Chapter Text
It isn’t until the second leg of the journey that it really hits him. This isn’t something he’s ever done before, and he can’t even say—not clearly, at any rate—why he’s doing it. He’s crowded into a window seat, somewhere over the plains, watching the sun play out through the clouds. It’s the first time he’s ever flown and it is, frankly, a little bit terrifying. Even so, apart from forgetting to pack a handkerchief and still having no answer from Gandalf, who stonewalled him all the way to the airport, as to what’s going to happen once he lands out west, it’s not quite as bad as he thought it would be.
Bilbo thinks he’s starting to understand why Thorin said to him, that rainy day back in March, that being on the road was one of the easiest things in the world. A year ago—a few months ago, even—he wouldn’t have agreed. But there is an ease to travelling. You can blank out your mind. Extraneous thoughts slip by and the space ahead, that wide open space, even more brilliant in flight than on the ground, just continues on. Spreads out into the corners of the world, pushes past them and out into infinity. This must have been how it felt to Columbus, Bilbo thinks; sailing off the edge of the earth, or trying to, only continuing on forever. It’s equal parts monotony and revelation, passing by the same scenery but in a new place: plus ça change, plus c'est la même chose. The clouds out his window now are not the same ones he left back at his apartment before dawn that morning, and yet they might as well be. It’s comforting, somehow, to think about that.
The fact that he’s now more comfortable out of his home than in it, and just how strange that is, isn’t lost on him. If his little attic apartment can even be called home, that is. Maybe it can’t. Over the course of this past year, he has probably spent more time, collectively, either on campus or in Thorin’s garage. “You’ve changed, Bilbo Baggins,” he mutters, glancing to the side to make sure the elderly lady sitting to his left is still asleep. It feels important, if foolish, to say the words aloud. But it takes a long time to cross the country; he hasn’t slept much in the last 30 hours. Later on, he will use this as an excuse.
Though upstate spring had just barely set in, out west summer is in full swing, heat rising off the tarmac as soon as the plane touches down. Bilbo watches the mountains on the approach, catches a glimpse of the great lake, gleaming. It may as well be another world—the moon, perhaps, dry and cracked. Salty. With his feet on foreign soil, and a stiff back, Bilbo shoulders his duffel bag and follows the crowd out of the airport in a daze, blinking back sunlight. He finds a place to stand, off to the side, and strips off his cardigan. Rolls up the sleeves of his shirt, unbuttons it at the neck. He’s tired and hungry, disoriented by how bright it is and how many people there are, never mind the fact that he’s been living in a city for the past year. His city is damp and quiet, students in a caffeinated haze and townspeople open and casual, leftovers from another time. You always read about the west as being the last great frontier, the one place left to get away from city life: that’s not accounting for airports. The mountains are miles upon miles away, hazy in the distance. If Bilbo squints across the airfields he can just make out snow-capped tips, but there is too much in the way, civilisation packed into the desert basin, everything on top of everything else and everything somehow hostile. Bilbo’s about to phone Gandalf, never mind the fact that he has no more questions left, because he is at a complete loss. Nothing looks familiar. Gritty sidewalks and dirty benches and people, absolutely everywhere. People. One of them slightly taller than the rest, and significantly less clean-shaven.
“Thorin,” Bilbo says, and it comes out more like a gasp. “Thorin,” he tries again. There in the line of cars, leaning against his battered Volvo with sunburnt arms crossed over his chest and frowning from behind dark sunglasses—it’s undeniably Thorin. Still real. Not yet fallen off the earth, and far too tan to be a ghost. “What are you doing here?”
“What do you think?”
“I— I wasn’t expecting you.” Wasn’t expecting to ever see you again. Was nearly crazy because of it. Those are just some of the things Bilbo doesn’t say.
“Yeah, I know.” Thorin looks him over. Bilbo fiddles with the strap of his duffel. “Come on, get in,” Thorin says, turning away and jerking the car door open. “We’re holding up traffic.”
Bilbo lingers, for a moment, amidst the cacophony of car horns and shouting voices and just stares. Gandalf is to blame here, almost certainly, but Bilbo can’t find it in himself to be angry. It’s partly that he’s exhausted, and partly that he’s relieved—relieved he’s not stuck in the middle of the airport on his own, yes, but more than that, just honestly relieved to see Thorin again. For someone who vanished so suddenly and completely, and was so utterly unreachable for days, he is startlingly, wonderfully solid, sprawled behind the wheel of the Volvo as if nothing ever happened. Three days, four, possibly five: that is all it has been since Thorin left, and yet it feels it’s been an age.
Thorin’s shoved the passenger door open for him so Bilbo stumbles over and climbs in, reaches back to push his duffel into the backseat as Thorin fights his way through airport traffic and out onto the highway. Thorin’s face in profile is just as strong as Bilbo remembered, though there’s a flush of sun across his cheekbones and the back of his neck now, fading to tan. Bilbo doesn’t tan—he freckles, and then he burns. He realises that he forgot to pack sunscreen, too. There’s a hole in the collar of Thorin’s t-shirt and he looks as though he hasn’t slept in about a week. Bilbo’s own exhaustion fled at the sight of Thorin, but it’s left him keyed up and anxious, too many questions. He kind of wants to reach across and put his hand on Thorin’s, clenched around the gearshift.
They leave the city behind in no time, driving north up the shore of the lake. Same scenery, new place, Bilbo thinks, and doesn’t work up the nerve to reach out but does dare to ask, “Why didn’t you say goodbye?” When he’s met with silence and a noticeably tightened jaw, he reminds Thorin, his voice tight, “You promised.”
“I left you a note.”
“A note in my mailbox. That doesn’t count, Thorin. I don’t even know when you actually left.”
“Friday,” Thorin says. Today’s Wednesday. Time has definitely slowed down.
“Friday,” Bilbo repeats. “Well, damn, Thorin. My question still stands. Why didn’t you say goodbye?”
Thorin takes a minute. Bilbo can feel the car’s vibrations; they’re surely breaking the speed limit, but he doesn’t say anything. Waits. They pull ahead of the line of traffic, road signs blurring past. Maybe the speed limit is higher out west. Thorin would like that, Bilbo thinks. Or maybe the signs are trying to tell him something—Get out now, while you can?—and Thorin doesn’t want him to able to read their messages.
“Because you were the only one who could’ve changed my mind,” Thorin says at last. “And I had to come back.”
It isn’t an apology, not even close, and Bilbo still feels he deserves one. He is still holding far too much hurt inside him, and even if he doesn’t want to place blame, it’s there sitting next to him in the car. But it’s hot and clear, the road open before them, mountains and red-brown desert flat all around, dry brush and burnt grass and wide, sparkling lake; more than anything else right now Bilbo wants to just close his eyes and breathe in deep, sand and dry wind layered over smoke and sweat. The Volvo’s air conditioning has never worked. It didn’t matter back upstate, but now they roll the windows down and Bilbo pushes his hair out of his face, holds it there with one hand against his forehead and the wind loud in his ears. The stereo is on, though he can hardly hear it. Thorin is resolutely not looking at him. Bilbo supposes he should actually be grateful that Thorin’s eyes are on the road. The speedometer inches up to eighty, passes it.
“Where’s Erebor?” Bilbo asks, shifting in his seat to put a little more distance between the two of them—not that there’s really anywhere to go in the narrow confines of the car.
“About two hours north,” Thorin says, and frowns. He chews his bottom lip for a second and then adds, “I would’ve thought you’d figured that out by now. You and your maps.”
“I meant the dog,” Bilbo says.
“. . . Oh.”
“ ‘Me and my maps’ got quite close, thank you.”
“I didn’t mean that you— Shut up. I’m not fighting with you about this.”
“I didn’t exactly find it, just . . . the general area. You do have a lot of mountains out here,” Bilbo says, glancing out the window. Not shutting up. “And a lot of wildfires.”
“Only one that matters,” Thorin says, and Bilbo wishes away the bitterness in his voice. Thorin rubs the bridge of his nose under his sunglasses. “Anyway. The dog’s at my sister’s. It’s too hot for him to be in the car for so long.”
“Is that where we’re going, then? Your sister’s place?”
“Yeah.”
Bilbo nods, whether in agreement or reassurance he’s not sure. Thorin’s sister. He’s seen her in photographs. The idea of her intimidates him. One Thorin is quite enough—another version, female, both in the same room . . . He almost doesn’t want to think about it. What on earth is he supposed to say to her? Is he meant to apologise, or to thank her, for whatever part she played in making Thorin the man he is? It would be easier, he thinks, if he didn’t feel he was being made to choose sides. He briefly considers faking sleep for the rest of the drive and just resting his head against the doorframe, breathing and listening and—yes, all right—being a coward.
“I thought—” Thorin starts, and Bilbo sits up straighter, looks away from the flat red rock outside and back to Thorin at his left, one hand loose on the steering wheel. Everything about him is outwardly careless, even more obvious now when he’s stripped of his upstate layers and bared to the western sun. It makes Bilbo’s throat go a little dry; it fills him with worry. “I thought about asking you to come,” Thorin says, the words slow to come and deep. Bilbo leans in closer to hear better over the rush of the wind. “Even though I told you I wouldn’t, that day at the lake, and after. But I didn’t think you’d say yes.”
“Thorin—”
“I didn’t want you to say yes,” Thorin amends. “This isn’t your fight.”
It’s not a fight, Bilbo wants to say; it’s a homecoming. But Thorin is already distracted—has to be, to admit something like that—and Bilbo is almost afraid that they would crash, no matter how at ease Thorin looks behind the wheel. Because this is Thorin, and he is scarily good at keeping a straight face when he wants to, Bilbo has figured that out by now. Has seen it enough that he can even tell, usually, when it’s a ruse. It’s definitely a ruse now, no questions. As Bilbo doesn’t particularly want to die in the desert, he doesn’t argue. Just says, “I know you had to come back.”
He can feel Thorin’s eyes on him now, rather than on the road. Can feel Thorin waiting for him to say more. Is he meant to apologise? Well, he’s done apologising, and besides, it’s not his turn. He reaches over and turns up the stereo instead, so loud that the speakers crack.
What do you know? This house is falling apart.
What can I say? This house is falling apart.
We got no money but we got heart;
we’re gonna rattle this ghost town.
This house is falling apart.
They drive on, past rock formations and bare, twisted trees, low scrubs of juniper and sage. There’s no one else on the road now. Thorin lets out a frustrated huff of air and turns to look ahead of them again, still accelerating. There are probably a hundred ways this scenario could have played out but didn’t: romantic airport re-encounters, running into open arms. Bilbo got a half-junked car and a stoic face, a rough-edged voice that hasn’t even called him by name yet, and there are too many things wrong with that to even think about but then, that’s always been their pattern. Why should it be any different now? Bitterness and forgiveness war in his mind, the haze of heat across the road making it hard to think. Thorin’s right hand is still clenched around the gearshift, waiting in that no-man’s-land between them.
It’s a two hour drive north to the edge of the national forest where Dís has her farm, spread out across the flat plains at the base of the Wasatch range. Bilbo takes the easy way out and stares out the window, drowns out his thoughts with the strange mix of pop and electronica coming out of the Volvo’s speakers. His skin is windblown and starting to burn by the time they pull off the highway, his cheeks tight, his eyes gritty and dry. It’s better than the alternative, he thinks, rubbing his glasses clean on his sleeve; he could be crying. He doesn’t think he could stand it if he started crying now. Thorin hasn’t so much as looked at him for the last half an hour.
The station wagon rattles up a dirt track, the undercarriage scraping along clumps of high, dry grass. Golden fields spread out before them, flat and sparse, and Bilbo wonders how anyone could make a living farming this hard land. He’s sweating through his shirt and thirsty, so thirsty, the water bottle Thorin thrust at him an hour ago obstinately unopened in his lap. They pass a couple of scattered outbuildings: whitewashed barns and a squat silo, a crooked wind pump with its metal frame rusting. Thorin slows to let a cluster of pale chickens pick their way across the dirt track and disappear into the brush. A hawk is circling overhead, lazy on the air currents, but Thorin doesn’t seem concerned. He swings the car around in front of a low farmhouse, more whitewashed wooden slat siding and a roof that slopes down low in the back, and cuts the ignition. Runs his hands along the steering wheel and leans back in his seat.
Bilbo doesn’t know what to say. The silence that swallows them up is making him feel a little sick. He pushes his door open and tumbles out onto dusty ground, leaning against the car and taking deep, slow breaths.
“Look,” Thorin says, getting out of the car, “Bilbo—”
The house’s front door bangs open and Bilbo jumps back, loses his balance and ends up in the dirt. Two young boys barrel down the porch steps and run at Thorin. Brushing himself off, Bilbo looks up to see their mother in the doorway, wearing an airy blue dress, her hair up in a knot on her head. He is suddenly as embarrassed as he has ever been, in his whole life. Thorin, on the other side of the car, has wrangled one boy under each arm and is laughing. He catches Bilbo’s eye for a moment and chokes, the sound dying out halfway from his throat. “Settle down, you little idiots,” he says, suddenly gruff, maneuvering them to the ground.
“Don’t call my children idiots,” Dís calls from the doorway, almost lazily. Looking from one to the other, Bilbo guesses that this is a conversation they’ve had plenty of times. “And come in out of the sun. Trust you to drive up here in the heat of the day.”
“I didn’t plan to,” Thorin says.
“Idiot,” Dís tosses over her shoulder, turning back into the house.
“You saw me this morning,” Thorin tells the boys, ignoring their mother. “So knock it off. Make yourselves useful and carry something.”
“You were gone for hours,” Kíli says.
“Yes, five of them. Here, take this,” Thorin says, handing the boy his rucksack. “Fíli . . . help our guest with his bags.”
“I can manage,” Bilbo stammers, finally breaking out of his daze. “Really.” But Fíli has his hands on the strap of Bilbo’s duffel and isn’t letting go; it’s easier to let the boy take it and drag it up the porch and into the house.
“She's right, you know,” Thorin says, slamming his door shut. “This is the worst time of day to be outside. You actually look a bit sick. Are you—”
“Your guest?”
“What?”
“Is that what I am now? A guest?” Bilbo swallows, tries to get some moisture in his mouth. He wishes he hadn’t been so stubborn about the water bottle. “You can’t honestly expect me to go inside that house with you without having a conversation.”
“And what exactly do you want to talk about?” Thorin asks, spreading his hands. “And can we at least do it in the shade?”
“My God, are you really that dense?”
“What, is everyone calling me an idiot today? Did I miss that memo?”
“Thorin, you left without a word—no, the note doesn’t count—and I phoned you, I don’t know how many times, and you never answered. Never called me back. You just dropped out of my life after everything and yet I was expected to just carry on, to go to classes and read for exams and I can’t— I don’t understand why.”
“I told you.”
“No, no, you do not get to use this family revenge quest as an excuse, not for everything. For leaving, yes, all right. You said you had to come back here; I understand. But Thorin, for all I knew you could have been dead.”
“. . . What?”
“I couldn’t reach you.”
“I didn’t want any distractions. I couldn’t afford distractions.”
“Oh, distraction, guest, what the hell am I meant to be, for you?” Bilbo yells across the car.
“Bilbo—”
“Because I’m tired, so very fucking tired, of not knowing where I stand. Even when we were just friends, I never really knew. Or were we friends, even, at all? And then one night we’re . . . and the next day, and weeks after, you barely even look at me!”
“I’m always looking at you,” Thorin mumbles. “You just don’t see it.”
“Then it doesn’t count!”
“Oh, for fuck’s sake.” Thorin kicks back against the side of the car and crosses his arms. Bilbo stomps around the hood to stand in front of him, a good deal shorter but making up for it with anger.
“You could have been dead, and I would not be all right with that, do you understand?” He is about two steps away from actually poking Thorin in the chest. It’s a little ridiculous, but he can’t stop. “I would not be all right. You want to come out here and play Indiana Jones, looking for relics, digging up the past, fine, and you can keep your private vendettas and your family secrets and play everything as close to the chest as you like but you— You don’t get to leave me like that, not knowing what happened, not being able to talk to you, to hear your voice ever again. I won’t do it, Thorin. I can’t. Really, actually can’t.”
“Since when do you get to decide? Who asked you?”
“Who asked you to come into my life and just . . . Thorin, you—you broke my heart.” Putting it into words like that feels stupid, not least because he’s still insisting that it’s not true, but the words come anyway, and he can’t take them back. And then, following immediately after, a sudden, horrible realisation: “Did you know?”
“Bilbo—”
“Did you know?” Bilbo repeats. He’s straining his neck to look Thorin in the eye and they are standing far too close but this is important and he’s not backing down.
Thorin holds his gaze for a long minute and then, at last, sighs, the tension bleeding out of his shoulders. He uncrosses his arms and moves as if to put them around Bilbo, stops short and shoves his hands into his pockets instead. Turns to the side and studies the wind pump, creaking forlornly across the field. “Yeah,” he says. Breathes in, out. “Yeah. I knew.”
Bilbo wants to step away, hurt and upset and definitely feeling sick now. He lets himself, just for a moment, lean into Thorin. Pressed full-length up against that solid warmth, he closes his eyes. One of Thorin’s hands comes up to rest on his back, a light touch that Bilbo shrugs off in a minute, pulling back and wiping a sleeve across his face.
“Please, just come inside,” Thorin says, his voice flat and tired, as tired as Bilbo feels.
Bilbo nods, not trusting his throat to loosen enough to let the words out, words he is longing to say. Words that have betrayed him. Words he doesn’t even recognise as belonging to him. He shoulders his satchel and follows Thorin into the house.
Dís is standing in the entryway, the boys looking slightly guilty at her side, and Bilbo is certain they witnessed the whole thing from the windows. The house is pleasantly cool, dim and clean: a couple of wooden chairs and a sagging wicker sofa in the front room, a coffee table with a vase of bright yellow flowers, lace curtains bordering the windows, turning from white to cream with age. Thorin’s garage was a mix of rigid order—the bookshelves, his workbench—and comfortable piles, things always in their place but still visible, and Bilbo had guessed that balanced neatness would run in the family. He doesn’t think there’s even a bit of dust in this house, and with two boys running around, that’s quite the feat. Two boys and a dog, he amends, as Erebor comes trotting into the entryway, sniffing Thorin absently before pressing up against Bilbo’s legs.
“Hello, you,” Bilbo chokes out, and kneels down, wraps his arms around the dog and presses his face into soft black fur. Erebor stands patiently, bearing Bilbo’s breakdown until it passes and he can straighten up and look Dís in the eye, hold out his hand and offer a proper greeting, the same way Bagginses have for hundreds of years. “Bilbo Baggins,” he says, “at your service. Sorry to impose on you like this.”
“Oh, stop. It’s no imposition. And we’re not exactly formal in this house,” Dís says, as she shakes his hand. “You’ll figure that out quickly. But you could teach some of those manners to my idiot brother.”
“Shut up,” Thorin says, and disappears off into the house, Bilbo’s duffel over one shoulder and his rucksack over the other.
“Ignore him. I do. One moment of formality, then: Dís Oakenshield,” she says, and ushers the boys forward, “and this is Fíli, and Kíli. Say hello to Mister Baggins, boys.”
“Hi, Mister Boggins,” Kíli says.
“Baggins,” Fíli corrects him, and then turns to Bilbo. “Hi.”
“Hello, boys,” Bilbo says, and tries not to grimace as he fakes a smile. He wants a drink of water, and someplace to sit down, in that order. “You can just call me Bilbo. Otherwise I’ll feel very old.” Kíli laughs. Bilbo suspects a swift prod from his mother keeps him from saying anything else.
“Let’s go into the kitchen,” Dís says. She’s nearly as tall as Thorin, Bilbo notices, as she shows him the way before her down the hall, poised and graceful, barefoot. “Make sure Thorin didn’t give you sunstroke. Honestly, you’d think he never lived here.”
“Has it been long since he’s been home?” Bilbo asks, gratefully accepting a glass of water and a seat at the kitchen table. He presses the glass to his forehead and slumps over in his seat.
“This’ll work better,” Dís says, and hands him a kitchen towel, wet and cool from the faucet. “Put that on the back of your neck.” Bilbo does, and nearly tears up all over again. He takes a quick drink of water to hide it. “Thorin comes back for Christmas,” Dís says. “Well, usually. Seems something kept him out east this past year.”
“Hmm.”
“It’s no use being cagey. I know almost everything there is to know about my brother, and what I don’t know, I’ll soon find out. By extension, that includes you, too. Apparently.”
Bilbo wonders if he should be worried. He thinks he probably should. Fíli and Kíli come into the kitchen at that moment and sidle up to the table, clearly curious, and save him from thinking about it any further.
“We have cows,” Kíli says. “Do you want to see? Do you like cows?”
“I do,” Bilbo says, because this, at least, is something he can talk about: farming. “I grew up very near a dairy farm, so I have seen a lot of cows in my life.”
“Ours aren’t for milk,” Kíli says.
“Oh no?”
“No. Do you still want to see? Even if you’ve seen them before?” Kíli climbs into a chair and leans across the table to study Bilbo. He and his brother are equally tanned, wearing faded blue jeans and t-shirts and no shoes. Kíli’s hair is longer than it was in the photograph Bilbo saw and he has grass-stained knees; Fíli looks a bit more like Thorin, growing into his nose. It’s a resemblance that shouldn’t be startling but still sort of is.
“Er, sure,” Bilbo says. “Did you want to do that now?”
“Not now,” Dís says firmly. “After dinner, when it cools off, you two can take Bilbo up to the pastures. Now, why don’t you go bother your uncle? Ask him when he became so insensitive, while you’re at it.”
“What’s that mean?” Kíli asks, and slides down from his chair.
“It means he’s saying things without thinking, right, Mom?” Fíli asks.
“Yes.”
“Oh,” Kíli says. “I do that sometimes; Fí says so.”
“It’s not the same for you,” Dís says. “You get a pass because you’re young.”
“Oh! Thanks, Mom,” Kíli says, and leaves the kitchen at a run, presumably headed for Thorin’s room, Fíli following after.
“Fíli,” Dís calls after her older son. He turns in the hall and sticks his head back into the kitchen, blond, tousled. “Be nice to your brother. Tell him what words mean before you call him names.”
“Yes, Mom,” Fíli says dutifully, and he too vanishes into the house.
“Now then,” Dís says, and smiles at Bilbo. “Us civilised ones can talk.”
“You frighten me,” Bilbo says—and then immediately drops his head to the table, embarrassed. “I said that aloud. I am very tired, I’m sorry, really—”
“Bilbo, please. We’re going to be good friends, you and I. Don’t worry about a thing.”
“Worry is my default mode. Your brother can tell you that.”
“My brother, as has already been established, is more than a little bit of an idiot about some very important things.”
“. . . You heard us outside.”
“I saw. It was enough. You’re very expressive with that face of yours, you know.”
Bilbo groans and doesn’t lift his head from the table. “He’s—he’s just— How on earth have you put up with him for so long? I’ve only known him since September and look where that’s gotten me . . .”
“He’s my brother,” Dís says simply. “And apart from my sons, he’s all I have. So I don’t have too many options. You, on the other hand—”
“I didn’t have a choice.”
“You always have a choice, Bilbo. You either keep going, or you give up.”
And he remembers those same words in another, similar voice, hears them like an echo: Thorin’s voice, over Badiou and bagels and a resignation so deep it chills him even now. But this time it’s different. This time Dís stands and refills his water glass, rolls an orange across the table to him, and waits with a patience in her eyes that Thorin’s, the same dark clear blue, rarely ever show.
“I chose to keep going,” Bilbo says, speaking more to his orange than to Thorin’s sister. “I chose to stick around, never mind the consequences. Hah. Well, I’m minding them now.”
“You’ll be all right,” Dís tells him. “In the end.”
“Whenever that is.”
“Might be tomorrow.”
Bilbo can’t honestly say if that would be a good thing or a bad one and so he says nothing. Eats his orange, the sharp bite of citrus waking him from the daze he’s been under these past few hours. Wipes the juice from his chin with the damp kitchen towel and looks over to Dís, standing at the sink. So much is the same: the long dark hair, the strong profile, broad-shouldered and firm, but where Thorin is solid like a wall, Dís is leaner, not quite feminine in a traditional sense but striking in a way that didn’t translate into photographs.
“I’ve given you Kíli’s room,” she says. “He’s more than excited to be bunking with his brother, so don’t let that discourage you. Unless, of course, you and Thorin want to share.” She doesn’t say it like a question but the inflection is almost there, and Bilbo finds himself shaking his head. Not emphatically, nothing dramatic, just a slow, weary refusal.
“That would be a disaster, I think,” he says quietly. “I don’t have the first clue as to what to say to him right now. Actually, I don’t know if I ever did.”
“He’s taking you up to Erebor tomorrow,” Dís tells him. “Alone. Just so you know, in case you need to spend some time thinking up witty comebacks.”
“Won’t you come?”
“I’m not the one obsessed with the past, Bilbo. That family gene must have skipped me. We do all right with this life, my sons and I.” She doesn’t say anything about the boys’ father, and Bilbo doesn’t ask. “We have our home here, the barley and our cows and as much open space as anyone could want. Anyone, that is, except Thorin.”
That’s always the way it is: Thorin is the exception to each and every one of Bilbo’s rules. So far, it’s proven to be a fairly stupid decision on his part, letting someone break everything apart like that. Dís is optimistic, but no matter what she says, Bilbo is certain she doesn’t know the whole story. He lets himself be led up to a small bedroom at the back of the house and is glad to be left alone. Kíli’s bookshelf holds tidy rows of comic books and school notebooks, a couple of army men and a plastic dinosaur, a glass jar of marbles with their coloured pips shining in the sun. The top wardrobe drawer’s been left ajar and cleared out; Bilbo’s duffel is sitting on the foot of the bed. He drops it to the floor, opens the window as wide as it can go but closes the curtains to keep out the sun, and stretches out on his back on the bed, a little short even for his frame. And he doesn’t mean to, but he falls asleep.
When he wakes it’s like coming out of a dream only to find you’re still dreaming, the room unfamiliar, the skies outside darkening, two pairs of eyes watching him from the foot of the bed. “We came to see if you wanted dinner,” Kíli says, as if there’s nothing unusual about watching a strange man sleep in your bed. “Do you?”
Bilbo rubs his face blearily and sits up on the bed. He hadn’t even bothered to change his shirt before lying down and it’s stuck to his back, impossibly wrinkled. The headache-haze has lifted though, and the breeze coming in through the open window is cool. “Dinner,” he says, “right.”
“Dinner, and then cows,” Kíli nods, solemn.
“Where’s Thorin?” Bilbo asks.
“Downstairs,” Fíli says. “In the kitchen. He wanted to come in and talk to you earlier but Mom made him go walk the fences instead.” At Bilbo’s blank look, Fíli explains, “To check on the cows, look for coyotes, that sort of thing. We just repaired the southern pasture fence last month. Lost two calves.”
“I’m sorry,” Bilbo says. Fíli shrugs.
“It happens,” he says. “You get used to it.” He looks at Bilbo, surprisingly critical for a nine year old. “Are you going to stay with us?”
“What do you mean?”
“Are you going to stay, if Uncle stays?”
“I don’t know, Fíli.”
“Because he said he might stay.”
“I’m sure he will,” Bilbo says.
“But I don’t think he’s very happy,” Fíli says.
Bilbo laughs a little, even if it’s forced, as he reaches down to unlace his shoes. “No, I don’t think he is either.”
“Are you?” Kíli asks, crouching down to look up at Bilbo.
“Kíli, that’s not the sort of question you just ask people,” Fíli says, tugging his younger brother up by the sleeve. “Sorry,” he tells Bilbo. “We’ll see you in the kitchen. Okay?”
“Sure,” Bilbo says, but he’s not laughing anymore. Is he happy? Well, no. But that’s not really the issue: he’s grown sort of accustomed to being, if not unhappy, then at least not precisely happy. What matters here isn’t present happiness but future. Can he be happy? And how? Thorin is downstairs, unhappy, and still, apparently, hell-bent on revenge, however he hopes to achieve it. Bilbo is upstairs, unhappy, and still, apparently, terrible at making up his mind. Whatever impulses drove him to come out here, whatever certainty—it’s all vanished and left him dry. Fitting, for the dry country he’s landed in. Except it’s such unfamiliar territory, and so much is at stake. Bilbo stands up and goes over to the window, leans out. The juniper trees are swaying gently in the wind, carrying a sharp spice smell. The moon is high and pale against the dusk sky, birds settling in for the night and calling out sounds strange to Bilbo’s eastern ears.
“Bilbo?” Dís is calling up the stairs.
“Yes,” Bilbo says, “Yes, coming, sorry.” He pulls a clean t-shirt out of his duffel bag and peels off his button-down to change, makes an attempt at flattening his hair. “You have a choice,” he reminds himself, out loud because he needs to hear it, and heads downstairs.
They’re all sitting around the kitchen table, the Oakenshield family, proud and strong and stubborn, and for a moment Bilbo is simply frozen in the doorway before the four of them, breathless. For years to come he will see them like this, so clearly in his memory, like the sharpest photograph you could ever imagine: the dark wisps of Dís’s hair, escaped from her bun; Thorin caught between a smile and a scowl; Fíli and Kíli round-faced and bright. All looking at him, as if expecting something. Bilbo is positive he won’t be able to deliver, whatever it is, and all he can do is stand there, paralysed. Then Dís nudges a chair towards him with her foot, and the illusion is broken. “Sorry,” he says again, his breath coming quickly for no good reason. “I didn’t mean to fall asleep.”
“Don’t worry about it,” Dís tells him. “You had a long day.”
Thorin clears his throat but one glance from his sister cuts off any words he might have been about to say. Fíli looks around the table and Bilbo flinches again under the scrutiny, expecting another inquisition, but the boy surprises him with a bright smile and then passes him the bread basket. “Thanks,” Bilbo says, and winces when he hands it off to Thorin at his right. Yeah, Thorin said; Yeah, I knew. The words are burned into Bilbo’s mind, as painfully obvious as the flush of sun on his face but harder, so much harder to fix.
“I gather you’re the one I should thank for making sure this guy eats a decent meal every once in a while,” Dís says to Bilbo, gesturing at Thorin with one hand while dishing out chili with the other. Neat and efficient, the person Thorin might have been if he was a bit more put-together, or possibly just a woman. Bilbo is reminded in some small ways of his own mother—the deftness of hands, the quick tongue.
“He can actually cook,” Bilbo replies, though he’s unsure why he’s defending Thorin.
“Oh, I know. I’ll make him cook tomorrow. But he doesn’t do it reliably.”
“I am right here, you know,” Thorin says.
Dís continues, as if he hasn’t spoken, “And though some alcohol may have its origin in barley, it is not the same thing.”
“I know how to harvest barley,” Kíli announces, his mouth half-full of chili, before Thorin can protest again.
“Oh, and who showed you that?” Fíli retorts.
“Uncle!” Kíli says.
“Wrong,” Fíli says. “Me.”
Kíli swallows, takes a drink of water, and then sticks out his tongue. Bilbo, watching it all, is desperately grateful that he doesn’t have to carry on a conversation. The boys chatter on, interrogating Thorin about some project he left unfinished last time he was with them—“And that was years and years ago,” Kíli whines, even if it was only one—and Dís joins in with cutting remarks, sending the occasional conspiratorial wink to Bilbo, who doesn’t feel he deserves it. The chili is good and thick, beans and lentils and, fittingly, barley grains, with a lasting smoky heat. Rib-sticking food, his mother would have called this. Bilbo looks down into his bowl and remembers what Gandalf told him before he left, about his mother being a Took before she was a Baggins, and he makes his choice. He’s come this far, and he’s going to see it through, wherever it may lead. He’ll keep going, until there’s nowhere left to go, even if he ends up running himself into the ground. At the rate they’re going, he and Thorin, that’s looking increasingly likely.
Thorin doesn’t talk to him during dinner but the silence is buffered by the boys playing intermediaries, asking Bilbo about the books he reads and pleading for stories about their uncle. “I’m sure you know all the good ones,” Bilbo says, and dodges by talking about the farmlands of his childhood instead. After they’re done, Thorin is the first to rise. He starts cleaning up the kitchen, his back to the table, and Bilbo sinks a little as he lets himself be dragged outside by the boys, pausing only long enough to borrow a pair of muck boots. The night is clear and starlit, the air just this side of cold. Fíli and Kíli are wearing identical jackets, smaller twins to one of Thorin’s own that Bilbo recognises with a pang. They take his hands and lead him sure-footed up the dirt track and out towards the hulking shadow of a barn, Erebor keeping pace easily at their side, trotting off every now and then to sniff things. Fíli ducks inside the barn and comes back with a .22 rifle slung easily across his chest. The gun is nearly taller than he is.
“Coyotes,” he says when he notices Bilbo staring. “We already put the chickens in for the night, and they don’t usually bother with the cows, but . . .” He shrugs. “Even though the little ones are a couple of months old now, they’re still prey.”
Bilbo refrains, but only just barely, from telling Fíli how adult he seems. He suspects the boy would take it as an insult. After all, he’s had to grow up fast, no doubt, just like his mother and uncle before him. They walk on, climbing up the hill and leaving scrubland and dry grass behind for a thickening copse of aspen trees. The dog darts ahead and then comes circling back, unconcerned. No coyotes, Bilbo figures. “There’s a lake,” Kíli says, tugging at Bilbo’s hand. “But you can’t swim in it. It’s for the cows.”
“I see,” Bilbo says. That, at least, explains the sudden verdure all around them, the softness of the grass beneath their feet now. Fíli swings open a gate and they cross into the lower pasture, latching the gate securely behind them. They are upon the cows before Bilbo realises it; he walks smack into one and stumbles back. The cow goes on chewing placidly, moonlight reflecting off wide liquid eyes. “Hello, cow,” Bilbo says, and pats it hesitantly. Kíli laughs.
“Do you like them?” he asks.
“What’s not to like?” Bilbo answers. The cow is huge and quiet, bristly to the touch as he runs his hand across the ridge of its back the wrong way, from rear to front. It huffs out a breath through its nose and ambles away to join the heard. Bilbo can just make out their outlines, distinct from the pine trees beyond.
“I like it here,” Fíli says, suddenly very serious. “And I don’t want to leave.”
“Yeah,” Kíli says, nodding. “I don’t want to leave either.”
“Are you leaving?” Bilbo asks, wondering if they’ve been enlisted on this mad quest to reclaim the mountain as well.
“No,” Kíli says. “I won’t go. I’ll stay here and take care of the farm.” He has a hand on Erebor’s collar and the dog is standing stolidly by
“We’re not leaving,” Fíli says. “But I’ve seen Uncle look this way before, and every time it happens he talks about leaving. Going to the mountain. We grew up on stories of that mountain.”
“I’ve heard some of them,” Bilbo says, gently, when it doesn’t look like Fíli is going to continue.
“They’re just stories, though,” the older boy says. “It’s not going to be like that ever again. No one tells us the whole truth, but I know enough to say that I don’t want to go there. I’ve heard Mom talking, when she thinks we’re asleep. You have to tell him to stop.”
“Tell who to stop what?” Bilbo asks, even though he’s sure he already knows.
“Tell Uncle to stop making Mom sad,” Kíli says. Bilbo is almost grateful he can’t see the boy’s face; the sound of his voice, high and cracking, is bad enough.
“He doesn’t understand,” Fíli says. He puts his hands on his brother’s shoulders from behind, draws Kíli close. “He doesn’t understand that we’re happy here. I think it’s been too long since he was happy, so . . .”
“Oh, boys,” Bilbo says, and even though he doesn’t know them, even though it’s only been a few hours since they met and he’s far from a tactile person, he reaches out and puts a hand to the top of each of their heads. “I’m glad you’re happy,” he says. Kíli grabs onto his leg. “But I’m afraid I don’t know what to say to Thorin, to fix things. And to be honest, he has a lot to say to me first.”
They stay out a little longer, listening to the cows shift their hooves and breathe slow, sleepy breaths. An owl hoots somewhere out in the mountains. The lights of the house, down below, are warm and steady, the only man-made sight for miles around. As they walk back down the road, Bilbo wonders whether it would have been kinder just to pretend, to have made up some answer that would reassure the boys. But if they’re anything like their uncle, and he suspects that they are, they’re never going to want to do things the easy way.
Thorin is standing on the porch waiting for them to return. Bilbo spots him from beside the barn and his breath catches: a tall silhouette leaning against a porch post, the red glow of a cigarette between his fingers. The dog runs up to him and Thorin pats him fondly. Fíli notices Bilbo staring and pauses for a moment after locking up the barn. “When you go out to the mountain tomorrow,” he says, “you’ll figure it out.” And he nods, self-assured, in a way that crushes Bilbo a little bit to see. The boys go inside, Kíli struggling to hold back a yawn, and the dog follows, shepherding. Bilbo can hear Dís talking to her sons as they get ready for bed, her voice drifting out of the open windows. Thorin unfolds himself from the wooden post and steps into the shaft of light spilling out from the entryway.
“Nice night,” he says. Bilbo just stares. “You’re really not . . . making this easy, you know,” Thorin sighs, and scuffs at the dirt with the toe of his right boot.
“I know,” Bilbo says. “But neither are you.”
Thorin takes a drag of his cigarette and turns to blow smoke downwind. “This isn’t my home,” he says. “I’m not trying to be difficult, it just—”
“Comes naturally?”
“Happens,” Thorin corrects. “I’m not good with words. I want to show you. I need to show you. Erebor. Will you come? I need you to see, so you’ll understand.”
“I don’t think I’ll understand, Thorin.” Bilbo turns and looks out at the darkened fields, the hum of crickets loud in the air, the moon casting a pale sheen over the land. Hills, in the distance, and beyond them mountains, and somewhere in there, the mountain: Erebor. “But yes, I’ll come.”
Thorin bends, lifts one leg and puts out his cigarette on the bottom of his boot, tucking the end into his pocket. He straightens up and tilts his head back to study the sky. “Good,” he says. “That’s good,” and Bilbo hears, unspoken, just beneath those words, “Thank you.”
