Actions

Work Header

How the West Was Won and Where It Got Us

Chapter 14

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

Bilbo’s never been a physical person. Most days, he doesn’t even like to be looked at, let alone touched. Thorin being who he is—having grown up in a family where gruff pats and manful shoulder-punches were affection’s base currency, where he was expected from birth to someday be the one in charge of an empire and “hands-on” is more than just an expression—doesn’t understand that. So he pushes Bilbo around and throws him onto couches like it’s nothing, like it’s second nature. Or he’ll come up from behind and drop a hand on Bilbo’s head while leaning over his shoulder to look at something, and Bilbo still can’t stop himself from tensing, every time. Just for a second, he is always afraid.

            If Bilbo could find the words to tell him about it, Thorin would probably stop. But Bilbo can’t decide which is worse: enduring that brief moment of fear, or not being touched at all.

            He can’t say that he “wakes up” the next morning, because he’s been awake for hours, watching the light play across the walls as the sun rises, the palm of his hand a dull, hot ache. Thorin is snoring lightly, still slumped over in his chair. He doesn’t stir when Bilbo slides off the end of the bed and picks last night’s discarded sweater off the floor. It’s cold in the attic, and Bilbo warms his hands gently over the stove as he boils water for tea. Thorin isn’t a tea person, but he’s getting a cup anyway. Flexing his fingers experimentally, Bilbo winces as the skin pulls tight. There’s a matching tightness in his chest, behind his eyes—he would like very much to go back to bed, under the quilts, and not have to face anyone. Well, Thorin could stay. He’s not other people, not really. Bilbo doesn’t like when people watch him sleep but Thorin’s already seen him, passed out and drooling in a sleeping bag on his couch, feverish and incoherent in his bed, curled up in the corners of the studio. Thorin doesn’t count.

            The water’s done, though the kettle doesn’t whistle; it’s his father’s, broken ever since he can remember. Bilbo makes tea, drinks it slowly, wills Thorin to wake up. The man doesn’t stir, so Bilbo watches him, the width of his back rising and falling with slow breaths, the dark hair half-fallen out of its tie. When the tea is gone Bilbo’s grown cold again, and Thorin is immobile as stone. It doesn’t seem fair to face the day alone. What day is it, even? Bilbo can’t remember. He crawls into his bed from the foot, careful not to disturb Thorin, and smothers himself in blankets till he can hardly breathe. The weight of them makes him feel safe.

            Later, Thorin will wake up just enough to notice the awful ache in his neck, and the lump taking up just half the bed beside him. When they both next wake, it will be side by side.

 

“I want to handle this on my own,” Bilbo says. They’ve been sitting in relative quiet for a good hour or two, watching the fog slowly lift as morning wears on. Bilbo’s taken a shower and put on his oldest threadbare corduroys, has a sweater wrapped around his shoulders. Thorin tried to get him to eat something but he couldn’t stomach more than toast. Bilbo tried to get Thorin to shower, too—to wash off the lingering smell of fear and smoke and anger—but Thorin won’t stop looking at the door every five seconds, as if he is expecting Azog to return. Part of Bilbo, some vindictiveness he thought he had long since left behind, wants that to happen. It’s wrong, but he thinks he might feel better if he could just watch Thorin hurt Azog.

            “You’re not shutting me out of this.”

            “It’s not your fight.”

            “It is my fight! You’re my— It is my fight, Bilbo.”

            “I just need some time to think about it.”

            “He didn’t give you any time. I have to act now. The longer I wait, the more time he will have had to plan.”

            “It doesn’t matter. I need to figure this out alone.” Bilbo rubs at a bare patch on the left knee of his pants.

            “No!” Thorin says. “You can’t handle this.”

            “Because I’m useless.”

            “What?”

            “That’s what you said to me, last night.”

            “I didn’t.”

            “Thorin, you did. Please don’t lie to me.”

            “No, I meant—“ Thorin makes a short noise of exasperation and runs a hand through his hair. “I didn’t mean that. You’re not useless.”

            “Just weak.”

            “Look, Bilbo, this isn’t something you can just ignore and hope will go away. Azog doesn’t give up. I know his ways, and I am telling you, you have to let me go after him.”

            “Funny way of asking permission you have there,” Bilbo says. “I ‘have to’ let you. Is this what we’ve become?”

            “What are you talking about?”

            “You don’t ask, ever. You always just do, do, do. Stop—stop taking care of me all the time. I’m not a child.”

            “Bilbo—”

            “I will handle this. By myself. Thank you for the bandages. Now please go.” Bilbo turns his back to Thorin. His head aches and his eyes are burning. He’s worried he might start crying, and that is the last thing this situation needs. Thorin doesn’t move for a minute, and Bilbo can feel the man glaring a hole in his back.

            “At least come and stay with me.”

            “No, thank you.” He is falling back on politeness, ingrained, a Baggins to the core. His mother, he thinks, would have been proud.

            Wouldn’t she?

            “What needs to happen to you to make you understand that this isn’t some kind of game?” Thorin is right behind him, Bilbo can feel it, breath hot on the back of his neck. “Next time he won’t just burn your hand, he’ll cut it off.”

            “Yes, he did say something like that.”

            Thorin is grinding his teeth so loudly Bilbo can hear it. He is halfway to relenting when Thorin slams a hand into the wall and says, “Fine. See if I care.” He storms out, not even bothering to collect his things. Bilbo watches him go from the awning windows and then slides slowly to the ground.

            “You do care,” he says. “I know you do. I just can’t . . .” He hugs his knees in close, drops his head onto his forearms. He doesn’t know what he is saying, or why he is even still talking. It feels as though he’s reached a cross-roads: if he doesn’t stand on his own now, he never will. And Thorin is leaving in a month, though he refuses to talk about that, and Bilbo is trying to plan for a future that doesn’t include him. They’re proving, more and more often these days, that they’re not good for each other.

            Thorin texts him that night. “You’re being an idiot.” Bilbo doesn’t reply, because he’s certainly not going to admit that, even if it is probably true. Another text follows a while later, but Bilbo deletes it before even opening it.

 

And then, all of a sudden, Bilbo doesn’t sleep anymore. Not properly, anyway. Nevermind his past habits, the ease with which he retreated into sleep at the first hint of a bad day. In the last three days he’s slept maybe 10 hours total, and none of it restful. It’s some kind of delayed reaction to this whole thing, he thinks, and lousy timing for it. April is one of the busiest academic months. He’s meant to be planning for a humanities colloquium, figuring out term paper topics, not jumping at every passing shadow.

            He’ll wake up damp with sweat, disoriented, no idea what day it is. It’s not even that he’s having nightmares—if he is, he doesn’t remember them. But he’ll be at his desk, working, contemplating bed around midnight or one o’clock in the morning, and the next thing he knows it’ll be five o’clock and then sleep seems pointless, when it’s already the next day and he has classes and lectures and stacks of reading. So he’ll make a pot of coffee and shower as the sun rises, and he’ll force himself out of the apartment to face the day.

            It’s one of those things that people always say will get easier with time. How much time, Bilbo wonders? How long is he meant to wait? They said that after his father’s death, and again after his mothers, and he’s still fucking waiting, thank you. It is more time than he feels he has to spare. Sometimes he thinks about taking advantage of his university health insurance, seeking out some campus counselor. But the first step to a consultation is a phone conversation, and he can never make himself so much as dial the numbers, let alone complete the call. It seems paradoxically cruel to have such a barrier as the first step in the system—he’s anxious, that’s the proper word for it, but in order to speak with anyone about resolving that he would need to do precisely one of the things that makes him anxious.

            He has hardly touched his phone since calling Thorin by mistake. Hasn’t even turned it on in two days. On some level, Bilbo knows that’s eminently stupid. It’s meant to be a tool for his own safety, a digital lifeline. All he sees when he looks at it, though, is a mistake, and what that led to. How they woke up side by side in the same bed. How they couldn’t talk to each other the next day. How they argued, later, and Thorin told him he didn’t understand anything.

            Well, maybe he doesn’t. What’s so wrong about that? At what point in your life are you meant to understand things?

            Sometimes it frightens Bilbo, how easily they can argue, and how often.

            Whenever Bilbo goes out now, he worries that he’s being followed. The other evening, he thought some exercise and fresh air might help take his mind off things, tire him out enough to get some rest. So he laced up his boots and went walking across campus—well-lit, plenty of students about. He couldn’t stop looking over his shoulder, though, and it always seemed so damned clichéd, when he would read about it in books, but it’s real: his breath kept coming faster and he couldn’t keep his steps from quickening. He ducked into the library, open 24 hours a day, and took refuge in a throng of first-years, cramming for prelims. No one came in after him. No pale hair, no black leather, no cigarette smoke. But the possibility alone was more than enough. He was on edge the entire way back to his apartment. In the soft glow of the street-lamps he saw shadows moving towards him with long fingers; the headlights of every car that passed by had Azog’s sharp eyes behind them. It’s illogical, absolutely ridiculous, because the man has easier ways to get what he wants than wasting his time stalking Bilbo, but knowing that and really believing it are two completely different things. He’s going back to an empty apartment again—Thorin had asked him to stay at the garage again after their argument, speaking through clenched teeth, but Bilbo said no, worried that they were too close to a breaking point, trying so hard to prevent something he desperately wanted not to see as inevitable, no matter how much it was starting to feel that way. So Thorin made him take Erebor instead for a few days, and they were a good few days, sneaking the dog out for early morning walks, having a gigantic black lump at the foot of his bed each night, but now there’s no one. Bilbo’s changed the locks, not that changing the locks will do any good. It’s a useless security measure. He doesn’t feel secure.

            He feels like an idiot. As though it’s somehow his fault. And even if he knows that he did absolutely nothing to cause it all, that he was just doing what he thought was right at the time, that still doesn’t change the way he can’t look himself in the eyes in the mirror. He feels like he’s drowning, or adrift, anything but on stable ground. He thinks that if he had a car, there’s no way in hell he’d still be in this city. He’d be out of the state, possibly even the country. He’d have driven into a tree in his haste to get away.

            As it is, he hops a bus to the nearest liquor store, comes back with two bottles of port tucked into his satchel. It is a compromise. He spent five minutes staring at shelves of vodka, tequila, things with a higher proof, but even as messed up as he is—he is just now beginning to admit it, but only to himself—that’s a bit farther than he’s willing to go, to sit alone drinking straight vodka in his attic. It is not something Bagginses do. The port is strong enough, fruity stuff, thick and sweet in his mouth. It sort of gives him a headache. He drinks it anyway, and wonders if this is how Thorin feels, all the time, and if this accounts for the perpetual grumpiness. He drinks it at night in hopes of sleeping, and though it makes him lethargic it doesn’t knock him out, so he drinks it again in the morning, and when he comes home from classes. It doesn’t stop the anxiety; it just makes him too slow to care. He suspects he’s failing French, and keeps falling asleep in his Tuesday afternoon theory seminar. None of his professors have said anything yet. More to the point, Thorin hasn’t said anything yet. Bilbo is waiting for him to notice, to push, to recognise his own symptoms in the face of another. It is as if he needs another confrontation, a second one to derail the first that will not let him go. He needs to create problems for himself so that he can fix them, and feel as though he’s got control over something. It is not a pattern of behaviour he has indulged in before, not even in his lowest moments, but he has read about it often enough, those tragic antiheroes of his whom he so used to admire.

            There is nothing admirable about this. Nothing at all.

            He is afraid to stay on campus late to study. Doesn’t even like hanging around the studio anymore. The wall-to-wall windows that first seemed so inviting only make him think now that he is visible, so terribly visible, to anyone passing by. If Azog really is some kind of Russian mob scion, as Bilbo had once feared, he probably has spies everywhere. They are probably watching him, right now, half-drunk on port and falling asleep over modal verb conjugations, cross-legged on his apartment floor.

            The week is a complete disaster. He wants badly to just leave it all behind, but he has nowhere to go.

            He’ll be in the middle of something—reading an article, scanning the stacks in the library, it doesn’t matter what—and then he will freeze up. He can go hours not thinking about it, but it always comes back, and when it does it knocks aside anything in its path. He replays the scene in his mind, and the pain in his hand reminds him daily that it happened, that it is still happening.

            He didn’t steal the map, of course. He laid out his options. Campus security. City police. Neither of them was particularly appealing. Bilbo has never gotten into serious trouble, but lives with an honest person’s irrational fear that the law will convict him anyway. When he is already blaming himself, charges from someone else would be too much to handle. Besides, Thorin hates the campus security—they have thrown him out of the studio, or tried to, too many times—and the city police don’t like to get involved in academic affairs. For at its heart, this is still academic; it is about a map, rare and valuable and obscure, and professional greed. It is about status, and fame.

            Bilbo has never wanted to make a name for himself. He just wants to live quietly, with his books, perhaps a garden of his own, if there’s money enough left to buy a house with any kind of a lawn. That does not mean, though, that he is entirely without connections. On Wednesday evening, five days later, he takes a deep breath and picks up his phone, hoping that the call will go straight through to the answering service. It rings three times, four, and then halfway through the fifth, Gandalf picks up.

            “Bilbo, my lad, you’ll never guess—”

            “I need your help,” Bilbo cuts in, before his not-uncle can go off on one of his stories. “Are you alone? That is, can you talk?”

            “One minute,” Gandalf says, his voice instantly changed. Deeper now, gruffer. A no-nonsense sort of voice. This is always who he has been: playing a bit of the fool, a bit of the absent-minded professor, until there is a crisis. Gandalf is practically built for crisis. There is some shuffling in the background, the creak of a door, and then Gandalf says, “You have my complete and undivided attention.”

            “I’m in some trouble,” Bilbo says. He dialed before he properly thought through this conversation, but he winces and forges ahead anyway. “I may have made an enemy. That is, I definitely made an enemy. He’s, um, very . . . well, terrifying.”

            “What happened?”

            “He wanted me to help him steal a map. From the rare manuscript collections. And I was never going to, but I . . . might have neglected to be clear about that.”

            “He thought the two of you had made a deal, and you failed to deliver,” Gandalf says.

            “Er, yes, something like that. And apparently he’s been following me, and now Thorin is talking about murder left and right, and—”

            “Thorin knows him?” 

            “Thorin hates him. Won’t tell me why. Well, I mean, something about his family, and now the fact that he— He, um. Hmm.” Bilbo scratches his nose, takes a deep breath. He shakes his head, trying to knock the words out. “Hmm.”

            “Tell me, Bilbo,” Gandalf says, somewhere between coaxing and demanding. Bilbo sighs.

            “I came back to the apartment. The other night, that is, I came back, and he was waiting. For me. Inside. We, erm, talked. He threatened me. And burned me. With a cigarette. I didn’t realise—people still do that? It’s so— Well. Then he left.”

            Gandalf says something then that sounds very much like a swear, but not in any language Bilbo can recognise. “What did you do?”

            “Panicked, mostly,” Bilbo admits. “I called Thorin.”

            “Who hates this man.”

            “Right. But he . . . patched me up. Before threatening murder. Or after, possibly. Things were a little . . . confused.”

            “I think you’d better tell me this man’s name, and anything else you might be holding back. Don’t worry about protecting Thorin; I know more of his secrets than he would care to admit.”

            “Really?” Bilbo asks. “How—”

            “The name, Bilbo!”

            “It’s Azog,” Bilbo says. “I don’t know if it’s a surname or—”

            Gandalf cuts in, quick, saying, “Azog is not a name at all.”

            “Er, sorry. What?”

            “It is a title. Bilbo, where are, right now? Are you safe?”

            “I’m in the apartment.”

            “I don’t suppose you have a gun.”

            “What? Gandalf, what on earth are you talking about? You know I don’t.”

            “You need protecting, Bilbo Baggins, and you cannot do it on your own, and I will not trust Thorin Oakenshield not to go off half-cocked and without a plan, not on something like this. I have been trying for some years now to take down Azog. You may have just given me an opening. This map, what do you know about it?”

            “Not much,” Bilbo says. “I can send you the notes I have, but wait a minute, hang on—”

            “Send the notes. I will handle Azog. Can I trust you to do as I say?”

            “What are you going to do?”

            “Bilbo, will you do as I say?”

            “Yes, but—”

            “Stay with Thorin for the next couple of days. It won’t be safe for you on your own, and I need you to keep him out of this. I shall call you when it’s all over.”

            “Gandalf, would you please just tell me what—”      

            “Send the notes. Goodbye.”

            Bilbo stares at the phone in his hand. He supposes that he should have expected this. Gandalf is only ever talkative when he wants to be. Fretting about it all the while, Bilbo signs in to his personal e-mail account, takes a minute to run his notes through an encryption program, and sends the files to Gandalf. The encryption is something Gandalf insists upon for electronic communication. Bilbo tells himself it’s because archaeology is a competitive and time-sensitive field, and tries not to acknowledge the growing suspicion—even stronger now, after that phone call—that there is far more to his not-uncle than meets the eye. Whatever else can be said about the man, he always keeps his word, even if it’s not in the way you were expecting.

            It is different, somehow, letting Gandalf take over things, than allowing Thorin to go off on a one-man revenge mission. Bilbo actively avoids thinking about why that is. He pours himself a glass of port instead, drinks it sitting on the kitchen floor. He will stay here, he tells himself, not go to Thorin's; stay, and prove that he can handle things. That he is not useless, or at least, not as useless as he appears. There is a spider spinning slowly in the corner, climbing up the side of the refrigerator. His mother wouldn’t be proud; she’d be appalled. The place is a mess.

            He is a mess.

            He doesn’t see Thorin again until Saturday, the twenty-seventh of April.

Notes:

Even though this is a shorter chapter, and leaves a lot unanswered, I have been feeling awfully guilty for not updating in ages, so I thought to give you at least this much would be better than nothing. It's the usual story: I've been writing term papers and grading student work and have no time. Also, this chapter was particularly challenging to write, because of 1) logistics with Gandalf's, which I sort of avoided anyway, and 2) some emotions I haven't revisited in a while, which were hard to get down on paper. Thanks for your patience. I think of this story often, and really appreciate you all sticking with it even during long bouts of radio silence. I should have the last of my term papers done by Tuesday night, and then apart from family stuff over the holidays, I plan to write. There are questions, questions that need answering, as they say, and I mean to give you some answers. Others, you'll have to figure out for yourselves. If you're curious, the tag for this on tumblr is "htw fic" and I occasionally post about writing it, updates, relevant music, art, etc. If you've anything related to this story you'd like me to see, please tag it with that so I can check it out.

In case you'd like a general sense of some things to come in this story, here is a brief list. SPOILER ALERT for any who would rather not know. If there's something you're curious about that you don't see on here, feel free to drop me a line. I may already be thinking about it, or it may not be on my mind yet. Either way, I'm always curious to hear what you all think.

[SPOILERS] Things to come include: more about Thorin's family, the end of Azog's story, B & T going on a (pseudo-)date with coffee and actual other people around, the inevitable trip westward and the accompanying question of whether Bilbo will stay or go.

Vague, I know. I don't want to give too much away. I'll reply to private messages on tumblr if you want more details. Thanks, as always, for reading!