Chapter Text
Max had to go all the way to Chicago which was pretty damn stupid considering she had to go straight back to Hawkins in a few days for the trial. She’d hated leaving her friends and Billy behind. The social worker wasn’t all bad but Max remained irritated and quiet the entire ride over. She barely spoke, more focused on what she would do when she got back to Hawkins than her current situation. She had to sleep on a crap bed which was honestly worse than the one Will’s mom had set out for her, and she had to stay with kids that were dull and annoying and had absolutely no idea what the real world was like.
She ignored it all and just focused on Hawkins. At least until her case worker came to her with a proposition.
“Your mother’s driven up here. She wants to speak with you.”
Thinking about the pros and cons, Max asked, “She’s alone right? Neil Hargrove’s still in jail.”
A nod.
“Yeah, I want to see her.”
“I can come in if you—”
“No. I’m fine alone.”
“Alright, just know I’ll be outside the room at all times and all you have to do is call for me if you need anything.”
Max resisted the urge to roll her eyes at the almost patronizing tone. She was fourteen now and had dealt with demodogs. Besides, if she wanted safety and comfort, the last place she’d look for it was in this woman. With the goal of keeping things smooth here so that she could get back to Hawkins as soon as possible though, Max just nodded in understanding and went with her.
At first, her mom had filled her thoughts as Max worried about what could have happened if she’d called for her when Neil attacked. She’d worried that her mother might not have come at all. However, the pod people had put all those thoughts on hold. A small part of her still didn’t want to talk to her mom but after dealing with her second alien encounter in less than a year, her mom was the one thing she desperately wanted.
Despite the unknown and apprehension she felt, Max ran into her mother’s arms the moment she saw her. She noted the social worker closing the door behind her as she looked up at her mom.
Right away her mom tried but it was too much for Max. “I’m so-so sorry. I didn’t know! I didn’t—”
“Mom,” Max softly begged, pushing back just a little.
“What? What is it Maxine? I’m so—”
“You knew,” Max murmured. “We both did and we just stood and watched.”
She watched her mother turn speechless. “I…Maxine it was—”
“You thought he wouldn’t hurt you or me,” sighed Max. She’d thought about this, the warped logic of the whole situation and she’d talked to Billy about it too. “Billy wasn’t your son so he wasn’t your focus. He gets it. He doesn’t blame you or anything.”
Her mother took a step back, clutching her hands to her chest. “It’s-it’s not that sweetheart. Maxine, I would have…Neil knew what he was doing with Billy but with you—”
“I’d be god knows where if it wasn’t for Billy!” Max shot back. Technically that wasn’t true. There were plenty of people she could have leaned on. However, she went with the words that would deliver the best punch and went best with the story she’d given police. “I have been stuck with Billy for most of the summer and he’s been the only person I could fully trust! You can’t throw him under the bus!”
“I’m not Maxine. Of course I’m not.”
“Then don’t say he deserved it,” hissed Max. She’d known where her mother’s words were going and she couldn’t bring herself to hear those. “I don’t know what Neil told you but Billy didn’t deserve it.”
Her mom went in to try and hug her. “Maxine—”
“No!” It hurt pushing her away but Max stood her ground. She had to if only on this issue. “If you push Billy away, you’re pushing me away too.”
“What happened—”
“Is the truth,” hissed Max. At least the only truth her mom needed to know. “I know…I know at first Neil was your answer to everything that went wrong with dad but…please don’t try and make me change my statement. He hurt me and he hurt Billy. Whatever you saw in him…Billy deserves to feel safe and so do I.”
Max finished in a whisper. She was hopeful but also so damn afraid. Would her mom refuse? Would she continue to defend Neil? Would she—
“I’m sorry Maxine.”
Max looked up, noting the difference in tone. This wasn’t some flashy apology.
“I should have…I never thought he’d ever hurt you. I thought he’d be the father figure you needed.”
Several harsh comebacks came into Max’s head but she bit her tongue. “I never needed one. I just needed you.”
“And I’m here now! I wasn’t before and I’m so…so sorry Maxine. But I won’t allow you to be harmed again. I’ll never let that happen again.”
Max’s shoulders finally relaxed. “I want to come home,” she whispered.
“You will. After all this is over you will.”
Max went in and hugged her mother, eyes squeezed tight as tears of relief fell from her eyes.
Jim looked over at Jane. “You want to get your wig on?”
“Why? We know it fits.”
“Not to see if it fits,” chuckled Jim. “We’re going to support Max and Billy. We should look our best.”
“So…we’re going into town?”
“Yep.”
“Town?”
Jim’s heart both soared and broke just a little at Jane’s wide eyes. “Yes in town. With people all around us. I’ll take you to my favorite diner afterwards and I figured we might as well give the school a look since—”
He stopped as Jane rushed him, hugging him so tightly that Jim wondered if she was using her powers to do it.
“No more secrets?”
“Well, obviously if you get peeved you can’t throw a kid across the room,” Jim stressed.
“But what if—”
“No throwing kids. If you have to, punch them,” snorted Jim. “But no psychic throwing.”
Jane frowned but nodded. “Ok. And the cabin?”
“I don’t want to come home one day and find the entire school is here for a party but…no. The cabin isn’t a secret anymore.”
Jane’s smile widened. “I’ll get the wig on.”
“You do that. We leave in ten.”
Jim finished doing up his uniform, making himself a bit more presentable than normal since they were going to court. When Jane walked out, it was with her head of curls again. They were a bit too dark and not quite the same but it would work until her hair grew more.
“You ready kiddo?”
“Yes.”
Jim took her hand and walked out of the cabin with her.
“Come here Billy,” said Joyce, her tone muffled by the pins in her mouth.
Billy groaned. Will laughed and he shot the kid a glare but it wasn’t even heated. Will just smiled again, hiding it behind his hands.
“Come here,” Joyce demanded and Billy finally moved closer. Joyce stuck the pins in his hair, pulling it up into a makeshift bun that only looked slightly more acceptable. “Oh you are a mess. You’re worse than Jonathan.”
“Sorry,” murmured Billy.
“No, no. No need for that. I don’t mind fussing over you a bit,” Joyce said with a kind smile. She started to fix his tie and rumpled suit. She had to redo the knot and stood back. “How does that look?”
Billy turned to the mirror and let out a small groan. On a normal day, he would have hated dressing up like some monkey but today he focused on it, distracting himself from the inevitable reunion with his father. He didn’t think about the trial, instead pulling at his hair and trying to loosen the tie just a little. “God it’s hideous.”
Joyce turned him around and redid his tie. “I think you look like a respectable young man.”
“Like I said, hideous.”
Joyce chuckled and then tugged at his ear. “Take the earring out too. I think it’s quite fashionable but it doesn’t exactly go with the suit.”
Billy rolled his eyes and did so, throwing it on the side table. “Better?”
“Much.”
“You look like you work in an office,” laughed Will.
“Cruel kid. Cruel,” Billy replied. He looked at himself in the mirror again, let out an irritated sigh, and loosened his tie once more. Looking at Joyce, he added, “And Max and I can’t sit with you guys?”
“I’m afraid so, court procedure and all that. You’ll be with your lawyer but don’t worry, we’ll be right behind you. And my application was approved. Max should be able to come back here in a day or two.”
Billy sighed in relief at that. “Good.” He shook out his hands. “No way to put this off anymore, is there?”
“I’m afraid not sweetheart. But don’t worry, we’re all here for you. I know Nancy and Jonathan are already there.”
Billy nodded and took another deep breath. To be perfectly honest, he wasn’t ready. But then, he hadn’t been ready for the pod people and he’d made it through that, hadn’t he?
“Let’s go.”
Steve anxiously rubbed his hands. The court room was small and there certainly weren’t many people interested in the outcome but what with their entire group being there along with some more police, some of the kids’ parents, Max’s mom, the social worker, and a few randos, the place was actually packed.
Billy and Max were outside the court room with their lawyer when the defendant walked in.
In that second, Steve realized he’d never actually seen Neil Hargrove. He looked like anyone. Maybe Steve had passed him on the street and had just never paid attention. It was entirely possible. The important thing was that Neil Hargrove looked like any dad and that’s what the jury would see.
In the days leading up to the trial, he’d talked with Billy a bit more, getting a few small details from him. At one point Billy had broken, saying he was unable to go through with it, that his dad would kill him if he did. After calming down, he called his breakdown a moment of weakness. Steve wondered if it was only because he was there that Billy was able to calm down in the first place though. He reassured him it was understandable and completely alright. He was about to have to deal with his father in a way he’d never been able to. Of course the stress and anxiety of it all would get to him.
But because of that small breakdown, Steve knew more about the hospital visit. He knew about the broken ribs, the punctured and bleeding lung, the fractured skull. Only thirteen years old and he’d nearly drowned in his own blood.
Neil Hargrove, just an ordinary father as far as everyone was concerned right now and it wasn’t until the trial actually began that they would know any better.
So, in order for no sympathy to be given to Neil, Steve had to reign himself in, not launch himself over the railing, and strangle the man to death.
One glance at the kids and Nancy showed they were going through similar responses.
The sound of the doors opening had everyone’s heads spinning. Billy and Max stood frozen until their lawyer gently urged them on.
“Hey Max,” Lucas whispered as she went by.
Will waved and Billy acknowledged it with a small one right back.
The judge came in and silence fell over the room. Steve instinctively grabbed hold of Jonathan who was on his right. Out of the corner of his eye, he watched Nancy do the same thing and Jonathan simply squeezed both their hands in response.
The drive back had been long and tedious and even worse since Max had been put in a nice shirt and pants. Max hated having to dress nice but at least she wasn’t stuck in an actual dress like for her mom’s wedding or anything like that. Billy was clearly just as uncomfortable at her side and she gripped his hand under the table as opening remarks were made.
Max knew she wouldn’t be the first to speak, there was even a possibility that she wouldn’t have to speak today if the trial was put into a recess. But that didn’t make it any easier.
Neil didn’t even look at them, at least from what Max could tell. He seemed utterly comfortable, like there was no way he’d ever be put in jail. The confidence made her shiver. She wanted to believe he was too stupid to realize the level of shit he was in but at the same time…maybe he wouldn’t be charged.
All she could really do was pray and to what, she had no idea. But it was a desperate attempt that Max wasn’t above. By this point, she’d do anything to assure they’d never have to see Neil again.
She sat there as a timeline was established and the first part of character testimony began. Every moment that someone stood up for Neil, Max wanted to throw up. It didn’t matter what version of Neil they knew, even if they only saw a simple man that was being wrongly accused. It still made Max sick and she wanted to get up and run out of the room.
It was worse every time she felt Billy tense next to her though. When that happened, she knew the person standing up there was lying out their ass. All Max could do was hold onto him and avoid looking at the piece of shit that defended Neil.
Steve went that day as well. For the most part, he just told the truth and kept all mentions of the Lab and pod people out of his story. Seeing him do pretty well eased Max’s fears of when she’d have to go up there.
When the defense asked for an extension of time in order to find their own expert to examine Billy’s past injuries, Max could only close her eyes. What did it matter! From what Max could tell, any doctor with half a brain could tell the images on the old photos and x-rays hadn’t been caused by falling down some stairs. Not unless those stairs were lined with spikes and god knows what else!
But the judge gave them that time and so they went into recess before their own lawyer could call a doctor to the stage. It meant they were done at about three o’clock and Max felt exhausted. All she’d done was sit there and she’d hated every second of it.
“The court will reconvene the following Tuesday at ten o’clock.”
She had four more days of waiting just for this!? Max wanted to cry but she kept her head up high and tried to breath evenly. She’d have to go back with the damn social worker and even if Will’s mom got the ok, she probably wouldn’t be back in Hawkins until Monday.
The thought was a depressing one, especially since she’d only get a few seconds to hug everyone and tell them goodbye all over again.
When they all stood, Max could feel Billy’s hand shift to her back. He was rubbing circles into it and though the gesture was appreciated, the fact that Billy’s hands shook didn’t exactly make it as comforting as she would have liked.
They watched Neil get taken away again, the cuffs put back on his wrists. Once that was over, their lawyer gave them a few more words and pointers for when it would finally be their turn to speak before leaving.
“Max, it’s time to go,” said her social worker from the other side of the railing.
“Give her a second,” growled out Billy.
“Excuse me but—”
“I said give her a damn second,” Billy hissed.
This time the woman seemed to listen and Max rushed by her and towards her friends. Of course they asked if she could stay longer and that hurt in its own right but she pushed it down and reminded herself soon. She’d be back soon. She talked briefly with her mother, gripping her tight and her mother promising she’d be home soon, but the last hug went to Billy right before she had to go.
“Thanks sis,” Billy murmured.
“You too.”
And with that, she left with her social worker, trying and failing not to glare at her every second she got.
“Who’s this Chief? Haven’t seen her around.”
Jim smiled at the waitress and rubbed Jane’s head. “Mine. I adopted her a little while back.”
“Really? I didn’t realize you were the kid type Chief. And what’s your name?”
“Jane.”
“Well it’s very nice to meet you Jane. What can I get for you?”
“Waffles.”
“And how many?”
“Lots.”
“I think three is good for now,” chuckled Jim just as all the other kids rushed into the booth. Mike squeezed in next to Jane, pushing Jim into the corner, and Dustin, Lucas, and Will jumped on the other side.
“The usual Denise,” grinned Dustin.
“You got it kiddo. And everyone else?”
Hands shot up as they took turns. She left to start grabbing drinks as Jane looked around. “Max isn’t here.”
“She had to go back with the social worker,” sighed Mike.
“But it looks like she’ll be back and staying with us by Monday,” Will added.
“Yeah, it’s quicker than we thought,” Lucas said, relief clear in his voice.
“So Chief,” Dustin said as he caught the glass of orange juice that Denise slid towards him, “lay it on us. How’s the trial looking?”
“Good so far. People tend to believe the kids first but it’ll still come down to their testimonies,” replied Jim.
“So there’s still a chance?” asked Lucas.
“There always is. Even the most definite cases can unexpectedly be turned,” Jim honestly answered.
“That could happen here?” murmured Jane.
“It can but you gotta think positive.”
Dustin nodded. “If we start freaking out, the next time Max sees us she’ll know we’re freaking out and then she’ll freak out and then we’ll freak out more and it’ll just be a continuous loop of freaking out!”
“Ditto,” snorted Lucas.
“She’ll be back though,” Will said, reaching across the table to squeeze Jane’s hand. “And if something happens we’ll all protect her.”
Jane nodded in agreement just as Denise started to come back with their food and Jane’s large plate of waffles.
Steve felt Billy start to move so he removed his hand from his hair. Billy was on his feet in seconds, pacing back and forth as he wiped away the tears.
“They’re all fucking liars! All of them!” He grabbed a few rocks, throwing them into the air. Steve listened to the delayed sound of them hitting the water at the bottom of the quarry.
He remained cross-legged, silently letting Billy get out his frustrations. They’d come here after the first day of the trial. Joyce had offered Billy a ride home but he’d declined, asking Steve if he knew anywhere quiet. Ever since Will’s fake body had been found in the area—and most people figured some John Doe had drowned because that made a lot more sense than a life-sized doll—the place had remained pretty quiet and it was far enough away from town that it was doubtful another car would come anywhere near them.
Billy had already gone through several quick emotional changes, though Steve could tell he was starting to simmer down overall. His tie was gone, having been thrown off in Steve’s car, and his hair fell lose again. His suit would have to get some magic done on it by Joyce considering their choice to sit but at least it wasn’t damaged.
The next time Billy walked near him, Steve reached up, grabbed his wrist, and pulled him down on his ass.
Billy let out an unintelligible grumble but didn’t get angry. He just let out an exaggerated huff and with it went the rest of his anger.
“Fucking Johnson, the prick that works with him, he knew he was lying out his ass for my old man. He fucking knew it,” sighed Billy.
“Yeah, well it’s not going to change the outcome. He’s going to jail.”
“But what if he—”
Steve stopped him with a kiss. They were still in the single digits and still really fucking uncertain but Steve got the reaction he was hoping for. Billy quieted, cheeks slightly pink once Steve pulled back.
“You need to try and stay positive. Just thinking about all the negatives is going to stress you the hell out,” said Steve.
Billy just nodded, rubbing at his eyes in frustrated motions.
“And Max will be back soon. Think of that as a positive too.”
“One big, fucked up family,” snorted Billy. “The good kind of fucked up though. I guess.”
Steve nodded in agreement as they turned to a moment of silence. The wind whistled through the area, the trees lush and bright. It was a good day with small, fluffy clouds peppering the blue sky. Steve noted it not because he’d grown suddenly conscious of nature but more so because he was still new to this thing with Billy and looking at their surroundings was easier. It was something he’d done on one of his first dates with a girl, awkwardly looking around and noticing everything else except her.
Of course, the awkwardness wasn’t anywhere near the same level. He felt comfortable with Billy in the way that he still felt comfortable with Nancy. With her, he’d known how to physically react though. Now he felt Billy and he were both still kind of on edge, trying to figure out what was the way to go about it. The fact that they were completely alone though, not even the kids or Joyce nearby, did take away some of the anxiety. Because of that, Steve allowed himself to stay pressed against Billy’s side, his warmth adding to that of the sun that shone from above.
“What do your parents think?”
“About what?” asked Steve.
“You going to court as a witness and everything. I mean, I’m guessing they know by now right?”
“Oh, yeah I briefly told them but I don’t think they really noticed until my dad read a little blurb about the trial in the local paper. All he asked was if I thought you or Max had stolen the TV.”
Billy snorted. “Hiding from an abusive asshole so what do we do? Steal our savior’s TV. Yeah, that’s totally what happened.”
Steve laughed and bumped against Billy’s shoulder. “So you think of me as your savior huh?”
“Fuck off, slip of the tongue.”
Steve just laughed again, this time going to rest against Billy and he could feel him relax against him.
“So any luck with the job hunting?” asked Steve.
“Not really. Most people aren’t looking for something as temporary as I’m thinking right now. May not hit anything. Doesn’t much matter though. I still have no idea what I’m doing next.”
Steve made a noise of acknowledgement. He wanted to know what that exactly meant. Would Billy leave once this was all over? Steve could understand why he would but that didn’t mean he wanted him to. He’d hoped he would come to the same conclusion as Steve had, that the good in Hawkins, the kids and Joyce and Hopper, were too great to leave behind. Steve wanted to know what was ahead, if this thing they were doing was going to go any further.
But that question was for a time when Billy wasn’t dealing with the damn trial so Steve kept his mouth shut and they continued to sit in the moment.
“How was Chicago?” asked Lucas.
“You been stalking me?” teased Max.
Lucas rolled his eyes leading Max to laugh. She replied, “It sucked. Hard. But It’s good to be back. It also means I don’t have to sit through one of those awful car rides.”
“Was the case worker that bad?” asked Will.
“I guess not…I mean, I get she was doing her job. But she wasn’t great,” sighed Max.
She sat on Joyce’s living room floor with Lucas and Will, having just got there at a little after nine. When she’d been given the ok to move in with the Byers, she’d insisted the social worker take her as soon as possible. Lucas had come over right away and the rest of them were supposed to show up soon.
Joyce came in with a thing of Pop Tarts for them for breakfast. Max quickly devoured hers as they tried to figure out something good to watch on TV. They were still flipping through channels when Billy walked in, clearly just having woken up. Max knew that Billy had been staying here but she hadn’t realized he hadn’t left already for the day. Because of that, it left an awkward moment of silence between them.
Max looked over to Lucas and then back to Billy, realizing the two had never really talked. Any relief in Billy’s eyes at seeing Max was clearly overpowered by his want to bolt. Max jumped up before he could though. She grabbed his hand and pulled him into the living room before stopping and pointing at Lucas.
“Apologize.”
“Max—”
“I’m serious Billy. Apologize,” Max said, allowing a bit of bite to come into her tone.
“Shit, alright. Don’t have to remind me of what happened here last time,” Billy grumbled. Max stared at him as he shoved his hands into his pockets and finally mumbled, “Sorry for threatening you and shit.”
“And,” stressed Max.
“And throwing you into a wall.”
“It was actually Joyce’s cabinet,” Lucas automatically replied.
Max rolled her eyes but continued to focus on Billy. “And you are sorry. Aren’t you Billy?” Max stressed again. She could tell that he was thinking about it, thinking about his conversations with Max, their moments of fear and weakness when all they’d had were each other to understand. He was thinking about the moments they’d been honest with each other and she finally watched as Billy’s face relaxed.
“I did a shit thing kid. I’m sorry,” sighed Billy.
“Yeah, well the pod people really screwed you up so I guess we’re even.”
“Lucas!” Max glared.
“Naw I…I probably deserved that. Fair play.” The sound of a car coming into the driveway had everyone turning to look out the window. Billy ruffled Max’s hair. “That’s Steve. I’ll see you later tonight sis. It’s good you’re home,” and then he was gone.
“Will, I didn’t just dream that right? Like, he gave me an honest apology?” asked Lucas.
“You definitely weren’t dreaming,” said Will.
“He’s still got some things to work on but he’s trying,” Max said. “And thanks for sort of accepting it I guess.”
“Yeah, ok, I’ll admit I probably shouldn’t have said what I did,” Lucas winced. “But hey! It turned out alright.”
“I guess,” sighed Max. “So, has he been hanging out with Steve a lot?”
Will nodded. “This weekend he spent most of his time with him. I think the only reason he came back for dinner is because he promised mom he’d be around.”
Max smirked at that and the look that Will had on suggested that he knew as well. Lucas was clueless though. “What? What are you guys talking about!”
“Nothing,” laughed Max as she sat back down. “Anyways, we were trying to find a channel to watch right? Let’s see what else is on.”
The second day of the trial didn’t end it. More character witnesses were brought in, Susan finally stood up and talked, a few doctors came to argue what had caused Billy’s old injuries, but nothing had been solved.
Billy found himself waiting again. It was easier with Max back in Hawkins and Steve somehow managed to calm him down in the worst moments but having to wait two more days was still anguish.
It was Friday again, a full week since this had started. Billy hoped to god it would be the last day and it didn’t go farther.
Like the last two times, everyone sat behind them as support but he only really had Max to hold onto. He didn’t even have that when it came time to finally go on the stand though.
Max actually went first. She held her own against the defense attorney, managing only to get snarky once or twice. Mostly he asked her about what she’d seen and there were only a few quick questions about her altercation with Neil. Billy didn’t want to ignore her courage but overall, she was talking about things she’d witnessed, not been put through. Billy could feel his throat becoming tighter and tighter with every second. He didn’t want to relive this.
Once Max was sitting down, she reached out and Billy squeezed her hand. Probably too tightly by her expression but Billy couldn’t help it. When his name was called out, he felt like he was walking to his execution.
Finally he could see everyone. There was no way to avoid the eyes, the kids and Steve, Joyce, his own father. They were all there, staring at him as his own lawyer went first having been the one to call him to the stand. Billy didn’t let himself get too comfortable despite the quick questions and easy answers. He knew the real challenge was when the defense came forward and that was proven with the first one he was thrown.
“You claim that your father hits you but you haven’t explained why, during your testimony or in the police interview. For what reason could a loving father hit his son?”
Billy forced air through his nose if only to keep from passing out.
“Billy, if I may call you Billy, you need to answer that. Otherwise, how can the jury find a motive at all?”
The only reason Billy didn’t immediately start yelling shit was because of how dry his throat was. “I don’t know.”
“I’m sorry. Could you speak up for the record?”
“I don’t know.” God it sounded like the fucking lie it was, didn’t it? But Billy couldn’t tell the truth. Just come out in front of all these fucking people? No, it was too much.
“So what? You never thought about it? Did your father never tell you anything as a hint?”
“I don’t remember—”
“You easily remember exactly, in great detail, how your father has harmed you over the years yet you don’t know why? Not even once? Over a decade of this has occurred if your claim is to be believed and you never figured out why?”
“Maybe he just enjoyed it,” Billy spit out.
“Maybe? So you’re basically just saying you still don’t know. Is that correct?”
Billy couldn’t find an answer.
“Well, since you’re being so quiet, how about I talk a little bit. Is that alright Billy? You see, I don’t think this is a case of abuse. I think this is a case of two ungrateful children acting out. After all, where’s the proof? All we have is your word and I think I’ve matched you in just how many words can be given. You say you’re the abused yet we have reports of you playing the bully plenty times over. We have people who have never seen any bad blood between you and your father. So what do you have to say to that?”
“When-when I went to the hospital—”
“It was a sad affair indeed. I don’t think anyone here would say they would want that harm done to a thirteen year old but that’s not the point. The point is, that incident was an unfortunate accident that you are now using against your father for some foolish power play.”
“It wasn’t—”
“Perhaps this entire situation is a bit extreme, but I’ve seen this kind of case before. Teenage rebellion gone wrong and now you’re trying to harm your father as well.”
Billy could have sworn there were supposed to be more questions. Not just this fuck talking over and over again. What the hell was going on? What was he supposed to do?!
“You can remember so much about the abuse because you’ve sat down and planned it out. Didn’t you?”
“No—”
“You memorized the words backwards and forwards, made sure you never forgot the number of times he hit you, and that’s why it’s so easy for you to remember. You didn’t think of a reason why a father might hit his son. You simply focused on the goal to ruin your father’s reputation, to perhaps even ruin his life.”
“It’s not—”
“You don’t know why he did it because there isn’t a reason. You made this all up—”
“I just wanted him to stop!” The shout came out half choked and covered in a sob. “I didn’t focus on fucking why I just wanted him to stop!”
“Mr. Hargrove, please, refrain from upsetting this courtroom,” the judge said as he banged his gavel.
Billy looked down at his shaking hands that were the only thing holding him up, pressed flat against the wood.
The defense started talking again. “When you attacked your father, you claim it was in self defense. Your step-sister says the same thing, having witnessed it. Why not one punch and run? You beat him until he was black and blue, until he was almost choking on his own blood. Why do that much damage if it was only in self defense? Why not go to the police immediately afterwards? Why hide with Mr. Harrington? What point did that serve at all?”
Billy forced himself to speak if only because it would look worse if he stayed silent. “He wouldn’t have stopped. I didn’t-didn’t know what to do,” he got out in static gasps.
“Could you clarify for the court?”
Billy swallowed. “My father…he would have kept coming after me if he could have. I…I had to make sure he wouldn’t follow to get away at all. And I-I went to Steve’s because I-I had nowhere-nowhere else to go and-and I didn’t know what to do.” He was surprised he’d managed to get it all out though the tears that were still coming.
“Did you ever convince your step-sister that your father was a bad man?”
“She already knew—”
“I asked if you convinced your step-sister to have a negative view of your father.”
“No—”
“So no motive, no physical evidence, no reason for why you should beat your father within an inch of his life. I think the case speaks for itself. No further questions your honor.”
Billy couldn’t bring himself to stop shaking.
“Do you wish to cross examine?”
“No your honor.”
“Then Mr. Hargrove, please remove yourself from the stand.”
They were going to fucking lose because he couldn’t keep his cool. He couldn’t keep Max safe, he still couldn’t stop his dad. He was so fucking worthless!
“Mr. Hargrove—”
Billy ran. It was the only thing he could think to do as he ignored the shouts and the people who stood. He ran out of the room and collapsed in the hallway, choked sobs coming out as he tried to get in a single breathe.
“Billy! Shit, just breathe ok? Come on, you got this!”
Steve was at his side and Max wasn’t far behind.
“Billy,” she said, “it’s ok. You—”
“It’s fucking over! I fucked it up! I couldn’t-couldn’t keep my-my cool!”
“On the contrary,” came their lawyer’s voice. “That was a spectacular performance.”
Max’s head whipped around. “If you’re going to talk like that you can go screw yourself!”
“I’m only speaking from how the jury will see it. My counterpart hopes the jury will see it as someone breaking down from the weight of his lies. I believe they will see it for what it is. A boy being forced to go through a terrible—”
“Just shut up right now!” yelled Max.
He could feel her hugging him and he buried his face in her hair, sobbing so hard he started to hiccup.
“I-I don’t-don’t want to go-go back in-in there.”
“You don’t have to.” Max glared at their lawyer but she continued talking. “The defense finished their questioning and I see no reason to call you to the stand again. You can wave your right to be present for the rest of the trial or we can postpone for another—”
“No.” Billy quickly shook his head. “Just go ahead. I’m-I’m not going in there again.”
“Alright, in that case we’ll reconvene. Max, do you wish to come in?”
Max hesitated but Steve gripped Billy’s arm. “I’ll stay with him.”
Billy shook his head. “You don’t have to—”
“One of us should be in there. It’s ok. I’ll…I’ll be ok,” Max said. She squeezed him hard and then quickly jumped to her feet. “Let’s finish this.”
Billy closed his eyes, his head resting against his knees as Steve pulled him close.
“It’ll be ok. It will.”
Steve was in the hallway by himself when everyone came out. Billy had finally gone off to the restroom, asking to be alone for a moment. Steve looked to the lawyer and then to Hopper. “Well?”
“They gave their final statements. The jury is now in deliberation.”
“How long could that take?” asked Steve.
“However long they need,” replied Billy and Max’s lawyer. “If they don’t come to a conclusion before two hours, at that time they’ll announce whether or not they haven’t come to a decision yet and then reconvene if necessary. It’s usually best if you wait here. They’ll announce their decision the moment it’s made.”
Well at least it really was almost over now. The pod people, the trial, this weird ass summer, it was all almost done. But what would their decision be?
When everyone’s eyes moved elsewhere, Steve turned around too and saw Billy had come back. He’d paused, eyes still puffy and unsure as ever. Steve knew he was feeling so god damn vulnerable and he probably hated not being in control but with Max in the lead, everyone suddenly rushed him before he could try and distance himself anymore. Even Jonathan and the Chief joined in, dragged over by Nancy and Jane respectively.
“It’s going to be ok,” Max said again as she squeezed him tight.
“Yeah and I mean, murder is always an option,” Dustin said.
“Dustin,” Hopper warned.
“What? I think it’s a great plan,” Dustin grumbled, pressed in between Billy and Joyce.
“Ok, enough with the murder plan, it’s going to be ok guys,” Steve replied, wrapping his arms around the large group.
“I’ll keep you safe,” Jane added.
“Fuck, you guys are saps you know that?” Billy grumbled, trying to wipe away the tears with his shoulder because his arms were pinned tight.
“Well you’re a sap too,” Will said who was hugging Billy from behind.
“Yeah, how you figure that?”
“Because you don’t mind this,” Nancy replied as she squeezed those her arms were wrapped around.
“Bunch of fucking saps,” Billy mumbled again but he hugged them back and finally allowed his head to rest against them.
A few shuttering breathes and quick squeezes and then the large group finally broke apart. Steve rubbed his hand up and down Billy’s back. “Better?”
Billy silently nodded just as the doors to the court room opened up. A man rushed out and quickly said, “The jury has made a decision.”
“It’s been like three minutes,” Billy got out. Steve could feel him freezing again under his touch, the panic immediately back in his eyes and any comfort gone.
“There have been deliberations that were even shorter,” their lawyer answered honestly. “Do you wish to come in?”
Billy shook his head, quick and fast.
Steve gripped his hand. “Do you want me to stay?”
Billy shook his head again. “Tell me what happens. Please.”
Steve nodded, squeezing his hand tight before forcing himself to rush back into the court room. The kids and Hopper and everyone else followed and as Steve sat down near to Jonathan, Neil Hargrove turned around in his seat for the first time during the whole trial.
“So you’re the fag fucking my son.”
Steve froze up. He felt Nancy pressing a hand against him but he honestly had no idea if she was trying to hold him back or just comfort him.
“It’s such a fucking waste. The both of you.”
“Hey!” growled out Hopper. The shout had Steve jumping as he looked over at the Chief. “You say one more word and you’ll lose a tooth.”
Neil simply looked Hopper up and down. “A fucking waste,” he repeated and then turned back in his chair without another word.
“Steve,” Nancy gently tried but he just squeezed her hand.
“Not right now,” he whispered just as all the jury members came in.
The judge spoke and then one member stood up, holding a piece of paper in his hand.
Steve felt his guts constrict. He didn’t dare to move, fearing he’d break the silence.
“We the jury have come to a verdict in the case of Hargrove vs. Hargrove and Mayfield. We have found the defendant—”
Steve grabbed hold of Nancy and Jonathan.
“Innocent on one account of child abuse.”
Oh god no—
“And guilty on one account of child abuse and one account of child neglect. It is the jury’s decision that Neil Hargrove be sentenced for ten years with a possibility of parole in five.”
“Yes!”
“Order!” yelled the judge. It took a moment but he finally said, “Jury, thank you for your service today. Neil Hargrove, you are hereby sentenced to prison for ten years with possibility of parole in five. The court is adjourned.”
Steve stood up and flicked the man off. It wasn’t as satisfying as strangling the guy but it certainly helped. “See you never you piece of shit,” and then Steve was the first rushing out of the court room. Outside, Billy was anxiously pacing back and forth before Steve ran into him. Billy stumbled, grabbing hold of Steve for purchase, eyes wide and desperate. “What—”
“Ten years! The son of a bitch is gone!”
Billy grabbed hold of Steve, pulling him closer as his fingers tangled up in hair and gripped the back of his clothes. “Thank you. Oh god, thank you.”
“Hey, hey I didn’t do anything,” Steve murmured as Billy buried his face in Steve’s shoulder.
“You were here,” countered Billy. “You were fucking here.”
And then the flood of their group, their party, their friends, their family came out and they blocked the hallway with their massive hug and tear stained faces full of relief.
Two days before school and Max had to say the day was pretty great. Granted, the day Jane was saved and the pod people were permanently blocked out was definitely the top one and the day Neil was sentenced to Jail time was a close contender for the second one. But today…
Max breathed a sigh of relief. She looked up, knowing that at least for the remainder of her school years, she’d never have to see Neil in that place again and it allowed her to breathe easily. Max walked up the steps and knocked on the door.
She was home.
Her mother rushed her, picking her up in her arms and hugging her so tight. So often Max had seen her mom fussing about looks, often not becoming too emotional or physical so as not to mess up a nice suit and she was amazingly good at keep tears back so as not to ruin make-up. But not today. Today Max felt herself actually being lifted and her lungs crushed but in that completely comforting way.
Everything was finished including the investigation and Max could finally come home.
When her mom finally pulled back, Max smiled up at her. “Hi mom.”
“Hi sweetheart,” she sniffed, wiping away the tears as she finally looked up. “I’m sorry. I’m not—”
“It’s fine. I certainly understand how you feel,” Joyce smiled. She’d driven Max here when the news had been given and behind Joyce was Billy, awkwardly standing there with hands shoved in his pocket. Billy being there wasn’t a surprise, Max had called ahead and had double checked if it was alright if he got the few things of his that had been left behind.
“Please, come in,” her mom quickly said, moving slightly to the side but still keeping a hand on Max, like she was afraid she’d disappear if she didn’t.
When Billy passed, her mom quickly said, “Billy I’m…I’m sorry—”
“It’s fine,” Billy got out with a forced smile. “Things still in my room?”
“Neil got around to bagging most of it up,” her mom admitted. “Some of it he already threw away. I’m sorry.”
“It’s ok. Whatever I find is more than I expected.”
Max looked to her mom and it looked like she’d want to talk to Joyce for a bit so Max pulled herself away, giving her mom a comforting squeeze. “I’m going to go help him. I’ll be right back.”
She followed Billy to his room, the walls now barren. His bed was stripped, his workout equipment shoved into the closet and five large garbage bags shoved in one corner. Billy let out a soft sigh and sat down, pulling apart the bags as Max went to help him.
A lot of the small things, the pieces that had only been there to please Neil like the sexy posters and shit, they started to shove in one garbage bag for actual trash. The rest of the clothes they divided up between what he wanted and needed and what could actually be thrown away. Max’s mom had already told Billy that he could have his car back and that, since she was now in control of everything while Neil was in jail, she could put it officially in his name so Neil could never take it away before she divorced him.
Max helped Billy take some of the bags out to the trunk of his car. He took a moment to move a hand over the hood of it, with a small smile on his face.
“Why do all boys look half in love with their cars?” snorted Max.
Billy laughed and gave her a playful shove. “Wait until you have your own wheels of freedom. I bet you anything you’ll be a little in love with it too.”
Max rolled her eyes, following Billy back into the house. She didn’t have the strength to grab any of his exercising stuff but she followed him to and fro since it gave her something to do. When it looked like everything he wanted was now in his car, Billy rested against the hood of his car and Max pulled herself up, sitting cross-legged.
In the past few days after the outcome of the trial, Max knew Billy had been with Steve a lot but she also knew he’d been going out with Joyce on several occasions. She hadn’t asked what it was about, not to his face anyway and Will and Jonathan had no idea what they’d been doing.
Max asked, “Are you staying?”
Billy was silent for a moment, pulling out a cigarette and lighting it. “Maybe. I’ve got this thing that I’m still laying some groundwork on. It kind of depends if Susan helps or not.”
“You talked to her? Just the two of you?”
Billy nodded. “When Joyce talked to her one time. She asked for me. It was really fucking awkward.”
“What did mom want?”
“She uh…she basically said if I need anything I can ask for it and she’ll give it to me. I think she’s trying to say sorry for…well you know,” sighed Billy. “I didn’t really want to and she can still say no but…well I need something if this deal I’m working out is actually going to work.”
“But if it works you can stay.”
Billy nodded. “That’s the idea.”
Max jumped off the car.
“Hey, where the hell are you going twerp?”
Max walked in on her mom and Joyce sitting down to a cup of coffee. Max pointed behind her to Billy who had hurried just behind her. “I don’t know what you’ve been talking about but make sure he stays,” Max said with a definitive nod.
Billy rolled his eyes. “Max, you can’t demand shit like that. Ignore her Susan, she—”
“No, you’re going to stay,” Max said, grabbing hold of his hand. “I still want you here. We need you here. Mom?”
The look on her mother’s face made Max smile. Whatever she’d thought before, Max felt that her mom was finally coming to accept that Billy and Max had found the sibling bond to tie them despite their rocky start.
“Don’t worry Maxine. We’ll figure something out.”
It was the day before the kids’ first day of high school-what a scary thought that was-as Steve drove up to the Byers. He knew that Billy had been planning on getting his car back. He had no idea if he had but either way it was pointless both of them driving so Steve went up the Byers’ driveway all the same. After all, he knew Billy was likely there as he’d still opted to stay with Joyce over going to Susan’s, even if they had been talking some. Steve hadn’t made plans with him, but a little over a week had passed since Neil’s trial and Steve felt like he could finally ask Billy the question that had been on his mind for so long. What’s next?
Once at the Byers’ house, he didn’t see Billy’s car and got out just as Joyce came onto the porch.
“Steve, it’s good to see you,” she said with a smile.
“You too. Billy’s here right?”
Joyce’s smile changed in a way that immediately had Steve wondering what the hell was up but he didn’t say anything as she walked over.
“Not right now, no. He’s at Greg’s Shop.”
It took Steve a moment to remember the mechanic’s shop and where it was. “So he did get his car back? Is that why he’s there?”
“Something like that,” smiled Joyce.
“Well if he’s coming back could I wait—”
“I think you should go meet him there.”
“Joyce…what’s going on?”
“Nothing. I just think you should meet him there. It might take a while and I’m sure he’s bored,” Joyce smiled. She squeezed Steve’s arm and then headed back to her house. “I’ll see you later!”
“Uh yeah, bye Joyce,” Steve got out. He shook his head, still utterly confused as he slowly got back in the car. He tried to think about why that conversation had felt so off but upon coming up with nothing, he decided to just go and find Greg’s Shop. He’d been there once before to get his tires changed and once back in town, he found it after only one wrong turn.
He spotted Billy’s car in the parking lot along with another one being worked on in the garage.
Steve hopped out just as Greg pulled himself out from under the car. “Steve Harrington, it’s good to see you kid. Those tires still good?”
“Yeah, they’re still fine,” Steve replied. “I’m actually—”
“Billy Hargrove. Yeah, he said you’d come. He’s upstairs.”
“Up-I didn’t realize you had an upstairs,” Steve honestly answered.
“Technically didn’t until this summer. Put the flooring down myself, insulated it. Got it finished about three weeks ago,” Greg replied. “The stairs are out back. You can cut through the office if you want.”
“Thanks,” Steve replied. He was even more confused as he walked into the office and out the back door. He looked at the stairs that were clearly newer than the building itself. They were nicely done and sturdy under his feet as he walked up to the small landing and the newly put in door. Greg must have had a lot of empty attic space seeing as the whole thing seemed to fit with the building rather than it just being a one story with a crawl space.
Steve heard music coming from the other side and he wondered if should knock or not. He hesitated and then decided to just go in, unsure if Billy would hear him anyways over the blasting tones.
Pushing the door open, Steve peaked inside the newly done second story and—
Holy shit. There looked to be two actual rooms on the far side while the rest of the place was wide and open with the support beams clearly showing. It wasn’t unfinished though. The place was definitely nicely done and it sure as hell didn’t look unlived in.
Steve’s eyes moved over the already messy kitchen, the mattress without a frame, the stereo sitting inside an empty bookshelf with a box of tapes, the work out equipment, the small table and chairs. It was obvious that things weren’t in their perfect place yet and Steve was betting that more things would accumulate after a time to make it more lived in. But the apartment-yeah it was a fully made apartment-had Steve staring as it clicked in his head exactly what this meant.
Just then, one of the doors opened up and out stepped Billy, a large grin coming across his lips. He walked over, turning off the stereo before he stopped in front of Steve.
“So,” grinned Billy. “What do you think?”
“You…you have a place! Holy shit-how did this happen?” asked Steve as he looked around again.
“Joyce helped me find it. Apparently Greg has been looking to hire someone full-time since his friend moved off half a year ago and he also did this space up to rent to someone.”
“But you don’t have any money. Right?”
“Susan actually helped with that. I’ll pay her back the moment I can but she gave me a little boost, enough for rent and groceries until I get my first paycheck.”
Steve looked around again. “You…you’re staying. You’re actually staying.”
“Ah, what did you think Harrington? That I’d leave you behind?” Billy said. He grabbed hold of Steve’s hair and pulled him close. “Not fucking likely.”
Steve felt Billy kiss him hard. It was no longer tinged with sadness or hesitation or fear or anything else. For once, Steve could tell there was nothing else on Billy’s mind. It was all done and behind them and Billy really could start again.
It was passionate and sloppy and Steve let him drag him over to the bed, both falling on it in a tangle of limbs and more kissing. When Billy moved back a little, he started to mess with Steve’s hair, the feeling nice and lazy and Steve looked around again, thinking about how this was fucking Billy’s.
“Christ, I need to catch up,” laughed Steve. “I still have no damn job and I’m stuck with my parents.”
“You could stay here.”
“You’re fucking serious.”
“God, I love it when you say that word.”
“No! Hold on a second, you…what could I possibly say?” laughed Steve. “Hey mom, dad. I know you’re already disappointed with me but I’m moving out with no job and I’m mooching off of this guy who lives above a garage.”
Billy did that horribly lewd thing with his tongue that Steve was starting to think he didn’t really mind at all.
“Alright, yeah. Terrible word choice,” Steve snorted as he rolled his eyes. “But even though I’ll be eighteen in four days, this isn’t going to go well with them.”
“Well…how about this,” Billy said as he kissed him again. “You find a job if only to make you feel like you’re not mooching off of me-though I don’t mind that in the slightest just so you know-and then you tell your parents something like…hey. I want to try and become more of an adult and yeah, I don’t have a place exactly set up but my very…very good friend Billy doesn’t mind helping me out and showing me what it’s like to live on my own and then just…never move out.”
“You know, it almost sounds plausible the way you say it.”
“It’s completely fucking plausible,” Billy said with another kiss.
“You…actually want me to move in? I…doesn’t the thought scare you even a little?” asked Steve. Despite how much he’d loved Nancy, he still hadn’t come to the thought of ever moving in with her.
“Listen, I’ve wasted enough of my life trying to do what people fucking told me to and you know what? Fuck all of them. I want to keep waking up with you next to me,” Billy shot back. He practically puffed out his chest at that and it felt good seeing Billy so sure of himself, so confidant after all the times Steve had seen him defeated and afraid. It was even better seeing this confidence that wasn’t laced with anger and hatred. Billy still deflated a bit though, looking away as he quickly added, “If…if you want to that is.”
“Hell, I…it sounds nice. It sounds really nice,” Steve admitted.
“How about you stay tonight?” asked Billy with a raised eyebrow. “And you know, just see how you like it.”
“Aren’t you working now?”
“I officially start tomorrow.”
Steve laughed and shoved him a bit. “You dick, you planned this didn’t you!”
Billy grinned. “I wanted to make it a surprise.”
“Well it’s a god damn amazing one,” Steve responded. They kissed again, the feeling so new and brilliant. It made Steve never want to stop. Still, a thought did pop into his head as he pulled back. “What about Greg?”
“What about him? Not bad eyes but no offense, I’d like to keep you to myself.”
“You’re awful,” laughed Steve. “No! Just, he’s going to notice me staying. You know?”
“Old school friend of Joyce’s apparently. Real hippie type despite the layer of grease he’s usually under,” replied Billy. He kissed Steve again, tangling his fingers in his hair and resting his forehead against Steve’s. “This is our place. At least…it can be. If you want it to be.”
Steve smiled at that. Considering where his life had been this time last year, Steve could say he’d made a turn so sharply left he was surprised he hadn’t flipped over. But then, he felt comfortable here. He wanted to explore the new possibilities ahead of him. Kind of like how he wouldn’t erase what happened with Nancy even if he could, he wanted to try this no matter what ending they got.
“Yeah,” Steve smiled, “let’s see where this goes.”
