Actions

Work Header

How the West Was Won and Where It Got Us

Chapter 18

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

Sometimes Bilbo wonders why he ever thought it would be a good idea to move up north. It’s early March but still feels like February, dreary and wet and frustratingly cold. Most of the snow’s melted into mud; campus is a mess and the streets in town are dirty, salt-stained and cracked with pot-holes from a long winter. The only bright point—the one thing that Bilbo’s holding onto in hopes of an actual spring—is the fact that the birds have begun to sing outside his window again. Just a little, here and there, and even then it’s only sparrows and starlings, mixed in with the harsh interruptions of a crow or two. It’s nothing like the symphony he used to have back home, bluebirds and finches and buntings, calling out across the garden. The trees are perpetually damp and bare here, and the grass is trampled and brown, and Bilbo hates everything.

            “I am so done with this,” he mutters to himself, dodging rainwater dripping from the gutters as he tugs open the door to the basement of Sibley Hall. He wipes the muck off his boots on the mat inside the café door and tromps into The Green Dragon. It’s early enough on a Wednesday that the place is mostly empty and his usual table—a two-seater, tucked into a corner by a mural of geometric stars and offering a good view of the various ways in and out of the café—is empty. There’s a cafe in his own English & Humanities building, but he prefers this one. It’s more spacious, for one thing, and less busy. The floor is brick, uneven and faded, and the tables and folding chairs are all a little wonky, stone and plastic and red metal. There’s some kind of long-lived art installation on the ceiling, filtering through the industrial lighting, and a changing array of student art and advertising posters on display. Students and professors are always in and out, working at their laptops, sleeping on the long bench against the side wall. It’s a comfortable spot. It’s relaxed.

            The Green Dragon is also, it must be said, a likely place to casually run into Thorin, as it’s run by the Art, Architecture & Planning department, and adjacent to the studio. Not that Bilbo is planning on running into Thorin, of course. He just came to get some work done. He’s been reading this novel called Remainder in conjunction with his course on psychoanalytic theory, trying to come up with a paper topic. Lately he’s come to the realisation that a lot of his life has been measured in losing things, so he’s particularly interested in what endures, in what remains. When he was a kid he had an idea that he could deal with things by telling stories, because the stories would outlast him. As if there was some kind of immortality, some kind of salvation, through words. He doesn’t think that anymore. Prefers to read stories rather than tell them. Scoffs at the word “redemption” on the back covers of novels: “A tale of sacrifice and redemption.” Yeah, right.

            Bilbo should probably have thought twice before enrolling in a course whose primary topic is something called the “death drive,” but then again, it is inescapably true: we’re all going to die someday.

            He gets himself a latte and a piece of crumb cake. He’s about halfway through the novel and things are getting very strange—the protagonist has become obsessed with repetition, with finding patterns in everything and recreating events with a degree of detail so exact and so literal it produces frightening results—when something wet nuzzles his hand, and he looks down to see Erebor there, tail thumping against the brick floor. “Hello, Ere,” Bilbo says, and sets his novel down so he can rub the dog’s ears. “What are you doing here?”

            “He got bored in studio.”

            Bilbo looks up, startled, because he was expecting Thorin—and trying to play it cool—but it’s Dwalin standing there, towering over him. “Oh,” Bilbo says. “Er, hello.” He scratches Erebor under the chin and the dog presses closer, licking his wrist, his forearms. “Yes, yes, all right, you,” Bilbo pushes Erebor back. “Enough.” He looks at the dog sternly, or attempts to. Erebor cocks his head, lets out a subdued whoof of air, and curls up underneath Bilbo’s table.

            “I need coffee,” Dwalin says. “You?”

            “What? Oh, I . . . I’m fine.”

            “You need coffee,” Dwalin declares, and marches off. A few other students have set up camp in the café since Bilbo last glanced up from the novel, and he notices them staring now. Well, of course they’re staring. Dwalin’s tall enough to stand out anyway, and he’s only wearing a t-shirt despite the cold rain. Then there are the tattoos, over his hands and around half of his very bald head, stark lines of black ink. Bilbo’s been curious about them since Thanksgiving but has yet to work up the courage to ask. There are more pressing mysteries in his life anyway. Dwalin comes back over, two cups of coffee in his massive hands, and drops into the chair opposite Bilbo before pushing one of the cups across the table to him.

            “Th-thank you,” Bilbo says.

            “So,” Dwalin says, and manages to inject a worrying amount of intent into that one syllable. He’s sideways in the chair, one arm hanging over the back of it, his knees too high to fit under the low table. “What are you up to these days?”

            “Just the usual.”

            “Hmmm.”

            Bilbo fiddles with the lid of his coffee cup. Dwalin keeps on staring. “What are you up to?” Bilbo counters.

            “The usual,” Dwalin smirks. He stretches his arms over his head and rocks back in the chair.

            “I still have no idea what you actually do.”

            “Really? I would’ve thought Thorin’d told you by now. What with the two of you being so . . . close.”

            “We’re—” Bilbo starts to say, but then shakes his head, because he really doesn’t know how to finish that sentence. “He didn’t tell me. Just that you’d known each other since you were kids.” He takes a sip of coffee before adding, tentatively, “In Erebor.”

            Underneath Bilbo’s chair the dog stirs at mention of his name. He’s tall enough that he can comfortably rest his chin on the table and so he does, dark eyes flicking from Dwalin to Bilbo and back again.

            “He’s like a brother to me,” Dwalin says, and leans forward. The chair scrapes along the floor. “So you’ll understand that I’m a little curious as to what’s going on between the two of you.”

            Bilbo tells himself that if he can just not look away first, he’ll be fine. But he breaks under the weight of Dwalin’s stare, faced with the harshness of those black lines and runic letters stern across his forehead. Dwalin looks disturbingly at ease playing the interrogator. “I just want to be his friend,” Bilbo blurts out. Dwalin’s frown deepens. “I mean,” Bilbo stammers, “I worry about him.”

            “He’s very good at that,” Dwalin concedes. “Making other people worry about him. Does it to me all the time.” And it seems that Bilbo’s said something right, because Dwalin raises his cup of coffee in a toast before knocking back the rest of it. “Well,” he says, and pushes his chair back to stand up. Bilbo winces at the harsh noise of metal grating over brick. “I have to get back to work. Not all of us can enjoy a student’s schedule. I’ll leave Ere with you. Thorin’ll come by for him later, probably.”

            “Probably?”

            “Eh, the dog likes you, it’s fine.”

            “Dogs aren’t allowed in here,” Bilbo points out. “I don’t know how we haven’t been told off already.”

            “They like him,” Dwalin says, jerking a finger back over his shoulder towards the cash register. Sure enough, the art students behind the counter grin. “He’s well-behaved.”

            “Even so . . .”

            “Live a little,” Dwalin tells him. “Get your nose out of those books.”

            “They’re sort of my job at the moment,” Bilbo says.

            Dwalin laughs, his shoulders shaking with it. “See you around,” he says, and claps one heavy hand on Bilbo’s shoulder. “I mean it,” he adds, when Bilbo gives him a skeptical look. “I’ll be watching you.”

            “You will?” Bilbo asks, pulling away, but Dwalin just gives him a careless wave and disappears off into the basement. “What do you think, Ere?” Bilbo asks the dog, who has put his front paws onto Bilbo’s lap. “Was that a threat? He really didn’t need to say anything. He could have just sat there and . . . menaced.” Bilbo picks up Erebor’s ears and frowns at the dog, who pushes up to nose at Bilbo’s neck. “Oh, get down, you great big lug,” Bilbo says, shaking his head and rubbing at the dampness. Erebor slides off, pacing a circuit around the table. It’s a tight fit between the table and the wall, so Bilbo tilts and shifts the table a bit. Erebor seems content enough to roam, sniffing casually at the cluster of art students at the long wooden table across from Bilbo before coming back to tuck himself under Dwalin’s abandoned chair.

            He’s half focused on his reading and half on NPR’s All Songs Considered program, playing at low volume over the Dragon’s speakers, and so doesn’t notice when Thorin does actually walk in, smears of white plaster across the front of his jeans and his hair tied up on top of his head. “Large coffee,” Bilbo hears him order, and looks up at the sound of that deep voice, rough-edged from lack of sleep.

            Bilbo catches Thorin’s eye and smiles, lifts one hand in a hesitant wave. Erebor’s ears perked up the moment Thorin walked in, but the dog, curiously, stays by Bilbo. Thorin raises an eyebrow at the dog but almost returns Bilbo’s smile and comes to join them, coffee in hand. “See you’re keeping my dog company,” he remarks.

            “More the other way around, really,” Bilbo says.

            “He’s good for that,” Thorin says, getting an arm around Erebor’s waist and pulling the dog towards him, wrestling. “Right, Ere?”

            “Dwalin brought him.”

            “Yeah. He wouldn’t leave me alone in studio so I sent him down here,” Thorin says. Erebor has one of Thorin’s wrists in his mouth, tugging playfully, wrestling right back. “Dwalin, I mean. Not the dog.”

            “What does he actually do?” Bilbo asks.

            “Apart from intimidate freshmen into leaving studio? Very useful. But odd jobs, mostly. He’s working on the construction crew upstairs right now,” Thorin says. Sibley Hall is undergoing renovations, Bilbo knows, because he’s seen enough men in coveralls and hardhats buying coffee in the Dragon. He just hadn’t expected Dwalin to be one of them. “Sometimes he helps out at one of the local farms, or the refinery up the lake. He’s good with his hands.”

            “He certainly seems, um, capable,” Bilbo says. He goes to take a sip of his coffee to cover the awkwardness, but his cup is already empty. So he sets it down, playing with the cardboard sleeve instead.

            Thorin is laughing at him, a little bit. Not out loud, and not particularly obviously, but Bilbo picks up on it all the same. He frowns across the table at Thorin. The smug look doesn’t leave Thorin’s eyes. Thorin’s trimmed his beard though, and the shirt he’s wearing looks marginally clean, so on the whole Bilbo doesn’t mind. He supposes he can handle being mocked if it makes Thorin happy. “What were you working on?” Bilbo asks, gesturing to the chalky plaster drying on Thorin’s hands and jeans.

            “Mixing up some cement,” Thorin says. “Among other things. It’s kind of a strange project. I was going to show you it, actually. We might as well go now. I’m due for a break.” Thorin stands and Erebor goes to his heels, so there’s really nothing for Bilbo to do except pack up his things and follow. “Have to pick up a few things from studio first,” Thorin says, and leads Bilbo and Erebor back upstairs. No one in the hall seems surprised to see either of them trailing after Thorin, who picks up a duffel bag and couple of 5-gallon buckets from the supply closet. “Take this,” he tells Bilbo, holding out the bag so he can shift the buckets, one per hand.

            “I can take one of those,” Bilbo offers.

            “They’re heavier than they look,” Thorin says. “Wouldn’t want to knock you over.”

            “Oh, very funny.” Bilbo shoulders the bag and looks down at Erebor. “He’s hilarious,” he tells the dog. Erebor doesn’t reply.

            “Come on, Bilbo. Keep up.” Thorin’s halfway out the door already, carrying the buckets with ease as he heads back downstairs and out to the parking lot.

            It’s still wet outside, a kind of weather pattern particular to this city—grey skies, cold, but you’re never sure if it’s raining, or snowing, or just generally damp. The morning’s fog has lifted though, and Thorin slings the buckets into the Volvo’s trunk, next to a stack of lumber and canvas sacking. Bilbo lets Erebor into the backseat, and they set off through North Campus. Underclassmen are out and about, crossing the bridge, looking thoroughly miserable about the weather. Thorin seems distracted, the fingers of his right hand clenched around the gear shift. Bilbo wants to ask where they’re going, but when Thorin’s in a mood like this it’s tricky. He’s learning not to ask too many questions.

            They’re only driving for five minutes or so when Thorin turns off the main road and pulls into an elementary school parking lot, of all places. There aren’t any kids outside. Thorin parks and cuts the engine, pauses a minute before getting out of the car. He opens the door for Erebor and goes back up to lean against the hood, looking out into the fog. Bilbo unbuckles and slides out of the car to join him.

            “I wanted to show you,” Thorin says. He points to something across the lawn, a structure Bilbo can barely make out. “Been working on this for three weeks now.”

            “I can’t see anything,” Bilbo finally admits, giving up on straining his eyes. He takes off his glasses and tugs his jacket up to wipe them on a dry part of his shirt. “This stupid rain . . .”

            “Here, come on,” Thorin says, and he’s got Bilbo by the arm before Bilbo even has a chance to put his glasses back on, dragging him across the lawn. Erebor bounds off ahead, undisturbed by rain or mud.

            They come to a stop in front of a staircase. “It’s . . . a castle?” Bilbo ventures. A doorway arches up before him, walls and turrets and slits for windows.  

            “It’s a playground,” Thorin says.

            “Well, yes, but a castle playground.”

            “If you like.” Thorin is smiling. He’s let go of Bilbo’s arm, shoved his own hands into his pockets, standing in a way that Bilbo recognises as the posture he adopts when he’s proud of something but doesn’t want to let on.

            “I do like,” Bilbo says, and smiles back. “You’ve been building a castle playground for the last three weeks and you’re only telling me now? We could have been playing knights of the round table for ages already, Thorin.”

            “It’s a commission,” Thorin explains. “The school put in a call to my department, looking for someone to revamp the place so kids would have something a bit more exciting. I submitted a proposal. Didn’t think they’d go for it, but then, this whole city’s crazy, so. Here it is. Not very Camelot. Just thought I might as well test out some designs I’ve been messing around with.”

            “It’s great,” Bilbo says, one hand on the balustrade. “Can I . . . go inside?”

            “Yeah, if you want.” Thorin follows Bilbo up the curved staircase. “I wanted to make a moat,” he says. “The school didn’t go for that.”

            “Even crazy cities have their limits,” Bilbo concedes.

            “What good is a castle without a moat?”

            “It’s a good castle, Thorin. They’re kids. They’re not going to care. I would’ve loved this as a child.”

            “It doesn’t suit you.”

            “Sorry?”

            “I mean— I didn’t design it with you in mind. Just for some kids.”

            It’s not real stone, of course—that would’ve taken too long, cost too much. Thorin walks Bilbo through the layout, three basic rooms and a couple of offshoot walkways, leading out to guard towers. The ceilings are a bit low, child-sized, and Thorin has to duck under the doorways. Bilbo doesn’t. Bilbo fits just fine. “It’s concrete,” Thorin is telling him, “but poured into wooden molds; that’s where you get the ridges and grooves. And then you treat it afterwards, a chisel and hammer, a wash of paint, try to fake out some textures. It takes a while, but it’s cheap. Comparatively. And it’ll last through whatever these kids throw at it.”

            “It’s fantastic.” Bilbo runs his hand along the wall, feeling the roughness, the grooves and lines. The floors are wood planking—“From a barn that collapsed a few miles up the lake,” Thorin tells him—and it feels far too grand to be sitting on an elementary school lawn. Far too incongruous.

            They climb up one of the guard towers—it’s unfinished, scaffolding and wooden molds empty at the top—and stand there in the rain. Walking the battlements, or very near to it. Erebor is circling the castle below. “Really fantastic. Did you do all this yourself?” Bilbo asks.

            Thorin’s smile fades a little, and he rubs the back of his neck. Turns away. “No,” he says. “I mean, mostly. You see the landscaping, down there?”

            Bilbo hadn’t paid much attention to it when walking up to the castle, but sure enough, there are trees flanking the staircase, still just saplings, and shrubbery ringing the guard towers, with a trellis and some young ivy beginning to climb. “Really making this a proper place,” Bilbo says. The lawn rises up a gentle slope to meet the staircase and spreads around to a garden in the back.

            “The commission was a two-part deal. Design and construction, and landscape architecture.”

            Before meeting Thorin and spending so much time in studio, Bilbo hadn’t even known there was such a thing as a landscape architect. Back home, everyone tended their own gardens, planted their own trees, and if things were messy and overgrown that was just part of the aesthetic. Manicured lawns were harsh; a sprawling wildflower patch was much more welcoming. But there are people here getting degrees in what Bilbo had previously thought of, a bit derisively, as advanced gardening. Seeing the results of it now, how the landscaping works to blend Thorin’s artificial castle so seamlessly into a bare school lawn, he’s forced to revise his opinion.

            “Well, whoever they are,” he says, “they’ve done a wonderful job.”

            Thorin scowls. “He’s all right,” he says.

            “Why am I not surprised you don’t work well with others?”

            Thorin shoves at Bilbo’s shoulder, but not hard enough to make him stumble—they are on top of an unfinished tower, after all, even if it is only eight feet high. “You’re one to talk,” he says. “I never see you talking to anyone in Olin.”

            “You see me in Olin?” Bilbo asks, taken aback. “When?”

            “Elrond knows his stuff,” Thorin says, turning aside and dodging Bilbo’s question. He leads Bilbo back down into the castle’s main hall, out of the rain. “He ticks me off. The guy is really— If you met him, you’d see what I mean. But if I had to work with someone out of that group, I think . . . I can see why he got the contract, anyway.”

            “I’m sure the school’s pleased.”

            “They can’t pay much, but it covers materials, and a little extra. It’s more of a charity thing. Work experience for us—which is a laugh, because we work all the fucking time in studio—and gets the school’s name out into the community in a good way, plus the local kids get something slightly more entertaining than your standard jungle gym.”

            “Which isn’t even a jungle,” Bilbo points out. “In any way, shape, or form.”

            Thorin’s smile returns. “It’s because Elrond has a daughter,” he says after a quiet minute or so of standing in the rain. “She’s not a student here, they’re too posh for that. Goes to that hippy-leftover alternative community school where they don’t believe in grades and everyone’s a vegan or some such bullshit.”

            “How awful,” Bilbo jokes, mostly. He could never be vegan. He enjoys desserts far too much to accept substitutions.

            “Elrond’s a dick,” Thorin says. “Walks around with his head held high”—You do that too, Bilbo wants to point out, but he holds his tongue—“He’s old money, you know, and everyone can tell. His clothes, the way he speaks. Your lot would love him, it’s like looking at someone out of Shakespeare. But he’s good at what he does, and he’s got a cute kid. Smart. A little bit of a brat. Six or seven, I think, and talks back to him already.”

            “Which you approve of, naturally.”

            “Of course,” Thorin says. “She planted those flower beds under the front windows.” There’s a softness in Thorin’s face as he speaks, a look Bilbo sees far too rarely. He thinks back to the photo album he found over Christmas, to the two boys growing older page by page, all the way across the country, and Thorin out here alone without his family.

            “I’m glad you took this job,” he says.

            “I needed the money,” Thorin says, bluntly. As if that’s all it was. Bilbo doesn’t know if it’s just because they know each other better, or if Thorin’s actually changed, that it’s now so easy to tell when the man is lying. They’re standing in the front doorway, looking out. Erebor’s come up the steps and is dripping in the entryway. Thorin takes a deep breath and then pushes off against the wall he’d been leaning on. “Anyway. I just wanted to show you. It’s not done, obviously, but I can’t work with concrete in this weather. And then I thought we could go for a drive but honestly, I’m fucking exhausted. I’ve been in studio since last night. Mid-term projects are due on Friday.”

            Bilbo wonders where this new self-preservation instinct has come from, to keep Thorin from driving. Wonders if it has anything to do with their talk a week or so ago, with Thorin’s insistence that Bilbo phone him next time. “When you say things like that, it makes me— I don’t know what to do,” he’d said, and Bilbo can still feel the ache in his arm now. He doesn’t know what to do either.

            Thorin’s standing by the driver’s side door, stretching. “Get over here,” he says, tilting his neck, beckoning. Bilbo goes. “You know how to drive, right?”

            “No,” Bilbo says.

            “No time like the present to learn. Get in.”

            “Thorin, that is really not a good idea.”

            “Oh, come on. I’m bored, God, Bilbo, I am so fucking bored with mid-term projects. I will go insane if I go back there. Let’s just drive around for a bit.”

            “I don’t know how.”

            “I’ll talk you through it.”

            “You’re exhausted.”

            “I can still talk,” Thorin says, and continues to prove it. He opens the door for Bilbo. Erebor climbs in while Bilbo tries to make up his mind. “Go on, there’s no one around.”

            Bilbo wavers. His own self-preservation instinct hasn’t quite kicked in yet. He’s starting to doubt, hanging around with Thorin, if it ever will. Maybe it is a compromise—what Thorin gives up, he takes in, all that reckless energy siphoned off, building up with every minute they spend together.

            Bilbo sits in the driver’s seat and is immediately struck by how far he is from the wheel, by how much longer Thorin’s legs are than his, how much more space the man takes up. Thorin gets into the passenger seat, his knees knocking against the dashboard until he reaches down between his feet and pulls the bar to slide the seat back. Bilbo does the same, tugging forward. Thorin slides out of his frame of vision.

            “Keys,” Thorin says. They’re still in the ignition. Bilbo starts the car and wills his hands not to tremble. “Don’t worry about it. Driving is easy. Being on the road is one of the easiest things in the world,” Thorin says. Bilbo looks over and sees that his eyes are closed, his head leaning against the window. “Right foot on the brake, put it into reverse,” Thorin tells him, his voice a low counterpoint against the soft rain drumming on the windshield. Bilbo does as he’s told, pulling the gearshift back to R.

            Theoretically, he knows how to drive. This is just practical application of theoretical skills. And basically, fundamentally, that’s all life ever is. Bilbo backs out of the parking space and Thorin coaches him on down the road, winding through the back hills of the Heights, his eyes closed the whole time. He only opens them once, to reach out and hit the stereo. Music floods the car, all synthesizers and tight drums, high and light. Bilbo finds himself smiling again without really knowing why. Just beside him, if he takes his eyes off the road for a second, as long as he dares, he can see Thorin smiling too, ear to ear. It might be the first time he’s ever seen that. It’s kind of wonderful. Bilbo wants to just hang on to that image. Keep it forever.

           

            Home is where I want to be, pick me up and turn me round.

            I feel numb, born with a weak heart; I guess I must be having fun.

            The less we say about it the better; we make it up as we go along.

            Feet on the ground, head in the sky, it’s okay, I know nothing’s wrong, nothing . . .

           

Notes:

So this was stupidly hard to write and I don't know why. I still feel like the dialogue isn't quite right but every time I change it I like it less so . . . here you go? I'm sorry. It's not up to par. I just felt like I'd kept you all waiting and I wanted to give you something, and I don't have time to work on it more these next few days because I have some family visiting and also there is that looming thing called The Hobbit Big Bang which I am possibly doing, or trying to do, or something. Aaaah.

The Green Dragon café is a real place on campus. I did not invent it. There is also a dining hall-type place called Oakenshields on campus. The guys will not be going there, as that would be hard to explain away, but the fact that it exists makes me happy so I thought I'd share. March weather here is ridiculous and I am so done. Bilbo is basically me.

Elrond & Arwen really don't have much more to do with this story. I was just thinking about the playground commission (I know it's an impractical playground, hush) while I was lying in bed one night, reading Dwell magazine (their current issue's on outdoor living and landscape architecture) and I figured most of the Company & also Thranduil/Mirkwood elves would be out west around Erebor, but here in the northeast is kind of the "on the road" portion of canon, so why not add Rivendell? I don't know. This is a weird chapter. I haven't been sleeping enough so you all get less filtered thoughts. I'm sorry if it's weird. I mostly just wanted to write Thorin being a secret softie about kids. I bet he'd buy Arwen ice cream and make her a slingshot and teach her all kinds of ways to annoy her dad. And the song on the stereo at the end is possibly my all-time favourite song ever. "This Must Be the Place (Naive Melody)" by Talking Heads. I cannot even tell you how much I love that song. I would just ramble at you for pages. I promise it will cure whatever funk you might be in, if you just turn the volume up loud enough.

Next time: airplanes, airports, and Utah. It was going to happen this time, but 1) I like making you wait, apparently, and 2) I ran out of time. Have to go cook dinner for the family now. Thanks for being such fantastic readers--you guys are honestly the best audience, I couldn't even have anticipated this--and I hope you're all well!