyebrow, and Steve doesn’t know anymore, if he does that to mock him or if he’s picked it up for real. “The party Max was talking about.”
“Oh, um, it's nothing.” Steve shrugs and scrapes at the last bits of rice on his plate. “Just this New Year’s thing at Nancy’s. I honestly, like, completely forgot about it.”
Billy doesn’t say anything, and when Steve looks back at him, his jaw is tense and he’s scraping at his plate too, even though there’s really nothing left.
After a weird moment of silence that rubs wrong at Steve’s skin, Billy says, “We don’t have to spend every fucking second together, Harrington. I’m not gonna, like, fall to pieces if you go out.”
Steve stares at him for a minute, waiting for a catch that doesn’t come, and then says, “Are you serious?”
When Billy finally looks up, he’s glaring. “Yeah, asshole, I can last one night without you, but thanks for the vote of confidence.”
Steve rolls his eyes at him and stamps down on the annoyance buzzing at the back of his brain. For someone so smart, Billy can be so dumb sometimes, even with his mind-reading thing—which must not be working tonight.
“I know you can, asshole. I meant—you really think I want to spend New Year’s at the Wheeler’s? Instead of here?”
Billy shrugs, like he couldn’t care less either way. “You don’t have to pretend they’re not your friends just cause they don’t like me, man. I really don’t give a shit.”
“Oh my god. Seriously?” When Billy just stares blankly at him, Steve sets his fork down and holds his hands out like he’s weighing shit, because clearly Billy is so dumb he needs, like, visuals. “Let’s see—I could spend New Year’s at my ex-girlfriend’s house with her whole family—who’ve never liked me, by the way—and baby-sit, like, six preteens, hopped up on sugar and up past their bedtimes, while every adult I know gets shitfaced. Or—” Steve lifts the other hand. “I could spend it in my own home, where it’s nice and warm, and watch the ball drop on my giant TV and make-out with my hot boyfriend all night.” He juggles the invisible weights for a second. “Really tough one there, I don’t know.”
Billy just stares at him, so Steve drops his hands with a sigh and says, “Seriously, dude. I don’t want to go to the party, okay. I really did forget about it, cause I was, you know, looking forward to just—hanging out with you. And, like, finally kissing someone I like at midnight.”
Of course, that’s the part that gets Billy’s attention. He smirks a little and says, “You never kissed anyone at midnight?”
“Uh, okay, I’m not a loser.” Billy raises his eyebrow again, and this time it’s definitely mocking. Steve rolls his eyes. “Shut up. Of course, I have. Just—never anybody important, you know?”
“What, Wheeler didn’t give it up last year?”
“I wasn’t here last year, for New Year’s, and we—broke up by then.”
Billy nods and then gets weird again, fiddles with his fork. For some reason, Steve flashes back to Max sitting in the passenger seat, toying with her bag and not looking at him. “Whatever,” says Billy, “You don’t have to stay here, but like. That’s, uh. That sounds good.”
Steve’s torn between teasing him some more or kissing that stupid, careful look off his face. It’s not that close a contest, though. Messing with Billy is too much fun. “Oh, yeah? I got permission to leave, huh?”
“Yup.”
“Oh, well, in that case.” Steve shoots up like he’s gonna make a run for the door, and he gets as far as the kitchen island before he feels Billy’s arms around his waist, his face in the back of his neck.
“You’re so fucking stupid,” he mumbles into Steve’s skin.
“You’re the one in love with me,” says Steve, his skin flushing hot at being able to say that and know it’s true. “What does that make you?”
Billy twists Steve around in his arms. “An idiot,” he says. But then he’s kissing Steve really, really soft, like how they used to back in summer, when they were just sort of figuring things out. It makes something burst open in Steve, something so bright his eyes start to burn with it, which doesn’t really make sense, and he’s not going to cry, it just feels like it.
“Love you,” Steve pants when Billy finally lets him go, and he can’t really shut up because it’s all he can think, just the one thought lighting up his brain over and over, “Love you, love you, love you.” He presses it each time into a different part of Billy’s dumb face.
“Jesus,” says Billy after too long of that. “I get it, you loser, get off me.”
Steve lets him pull away and just watches him sort out the kitchen for a minute or two, before he flicks the radio on and joins him.
At three minutes to midnight, Steve is yellow and hazy and warm. Literally nothing in the world could bother him right now—except for whatever is fucking poking him in the face, what the fuck.
“Harrington,” it says, sounding a lot like Billy. “I can’t fucking believe this. Dude, are you seriously gonna miss this fucking ball drop after we’ve sat here for, like, hours watching this thing—Steve.”
“What,” says Steve.
“Oh my god. Man, wake up. Do you want to fucking kiss me or not?”
Steve blinks harder at that, cause the only thing better than sleeping is kissing Billy. But when he can finally focus, Billy’s glaring at him, which doesn’t seem promising.
“Twenty seconds, dude. You are cutting this so close.”
The volume on the TV is down real low, but if he strains, Steve can just hear the faint sound of people cheering seventeen, sixteen, fifteen—
“Come ‘ere,” Steve mumbles, making grabbing motions at Billy’s face, cause he’s too far away and Steve’s too tired to go to him.
But Billy just squints at him. “You awake for real?” he says.
“God, Billy. Shut up and kiss me, we’re gonna miss it.”
“Well, who the fuck’s fault is that, man—”
The voices on the TV get a little louder, chanting six, five, four—
“Billy,” says Steve.
—three, two—
Billy finally huffs and lets Steve pull him closer.
He doesn’t think they miss it, but once Billy’s lips are on his, warm and soft and perfect, it’s really hard to tell if time is passing at all.
They kiss forever, until Billy whispers, “Happy New Year, baby,” into Steve’s mouth and Steve hums back, just awake enough to murmur, “Love you,” one last time before he drifts back off.
