Actions

Work Header

songbird

Chapter 10: How Soon Is Now

Summary:

Big News all around.

Notes:

Okay, this one is a doozy.

I really want to thank you guys in the comments for pointing out that Steve and Billy needed to clear things up in terms of how much Jack is still hanging over the relationship. I guess because I love hurt/comfort, this was how my mind decided to do that. In 13k words, because at the end of the day this fic is self-indulgent, and I wanted to keep everything in, so I did.

Thank you to everyone who has been reading/commenting/kudos-ing, whether from the beginning or just now—I love all of you! This is the first long fic I've ever written, and all your encouragement helps more than you can imagine!

This will be the last real "chapter," as the next one (should be) an epilogue. I think it will likely be a bit longer before the next update, since I'll probably linger over the ending forever. But, like I've been saying, expect more from this universe in the future.

 

In terms of Warnings for this chapter — in the scene at Jonathan's house, there is reference to a relationship that is borderline non-con because of age difference (I don't condone it, but the character doesn't see it that way). If you think this could be difficult for you to read, you can skip from “Always?” to "It is the point." and I'll summarize in the end notes.

I hope you enjoy! Let me know what you think!

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

 

 

 

It’s January 4, 1986, Saturday—the best day of the week. It used to be Sundays, the only mornings Steve ever got to wake up with Billy, got to see him all golden in the early light, and grumbly, rubbing his face into his pillow like a kid.

But now that Steve gets Billy every morning, Saturdays mean waking slow and easy, with no alarms threatening work or school, and the whole day stretched out in front of them with none of that almost-Monday stress.

Today stands to be one of the best ones yet, with Billy’s rough, so good, baby, kissed into Steve’s neck and his big, warm hands pressing him into the shower tiles after that—but when Steve finally makes his way down to the kitchen and sees that fucking envelope still sitting on the countertop, unopened, after three full days, his good vibe is sort of ruined.

Billy’s at the stove making omelets, so Steve restrains himself from throwing it at him, hops onto the counter next to him instead and shoves it in his face.

“What’s with this,” Steve says.

“Uh, rude?” says Billy. 

“Billy,” says Steve, not in the mood. “Seriously. How is this not driving you crazy?”

Billy shrugs, his I don’t want to talk about it shrug, which is not quite his I have no fucking clue shrug and tighter than his I couldn’t care less shrug. Steve’s gotten pretty good at reading his shoulders, but that doesn’t mean he gets the bigger stuff, like why Billy wouldn’t want to know already.

Especially cause, and Steve’s no expert, but this envelope is fucking heavy. There’s no way any school would send a whole file of papers for a rejection letter. Steve’s, like, 95% sure that means Billy got in, and if Steve can figure that out, Billy definitely can—so he just doesn’t get it.

“What if I open it?” Steve asks, already working a finger under the glue. Billy snatches it from him before he can do more than that, which was sort of the point. He waits for him to open it instead, counting on Billy’s need to always be first for everything, but he just tosses it on the breakfast bar and goes back to cooking.

“What the fuck,” says Steve, but Billy stays silent.

The quiet gets heavy, then, and too-full, even after Billy pulls two plates down from the cabinet and divides the giant omelet between them. He shuffles around the kitchen grabbing napkins and silverware and ketchup for Steve, even though he thinks it’s disgusting (seriously, dude, ketchup on eggs, are you a fucking heathen?), but he doesn’t look at Steve once. It’s hard not to feel like shit, a little, at that, because usually Billy laughs when he cooks, and dances, and steals kisses from Steve whenever he can, and now he’s not even looking.

They only get two breakfasts a week, like this, now that the holidays are over, and Steve’s fucked this one up in the span of thirty seconds—so, it’s like a record, or something, and it sucks.

Billy sets everything carefully at the table and only spares Steve a glance when he finally sits down, raises an eyebrow at him, like, coming?

So, Steve sits, too, and tries to eat, but his stomach feels like knots. And it’s so stupid, because he knows that Billy’s probably not even mad, that the air can’t possibly be as thick as it feels, pressing on him, weighing down his lungs.

“Hey,” says Billy after an hour, or maybe just five minutes, but it’s hard to tell. When Steve looks up from his plate, Billy’s got his confused eyebrows on. He looks at Steve for half a second before he sets his fork down and reaches to cradle Steve’s face with one hand, rubs his thumb at the edge of Steve’s jaw.

“Not mad you,” he says lowly, cause he’s a mind-reader about 80% of the time, at least. “I just. Don’t want to open it yet.”

“Okay,” says Steve, because yeah, that was pretty obvious, and Steve needs to learn how to, like, let things go. Leaving things alone is not his strong suit, but he needs to get better at it, cause Billy’s so good about all Steve’s weird, fucked-up things, and Steve could do, like, the least by giving him this—space, or whatever. “Sorry.”

“Okay. Make it up to me by, like, eating your fucking breakfast. I slaved over that stove, you know, you could, like, appreciate it.” But he’s grinning when he says it and it’s so easy to fall into their normal again.

“Was it, like, exhausting?” Steve asks. “All ten minutes it took you?”

“Oh, you think you could do it? That’s pretty big talk for Steve ‘Burns-Campbell's-Soup’ Harrington.”

“Okay, asshole, that was one time, and—”

“Yeah, one time, cause I banned you from soup after that. Banned you from toast, pasta, eggs, definitely cookies—man, you got anything left?”

“I guess I wouldn’t know, cause I got my own personal chef now." 

“Oh, really?” 

“Yeah, I mean, he’s an okay kisser, I guess, but the food’s the only reason I’m keeping him arou—” Steve cuts off with a laugh when Billy throws his crust at him. He catches it just before it bounces off the table and stuffs it in his mouth, chewing obnoxiously at Billy until he laughs, too.

Steve eats the rest of his omelet as Billy goes on about how Steve would be hopeless without me, man, like pizza five times a week, or starving, his ankles knocking against Billy’s under the table.

 

 

 

Billy might not want to open the envelope right away, but Steve definitely got him thinking about it again, cause Steve catches him glancing at it the rest of the morning. He keeps finding excuses to go back into the kitchen—cleaning dishes, getting snacks, one time bringing Steve a glass of water even though he didn’t ask for it and basically never drinks water unless forced.

When Steve wakes from his post-lunch haze to find Billy’s spot empty again, he stumbles into the kitchen, leans against the doorway, and watches with bleary eyes as Billy just stares and stares at the letter. His back’s to the door, so he doesn’t notice Steve shuffling over until he wraps his arms around Billy’s waist and presses his forehead to Billy’s neck.

He wants to try again, to say, I’ll open it for you, or you’re so smart, baby, or if you didn’t get in, you can stay here with me. But he did learn something from this morning, so even though it’s killing him watching Billy worry so much over some stupid paper, he keeps quiet and just holds him.

Billy leans back into him and puts a hand over Steve’s, but he doesn’t talk, so Steve doesn’t either. They just stand like that, for long enough that Steve starts to feel like he’s falling asleep all draped around Billy, which can’t be comfortable. So, after maybe twenty minutes, he kisses Billy softly, just once, at the base of his neck and goes back to the couch for a post-nap nap.

When he wakes up again, the sun’s going down, the carpet littered with golden squares of light from the windowpanes. Billy’s got all the lamps on already—he’s so good like that—and he’s rubbing Steve’s feet absently, watching some football game on low.

Steve stretches a little and sighs, and when he looks at Billy again, he’s looking back, smiling at him kind of weird, like a dope.

“Hey,” says Billy, and something about the sound of his voice all low and full makes Steve want to kiss him. There’s nothing stopping him but gravity and the sweet, warm pull of the couch, so Steve fights both, struggles up until he’s sitting—halfway there. Just when he’s about to reach over and get Billy to close the last few inches, he catches sight of something white on the coffee table. The letter—opened and scattered, all however-many pages spread out, sort of curled up from being folded so long.

Steve snaps his gaze to Billy, but he just looks back, frustratingly silent, so Steve reaches slowly towards the paper. 

“Can I . . .?”

Billy nods and Steve snatches the letter so fast he almost gets a paper cut, but he’s been waiting days, and he’s so done with being patient. He doesn’t read the whole thing, because that would take forever, but he catches pleased to inform and class of 1990 and looking forward to, and that’s enough for Steve to get the gist of it.

He knew already, he really did, so it’s kind of crazy, the rush he gets reading it for it real—Billy got into college, a good one, too, in California, which Steve knows he misses like crazy even if he never says so. Steve wants to laugh or maybe cry, but he does neither, just tosses the letter hastily on the table and crawls over all the blankets to get to Billy.

He climbs clumsily into Billy’s lap, grabs his face, and kisses him—on his cheeks, on his nose, on his eyebrow, everywhere he can reach. For once, he can’t even speak, too overwhelmed with loving Billy so much he might burst from it.

Billy huffs like he’s annoyed, but his hands on Steve’s hips are steady, pulling him closer. Steve breathes into his Billy’s neck for a minute, trying to center himself, before he leans back just enough to meet Billy’s eyes. He cups his face, thumbs over his cheeks.

“I’m so fucking proud of you,” Steve says, and he can’t help how it comes out, rough with tears, and he’s not crying, but he might in a second, so what.

Billy’s eyes get kind of wide, like he’s not used to hearing that, which Steve guesses he wouldn’t be, wonders at the last person who told Billy they were proud of him, if anyone ever has. That doesn’t make it easier to fight the burning in his eyes, so he just kisses Billy again, soft and quick, what else can he do.

“I mean it,” he goes on, helpless with it and needing Billy to know. “You’re so smart, and you deserve this so much, like, more than anybody, and I love you so much, I’m just—” losing it, basically, is what he’s doing, but Billy doesn’t seem to mind. He rubs his hands up and down Steve’s back and when Steve has to hide his face in Billy’s neck again, he presses a kiss to Steve’s temple.

When Steve gets a hold of himself again, he sits back in Billy’s lap, braces his palms against his chest and says, “We should celebrate.”

Billy squeezes his hips, but counters with, “Thought you had plans tonight,” which, Steve does—with Nancy and Johnathan, but he doesn’t want to think about that now, and also—

“Not for hours,” he says, smirking a little. “Like, hours and hours. I can think of some things we can do.”  

“Oh, yeah?”

“Yeah. Like, anything you want.”

“Anything?” says Billy. Then, he sort of tilts Steve to the side to get a better look at the TV and adds, “Cause, like, the Rams are up by three and—”

“Billy.”

But then he’s pushing Steve off his lap and into the sofa cushions, moves to follow him down, except there’s stuff getting in the way. 

“These fucking blankets,” he mutters under his breath as he tries to untangle them from Steve’s legs and throw them off to the side.

It shouldn’t be so funny, but Steve’s half-hysterical already, so he starts laughing and can’t really stop, until Billy finally wins against the Italian cashmere throw and kisses him quiet.

 

 

 

Later, after their second shower of the day, they’re back on the couch, waiting for the new Miami Vice to start, when Steve thinks maybe he should ask Billy that thing he’s been meaning to ask. Now’s as good time a time as any, with Billy all relaxed and still happy from the letter and stuff—and also cause Steve has to leave in an hour, so he can’t really put it off anymore.

He steels himself for a minute and then nudges Billy’s thigh with his toe and says, “Hey, um. Can I ask you something?”, trying to sound like maybe he just thought of it and not like he’s been rehearsing it in his head for the last two days.

Billy looks over at him, expectant, so Steve goes on, “I was just thinking—and like, you can totally say no, and that’s completely fine, I would never say anything without asking you first, and, like, it’s gotta be a mutual decision and everything, so—”

“Oh my god, dude, what?”

“Sorry, okay. So. How do you feel about. If I—um. If I told Nancy and Jonathan, about us.”

When Billy just blinks at him with no reaction, Steve starts rambling, “Just cause, like, they know something’s up with me, I’ve been kind of, just, missing, for weeks, you know. Not like—I mean, I wanted to be here, with you, I just—I’ve been making excuses, but not really good ones, and also Jonathan dropped Max here the other day? And that was probably really weird, like, all of a sudden, and I know they’re gonna ask me about it tonight, and I don’t really know what I can say—”

“Steve,” says Billy, “Man, stop. Are you even breathing?” Steve’s not sure. Feels like maybe not.

He waits for Billy to say, fuck no, to say, are you crazy? Do you want us to die? But Billy just messes with the blankets covering Steve’s feet and stays quiet.

After forever of that, just endless, heavy silence, Steve can’t take it anymore, “Sorry, forget it, like. I shouldn’t have even asked, it’s okay, I’ll come up with something—”

“Dude,” says Billy, exasperated. “I’m not—saying no, okay. I’m just—thinking. Some people, you know, think before they talk.”

Which, shouldn’t, like, sting, or whatever, because Billy’s just thinking, but it feels harsh. Like, they tease each other all the time, but Billy’s not actually mean to him anymore, and it kind of feels like that.

But Steve needs to just shut up and let Billy think, so he nods and swallows and tries to pretend like maybe he didn’t say anything, like it’s ten minutes ago and he’s still glowing warm from the echo of Billy’s hands on him.

But only a minute or two later, Billy sighs loudly and nudges Steve with his foot. “Come over here,” he says, which—

“What?”

Billy rolls his eyes and tugs at the blanket like it’ll bring Steve closer. “If you stay over there, you’re just gonna get all in your head or whatever. I just gotta—think about it for a minute, but I can actually do more than one thing at once. So, like, put your dumb show on and come over here." 

So, Steve makes sure the channel’s right and then goes—it’s easier than breathing, stretching out between Billy’s legs, lying on his chest just right so he can still see the TV. Billy’s hands go to Steve’s back automatically, slipping under his shirt, and they don’t do this too often, cause Billy’s legs go numb, but it’s kind of the best, definitely good enough to make Steve mostly forget that Billy is thinking.

When the show cuts to commercial about halfway through, Billy taps his fingers against Steve’s back purposefully, and says, “Okay.”

Steve twists to face him and props his chin up on his hands. “Wait, so. Okay, like—okay?”

Billy rolls his eyes and tugs at a stand of hair that’s fallen into Steve’s face. “Yeah, idiot. Okay, like okay.”

“I can tell them,” Steve says, just, really making sure. 

“Yeah,” says Billy. He smooths more of Steve’s hair down. After a beat, he adds, “They’re your friends.”

Steve’s kind of really in love with Billy. Feels like he maybe doesn’t say it enough, but if he said it right now Billy would just roll his eyes again and grumble, so he presses closer instead and kisses Billy as deep as he can like this.

“Okay,” he breathes against Billy’s lips.

“Just, uh,” Billy says when Steve pulls back. “Make sure they don’t, you know. Spread it around.”

“Of course,” Steve says quickly. “No, yeah, of course. They can totally keep a secret. Like, I’ll make sure. No one else will find out, I promise.” Out of the corner of his eyes he can tell the show’s back on, but it doesn’t matter, cause he has to add, “I just—really love you, you know. Like, that’s sort of the biggest part of my life, right now, and I just want them to know.”

Billy’s smile starts small and real, but then turns into his dumb, joking grin before long. “Dude, I get it. You wanna brag about bagging the hottest guy in Hawkins. I don’t blame you.”

It startles a laugh out of Steve. “Yup,” he says, grinning back. “That’s exactly it.”

“Knew it.” Billy nods towards the TV. “Show’s back on.”

“Yeah,” says Steve, pressing forward again, more interested in feeling Billy’s smile against his. “Don’t really care right now.”

“You don’t care about Miami Vice?” says Billy, just shy of Steve’s mouth. “Wow, you must really have it bad.”

“Yeah,” Steve says again. He does.

 

 

 

It’s just past eleven at Jonathan’s place, and Steve still hasn’t done it yet. It’s only after their third drink each, when they’ve migrated onto the floor of the living room and Nancy’s sort of humming to whatever niche, indie thing playing, that Steve feels ready enough to try to say something. He still feels like he might puke, but Jon ran out of beer a while ago, so that might just be his last vodka cola mixing badly with the Miller.

“So,” he says, and waits for Jonathan to glance over and Nancy to make a questioning sort of sound before he goes on, rolling one of the empty bottles between his palms for something to look at, “I know I’ve been kind of, uh, weird, lately. Like, not hanging out with you guys as much.”

Nancy’s been lying flat on the ground, but she uses Jonathan’s arm to pull herself back up, maybe guessing at Steve’s tone that this is important. She leans against Jon’s side and nods at Steve, like, yeah, we know.

Steve takes a breath. “Yeah. So, the thing is. I’m—with someone. Like, uh. We’re together.”

There’s a beat where they just stare at him, and then Nancy starts to smile. She elbow’s Jon, saying, “I knew it,” grins up at him, smug, “I told you.”

Jonathan laughs. “I know,” he says, “I agreed with you.”

“Oh,” says Nance, “Right.” She looks at Steve, still smiling. “We figured,” she says, like he didn’t just see that whole thing. “You’ve just been—happier. Secretive and weird, but happy.”

Which is kind of nice. Some of the stress fades for a second before Steve remembers that he hasn’t really even gotten to the Big News, and then it’s back full force, his fingers almost going numb from the nerves. Nancy’s still saying something, though—

“—just couldn’t figure out why you hadn’t said anything about her yet. I mean, is it someone I’m friends with? Is it Maddy Deidrick? It is, isn’t it. You know, I don’t care, Steve, really. I’m just happy for you.”

Steve sets the empty bottle on the floor so he can wipe his hands off on his knees. He really wants to do this—nobody’s asking him to—Nancy and Jonathan didn’t even ask, even though it’s looking like they knew he was hiding things. He wanted this, he just has to, like, get through it, which right now seems like one of the hardest things he’s ever done, right up there with wandering demodog-invested tunnels and watching Billy’s skin turn black and blue.

“Yeah,” he says, and his voice catches weird, comes out kind of shaky. Nancy’s been messing with something on Jon’s shirt, but she turns back to Steve now, concerned.

“Um.” This is so much harder than it was supposed to be. Jonathan’s barely-touched drink is still on the coffee table, so Steve grabs it and downs it before he can think about it, so quick it sloshes over his chin.

“Okay,” says Jonathan, surprised. “What—”

But Steve has to literally say this right now, with the too-sweet, acid taste still in his throat, or he won’t get it out at all.

“I’m seeing a guy,” he says in a rush, clenching the now-empty cup in his hands. 

“Oh,” says Jonathan.

“That’s why I didn’t say anything,” Steve adds.

“Oh,” says Nancy.

Steve watches their dumbfounded expressions for ages, just waiting for it to settle enough that they actually say something.

“I mean,” Jonathan starts awkwardly, glancing at Nancy and then Steve and then Nancy again, who’s still sort of gaping, blinking her eyes real big like maybe she thinks she imagined it. “That’s. Uh. Cool?”

“Cool?” Steve echoes.

“I mean—that’s great, Steve. Really. It’s uh. We didn’t think—but that’s great. I’m glad that you’re, uh, telling us that and also that you’re—happy, now?”

“Oh. No,” says Steve. “I’m not—I still like girls, and everything.” He looks over at Nancy, who’s still staring. “That wasn’t. I mean, Nance—” she meets his gaze, her eyebrows all squinched up. “When we were together—I mean that was real for me, it’s not like I was faking that or anything. I like girls, I still do, I just. Like guys, too.”

“Have you,” Nancy starts, slowly, like she’s choosing her words really carefully, “always liked guys, too?”

Steve picks at a fraying string in the hem of his pants and shrugs. “I don’t know. Maybe? I guess, I just, didn’t notice, before.”

“Well,” says Nancy, and then she nods, just once, and crawls over the few feet between them to settle next to Steve, takes one of his hand in both of hers.

It’s probably the first time their hands have touched at all since they broke up—and Steve doesn’t know what he expects to feel, but he’s kind of relieved that it’s mostly nothing, just, noticing that her hands are cold, kind of clammy, and strangely small.

“We love you,” she says. “And we accept your—whatever it is. Your liking guys, too. If it’s making you happy, then it’s good, right?”

“Right,” says Steve, warming again. They’re his friends, of course, they don’t think it’s weird. Why did it seem like five minutes ago this was the worst thing he could imagine doing? That’s so dumb. They love him.

Except, then Steve remembers again—this isn’t even the worst part of what he has to say.

Nancy’s dropped his hand already and is heading toward the kitchen to make more drinks, guys, this is a big deal, we have to celebrate, and Steve’s not about to stop her, because he’s really going to need another two or three more to get through this next part. 

Luckily—or maybe not—he’s not the one to bring it up again, because after Nancy doles out their drinks and settles back down, she starts right away with, “So—this boy. What’s his name? Was he in your year? Or do you know him from work. Oh my god,” she gasps. “Is he older? Steve. How much older than you is he?” 

Jonathan’s kind of smiling into Nance’s shoulder as she talks but he looks questioningly at Steve, too, and—right. Okay. This is why it was the worst thing he could imagine doing.

“Uh, okay. So—”

“Wait,” says Nancy, holding a hand out. “Is it someone we know?" 

“Um. Yeah.” 

“Oh my god.” Nancy glances back at Jonathan, like she wants to make sure he’s hearing this. “Who?” 

“Okay,” Steve starts, “So, here’s the thing.” But then he can’t really go into the thing, because he needs more sugar or vodka or something to get his heart to slow down just a little, and his hands to stop sweating so much.

But then he meets Jonathan’s eyes by accident, and Jon must see something there, or maybe he’s got that mind-reading thing just like Billy, because he sort of stiffens and then sits up straighter.

“Wait,” he says.

Nancy turns to him again, and Steve feels like he can actually see the pieces coming together in Jon’s head—mostly the fact that Max was over, and why would she ever come alone, unless—

“No,” says Jon, in disbelief. And then, “Billy?”

“Billy who,” says Nancy, twisting back to look at Steve, and then Jon again. “Who,” she prods.

Jonathan stares and stares at Steve like he’s waiting to be corrected, but there’s no correcting to be done, so Steve just stares back. Finally, Jon says, “Billy Hargrove.”

And Nancy does this kind of snort laugh that means she’s pretty past tipsy and well into drunk. “Sure,” she says, “Okay. And I bet it’s that science teacher Dustin’s in love with. No—wait. That old janitor, you remember? Dickens or something. Philip. Phiggins?” She goes on listing names, cause she thinks it’s a game they’re playing, but Jonathan won’t quit staring, cause he knows it’s real.

“Nance,” Jon says softly.

She snaps her fingers. “Higgins!”

It’s only when she looks up, waiting for them to laugh, that she notices the serious sort of look on Jonathan’s face. Steve has no idea what his face looks like, but it can’t be good, cause he feels like he might be sick, all hazy and overwarm, like his blood’s too thick. Jonathan won’t stop looking at him.

“What,” says Nancy. “Did he say who it was?”

And Steve doesn’t want to do this anymore, actually. This was so dumb. He could’ve just made something up about planning Max’s birthday or something, but, no, he had to go and tell the truth, like some idiot.

Steve finishes the rest of his drink in one go and heads to the kitchen, to get more and also to hide, maybe forever, because he doesn’t want to see the stupid, disappointed look on Nancy’s face when she figures it out.

Ten minutes and three more shots later, Steve ambles back to the living room because seriously, what the fuck does it even matter. Like. Okay, so if Nancy’s mad or disappointed or thinks he’s making bad decisions or whatever, like, it’s not even her business and he can do what he likes. And, also, Billy’s the best guy in the world—the hottest, duh, but also the funniest and warmest, with the best laugh, so. It doesn’t matter.

Steve falls over the back of the couch and lands with a fwoomp on the cushions, face first, but it smells like beer and sweat, so he turns sideways, curls his arm under his head and gets his first good look at the room since the Bigger News. The Biggest.

Nancy’s leaning against the armchair, staring at Steve, her eyebrows all scowly again. Jonathan’s sitting cross-legged on the chair itself, picking at the stitching and pretending like he’s not staring at Steve, even though he keeps glancing up—not really slick.

“What,” says Steve.

“Billy Hargrove?” says Nancy, and he can tell by the way it comes out, too loud and too fast, that she’s been holding it in probably this whole time. “What are you thinking? Steve, he’s psychotic. He beat you to a pulp, just a few months ago. That doesn’t bother you?”

It really doesn’t, because that was over a year ago, and this morning Billy kissed Steve’s eyelids and called him sweetheart. But he can’t tell Nancy that, so he says, “No. It doesn’t. Jonathan beat me up too,” he adds, throwing an arm out haphazardly in Jon’s direction, “and I’m still friends with him.”

“That is not the same thing,” says Nancy, and Steve doesn’t get why she sounds so furious.

“I know he’s hot, Steve,” she goes on, which, good, because he is, the hottest. “But there are plenty of hot guys in Hawkins, okay, and every single one of them is a hundred times better than Billy Hargrove.”

“Shut up,” Steve says, cause he’s really sick of it now, like, it’s not even funny, it’s just mean.

“I mean it,” says Nancy, “You can do so much better. I know you probably think there aren’t that many—homosexuals—in Hawkins, but anyone is better than Billy.”

“You don’t even know him.” And Steve doesn’t know how they got to this point, Nancy all angry and saying awful things about the guy he’s in love with, saying things like homosexuals, just—god.

“I know enough.”

“You don’t,” says Steve with a bitter kind of laugh. “You seriously don’t even know him, like, at all, and if you did, if you knew how he was, with me, you wouldn’t—you wouldn’t even think that." 

That seems to stop Nancy short for a second. She stares at him for a while and Steve thinks maybe she’s giving up, finally coming around, but then she starts shaking her head.

“Steve,” she says, “tell me you don’t actually like him. You guys are just fooling around, right? You’re not actually—you don’t really like him, right?”  

“So, what,” says Steve, “Yeah, I love him, so, what.”

Nancy gets up on her knees, right in his face, and grips the sofa cushions, hard, like she wants to strangle him, but is taking it out on the couch instead. “You always do this,” she says, furious again. She gets so mad at him when she’s drunk. “You always fall in love with these people who just hurt you, Steve. And you don’t deserve that.”

“Always?” says Steve, cause, like, that’s not even fair. “Just cause you dumped me doesn’t mean, like, always.” 

“What about Laura Sherwin?” Oh, Jesus. Nancy was always throwing that in his face.

“Oh my god, why are you so obsessed with that? Laura was, like, five years ago, I don’t even care anymore.”

“You should care, cause you just keep letting people take advantage of you.”

“Who’s Laura Sherwin?” says Jon, and Steve maybe forgot about him, but there he is, like a little gargoyle perched on the chair above them.

“She dated Steve when he was a freshman,” says Nancy, glaring, like it’s still his fault, all these years later.

“Why don’t I know her?” Jon needs to butt out, okay, it’s not his business.

“Because she was a senior,” says Nancy, “She graduated before we even got to Hawkins High.”

“That’s not weird,” says Steve, for what feels like the millionth time. Nancy got so upset, back when he told her about Laura, like off-hand or whatever, when they were talking about first times, cause that’s what couples do. You’re not supposed to bring it up when there are other people around, but Nancy’s always such a bitch when she’s drunk and also mad at him.

“It is weird,” says Nancy, her usual response, “because she was held back a year, and was nineteen. You were fifteen, Steve. Don’t you see how fucked up that is? That would be like—like you dating Max, now.”  

“What the fuck, no,” says Steve, because, gross. “It’s not the same—Max is just a kid, she’s, like, fourteen.”

“Oh, okay, so, what? You’d date her in, like, three weeks?”

“No.”

“You were a kid, too, Steve.”

“Shut up.” He hates it when she says that. “Why are we even talking about this, it’s not even the point.”

“It is the point. Cause you just keep doing this, you keep letting people take things from you. Billy doesn’t love you, Steve, he’s using you, just like Laura and just like me.” She’s sort of crying, Steve realizes, which makes him feel sick again. It’s really, really cold in here.

Nancy won’t stop saying things, “I shouldn’t have kept seeing you once I knew how much you loved me, when I didn’t feel the same way, because that’s not fair, okay? You just—you love people so much, Steve. You love people so hard, and you deserve somebody who’s gonna love you with their whole heart. Do you really think Billy Hargrove can love you like that?" 

And—Nancy can’t possibly know about Jack or how much Billy still loves him, or about all the times Billy goes quiet and still, and his eyes get hazy, like maybe he’s pretending Jack’s still alive in Steve’s place. She can’t know about that, even if she is a mind-reader, cause Steve doesn’t think about it, ever, can’t stand to.

But that’s not fair to Billy, either—it’s not his fault he can’t give Steve his whole heart, and Steve doesn’t even care, it doesn’t matter—all he needs is some of it, just a piece.

Nancy must see something in Steve’s face that isn’t so good, cause her voice gets softer when she says, “I just don’t want you to get hurt again.”

And Steve doesn’t want to tell her about how impossible that is, how loving Billy is just a part of him now, like breathing, and it’s not gonna go away, not ever, even after Billy gets tired of him, or mad at him, and leaves. Steve’s gonna get hurt no matter what, so why shouldn’t he get to enjoy this good part, the mornings when Billy calls him baby and holds him like he means it. 

He can’t tell her that, so he says, “Too late,” which is kind of the same thing.

She looks at him really, really sad, with her cheeks all red and wet still from the tears. Then she hands him another drink from thin air, knocks it against her own, and says, “Fuck him. We’ll find you someone better, okay?" 

Steve doesn’t want to toast to that, at all—there’s no one better—but he could really use another drink. He’s so close to the point where he’ll just forget this whole fucking night, and that sort of seems like the best way to deal with all this. So, he downs it and holds the cup out for more.

 

 

 

Steve’s cold in a distant way, like wearing two pairs of socks and getting the outer one wet, not freezing, just weird. It’s getting colder, though, worse, and he feels really bad, like, he might be sick, or maybe he just was sick, and now this is the awful, shaky part that comes after.

Something pulls him up too fast, like, way, way too fast, like, it should slow down a little, hold some horses. 

“I don’t have any horses, but we’re almost to the door, okay? You think you can make it, or do you need to puke again?”

Steve is the champ of not puking, like, maybe a king, or something. Like, that’s his name.

“Yeah, I know, King Steve. Keep it together for ten more steps, okay?”

Sounds like Jonathan. Good old Jonathan, counting steps, keeping count. He’s so smart, but not as smart as Billy. If Billy was here, he’d find, like, the square root of the steps, cause he’s in calculous, like a big nerd.

Steve leans against something sturdier than Jonathan or calculous, like a wall, a cold, rough, wall. It’s so, so dark. Steve’s trying to feel his fingers and his socks and his eyeballs in his head to distract from the dark that’s all over everything, but then part of the wall opens up with sunlight, and Billy is there, of course he is, he’s got all the sunlight in the whole world inside him.

“Baby,” says Steve, or he tries to, but he’s moving at the same time and it’s hard to do both. He just needs to lean against something sturdier than the wall, something like Billy’s chest.

Then there’s a hand in his hair and an arm around his waist, and the spot where he always tucks his nose smells just the same. 

“—gonna let him stay on the couch, but he was pretty, uh, insistent on coming back. So, I guess, just, make sure he drinks water, and doesn’t, like, drown in his puke?”

“—plenty of experience taking care of lightweights. Uh, thanks for—”

Oh, that’s Billy.

“Billy.” Steve pulls back to see his pretty face but miscalculates—he’s so bad at math—almost trips down some steps, but Billy’s got strong arms and big, warm hands, which reminds him, “Billy, it’s okay, Jon knows.” He tries to wink, cause he’s slick, but his head gets kind of dizzy, so he decides to just close his eyes instead.

“Easy, man. Yeah, I, uh, got that part.”

“Okay, so. You look like you—got this handled, so I’m gonna go—”

And then the wall closes up with Steve on the other side, the warm, gold side, with Billy’s hands still on him, which is the best thing in the world.

“Jesus, Harrington. How much did you drink? Aren’t you supposed to be some kind of keg master?”

“King,” says Steve into Billy’s neck, cause that part’s important. Also, it’s not his fault—“It’s the vodka,” he tries to explain, “That’s not resolations, it’s, it’s cheating.”

“Yeah,” Billy laughs, the most amazing sound ever. “I hear ya, man. Let’s go to the kitchen, okay. Can you walk?”

Steve can walk, Steve is a master of walking, sometimes he can even run. He pulls away from Billy to show him, but Billy likes holding him too much or something, cause he keeps his arm around Steve, even though he totally doesn’t need to.

Then Steve’s sitting, which is kind of better than the walking and the standing. He can get back to that in second, he’s just taking a break, just a little nap, and then he’s gonna show Billy how good he can walk and also how much he loves him.

The table is so nice, like, smoother than he would’ve thought, and he’s almost getting to the hazy part before he drifts off for real, but then there’s a hand in his hair again and Billy’s soft, tilty voice saying, “Hey, Stevie, come on. Don’t sleep yet, okay. Come on, sit up and drink this.”

Steve blinks and blinks for a while, just to see what there is to drink, but it’s just water.

“Gross,” says Steve, trying to bat the glass away, missing a little.

“Hey,” says Billy, closer than before, and when Steve looks over, he’s right there, sitting next to him, and he’s so beautiful—Steve maybe needs to be in his lap, right now.

“Stop,” says Billy when Steve tries to shift toward him, so Steve stops, cause, like, it’s important to listen, and also Billy doesn’t say that often, so Steve’s probably being bad.

“Drink this,” Billy says again, shoving the water right under Steve’s nose, but, like, it’s a free country and also Steve’s house, so if he doesn’t want to, he doesn’t have to.

“Yeah, but you’ll feel so much better, dude. Don’t you trust me?”

Steve trusts Billy more than anybody, even more than he trusts himself, but that’s not the point, the point is water is gross and tasteless and bad, and Steve already feels kind of sick and water would just make it worse.

“No, man, it’s gonna make you feel better. Just drink it, okay. Come on, Stevie. Be good for me,” Billy says that last part softer, the way he does when they’re doing stuff, and like, that’s not even fair. That’s like a trick, and mean, because now Steve has to do it, or he’ll feel like shit.

He tries to glare at Billy for pulling that right now, but his eyes maybe aren’t in his head anymore because it doesn’t work. Still, he wants to be good, so he sips at the water forever and ever until it’s gone, and he can show Billy the empty glass like a prize. Now, he’s supposed to get other prizes, like sitting in Billy’s lap, and kissing. Except, he still feels kind of bad, so maybe kissing later, but the lap part now.

But when he reaches for Billy, his hand hits open air, like Billy’s disappeared. Steve’s heart drops low into his feet, and he’s about three seconds from losing his shit, before another full glass is on the table and Billy’s back, saying, “One more.”

“No,” says Steve, which Billy’s supposed to listen to, but he just frowns.

“Baby,” he says, slow, like Steve is dumb—which he is, but he hates when people talk at him like that, cause he’s not a complete moron, okay, just bad at lots of things.

“Don’t you feel better?” Billy is saying, lowly. “Come on, one more, and then you can lie on me in the living room. Okay?”

And, yeah, that sounds like the best thing in the world right now, but Steve already did the thing once, and he’s supposed get good stuff now, not after more things.

“I did,” he says, in case Billy missed it while he was disappeared.

“I know,” says Billy. “So, do it again. Then that’s it, I promise.”

So, whatever, so Steve drinks more water, like, maybe a whole fountain, or an ocean or something else big and full of water. It takes a long time, long enough for all the hazy, good part of the vodka to go away, leaving him with a headache and a sore throat, and an awful, empty feeling in his stomach, because he’s not being good enough. Also, he doesn’t remember, but he thinks Nancy’s mad at him, and also Billy doesn’t love him enough.

“Hey,” says Billy after a hundred years.

Steve’s head is on the table again even though he doesn’t remember putting it there. Billy’s rubbing one finger down the side of Steve’s face and up again, back and forth, like he’s a cat or something, but it feels so good, Steve doesn’t mind. He could be cat if he wanted, it’d probably be so much easier than all of this. His head wouldn’t hurt so bad.

“You want to lie down?”

Steve wants to lie down more than he wants to kiss Billy, which is really saying something. It’s hard to get up though—he doesn’t feel sick anymore, but his body is so heavy, full of sand and sadness, and Steve feels like in a minute or two he’s gonna cry—which is exactly what he knew would happen if he drank that stupid water, and now look. That’s what he gets for trusting Billy and trying to be good.

“Come on,” says Billy and then he’s pulling Steve up with his warm hands, and they’re so big and perfect, so much better than Nancy holding his hand before, saying dumb, mean things about how Billy doesn’t love him—as if Steve doesn’t know already.  

It takes them days to get to the sofa, and when they do, Billy just stands there, looking at Steve. It’s too hard to think, so Steve waits for the couch to decide who to sit on, so he doesn’t have to.

“Want to lie on me like before?” Billy asks finally, real soft. And duh—but even though Steve wants to, he feels like if he lies down right now he might not ever get up again. He wants to be in Billy’s lap and hide his face in Billy’s neck, like they did ages and ages ago, when Billy got into college and Steve was proud of him.

That’s too many words to put together, so Steve shakes his head slowly—too fast and his brain might fall out—and says, “No, you sit.” Billy sits, and then Steve, so, so carefully, sits too, right on top of him. Except his body’s not listening, so he ends up more sideways, half leaning against the sofa arm and half against Billy’s chest, but that’s okay. His head fits perfect on Billy’s shoulder. Billy’s hair is like an angel’s, soft and pretty. It smells so good.

Billy curls one arm around Steve’s back and uses the other hand to rub Steve’s legs, like he’s trying to warm him up. It’s really nice—it’s so nice that it starts to feel awful, because Steve doesn’t deserve it, and also he can’t stop thinking about that thing Nancy said.

Steve’s whole body feels better just by being so close to Billy. His heart feels warm despite all the sand weighing it down. But maybe that’s just cause he loves people too much, and Billy doesn’t feel the same. This whole time Steve’s been thinking that, even though Billy misses Jack, he’s still getting something good out of this thing they have, but maybe not—maybe Billy doesn’t feel light and gold and safe when he’s with Steve—and if that’s true, it’s about the worst thing in the universe, in any universe.

“Hey,” says Billy, suddenly. “You okay?” There’s a hand trying to get at Steve’s face, but Steve presses closer to Billy’s neck and won’t budge. “Baby, are you crying?”

“No,” Steve mumbles, but that’s lying, which isn’t good, so he adds, “Sorry,” also cause he’s probably making a mess of Billy’s shirt.

“Don’t be sorry.” Billy’s voice is so soft and perfect. If Steve was crying, it would probably make him cry even more, so it’s a good thing that he’s not. “What did they say to you?”

Steve doesn’t want to think about that, but he can’t stop hearing it all again, Nancy’s voice on a loop—he’s using you, just like Laura, and, do you really think Billy Hargrove can love you like that? And—Steve realizes suddenly, Billy’s a mind-reader, which means he’s probably been hearing it too, this whole time, which is just awful.

Steve lifts his heavy head and paws at Billy’s face till he can see him in focus. He looks so sad and worried, and it’s all Steve’s fault.

“It’s okay,” Steve says, because he’s not sure Billy heard that part, about how Steve doesn’t mind, how he’ll take anything Billy can give him. “I don’t care, it doesn’t matter.”

Billy cups Steve’s face in his perfect hands. “Sure, it does, baby. They’re your friends, and it matters if it’s making you sad.”

Who cares if Steve’s sad now, that’s just cause of the water—he’s happy most of the time, even with only some of Billy’s heart, Billy has to know that.

“It’s not your fault,” he says, wrapping his fingers around Billy’s wrist so he can steal some of his warmth. It’s getting so cold again, even with all the lights on. “If you don’t love me so much—it’s okay. I mean, I don’t mind.”

Billy’s eyebrows get all squinted. “What are you talking about?”

“It’s not your fault,” Steve says again, because that’s the important part. Does Billy get that?

“Steve—I love you. I told you that.”

“I know,” says Steve, “But you don’t love me how I love you.”

“What does that even mean?”

“I—” It’s so hard to think right now, and to try to remember how Nancy put it, that he loves too much, too hard, too often. Steve wishes there was a bigger word than love, because it’s not enough, it’s too short and small to cover everything Steve feels for Billy, the overwhelming, joy-bringing, warm-gold thing that comes over him every time he even sees Billy, let alone what he feels when Billy touches him, when he calls him baby.  

He tries to think about how he can say all that to Billy, who’s so smart, who has so many words in his head that would probably work better, if only Steve knew them. And then he remembers—

“You’re my whole word,” Steve says, trying to quit crying long enough to make sense. “And it’s okay, that I’m not yours—I don’t care.” Billy goes stiff beneath him, so Steve rushes on, making sure he gets it—“As long as you love me even this much,” Steve holds his fingers up to show him the tiny bit, cause Billy needs visuals sometimes, “then, it’s okay. That’s—that’s all I even need.”

Billy doesn’t say anything for a long, long time, long enough that Steve is really sure he fucked this up. He’s so stupid. He should just stop talking, he’s always ruining things, cause he never knows when to shut the fuck up.

“Billy?” says Steve when the silence feels like it might really choke him. His voice sounds like someone else, small and scared.

Billy’s hands settle on him again, nudging Steve’s head to his normal spot, tucked against Billy’s neck. Steve goes easy—he’s so, so tired.

“Let’s not talk about this right now,” says Billy, his voice like gravel, like how it is after his panic freak-outs—Steve did that.

“Sorry,” he says, fighting a fresh wave of tears. All he does is hurt Billy when he’s trying not to. “I’m sorry.”

“Jesus,” says Billy, and if Steve didn’t know better, he’d think Billy was crying, too. “Don’t be sorry, sweetheart. I’m sorry. I’m so sorry, but I’m gonna fix this, okay? Just, not right now. You should go to bed. You still feeling sick?”

Steve shakes his head against Billy’s shoulder. “Want to lie down,” he says. He might not make it upstairs, but Billy seems to get that, cause he slips carefully off the couch and helps Steve lie down right there. He piles all the blankets over him, even tucks in the edges so they won’t fall off, but he doesn’t try to sit back down, or lie next to Steve, which feels like a knife twisting, hot and horrible, in Steve’s gut.

He tries not to be such a baby, but he only lasts maybe three seconds before he says, “Don’t go,” kind of panicked. He can’t help it. He doesn’t sleep without Billy. He hasn’t in months, doesn’t think he’ll ever be able to again.

Billy’s back in an instant, kneeling next to him, pushing his hair off his forehead. “Just getting you some water,” he murmurs. “But I’m right here, okay? I’m not going anywhere.” He rubs his thumb softly over Steve’s eyebrows, his cheeks, his eyelids when they fall closed.

“Love you,” Steve whispers, like he does every night—it’s important, that it’s the last thing he says before he falls asleep, just in case he never wakes up.  

“I love you, too,” says Billy, but he sounds so sad. “I love you so much. And I’m gonna love you better, okay?”

Steve wants to tell him, again, that he doesn’t care, that it doesn’t matter what Nancy says—a little bit of Billy is so much better than a whole lot of somebody else. But he’s too tired and warm, and Billy’s hand’s in his hair now, so he can’t do much but drift off.

 

 

 

Someone is nailing something into Steve’s head, with a jackhammer, or a saw. And why is it so fucking bright in here?

He tries to lift the blanket up over his head, which works for a little while, but then he can’t breathe, which is so dumb, like who even invented that? Breathing, or blankets you can’t breathe under—god.

Then somebody is screaming.

“Steve,” says Billy, for maybe the third or fourth time before Steve finally unsticks his gross, chapped lips enough to say,

“Shhh. Why are you yelling?”

Steve has to blink a few times before the blur of yellow and blue finally clears up. Billy’s sitting just on the edge of the sofa cushion, a warm spot next to Steve’s thigh. He shakes something loud and awful in Steve’s face.

“Want some?” he says.

“Stop. God, you’re such an asshole, leave me alone.”

“Oh, sorry, dude. Thought you’d want some aspirin but I guess I was wrong.” He starts to shift like he’s gonna get up and Steve reaches clumsily for him, hangs onto to his sleeve.

“Wait, never mind, I love you, come back.”  

When Billy sits again, he presses a tiny pill into Steve’s palm, waits for him prop himself against the sofa arm, then passes him a glass of water. Steve swallows as fast as he can and flops down, squishing his face into the back of the couch.

“Leave me to die,” he says, muffled against the fabric. There’s a light touch on his hair and then the couch creaks, and Billy’s warmth is gone. Steve turns back to the room, frowning, cause he didn’t really mean it, Billy’s supposed to come and coddle him some more. The room is empty, but Steve’s too tired and sick to go after Billy, so he closes his eyes and lies as still as he can until exhaustion takes over.

 

 

 

The next thing to wake him is the smell of cookies baking, so sweet and sharp in Steve’s memory that he jolts up, convinced for half a second that he’s not at home, but at Nana’s, until his vision rights itself. He’s still in the living room, with its same off-yellow carpet, its same dark walls, but the smell sticks around—so that’s not a dream.

It takes him more tries than he wants to admit to stagger off of the sofa and shuffle slowly into the kitchen—and what a goddamn sight.

Everything is covered in flour. Steve doesn’t think his kitchen ever even saw flour before Billy started living here, but they must have sacks and sacks of it now, because it’s coating every surface, including Billy’s shirt, the back of his pants, and—when he turns at the sound of Steve showing up—almost the entire side of his face.

Steve’s not totally convinced he’s awake. “What are you doing?” he says, his voice shot from sleep and whatever cheap shit he was drinking last night.

“Making cookies,” says Billy, like that makes sense. He turns back to the counter before Steve can send him a truly suspicious look, so Steve wanders over, presses against Billy’s back, and peers over his shoulder.

That really is cookie dough, with chocolate chips and everything, but it still doesn’t explain the sheer amount of flour, until Steve starts slowing taking in the rest of the room. The oven light is on, so Steve sees the two trays already cooking, plus there’s at least three full cooling racks spread around the counters, and two Tupperware containers stacked near the breadbox, with little round blurs inside.

“Do you have. . . a bake sale, to get to?" 

Billy snorts but doesn’t say anything, so Steve adds, “Seriously. What’s going on?”

Billy shrugs, bumping Steve’s chin up and down. “What, I can’t make cookies if I want?”

“Um. Sure? You can. But, this is a lot of cookies.”

Billy shrugs again, and it’s hard for Steve to get a good read on him, like this, but it’s feeling a lot like shrug number four, don’t fucking talk to me, which is a tighter, rarer shrug Steve hasn’t seen in a while.

Steve’s arms fall away, and he steps back before he can think about it. Billy hasn’t always liked Steve touching him—he has to remember that.

He pretends like he’s checking out the cookies in the oven to retreat a few more feet, and then he says, “I didn’t, uh, say anything stupid last night, right?”

Billy just shrugs again and makes a dismissive sound. Steve must’ve though, cause the last he remembers seeing Billy was just before he left for Jonathan’s, when Billy was spread out on the couch all soft and sleepy, letting Steve press a dozen kisses into his face before he pushed him off, told him he was gonna be late.

So, Steve said something dumb last night, probably, when he came back—something mean, or shitty, or just stupid—which is so classic, and now Billy’s fucking stress baking about it. God. And of course, Steve doesn’t remember shit, doesn’t even remember if he went through with telling Nancy and Jonathan about them. It seems like such an incredibly important thing that he would have to remember. But if it went badly—that’s just the sort of thing Steve would cure with more drinks than he can handle.

There’s only one way he can think to check, so he mumbles something about a shower and leaves Billy to his cookies.

He makes sure the bedroom door is closed tight and even turns the shower on in case Billy comes upstairs. Then he grabs the phone and dials from memory. It only rings twice.

“Hello?”

“Dude, it’s me,” says Steve.

“Hey,” says Jonathan, and Steve has a bad feeling already, just from the awkwardness in that one word.

“So.” Better lead with the facts. “I don’t remember last night.”

“Yeah,” says Jon, “That—makes sense. You were in pretty rough shape. I wanted you to stay over but, uh. You wanted to go home.”

“Okay,” says Steve. “Did I, uh. Did we. Talk about—anything, in, um, particular?” He feels like banging his head against the side table—maybe that would shake his memory loose, or at least put him out of his misery.

“Yeah,” Jonathan says again. “You told us about—uh. What you’ve been up to. And who, um. Who you’ve been hanging out with.”

“Will’s right there, isn’t he?”

“Yeah,” says Jon.

“Great. Cool. Okay, so I’m guessing, it didn’t go over well?”

Jonathan pauses for such a dramatic amount of time before he says, “We love you no matter what, you know? It’s just—Nancy’s just worried. She says you don’t always think straight about this stuff. But. I don’t know. I . . .”

“What,” says Steve.

There’s a shuffling sound, like Jonathan’s moving the receiver to his other ear, trying to get further away from Will. He goes on even quieter, “I dropped you off, you know? And I saw—not much, really, but. Enough, I guess. You looked really happy, man, and I just think, maybe, this time, she’s wrong.”

Steve laughs, just barely. “Had to happen sometime, right?”

Jon laughs too. “Yeah. Are you okay?”

“I mean, my head feels like it’s full of angry lumberjacks,” says Steve, pressing his knuckles to his temple. “And I think I said some dumb shit last night that I don’t remember. There’s enough cookies in my kitchen to feed a fucking army.”

“Cookies?”

Steve sighs. “Billy likes to bake about his feelings, or whatever.”

Jonathan snorts. “Wow. That’s—unexpected.”

“Yeah,” says Steve, feeling kind of warm despite everything. “That’s Billy.”

“You’re really together, huh,” Jon says, softly. “Like, it’s serious?”

Steve really fucking wishes he could remember how much he’s already said, but, “Yeah. As serious as it gets, I guess. I mean, unless I fucked it up last night.”

“Nah,” says Jon. “I think you’re fine. Like I said, I uh. I think Nance was wrong. She was just surprised, you know? Just give her a few days. I bet she already feels terrible about it. I mean, she also just feels terrible, cause you guys were pretty much trying to out-drink each other.”

“Great,” says Steve, cause his drunken conversations with Nancy always end well. “Look, I better go.” Better see if there’s anything left of the kitchen, under all that flour. “Thanks, man.”

“Yeah,” says Jonathan. “Anytime. And, hey, I know you don’t remember, but—we do love you. Okay? Like, always.”

“Thanks,” says Steve, trying to soak that in so he has enough strength to face Billy, all hurt and angry downstairs. “Love you, too.”

Steve takes a shower in the end, because it would look pretty suspicious if his hair wasn’t wet, and also, he needs a little longer to figure out a game plan. If it was anything else, he would just leave Billy alone, let him get all his broodiness out in the kitchen before talking to him again—that’s just what he needs sometimes, space. But—

This time it’s Steve’s fault. And how can he just sit and do nothing when Billy might be waiting on him, for an apology or something.

After almost an hour, he hasn’t really settled on a decision, so he heads back down—maybe Billy will be better already, maybe it was just a passing thing.

When Steve gets to the kitchen, Billy’s packing a tray of cookies into a container, and Steve can tell just from the set of his shoulders that he’s not better, sending off pretty clear don’t fuck with me vibes, so Steve switches course to the living room. Even if Billy wants him to apologize, it wouldn’t do any good right now. So, he just has to wait, like that’s easy, or something. God.

Another hour goes by before Billy wanders in, holding a plate stacked so high with cookies, it looks like a Jenga tower. He sets it on the coffee table and then just kind of stands there for a second. Then he says, “Hungry?”

“Yeah,” says Steve.

He’s starving actually, but he’s been too afraid to bother Billy in the kitchen. If it went on any longer, he was going to risk it, but he also doesn’t even know what there is to eat—Billy always gets things for him, snacks and meals and stuff. Steve can’t remember the last time he had to fend for himself, which is—disconcerting, and also embarrassing.

Billy nods at the plate, like, take one, and Steve doesn’t need more convincing. He takes a bite, and just—holy shit. He makes a truly obscene sound.

“Oh my god,” he says, words mumbled from the cookie he still can’t stop eating. “This is amazing.”

Billy’s lip sort of twitches, the first hint of a smile Steve has seen all day. “Yeah?”

“Holy shit, dude. Just—” Steve reaches for another one before he’s even finished chewing. “How the fuck do you do this? Do you even follow a recipe? Oh my god.”

Billy’s manages a shadow of a smile before it wilts. “I can make you something else,” he says, which makes no sense. Isn’t he listening? Steve never wants to eat anything else for his entire life but these cookies. “If you want, like, lunch stuff.”

“Dude,” says Steve, starting on his third one. He’s pretty sure there’s chocolate all over his face but he doesn’t care. “This is the greatest thing I have ever put in my mouth.” He glances down at Billy as obvious and dumb as he can, smirks and adds, “Seriously, man. I’m sorry, but it’s true.” 

That gets a laugh, finally, but it doesn’t last long. Billy coughs and sits on the arm of the sofa, a good four, five feet from Steve. He starts messing with the ends of his hair, which he only does when he has to do something but really doesn’t want to. It sends an anxious spike through Steve’s gut.

“So, listen,” says Billy, staring at the TV, which is playing some dumb daytime soap Steve’s mom used to watch. “We have to talk about something.” 

And that—doesn’t sound good. The cookie in Steve’s mouth gets heavier, harder to swallow. He has to cough a few times before he can choke out, “Okay.”  

What the fuck did he say last night? Billy keeps staring at the TV like he’s hyping himself up, and Steve’s mind races, trying frantically to think of what could be so bad to make Billy say we have to talk—like, everybody knows what that means, right?

The only thing Steve can think is that maybe he said something about Nancy? Something that made Billy think he still likes her, which is just—not true at all. Steve has to fight back his instinct to explain that, because it’s just a wild guess and he needs to, like, think, before he talks but. It’s so fucking hard, with Billy looking so grave and sad and nervous.

Steve tries to be patient, he really does, but the minutes drag on and on with Billy just staring at that stupid show, one crazy dramatic close up after the next, and Steve can’t take it anymore.  

“Is that what the cookies are for?” he asks, just for something to say, to break this awful, spreading quiet.

Billy looks over at Steve, there and gone, and shrugs—a new one Steve doesn’t recognize. “Wanted to make you something,” he says, which should make Steve feel better, but just makes him feel worse, because, what could they possibly have to talk about that requires hundreds of cookies to soften the blow?

“So, they’re apology cookies,” Steve jokes, because he’s an idiot who can’t shut up, and also maybe he’s starting to freak out a little.

Billy sort of glares at him. “Not apologizing,” he says. “Just telling you something.”

And okay, sure, that’s fair, that’s fine—

Steve knows it’s nuts, that there’s no proof and he’s just spiraling into crazy like he does sometimes—but the only conclusion he can come to is that Billy’s breaking up with him.

He’s stares at the plate of towering cookies, and then at Billy’s pale, unreadable face, his tight shoulders, and thinks, this is it, I’ve really lost him. The staggering weight of that thought is almost enough to make him gasp, but he holds it in. His thoughts scatter out, scrambling for something to say right now, something to stop this, because Billy’s going to leave, and Steve will be alone, and this house that was so big and empty before is going to feel like an endless, freezing cage without him. Steve can’t let that happen.

“You know you can stay here,” he says in rush, and he barely recognizes his own voice, so weird and panicked. “No matter what, like, it doesn’t matter.”

Billy looks away from the TV, his expression blank with surprise. “What?” he says.

Steve can’t think about the words, they just tumble out, “I just mean—I don’t want you to feel like you have to go back to—that house. You can stay here no matter what, like. It’s okay, even if you don’t want to do stuff, with me, anymore. I mean, you’re still, like, my best friend, and there’s the guest room. Like, you can just stay.” God, Steve is the most pathetic person in the whole fucking world. He knew that before, but now he really knows.

Billy stares at him for a long, long minute, and then he says, “Do you think I’m breaking up with you right now?” 

“Uh,” says Steve, because he doesn’t know what he thinks. He feels kind of light-headed, like his lungs aren’t working right.

“Jesus,” Billy mutters and then he slides down the arm of the couch onto the cushion, gets that much closer to Steve before he stills, grips at the blanket. “I don’t—” he starts, and swallows hard. “I’m not breaking up with you. I love you. And I don’t get why you don’t—I just. I can’t touch you right now, but—I love you, like, a lot, and I’m not breaking up with you. Okay?”

“Okay,” says Steve. He feels like his ears are ringing. He has absolutely no idea what’s even going on right now, but, yeah, it’s good, to hear that. “Sorry, but, then, like, what’s with this?” Steve asks, gesturing with the half-eaten cookie in his hand to the plate of at least twenty more.

Billy runs a hand through his hair, messing with it. “I just need to tell you something,” he says. “And you need to let me. I don’t, like, ramble and shit like you do, so it might take me a while, and if you butt in all the time I’m gonna like—lose my fucking nerve, okay? So, like, every time you feel like you need to say something—” Billy nods at the plate, “just eat a fucking cookie.”

Which is just—the weirdest, dumbest thing Steve has ever heard, like the level of planning for this—Steve should probably be offended or something, but instead he’s trying hard to stamp down on the laughter bubbling up his throat. The wound-up, heavy curl of anxiety in his gut loosens, because Billy is so stupid, but he’s, like, Steve’s favorite idiot in the whole world.

“That’s why you made so many,” Steve says, unable to hide the humor in his voice.

Billy shrugs and smiles kind of rueful, “Yeah, well. What can I say, man, you like to talk.”

Steve laughs then, and it seems to settle Billy a little. His shoulders dip and he stops touching his hair so much.

“Okay,” says Steve, more curious now. “I’m listening."

“I mean it,” says Billy, “No talking.”

Steve mimes zipping his mouth closed and locking it, but instead of throwing the imaginary key away, he hands it to Billy, who rolls his eyes but takes it and pretends to put it in his pocket. Steve skins tickles with muted laughter—he’s pretty sure he’s Billy’s favorite idiot, too.

“Okay,” Billy starts, blowing air out of his nose. Steve can’t help the tingle of his nerves at seeing Billy so worried, but all he can do is hold his breath and wait.

“So—okay. I didn’t—I never had crushes, when I was a kid, right?”

Steve doesn’t know what he was expecting, exactly, but it wasn’t that. He nods encouragingly anyway, because, sure, okay.

Billy flicks his gaze away from Steve, back to the TV still playing that dumb show, but he goes on, “I just never got it—what everyone was talking about. I could tell when people were hot, like people in movies and shit, and I liked looking at them, I guess. But I never saw anybody and thought, like. I want to fuck them, you know? Or even like kiss them or whatever. And the idea of people touching me like that—”

Billy cuts himself off and shifts awkwardly on the couch, and Steve’s trying, like, really hard not to jump to conclusions, trying really hard not to feel like shit, because he’s been touching Billy this whole time when he doesn’t even like it. But why wouldn’t he say something—didn’t he say it was good?

Billy just stares at the TV for another minute, and Steve guesses he’s just thinking about what he’s gonna say next, but yeah. It’s impossible to sit here and watch him think so much and not say something.

Steve reaches for a cookie and stuffs in his mouth in one bite. Billy turns at the movement, smirks a little at Steve’s obnoxious chewing. Steve gives him a thumbs up, because there’s got to be some way for him to say, you’re doing great, baby, without talking. Billy rolls his eyes, but then takes a breath and goes on,

“I thought, like, maybe it just happened to people when they got older, you know? Like, I kept thinking, maybe one day I would wake up and just want that. But it never happened, and everyone was, like, getting girlfriends and shit, and trying to spy on chicks at the beach, and I just—” he shrugs, “didn’t get it.” Billy clenches his jaw and doesn’t look at Steve when he says, “Thought I was broken or some shit, but. People do dumbass stuff when they’re, like, in love or trying to get laid or something. So, I just thought, who the fuck needs it, you know? Like, whatever. Everyone pisses me off anyway, so. Why would I want to fuck somebody when I don’t even like them?" 

“But then—” Billy tugs at his hair and stares at the far wall, “then I met Jack.”

Oh, Steve thinks. So, this is that conversation. He doesn’t feel like he can eat another cookie right now, thinks it would probably get stuck in his throat and choke him, but he reaches for one anyway, watches the chocolate melt all over his fingers and tries not to lose it.

“Didn’t even meet him,” Billy goes on, “I just—I had to change schools halfway through the year, and I fucking hated that, everyone staring at me cause I was fresh meat, or whatever. But Jack, like, he didn’t even care.

“He was the most popular guy in the whole fucking school. He just—he could just look at somebody and know exactly what they wanted. He made you feel like you were the coolest shit around, you know? People would get so fucking dumb around him, just like, vying for his attention and shit. He was hot as fuck, but it wasn’t even that. It was just his vibe.”

Steve keeps nodding, mostly cause he’s not sure what the fuck else to do. Feels like a million tiny needles sticking in his chest, hearing all this about some other guy Billy loves, but it’s okay, cause Billy needs to tell him this for some reason. It’s fine.

Billy finally looks over at him, and Steve’s doesn’t know what terrible look is on his face but Billy swallows, kind of guilty, and says, “I’m not—I’m just trying to explain cause like—the first time I saw him, he didn’t even notice me—and I just. I couldn’t breathe. It was like, I was just hot all over, like my skin. I’d never felt anything like that before. And I was fifteen, okay, it wasn’t like I was some kid. And it wasn’t like some fucking awakening, like, then I just wanted to fuck people after that. It was just him.

“So, whatever, we—started hanging out and. He was always talking like we’d be together forever.” Billy stares at the wall, and Steve wonders how much longer this is gonna go on before he can make some excuse to go fucking cry, but he can’t ask because he’s not allowed to talk. He eats the melted cookie in his hands for something to do.

“But I always knew,” says Billy after a minute, “that like, if we ever stopped—if we ever broke up, or whatever, I’d never find anybody else that made me feel like that. It was, like, once in a lifetime bullshit or something." 

If Steve blinks really fast, he can keep the burning in his eyes to a minimum, at least for a while. He might never be able to eat chocolate chip cookies again, though.

“And then he—” Billy’s voice is so rough, Steve has to look over. He’s eyes are sort of blurry, so it’s hard to tell, but it sort of seems like Billy’s might be, too.

“He died,” says Billy, his teeth clenched so hard, Steve wishes he could rub his thumb over his jaw. But that’s not a good idea right now—or, maybe ever again, he’s not sure. “And, uh,” Billy clears his throat and rubs his knuckles into his eyes. “I just knew, that was it, you know. I’d never get that again.”

It’s weird, how Steve keeps thinking it can’t hurt any worse than it does, and then Billy keeps going, and it turns out there’s just—endless ways his heart can twist and burn and break. And he still can’t stop nodding. 

“And I’m just telling you this,” says Billy, in a desperate kind of way that makes Steve want to hold him, despite everything. Billy looks at Steve and clenches his hands in his lap like he wants to reach out but can’t. “I’m telling you, so you’ll have, like, fucking context, okay? Because, then I got to Hawkins, and—I saw you.

“You didn’t notice me—you were, like, talking to Wheeler and just—laughing at something, and you were so—I couldn’t breathe, okay? And I just felt so fucking sick with it, because what kind of fucking piece of shit feels like that for someone else after—sixteen days. That’s it. Like—” Billy scrapes a hand through his hair again, rubs at his face. Steve feels like he might not be breathing, he’s so lost, does that mean—

“I hated you so much, for making me feel like that. And I wanted you to hate me, too, cause I thought, if you couldn’t stand the sight of me, then you’d never smile at me, and then maybe it would stop. But it didn’t—you hated me, and I just kept wanting—and then, after that shitty night—” He glances guiltily at Steve’s forehead and the scar from the time Billy cracked a plate over his head. It’s probably a sign of how fucked up Steve is, but he doesn’t mind it so much—if anyone was gonna leave a permanent mark on him, he’s glad it was Billy. “I don’t know,” Billy goes on, “You were, like, indifferent, which was so much worse.”

“I was kind of obsessed with you, I guess,” he adds, lowly, as if Steve is going to mind. “That’s why—I just started looking for you wherever I went and—” he shrugs. Steve guesses that’s why Billy started showing up at his doorstep every other week, grinning with blood in his teeth.

“I’m telling you this,” Billy says again, shifting to sit facing Steve, who’s about ready to explode, needing to touch him, to tell Billy he loves him until his voice gives out, “so, you get it, okay? Like—I can’t believe you’d think that you love me, more than I love you. That’s such bullshit. I love you so much. And I’m not with you because I need to be with someone, because I want to kiss someone or fuck someone—I don’t need that shit, okay. And—and I know I should’ve said this before, I guess, about Jack—but, baby.” Billy shifts on the couch, not touching Steve, but closer.

“There’s no better or worse, okay?” he says softly, his eyes flicking over Steve’s face like he’s making sure the words land right. “I didn’t—love him more than you—it’s just different.” 

He goes on, soft but firmly, “You are my whole world. And like, that wasn’t always true, cause I didn’t even know you before. But, right now, you are. Do you get that? I really need you to get that.” Steve nods again, his fingers clenching in the blankets so he doesn’t do something dumb, like grab Billy’s face and kiss him. 

“Okay,” says Billy, and then he lets out a really big breath, tugs at the blanket covering Steve’ legs. “You can talk now. Thanks for—being quiet. You were really good.”

Steve tries to let that ground him, and it helps a little, but not enough—“Can I touch you?” he says, his throat weirdly sore. He’s not sure how long they’ve been sitting here, maybe years.

Billy hesitates and then shifts closer, their knees knocking together. “Let me, okay,” he says, and Steve nods quickly—he’ll take anything he can get.

Billy cradles Steve’s cheek with one hand and rubs a thumb under his eye before reaching for the nape of his neck. He guides Steve’s head to his shoulder, and it’s kind of awkward with them facing each other like this, but Billy let’s Steve scooch closer, one leg curled under him, the other stretching out behind Billy. He rests his forehead on Billy’s shoulder and just breathes him in, feeling weirdly shaken—feels like the morning he lay there watching Billy sleep—all these new things swirling inside him.

He doesn’t really know what to do with it all. Last time, he just kept quiet and that didn’t really feel good, so—

“Thanks for telling me,” he says softly. “I, uh. I don’t really remember what I said, last night—but, I’m sorry if I hurt you? Or, like, made you sad, but I’m glad I—know this stuff, now. Also—I love you, like. I know I said, but—I love you, like that, too.”

Billy plays with the hair at the back of Steve’s neck, which is super long now—he really needs a haircut—then Billy says, “You said you didn’t mind, that I didn’t love you that much, which—” He tugs at Steve’s hair lightly, but with purpose, until Steve lifts his head and meets his eyes again.

“Don’t say that, okay?” Billy’s gaze is firm. “You deserve, like, the fucking world, so just. Don’t, like, settle for shit.”

“Not settling,” says Steve, tugging at the bottom of Billy’s shirt cause he’s not allowed to kiss him. Except, maybe Billy’s a little better already or something, cause he leans forward just enough to brush their lips together, barely, before resting his forehead on Steve’s.

It must be four or five already, so Steve’s gone almost the whole day without touching Billy and it’s just—so good. But it reminds him, again, how much he hates not knowing if—

“You gotta tell me, somehow,” Steve whispers, not wanting Billy to pull away, just needing him to know. “If I’m not supposed to touch you. Like, we need some kind of signal, or something, cause I’ll just do it, without thinking, and I don’t want to—I don’t ever want to make you feel bad, like that. Okay?”  

Billy’s quiet for a while, but it’s okay—Steve’s starting to get it—he’s just thinking.

“Okay,” says Billy. “I’ll come up with something.”

“Okay,” says Steve.

They sit there for a really long time, and then Billy says, “You are covered in chocolate.”

“Well,” says Steve, “Who’s fault is that?  You could’ve made sugar cookies.”

“Guess I thought you could eat like a grown-up. I’ll get you, like, a bib next time.”

“Fuck you,” says Steve, but he’s laughing before he even finishes. “Also, we have so many fucking cookies now.”

“Yeah,” says Billy, sort of embarrassed. “I didn’t mean to make that many. I just couldn’t really stop.”

“Maybe you should start a bakery. No—set up a stand! Like the Girl Scouts. “ Steve grins. “Pretty face like yours, you’d get a lot of business.”

“Oh, you think so, smartass?”

“Yup.” He’s just starting to laugh some more when Billy leans forward again and kisses him before he can.

“Love you,” says Billy against his lips. When he pulls away, Steve follows after him on instinct, but Billy stops him with a hand on his chest, meets his eyes. “I’m gonna tell you more. Okay?”

“You don’t have to,” Steve mumbles, cause like, what kind of needy asshole is Steve if he makes Billy say it like ten times a day, just cause that’s what he likes to do.

“I’m gonna,” says Billy resolutely. “Cause I don’t think you really believe me.”

“I do,” says Steve, he does.

Billy shakes his head, presses a thumb to Steve’s bitten lips. “Not enough,” he says. “But, you will. I’m gonna say it, like, so much you’ll get sick of it.”

Not possible, Steve almost says, but that sounds really dumb, so he just nods and waits for Billy to decide if they’re gonna kiss again.

He does, and they do.

 

 

 

 

End Part IV

 

 

 

 

Notes:

RE: the Warning: Nancy brings up the fact that Steve dated a 19-year-old girl when he was 15, which Nancy has a problem with (understandably). Steve doesn't see this as an issue, but also doesn't like to think about it.

 

In terms of other end notes, I just wanted to briefly comment on Billy's sexuality, in case it comes off as confusing or unexpected. I tried to hint at it earlier in the work, but basically I think Billy could be considered grey-asexual or potentially demisexual? I modeled his experience with attraction from my own, which is pretty much as he described. I don't label myself in that way, so I don't know exactly what the "correct" label is, but please let me know if you feel one way or the other about Billy's character (I'd be happy to add tags, etc). If anyone has any comments or questions, I'm always open to talk about it! Just wanted to make clear that I'm not trying to misrepresent any identities! Just writing what I know.

Hope you enjoyed!