Actions

Work Header

Playing Defense

Chapter Text

When the lab finally intruded on Steve’s life again, he didn’t even notice. He’d been far too wrapped up in the walking storm that was Nancy Wheeler.

Nancy was smart and beautiful and unbelievably kind, practically the antithesis to everything Steve was. She smiled at him and the corners of her eyes crinkled and Steve felt like he was over the goddamn moon. And she was perfectly, indisputably normal. She was so normal it made Carol roll her eyes in exasperation. Steve chased after that normalcy like a moth to a flame, might have done so even if he hadn’t liked who Nancy turned out to be once he got to know her, but he did like her and she liked him too so really he figured he’d completely lucked out for once.

He even laughed when Nancy pointed insistently at some math equation that didn’t make a damn bit of sense to Steve, trying to explain something that he knew was only going to fly right over his head. She smiled at him, and when she rolled her eyes in amusement at his total cluelessness and said, “You’re an idiot, Steve Harrington,” he tried to let it feel like the playful teasing it was probably supposed to be. He’d long since learned not to get so sensitive over having his own idiocy pointed out – it wasn’t like he was winning a Nobel Prize anytime soon, and it wasn’t like anybody knew what he’d been up to before the age of twelve instead of learning basic reading and math. He’d resigned himself to always playing catch-up a long time ago. So he just smiled and kissed Nancy and let himself bask in how amazingly lucky he had gotten.

Except that was about when everything had started to fall apart. Jonathan Byers’ brother disappeared, and so did Nancy’s friend Barb, from his own party. And then Nicole started talking about some pictures Jonathan had taken of the same night, pictures of him and Nancy.

He thumbed through Jonathan’s pictures, raising an eyebrow at the sheer creep factor on display and ignoring his protests, but stopped dead when he caught sight of the last one in his stack. It had been taken when they’d been in the pool, a close shot of his arms around Nancy. But the water had weighed down the long sleeves of his shirt and washed off the concealer that usually kept the dark ink scrawled across the soft skin of his wrist hidden, leaving it on full display in grainy black and white.

Had Jonathan had time to look at the picture? No, probably not; he’d only just developed them when Nicole had spotted them, and she’d wasted no time in reporting back about them. Really, the number was hardly visible. If you didn’t know what you were looking at, it would have probably been hard to tell it was a number at all. But it wasn’t a chance Steve could take. Not when a single photo taken by fucking Jonathan Byers could have sent his whole precariously balanced life crashing to the ground.

So he tore the other photos into pieces, and rained them down on the blacktop to blow away in the wind, and smashed Jonathan’s camera for good measure so he wouldn’t have to worry about any more pictures getting taken. But he took the shredded remains of that photo and slipped them into the pocket of his jacket, and resolved to burn them or something when he got home.

Things only went further off the rails from there. There was seeing Jonathan in Nancy’s room after Nancy had blown him off, and letting Tommy talk him into that dumb shit at the movie theater, and getting his face beat in by Jonathan in the next alley over. And somehow, that had changed everything. Because Steve wasn’t a big enough idiot to not know when he’d been a real piece of work. And even though he’d blocked out any emotion reading a long time ago, he still felt Jonathan’s hurt and anger when he’d mentioned his brother right before their fight, pulsing and bright and catching him so off guard he hadn’t been prepared for Jonathan’s first punch. And in the face of that kind of emotion, listening to Tommy and Carol talk about Jonathan like he’d killed his little brother and stuffed his body in the woods somewhere filled him with a self-disgust he hadn’t felt in a very long time.

So he’d told Tommy to kiss his ass, and decided if he was going to fix his fuck up, he should probably start with Jonathan. He drove over to the Byers’ place, trying to remember what the hell a genuine apology sounded like, but as it turned out Jonathan and Nancy had been a little busy and didn’t have much time for what would have probably been a sorry excuse for an apology anyway because there was a fucking faceless monster coming through the wall.

Considering the circumstances, he was too piss-scared in that moment to even think of using his powers, staring down some creepy fucking sci-fi monster with petals for a head and jaws filled to the brim with serrated teeth, when he’d just come to clear the air with Jonathan. Before he could even process what the fuck had just happened he was swinging a nail-covered baseball bat at it for dear life and amazingly, not once did it ever cross his mind that he had a much better method of defense, not until the thing had gone up in flames in the middle of the Byers’ hallway.

Later, Nancy explained just what the hell he’d stumbled into, at least to the extent that she knew. Which really wasn’t much – a plan to find Jonathan’s missing brother, something about another dimension, and the monster that had apparently taken Barb right in his own backyard. He shuddered at the idea. A month went by before he could even look at that damn pool without picturing that thing lurking at the edge of the woods.

But miraculously, things started to go back to normal after that. Hawkins had a weird tendency for ignoring any oddities that couldn’t be easily explained it seemed, and no one knew that better than Steve himself. But it was weird to watch it happen from this perspective. It was weird to watch his relationship with Nancy patch itself back up, and to quietly make amends with Jonathan, and to try and forget he’d seen a real life demon coming through the walls of the Byers’ house.

But if there was one thing Steve was good at, it was pretending everything about his life was normal. He figured this was just one more thing to add to the pile of ‘shit to never think about or talk about again.’ After all, it wasn’t like the nightmares were anything new either.

~~~

He might have continued on in blissful ignorance had it not been for the kids’ complete inability to keep a secret.

He’d come over just to take Nancy out to dinner, but she’d needed a few more minutes to get ready, which somehow resulted in her weird little brother and his geeky friends regaling him with the extended plot of their last equally weird nerd game.

Steve had faded in and out of paying attention as they talked about 20 letter D’s and fireball whiskey or something, wishing he’d just waited for Nancy in the car. That was, until her brother Mike had said, “And then Dustin tried to throw the goblins off the board like he had Eleven’s mind powers or something and-”

Steve froze, and before he could think of anything else he interrupted Mike’s spiel with an abrupt, “Did you say Eleven?”

Mike faltered, looking caught out, and looked at his friends for help, but they seemed similarly unsure of what to say. “Uh… I meant Eleanor?” Mike tried after a beat, but Steve didn’t need any stupid powers to know that was a damn lie.

It could have been a coincidence, of course. Maybe people really did go around naming their kids numbers these days – hell, it’s not like Steve would know. And maybe those kids also sometimes had “mind powers.” That wasn’t so strange, right? It could totally happen.

But he knew that there had been more kids at that damn lab than just himself. He remembered seeing a little girl, quickly shuffled past him. He knew what his number seven implied.

Steve rubbed his thumb subconsciously against the skin of his wrist. “No, you definitely said Eleven,” he pressed, carefully restraining himself from grabbing Nancy’s brother by the shoulders and shaking some sense into him.

The curly haired kid, Dusty or Dustin or whatever, gave an exaggerated snort and a roll of his eyes. “Dude, you really are an idiot. He said Eleanor! What kind of a name is Eleven anyway?”

And, well. Steve could answer that question, but it wasn’t an answer he was going to give to a bunch of twelve year olds. And, as Mike told him next, looking more than a little morose, “Eleanor” was gone now anyway. Steve didn’t know if gone meant left or dead or what, but he couldn’t push without revealing some real uncomfortable truths to a bunch of pre-teens. And even though he’d considered that after what they’d done facing down that monster Nancy might understand if he explained, he hadn’t gotten the nerve to tell her yet, let alone these brats.

So he forced himself to relax back into the couch, and he scoffed and rolled his eyes and said “Whatever losers” and acted like he very much definitely did not care about the girl named Eleven.

It didn’t matter anyway. By the time he’d found out there was a girl who could push stuff around with her mind, she was already gone. And Steve was right back where he started.

~~

It wasn’t until much later that he’d seen the newspaper article. It had been casually discarded on the cheap Formica table of the 24 hour diner, left behind by some careless, freshly caffeinated reader. Research scientist Dr. Martin Brenner, age 58. Papa’s face stared up at him printed in cheap black and white ink, blurred and marked by a coffee ring. Steve stared at his face, and the word dead that stared mockingly up at him from the paper, and for once couldn’t figure out how to identify the emotions he was feeling.