Chapter Text
October ends on a Wednesday and Bilbo is in the typical mid-week crisis that affects every grad student. He doesn’t have classes on Wednesdays and should be doing his laundry or washing his floor or something productive but instead has been sitting in bed since he awoke at seven, huddled in his blankets, emerging only for a fresh cup of tea. He tells himself that he’s reading but honestly he’s staring at the walls. Jacob’s Room sits neglected in his lap and he’s thinking of a time when he was just a kid, when his parents packed him into the car and drove an hour east to the bay. They had a picnic lunch. He fell asleep on the blanket and woke up with sand in his hair.
It’s one of the better memories he’s had as of late.
He manages to get out of bed around four in the afternoon, by which time it’s nearly dark. He makes himself toast, more out of a sense of obligation, trying to remember the taste of apricot jam. Two-hundred and fifty-four pages of reading left for the week, and then it will be the weekend. It will be Saturday, and it will be November, and though Bilbo said he would come back, he’s not sure he will. He could just tell Gandalf he went, but then, lying to the old man has never worked out before. Gandalf always, somehow, knows. Always has. Bilbo paces his floor—still unwashed—Friday night, alone in his attic, and frets about the next morning.
The “alone in his attic” bit is starting to worry him. At least there is no wallpaper, yellow or otherwise, and he’s not a woman. Still, the whole situation is verging uncomfortably into the territory of literary trope.
Bilbo goes back to the studio on Saturday. It’s snowing lightly as he makes the trek from his apartment up to Milstein, the oaks still hanging on to crippled leaves, the streets wet and grey. He’s wearing a knit hat that will make his hair into an absolute wreck when he takes it off, and an oversized Fair Isle sweater that used to be—embarrassingly, but it’s not as if anyone can tell—his mother’s. It’s armour emotionally as much as it is protection against the cold, and he feels about twelve years old again for even thinking it, but there it is.
Thorin isn’t asleep this time but bent over a drafting table, all broad shoulders in worn flannel, his back to the door. Bilbo wonders if he should cough or something, announce his presence, but Thorin turns around before he can decide. So he takes off his hat instead and says, “I hope it’s all right. That I came back, I mean.”
Thorin is laughing too hard to answer. Actually laughing, full-bodied, his head tilted back, one hand on his knee. Bilbo frowns at him until he settles down enough to ask, “What happened to you?”
“. . . What do you mean?”
“You look like hell.”
“If you’re referring to the state of my hair,” Bilbo says, patting uselessly at it with a hand and earning another laugh from Thorin, “you hardly have a place to talk. Do you even know what a comb is?”
“I do.”
“And when was the last time you used one?” Bilbo gives up on his hair as a lost cause and takes off his coat instead.
“This morning.”
“I doubt that. And I didn’t come to talk personal appearance with you, anyway.”
“Good,” Thorin says, though he still looks far too smug. “Let’s talk groundplans. Get over here.”
Bilbo hangs his coat off the back of a chair and goes to Thorin’s side. The drafting table is covered with a sheet of tracing paper overlaid on a template of a building that is, roughly, a square. Standing so close, Bilbo can see that the knuckles of Thorin’s right hand are split and there is a bruise on his chin, dark under his beard. His boots are unlaced and for some reason that bothers Bilbo almost more than the other things do. Before he can speak, though, Thorin is handing him a triangle and a scale-rule and saying, “Since you like Olin so much, we’ll start there.”
“I don’t like Olin,” Bilbo protests, “and I certainly don’t like it enough to draw seven floors of it, if that’s what you’re getting at.”
“Only the first floor.” Thorin slides off his stool and gestures to it. “Sit. Makes no sense for me to just teach you this abstractly. You might as well do it.”
“I’m not going to be a library designer.”
“Neither am I. It’s an exercise. Stop complaining.”
“What do you want to design?” Bilbo asks, hoisting himself up onto the stool.
“Scale-rule practice first. Tell me these dimensions.” Thorin runs his finger along several of the lines on the groundplan. “And I’m more interested in restoration.”
“All right, what do you want to restore, then?”
“Castles. Churches. Old stone houses. I like the geometry of them. You’re doing it wrong.”
“Am I?”
“Eighth-inch scale. Check your key.”
Sure enough, the key on the bottom right of the drawing confirms it. 1/8” = 1’0”. Bilbo flips the scale-rule and re-measures. “Not very many castles around here,” he says, drawing a neat tick-mark on the paper at twenty-five feet.
“No.”
“So you want to work in Europe?”
“No. This wall next.”
“If not Europe, then where?”
“I didn’t say I wouldn’t work in Europe.”
“You did, though—or, no, just that you don’t want to. So you would work there?”
“If someone hired me, I would work.”
“So—”
“Now that you have the walls, you need windows. And doors.” Thorin tugs a piece of paper off the neighbouring desk, instructions on how to properly indicate windows and doors in groundplans. Penciled in block capitals below are notes about Olin Library and its entrances and exits.
“Did you write this up?” Bilbo asks. “Is that why you were in Olin the other day?”
“You saw me?”
“Well, I—that is . . . I thought I did.”
“Sure you weren’t hallucinating?” Thorin asks, and it sounds as if he’s joking but Bilbo flinches all the same.
“I’m not the one who’s hung-over,” he mutters, pulling the paper out of Thorin’s hand. He bites his tongue and starts marking out the front doors, already certain that this is going to be incredibly tedious. Marking the windows, when Olin has practically an entire wall of them on the first floor.
“What did you say?”
“Nothing.”
“Thought we agreed not to talk personal appearance. Or should I start in on your sweater?”
“There is nothing wrong with my sweater.”
“You could fit another person in there.”
“At least it’s clean,” Bilbo says. He can feel the back of his neck itching and it’s not from the sweater, whose wool has always been soft. He doesn’t dare to look up from the tracing paper. There is a tight, long silence. Then Thorin, his voice rough, says, “Fuck off” and walks away, jostling the table as he goes and making Bilbo’s line crooked.
They don’t talk after that.
Bilbo painstakingly marks out each window, each door, cross-hatching the solid sections. It takes the better part of an hour because he is a perfectionist and the pencil keep smudging and his hands are shaking even though he glares at them in an attempt to get them to stop. He can hear Thorin moving around, is certain that the man is going to shout at him any second, but can’t bring himself to look up and find out. This was a mistake, coming here. Thinking he could do something with his hands, with other people, and do it without feeling as though he’s going to be ill from a combination of anxiety and, startlingly, anger that turns his stomach.
Bilbo pushes the stool back from the desk, knocking his pencil and scale-rule to the floor. He’s halfway into his coat when the music starts. It’s so far from what he was expecting that it stops him in his tracks.
It’s just a drumbeat, low and then a scattering of high, light hits, and a slow three-note bass pattern. Something that sounds like a muted xylophone mixes with a cello and everything weaves together. Bilbo doesn’t turn around to look but he can hear that Thorin has stopped moving. Is, presumably, sitting somewhere, or leaning against the wall. Listening. Waiting.
Waiting to see what Bilbo does? Or just waiting?
Now I’m waking at the crack of dawn
to send a little money home
from here to the moon.
It’s rising like a discothèque,
and now my bags are down and packed
for traveling.
The man’s voice is liquid-smooth, clear over the instrumental texture. There’s a lot going on in the song but somehow it’s soothing, not agitating. Bilbo drops his shoulders, shrugs out of the coat sleeves, still staring at the back wall and the door. He can see a speaker in the far corner, paired with one in the front of the room. He gets the sense that this is, probably, something Thorin does often. Comes up here and plays music loudly. Disrupts the other students. Perhaps that’s why the studio is empty when he comes—Thorin has already annoyed everyone else away.
Bilbo waits out the song, trying to follow each instrument as they blend in and out, trying to slow his own breathing. Already he feels less like throwing up, which is something of a small miracle in itself, but he still cannot turn around. When the song slows and fades out, instrument by instrument, Bilbo leaves.
Thorin doesn’t say a word.
Sunday passes quietly, Bilbo in his attic, shuffling around with a blanket over his shoulders and fingerless gloves on his hands, the air colder than early November has any right to make it. Yesterday’s snow didn’t last but the world outside is damp and Bilbo doesn’t want to face it. Come Monday, he has to, with his first-year colloquium to attend. The class is about as interesting as expected, something on early modern poetry that Bilbo tries to follow. He ends up marking lines on his notebook instead, stopping himself when he realises he’s drawn a window in groundplan view. The student next to him is playing solitaire on her phone and Bilbo watches over his shoulder, discreetly, for the remainder of the lecture. She’s not very good.
On Thursday Bilbo makes himself go back to Olin. He hasn’t been avoiding it, not deliberately. Just accidentally. There’s no sign of Thorin, or anyone who might be Thorin, and he climbs the stairs slowly up to the seventh floor and sits—hides—in his carrel. He reads for a bit but Women in Love is tedious and he’s not in the mood. Lawrence has never been his favourite. The seventh floor is quiet, the lights dim in the stacks. It’s pleasant enough to stare out the window for a while, looking at the campus outside and not the window itself. When the snow starts up again and the sky darkens, Bilbo packs his books into his schoolbag and thinks about going back to his apartment. He won’t get any work done tonight, he knows, but he might as well try.
Before he leaves, reluctantly, he checks his e-mail. There might be word from a professor, a new assignment or a cancelled class. There isn’t. There is, though, an e-mail from an address he doesn’t recognise, the initials T.O. and a string of numbers. He panics and signs out of his account. Takes several deep breaths. Then, very deliberately, logs in again and opens the message.
Bilbo—
Wondering if you’re going to come back on Saturday. I’ll do my best not to mock your sweater. Or your hair. Your groundplan was good. Precise. It’s not done yet. Shame to leave it unfinished.
I looked you up, by the way. In the student directory. Not hard, with a first name like yours. Figured it was fair use of my “instructor” status, to check in on you.
What if I play more music for you? Will you come back then?
—T.
It’s awkward and stilted and doesn’t say half of what it should. Bilbo definitely doesn’t print it out and hang it on the wall next to his desk. Doesn’t glance at it from time to time, as if to remind himself that it’s (not) real. Doesn’t wake up early Saturday morning and lace up his boots and walk up the hill, where Thorin won’t be waiting.
---
It’s been almost a week since what Bilbo is privately referring to as “the disastrous dinner of April the seventh.” If he was the sort to keep a journal, that date would either have pages upon pages written about it or be struck out entirely—he can’t quite decide. Since he doesn’t keep a journal, it’s a moot point. He made it halfway down Thorin’s long driveway that night before Thorin was calling after him, offering to drive him home, telling him to wait. Bilbo didn’t wait. Not because he wanted to leave, but because he thought, foolishly, that if he just kept walking, Thorin, with his longer legs and his heavy boots and his rusted car, would come after him.
Thorin didn’t.
Of course he didn’t.
They’ve spent the week avoiding each other, which isn’t very hard, as their classes don’t overlap and they use different libraries and Bilbo’s something of a hermit even in the best of times. He has a cell-phone now, has had one since Christmastime, and Thorin’s is one of the few numbers in it—Thorin drove him to the store to purchase it, and intimidated the technician trying to sell Bilbo a higher-priced model—but the architecture grad doesn’t call. Bilbo is a little grateful and a little annoyed, but mostly just disappointed. He throws himself into his work. He writes a lousy paper on Defoe’s mapping of early eighteenth-century London’s narrow alleyways qua escape routes for thieves in Moll Flanders for a course he has come to resent, a course that has left him firmly determined to stop trying to venture out of his field. He prepares and delivers, badly, a presentation on time and narrative and the paradox of the “as-yet untold” story in Ricouer. He gets rejected from a collaborative conference on the nineteenth century and refuses to admit that he’s upset over it. It would have meant presenting a paper in front of some indeterminate number of people, anyway, so perhaps it’s for the best. He goes for a walk and flinches when he sees a man with a dog but no, it’s not Thorin, not Erebor, and if he goes back to his attic and draws the curtains and knocks his head against the wall, no one has to know.
It’s been that sort of week and yet, here he is, Friday night, over at Thorin’s and at a loss for words. He didn’t mean for it to happen, but then, that’s usually how these things work. On Thursday Thorin came up to Bilbo’s carrel in Olin, tucked away on the seventh floor, a scowl on his face that he was quick to blame on the building—“Fucking depressing aesthetic,” he said, as if the Fine Arts Library was any great improvement—and hovered over Bilbo and asked surprisingly astute questions about his research until Bilbo gave him a look that very clearly said, “I’m so busy I can’t even think straight, so if you have a purpose for bothering me, please state it and be done.” And Thorin invited him to dinner again, and said he’d pick Bilbo up at seven, and left before he got a proper reply.
Bilbo dropped his head onto his desk and spent the rest of the evening entirely unable to focus on work, awake all hours of the morning and hating himself for it, and Friday came even though he wished it away.
So Bilbo sits on Thorin’s couch, sleepy and full in a way he hasn’t been since last week, waiting for things to go wrong. And things don’t go wrong. They’ve spent the week pretending and equally, separately, absorbed. The dinner was good—pasta with some kind of mushroom sauce, and Thorin didn’t even ask Bilbo to bring anything, and he cooked vegetables, not just meat with some vegetables but only vegetables, and that should be the first hint that something is wrong—and now Ere is asleep on his bed in the corner and the two of them are on the couch with the television glowing and rain trickling down the windows. It’s so domestic it hurts.
Bilbo has to break it.
“What are we even doing?” he asks.
“What?”
“You, me. Here.”
“What are you talking about?”
“I don’t know,” Bilbo says, and gives a small laugh. “And that’s precisely the point.”
Thorin shifts on the couch, dragging his arm slowly out from behind his head to drop both his hands in his lap. He turns and looks at Bilbo. Bilbo notices, somewhere in the back of his mind, that there are lines under Thorin’s eyes. He smells of Old Spice and the early spring rain. His shirt is wrinkled and a little too tight.
“Thought you didn’t want to talk about it,” he says.
“I don’t.”
“What’s the problem, then?”
“God, Thorin, we can’t just carry on not talking about it. Do you even realise how ridiculous that sounds? What are we supposed to do, just keep on pretending for, what, another month and a half, and then you’ll graduate and you’ll leave and I’ll just be—no, that doesn’t work. Not for me.”
“Talk, then.”
“I can’t.”
“You mean won’t.”
“No, I mean—every time I try to say what I want to say, I can’t find the words.”
“Thought that was your job. English, and all.”
“Shut up, that’s not it.” Bilbo looks down at his feet, hoping that if he continues to say nothing, Thorin will step in. Take the lead.
“I wanted to talk to you a week ago. You ran out of here, didn’t say a word, and then next thing I know it’s as if nothing happened. You agreed to dinner. Now you say we can’t do this, whatever this is, anymore. I’m trying to understand, here, Bilbo, I am. Give me some credit. But I’m not a fucking mind-reader.”
“No one’s asking you to be,” Bilbo says, with perhaps a little more bite than the situation warrants, when they’re both so pleasantly full from their dinners. There is a hole in his right sock. He can see it, glaringly obvious, when he wriggles his toes. He’s had dinner but no dessert and no after-dinner drinks with his not-friend and they’ve made it through one-and-a-half Star Wars films and he’s had a hole in his sock the entire time. It is, he thinks, the sort of thing he should have noticed.
“Would be a damn sight easier if I was.”
“I don’t know what to call you,” Bilbo says finally, tearing his eyes away from his sock.
“What?” Thorin asks, after a moment of tense staring. “I don’t understand.”
“Of course you don’t.”
“No, hey, come on. You can’t just duck out of conversations every time I can’t follow. Use your words. What do you mean?”
“It’s what I was saying. What are we doing here? What are we?”
“Students?” Thorin ventures. “Young professionals? Failures-in-waiting?”
“You’re not a failure.”
“Hardly a professional.”
“No, look, that’s not it. I don’t mean life or—or academics, or what-have-you. I mean us.”
“Us.”
“I mean,” Bilbo says, and his face feels very hot, “you know. Us. As in, you, me, together.” He glances up at Thorin from the side, biting his lip, ready to flinch away. It takes a moment for Thorin to process what Bilbo’s just said. When he does, he blinks several times, steadily, and the corners of his mouth turn down.
“You don’t know what to call me,” he says. “Besides my name.”
“Right.” Bilbo swallows, unable to look away. “I mean, I know your name.”
“I’d hope so.”
“It’s just that . . . it’s been a while. And I haven’t . . . I know I’m not exactly . . . oh, hell.”
“I’m not your boyfriend, if that’s what you’re hinting at.”
“No. No. I mean, yes, in a way, that’s what I—but . . . no.”
“It’s a stupid word.” Thorin looks at Bilbo, his eyes hard. He huffs out a breath and stands abruptly, walking over to the refrigerator. He opens it, stares inside for a long minute, and then comes back to the couch empty-handed, which is something. “I don’t know what I am. Or what you are.” He’s standing there, hands tense at his sides like he doesn’t know what to do with them.
Bilbo thinks that he may have stopped breathing. His heart is beating so strongly it hurts. He wonders how quickly he can make it to the door, retrace his steps from last week. The walk home will be long and wet but at this point it’s starting to look enticing.
“I do know what we are, though,” Thorin says, dragging the words out, as if it’s a challenge to even speak them. Bilbo has to mentally re-wind, bring himself back in through the door, out of the rain and onto the couch to make sure he’s heard correctly.
“What’s that?” he asks, completely and utterly confused.
“We are going to make this work.”
It is, possibly, one of the strangest things Thorin has ever said to him. And Thorin has been known to say some very strange things. Bilbo tilts his head, as though if he could only get the right angle, the right perspective on this situation, it would make sense. He tilts so far he nearly falls over and then Thorin’s hands are steadying and warm on his shoulders, and everything is even more confused.
“I—I can’t believe I just said that.” Thorin gives a low, hesitant noise, somewhere deep in his throat. “Fuck. I feel ridiculous.” He doesn’t lift his hands.
“You sound ridiculous,” Bilbo points out.
“Thank you for that.”
And then they’re both laughing, and Bilbo brings his hands up to rest on Thorin’s wrists. “You do realise what this means,” he says, suddenly serious.
“No. What?”
“We’ll have to talk. I mean, actually talk. About things.”
“Oh, God,” Thorin says. “I take it back.”
“You do?” The thought is terrifying. Bilbo’s certain he’s gripping too tight, but Thorin’s wrists are solid; unlike his own, they don’t feel as though they would break under pressure. He has to keep holding on.
“What? No, no, you idiot. I . . . meant what I said.” Thorin half-shrugs, taking his hands back. He shoves them in his pockets and rocks back on his heels, looking down at Bilbo. “Damn dog likes you too much, anyway. You couldn’t leave if you tried.”
Bilbo smiles, because even if he very much he doubts the rest of it, that much, at least, he knows to be true.
