Chapter Text
Bilbo wakes up that Saturday after Gandalf’s unexpected phone-call determined to spend the entire day in his attic. He has a reasonable idea what it is Gandalf would rather he do. Milstein Hall is part of the School of Art, Architecture, and Planning. The event calendar on their website lists today as the first in a series of hands-on design workshops, two hour sessions every Saturday, now until further notice. Apparently it’s a kind of extended thesis requirement for some of the graduates, giving them practice lecturing and critiquing. In order to give them something to critique, the architecture department opened up the program to the general public. How Gandalf found out about this, Bilbo has no idea. But he’s not really surprised—the old man seems to know everything about everyone, always. No matter where he is or what else he’s involved in.
Bilbo could go. Technically. He knows this. It’s free of cost, all materials provided. He’s awake anyway—can’t sleep—and it’s only two hours out of his day, which leaves plenty of time to get his reading done. It’s a gorgeous late October morning, the rare upstate kind that’s forgotten it’s meant to be channeling winter already, so the sky is deep, bright blue. Not a bad day to walk up to campus. Bilbo’s passed by the studio before. He has seen its wall-to-wall windows and has thought to himself, each time, that it must be a nice place to work.
To work with his hands.
This is what he wanted. Isn’t it?
Bilbo paces his apartment, mug of tea in hand, gesturing vaguely. He draws the line at talking to himself. He has a houseplant—he could talk to that.
Or he could just crawl back into bed, Gandalf’s advice be damned. Except that his not-uncle’s advice is uncannily good, even when he doesn’t want to hear it. Perhaps especially then.
He’s made his mind up before he really admits it to himself. It’s only two hours. One class. He doesn’t have to commit to anything. If it comes down to it, he supposes that he doesn’t even need to stay for the full session. If there are too many people, or if he feels out of place, or—
Carrying on a silent argument with oneself nearly qualifies as talking to oneself. Bilbo gets dressed and pours his now-cold tea down the drain. Changes his sweater. Stares at himself in the bathroom mirror and debates putting in his contact lenses. Changes his sweater again and keeps the glasses. Puts on his gloves and his scarf, because it’s already quarter after seven, and he needs to start walking and stop worrying about his appearance and first-impressions. It’s not as if he’s going to make friends.
Hands-on workshop. Something to distract himself. That’s all he wants.
The building is quiet when he gets there and he stands outside for a minute to catch his breath and loosen the scarf from his throat. He knows his hair is probably a mess, bangs stuck to his forehead with sweat, and he scrubs a hand through it even though it’s a lost cause. The concrete steps are smooth and quiet underfoot as he makes his way up to the studio, passing student projects in various states of completion. For some indiscernible reason, the hall is filled with birds. Geese, mainly, of the Canadian variety, with a pigeon or two thrown in for . . . variety, Bilbo supposes.
He’s so distracted by the geese—halfway up the walls, leaning on the windows, hanging from the ceiling—that he walks straight into the studio. No pausing outside the doorway to compose himself or survey the room. Straight in, to a wide open room, clear and light with the morning sun. There isn’t anyone there. Idly, Bilbo wonders if it’s been cancelled.
He goes over to one of the windows that faces down towards the lake, wondering if the view is as good as he imagined. He’s staring out at blazing trees and the tops of houses when a noise comes from behind. A ragged groan on the other side of the room, behind one of the large tables.
“Don’t tell me someone actually came,” a voice says, deep and not-quite-smooth. Bilbo watches, pressed back against the window, as a man unfolds himself from the floor and pushes upright, palms flat against the table, neck stretching first to one side and then the other, slowly. He can’t quite look away. “Or are you just lost?” the man asks.
“Sorry?”
“What are you doing here?”
“I thought—that is, I’d heard there was some kind of . . . workshop. Or something.”
“There is.”
“Oh. Right. And, er, is that here?”
“It is.”
“Right. Thank you.” Bilbo clears his throat and looks to the door. Surely other students will arrive soon, or the instructor. The man crosses the room to lean against the desk next to Bilbo and looks at him. He smells faintly of alcohol. His hair is long and tangled, a dark mess tied in a knot at the back of his head, and his shirt is wrinkled, but his eyes are bright and his hands are steady as he crosses his arms over his chest.
“Are you really going to do this?” he asks.
“I’m not sure I know what you mean,” Bilbo says.
“The workshop. You’re actually interested?”
“Yes?”
The man lets out a short laugh. His face doesn’t look amused, and Bilbo bites his lip, glancing once again at the door. “You can stop looking over there,” the man says. “No one ever comes to these things. Waste of fucking time.”
“You’re here,” Bilbo ventures.
“You see my problem, then.”
“Sorry, no.”
“Thorin,” the man says, offering Bilbo a hand with some show of reluctance. Bilbo takes it, his fingers narrow and cold in Thorin’s grip. “M.Arch.1, final year. Here because I have to be. And you’re here, God knows why, so I suppose that makes you my student. At least my profs will be pleased. They can tick their little boxes. Come on. Let’s get this over with.”
Thorin walks back to the table at the front of the room and starts sorting through papers. Bilbo gives the door one last look before turning his back and taking a seat at one of the drafting tables. He folds his hands in his lap. He waits. Thorin is still rifling through papers, his back to Bilbo.
“So,” Bilbo ventures, “what exactly do you teach? Here, I mean.”
“Depends.”
“I see.” Bilbo takes off his glasses and cleans them on the sleeve of his sweater. “Depends on what?”
“Why are you here?” Thorin asks, his voice suddenly close.
“What?” Bilbo looks up quickly and shoves his glasses back on. Thorin is standing right in front of him. “Just . . . looking for something to do.”
“On a Saturday morning? Nothing better to do? What are you, a first-year?”
“Yes? But, er, in the doctoral program. Not . . . not undergrad.”
“Small mercies. What department?”
“English. Literature.”
“Hmm. Should’ve guessed.”
“Sorry?”
Thorin waves a hand at Bilbo. “You look the part.”
“Thank you?”
“Sure, take it as a compliment.” Thorin drags a hand through his hair and looks annoyed, whether with its tangles or the situation Bilbo can’t tell. “You interested in defecting, then? Becoming an architect?”
“No, not really. I just . . . like space.”
“Hmm.”
“I mean,” Bilbo says, flustered now, and wishing Thorin would stop staring at him, or standing so close. “I like how space functions in novels. How characters’ actions are determined by the spaces they inhabit. How, say, the late 19th century Modernist interior would affect someone’s mental state, their interiority, that kind of thing. Or how certain characters are attuned to their surroundings, geographically, and how the author presents that, whether there are maps in the text, or how their surroundings are described. Or. You know.”
“Space.”
“Yes.”
Thorin continues to stare at Bilbo. The clock ticks several minutes by. No one else walks into the studio. After Bilbo drops his gaze to his lap and shifts his feet on the rungs of the high stool, Thorin heaves a sigh. “All right, space cadet. You ever done anything with a scale rule?”
Thorin spends the better part of an hour explaining the various tools and instruments Bilbo can expect to use in the workshop—if, that is, he sticks around. It’s fairly straightforward and Thorin sounds bored out of his mind, and when he starts going into the different kinds of paper Bilbo has to stop him.
“Can’t we just . . . make something?”
“You want to make something?”
“I mean, is it really necessary for me to learn this?”
“My profs think so. That, and you’re taking enough notes to make me think it is.”
“Oh, no, that’s not—I just need something to do with my hands,” Bilbo confesses. “That’s really why I’m here.”
“Restless, huh?”
“A bit, yes.”
“You won’t get very far making a scale model without doing your drawings first.” Thorin rubs his face, scratching at what looks like a week’s worth of unshaved chin. “Guess we can do some kind of mock-up. Just to demonstrate. It’ll look terrible.”
“I don’t mind.”
“It’ll only be paper. I’m not wasting good supplies on this.”
“That’s fine.”
“All right, get over here. I don’t trust you with a blade. Probably bleed all over the table.”
“I wouldn’t,” Bilbo says, but he slides down from his stool and joins Thorin at the table anyway as the architecture grad starts cutting and folding paper. Thorin points things out here and there, asks Bilbo to hand him things, curses at the tape sticking to his fingers. Bilbo fights a completely unfounded urge to smile.
“There,” Thorin says, after a while, and sets the model down in front of Bilbo.
Bilbo blinks at it. “It’s just a square.”
“Basically.”
“Is it . . . meant to be like that?”
“It’s Olin,” Thorin says, which means, yes. It is meant to be a square. The library is a Cold War relic, all narrow windows and sub-sub-basements that doubled as bomb shelters back in the day.
Bilbo lets go of his smile and when Thorin claps a hand on his shoulder he’s so startled he thinks he’ll fall over.
“Was wondering if you could do that,” Thorin says. “We’re out of time. I’ve got actual work to do.”
“Of course,” Bilbo says, and tries another smile. “I’ll let you get back to it.” Thorin shoves the crude paper model at him.
“Take it. It’s not just a square, you know. And if you wanted to come back next week, we could—I have to be here anyway, so you might as well show up.”
“I will,” Bilbo says, and thinks that he’s probably telling the truth. “Er, thanks. For the workshop. Sorry to take up your time.”
“I’d just have been sleeping if you hadn’t come.”
“Well, you should probably . . . sleep anyway. You, uh, look like you could use it.”
“Hah. Sure. I could use a lot of things.” Thorin rubs glue off of one thumb and stares at some point over Bilbo’s right shoulder. “Get out of here,” he says. “Don’t spend all weekend with your books. You look pale.”
“I’m always pale,” Bilbo says, and feels his cheeks flush without knowing why. “Nevermind. Just—have a nice weekend.”
“We’ll see,” Thorin says, which isn’t really the conversationally expected response, so Bilbo just nods and turns to leave. “Wait, hang on,” Thorin calls after him. “You never actually told me your name. Unless you just want to be space cadet . . .”
“It’s Bilbo,” he says, already at the door, not turning around.
“So that’s a no to space cadet?”
Bilbo leaves before he can answer, mostly because he doesn’t know what he would say, and that doesn’t tend to end well. Thorin’s laughter follows him as he goes, through the hall, down the stairs, out of the building. When Bilbo walks down the hill back to his apartment, he doesn’t turn around. Doesn’t want to know if Thorin is watching him go, from those wide studio windows.
---
Sometimes it’s one in the morning and Bilbo finds himself sitting at his desk, cross-legged in a high-backed office chair he salvaged from the department’s recent remodeling efforts, wrapped in a sweater that’s always been somewhat itchy, feet cold despite two pairs of socks and the fact that it’s now well into April and officially spring, his books and papers spread out before him, the light of his computer screen a cold glow, and for no reason at all, he’ll feel like crying.
It doesn’t make sense.
He’ll get up and make a cup of tea, or put a record on, something dusty-sounding, with lots of harmonica. He’ll check to make sure he’s closed the curtains on the awning windows so no one can see in. He’ll press the palms of his hands against his eyes and push, push, but he’s not sure what he’s trying to push out, or what he’s trying to keep in. Everything. Nothing. He can’t even answer his own questions. Questions of what he’s doing here, of why he can’t focus. He’ll stand in the shower, so hot that it burns, until he feels guilty about wasting water.
He’ll sit back at his desk, cold, tense, until he’s so tired he can fall into bed and know he won’t remember his dreams. Know he’ll wake in the morning feeling awful, with a bad taste in his mouth and none of his reading done.
He’s fine.
He’s just a little worn out.
He had dinner with Thorin last weekend and it had been good. More than good. He was expecting company, one or two of Thorin’s strange and—frankly—intimidating group of friends, but there was no one. Just Thorin and himself, with Thorin’s dog nosing up against Bilbo’s leg and banana muffins heartily mocked and summarily eaten, the stereo playing yet another band Thorin was determined Bilbo should know. The biggest surprise was that Thorin actually cooked. Really, properly cooked. He was living in a garage-turned-apartment on the back of a History professor’s property, and said professor had a grill. Apparently grilling steak was one of the few culinary skills Thorin would admit to having, though Bilbo suspected there were more.
They stood on the back deck—and since when did garages have back decks, Bilbo wondered—while Thorin grilled, talking through the smoke and watching Erebor run around the yard. “You keep staring and I’ll start to think you’re only here for that dog,” Thorin said.
“I’ll keep staring, then,” Bilbo replied, looking pointedly out at the flat-coated retriever.
“I’ll eat your steak.”
“You wouldn’t dare.”
“I would.”
Bilbo sighed and gave Thorin a long-suffering look which lasted all of three seconds before he ducked his head, quickly embarrassed. Bantering, again. Where did it come from? How did people manage it?
“If you do, I’ll keep the muffins for myself.”
“All of them? Bilbo, you’ll get fat.”
“I will not.”
“Hide it under all those sweaters.”
“Shut up, you,” Bilbo told Thorin, who was shaking with barely-concealed laughter. He made a move as if to hit Thorin on the shoulder but pulled the motion and turned instead, stepping off the deck and into the yard. “Here, Ere,” he called, and the dog came bounding up, his head nearly level with Bilbo’s hips, seventy-five pounds of enthusiasm. “Good dog.”
“No steak for him, either,” Thorin called off the deck. Bilbo pretended not to hear. “Swear it’s like you’ve teamed up against me.” Thorin muttered as he finished cooking their dinner and Ere tackled Bilbo into the grass and made him sneeze, and the spring sun hung low in the sky, washing everything in golden light. They ate inside, across from each other at Thorin’s Formica table, and if Bilbo sat a little stiffly on the threadbare couch after dinner when the sun had set and Ere was a sleepy hump on the cushion next to him and Thorin was offering him a beer, then the situation itself had nothing to do with it.
It was just him.
“What’s wrong with you?” Thorin asked.
So perhaps it wasn't just him, or at the very least, it was enough of him that other people could see it too. “Nothing,” Bilbo said. “I’m fine.”
Thorin knocked the beer bottle against Bilbo’s knee. Bilbo took it automatically and then stared at it, cold in his hands, without drinking. “More fine or less fine?” Thorin asked.
“More,” Bilbo said, which couldn’t be called lying, because Thorin never specified a basis for comparison.
“More than last term?”
“Of course. You—you should know that.”
“I’d hoped.” Thorin took a drink, contemplated the scene on his couch briefly, and then slipped a knee under Ere, scooping a too-large dog easily into his lap so he could sit down. “I would like to think that . . .” Thorin rubbed his dog’s ears, looking anywhere but at Bilbo. “I would like to think that we’re friends,” he said, voice gruffer than usual.
“Aren’t we?” Bilbo asked. “We are, aren’t we?”
“Then why do you never tell me what’s bothering you? It’s always me, pulling . . . I’m not good at this. Talking. Getting other people to talk. God knows I’m terrible at picking up hints. But I can listen to you, if you would just start the conversation, so . . . work with me here.”
“Thorin, it’s not—it isn’t as though I don’t appreciate what you’re trying to do.”
“Keyword: trying.”
“I don’t know what to tell you.”
“I’m worried about you,” Thorin said, the words coming out in a rush, as if he didn’t mean to speak them. “I mean—”
“Did you ask me to dinner just to psychoanalyse me?” Bilbo asked. He took a gulp of beer and grimaced at the taste. Stout. Of course Thorin would drink stout.
“No, just for your dessert,” Thorin retorted. “And stop making that face, that’s good beer.”
“You can keep it for yourself, then. Some company for your Friday nights.”
“And what’s that supposed to mean?”
“Just that I wish you would stop showing up hungover every Saturday, as if it isn’t anything, as if it’s just normal and there’s you and there’s me and every time I see you, practically, you’re—” Bilbo broke off to wave his hands around. Ere made a noise of protest at the couch shifting.
“We’re not having this conversation,” Thorin said, his voice even and pitched low. “I’m trying to help you.”
“Maybe you’re the one who needs help.”
“I’m not the one who—damn it, would you stop this?”
“What?”
“This, all this, always turning the conversation onto other people. I told you, I don’t know how to do this. I asked you to dinner tonight so I could just listen to you.”
“Conversation is a two-way street, Thorin. And that’s just if we’re being trite. If you really wanted to hear—”
“I do.”
“If you really wanted to hear,” Bilbo repeated, dislodging himself from Ere’s sprawled limbs and standing up, “you’d have figured it out already. I’ve told you. I’ve been telling you, all along. You just haven’t been listening.” He stuffed his hands in his pockets and squared his shoulders. “Forget it. I’ll see myself out.”
