Chapter Text
He was going to tell Nancy. He really was. Steve had every intention of getting up the courage to wipe off the concealer on his arm, show her the number, explain what it meant. Hell, maybe he could go looking for an old newspaper while he was at it, he was sure the library must have had some from 1969 though he’d never run the risk of going looking for them before.
But then there had been that disastrous Halloween party, and Nancy had spat the word bullshit at him like she knew just how accurate it really was, and any plans to tell her the truth had fallen through in an instant.
And sure, he got that Nancy wasn’t as practiced as he was at pretending like everything was okay when it was far from it. In fact, if King Steve had ever really been king of anything, it was probably king of lying to himself. So he would have understood if she’d just meant lying about Barb’s death was too much for her.
He couldn’t risk it though, no matter how hard Nancy pressed about telling Barb’s parents the truth. If the lab found out he’d been involved in the secret getting out… He’d long since assumed the lab had always known who he was. He’d gone back to the same house they’d stolen him from, for God’s sake. But the same kid going missing a second time was more likely to draw unwanted attention, so Steve figured that was why they’d left him alone. Or hell, maybe with Eleven and whoever had come in between, they’d decided they didn’t need him anymore after all.
But he knew their truce was tenuous at best. If the lab had any reason to think he might expose what they’d done… well, it might be too suspicious to kidnap the same kid twice, but it was hardly suspicious at all if that kid just turned up dead one day. They could probably fake it too – they’d used that body double they fished out of the quarry for Will. He doubted his own parents would have much reason to check if he was full of stuffing too.
Or maybe they’d just tie up his loose end. He didn’t know which option was worse really. Though maybe he did. A part of him had decided long ago that he’d rather die than go back to that awful place.
So when Nancy started calling him bullshit, well, when it came to lying about Barb and pretending he was just an idiot teenager, maybe she was right.
But damn it, when he’d told Nancy he loved her he’d meant it. He’d been more honest than he’d ever been before in his entire life. And to think that she’d said it back to him and not meant the same, to think that as much as he wanted to deny it he couldn’t feel any love coming from her when she looked at him…
Which was all not to even mention the walking problem that was Billy Hargrove.
Billy, who had swung into the school parking lot in his loud, dumb Camaro, already stomping around like he owned the place day one. Billy, who made all the Hawkins girls fawn after him in his wake. Billy, who seemed to have an aversion to pants in his own size.
Not that Steve had noticed that last one, of course.
All of those things were frustrating enough on their own, but they weren’t what made Billy such a problem. No, that was the way Billy had taken one look at him and decided that there was no greater task on all of God’s green earth than annoying the ever living fuck out of Steve.
Tactics ranged from giving Steve yet another bruise to ice after basketball, to sneering pretty boy at him like it was going out of style, to staring at him throughout all of second period looking three minutes away from trying to eat him alive. Frankly, Steve had no idea what his game was. Intimidation, he got. Roughhousing on the court, he got. Burning a hole through the back of his head when they were both supposed to be taking a pop quiz on Catcher in the Rye? Yeah, that one didn’t make as much sense to him.
Though he had to appreciate his teacher’s timing with making him read a story about a kid who runs around calling everyone else a “phony” while the memories of the lovely Halloween party were still freshly healing scars. It was good to know fate still had it out to kick him in the balls whenever it could. Well, it had company now.
Anyway. He was getting real tired of Billy’s shit. Especially when Billy’s shit involved fucking with him in the middle of the locker room after everyone else had conveniently already left.
“Harrington,” he teased in his stupidly gravelly voice, “what’s got your panties in a twist today, huh? What’s the matter, you not interested in being a team player anymore?”
Steve rolled his eyes. No, he was most definitely not interested in being a “team player” with Billy Hargrove. “Team player, huh? Tell that to the guy who’d rather fuck with his teammates than actually score any points.”
Billy leaned himself against the locker next to the one Steve currently had open, easy and lazy, with his neck pulled back like he was baring his throat. “Aw Steve, you know you’re the only one I fuck with. Not like Nancy though, huh? Saw her hanging around that Byers freak.” His lips quirked up in a grin, tongue poking out between his bared teeth.
Steve tried to stifle the urge to punch him. “Fuck you man.” It was a weak comeback at best, but he was exhausted. The last thing he wanted to hear about was Nancy hanging out with Jonathan, and the last person he wanted to hear it from was Billy.
Billy took the rebuke with his usual amounts of shits given, which was to say none. “Right, guy like you, you probably have droves of girls on your heels, huh pretty boy? Plenty of bitches in the sea, as I like to say. ‘Course, plenty of guys out there for Nancy to fuck too.”
Steve gritted his teeth. “Fuck. You,” he repeated, because he knew Nancy wouldn’t do that shit to him, and it wasn’t worth getting himself pissed off at Billy for something he knew to be a lie.
Billy only laughed, undeterred. “Not a chance.” He leaned in close, until Steve could make out his individual eyelashes, and did he wear mascara? “Unless you like that sort of thing, Harrington.” And – what the fuck was that supposed to mean? Because there was no way he was seriously even jokingly suggesting…
Billy sneered. He projected disgust, but there was something that didn’t match just underneath the surface. Even if Steve didn’t use his powers anymore, years of having them had made him pretty damn good at picking up on emotions the old fashioned way. And there was something off about the look Billy gave him. Something hurt and hungry and absolutely terrified. Something familiar. It almost, almost, made Steve want to tear down the mental walls he’d put up around his powers and reach out with them purposefully for the first time since he’d been 14 and he’d decided normal kids didn’t do that.
But then Billy shoved him with a hand against his chest until his back hit the cold metal of the lockers and whatever had been there was gone, Billy taking it with him as he swaggered out of the gym and left Steve behind to rub the ache out of his new bruise. Jesus Christ. Whatever he thought he saw, it must not have been there at all, Steve decided. Because he’d been a dick, he knew what it was like to call kids queer and fag and know that there was something swimming inside you that you’d decided never to acknowledge again, but he’d never been that much of an asshole.
He resolved to stay away from Billy when he could. Not that Billy seemed intent on offering him that option, but it was worth a shot. No need to confuse himself even further with what exactly he was trying to get out of deliberately pissing Steve off.
~~~
His resolution did not last nearly as long as he would have liked. Worse, it was his own damn fault the plan failed. He hadn’t exactly been up for partying the last few days, but he’d hardly seen Nancy at all in the wake of their fight and he couldn’t get thoughts of the lab out of his head no matter what he did, so a few hours he could have spent half-conscious, steadily working his way up to blackout drunk, sounded like an amazing idea for once.
To his credit, he’d been well on his way to accomplishing exactly what he’d set out to do before he’d gotten sidetracked. Said sidetrack happened about an hour into the party when he’d snagged a bottle and gone looking for somewhere he could probably pass out undisturbed, and came in the form of one extremely plastered Billy Hargrove laying on his back, shirtless, alone, and splayed out across Rachel Redman’s parents’ bed.
He should have kept walking. He was sure that when a normal guy saw another dude laying on the bed shirtless they absolutely did not stop to gawk – not that he was gawking, of course. There was probably some other unoccupied room he could have taken refuge in. Hell, he probably should have gone home and just drank until the background noise of the TV started to resemble someone else living in that big, empty house that reminded him far too much of the sterile, echoey walls of the lab.
Whatever he should have done, it was definitely not enter the damn bedroom.
But as luck would have it, Steve was a goddamn idiot, and getting halfway to drunk had loosened the usually tight wall he kept his powers locked behind and they’d started to seep through the weak spots. Even from the hallway he could feel discomfort and self-disgust coming off of Billy in waves. And because he had no self-preservation instinct, apparently, he’d stepped into the room before he’d been aware of his own feet.
It took Billy a few seconds to even notice Steve’s presence. If he hadn’t already known Billy was shitfaced, that would have been enough to tip him off; most days he could have sworn Billy had some sort of homing device when it came to him, despite his best efforts to fly under the radar. This time, however, Billy blinked blurrily at him, face scrunching a little in drunken confusion, before getting an arm under himself so he could at least make an attempt at propping himself up.
“Th’fuck are you lookin’ at, pretty boy?” he slurred, though it lacked its usual punch. “See something you like?” The hand that wasn’t supporting his upper body flung itself out in a way that was probably supposed to indicate himself but ended up gesturing primarily to the bedside lamp.
Even without his freaky powers Steve would have known Billy wasn’t exactly prepared for a fight, so he didn’t bother getting worked up about the dig. “Don’t flatter yourself. Just making sure you didn’t choke to death on your own vomit.”
“Charming,” Billy grunted, resting his hand back behind his head. The new pose left him at an angle commonly seen in things Steve had absolutely no desire to connect Billy Hargrove to in his mind. Really. He very carefully did not find his eyes drawn to the bunching muscles in Billy’s arm that effortlessly supported his weight or the ridiculous six-pack or the faint pattern of mottled bruises scattered across Billy’s lower torso. Wait, what was that last one?
He blinked, but his vision didn’t change. The dark marks stood out in harsh contrast to otherwise smooth tan skin. Something dumb about picking fights was on the tip of his tongue, but he shut his trap when he saw they looked bad, and they looked fresh. Instead, he drew closer thoughtlessly. He reached out to his own wrist, his thumb rubbing light circles over where his number was hidden.
Billy didn’t say anything, but he’d obviously noticed what had drawn Steve’s attention; he’d gone ramrod straight when Steve moved closer, tense and flighty despite the casual nature he was projecting. Something like fear nudged against the cracks in the wall keeping Steve’s powers at bay, which he’d definitely never expected to feel from Billy of all people.
Left with the burden of being the one to break the silence, he aimed for something that wouldn’t lead to him getting decked in the face. “You want some ice for that?” he tried, already wincing a little in preparation for Billy’s response.
To his surprise, Billy only shook his head and mumbled, “Only one kind of medicine I need,” holding out his hand for the bottle Steve had nearly forgotten he was carrying. And yeah, whatever else went on between the two of them during school hours, Steve could understand that sentiment just fine. So he obligingly passed the bottle over, but he sat himself down on the edge of the bed with the clear implication that he was only loaning it, not giving it up entirely. He still hadn’t given up on his plan to find somewhere quiet to black out tonight.
For his part, Billy didn’t protest his continued presence. Instead, he actually swung his legs up and over the side of the bed, sitting the rest of the way up but leaning his side against the headboard so the two of them were facing the same direction. Steve listened rather than watched as he uncapped the bottle, took a sip, and wordlessly handed it back for Steve to do the same.
They stayed like that for a few minutes, or maybe only a few seconds that seemed to drag on forever, mirroring each other’s poses and listening to the muffled thump of music and shouting voices through the wall. Eventually, Steve said, “Those bruises look nasty man.”
He’d hoped he’d built up enough good will to get a real response, but when Billy glanced sideways at him his eyes were narrowed. “Mind your own business,” he snapped, tone laced with venom.
Steve rolled his eyes, not particularly intimidated by a guy who was either unwilling or incapable of sitting up without the use of the headboard for support. “Whatever, Hargrove. Don’t say I didn’t try to be nice.”
Billy huffed derisively, snagging the bottle back out of his hands. “You ever heard of privacy, Harrington?” And wasn’t that ironic. It seemed no matter what Steve did, he’d end up arguing with someone about keeping secrets. Not that he expected Billy to be up front about anything, let alone perceived weaknesses.
But yeah, Steve had his own concerns about privacy. He had shit he’d resolved never to mention to anyone, shit he knew he’d get killed for saying, shit Billy wouldn’t have fucking dreamed of in a million years. Labs and numbers and flower petals that opened to reveal rows of teeth. Boys behind counters serving ice cream and the harsh sound of his dad’s voice around harsher consonants. “Like you’re the only one in this town with a secret.”
Billy outright sneered at him then, his lips curling backwards to reveal a smile that was all teeth. “As if some perfect pretty boy like you has anything to hide.”
“Perfect?” he repeated, electing to ignore the ‘pretty boy’ once again. “Hardly.”
“Right, sorry, of course,” Billy said sarcastically. “’Cause clearly trust fund Steve has so much to bitch about. Cry me a fuckin’ river.”
“You’re a real dick, you know that, Hargrove?” Steve rolled his eyes. “The fuck do you know anyway?”
“What I know,” Billy said, jabbing a finger in Steve’s direction that landed somewhere around the center of his chest, “is that King Steve gets to live the easy life while some of us have real fuckin’ problems.” His eyes darkened a little but his finger didn’t move. The point of contact drew Steve’s focus, but he didn’t miss Billy’s added, likely alcohol-induced, “Some of us spend our whole lives pretending we don’t.”
Steve huffed a dark laugh, lacking any actual enjoyment. “You really think King Steve isn’t just some shitty act? Something I showboat around because it’s better than the alternative? Nance said I was bullshit, and you know what? She was right. Think what you want, Hargrove, but you don’t really know shit about me. If you knew… it’d change the way every person in town looked at me.”
“Oh? Enlighten me, then. What does the great Steve Harrington have to hide?” Billy’s tone had gone taunting, but it was only surface level. He was staring intently now, obviously listening, waiting for Steve’s answer. He had a half-second of wild, stupid thought where he thought if he just said it, just stopped pretending for once in his damn life, that maybe Billy would get it. Maybe, through whatever tenuous bond the shared drunkenness had led them to forge, it wouldn’t have completely blown up in his face.
But it was a stupid thought, barely worth entertaining. He would have had to have been a real Class A idiot to trust Billy Hargrove with anything like that and not expect it to be thrown back in his face. Even if the look Billy was fixing him with made him think that there was something more to this conversation, some second layer that only Billy seemed to know they were talking about that had kept him from decking Steve and storming out a long time ago.
Finally, Steve said, “That’s all Hawkins is. We’re all just hiding shit, whether it’s who’s fucking who, or who had a screaming match in public last week, or what other kid is next in line to just fucking disappear someday. And everyone’s either blissfully unaware or so committed to not acknowledging anything’s wrong that they can’t see what’s right in front of them. Like slapping concealer on a ta- a bruise and acting like just because you can’t see it, it’s not there.” He rubbed again at his wrist, feeling the faint raised bumps of the tattoo that he’d never really escape no matter what he did.
Billy was just staring at him like Steve had answered a question he hadn’t known how to ask. He heaved a sigh, unsure if his sudden exhaustion was a result of the drinks or if it had been a long time coming. “We’re all just fuckin’… pretending to be normal, y’know?” Steve said into the silence that followed his words.
Billy eyed him for a moment longer, but eventually shrugged and nodded, seeming unwilling to push his original question further. Steve thought that might have been the end of it, but after a beat Billy mumbled, “This town fucking sucks, huh Harrington?”
Steve surprised himself with his short laugh. “Hey, I’ll drink to that, man.” Billy obligingly passed the bottle back over after lifting it in a mock-toast, and they sat like that for a while, both of them getting steadily drunker as they lapsed back into occasional comments about shit that didn’t matter.
It was the first time Steve really thought of Billy as a person, someone who had reasons for shit he did and didn’t just exist as some antagonizing force at the peripheral of his life. Someone who had his own bruises and secrets to hide, who was doing his own performance just like Steve was, and someone that, when away from the ever-present observation of the school and removed of the burdens of sobriety, could actually hold a conversation instead of just shoving Steve’s shoulder into the nearest hard surface.
And it was sort of funny, Steve thought, funny in a sad way, that the only way they could share this kind of camaraderie was when they were both three sheets to the wind. It wouldn’t last. He knew that already; when they both went back to school, and they saw each other in the hallway, tonight wouldn’t matter. It would be back to the same shit.
Nevertheless, Steve let himself enjoy it while he could. He didn’t think about tomorrow when he slumped unsteadily and Billy leaned against his side so they were propping each other up. He didn’t think about the likelihood of getting punched the next time he saw Billy when he said something that surprised a laugh out of Billy and Steve felt the little shaking motions of his shoulders. He didn’t think about his fight with Nancy when Billy’s hand rested casually against his thigh.
He did think about what the hell they were doing. Because this wasn’t how this was supposed to go. He and Billy were enemies, or rivals, or even just two assholes in a dick measuring competition. They didn’t hang out, they didn’t get drunk together, and they certainly didn’t do whatever the fuck this was. And yet, Steve couldn’t bring himself to protest it. It felt easy in a way nothing had lately, maybe never had, and he wasn’t going to be the one to shatter the moment.
But like he’d predicted, it wasn’t going to last. Billy’s gaze dropped to his hand, apparently fully registering its position for the first time, and a shadow darkened his face. Steve almost thought to reach out and read whatever emotions he was feeling, but before he could Billy had risen from the bed. He snatched the bottle and what remained of its contents before wordlessly shouldering the door open and presumably heading back into the thick of the party.
Steve blinked curiously at his departure, but it held no answers. Maybe Billy had just realized what he had – that it was only a matter of time before things went right back to how they had been – and decided that sooner was better than later. Whatever his reasons, Steve decided he was far too tired and drunk to try to figure out what the fuck just happened. Maybe it was time he headed home himself, while he still had enough presence of mind to leave Tylenol out for the next morning.
He wasn’t looking forward to what the next day would bring, in more ways than one.
