Actions

Work Header

Panacea

Chapter 5: Setbacks

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

Dustin was pretty sure Steve was ignoring him.

It wasn’t obvious, not to anyone who didn’t know Steve as well as Dustin did. Steve had been busy Tuesday night, which was okay because Steve was always busy Tuesdays even though he never told Dustin what the hell he was doing. On Thursday they went to Steve’s like usual, but he’d looked tired and had barely said two words to Dustin the whole time. Rude, but not suspicious on its own, not until Dustin paired it with the past Monday, when Steve had disappeared upstairs with Will of all people for like, hours. But today was the last straw. It was a Friday, and Friday always meant Steve took them to the arcade after work, and usually ended up hanging out and even playing a game or two and sometimes bought them food at the diner. It was a sacred ritual. Steve had never acknowledged it as one, but he’d never missed a Friday yet, so Dustin knew that Steve had accepted its sacredness. Except this morning, an hour before they were supposed to leave for the arcade, Steve had muttered something about not being able to take them into the walkie and then switched it off before Dustin could even ask why. And Steve knew he wasn’t supposed to switch off the walkie under any circumstances.

So Steve had to be ignoring him, or all of them, or something. But what Dustin didn’t understand was why.

He glared at the walkie where it lay on his desk like it would give up Steve’s secrets if he could just intimidate it enough. This didn’t feel like that time he’d used Steve’s fancy hairspray to make a flamethrower that had almost set the curtains on fire and Steve hadn’t given him quarters for the arcade for a week. At least that time Dustin knew what he did (and he still said it was worth it, because flamethrowers were perfectly viable makeshift weapons against the Upside Down and he was just staying prepared and besides, flamethrowers were badass). This time, he couldn’t even figure out what he’d done wrong.

Making a snap decision, Dustin reached for the discarded walkie. “Party, do you copy? I repeat, Party, do you copy?” One by one each of their voices crackled an affirmative, save for Steve of course. It hadn’t taken long; maybe he hadn’t been the only one bothered by the abrupt cancellation. “I think something’s up with Steve. He never cancels on Fridays!”

Mike’s voice crackled through the speaker. “Yeah, what gives? He always takes us.” Though impatient, Dustin thought he could hear a little concern in Mike’s voice too. Even though Mike tried to play it cool, Dustin hadn’t missed the way he’d definitely gotten less vocally opposed to Steve hanging around when they played D&D, even though he still rolled his eyes at the idea of needing a babysitter.

Max’s voice was equally brash, but her worry was more evident. “Do you think something’s wrong? Like, that he’s not telling us about?”

“What if it’s Code Red stuff?” Lucas chimed in, and shit Dustin hadn’t even thought of that because if it was Upside Down stuff Steve would have told them, right? Or would he have not mentioned it because he didn’t think they could handle it? Steve was stupid like that sometimes.

“Monsters? Hurting Steve?” El asked, and Dustin jumped a little because he had no idea she’d been listening.

“We should do something,” Dustin decided. “We’ve got to figure out what’s up with him.” He didn’t know exactly what that something was, but they’d figure it out as they went. They always did.

“Maybe he’s just busy,” Will suggested, but it was quickly drowned out in the rest of their excitement. They squabbled back and forth for a bit before deciding to just meet at Mike’s, hoping it would at least let them argue without people purposefully holding down the talk button to mute everyone. El had even convinced Hopper to let her go, made easier because she’d already been cleared to go to the arcade today.

Unfortunately, they didn’t make much headway in Mike’s basement either. Dustin preferred a full-frontal assault – or, more specifically, showing up at Steve’s door and pounding on it until they were let in and given answers. It was an idea shared only by Max, who didn’t have the patience for Mike and Lucas’s suggested recon and subterfuge or Will and El’s uncertainty that they should be intervening at all.

Midway through another impassioned speech about tying Steve to a chair to make him talk, the basement door opened to reveal Nancy precariously balancing a pitcher of lemonade and a stack of cups as she came down the stairs. “Mom said to bring you this, and also to tell you to keep it down,” she directed towards Mike.

Really, Dustin doubted that last part had come from Mrs. Wheeler at all. “We can’t keep it down, Steve’s in danger and they won’t listen to me when I-”

“Steve’s in danger?” Nancy asked, pausing halfway to setting the pitcher on the table.

“Yes!” half of them shouted, just as the other half yelled “No!”

Mike huffed a frustrated sigh. “We don’t know that,” he pointed out, which was technically true even though Dustin didn’t need to know anything when his Steve radar was telling him something was off. “He just hasn’t been around as much.”

“And that could mean something is wrong,” Dustin argued.

Nancy looked like she debated something in her head for a brief moment, but seemed to reach a decision. “Look, as weird as it is to say, you’re probably around Steve more than any of us-”

“That’s exactly the problem-”

“-So you might know if Steve’s been around anyone different lately?”

Dustin had no idea what she was getting at, but the look in Nancy’s eyes was so intense he wracked his brain for a minute before answering. “Uh, not really. Not unless you count Robin or Billy. …Why? You think that’s why he’s acting so weird?”

“It’s not just weird,” Nancy said, pursing her lips in thought. “He’s acting like he did when we dated. Like he’s in love with somebody.”

Dustin gaped like a fish, and by the beat of silence before pandemonium broke out he was pretty sure the rest of the group did too.

“Steve’s got a secret girlfriend?”

“Why wouldn’t he tell us?”

“You’re not dating again, are you?”

“Obviously, she wouldn’t be asking if she was the one-”

But… it sort of made sense, didn’t it? At least a little bit. It would explain why Steve was so busy all of the sudden, and why he might have blown them off today. It might also be whatever Steve was doing on Tuesdays too. What if that was when he met up with her? But also, why hadn’t Steve told any of them?

El was frowning, even in the midst of the chaos the Wheelers’ basement had become. “But Steve and I are friends. And friends don’t lie.”

Nancy looked a little uncomfortable – like she knew just as well as any of the rest of them that friends did lie to one another for any number of reasons – but before she could reply to El, Lucas cut in with, “Wait, who would it even be?”

“That’s what I’ve been trying to figure out,” Nancy admitted a little self-consciously, as she’d been less than successful so far.

“Well, it’s definitely not Robin,” Dustin said, still a little annoyed about Steve’s continual refusal to tell him why he wouldn’t ask out the super cool amazing girl who’d cracked a freakin Russian code. “Steve kept telling me she just wasn’t his type, which is ridiculous, because how could she not be his type?”

Nancy winced. “Yeah, I uh… might have asked her? She said no. But that’s why I wanted to ask if any of you had noticed Steve with anyone else.”

Dustin and the rest of the party just shook their heads. Despite their attempted brainstorming session, they still weren’t sure what to do about Steve, and even though Nancy’s theory held water it still didn’t explain the reason for secrecy. They each agreed to keep an eye out for any clues when they saw Steve next, and the rest of the afternoon devolved into board games in the Wheelers’ basement, but as Dustin finally biked home and got inside just in time for dinner he couldn’t help staring at the wall where the phone hung.

He knew Steve might have a reason for keeping this girl secret from the others, but Steve wouldn’t lie to him. He wouldn’t. All he had to do was call and ask. But why did that feel so hard to do right now?

With an impatient sigh directed at himself, Dustin walked pointedly over to the phone and punched in Steve’s number. He was being stupid – Steve would tell him.

Unfortunately, the voice that snapped a grumpy, “What” on the other end of the line after three rings was decidedly not Steve’s. Dustin sighed; just his luck.

“Billy, is Steve there? I’ve got to talk to him.”

“Thought he told you this morning he was sick.” Billy’s voice sounded a little deeper than usual, almost like he’d been… sleeping?

“Dude, were you asleep? It’s like, six pm.”

An impatient breath crackled through the phone line. “Is that what you really called to ask?”

And no, it hadn’t been, but Dustin didn’t exactly relish the idea of trying to explain to Billy that he was going to ask Steve if he had a secret girlfriend. Plus, even if Billy knew anything about it since he lived with Steve, he wasn’t likely to tell Dustin jack shit. “No, just-” Dustin cut himself off. If he couldn’t get Steve on the phone, he only really had one plan left, right? Mike and Lucas had disagreed, but Mike and Lucas weren’t here now. “Never mind, just tell Steve I’ll talk to him soon,” he said instead, and then hung up.

He had a plan to set into motion. And step one of the plan was eating dinner, because all this secretive business had left him starving and he couldn’t be sneaky on an empty stomach.

~~

Billy raised a bemused eyebrow at the abrupt dial tone. What had that been all about exactly? Dustin was always a little weird, like the rest of the little nerds, but that was pretty damn weird even for his standards. He shook his head as he returned upstairs, heading back to the bedroom.

Steve cracked an eyelid open but made no other move. “S’that?” he asked, voice muffled where his face was half-pressed into the pillow.

“Dustin,” Billy answered, itching idly at his bare stomach. He hadn’t bothered to put on clothes just to answer a phone, so he was standing just in boxer shorts. It still made him a little amused that he could wander around this big McMansion in nothing but boxers – it felt taboo when compared to the prim, stuffy decorating.

Steve sat up a little more at that, lifting his head and leaning back against the pillows to face Billy more fully, the left side of his hair flattened comically to his face. “Was he alright?”

Billy sat at the edge of the bed. “He sounded fine, as far as I could tell. He wouldn’t tell me what he was calling about though.”

“Maybe I should-” Steve started, already making movements to get out of bed, but Billy stopped him with a hand on his shoulder.

“It can wait till tomorrow,” he insisted. Steve still looked exhausted; he figured a few nights of panic attack-inducing nightmares that may or may not have been supernaturally connected, paired with their attempts to strategically rework their sleep schedule so that they were awake for 2:15, would do that to a guy. Billy was certainly feeling the effects himself; it had taken a few rings for him to hear the phone through the haze of his own sleep, even though he was usually such a light sleeper. It had been required, living with Neil. He’d started to sleep a little deeper nowadays.

The new schedule had been draining to switch to all at once, but it had been working at least. Steve didn’t seem to get the nightmares as long as he was awake for the time instead of asleep. It meant they were right after all about the time not being a coincidence, even as it gave them a way to avoid the dream. But it had also led to an increase in mid-day naps, or mid-evening as the current case may be, as Steve had insisted on going back to work tomorrow and not leaving Robin alone again, and for that he had to get at least some sleep.

Steve, though he looked tired enough not to put up much of an argument, had an uncertain frown on his face. “I’ve been thinking, I know we’ve been trying to avoid the nightmares, but what if that’s not the right call?”

Billy stared at him incredulously. “You want the nightmares?”

“Well no, not really. But it’s been two days since we noticed the pattern and we still haven’t figured out anything about the nightmares – why I’m getting them, who’s making them happen, or even what they’re trying to do with them. Maybe… well, maybe we could learn a little more if I actually had them.”

”This is a terrible idea," Mind Fucker said, and Billy had to agree. ”Whatever the dreams are trying to accomplish, we are better off not knowing than letting them accomplish it. Plus I do not enjoy when he panics.”

Yeah, neither did Billy. “I don’t want you to have to do that. If we know a way to stop them from happening at all, isn’t that enough?”

“For how long?” Steve waved a hand to the dark circles under his eyes. “I can’t keep this schedule forever. I’ve got eighteen years of experience that say when 2 in the morning rolls around I should be asleep, and they’re not easy to ignore. I’m gonna slip up at some point, and I’d rather it be on purpose now than by total surprise later. And what if the dreams are just… a warning for something worse? And ignoring them ends up fucking us? If everyone was put in danger because I couldn’t handle a stupid dream…”

Billy didn’t like it, and Mind Fucker certainly didn’t either, but Steve had a point. How long could they keep this up for? And what if it really did mean something much worse was coming? Without any information, they’d never know how to stop the dreams for good.

”This is still a bad idea.”

Steve reached out for Billy’s hand, covering it with his own. “The last time, the Mind Flayer looked at me. Like it knew I was there, and it was there too. If I can figure out anything about this, anything at all, then it has to be in the dream.”

Billy sighed, his shoulders slumping at Steve’s determined look. “Tomorrow,” he offered. “No offense, but you still look like shit, and you’ve got work in the morning. We’ll try it tomorrow.” Billy broke their contact only to scoot up to the head of the bed himself and lay down properly. “In the meantime, we should get some sleep while we can. We’ve still got a while before we have to be awake.”

He hardly needed much persuasion there. Steve’s eyes were already starting to close again as he gave a contented hum and slung an arm across Billy’s waist. Maybe, after they slept, Billy could convince Steve this was a stupid plan and it wasn’t worth the risk. Then again, he thought as he considered the amazing amounts of stubbornness Steve could exhibit when he was worried about someone else, probably not.

~~

The plan was in motion. Dustin had not-so-subtly dropped hints to his mom over dinner about how Steve was sick, and probably couldn’t even get up to make food for himself, and how sad and tragic was that, poor sick Steve, foodless? Mom had made the appropriate gasps of sympathy for Steve, who’d practically become a fixture in their lives over the last year, and had packaged up the rest of the casserole leftovers in Tupperware (their nice one too, since she knew it would make Steve return it soon and she’d get to make sure he was feeling better for herself) and let Dustin take it right over after dinner on his bike.

Dustin hoped Steve was grateful, because it had been a good casserole. The things Dustin did in the name of brotherhood.

It was only around 8 pm when Dustin slowed to a stop in front of Steve’s house. The lights were on, but that didn’t mean much because Steve liked to leave the lights on even in the middle of the night, so Dustin tried knocking first before giving up and grabbing the key from the big potted plant by the door. Like he’d told Billy before, it wasn’t technically breaking and entering if Steve had all but given him the spare key, right?

Unlocking the door and heading inside, casserole in hand, Dustin noted the house was still suspiciously quiet. Steve and Billy’s cars were both parked in the driveway, so the chances of them not being in the house were slim, though he couldn’t entirely rule it out. He set the Tupperware down on the kitchen counter, considering his options. Maybe Steve was just in his room? That could explain why he hadn’t heard the knocking. He could just run upstairs for a quick check; it seemed like a missed opportunity to have come all the way here and have his perfectly laid plan, complete with a believable reason he’d come over that wasn’t just interrogation, go to waste.

He’d just poke his head in. If Steve wasn’t there, he’d have to come back tomorrow, but if he was then he could get this whole business over with and he would know for sure that there was no way Steve was lying to him.

Now committed, he took the stairs in twos, heading down the hallway to Steve’s door. The Harringtons had so many extra rooms that, now that he thought about it, he wasn’t totally sure which one Billy’s was. But it was fine because he really did not want to run into Billy right now anyway, and he knew enough to know which one was Steve’s room despite the relatively few times he’d actually been up here.

Dustin pushed the door open a crack and stuck his head in, just enough to see that Steve was in fact in bed at only 8 pm. It must have been some sickness he’d picked up, which in retrospect Dustin really didn’t want to catch now that it looked like it was real, so he should probably go –

Except, now that he looked, was there someone else in Steve’s bed?

There was another lump in the blankets next to Steve, and the lamp in the corner of the room kept things just bright enough Dustin thought he could make out blonde hair peeking out from the covers. Had Nancy actually been right? Was this the secret girlfriend? She had to be – why else could he see the edge of a bare calf sticking out of the blankets?

He knew he should just close the door and go. He’d wanted to give Steve a chance to tell him the truth, and he’d just ruin that if he looked. But he also couldn’t deny he was a little curious to see just why Steve hadn’t wanted to tell any of them. And, if he was being honest with himself, his faith in Steve’s truthfulness was a little shaken when confronted with evidence like this.

A quick peek couldn’t hurt. Then at least he would know Steve was telling the truth when he told his old pal Dustin about his new girlfriend. Not wanting to wake them, Dustin crept closer to the bed so he could get a better look at her face, which was turned towards Steve. She had an arm slung across Steve’s chest, an arm that was sort of muscular, almost a little masculine actually, and when Dustin followed the path from the arm up to the face-

Holy shit. Holy shit holy shit holy SHIT.

Billy fucking Hargrove was in Steve’s bed. Sleeping with him. Cuddling.

A yelp of surprise tore free from Dustin despite his best efforts to back away silently, and his scramble backwards left him overbalancing and hitting the wall with a resounding thud. Steve’s eyes flew open, startled and then confused as he took in Dustin, pressed against his wall and not moving like an idiot. And then Billy sat up behind him and Steve must have made the realization at that moment because both their eyes went wide. It would have been funny if Dustin wasn’t sporting the same look on his own face.

“…Dustin?” Steve asked, voice thin.

“Steve,” Dustin said, for lack of anything better coming to mind.

“…This isn’t what it looks like?”

Notes:

Dustin, bursting into the room: Wake up sleepyhead!!
Steve: Dustin-
Billy, in bed behind him: What the fuck, man
Dustin: :0

There’s a certain irony to writing about Steve not being able to adapt to a new sleep schedule of being up at 2 am, and then looking down at my own clock and it’s 3 am. Maybe I should take Steve’s advice lol.