Chapter Text
In the quest for Erebor, Bilbo Baggins was a bit of a misfit.
Obviously, he was a Hobbit, while everyone else on the quest was a Dwarf. He was also a scholar, with no combat training, when even Ori had some limited knowledge in how to defend himself. He was notably smaller than the dwarves (a fact which Fíli found secretly delightful, because it was about time someone was shorter than him). He talked with his (delicate little cutesy) hands. He totally lacked a beard, which was just disturbing at first, but the dwarves had adapted. He was incredibly quiet and light on his feet (hence being a burglar). His hair was absolutely fascinating, all fluffy-soft curls, and that was just on his head (his feet were perhaps a bit . . . odd but again, as long as you weren't an elf dwarves could come to accept your physical peculiarities). Each of these differences all of the dwarves were aware of and most attempted to account for them in their day-to-day interactions with their Hobbit.
However, there were only two dwarves who were aware of one Hobbit peculiarity, and both of those dwarves served on Team Younger, one of whom cheated his way on and one of whom was currently off snogging his brother.
The fact known only to Bofur and Kíli was this: Hobbits, and therefore Bilbo, cannot swim.
And yet the Elders had produced a plan which consisted of tossing Bilbo into a stream of water and sending Thorin in to gallantly fish him out again. Unfortunately, they had not revealed the exact details of this plot in the Laying of the Bets conference, merely saying that they would orchestrate a situation in which Thorin could save someone and appear as the grand and “handsome” hero he was. If they had been more specific, one of the aforementioned Youngers, both of whom were quite fond of Bilbo, would most likely have intervened on the Hobbit’s behalf.
But Bofur and Kíli did not know about the Hobbit-dunking portion of the plan, and so the Elders proceeded with dangerous ignorance.
Despite not knowing this, the Elders had taken natural precautions:
1. All Elders, save their besotted prince, were in attendance (Balin with Thorin, Bombur with Bilbo, Oin and Dori just behind a convenient set of fluffy bushes a bit further downstream), meaning even if Thorin failed for some reason to follow through, Bilbo would be safe.
2. Even Nori was present, in case any kissing should occur; he was perched in a nearby tree.
3. Oin had ascertained that the water would not go over their Hobbit’s head.
4. Thorin was an excellent swimmer.
With these safeguards, the Elders believed Plan Save the Hobbit, King in Shining Armor would come off without a hitch.
They were. Sort of right in this assumption.
However, there were a few small snafus in their otherwise “ingenious” plan.
First, dwarves are not well-versed in plant life. In Erebor, they had grown very little, depending on the Men of Dale and some trade with the Greenwood for most of their plant-y sort of needs. The only plants they could generally recognize by sight were helpful herbs purposefully cultivated in and around the mountain. Because of this, Dori and even Oin, who perhaps might have been expected to know better, were unaware that the white blossoms poking up cheerfully from their leafy hiding place belonged to a plant called giant hogsweed, and that when they pressed forward to see better, pushing down on said plant, sap would rub off on their wrists and necks which would, within a few moments, turn into rashes. And possibly blisters.
They learned this the hard way.
“Stop banging me with your elbow-”
“I’m just scratching-”
“Scratch more quietly this isn’t a party, it’s a covert bush-”
“As if you do anything quietly-!”
“I can be quiet whenever I - ah you touched me, now I’m itching-”
“Is that a blister, is this plant on fire-?!”
And so, the Elders lost the attention and support of both Dori and Oin approximately two minutes before Bombur and Bilbo walked up the hillock.
Their next mistake was as follows: when Oin made sure that the water wasn’t too deep, he had done so while walking grumpily and carefully along in his bare feet. He didn’t take into account that someone who had been knocked into the water unexpectedly would have flailing feet and arms, so when Bilbo landed, and his little legs went wild, he couldn’t get any purchase. So he immediately went under.
“Bilbo!” Balin cried, his hands rising to his cheeks as Bilbo hit the water. “Thorin, you must save him!”
Thorin glanced at him. “It’s not very deep. I’m sure he’ll be-”
Bilbo’s head broke the surface with a mighty cough.
And disappeared again.
Which led to the final problem with the Elders’ plan: Thorin was an excellent swimmer, true. But he was also injured and wearing every piece of armor he owned. So when Bilbo disappeared, and Thorin leapt in to save him, his heavy boots slid on the slick muck at the bottom of the stream and he went down too, with a tremendous splash and a waving foot that kicked the floundering Bilbo soundly in the hindquarters.
Said kick to the bottom did at least push their hobbit up out of the water a bit, sputtering and spitting as he broke the surface.
“Thorin!” Balin snapped. “Get your feet under you before he drowns!”
“What do you think I’m doing?!” their illustrious king growled back, spitting out water and thrashing majestically. He heaved with his arms, performing a sort of flip until his feet were sinking into the mud. “Stop flailing!” he yelled at their Hobbit.
In direct opposition to this very simple and direct order, Bilbo flailed.
Wildly.
Thorin grabbed for the nearest piece of Hobbit, which happened to be the seat of his (sopping wet, abused, worn-every-day-for-months, barely holding together) trousers, and heaved.
At this point, the Elders learned that they should have considered the delicate state of Bilbo’s clothes which were, unlike the layers the dwarves wore, not really sufficient for the amount of strain they had been put through. Because as soon as Thorin got a good grip on the pants – and a touch of Hobbit flesh underneath, if his startled expression and Bilbo’s shout of watery indignation were anything to go by – and lifted Bilbo from the stream, the seam ripped, splitting the Hobbit’s trousers neatly in two across the groin.
Bilbo splashed down again with something like a squeak.
The loss of counterbalance sent Thorin reeling backwards and in a moment – he was underwater too.
Bombur and Balin exchanged a concerned look.
Bombur grabbed his nose and jumped in with a mighty splash, which was overlaid by twin splashes further downstream as Dori and Oin, desperate to fight the itching welts breaking out over their necks and wrists, leapt in the water in search of relief.
Balin walked in more sedately and grabbed Thorin’s shoulder, providing enough leverage to get the king back on his feet. “The Hobbit,” Thorin gasped, already pulling away.
Which was when Bilbo’s flailing body slammed into Dori and Oin, and they all went down in a tangle of arms, legs, and rashes.
It was about this time that Nori, overcome by a fit of giggles such as he had not experienced since his twentieth birthday, fell out of his tree and landed gracelessly in a bush.
….A fluffy bush.
In the end, Thorin did stomp forward and save their Hobbit, grabbing him about the waist and holding Bilbo against his masculine (very wet, very heavy, chain-covered) chest as he bellowed, in his best Leader of Dwarves Voice, “Stop kicking and put your feet down!”
Bilbo’s hands slipped and slid over the mail until he dug them tenaciously into the rich blue cloth and coughed water all over the king’s beard. His hazel eyes were wide and his curls were wet and he looked for all the world like an adorable terrier puppy.
Balin smiled benignly as Bombur rolled to his feet (Oin and Dori were too busy scrubbing at each other madly and only half paying attention). Yes, now Bilbo would thank Thorin, and Thorin would graciously accept, and-
“Don’t yell at me!”
Balin blinked. That was not what he had expected their Hobbit to say.
“You kicked me in the face,” Thorin said seriously, his hands firm on the Hobbit’s waist. “Thrice. When all you had to do was put your feet down and stand up. I raised my voice to get your attention.”
Bilbo glared at him, though he didn’t let go. He was hanging on so tight that his knuckles shone white. “I can’t swim,” he snarled with an intensity far beyond the anger he’d demonstrated during the great dinner battles.
Thorin stared at him. “You what?!” he demanded.
“I can’t swim!” Bilbo let go only long enough to curl his hand into a fist and pound it, once, against the king’s chest. Then he grabbed on again. “I can’t swim and you will get me out of this river this instant!!”
“It’s only a stream-” Thorin said in a voice that was almost gentle, but Bilbo was having none of it.
“This instant I said!”
And so Thorin did, with the not-at-all-helpful assistance of a horrified Balin and a remorseful Bombur, who bustled the both of them up on shore in a fashion that nearly knocked them all over again. Thorin finally snarled at them to “Stop helping!” which made Bilbo argue, “You can’t yell at them for being nice!” (bless him) and Thorin growl, “I can if we want to live!”
And then they were on dry land.
“Dwarves!” Bilbo snarled, and who knew he could even make that noise? “You can’t-you just-!” his eyes were positively sparking, and he let go with one hand to point an extremely chastising finger in Bombur’s direction. “You don’t watch what you’re doing! I have never in all my days-bebother and confusticate all dwarves! The lot of you!”
Balin opened his mouth to soothe, only to be interrupted by Nori’s yelped, “WHAT IS IN THESE BUSHES?!” which drew Balin’s attention away long enough for Thorin and Bilbo to walk (stomp) away.
“What are you doing on a quest to fight a dragon when you can’t swim?” he heard Thorin demand, but the king was sticking close to the Hobbit’s side.
“It’s not a water dragon!” Bilbo snapped, and oh. His pants were very badly torn indeed, which only emphasized the ragged state of his delicate Hobbit underwear. “Why should it even come up!”
“Because it’s a basic skill and you must learn it as soon as possible.”
“Hobbits do not swim! Perhaps next time you hire a burglar, you should learn a little something about his people!”
“Hobbits also don’t go on quests, and yet here we are,” Thorin answered, and Balin wanted to burst into applause at his king’s utterly reasonable and caring tone of voice. It was as if Thorin has transformed, for one glorious moment, from a brooding fifty-year-old to a full grown king of the mountain.
A dripping, cranky, red-necked Dori squelched to a stop beside Balin. “. . . I should probably offer to fix his trousers,” he said, rubbing vigorously at his right wrist with his left cuff.
“Probably,” Balin agreed. “He certainly can’t go into the wood like that.”
“But they are walking rather close together.” Dori glanced over at his brother, who was rolling vigorously in the grass and growling under his breath about plants and dwarves belong in a fekking mountain. “Language, Nori!” he called, and, well. Nori’s response certainly used language, of a very colorful sort.
Thorin’s hand took Bilbo’s elbow as the pair crested the small hill and disappeared down the other side. Bilbo did not shake it off.
Balin made a pleased noise.
Perhaps they had gone into this plan missing an important piece of information (rather…vital. Really). But, Balin was a dwarf, and to a dwarf, if everyone came out of the other end of the mine alive and with all their major limbs intact then, well. That was a successful mission. And no one here was missing so much as a finger.
He turned to his (very itchy, splotchy, wet, irritated) friend. “Come along,” he said in a voice rich with sympathy. “Let’s get you inside. I’m sure Beorn knows something about treating, ah . . . bush rash.”
And with that, the Elders-plus-Nori followed their king and Hobbit over the hill and into the house of their (somewhat) friendly (at least to the “bunny”) skinchanger.
