Actions

Work Header

How the West Was Won and Where It Got Us

Chapter 15

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

He needs to return to his roots. When he was younger, and working on a project with his father, the man would always tell him, “Bilbo, my boy, if ever you don’t know where you stand, just retrace your steps.” It worked when he was five and got lost in the park. It worked when he was eleven and misplaced his favourite book of stories. It worked that night in February when he was twenty-two and getting hit on for the first time in his life—he’d honestly thought the man was just offering him a couch to sleep on for the night, a shorter walk home in the dark. Once he realised, he’d turned and walked right out of the bar, and back the long twelve blocks to his university apartment, kept on walking until he was in his bed with the quilts over his head. It worked, too, when his parents had died. That is, it had mostly worked. Bag End had been waiting for him, however briefly, to come back and walk its halls once again.

            Ever since then, though, Bilbo hasn’t been able to figure out exactly how far back he needs to retrace his steps. He feels as if he’s been going backwards forever, only nothing he passes looks familiar, and he hasn’t reached his roots yet. How long are you meant to rewind your life before you can figure out where you made a wrong turn?

            His roots are not here, in this upstate city, amongst all these people he does not know. Now, even more than ever, he does not feel that he belongs.

            Thorin’s gone. Has been gone a day, two, possibly more. Bilbo can’t be sure. He didn’t say goodbye—“He promised,” Bilbo keeps telling himself, “He promised,” until his throat is dry—and the note he left behind isn’t dated. Bilbo found it yesterday morning, when he finally checked his mail. No one ever sends him anything by post. Most days he doesn’t even spare the mailbox a passing glance as he enters his house. Why Thorin should choose to leave a note there, of all places, is entirely inexplicable.

            Well. No, it isn’t.

            He didn’t want to say goodbye. He wanted a head-start on leaving. He is a complete and total arsehole.

            Bilbo’s tempted to go with the last one, currently. If he gives himself over to anger, maybe he can get his heart to stop breaking.

            He’d been leaving Thorin increasingly incoherent—pathetic, his mind supplies—text messages and voicemails. “Where are you?” “Call me.” “Have you really gone?” “Thorin?” “Hello?” “Thorin, for God’s sake, will you just— Will you just pick up the phone? Please, I really need to hear your voice right now. I just need to hear you. I don’t understand. How— Why didn’t you tell me you were going? You said you would say goodbye!” “I know you pretend to be a terrible person but honestly, Thorin, what are you doing? Why won’t you answer? Why won’t you just fucking talk to me, God, I hate you for leaving, do you know that? Hate. I told you that someday you’d know it. You promised me, not just about saying goodbye. You promised me no one would ever leave me again and you’ve—you’ve just—”

            All right, so anger isn’t really working. Bilbo has never been able to get properly angry. Can’t muster up the requisite fire inside. Thorin always did it spectacularly, terrifyingly well, and Bilbo figured one person out of two was quite enough.

            He needs to stop thinking of them as a pair. They’re not. That’s been made very clear. Maybe they could have been, once. Or maybe they never were.

            Bilbo is starting to wonder if he hasn’t made this whole thing up. He was lonely, desperately so, and he needed company of the sort that would step in and take over and take up space. Enter Thorin Oakenshield, always somehow too large for any room you put him in. Competent and brash and frighteningly good-looking when the scowl dropped from his face. Self-sufficient and intimidatingly adept at getting his own way. Bitter and uncompromising, barely held together by alcohol and unflinching determination and self-loathing. Let’s be honest: They never had anything in common, really, apart from how much they each couldn’t stand themselves.

            They rarely went anywhere in public. They never spoke to other people when they were together. If not for the fact that Gandalf and Azog—Gandalf, who is more than a little insane, it must be said, and Azog, who has simply disappeared, and any inquiries made to Gandalf are met with a troubling, if satisfied, smile— both knew the man, Bilbo would be entertaining some serious doubts. Even as it is, he is doubting.

            I dreamed that you bewitched me into bed

            And sung me moon-struck, kissed me quite insane.

            (I think I made you up inside my head.)

            [. . .]

            I fancied you’d return the way you said,

            But I grow old and I forget your name.

            (I think I made you up inside my head.)

            It has been years since he read any Plath, but the poem comes to him now, first the refrain, unbidden, and then the verses. In a moment of weakness, Bilbo caves and calls Gandalf. Even if it’s crazy, he just needs to hear.

            “Did you know that the liriodendron—” Gandalf starts off, as soon as he picks up, but Bilbo cuts in.

            “Was any of it real?” he blurts out, and brings a hand to his mouth, clenches it into a fist.

            “Oh, Bilbo,” Gandalf says, slowly. They have had this conversation already. Four times since yesterday, in fact. “My dear boy.”

            “How could he just— I don’t understand. I know, I know you keep telling me, but . . .”

            “You’re not insane,” Gandalf says, as if that’s what they should be worrying about now, not the fact that Thorin is gone, gone, completely and shatteringly absent. He left Bilbo the keys to his garage, and one brief note, the handwriting in architect’s capitals, angular and impersonal. The paper—still clutched in Bilbo’s hand; he has hardly let it go—doesn’t smell like him anymore.

            “You knew him, Gandalf. You told me you knew his secrets. Please just tell me, what’s going on?”

            “I think it is safe to say that you now know precisely as much as I do about Thorin Oakenshield, and possibly a good deal more.”

            “That can’t be true. I feel like I don’t know anything.” Bilbo sinks to the floor, right in the middle of his apartment. His toes are cold. He hasn’t showered since the night before last and the hem of his sweater is unraveling a little more each day. “Have you heard anything? At all?”

            “Bilbo, it has been exactly nine hours and fourteen minutes since you last asked me that, and the answer is the same now as it was then: No.”

            Bilbo bites down on a knuckle and forces himself to breathe in through his nose. “All right,” he says, nodding to himself. “All right.” Chin up, he tells himself. Stop it, just stop—stop falling to pieces.

            “My project wraps in two days, you know,” Gandalf says. “I could come up for a visit.”

            “There’s nothing you can do,” Bilbo says. Then, feeling bad about his tone, adds, “Thanks, anyway.”

            “Have heart,” Gandalf is saying, but Bilbo hangs up. He doesn’t even have the energy to throw his phone across the apartment.

            He needs to return to his roots.

            It is Sunday, the twelfth of May. He saw Thorin last on Monday, the sixth. It was raining, soft and warm, and the sky was pale grey. Bilbo loaded his bicycle—fixed, now—onto the rack of the local bus and rode up the hill, then cycled the last two miles or so to Thorin’s garage. Erebor ran down the lane to greet him, and Bilbo can still see the look on Thorin’s face as he stood on the back deck and watched them come closer. Inside, Thorin threw him a towel, and Bilbo peeled off his wet socks, and they spent a comfortable afternoon sprawled around the garage, Bilbo baking bread, Thorin tinkering with a model, Erebor nudging each of them in turn. Bilbo wanted to stay the night but didn’t know how to ask, and Thorin didn’t offer. He looked distracted as he loaded Bilbo’s bicycle into the trunk of his station wagon.

            They swam in the lake the Friday before, and Bilbo froze on the roof of the Volvo, his hands almost aching to reach out. Thorin had such confidence that it was breath-taking. Bilbo closed his eyes against the sun. When they got dressed afterwards, Bilbo felt Thorin’s eyes on him, felt the colour rushing to his cheeks. They finished the case of beer back at the garage and were stretched sideways across Thorin’s bed, Bilbo fighting with the NYT crossword and Thorin frowning over a book on stone quarries in Wales, and then Thorin reached out, brought a hand to Bilbo’s neck, right where jaw meets ear, and pulled him close. Bilbo never did finish the crossword, too caught up in the blank spaces of Thorin’s body instead, dips and hollows of muscles and joints, his hair smelling of the lake. Thorin’s beard was rough against his chin, the calluses on Thorin’s hands hard against his hips.

            The last week of April, they saw each other every day. Dinner on the twenty-ninth, after Thorin’s confrontation with his advisors, and Bilbo drank to keep pace with Thorin and ended up asleep in his bed. He woke to Thorin next to him, on his side, head propped up on one hand, just watching. Thorin’s eyes were always startling, especially so close, and the line of his lips was thin. Bilbo blinked away sleep and a creeping headache while Thorin rolled over and said nothing. They never had a proper conversation about what happened on Saturday. Bilbo tried, once or twice over the next few days, to bring it up, but got too embarrassed. Thorin isn’t the type to talk about it, anyway. He just . . . does it. A physical thing, easy like all others. Saturday: their hips together, the friction of their jeans, the rumble of Thorin’s voice against Bilbo’s throat. “I don’t,” Bilbo had said, and then Thorin, “I know.”

            Bilbo shakes his head. This is not what he wants to be remembering. It is too close, so close it makes his stomach twist. He thinks back further, skipping over a weekend spent barricaded in his attic apartment, numb with terror, Thorin’s switchblade on his table. Holding his breath while waiting for a phone call, an e-mail, some kind of “all clear” from Gandalf, ignoring Thorin pounding on his house’s door. He didn’t give Thorin new keys when he changed the locks. It slipped his mind, or maybe, subconsciously, he already knew. He skips even faster over the smell of cigarettes and charred flesh, over yelling and elevator doors and rain-dark parking lots. Over a disastrous dinner that had started out so well. Over whispered conversations in the rare manuscripts archives, over stilted conversations in the design studio. He never did finish Badiou. And earlier still, in February when Thorin twisted his arm and made him feel, for the first time since his mother’s death, that he was really alive. Pain is perhaps the strongest grounding force we can know. Bilbo remembers this, and bites his lip.

            This isn’t working. He doesn’t want to be seeing Thorin, shoulders large and looming, six days worth of unshaved chin and six feet plus worth of muscle, hair tangled into a knot, knuckles split and dusted with pencil lead. Smelling of pine and pipe tobacco and beer, of wet dog and wood glue. Bilbo misses Erebor, too—far more than he thought he would. The fact that the man named his dog after his lost home should probably have been a clue from the start: Thorin will never love anything as much as revenge. This mad quest he’s embarked on to reclaim his homeland, as if he were straight out of a medieval epic, was never going to be quietly set aside.

            Back to his roots. It’s Sunday, and still early. Bilbo gets up off the floor, puts one foot in front of the other until he’s in his shower. If he is really going back, he shouldn’t be at home on a Sunday morning. He should be in church. There’s a little chapel on the lake—the other side of the lake from the garage, thankfully. The congregation is small. He’s only been once before. It didn’t feel right, going on his own. Church had always been something to do with parents: growing up, Bilbo sang in the choir, was a sacristan, carried the sacred flame into the sanctuary and lit all the candles before the service. About the time his voice broke, from boy soprano down to tenor, he started to wonder about the words he was hearing, and whether or not he really believed any of them. But now, he thinks, it might help, or at least he is desperate enough to give it a try. So he gets cleaned up, puts on a clean button-down and flattens his hair with one hand while eating a piece of toast with the other. Looking at himself in the mirror is still too hard. His fingers fumble with the laces of his boots. The bicycle ride up to the chapel gives him time to clear his head, cool air on his face and the scent of last night’s rain, the trees glistening with new leaves.

            Upstate spring is a rare, fleeting thing. The weather’s too quick to slip back into winter, dreary and wind-blown, clouds scudding across the skies. But there are a few days, just a few, when the sun breaks through and the skies turn glassy and bright, and you can taste new earth with every breath. Bilbo is panting hard by the time he reaches the road that circles the lake and he stands up on the pedals, leans forward, coasts around a bend. In someone’s garden, snowdrops have begun to bloom.

            When he gets to the chapel, though, he can’t actually bring himself to step inside. He leans his bicycle up against a post and stares at the trees, listening to a muffled hymn from inside the sanctuary. It is the first music he has heard since Thorin left. It’s fitting, Bilbo thinks, closing his eyes, that Thorin’s note should have closed with lyrics, and that they should have been Springsteen: “When I die I want no part of Heaven; I would not do Heaven’s work well. I pray the Devil comes and takes me to stand at the fiery furnaces of Hell.” Bilbo doesn’t know the song. Doesn’t want to, if he’s being honest. He never did give Thorin back his mp3 player, and the song’s surely on there, somewhere, but to hear that deep, rough voice now would break his heart, no matter what the tune was. If Thorin has gone off to die, Bilbo would rather not know.

            That’s a lie. Of course he would want to know. But he doesn’t think he could handle it, either the knowing or the fact itself.

            Call it cowardice, call it weakness—the name of the thing doesn’t change the fact that it is all he knows. Thorin was right, he is useless. In real life, when it really counts, he can’t do anything. He’s spent the last day and a half breathless with fear, and why? Because he’s been left alone? Well, we are all alone, in the end. That’s not it. Because it is Thorin who has left him? Closer, but still not quite. He always knew Thorin was leaving. Because Thorin didn’t say goodbye? But then, what is the note, if not a last farewell? No, what is really at the heart of all this, probably, is that Thorin left alone.

            But Bilbo doesn’t even know if he would have gone, had Thorin asked. So really, what’s the point? He is being an idiot. “A fucking idiot,” Thorin would have said, and given him that look, sideways, smile just on the crooked side, just enough to be called a smirk.

            This is hopeless.

            Bilbo gets back on his bicycle and coasts down the hill, flying through the intersection, past Millstein without a second glance, past the undergrad housing. He makes a hard left, leaning into the turn, and passes his apartment by, face into the wind, mouth set in a thin line. He cycles all the way down to the railroad tracks, over them and to the river’s edge. Then there is nowhere further for him to go, so he drops his bicycle in the grass and sits on the low stone wall at the water’s edge. The current swirls gently, carrying city runoff down to the lake. That’s me, Bilbo thinks; I am the runoff, and Thorin was the current, only now he’s gone and I’ve gone stagnant.

            As analogies go, it’s a fairly juvenile one. His poetry professors would cringe. Bilbo watches the water for a good hour, until the damp has seeped into his pants and his fingers are cold but no longer shaking. “Find another current,” he tells himself, aloud. There isn’t anyone around to hear. “Right, then.” He stands, dusts his pants off, and begins the long ride back up the hill.

            He throws himself into his work. Sleeps for fourteen hours straight and turns out an eighteen-page paper in two days. Reads an entire novel in one sitting, before lunch. Vacuums his floors, cleans the kitchen and the bathroom, makes the trek down to the laundromat and breathes in the scent of detergent on clean sheets. Gandalf calls him three times, and Bilbo ignores each call, and deletes the voice-mails before listening to them. Thorin does not call at all. Bilbo thinks about erasing his contact details, but cannot quite bring himself to do it. He bakes a cake instead, and opens the awning windows to let in the cool spring breeze. He works and works and resolutely ignores everything else. This is how Bagginses have always coped. When his father fell ill, Bilbo and his mother repainted the kitchen. When he died, they replanted the entire garden, and all the neighbours dropped by to tell them how beautiful it looked, and how sorry they were, and Bilbo and his mother stood behind fence-posts with smiles stuck to their faces. Bilbo still has a scar on his arm, just below the wrist, from a particularly wily rose branch.

            He runs a thumb over it, lying on his stomach on the bare clean floor. “I can do this. It’s just life. That’s all. Things happen, and then you go on.”

            If he dreams about Erebor that night, the real Erebor, a shining silver mountain, he tries not to remember it in the morning.

 

Instead, he thinks about breakfast. When Thorin found out that Bilbo had never had a proper bagel, it was a Tuesday in November and hissing down rain. They were in the studio, talking about something entirely unrelated, when Thorin’s stomach grumbled loud enough to be heard from a table away. Bilbo bit back laughter and tried not to look, but it was a short-lived effort. “I would kill someone for a bagel right now,” Thorin said, up to his elbows in balsa wood and muslin.

            “Bagels,” Bilbo said. “Not really my thing.”

            Thorin gaped at him for a full minute, possibly more. Then he placed a miniature support beam onto his bridge, very carefully, and came to lean over Bilbo’s table. “How are they not your thing?” he asked. “What is wrong with you?”

            “I’ve just never thought they were that good,” Bilbo said. “That’s a perfectly legitimate opinion.”

            “No,” Thorin said, and that was that. Bilbo found himself being dragged off campus and into Collegetown, his cheeks reddening with cold, Thorin’s grip warm and tight on his shoulder. The bagel shop was packed with students but Thorin strong-armed his way through to get a table, told Bilbo in no uncertain terms to stay put, and returned with at least a dozen bagels. “Tuesdays,” Thorin said. “A dozen for six dollars.”

            “I can’t eat that many.”

            “Who said they were all for you?” Thorin pushed a bagel—just one—into Bilbo’s hand and stuffed another into his own mouth. Rain dripped off his upturned coat collar and onto the table. One of his feet was tapping evenly on the leg of his stool. Bilbo shook water from his hair and took a bite: warm and chewy, just a little bit sour. “Proper bagels,” Thorin was saying, “are only found in New York.”

            “Since when did you become a gourmet?” Bilbo asked.

            “I’ve lived here for long enough to learn,” Thorin retorted. “I can play the part, when I have to.”

            “Hmm. Yes, I suppose you can.” Bilbo took another bite, savouring the taste. The texture was perfect, just the right balance between tough and airy. The shop’s grainy speakers were playing Chicago with the volume turned low. A troupe of law students with posh accents crowded the table next to theirs, pantsuits and briefcases, tearing apart their classmates behind their backs. Thorin glared at them until they noticed, and then they left. It should have been painfully awkward, and it was, but it was also comfortable, somehow. Sitting knee-to-knee under the narrow table on rickety stools, eating bagels, with someone who was still practically a stranger, Bilbo found himself not just resigned to his situation but actually enjoying it.

            “What’s the verdict?” Thorin asked. “Still not your thing?”

            Bilbo chewed and swallowed. He looked up and met Thorin’s eyes, properly. “You’ve converted me,” he said.

            “Good,” Thorin replied, and broke into a rare smile, one that reached the corners of his eyes. He ran a hand through damp hair and leaned forward. “Today’s a success, then.”

            “Yes, good. Now give me another.”

            “I thought you couldn’t eat that many.”

            “Yes, well, you thought wrong.”

            It had been easy enough to snipe back and forth across the table, swapping bagel flavours and watching the rain. Thorin bought Bilbo a cup of coffee before their walk back, and took him the long way around, across the footbridge and into one of the gorges. They cut across the engineering quad, dodging umbrellas and puddles as they went. The coffee burnt Bilbo’s tongue, but it warmed his hands, and Thorin’s good mood lasted the whole day.

            What happens to people, to make them change? Bilbo knows now that even then, even that rainy Tuesday, Thorin must have been alight with cross-country desires, kindling a long-awaited vengeance inside the sturdy frame of his chest. If he could go back and tell himself then what he knows now, Bilbo thinks he would have spoken a warning: Stay away. Everyone else seemed to hear it loud and clear. Why was he never suspicious, not even a little bit, that Thorin had no friends? When he thought about that abrupt and confusing Thanksgiving, or about the curiously empty studio, why did it never strike him as anything other than simply odd? He has said it before: gradschool turned him into an optimist. He doesn’t know when that happened—can’t pin down the exact date—but it happened early on, and it is only just leaving him now.

            That leaves the alternatives: a pessimist, or a realist. Pessimism has never been Bilbo’s thing, and unlike bagels, he doesn’t think he’ll be converted so easily. Besides, it’s a funny word. Realism is solid, structured; it has a history. It is something he should be able to hang on to when everything else fails: facts. With the morning sun warming his back, Bilbo sits at his desk and makes a list.

            Fact: Thorin is gone.  

            Fact: He didn’t take you with him.

            Fact: He is (probably) never coming back.

            Fact: You need to get over that, or you’re going to fall apart.

            Fact: Or, you could just go after him.

Notes:

In the spirit of Christmas, or something, here's an update sooner than I expected. Thanks for such enthusiastic, fantastic support throughout this whole endeavour, even when I haven't been able to give this fic as much attention as any of us would like. I appreciate all of you who read, leave kudos, comment, talk to me on tumblr ("htw fic" is the tag, stick-around-town is the blog), etc. I couldn't be doing this without you, so, thanks.

What will happen next? Your guess is as good as mine, honestly. Feel free to make conjectures in comments below. Also, I'll update the annotations/refs after the holidays, when I have a bit of free time. The Springsteen song here is "Youngstown" (there's a vid in the tag/on my blog) and the poem is "Mad Girl's Love Song," written 1951 when Plath was a student at Smith College.