Chapter Text
“How can this not be what it looks like?”
Okay, that wasn’t the response Steve had been hoping for, but it was probably fair. Even he could admit it was a little… compromising… to be caught in bed with the guy you were supposed to be having a secret relationship with. What a secret – they’d made it what, a month and a half? He doubted all the deflection in the world was going to save him this time.
Dustin took Steve’s lack of an answer as an opportunity to continue. “Because what it looks like,” he said, gesturing to the bed at large, “is your mystery girlfriend is actually a boyfriend, and it’s Billy!”
He thought I had a girlfriend? was Steve’s immediate first thought, which he quickly discarded as not the most pressing concern right now. Billy hadn’t said a word, and was a frozen line of tension against Steve’s back; Steve covertly slid a hand backwards until it brushed against Billy’s fingertips. “Listen, just – shit, just calm down a minute okay? Because I get it if you want to leave or you never want to see me again or whatever but you can’t tell anyone, alright? I know that’s a lot to ask, but I’m serious man, just-”
“Never see you again?” Dustin repeated, and Steve cringed in expectation of anger, or disgust, or anything he’d really hoped Dustin would never look at him with, but Dustin just looked a little dumbstruck. “I… Steve, I don’t hate you or anything, Jesus.”
Steve was a little embarrassed to admit that the relief of those words felt like a ton of bricks being lifted from his chest. “You don’t?”
Dustin shook his head adamantly. “I’m surprised, yeah, of course I’m surprised. Who wouldn’t be? And I have to admit that I don’t really get your taste – I mean, Billy? You didn’t ask Robin out and you went from Nancy to Billy?” If Billy had been at all able to respond, he probably would have had something snarky to say about that. Steve kind of missed it when it went unsaid. “But I don’t hate you Steve. You’re like my brother. And even if you weren’t, that’s not, like, bad or anything. I know some people think so, but they’re idiots.”
Steve mentally kicked himself a little for doubting Dustin; he wasn’t like that, he was a good kid, Steve knew that, and maybe he shouldn’t have been so worried. He couldn’t exactly be blamed for worrying about what a small town like Hawkins was imparting on the youth, of course, but it was nice to know that the kid he’d come to really care about wasn’t going anywhere. He smiled, something that was still tinged with surprise but was mostly just relieved and happy he had Dustin in his life now.
Finally Billy spoke. “So you won’t tell anyone?” It was probably as soft as Dustin had ever heard Billy sound. Even Steve, who’d long since discovered the big softie Billy liked to pretend he wasn’t, was still caught off-guard by its hesitance and uncertainty.
“Of course not. ...Not that I really like keeping secrets from my friends.” Dustin gave a pointed stare at Steve as he said this. Steve rubbed the back of his neck a little sheepishly by way of apology, but really, what had Dustin expected? That Steve wasn’t going to keep it as quiet as possible that he was dating a guy in Hawkins, Indiana? “But… I get why you didn’t want people to know. Even me. And I’m sorry for butting in, okay?”
And yeah, the dejected tone Dustin said ‘even me’ with was really making Steve feel like a bit of an ass, even as he knew he wouldn’t have endangered himself and Billy like that before he knew for sure how Dustin would react. “I’m sorry, for the secrecy. We just couldn’t tell anyone, and that included you too man. …Speaking of which, what did you come over here for anyway? And what were you saying about the secret girlfriend I supposedly have?”
Dustin sighed, but didn’t look quite so forlorn. “Oh yeah, there’s casserole leftovers downstairs for you from my Mom – I told her you were sick. I was… kind of using it as an excuse to come over because we were all worried that you seemed like you were avoiding us and we were afraid it was Upside Down stuff but then we thought you might be spending time with a girlfriend instead and so I was just gonna ask you but now… well…” Dustin’s sudden flurry of information tapered off into uncertainty as he indicated the room at large.
Billy, who’d moved so he was no longer half-hidden by Steve’s shoulder but was now probably making Dustin very aware of his shirtlessness judging by the kid’s sudden interest in the carpet, processed the jumble of words a bit faster than Steve. “So your whole nerd gang is convinced the reason Steve’s been missing in action is because of a girlfriend?” He hissed a considering breath through his teeth.
“But they thought it was Upside Down stuff first,” Steve pointed out, and while he’d always been shit at lying, he was pretty sure he had a mystery that would keep the kids distracted enough that they wouldn’t look into Steve’s love life any further. “So what if we just tell them it is?” Steve looked over and caught Billy’s eye, and saw his reluctant agreement.
Dustin raised an unimpressed eyebrow. “That stuff is serious. We can’t just lie about it.”
“We wouldn’t be lying.” Briefly, Steve explained the strange nightmares, the specific time, and his worries that the other Mind Flayer might be trying to communicate something in the dreams. “We don’t really know what’s causing them, but some nights I get them and some nights I don’t. We’ve been avoiding them by not sleeping normal hours… hence why we were asleep in the middle of the evening.” Steve left out his idea about purposefully facing the nightmare tomorrow night – he knew Dustin wouldn’t like it, but it was the best plan they had.
“Yeah, that’s a little more of a pressing concern than who you’re dating,” Dustin said once Steve had explained. “I’m sure if you told them that, they’d chalk the disappearing act up to the dreams and weird sleep and would forget all about the girlfriend idea. But Steve has to go back to hanging out with us again to sell this. No more ditching Fridays, or they’ll realize something else is up.”
Steve laughed a little. “If I had known I was signing away all rights to privacy when I started taking you little shits to the arcade, I would have dropped your asses at the side of the road.” It wasn’t true of course, wasn’t even close – even if they were obnoxiously nosey, it was nice knowing that people would actually care if he disappeared now, that somebody would actually even notice when he stopped showing up. “Alright, I’ll tell them to come over here Sunday when I’m off from work, and we’ll tell everyone about the dreams then.”
By then, he’d hopefully have a better idea of what they were dealing with.
~~
When Steve entered Family Video the next morning, Robin took one look at him, grabbed his arm, and hauled him towards the break room. “We have to talk,” she insisted, pushing him down into a shitty plastic chair and shutting the door firmly behind her.
“Uh,” Steve managed dumbly, still a little in shock at the abrupt handling.
“Nancy is on to you. She came looking for you the other day, and she asked me if we were dating, and when I said no she got all interested about if you had some secret girlfriend and I told her to let it go but we both know she’s not going to. Also,” she added, giving him a quick once-over, “you look like shit. Why do you look like shit?”
“Would you believe me if I said I was sick?” Steve asked, still trying to process the first part of her statement.
“Considering I’ve never seen your hair look this flat? Yeah, I probably would, if I didn’t know better.”
“Know better? Dude, you’ve known me for like, three months.”
“Yeah, and in those three months I saw Russians beat the shit out of you and you were still on your feet and swinging bats at mall-sized monsters. So no, I don’t think any sickness short of the bubonic plague would keep you out of work for two days on its own.”
“…Fair point,” Steve allowed begrudgingly. Plus he was starting to process what she’d said about Nancy. “Fuck,” he moaned, “we’re the worst secret couple, like, ever. Nancy’s suspicious, the damn kids are all suspicious, and – Jesus – Dustin knows. ”
Robin’s eyes widened. “No shit? How’d that go?”
“It was an accident, of course, and that kid’s never been able to leave well enough alone – just look at the Russian broadcast – but he took it… surprisingly well.” Steve couldn’t help the surprised yet pleased smile from breaking out on his face again. It had been messy, and not his ideal circumstances, but it was also nice to know Dustin was okay with him, even if he still questioned his judgment in boyfriends.
Robin didn’t look particularly surprised, but she did seem happy for him nonetheless. “So, circling back to why you look like shit…?”
“Long story,” Steve sighed, peeking out the break room window to see the first customers trickling into the store. “Come over Sunday? With any luck it’ll keep everyone distracted and we won't have to worry about anyone else getting too nosy. That said, it’s… well, we think it might be more monster shit. If, you know, you don’t want to get wrapped up in that again, I’d get it.” He’d very much miss having her around, but he wasn’t going to get her tangled up in Hawkins’ weird supernatural business again if she wasn’t up for it.
“And how long do you think you’ll make it without my indispensable help? I don’t think so.” Robin flashed a cocky smirk at him as they got up to return to the front of the store, and Steve let relief win out over the guilt of dragging her back into Upside Down stuff. It was nice to know she had his back, whether they were facing down monsters or disgruntled movie renters.
Two hours into his shift later, Steve was legitimately debating which was worse.
~~
As tired as he had been, it was a little hard for Steve to fall asleep that night. His eyes kept slipping over to the clock, watching 11:30 become 11:45 which became 12:25 before he knew it. As ready as he’d been to commit to finding out more about these nightmares tonight, the nervousness he felt and the hard line of tension that was Billy beside him were really making it hard to actually fall asleep. But he had to do this, because being completely blind about whatever was going on was worse than whatever he might learn. When he finally felt his eyes starting to close of their own volition, it was nearly 2 am, and Steve had just a brief blurry moment to be thankful he hadn’t accidentally stayed awake this night.
He was back in the Starcourt Mall again, and the repetition was enough that this time he was at least distantly conscious of the fact that he was dreaming. The Mind Flayer towered over Billy once again, and again Steve was locked in place, but this time he had the presence of mind to shout at the thing in the hopes that he wasn’t wrong, and that maybe he could learn something from this after all. “Why are you doing this?” he yelled, furious gaze turned towards the Mind Flayer, which paused and turned to regard him.
The scene around them seemed to freeze in time, blurring at the edges, until it felt like just Steve and the Mind Flayer in the chasm of the half-busted mall. He clenched his fists against the empty air where his bat should have been, trying vainly to quell the rabbit-like beating of his own heart as the Mind Flayer rumbled nearer.
The voice it spoke with was entirely foreign, a deep and sonorous growl that dripped with malice, tinged with the odd reverb he’d heard, just once, in Billy’s voice when Mind Fucker had seemed to speak through him. “Aren’t you a curious one,” it said, voice seeming to echo against the walls of Steve’s head. ”I can certainly see what he found so special in you and that friend of yours.”
Steve’s arms involuntarily trembled; he crossed them over his chest, digging his nails into his skin to ground himself. “He – you mean, the other one of you. The one inside Billy.”
”Yes… and my plans had been going so well too. No matter, I have only been… delayed.” The Mind Flayer was practically on top of him now, the smell of its rotting flesh skin making Steve recoil. ”As for your question, I will tell you what I told your young friend, the one who let us in. Doors are opening once again. We are going to stay. We’re going to end you, and then we’re going to end everything.”
It paused, and seemed to look almost like it was considering Steve. ”I was overconfident last time. I overlooked you. I will not make the same mistake again.” The Mind Flayer’s clawed appendages reached out as if to gut him like he’d seen happen to Billy in these dreams, but something yanked at his shoulder and sent him stumbling backwards, a half-step of distance between himself and where the limb had slammed into the floor, cracking the tiles. He didn’t know for sure if the Mind Flayer could hurt him here, but looking at the damage, he wasn’t willing to take that risk if he didn’t have to. When someone behind him kept pulling on his arm, he didn’t think twice about it before he turned and ran.
He kept half his brain on keeping his feet under him and the Mind Flayer behind him, and half looking at who his mystery rescuer was. They were turned away from him, but Steve could make out long dark hair, long enough he was pretty sure she was a girl. It didn’t make sense, not if the Mind Flayer was responsible for these dreams, that someone else would have been here to save him, right? Not unless –
The girl turned back to judge the Mind Flayer’s progress, and at once Steve thought he could recognize the profile of her face. “Heather?” he asked, nearly missing a step but recovering well enough to dive behind cover with her. “What are you doing here?” And that was, maybe, a stupid question to ask considering it was his dream and if anything he had probably thought her up, right? How did dreams work anyway? Jesus, he didn’t know.
“I could ask you the same question. These dreams suck, but it’s usually Billy dying, not you.”
Steve blinked in surprise, because that didn’t make any sense. This was his dream, right? And he really thought that any Heather he would have dreamed up in the mall would have been Mind Flayer-possessed, or at least not actively confusing him. But what she said wasn’t adding up, because it was him who had to watch Billy die, but Heather was talking like this was her dream… “Are you… real? Like, actually here?”
Realization lit her eyes, but before he could get his answer, Steve noticed they’d been spotted; the Mind Flayer lumbered over to them once again, but before it could move to attack the mall suddenly fell away and he was slamming up in bed once again.
~~
Billy was woken abruptly from his admittedly already light slumber for the second night in a row, and really, he was starting to doubt which night was worse. Because while waking up to discover they’d been found out had absolutely sucked and nearly left him struck dumb with panic, seeing Steve barely able to breathe while he calmed down was really fighting for that number one spot of worst things to wake up to.
He still felt like he hadn’t fully processed what had happened last night. It was terrifying, to know his and Steve’s safety was now entrusted to a fourteen year old, when any slip up could really fuck them over. But at the same time, Dustin hadn’t run screaming for the hills or, as far as he could tell, went spreading it all around town. While he’d gotten a stink eye or two from the kid, he had felt like they were more because he could never be good enough for his precious Steve (and damn if Billy didn’t think the same thing) rather than because what they were doing was wrong or disgusting to Dustin. And that, at least, had been a little nice. Dustin, and Robin for that matter, had made him reconsider his own paranoia – not that he was likely to run around Hawkins proclaiming he had a boyfriend or anything, but that maybe certain people would… understand.
It was likely this confusing jumble of reactions that had ultimately let Steve win their disagreement about facing these nightmares again. But as he watched the panic slowly ebb from the tense line of Steve’s shoulders, he regretted not pushing his side harder.
“It’s… it’s coming back. Or at least it’s trying to.” Billy didn’t have to ask who it was. “Billy, it’s coming after you. After us. I don’t know when, I don’t know how to stop it or what to do about it, but whatever closing the gate last month did, it wasn’t permanent.”
“Well fuck,” Billy sighed, just as Mind Fucker gave an angry growl.
”As far as I can tell, the gate that was under the mall is closed. If it is seeking a way into this world, it must be finding another path.” That wasn’t particularly comforting. While it was at least good to know that their actions to close the gate hadn’t been entirely in vain, it also meant they had no idea what door it was trying to use, which made it a lot harder to stop.
He opened his mouth to relay Mind Fucker’s message to Steve, but before he could the shrill ringing of the phone cut him off. “Who the hell is calling at two in the morning?” Billy asked, a little dumbfounded and a touch worried. Because if Steve was getting a call at this time, it couldn’t be anything good, and there was nobody out of the pool of people who had Steve’s number that he wanted to hear were in some kind of danger. Damn, but being with Steve really had turned him soft.
Speaking of, Steve was already getting out of bed and heading for the phone with a mumbled, “I think I might have an idea.” Billy followed a few steps behind, if only because he had no idea who Steve was talking about, and hit the lower floor just as Steve was saying “Harrington residence” into the receiver. Polite as always, even at 2 am – it would have been amusing, if Billy wasn’t listening so hard to make out the other side of the phone call.
There was a pause before Steve spoke again, listening to the voice that Billy could only identify as female, though the actual words were too quiet to be made out. “Yeah, that was – that was me. In the dream. I don’t know what’s going on, not completely, but I’m trying to figure it out too.” Another pause. “Heather, listen, I think… I think you should come over tomorrow afternoon. We’re going to figure this out, but we can’t do it alone.”
If he was understanding this right, Heather had… been in Steve’s dream? Or more than that, she and Steve had been in the same dream with the Mind Flayer. Shit.
Steve had just hung up the phone again, looking pretty damn overwhelmed, and all Billy could think to do was smile a little, something paper-thin that wasn’t really meant to be convincing, and joke, “You cheating on me with Heather in your dreams?”
Steve’s resulting chuckle was born more of surprise and relief than humor, but it was something.
