Chapter Text
The last time Bilbo slept out under the stars he was fourteen, camped out next to the sycamore tree in his parents’ backyard. It was early July, just before his first year of high school, a lazy summer of days spent lounging around the house with book after book, endless pitchers of iced tea and whole baskets of fresh strawberries. “Get some fresh air, you,” his mother said, often, and waved him out of the house. Lying next to an open window and paging through dusty novels didn’t qualify, so into the garden he went. It was a wet summer, thunderheads building nearly every afternoon, the sky his favourite dark blue-grey before clearing up in the evenings. He’d lie on his back in the tall grass, watch the petunias sway on the arbor, count how long it took for a cloud to pass by. One night, he spread a tarp and brought out his quilt, set up camp for the night in the yard to watch a comet streak across the sky. Ten years have passed and that is still one of his clearest memories: damp grass beneath him, cool breeze across his face, soft glow of lights from the kitchen window, and thousands of stars dotting the sky, a canopy of pinprick lights.
The western skies are so much clearer than he ever imagined. Without any humidity, the constellations are so vivid they look almost fake. Unaccountably awake in the pre-dawn hours and sitting on a rock beside the tent, Bilbo studies the spray of white across deep black, picking out Bootes, Lyra, with Vega burning brightest—all the names his father taught him, what seems so many years ago now. Thorin is snoring softly and Bilbo tells himself he is grateful for the solitude. He doesn’t know what time it is, but it’s definitely already “tomorrow,” and that’s later than he’d like. The exhaustion that swamped him earlier has vanished. He’s restless; his heart’s beating much too fast. Wrapped up in an old fleece borrowed from Dís, dry socks and sneakers back on his feet, Bilbo hugs his knees to his chest. He knows he is only imagining it but the near-morning wind smells of more than ash, more than the dead coals of their campfire. What kind of past is this conjuring up for Thorin? What does he see, when he looks out over this bare rock?
Erebor was more than just a mine. Bilbo noticed the sign yesterday, pointing to the road winding around the leeward slope, but didn’t go to see what lay beyond. By the time the sun rises, he’s walked through thirteen empty houses, some burnt down to the foundations, some with their second stories collapsed, all of them built into the rock and looking out onto a greener land. He sits down on a bench in the entryway of the fourteenth, wipes away a layer of dust and ash from the nameplate hanging beside the doorframe. Durin, it reads.
“What are you doing here?” Thorin ducks under the lopsided entrance and stands silhouetted against the pale early light. Every inch of him is confrontational.
“Just . . . trying to understand.”
“This was my house,” Thorin says. He crosses his arms over his chest and looks at Bilbo.
“But it says—”
“I changed my name. Afterwards . . .”
“Oh,” Bilbo says. He runs his fingers over the carving. “Oh. Right.”
Thorin sighs and kicks at a cluster of weeds growing up through the cracked stone floors. “Might as well give you the tour,” he says. “Come on.”
This house is better preserved than some of the others. Bilbo was expecting to find one house largely repaired, and that one would be Thorin’s, the first of his rebuilt vision of Erebor. But this isn’t a home. It’s a memorial.
Shattered picture frames on the mantel of a fireplace that’s fallen in on itself. A kitchen with one of its walls missing, open to the rock face beyond, coated with red desert dirt. The front bedroom—“This is where I was born,” Thorin says, and won’t go past the threshold—with a massive oaken bed, cracked in half. It’s not simply that Bilbo, as a literature grad, is too used to looking for metaphors. It’s that there really are metaphors everywhere in Erebor. They’re inescapable. It’s stifling to behold.
“Why are you doing this to yourself?” Bilbo asks, when they’re standing at the other end of the house, at the foot of a staircase that’s missing half its steps. “Why do you keep coming back to this?”
“I have to. No one else will.”
“They’ve moved on, Thorin. And you should, too.”
“They’ve forgotten!” Thorin hits the banister with a fist, produces an alarming crack. “They’ve left it all behind.”
“Well, maybe they had to.”
“How could they?”
“Sometimes, when things get . . . really bad,” Bilbo says, and cringes at how inadequate his words are, “sometimes you have to forget. Or else you can’t keep going.” Why didn’t he read philosophy, or psychology? Something useful, something practical. He suspects if he quotes Tolstoy, Thorin might hit him.
Thorin rolls his eyes, his upper lip drawn into a snarl. “Oh, so you’ll you never go back to your home again?”
“It’s not mine anymore. I can’t just go walking in the front door.”
“Or maybe you don’t want it back.”
“That’s not true,” Bilbo says, shaking his head. “I do.”
“If you did, you’d fight for it,” Thorin says, and there’s that familiar bitterness again.
Bilbo’s patience runs out. “Thorin, there’s nothing I can do! Everyone else has realised it. Why haven’t you? Why can’t you?”
“I don’t know how to!” Thorin shouts, and moves as if to wrench the banister out of the ground. But while Bilbo watches, cringing, Thorin just sinks down. Deflates. “I don’t . . . know what I’m supposed to do,” he says. “I mean, fuck, Bilbo . . . What am I supposed to do? This has been—for so many years, this has been my end-game. This is what it’s all been for. If not this, then . . . what?”
“The funny thing about life,” Bilbo says, crouching down before Thorin to look him in the eye, “is that it goes on. Whether you have a direction or not. I’ve learned that, this past year.” When Thorin shakes his head, and reaches out to push Bilbo away, Bilbo presses on, saying, “No, no, it’s true. You’re the one who taught me that. Remember?”
“You don’t want to learn from me.”
“Stop it.”
“What?”
“You’re being an idiot. Again.”
“I mean it.”
“Well, then you’re a sincere idiot. Thorin, come on, you can’t seriously believe that. All the time you spent teaching me . . . it wasn’t just model-building, you know. I’m still awful at cutting foam-core in straight lines, no thanks to you. But I can do other things now. Things that I couldn’t, before. And it’s— You’re the one. The reason I can.”
“Then why can’t I do what I need to do?”
“Who says you need to?”
Thorin looks up. Bilbo has seen his eyes hundreds—thousands—of times by now but will never not be startled by how deep their blue runs. “If not me, then who?”
“Why anyone?”
Thorin doesn’t have an answer to that. He sits there at the bottom of the staircase, staring at his hands while Bilbo scuffs the toe of his sneaker in the dirt. All the years and all the mountain winds have yet to clear the smell of death from the house. It lingers on in every corner, every broken floorboard. Bilbo nudges over a loose stair riser, absently, as if all he needs to do is ruin the place enough to make Thorin see that it cannot be saved. A glint in the dust catches his eye and he squats down, picks a ring from the debris. Wrought silver with a polished white stone, glimmering. Bilbo turns it over in his fingers, rubs the soot away. He’s about to stand up when Thorin snatches the ring from his hand and the suddenness of the movement knocks Bilbo off-balance. He falls to the ground, bruising himself against the broken staircase, and looks up at Thorin in annoyance. “What the hell,” he asks, “was that about?” He stands, brushes himself off, and waits, hands on his hips, for an answer.
“Where did you get this?” Thorin asks. His voice is hushed, almost trembling. He looks as though he’s about to be ill.
“It was just there,” Bilbo points, “in the dirt.”
Thorin is holding the ring up close, running a thumb over the stone. “I didn’t think I’d ever see this again,” he says. “This stone . . .”
“Hello, are you not even going to apologise? And here I thought we were making progress. Thorin? Are you ignoring me now? Really?” Bilbo shoves against Thorin’s shoulder, trying to get him to look up. Thorin snarls and surges forward, drives Bilbo against a shuddering wall with a forearm across his throat, the ring held fast in his other fist. Eyes wide, gasping, Bilbo struggles to pry Thorin’s arm off of him. It’s hopeless, of course. Thorin has nearly a foot of height on him, and at least 20 pounds, and Bilbo can no more move Thorin than he can shift the mountain they’re standing on. Then Thorin flinches back, and looks at Bilbo, pain written so clear across his face for a moment before he turns and runs out of the house. “Wait!” Bilbo calls after him, coughing. “Wait, damn it!”
The sun is full-on blinding outside, high and clear, and Bilbo stumbles and squints as he looks for Thorin. There are so many places he could have fled to—he knows this mountain better than anyone. Bilbo runs along the road, tripping over rubble, calling out Thorin’s name. He’s not even sure he’s going the right way. The road doesn’t seem to lead anywhere; the string of houses ends, giving way to a line of fencing that’s blackened like everything else in Erebor. Bilbo comes skidding to a stop at the road’s edge, where dirt track ends abruptly in a rock slide. Bent over, hands on his knees as he tries to catch his breath, he looks around. To the left, bare rock. To the right, a narrow stairway carved into the rock, curving down. Bilbo makes his way down it carefully, keeping a hand on the mountainside to steady himself until he comes to a wide ledge, dotted by row after row of stone cairns. He stops just short of the first one.
Reaching up to wipe his watering eyes and running nose, still stinging from being thrown against the wall, Bilbo finds his hand smeared with blood. He can taste it on his lips, warm and thick, and he lifts the hem of his shirt to wipe it away. Thorin is a silhouette at the far end, standing straight and tall next to the last row of cairns. Pressing a hand to his bleeding nose, Bilbo picks his way forward. There’s a strong wind kicking up on this side of the mountain. At least they’ll have some relief, when it comes time to hike down.
“Thorin, really, what the hell?” Bilbo keeps his distance and raises his voice instead, hangs back just enough to be out of arm’s reach. “What is wrong with you?” He can taste blood in his throat and tilts his head forward, breathes through his mouth. It dawns on him that this was probably a stupid idea, running down a mountain after the guy who just tried to choke him. But then again, this whole trip has been a stupid idea from the start, so what else is new? He used to be smart, once. What happened?
Thorin turns around as Bilbo is wiping his face on his shirt again. He’s still wearing that wounded look on his face and it only gets worse. Bilbo hides his hands behind his back, but it doesn’t help. But then, he doesn’t really want to help. He has this sick urge to see what will happen, just this once, if he refuses to back down.
“I . . . I shouldn’t have . . . Sorry,” Thorin finally says, and takes a step away from the edge, closer to Bilbo. Bilbo just looks at him, waiting for more. He’s owed more, isn’t he? Thorin doesn’t seem to know how to give it. Just stands there, looking miserable. “You should keep pressure on that,” he says, gesturing vaguely at Bilbo’s face. “It’ll stop sooner that way.”
“It wouldn’t have started if you hadn’t been a complete arse back there,” Bilbo says.
“I didn’t do that!”
“Yes, you did!”
“No, I wouldn’t . . . I do know my own strength, Bilbo.”
“I doubt that.”
“It’s the altitude,” Thorin says, and steps closer, grabs Bilbo’s shoulder when he goes to back away. He takes his bandana from his pocket, folds it over to find a clean square, and presses it to Bilbo’s nose, his other hand on the back of Bilbo’s head. Tugs Bilbo close to his chest. “We climbed too quickly yesterday.”
“Still your fault,” Bilbo mumbles through the cloth. His heart’s beating so loudly, standing there so close to Thorin. “Arse. You owe me an apology. A real one,” he clarifies, because even though he can’t look up to see Thorin’s face, he’s sure Thorin is frowning in argument.
“I would never hurt you.”
“Hah,” Bilbo says, and thinks, Oh, God, here we go, and that piece inside him that started to let go last night unravels just a bit farther.
“Willingly. I would never willingly hurt you.”
“Oh, keep telling yourself that. I’m sure it helps you sleep at night. Wait, no, it doesn’t. I know because I’ve seen you.” Bilbo twists and glances up at Thorin. “I’ve been right next to you. We’ve both . . . Well. You know. You were there, too.”
Thorin gives him that wounded look again. Says, “Stop it,” and tries to tilt Bilbo’s head down again.
“No. You didn’t stop back there when I asked you to, so why should I now? I’ve let you push me around for months, and all right, maybe I needed it at first, but enough is enough, Thorin. Really.” Bilbo reaches up and forces Thorin’s hands away. Steps out of the circle of his arms and tells himself he doesn’t miss the touch. “I haven’t exactly stood up for myself before, but if I don’t do it now, then when?”
Thorin looks shocked. A small part of Bilbo relishes it. Push farther, he thinks; so far that you can’t go back, so that he’ll understand just how much this won’t work anymore. Because this has always been Bilbo’s problem: he’s not good at confrontation. He’d rather talk around the problem, or wait for others to figure things out. And that’s why he’s gotten along so well with Thorin all along, Thorin who barges ahead heedlessly, who never stops to think about consequences. They were, he thought, balancing each other out. Now he sees that the scales have never been even. It’s just that his perspective was off, this entire time.
“What is this place?” Bilbo asks, though he already knows the answer.
“A graveyard,” Thorin says.
“And who dug the graves? Piled the stones?”
“I did.”
“All of them?”
Thorin nods. He’s looking at his hands—at Bilbo’s blood on his hands. You couldn’t ask for better symbolism, Bilbo thinks, and tells himself that it doesn’t hurt at all. Tries not to picture fourteen-year-old Thorin there with a shovel, standing over his mother’s dead body. His mother looks an awful lot like Dís, in Bilbo’s mind. He swallows and still tastes the blood from his stupid nose. Everything about this is wrong, but he can’t stop. This is, after all, the end.
“You may as well dig another one,” he says. “I’ll wait, if you like.” He crosses his arms over his chest, feigning a nonchalance he doesn’t feel at all.
“What— What the fuck are you talking about?” Thorin asks.
“If you keep going like this, you’re going to kill yourself.” Bilbo stares Thorin down. “Or possibly me. I’m not sure. What do you think, Thorin?”
“. . . I think you’ve lost it.”
“Oh, wonderful, let’s attack each other’s sanity. Yes. I have plenty of ammo for that. Where shall I start?”
“Don’t—” Thorin says. “Don’t go there.”
“You haven’t left me anywhere else to go. Look at yourself! What are you even doing, here? What was the point of all of this? Did you think we’d climb the mountain and somehow everything would fix itself?”
“Nothing’s broken, damn it,” Thorin insists, and Bilbo loses his mask, has to press his hand to his mouth to hold bitter laughter in, to keep salty blood out.
“You’re so wrong,” he says. “So wrong. We can’t even have an honest conversation about this.”
“About what, exactly?”
“About anything. Thorin, I— I think I love you, but we can’t go two days without hurting each other!”
Thorin opens his mouth as if to shout back, but then closes it again. Does this several times, while Bilbo watches, holding his breath. “You’ve never hurt me,” Thorin finally says. Carefully chosen words, yes, and not the worst ones he could have chosen, but not the right ones either.
Bilbo exhales. “Please don’t lie to me,” he says. “Not after . . . everything. I don’t deserve that, and you know it.” He meant for this to be a knock-down, drag-out fight but he’s tired, light-headed, and more than anything just sad.
They end up sitting side by side on the ledge, their backs to the graves as they look out over the valley, a swath of green stretching out towards the lake. Thorin keeps looking over at Bilbo like he’s sorry, but has yet to say it. Bilbo is sorry, sorrier than he’s been since the last time he was in a graveyard, but can’t figure out what to do about it. His legs are dangling over the edge, out into open air. His nose has stopped bleeding but the evidence is all over his shirt, their hands. He wipes his palms on his jeans and spreads it a little further. “What a mess we are,” he says softly.
Thorin takes a handful of dirt and holds it out over the edge, lets it go. The updraft carries it for a bit, and then it falls. “I never thought I would see that ring again,” he says. “It was my mother’s wedding ring. When I . . . when I buried her, she was so— I was sure that she had died with it on her finger.” He pulls the ring out of his pocket. It looks so small against his fingers, his broad palms. “They didn’t have enough money when they were first married to have rings made, so my father worked the silver into a band and left the setting bare. Several years later, he was mining up north and found this stone. It’s opal. You can see nearly every colour, reflected in it somewhere.”
Bilbo hugs his knees to his chest. He saw both of his parents buried with their rings and didn’t choke anyone for it. Someone should give him a medal.
“I didn’t mean to . . . shove you. I was just surprised, and angry. After so many years, to see this again . . . It’s like a miracle. Don’t you see?”
“Dís was right,” Bilbo says. “You are really awful at apologies.”
“What do you want me to say?”
“I don’t need a history lesson, Thorin. I need your honesty, not about the past or some distant dream future but right now. You and I. You told me once that we would make this work. The way I see it . . .” Bilbo swallows, and his throat is tight. “The way I see it, we’ve tried. And we’ve failed.”
“No, no, Bilbo—”
“There’s no such thing as miracles.”
Thorin’s face hardens. “What are you saying, exactly?”
“I’m saying . . . I don’t know who you are anymore, Thorin Oakenshield. Or Durin. Whatever your name is. And I’ve been wondering if I ever really knew.”
“Don’t be ridiculous.”
Bilbo tucks his chin to his knees. “I’m being a pragmatist,” he says, and breathes out all his air, pushes until his chest feels tight. Draws a deep breath in and says, “I can’t be what you need.”
“You can. I’m sure of it. We just have to . . . adjust. Something.”
Bilbo shakes his head. “I can’t,” he says. He kind of wants to cry.
“I’m the same person I’ve always been,” Thorin says. A hard note is creeping into his voice. “Maybe it’s you who’s changed.”
“Maybe.”
Thorin doesn’t tell him to change back. Small mercies, Bilbo supposes. They hike out in the early afternoon, bump along in the pickup back to the farm. With the windows down and the dust flying, the engine humming, Bilbo can pretend that they’re not speaking because it’s too loud. The boys run out to meet them and the apprehension on Fíli’s young face hurts to look at. Bilbo pats Kíli absently on the head and bites his lip. He washed his face with water from his canteen and he’s wearing Thorin’s spare shirt. Thorin, proving that he’s still the perfect Boy Scout even when he’s being completely impossible, unrolled it from his pack and thrust it into Bilbo’s arms at the bottom of the mountain, just before the drive back. “Don’t give Dís a heart-attack,” he said.
Bilbo can tell that Thorin’s upset with him, that he’s still thinking of counter-arguments, of how to make things work. There’s that determination he always found so admirable. Thorin gives him a long, inscrutable look before going inside. Bilbo lingers in the yard, hands in his pockets. He supposes he should be grateful that Thorin didn’t just leave him there, up on the mountain, but it’s not as though being back here with him is comfortable in any way. Not at all how it used to be. God, he misses those days. Long, aimless afternoons in Thorin’s garage, lounging around on the couch or a quilt on the floor, sunlight playing through the windows, music always soft in the background and the kitchen smelling permanently of fresh-ground coffee beans. It’s pointless to think about it now. Even if he goes back to the garage, it won’t be the same. Thorin won’t be coming back with him, that much is clear.
He’s still standing there, looking off into the distance, when Dís comes up behind him and claps a hand on his shoulder. “Nice shirt,” she says, and her smile is just wicked enough to look like her brother’s, and she raises an eyebrow, teasing.
“Don’t,” Bilbo says, “Please don’t. It’s not what you think.”
“No?”
“No.”
Dís sighs and slumps a little. Her arm is still around Bilbo’s shoulders. “Well, damn,” she says. “I mean, it was sort of obvious when Thorin came in and didn’t say anything. But still, one has to hope, right?”
“I’m sorry.”
“Oh, come on, don’t say that. It’s hardly your fault my brother’s a wreck. Actually, I think you deserve a lot of credit for putting up with him for so long.”
“What happens now?” Bilbo asks. It’s not that he wants to know, or expects Dís to have an answer. He’s just feeling a little lost, in all areas, and all senses of the word.
“Your flight out is tomorrow,” Dís says. When Bilbo looks at her, surprised, she lifts her arm from his shoulder to pat his head and smiles. “You left your ticket on Kíli’s dresser. I found it yesterday.”
“You’re not . . . mad?”
“What, that you’re not staying?” Dís asks. Bilbo nods. “I trust you,” she says, “and I’m sure you have your reasons.”
“What if they’re the wrong ones?” Bilbo asks. “I . . . I feel like I’m letting you all down.”
“Then stay.”
It sounds so simple. And as much as Bilbo would like to believe that Dís is only playing devil’s advocate, it’s obvious that she genuinely wishes he would stay. Would give it another shot. And he could almost see himself staying here, waking up in the mornings with the boys to check for eggs, to walk the fences, playing in the fields with Ere, working on the farm by Thorin’s side, sweat-drenched and sore and coming in at night to ice-cold water from the well and family dinners, Thorin’s narrow single bed in the back room. But would it really be like that? Would things really work out that way? Wouldn’t they just keep on going the way they are now, talking at cross-purposes, unable to see eye-to-eye, hurting each other?
Bilbo hangs his head. “It’s all right,” Dís tells him, but really it’s not.
They head back inside to find that Thorin’s gone, left out of the back door while they were standing out front, and neither of the boys knows where he’s headed. “Well, that’s just typical,” Dís says.
“Ere’s still here,” Fíli says, “so Uncle can’t have gone that far.”
“I bet he’ll be back for dinner,” Kíli adds.
“Shouldn’t we . . . I don’t know, go look for him?” Bilbo asks.
“It’s probably for the best,” Dís says. “I kind of want to hit him right now.”
“Why, Mom?” Kíli asks.
“You saw what it’s like up there,” Fíli cuts in, talking to Bilbo. “You saw what he’s like, up there. So what do you think?”
“Er,” Bilbo says, and rubs his nose. “I think . . . you boys have the right idea. Down here.”
Fíli nods. “Yeah,” he says. “I think so, too. Come on, Kí, let’s take Ere for a walk.” The boys leave, and Bilbo suspects they’ve gone to look for Thorin anyway. But that’s left him here with Dís and no idea what to say. There are so many questions he’d like to ask her, about Erebor before the fire, about the Durin family and the brother Thorin’s mentioned only once, whether she knows anything about Azog and the enormous mystery surrounding him and his hatred for Thorin. Someone has yet to explain that one to him, but it’s just one on a long list of unknowns. Topping that list, currently, is the question of whether or not Thorin now hates him.
But what can he do? Stay out here, throw himself into an impossible project, rebuild Erebor, make it anew out of nothing and for no one, and continue living his life on someone else’s terms? Even for someone whom he loves—and he’ll admit it now, now that the words slipped out—that’s too much to ask. He has to make a life of his own, doesn’t he? He has a place to go back to, and four more years of school, and so many books yet to read. Can he really leave all that behind? For Thorin, he thinks he could. But he’s a pragmatist, yes, and even though it’s the last thing he wants to think, he cannot see anything good for either of them, should he choose to stay. They’ve proven it time and again: things go so well, until they don’t.
Dinner is a subdued affair. Fíli and Kíli come back, Erebor the dog in tow but no Thorin. The four of them in the farmhouse kitchen and try to talk about anything but the missing piece of the picture, and then Bilbo goes upstairs to shower. He’s standing there under the spray, rinsing out his bloodstained shirt and jeans, when he hears the front door open and shut. The rumble of Thorin’s voice carries through the thin walls, up the stairs. Are he and Dís fighting? No, it doesn’t sound like an argument. Heavy footsteps climb the stairs, pause outside the bathroom door while Bilbo holds his breath. After they pass, he shuts off the shower. Pulls the curtain back to look out the window at the night sky, hazy pools of yellow from the sodium lights on the barn and silo breaking up the darkness. The wind through the cedar trees sounds like something shattering even as it brings a fresh, clear scent.
Back in Kíli’s bedroom, barefoot in his pajamas, Bilbo picks up his journal. He hasn’t written anything in it in a long time. It’s not much to speak of, a battered cardboard cover on a two-ring binder, pages water-stained and wrinkled from when he dropped it in a puddle coming out of the library one night. And he always feels a little bit silly writing in it. Talking to himself. As if that would help, right? Still, he shoved it into his satchel for this trip. “I don’t know what I was thinking,” he mutters. “Coming out here.”
There’s a knock on the door, and Bilbo hastily shoves the journal under the pillow. “Yes?” he says.
“Can we talk?” Thorin asks.
“Um, sure.”
“Can we talk not through a closed door?”
Bilbo stands and straightens the covers, goes to open the door. Thorin is leaning against the frame. Their faces are very close. “Did you want to come in, then?” Bilbo asks. Thorin shakes his head.
“Not here,” he says. “Can we . . . It feels weird, talking here.”
Sighing, Bilbo runs a hand through his hair. “All right,” he says. “Where to?”
Thorin leads them down to the end of the hall and into the back bedroom. His room, with one window looking out to the mountains and the other back towards the highway. Bilbo hesitates, and then follows him inside. “Sit wherever,” Thorin says, and it feels like a test. Bilbo takes the one chair, leaving Thorin the bed. Thorin opts to pace. The room is small; every step takes him halfway across the floor.
“You’re leaving,” Thorin says. Bilbo nods. “Tomorrow.” Bilbo nods again. “How can I make you see that you have to stay?”
“How can I stay, when you never asked me to come in the first place?” Bilbo counters.
“I was wrong about that.”
“We both were.”
“No, don’t say that. You . . . I’m glad you came here. I need you here.”
“Thorin, I never meant to stay.” That’s really not true, but Bilbo wants it to be, or needs it to be—he’s not sure which. He’s made up his mind and has to believe that he’s doing the right thing. Has to remind himself that if he stays they’re only going to find new ways to go wrong. “I was always going to go back.”
“Someday, maybe.”
“Tomorrow.”
“I don’t want you to leave,” Thorin says, and comes to a stop in front of Bilbo. Leans down over him. Bilbo nearly loses his resolve.
“What about what I want?” he asks, his throat tight.
Thorin backs off. “Is that what you want?” he asks slowly. “To leave? To go back and be all alone, again?” It’s cruel, to spell it out that way. Thorin has to know that.
“Yes,” Bilbo lies. He looks up, willing Thorin to recognise how much everything has come apart inside of him. To recognise that he’s only picking the lesser of two evils, the thing that will ruin him least.
Thorin goes to sit on the bed. He puts his head in his hands. His hair’s tied back but escaping, falling into his face. Without looking up, he holds one arm out towards Bilbo. “Before you go, then,” he says, hoarse, “we have one more night.” The question is unspoken, the way it always is between them. Bilbo knows that he could say no. Could say nothing, and just walk out of the room.
He goes over, lets Thorin draw him in close. Runs his fingers through long dark hair, bows his head down until his face is hidden too. It speaks volumes, really, that neither one of them can bear to look the other in the eyes for the rest of the night.
In the morning, Bilbo says his goodbyes, to Dís and the boys and Ere. “You’ll come back to visit us, right?” Kíli asks, arms wrapped around Bilbo’s stomach. “Right?” And Bilbo says he will, and gives Fíli a long hug, trying to push encouragement and empathy and all manner of things his way. Dís kisses him on the cheek. “Don’t be a stranger, Bilbo,” she murmurs into his ear. “Take care of yourself.” When they separate, he feels as though he’s letting go of someone he’s known for so much longer than three days. Balancing on the line between determination and resignation and miserable about it, Bilbo sinks into the passenger seat of Thorin’s Volvo. The set of Thorin’s jaw and the tense lines of his shoulders as he slides in behind the steering wheel are hard to watch, and the drive south is torture. There’s nothing either of them can say—are willing to say—that will fix this. He wants, and wants, but can’t. Why? Just open your mouth and say it, he tells himself; you’re a Baggins, you have a whole long history of being good with words, so just say it.
He can’t. Of course he can’t. What do you say, when you learn that loving someone means your heart living outside of your chest, and going off to break itself? How can you possibly stop it? All he can do is take himself away, pull them apart, and hope that someday, somehow, each of them will figure out how to carry on, how to ignore all the pieces of themselves they’ve already left behind. Thorin always was carrying around a heartful of ghosts. Now Bilbo will be just another lost face, no different from any of the others. And Thorin will be all right, because he’s always all right, even when he’s destroying himself. And Bilbo will go back to the way things were, because he’s fine with being alone. Right?
They don’t listen to music on the way to the airport. It’s a small kindness. Bilbo doesn’t think he could stand anymore well-placed metaphors in his life. The more he studies Thorin, surreptitiously, the harder he has to work not to be afraid of what’s to come. Nearly everything he’s done this past year has had Thorin as its driving force. And what does he have to show for that now? An empty house he cannot hope to fill, waiting for him. A pale scar burnt into the palm of his hand. Memories, experiences, failures. If only Thorin would listen to him, if only he could get his words across, he might have something tangible, something that’s not absence in any other form. When they pull up to the curb at the airport outside the departure gates, Bilbo tries once more. “Thorin,” he says, “I wish I could make you understand.”
“Understand what?” Thorin huffs. He’s angry, a callback to the way things used to be, in the winter. Have they really gone nowhere since then, made no progress?
“That there’s so much more to it all,” Bilbo says.
“Sure means a lot, coming from you.”
“Why don’t you ever listen to me?”
“What the hell do you know about it, anyway? You were lost ever since I met you. And you’re lecturing me about appreciating the rest of the world? If you’d seen half the things I’ve seen— Forget it. You’ve made your point. We don’t work. So that’s it.” Thorin gets out of the car and slams the door.
“Oh, why are you so damn stubborn?” Bilbo mutters, fighting with his door handle. He’s sure Thorin hears him, though he gets no reaction.
“Goodbye,” Thorin tells him pointedly, his arms across his chest. Bilbo fiddles with the strap of his satchel. Shifts his footing. He’s waiting for something that won’t ever come, probably. When Thorin turns his head aside, Bilbo studies that face one last time, the strong profile of the nose, the veins sharp against his neck, eyes uncompromisingly blue. Well, Bilbo thinks, you were the one who pushed back. This is what you wanted, wasn’t it? Deal with it. He sighs, picks up his duffel, and walks away. The small part of him that’s still clinging to optimism makes him walk slowly, waiting for Thorin to call after him. He hears the car door shut and the engine sputter just as he steps into the airport.
On the plane he tries to read and ignore his seat-neighbour, a pale gangly kid who keeps staring at him. He can’t concentrate on the words on the page, but it’s a small gesture towards delaying the inevitable, coming to terms with the fact that he’s gone and made a stranger of himself, despite Dís’s warning. What’s done is done, but that doesn’t mean he has to face up to it just yet. The book smells like his attic, dusty, a little damp. Someone else’s notes are in the margins besides his own; that’s always bothered him. They’re not even particularly smart commentary. Bilbo flips the page with more force than necessary and tries to focus his gaze again. Danish philosophy is probably not the best choice of reading material for this situation. He reads another page, and shuts the book. The pale kid is still staring at him. He looks ill, actually. Bilbo shifts a little farther away. He switches planes, gets a new seat-neighbour, sleeps most of the way back. Wakes up disoriented and anxious half an hour out of Syracuse and watches the lights of the city come into view as night falls. What happens next? He still doesn’t have an answer.
