Chapter Text
Once upon a time, they lay on their backs on the roof of a rusted car, sunning themselves, and Thorin pretended that he believed in impermanence. “Perfection isn’t real,” he said, and Bilbo had been the one to argue irrationally that life should go on, exactly this way, forever. Once upon a time, their roles were swapped, and Bilbo hadn’t been afraid to disagree. Once upon a time, they had walked in the rain until they were soaked to the skin, stood on the north campus bridge and watched the river run past, and Thorin hadn’t threatened to throw him in, and they had gone back to his place together and gotten far too drunk, had woken up in the morning equally hungover and half on top of each other, Thorin’s hair still damp to the touch. The stories Bilbo tells himself on the flight back east all start the same way, in some now-distant past that feels more like a dream than a memory, even if he can swear it all happened. Once. It’s never the initial act that’s the problem—it’s the continuation. The permanence. If they could just find a way to live in a series of moments, little vignettes, like some Parisian novel, everything would be perfect. They’d wake up every morning to dew-damp grass and Erebor pawing at the door, to fresh-brewed coffee and lazy, elaborate breakfasts. Every day would be the same, only called by a different name, and it wouldn’t matter that they never made any progress because that wouldn’t be the point. You could skip a chapter, or go back and read the same one over again, and it wouldn’t matter. Nothing would matter.
Bilbo can’t even say how much he would like things not to matter right now. They do matter, of course; they matter immensely, and he’s just treading water and pretending he’s making progress towards the shore, for all the good it’s doing him. He is drowning. Sooner or later, the bottom of the ocean will catch up to him. He’s not in a Parisian novel, not in Nadja or A la recherché; he’s not some art-house kid floating by in a haze of cigarette smoke whose days are all alike and all equally unimportant. He is just someone who has missed a turn, somewhere, and now it is too late to go back.
This is why he doesn’t travel: he’s prone to overwrought metaphors, when he’s on the move.
The airport is largely deserted. Bilbo hauls himself and his bags off the plane and does not look back. If he were Orpheus, and Thorin were Eurydice—a thought which, at any other time, would be hilarious—they would have to rewrite the myth. Orpheus would leave Eurydice in the Underworld, not because he looked back when he shouldn’t have but because he never asked her to follow him in the first place. He went into Hell, and then walked out alone. Eurydice is, presumably, burning. Orpheus is back amongst the flowers.
The thought did cross Bilbo’s mind, to ask Thorin to come back East, to re-start their relationship on his terms this time. Thorin could have found work locally, Bilbo would go back to classes, would start teaching in the fall, and they would live in Balin’s house and throw dinner parties and grow vegetables in the garden. Why didn’t he just ask? Thorin would have said no, almost definitely, would probably even have laughed at him, but what really held Bilbo back was the fear that Thorin would say yes. He understands, better than Thorin gives him credit for, what it is to give up on a dream, and how much that kills you. And he doesn’t want the responsibility. Doing it to himself is one thing, but doing it to someone else . . . he just couldn’t. If Thorin wants to run himself into the ground pursuing a hopeless cause, isn’t that his choice? Who is Bilbo, to stand in his way? Isn’t it just better to minimise the casualties, to try to contain the damage, to make a strategic retreat?
He’s not an idiot. He knows he’s running away. It’s just that there are nicer ways to say it. Bilbo’s not looking forward to facing Gandalf. The old man will probably tell him all the things he doesn’t want to hear, and nothing that he does, and it will be another insufferable car ride, another hour of his life gone wrong. But when his fellow passengers disperse and Bilbo looks around, there’s no sign of his not-uncle. “Is this just a day when everything is awful?” Bilbo asks out loud. “Is that what this is?” Even if he were to call Gandalf, there’s no telling when the old man would arrive. He’s sitting there on a bench, counting the cash in his wallet and wondering how much bus fare will be, when someone says his name.
“Bilbo Baggins. You look lost.”
Glancing up, startled, Bilbo sees a tall, slim man with a dark ponytail standing before him. He’s wearing dark jeans and a t-shirt and looks about a hundred times cleaner than Bilbo feels. “Yes,” Bilbo says, and then, “no. I mean, what?”
“I said, you look lost. Are you?”
“Er, no. Sorry, do I know you?”
“We haven’t officially met, no.”
“Right. I’m just, ah, waiting for the bus, so . . .” Bilbo gathers his things and moves to stand. The man has him at a severe height disadvantage.
“There’s no need to be alarmed,” he says, and steps back, puts his hands in his pockets. “This isn’t a test, and I’m not trying to rob you. Thorin asked me to come and meet you.”
“He did?” Bilbo asks, and his stomach twists. Standing up was a bad idea.
“It was quite a shock when he called this morning, I have to say. I wasn’t expecting to ever hear from him again.” The man gives Bilbo a once-over, surely noticing the darkness beneath his eyes, the rumpled state of his clothing. Surely judging. Bilbo cringes. “I’m Elrond Peredhel. It’s good to meet you at last, officially, albeit under somewhat unusual circumstances. Is that all you have?” he asks, tilting his head towards Bilbo’s duffel. When Bilbo nods, numbly, Elrond slings the bag over his shoulder. “I’m parked just out front. Shall we?”
It’s a typical early-summer night upstate, raining and cool. Bilbo climbs into the passenger side of an old Mercedes, the only car parked along the curb. The leather seat is cracked beneath him and Elrond tells him not to worry about getting it wet. While Bilbo leans back and tries to let the rain sink in metaphorically as much as physically, Elrond steers them gently out of the airport lot and towards the highway. The stereo’s on with the volume down low, a girl singing over guitar, cello, all sorts of string instruments. There’s a stuffed rabbit in the back seat, and a couple of chapter books. Elrond doesn’t look old enough to be a father. Dís didn’t look old enough to be a mother. But there they both are. Bilbo doesn’t think he could ever raise a child. To be responsible for something like that, someone who depends on you so entirely . . . it’s actually terrifying. How does anyone do it? He’s already proven himself incapable. Elrond notices him staring at the rabbit and says, “My daughter’s. She’s six.”
“Yes, um, he said that.”
“They get on like a house on fire, very nearly literally.” Elrond smiles at Bilbo, just the smallest tilt of his lips. It’s not the kindest analogy he could have chosen. Bilbo wonders if it was deliberate. “I had to bring her by the studio one day, early on, and she wandered over to his table and made herself right at home. Glue all over her hands. Took me a week to get it out of her hair. Neither of her brothers were ever so difficult, really.”
“Brothers?” Bilbo asks.
“Yes, my sons. Twins. They’re ten. I don’t think they’ve ever met Thorin, and it seems prudent to keep it that way. Not that he’s . . . well. You probably know him nearly as well as I do, at this point.”
Bilbo sits up straighter. “Nearly?” he asks. “Nearly?” He’s offended, more than willing to argue, even if it’s a stupid point of contention, particularly with someone who’s being nice enough to drive him home. No, not home, simply back. But really, doesn’t he know Thorin better than anyone, at this point? Even if they did just part on rather bad terms. Rather terrible terms.
“How long have you known Thorin Oakenshield?” Elrond asks. The windshield wipers drag slowly back and forth, distractingly loud.
“Almost a year,” Bilbo says, exaggerating. Long enough to know that’s not his real name, he thinks. Long enough for him to rearrange my entire life.
“It will be three years this August since I met him. I’m sure that whatever’s going on between the two of you has brought a lot to light, but there are only so many revelations one year—even the most intense of years—can produce.” The road is nearly empty as they drive through the suburbs, past the discount liquor store, a string of churches and parks. “I’m not trying to deny you anything,” Elrond says, easing to a stop at a red light. “Actually, I’m glad you two met. I just want to be sure you understand where I’m coming from when I ask after him. To be honest, I’ve been worried for a while now. He’s always been difficult to get along with, but I’d thought he and I had at least reached an understanding, after working together for so long. We were, for a time, on equal footing with each other. And then he turns in his final project, hardly says a word through critique, and just walks out the door afterwards. He didn’t even come to the end-of-the-year party.”
“Not really his thing,” Bilbo says. “Parties.”
“Yes, but parties with an open bar? He’s always come before, even when he probably shouldn’t have. Don’t forget, I tried being his friend once, I know what he’s like. And I know he’s gotten several job offers recently and refused every one, much to the dismay of his advisors, who have all felt the need to tell me about it. He never collected his portfolio, and even that friend of his, MacFundin, hasn’t been around to frighten off the undergrads. Something’s going on with him. And then for him to call this morning, very early this morning, mind you, and ask me to drive up here? Thorin hates owing favours. So that tells me something of what you’re worth, to him, but nothing about what’s going on. He was very terse over the phone. Didn’t answer any of my questions.”
“What else is new?” Bilbo asks.
“What happened?”
“To him, or . . . ?”
“To him, to you. Either.”
“None of your business,” Bilbo says, and hunches into his seat.
“Humour me.”
“I’d rather not, thanks.”
“Shall I tell you my theory, then?” Elrond asks. “Just to pass the time.”
“It doesn’t matter,” Bilbo says. It doesn’t, it doesn’t.
“You know, for a while, back in our first year, I was expecting . . .” Elrond drums his fingers on the steering wheel, and turns to look at Bilbo, as if he’s trying to figure something out. “You’ve walked across the bridge to North Campus, haven’t you?”
“Yes,” Bilbo says, not following.
“You know what those fences are for, then?”
“I don’t understand.”
“But you do. Because I’m willing to bet that you’ve thought it, too.”
“I wouldn’t—”
“I didn’t mean you would,” Elrond says. “Though, I suppose you have, and I’m sorry for that. Very glad you didn’t. But I meant that you must have wondered, about Thorin, about that long walk home he used to take every night he didn’t sleep in studio. Do you know what the statistics are?”
“No, I don’t,” Bilbo says. He’s got his arms crossed over his chest, his fingers twisted into his shirt. This isn’t a conversation he ever wanted to have.
“In the last twenty-two years, twenty-nine people have jumped from that bridge and others around the city. Three years ago, the year Thorin and I first started here, we had six students kill themselves one after another. Do you really think we weren’t all intensely aware of what was going on just around the corner from the studio? That when Milstein was built the year after, with all those windows, we didn’t walk over every day and hope we wouldn’t see anyone standing there on the walkway wall? How fast do you think you can run?”
“What?”
“Fast enough to get from the third floor of Rand over to the bridge before they jump?”
“I don’t think—”
“My legs are longer than yours. And I couldn’t do it.” Elrond exhales, hard, and presses his shoulders back into the car seat. When he speaks again, his voice is softer. “I’m worried about him. And you, now. That’s all I’m trying to say.”
Bilbo fiddles with his seatbelt. His hands won’t lie still. He doesn’t want to look over at Elrond, doesn’t want to even begin to guess at what sort of expression is on the man’s face.
“There are a lot of things in the long history of Thorin Oakenshield that I won’t even pretend to know about,” Elrond continues. “Some of it he’s told me when I’ve found him drunk under a drafting table at eight in the morning. Some of it I’ve guessed, or overheard. All of it, put together, is enough that I have to ask.” He turns again to look at Bilbo, rather than the road. They are coasting down a hill, straight and fast. “Is he all right? Wherever it is that you’ve left him, whatever he’s doing, is he going to be all right?”
They reach the bottom of the hill before Bilbo can answer, and Elrond has to look away to steer them around a turn. A line of trees whips past, and then open fields. There aren’t any lights anywhere, no other cars on the road. “I don’t know,” Bilbo finally says. “I hope so. I think so.”
“That’s not exactly the answer I was looking for.”
“Sorry.”
“No, no, it’s not your fault. Not at all. Please don’t think that.”
“I think he’s where he needs to be,” Bilbo says.
“That’s a thought that could go many ways. Would you care to clarify?”
They’re nearly back to the city. The rain’s stopped. Bilbo rolls down the window, just an inch or two, and the cool air across his forehead is the best thing he’s felt all day. “I don’t know,” he says again. “I don’t have any clarity. I can promise you he’s not going to throw himself off a bridge, but only because there aren’t any bridges out there.”
“He’s resourceful,” Elrond says, grim. “During our first year, when we were doing materials tests, his structure won out against all the rest. He doesn’t need a bridge.”
“If you’re so concerned about him, why didn’t you go after him yourself? Why does it all fall on me? Why does everyone— I tried, you know, I tried my best. It wasn’t enough.”
“I’m not blaming you. You’re blaming yourself, it’s clear, and I wish you wouldn’t, but I know my saying so isn’t going to stop you. After all, we hardly know each other. All we have in common is one of the most troublesome people I’ve ever met.”
“He really is,” Bilbo murmurs.
“Thorin never trusted me enough to let me help him. After he met you—and it was fairly obvious, you know, back in October when he stopped biting the heads off anyone who walked past his table in studio—after he met you, I thought, Well, at least he’s found someone who will help him. And he was unexpectedly pleasant towards the end of term, and I thought, It’s working, whoever it is, they’ve found a way to get through to him.” Elrond laughs a little, and shakes his head. “I wasn’t expecting you, of course.”
“What’s that supposed to mean?”
“I didn’t think you were his type.”
“What, too boring? Or just too pathetic?”
“Too male, actually. Though I shouldn’t assume, particularly not in this city.” They’re at the intersection of the main road and the turn-off towards campus. Before Bilbo can make some token protest, can claim that he’s reading too much into things, Elrond starts speaking again. “Particularly not when I get the same assumptions tossed in my direction on a near-daily basis, never mind the fact that there’s no truth to them,” he says, and takes them through the lower part of campus, driving slow. Bilbo doesn’t know if he’s ready to be back. Part of him wants to—needs to—ask Elrond to just keep driving. “But it was you, of course, except now you’re sitting here next to me and Thorin’s off making us worry. Which is very inconsiderate of him, really.”
“You sound surprised,” Bilbo notes, surprised himself.
“I am. Thorin can be as rude as he pleases, but he’s never inconsiderate.”
“Hah. I guess I do know him better than you do after all. He can be extremely inconsiderate when he puts his mind to it, believe me.”
“You’re angry with him.”
“I’m furious,” Bilbo says. “At both of us.”
“I’m not here to judge you, you know. If you need to talk . . .” Elrond’s offer hangs in the air as they make the last turn, out of campus, down to Bilbo’s street.
“What does it matter?” Bilbo asks. It’s not rhetorical the way it usually is when people ask that question. He desperately needs an answer.
“It matters,” Elrond says. “You haven’t been able to say his name this entire time, whether you’ve realised it or not. You’d rather look out the window than meet my eyes, even when it’s dark and raining and there’s nothing to see out there. I don’t know everything that happened between the two of you, and you certainly don’t have to tell me, but I can guess. Whatever it was, this past year has mattered for you. It will continue to matter.”
Bilbo hadn’t realised, and can’t answer, and doesn’t want to admit it. Instead he counts down houses from the street corner and watches his approach, and glances over at the driver’s seat just to prove that he can.
“It will continue to matter,” Elrond repeats, and when he swallows the corners of his mouth press together and tighten. “Just because someone is gone doesn’t mean you stop loving them.”
“He said goodbye,” Bilbo says. “And then he left me at the airport. I don’t think it’s my love we need to question here.”
“Either way, my answer’s still the same.”
Bilbo stops himself from letting out a laugh only because he’s holding his breath. When he lets it out, slowly, all he can do is shake his head, never mind that he’s not even sure what he’s disagreeing with at this point.
“Take care of yourself, Bilbo,” Elrond tells him when they finally come to a stop in front of Bilbo’s house.
“Thanks for the ride,” Bilbo says, still looking down. Still trying to get his hands to stop toying with the seatbelt, to stop trembling when they have nothing to hold.
“Don’t thank me, thank Thorin.”
Bilbo gets his bags and stands on the sidewalk, one hand on the car door. “Thank you,” he says, quietly, carefully. Elrond sighs.
“You’re going to be fine,” he says, and the sincerity in his voice is so strong that it’s almost convincing. “You can call me, you know. Anytime, if you need anything, call me.” He opens the glove-box and takes out a notebook and a pen, tears a sheet out and writes down his phone number. Bilbo takes the paper when Elrond holds it out the window, but doesn’t even read the number before slipping it into his pocket. He already knows he won’t call. Elrond catches his eye once more—a long, unblinking, breathless minute—and then smiles at him, and drives off. Bilbo looks down the slope at his house, at faded once-white siding and crooked black shutters, and tells himself, “Welcome home,” even if it doesn’t feel like it.
Coming back to a place after being away, it always seems as though everything should be different. You’ve changed, or there’s new dust on the windowsills, or your sheets don’t smell quite right. And it is all of those things, but what’s worst is the emptiness and that hasn’t changed at all. Bilbo drops his bags by the door and goes to unlatch the windows, lets the night air blow through. Even the smallest tasks are daunting: unpacking, piling his clothing in the laundry hamper, showering. He eats a bowl of cereal sitting on the floor in his underwear and an oversized sweatshirt wearing thin at the elbows, his spoon mechanically shifting from bowl to mouth and back again. Is this what it’s going to be like now? Going through the motions? Has he, too, just regressed to the person he used to be?
There’s nothing to say, and to be the first to call is basically the same as an admission of guilt, but Bilbo can’t help reaching for his phone. It’s not in his satchel, where he usually keeps it. A quick search of the pockets of his duffel comes up empty. He digs through his hamper, turns out the pockets of his jeans—nothing. Perhaps it fell out in Elrond’s car? That doesn’t seem likely. Much more likely, Bilbo realises, his stomach sinking, is that it was stolen. His neighbour on the first leg of the flight, that pale kid that watched him from Salt Lake City to Chicago. The one with twitchy fingers. “Damn it,” Bilbo says, crumpling his dirty jeans in his hand. He throws them back into the hamper and tips his head back, breathing hard. There is a first time for everything, he has learned this year, even being robbed. “Oh, damn it, this is not what I needed.” He can feel his eyes burning from sheer frustration, from exhaustion, from trying not to cry. He is an adult, he has made the grown-up choice, what is right but not easy, and now he is on his own and he can handle it, he can, it will be fine. He’s lived without a phone for far longer than he has with, and he didn’t even pay for it in the first place, so it doesn’t matter. Never mind what Elrond said, it doesn’t matter. In fact, it’s better this way, probably.
He can’t sleep that night. Just a few days out West have set his body clock back and he stays up staring out the window until two in the morning thinking it’s only midnight, gets into bed only to stare at the ceiling instead. Cracked paint, and faint traces of spider webs. How old is this house? Thirty, forty years? It’s hardly historic, especially not for the area, but it’s old enough to have sagging floors and dark-wood trim, the rooflines of an older age. Thorin would know, could probably list off an entire inventory of architectural details that show the house’s age. Bilbo turns over, draws the sheets and thin summer blanket up to his chin, and shuts his eyes. Three o’clock comes, then four, mists rising in the street outside, and Bilbo switches on his bedside light and picks up a book he’s already read, back in an undergrad philosophy class. Four in the morning seems the right time for Kierkegaard. He hasn’t touched his own journal since leaving Dís’s house, beyond shoving it a dresser drawer, but Quidam’s diary says everything he would want to say anyway.
(March 17. Midnight.)
False alarm. Right now I have driven a hundred miles in sixteen hours, I have been nearly dead with anxiety and impatience—and for nothing. My life has been endangered in a ludicrous way—and for nothing. . . . How can a brain stand all this! This is a higher and rougher sea than is known in the Atlantic Ocean, for all the swell swings between nothing and the most dreadful of all.
Bilbo can’t claim serendipity; he’s read this before, knows what to look for. Validation—that’s what he’s seeking. Someone to put words to the way he’s feeling, to say, “Look, you are not the only one going through this.” The unfortunate thing about Kierkegaard, though, is that there is not exactly a happy ending as time passes. Bilbo flips pages, reads forward.
(April 24. Morning.)
A year ago today. I have gone astray; I am like someone who has come into a strange country where people speak another language and have other customs.
(May 27. Midnight.)
It is impossible. My edifice has collapsed.
Bilbo almost wants to tear out whole passages, mail them to Thorin heavily underlined, some sort of cryptic literary wake-up call. But he doesn’t think Thorin would understand. 19th century Danish philosophy is a bit of an obscure field, even when you know what you’re getting into.
(July 3. Midnight.)
Where shall we see each other again? In eternity. So there is certainly enough time for an understanding. Where is eternity? When does eternity begin? What language is spoken there? Or is there perhaps no speaking at all?
He stops there, because he knows what is coming only four days later. Knows, and wants to read, to push until the breaking point, but he can’t face it yet. Not tonight. He closes the book and tucks it under his pillow, closes his eyes to listen to the early morning birds instead, tries to ignore the hum of the refrigerator and the hiss of tires on rainy streets.
They tell you that things will look better in the morning. Bilbo’s morning is fog-bound, and his eyes burn when he opens them. He takes an aspirin, wipes the lenses of his glasses clear, and warms his hands over the kettle on the stove, waiting to make tea. The air is cool and damp, though it will burn off by lunchtime. Things don’t look better. They don’t look worse either, but it’s small comfort. Bilbo knows how these things go. This is just the first step of a long descent.
He falls asleep in front of his laptop that afternoon, half-heartedly reading Plato for a final paper. When he wakes up again, a crick in his neck, dry-lipped, it’s almost evening. The plant in his kitchen has died. Bilbo pinches leaves off of it as he stands there drinking a glass of water. He leaves the tap running, takes off his glasses, and ducks his head under. The shock snaps his eyes open, makes his shoulders tense. “Get it together,” he tells himself under his breath, and rubs at his hair with a kitchen towel. “Useless.” It’s been a long time since he’s slept a day away. Determined to make something of the hours he has left until he makes another mark on his calendar, Bilbo sits back at his desk and opens up his university e-mail account. There’s a conference call for papers that he’d meant to submit an abstract for, before he left. Might as well do it now, even if it won’t amount to anything. It doesn’t hit him until he’s already logged in and scrolling through his inbox that what he’s really doing is looking for a message from Thorin. There isn’t one, probably because the last thing Thorin said to him was “Goodbye.” Several days late, but that finally fulfilled the promise Bilbo had asked for: when Thorin left, he said goodbye.
When Bilbo starts to write, he hesitates, stares at the letters and numbers in the address line, at the blank subject line. He types, “Hello.” That’s not the hard part. It’s only logical that one should follow the other. What’s hard is what should come after. All night long he keeps coming back to it, adding words and deleting them, close to discarding the whole thing. By the time he finally sends it, all he’s added is a question mark: “Hello?” The body of the e-mail is blank.
Bilbo spends the next several minutes breathing far too quickly, and then shuts down his laptop. Almost immediately, he turns it back on, his fingers tripping over themselves as he logs in, pulls his e-mail account back up. There won’t be a reply; he knows this. If there is one, ever, it won’t be within the next hour. Still, he sits up most of the night waiting, pacing, doing circuits of his attic, all the way out to where his head brushes up against the rafters, waiting. He is fairly sure that he’s the textbook definition of “pathetic” at this point. Miserably self-aware, Bilbo crawls into bed and smothers himself with his pillow.
Sleeping, waking up, and sleeping again, with nothing in between to distinguish the hours except restlessness—that is, apparently, his new routine. Just after four on Sunday afternoon, the quiet in his head becomes so overwhelming that it starts to make him feel sick. He can’t even look over at his laptop, still patiently logged in to his e-mail account. Instead, Bilbo digs his old bicycle out from behind the trash bins beside the house, hauls it up the steps to the street, and coasts down the hill. Down along the river, all the way out to Cass Park, the wind is in his face and loud in his ears. The water’s all stirred up from last night’s rain and the sky is that hazy orange it gets around sunset when it can’t make up its mind, whether to rain again or not. Bilbo rides past a couple of kids on rollerblades, ducks his head under the bridge, circles around the field, dodging geese. At the dog park he stops, leans up against the fence. Every dog there is not Erebor and it hurts. He has his hand wrapped around the fence links and is staring at a fair-haired young man with a golden retriever, trying to see them in the reverse colours, when he hears a shout and feels rough, wet puppy tongue on his fingers.
“Sorry, sorry,” a girl is saying as she runs over. “He’s a little excited. It’s our first time here.” She gets a grip on her puppy’s collar and hauls him back from the fence. The puppy whines. The girl’s very pretty—tall, red-headed, freckled, maybe high school aged—and very clean. Bilbo’s sweating and wearing yesterday’s t-shirt. This is becoming another pattern, encountering people who make him acutely aware of how he continually comes up short. The girl doesn’t seem to notice, though she’s staring right at him. “Where’s your dog?” she asks.
“He’s, er, with my . . . friend,” Bilbo says, feeling the heat rise to his cheeks. Ere’s not even his dog. “Out west.” Thorin’s not even his friend.
“Want to come in?” she asks. “To the yard, I mean. We could use another fetch partner, right, pup?” The puppy is pressing his nose to the fence again. Bilbo holds a finger to it absently, breathes in and out, and then realises that the girl is still waiting for a response.
“No,” he says, straightening up. “But thanks. I should get going.”
“All right. Maybe next time!”
“Sure,” Bilbo lies, and doesn’t return her wave as he climbs back on his bicycle, doesn’t look back at the puppy still standing right up against the fence. His feet are heavy on the pedals as he heads back into town. Waiting for the light to change, Bilbo leans forward on his handlebars and makes himself a list. Things to do: get your life together. It is, granted, a short list, but there are a lot of sub-categories on there, such as buying proper groceries, doing laundry, returning long overdue library books, not thinking about Thorin, meeting with the professors on his dissertation committee, planning out the course he’ll be teaching in the fall term, paying rent, and not thinking about Thorin. The light changes. Bilbo pushes his legs into motion and crosses the highway, trying to build up a rhythm. He makes it halfway up the hill he lives on before he has to hop off and push the bicycle the rest of the way, panting, grateful that it’s still early enough in the summer that evenings are cool. The crickets are out in force, chirping unseen from every garden and hedgerow he passes. The trees in the cemetery are in full bloom. When he gets back up to his attic, Bilbo goes through his shelves and stacks all his library books by the door. Time to start checking things off the list.
On Thursday, when the sun is just about to set, the streets are quiet except for the occasional rumble of a passing bus or the kids from the house on the corner shouting across the yard as they play tag. Bilbo is sitting on a park bench across the street from the laundromat, waiting for the washing machine to finish. He’s spent too many days in the same clothes. Too many days in the same skin, too, but that’s harder to change. That requires more than five dollars in quarters and a free evening.
He kind of hates doing laundry here. When he was younger, laundry day was one of his favourite times. He’d stand behind the house with an armful of wet clothing, following his mother down the line as she pinned shirts up to dry. That memory is faded now—he can’t smell the detergent, can’t feel the sunshine warming his face, the weight of the laundry in his arms. Much clearer is the memory of doing his laundry with Thorin in the basement of Balin’s house, and hanging their things over tree branches outside while they messed around with Ere and watched the clouds go by. He doesn’t have a clothesline at his apartment. He strings things up across the shower stall instead, and watches the walls grow mould. Just last week he’d dragged in the stool from the kitchen and balanced atop it with a spray-bottle filled with bleach and a rag, scrubbing, scrubbing, trying to get the walls back to white.
There are dogs in this park, too, a puppy and an older, rangy-looking dog roaming around the green, nosing fallen flower petals. Sometimes Bilbo thinks it would be a blessing to have amnesia. Perhaps then every single thing wouldn’t remind him of what he’s trying, increasingly desperately, to forget. He’s spent the past days writing letters in his head, frustrated and isolated and swallowing back so much regret he’s lost his appetite. The laundry takes just over an hour, half to wash and half to dry; by the time he’s piling warm, clean sheets into his bag the stars are out, the moon a crescent sliver over the lake. Bilbo can’t see it from the windows of his apartment. Does it look the same, rising out over Erebor? The mountain is so far away it may a well be another planet, with different stars, a moon of its own. He’s folding socks when the line of poetry comes to him, something about “distant bodies eclipsing each other / with versions of gravity and light.” Which comes out on top? If he and Thorin are binary stars, do their orbits ever intersect? Where is their center? That’s the thing about orbits, isn’t it, that you circle and circle and never get anywhere? He’s had this thought before, almost exactly. When was that? Is he still the same person now as he was then?
Well, no. He’s not lying on his back on a couch with Thorin on top of him, for one thing, so that’s definitely not the same.
It hardly seems fair. But of course, life isn’t fair; life often doesn’t make sense and things happen to you and you have to find a way to go on. He knows all of this as well as he knows his 17th century British poets. It doesn’t help. Nothing helps. It’s almost five in the morning by the time he finally closes his eyes and the cotton blanket on his bed may as well be a boulder—it’s smothering him just the same.
And Friday passes, and the weekend goes by, and Bilbo writes a sort of terrible final paper on Hannah Arendt and storytellers and the communities they build up around them, bitter about every second of it. He can’t tell stories anymore. They repeat and repeat and amount to nothing, so he’s given up. He hates Arendt’s storytellers for being able to create meaning, for leading their communities onward towards some eventual ideal paradise or redemption or whatever word she chooses to use when he’s stuck in limbo. He hates how Arendt’s storytellers can only tell proper stories about people who have already died. That’s not exactly hopeful. He thinks he’s probably missing a lot of what the point really is, but it’s the twenty-eighth of May and this is long over-due. He doesn’t have time to think about it anymore. Running off into the blue—and the expression’s all wrong, Bilbo thinks, it’s red, it’s mountains, it’s not blue at all—after Thorin during revisions week has put him behind in more ways than one. He’s nearly there, nearly done, but the wide-open summer before him is paralysing. Three months with nothing to do but read sounds like a dream but these days he’s not at all good at being on his own. Take away even the barest structure of classes and reading group, and what does that leave him with? He has visions of himself sleeping till noon, never leaving the attic, becoming madder by the day. The coming summer should be restful. More than anything, though, it worries him. He doesn’t have a good track record with summers.
Bilbo spends the rest of Monday cleaning the attic. It doesn’t need it—he’s already dusted everything that can be dusted. Going through the motions gives him something to focus on, though, and the soreness that comes with washing the floors on his knees, the lingering ache, is just enough of a distraction when he is done, when he finally sits down and makes himself have something to eat. It’s been hours, hours upon hours; he doesn’t even know where the time went. His back is stiff, and his neck. His hands smell of lemon and pine instead of coffee and ink as he rubs tired muscles. It is not acceptable to break your own bones, Bilbo reminds himself, tracing his fingers along the ridge of his collarbone. But it’s so thin, so sharp—how hard could it be? He can remember Thorin’s fingers tracing the same path, rough and strong and always warm. Thorin, who is at least twice as strong as Bilbo, would have had no trouble. A little extra pressure, and then a crack. That’s all it would take.
But no, he’s not doing this anymore, he’s not thinking these sorts of thoughts.
Except that he is. It’s eleven minutes after three in the morning and he is sitting in front of the fan in his underwear, eating stale bread and choking on it. Marveling at the fragility of the human body. If you think about it, what are we, anyway? Skin and muscle and bones, blood and sinew. All of it so easy to destroy. The lines of his kneecaps are pale, his ankles, the turn of his wrists. His face is sunburned and peeling. From his awning window he can see the cars passing on the street, tires hissing in the rain. Lightning flickers across the sky, still far off, too far for the accompanying thunder to be heard. Bilbo presses his hands against his eyes, skin hot and damp beneath his fingertips. He would give just about anything to have someone to talk to. The only words that come, though, are poetry. Again with the poetry. He doesn’t even study poetry anymore, hasn’t properly read Eliot in years, and it is neither good conversation material nor particularly helpful, but still: “Here is a place of disaffection,” he says, voice quiet against the whirr of the fan; “Time before and time after in a dim light . . . strained time-ridden faces distracted from distraction by distraction.”
Perhaps that’s what he needs: a distraction large enough to drive him away from all of this. Washing the dishes didn’t help, nor did scrubbing the shower; his bookshelf has never been so organised, his sweaters so colour-coded, and still his thoughts keep turning to Thorin. He needs to forget about Thorin. He needs to forget about this year, these past nine months of his life. There are twenty-three, nearly twenty-four years’ worth of other moments for him to dwell on. Other people, other voices, other sets of hands to be imagining. The voice inside his head has not been entirely his own for too long—anytime he starts to do something stupid the register drops, the tone changes, suddenly he’s a smoker, telling himself off with rough, rounded vowels—and he needs to change that. Needs to become his own person again. That was the point of leaving, wasn’t it?
Trying to bury the slow, horrible thought that there was no point at all, Bilbo stands up and goes into the bathroom. Avoiding his eyes in the mirror as he brushes his teeth, he hums a made-up melody to fill the silence. He lies flat on his back in bed, on top of the sheets, so hot that he can hardly stand to have anything touching him. The fan barely stirs the air. It’s a long, quiet night.
It’s a lot of long, quiet nights. On and on and on. That’s the last bit of the Kierkegaard, that’s what he’s been avoiding.
(July 7. Morning.)
Today a year ago. Let us see. My philosophy of life was that under my reserve I concealed my melancholy. It was my pride that I was able to do that, it was my determination to keep that up with all my might. I have come to wreck. Upon what? Upon the incompatibility of individual disposition . . . What is it that confounds my life? That to me the maxim becomes meaningless: ultra posse nemo obligatur [no one is obligated beyond what he is able to do]. What is my guilt? That I have ventured upon an undertaking I could not achieve. What is my fault? That I have made a person unhappy. In what way unhappy? In possibility . . . What is my punishment? To endure this consciousness.
Even if you asked him, point-blank, why he went, he wouldn’t be able to tell you. He just wakes up one morning and decides: he’s had enough. Enough avoiding things, enough aimless hoping, enough guilt. Clearly it isn’t working. Give even the most reserved person long enough and they will come to their limit. Likewise, he has found his: four weeks and four days, two hours, twelve minutes. There are seconds in that equation too, but rather than stand around counting those Bilbo pulls on a t-shirt and a pair of jeans, digs his sneakers out of the back of the closet, and goes down to the side of the house to unlock his bicycle. The ride up to the botanical gardens is a hard one; it feels longer from his time away, looks almost unfamiliar in the high summer colours. Last time he was here, it was flooded. Now it is spectacularly verdant, nearly overwhelming in its saturation. Bilbo climbs past the oaks, coasts down past the lilacs already dropping blossoms. Walking his bicycle over the footbridge he stops for a minute and watches the water rush past below. It’s running clear clue. Soon the lake will be warm enough for swimming. Soon, he will have been here an entire year. Sometimes you don’t realise how far you’ve come because you don’t have all the pieces and you don’t want them, but time passes just the same and you grow up by virtue of growing older.
So here he is, staring down Thorin’s garage and Balin’s house—both of them his, now—and still standing, still breathing. On the other side of the bridge. He goes into the garage first, both longing for some familiarity and trying to tackle the hardest thing first. The space is just as he left it just over a month ago, except for that flannel shirt of Thorin’s that had been tossed over the reading chair. That shirt’s in Bilbo’s closet now. Thorin’s not getting it back, even if he asks for it. Bilbo throws open the kitchen window and lets a month of stale air clear out as he leans over the sink and reminds himself to do what he came here to do, which is move on.
A line from one of the songs he’d heard in Elrond’s car kept sticking in his head once he was alone again, and he’d looked it up, tracked down the girl’s entire discography. He downloaded her newest album last night and now he goes over to Thorin’s stereo and hooks up the mp3 player, puts it on. A strong beat; that is what he needs now. And it fits his mood almost exactly, right from the start.
Well, if it's better that way,
you’d be the first to say so.
Maybe I wasn't so sure,
but it doesn't matter who shot first.
It’s not about what anyone deserves.
If you should ever feel bad,
consider it a study
in just how far it is
between a hand you touch and an arm you twist.
It’s not about what was attached to it.
He walks through the garage trailing his fingers over every surface, the worn fabric of the couch, the lines of dust on the bookshelves, the scarred wood of the workbench and the cool iron of the woodstove as the album plays on and Lauren O’Connell sings about holding on, letting go, burning a house down, about losing a place that once was yours. He is standing at the foot of Thorin’s bed when she swears and he flinches—he’s turned the volume up too high. But maybe this is what he needs, these words that aren’t his own but sometimes he wishes were. The sheets on the bed are rumpled. He could almost pretend someone had slept in them just a few hours ago, had risen and climbed down that ladder to make a pot of coffee, had eaten a lazy breakfast at the kitchen table. He could almost pretend he’d been in that bed as well. Would he have an easier time sleeping if he were sleeping here? It’s possible. But he’s not sure he can bear to test that theory and have it fail. A large part of him thinks it would fail. It seems a smarter move to strip the sheets, to bundle them neatly into the hamper in the closet and shut the door. Moving on. This is what it means. It means cleaning up after the fact, picking up and putting things away and closing them off. “I want something returned to me,” he hears sung, from down beneath his feet, and thinks that his life would be a hell of a lot easier if he could give that something a name.
By the time the album runs out, the garage no longer smells like Thorin. Bilbo’s packed up a crate of books and movies, a couple of miscellaneous things he’s taking with him. He doesn’t know when he’ll come back. There doesn’t seem to be much of a reason to. He’ll do the laundry, at some point, and fold it all back up, tuck it away on the proper shelves. But not today. Today he lashes the crate to the rack on the back of his bicycle and walks over to the house. His house. He owns a house now. That is something he never expected, not after he signed away the deed to his family home, the only house he thought he’d ever have and need. Does he need this one? Wouldn’t it be easier to just carry on living in his attic, close to campus, high up and closed in and finishing things where he started them? The part of him that looks relentlessly for symbolic meaning in everything is torn between wanting to complete the pattern that way and wanting to believe that Thorin left him the keys to the house for a reason, and that there will be something inside that will help him to make sense of all of this. That will return something to him. So he unlocks the front door and steps inside.
It is only the seventh time he’s been in this house, and four of those were to do laundry and the fifth and sixth were to raid the pantry. There are so many rooms he’s never seen in the old farmhouse. He’s reminded, walking through the front hall, that Thorin’s garage was once a barn, that both it and this farmhouse were built in the early 1900s and have the history of a century behind them. Balin cleaned out his house when he left. The rooms are largely empty, some furniture and a couple of paintings on the walls, shelves mostly filled with books or curios. He must have resigned his professorship when he left, too. This does not look like a place anyone was planning on returning to. Bilbo wonders if Balin was the one who told Thorin to leave him the keys, or if the persuasion went the other way around. It’s nicer to think of Thorin being the one to make the grand gesture—to say, “Look, I’m leaving you, but at least I’m leaving you a house”—and getting the keys himself. It is finally getting easier to think of him, instead of harder and harder with each passing hour. After that first aborted e-mail attempt, Bilbo wrote back, and then again, and again, but he hasn’t received any replies. The kinder answer is that all he has is Thorin’s university address, and now that he’s graduated Thorin doesn’t have access anymore, but that’s a lot of optimism to accept. What’s simpler, what seems more obvious, is that they have nothing left to say to each other.
It’s an illusion that shatters the second the telephone rings.
The noise is so unusual it actually takes Bilbo some time to realise what it is. Whose phone sounds like that anymore? He’s scrambling down the stairs and running across the kitchen, slipping in his socks on the tile floor, to where he saw an old rotary phone on a table next to the study entrance when the ringing stops and then he feels like an idiot. Why should anyone be looking for him here? It’s far more likely that it’s simply a wrong number, or someone looking for the history professor who used to live here. Isn’t it a little too convenient, that he should be there right when someone—Thorin, it was Thorin, his mind chants, and he tells it furiously to shut up—should call?
The phone rings again, jangling and bright. Bilbo picks up the handset without thinking and says, before he can stop himself, “Hello?”
“Bilbo?”
“Oh God,” Bilbo panics, and hangs up. Thorin sounded about as shocked as he currently feels. He wants to talk to Thorin. He doesn’t want to talk to Thorin. He wants to talk to Thorin. He wants to call back, but how in the world do you redial on a rotary phone?
It rings again as he’s looking at the numbers. “Please don’t hang up,” Thorin says, the second the call connects. His breath is loud in Bilbo’s ear. “Please, Bilbo. Don’t hang up.”
“I’m here,” Bilbo says, and all of sudden he can hardly stand. The cord on the phone is long enough for him to sink to the ground and so he does, pressing the handset to his ear as he leans back against the wall.
Thorin lets out a laugh that is more breath than sound. “Do you have any idea how good it is to hear your voice?” he asks.
“Some,” Bilbo says, and can’t help the smile that spreads across his face.
“I’ve been calling you for days. Why did you never pick up?”
“This is the first time I’ve come over here.”
“No, I’ve been calling your cell, for days. Weeks. I thought . . . I thought you didn’t want to talk to me anymore.”
“Oh,” Bilbo says. He twists the cord around his fingers and watches it spring back.
“I guess you still don’t.”
“No! Oh, no, I was just . . . My cellphone was stolen on the plane. So that’s why.”
“You could have got another one, called me—”
“I don’t know your number,” Bilbo says, and wonders why the words leave a sour taste in his mouth. Then he gets it. “Hang on. Why am I on the defensive again? Why are you calling, anyway? You’re the one who said goodbye.”
“Not because I wanted to! You— I was calling to apologise.”
“Was?” Bilbo stresses.
“Am. I am calling to apologise. Bilbo, I’m sorry.”
“Specifically?”
“What?”
“What are you sorry for, specifically?”
“A lot of things. Would you like a list?”
“Yes. Actually, yes, at this point, I would like a list.”
“You’re impossible,” Thorin says. He doesn’t seem angry, though. “Really? A list?”
“Yes.”
Thorin sighs, a rush of breath into the phone that sounds a lot like static. “Well, get comfortable, because it’s a long one.”
“I’m on the floor in the kitchen of my new house,” Bilbo tells him. “About an 8 on the comfort scale, I’d say.”
“Only an 8?”
“It would be a 9 if I was in a chair, but apparently Balin doesn’t believe in cordless phones.” That earns him a laugh. Bilbo tries to squash the pride he feels at having made Thorin laugh—it’s been a long time since he’s done it, but he is here to move on, and it doesn’t matter. It doesn’t. “Go on,” he prompts Thorin, and swallows the tightness in his throat.
“Right. Yeah. Did you want it chronologically? Or in orders of magnitude?”
“Stop stalling.”
“I’m sorry for the way we left things.”
Bilbo’s quiet. He’s testing a theory. What will happen, if he simply waits?
“For the way I left things. I shouldn’t have told you that you were lost. I shouldn’t have shouted at you at the airport. I shouldn’t have made you . . . stay with me, that last night. I’m not good at saying goodbye. I wasn’t ready to let you go.”
“Is Dís standing beside you and narrating in your ear?” Bilbo has to ask, breaking his silence.
“What? No!”
“Because this is all sounding very reasonable, and not at all like the man who threw me against the wall of his childhood home and tried to choke me one of the last times I was able to look him in the eye.”
“. . . I wish you wouldn’t say it like that.”
“You’d rather I lie?”
“Look, I know I have issues with my temper, all right, I know, and I’m sorry I hurt you that day, I shouldn’t have, God, I wish I hadn’t, don’t you know that?” Thorin’s voice is ragged, deep. He sounds like he’s been smoking.
“What about all the other days? Are they on your list, too? Because they’re on mine.”
“Are we making calendars now?”
“We’re comparing lives. Or, loves, I suppose. I’ve said it to you now, at least once. You have yet to say it back.”
“You didn’t say it,” Thorin points out. “You said you’d thought it.”
“And you can’t even say the word. It’s love, Thorin, it’s not a disease, it’s not going to kill you, why don’t you just say it?”
“It could. People have died for stupider things. For worse things.”
“People. Not you.”
“Is that what you’re worried about? Obviously, I’m still alive.”
“Obviously,” Bilbo says. His words are met with a moment silence. He frowns.
“Have you been talking to Elrond?” Thorin asks, after the silence has stretched long enough, his words sharp and clearly not pleased. “About this?”
“No. I did talk to him, and it was one of the most informative car rides I’ve had in a long time, but no, I haven’t been talking to him.”
“I asked him to go and pick you up.”
“Yes, I know. What do you want, a medal?”
“A little gratitude would be nice.”
“Thorin, do you have any idea what these last weeks have been like for me? Not knowing anything about you, and doing all that I could not to think about it because the not-knowing was torture? This is the first day I’ve woken up and haven’t immediately wished I was still dreaming. Do you know what I’ve been dreaming about? You, mostly, which is almost hilarious considering that there are people I miss so much more than I could ever miss you. Take, for example, my parents. I would give anything to see them again, you know, actually anything, but it’s never going to happen. They’ve done all they can for me, and they’ve died, and you, who have not died, who could still be doing so much more, for me, for your family, for so many people, are instead so wrapped up in your fucking mountain that you can’t even be bothered to tell me you’re properly sorry?” Bilbo nearly stuffs his fist in his mouth to stop himself from talking.
“Isn’t that what I’ve been doing? Telling you I’m sorry? What more do you want me to apologise for, being born? Believe me, there are plenty of people who’d like to hear that one. I just didn’t think to put you on that list.”
“I’m not! You’ve broken my heart, and I’d let you do it over again, and I’d still be glad to have met you. Which partially goes to show you that there’s something very seriously wrong with me, but you’re not taking responsibility and I want you to be sorry for that! I want . . . I need you to be sorry for that.”
“I’m sorry I broke your heart,” Thorin says. For words that Bilbo has waited what feels like forever to hear, they hardly move him.
“I’m sure you are,” he says.
“Has all of this been my fault? Is that what you’re trying to say, Mr. ‘Conversation is a Two-Way Street’? You remember that, right? That’s rich.”
“If I put this into an architectural analogy, will you understand it better? I’m the roof. You’re the support beams. The floor is everything else, all of this, daily life, and I was doing all right down there. I wasn’t where I belonged but we were both even surfaces and I was managing. You came along and lifted me out of that. For a while it was fantastic. I saw sunlight again. Then you started leaving, bit by bit, and I had to learn to balance. Now you’ve left entirely and I’m back on the ground only this time I had to fall to get there, so I’m in pieces. Get the picture?”
“Hmmph. Your structural foundations need work.”
“This isn’t a critique session! This is my life! Your life! Have a little care in what you do, that’s all I’m asking, because yes, all right, I’m still here, I’m putting things back together, but where have you gone? What are you doing? Is there even anything that can be a roof over you at all, up on that mountain of yours?” That’s the other side of the equation, and it comes out in a rush, and Bilbo winces after he’s said it because he should be worrying about himself, not about Thorin, but he can’t help it.
“I’m not on the mountain,” Thorin says.
“Where are you?”
“I’m at the farm. Dís’s place.”
“I thought you said she wasn’t feeding you lines.”
“She’s not. She and the boys are out.”
“Have you been staying with them??”
“For a few days, yeah.”
“And before that you were, what, sleeping out under the stars?”
“I told you I was going to rebuild Erebor.”
“Stick by stick, if necessary.”
“Stone by stone,” Thorin says. Bilbo can practically picture him pacing Dís’s kitchen, those faded white curtains blowing in the early afternoon wind.
“So you’re still determined to do it.”
“I have to.”
“Why?” Bilbo asks. “No one expects you to. And you don’t have to make every choice in your life just to prove other people wrong. I mean that honestly—no one expects you to, no one is asking it of you, so why can’t you just move on?”
“You’re asking me to get over it?”
“No. You never get over it, not progressively. I’m telling you that you have to make the choice. You have to be over it. Just . . . decide to.”
“It’s not that simple.”
“Sometimes it is,” Bilbo says. He doesn’t say, “Look at me, I did it,” because it’s not quite true yet, but the sentiment is there. He hopes it gets through.
“Fuck, Bilbo, I’m telling you it’s not. I can’t— I can’t let this go.”
“I thought you wanted us to work things out. Isn’t that what you said to me?”
“Yeah, but—”
“But what you want more is commit yourself to a project that won’t work out, so that when it fails you can claim the world was against you and carry on just as you have all these years, and if you and I were to work out that would ruin your losing streak, wouldn’t it?”
“What the hell are you talking about? Where did all that come from?”
“I’ve had a lot of time, these past weeks, to think about things. A lot of time to reflect.”
“Get a better mirror,” Thorin snaps. “No, look, that’s not true at all. I wanted you to be the one to break my losing streak, not—not continue it. Which is what you’re doing.”
“It’s what we’re both doing,” Bilbo says. “It’s called self-sabotage, Thorin. It’s nothing new to me, really. I don’t know why it took me so long to give it a name. But I know what it is now, and if I can’t make you stop it—and I don’t think I can—then at least I can take myself out of the target zone.”
“I never wanted to hurt you,” Thorin says, very quietly. It is, probably, the kindest thing he could say right now. It nearly makes Bilbo cry.
“I know,” he says, rubbing at his eyes. He’s wondered that a lot, these past weeks. Thorin must have known he was doing it, admitted as much when they were standing out in front of Dís’s farm, but the bigger question, the more important question, is whether or not it was deliberate. Thorin could be lying, of course. It has to be said that he does lie about a lot of things. But this one? This one feels real.
“It just sort of . . . happened,” Thorin continues. “And I could see myself doing it, and I couldn’t stop it, and when you still stuck around I thought, Wait, maybe he doesn’t feel it, maybe we can work out, maybe this can keep going. And it turned into a habit. I’ve never been good at caring for things without tearing them to pieces. So . . . it was always going to happen to you.”
“Always?”
“Almost from the moment I saw you, actually,” Thorin says, and lets out a short laugh. “You looked so ridiculous, in that stupid sweater, rambling about literary space . . .”
“You were drunk.”
“Hungover. Clarification: I was hungover. It was fucking early on a Saturday morning, what else would I be? That, and angry. But then you smiled and, I don’t know, I couldn’t help it. I was so ready to hate you, but I couldn’t.”
“And what about now?” Bilbo asks.
“I don’t hate you, Bilbo. I’m frustrated with you.”
“Well, that makes two of us. I’m frustrated with you as well. Thorin, I’m tired. I’m tired of arguing with you, and I’m exhausted with . . . well, everything, to be honest.” Bilbo pulls his legs up to his chest. The right knee of his jeans is wearing thin. “If this is the way we’re going to leave it, that we just don’t work, then can we please just leave it? I need— I need a clean break. So that I know, and can start thinking about other things instead.”
“Instead of me?”
“Instead of you, yes. I’ve been trying, but it’s very hard.” Bilbo lays his cheek down to his knee. The threadbare denim is soft against his skin.
“What if . . . you stopped trying? What if you came back?” Thorin says, as if it were so easy. “Come back out here. We don’t have to leave it, we don’t have to argue, if you’re out here with me I swear this time—”
“What, this time it will somehow, miraculously work out? Because we’ve already ruined it, so we’ve paid our dues and now we get to start over? I don’t know if it works that way. And more than that, I can’t. I have at least four more years until I get my degree. I have to stay. I’ve worked so hard to get here. It’s the first thing I’ve been doing that’s entirely my own since my parents died. I can’t just give it up.”
“That’s it, though,” Thorin says. “Erebor is exactly the same. So you do understand why I have to do it. No one expects you to get a Ph.D., you’ve just decided that you have to do it. To prove something to yourself. Right? Well, this is my proof, Bilbo. I owe it to myself to give it everything I have, and I can’t stop until I’ve done that.”
There’s not much to say after that. They stay on the phone, just quiet breathing and background noise, the crickets in the trees outside on Bilbo’s end, a drawer opening and shutting on Thorin’s.
“So what happens four years down the line?” Bilbo finally asks, because one of them has to and it’s not likely it’s going to be Thorin, not anytime today. “Will you have enough proof by then?”
“I might,” Thorin says.
“Even if it doesn’t work out? Even if you fail?”
Thorin is quiet for a minute. Then he sighs. “I know what you want me to say. But I don’t think I can say it honestly right now.”
“Then I’d rather you didn’t say it at all.”
“That’s what I thought.”
“How well you know me,” Bilbo says, thinking of it as a joke even when it’s the truth.
“I’m sorry,” Thorin says, again. “I guess it would be easier if I didn’t.”
“Not easier,” Bilbo says. “Just . . . not the same. But we could talk ‘what ifs’ all day, and it wouldn’t change anything.” He lifts his head, straightens up. “And besides,” he says, looking up at the ceiling, at the room around him, at a house that’s now his own, “I think we’re even now.”
“We are? How?”
“I finally feel like I know you, Thorin Oakenshield.”
“Even though . . . After everything, you still want to?”
“Like I said, there’s almost definitely something wrong with me.” Bilbo laughs, and toys with the phone cord, winds it around his fingers, lets it snap back. “Almost definitely. But yes, I do.”
“So does that mean . . . Can I call you again?” Thorin asks, his words running over each other in a rush. “Here, if you move in, or . . . not here, if you get a new phone?”
“When, four years from now?”
“Yeah. Or— Or sooner, maybe.”
“Yes,” Bilbo says, and takes a deep breath. “Yes, all right.”
And so it is.
----------
