Chapter Text
“The golden wood,” Gandalf murmured thoughtfully. “There are two possibilities, and one is much more likely: the woods of Lothlorien. There resides the Lady Galadriel, one of the oldest and wisest elves to dwell on this side of the veil.”
“You knew of her, and did not think that she might be able to help us?” Thorin bit back his irritation. Mentioning the golden wood to Gandalf had been a good idea, but it was also more proof that Gandalf was holding out on them. Surely one of the oldest elves in all the worlds would know how to find Gondolin. Gandalf might have saved them the trouble of wandering.
And then there was the matter of what he meant by “the veil.”
“The Lady Galadriel keeps her world concealed from darker powers with her own power, which is not inconsiderable,” Gandalf told him, his bushy eyebrows raised in reproof. “It is true, she might be able to help us if she so chooses, but we might not be able to find her, if she doesn’t want to be found.”
“But as we’re not a darker power, shouldn’t we be able to find her?” Dori wondered, petting his dæmon’s fur absently while she bathed herself.
“If we leave Nori behind,” Dwalin grumped.
“I don’t think I deserved that,” Nori exclaimed, clutching his chest as if Dwalin’s comments had wounded him deeply. Thorin thought he heard something in him crack at the effort it took not to roll his eyes. Mingalaz was less reserved, smacking Nori’s dæmon lightly with one of her large paws.
“In any case,” Gandalf continued, raising his voice slightly over the grumbling dwarves, “there is a way to find out if the Lady Galadriel is open to speaking to us. In this very world, there is sometimes a portal that appears to the north of here. If it is there, she is open to company. If it is not, which I think likely given the plague in Minas Anor, we must find another way to get the information we need.”
“You know where this portal is then?” Thorin pressed, but Gandalf shook his head.
“It was a long time ago that I last passed through it,” the wizard admitted. It seemed like it had been a long time since he last did anything. “Bilbo and Myrtle have a better chance of finding it than I.”
“Something is stuffing up Myrtle’s nose,” Bilbo said gloomily, but Gandalf didn’t seem the least bit concerned.
“Myrtle’s ability to find portals is just an extension of your own latent abilities,” Gandalf told him gently, his ever-silent moth dæmon fluttering out to sit on one of his fingers. “You can do it as well, and I imagine with a different sense than she does, as your nose is not as sensitive. But what might be more sensitive?”
Thorin found his eyes drawn to Bilbo’s delicately pointed ears. The Elves had similar ears, and their hearing had been superior. Not to mention the handful of occasions he’d seen Bilbo’s ears twitch in response to something he couldn’t hear.
Bilbo seemed to realize the answer, one of his hands coming up to cup his ear. “What would a portal sound like?” he wondered, brushing a cluster of curls behind his ear. Thorin realized that he was probably staring, and looked away.
“You know the answer, you just haven’t been paying attention,” Gandalf assured him. “I can point us in the right direction, and if there is a portal to find, I have no doubt you will be able to find it.”
Bilbo’s pursed lips suggested that he wasn’t nearly as confident, but then Ori told him, “I know you can do it!” Bilbo’s expression lightened a little.
Thorin had one more question. “If the way is shut, where else can we find the information we need?”
“I am afraid I do not have all the answers,” Gandalf replied, though Thorin privately disagreed, and Mingalaz growled. “If the way is shut, your compass might be better able to answer that question.”
It wasn’t a satisfactory answer, not by any stretch of the imagination, but it was an answer, and there wasn’t much point in trying to press. He tried asking the compass what they would do if this failed, but it didn’t answer, the needle staying stubbornly still. It was apparently confident that they would succeed, if an inanimate object could be confident. So they set out from Osgiliath, the whole party in much higher spirits than when they had arrived. They had some direction now, and they had dry socks. The two most important components of a happy journey.
“Thorin, be honest,” Dwalin said as they walked near the back of the company. “Do you think the hobbit can find the portal?”
“If there is a portal, Bilbo will find it,” Thorin answered firmly, ignoring the assault on his honesty. “Gandalf is right. If Myrtle can find portals, Bilbo should be able to do the same.”
Dwalin raised an eyebrow. “Oh it’s ‘Bilbo’ now, is it? What happened to ‘Master Baggins?’”
“He asked me to use his given name,” Thorin replied, meeting Dwalin’s gaze flatly.
Dwalin just shook his head, his mouth twisted wryly. “You might have done it from the start.”
It was true. There was no real significance to being asked to call someone by their given name, because dwarves did not have surnames in the same way. But giving out Myrtle’s name, and the fact the she spoke freely in front of the company would have been very strange back in Erebor. It made Thorin feel guilty about concealing Mingalaz’s name, and he had little doubt much of the company felt the same. He had avoided using Bilbo’s given name as a result, to pretend that he did not know the hobbit’s secret name and stave off the guilt. Being told a dæmon’s name was a mark of great trust, and it was an insult not to reciprocate. Even though Bilbo had no idea what it meant to them to be told his dæmon’s name, and thus for him the act implied nothing, Thorin still felt like he was holding out on him. That was why he had almost spilled the beans at their first meeting: returning that trust was almost automatic, even for a King. Someone looking to usurp you wouldn’t give out their dæmon’s name, because it would give you power over them as well, so there was nothing to fear from that.
As they traveled north, the land changed from open plains to more forested, and Thorin began to have doubts. The trees were not thick, but forests had plenty of their own sounds, especially so close to a large river. Gandalf no longer knew where they were going, and Bilbo probably couldn’t hear anything. They might wander for days without knowing if the portal even existed or not.
“Relax,” Mingalaz muttered, rubbing up against him. Her size always meant that it was a struggle to stay on his feet when this happened. “I think he’s onto something.”
Thorin looked over at their portal-finder, and noted with some relief that he did seem to be onto something. As he was walking, everything about his posture was strained and tight, as if he were trying with all of his being to listen to something. Thorin desperately wanted to ask if Mingalaz was right, but he feared disrupting Bilbo’s concentration. If he’d found anything, Bilbo would say so soon enough.
“Gandalf was wrong,” Thorin said quietly. “The portal is open.”
“Or there is another one close by,” Mingalaz pointed out. “Hush, stop jumping to conclusions and let him work.”
Before long Bilbo requested they halt, and Thorin was certain now that he’d found the portal, but Bilbo walked here and there, opening his mouth as if he meant to speak and then closing it again. He pressed his fingers against his lips absently, muttered to himself, and tapped his large feet as if he thought the portal was beneath them, but he appeared no closer to finding the portal. The strangest thing he did was ask Óin if he could borrow his ear trumpet, a request that had to be repeated several times but was granted as soon as it was understood. Bilbo immediately covered one ear and put the trumpet in the other, listening with such an intense look of concentration that Thorin almost laughed. He rather liked the way Bilbo scrunched his face up when he was focusing.
Mingalaz snorted, and Thorin instead focused on the memory of Mingalaz carrying Myrtle in her mouth. This earned him a nip on the leg, but it was worth it.
Suddenly, Bilbo snapped his fingers. “I’ve got it!” he declared, and headed for the nearest tree. “Be right back.” He started climbing, Myrtle clinging to his back for dear life.
Still on the ground, the dwarves shifted uncomfortably. “What if he falls?” Ori wondered, twisting his scarf in his hands. His dæmon hooted piteously, which seemed rather ridiculous considering she could fly. She could just check on him.
“One of us just has to catch him,” Kíli said easily.
“What about Myrtle?” Bofur asked. “Can’t touch ‘er, can we?”
That put an end to that, and the dwarves were left hoping that Bilbo was very good at climbing trees.
“I don’t think they’re going to like this,” Bilbo admitted, setting Myrtle on a sturdy branch. “Dwarves don’t look like natural tree climbers.”
“Too dense,” Myrtle agreed. “But there’s no other way.” And Myrtle was right, there really was no other way, because the portal was up in a tree.
When they had entered the woods, Bilbo had heard a strange rushing sound that didn’t feel like the wind or the sounds of the river. As it had gotten stronger, he recognized it as the sound of an open portal. Bilbo had heard it before with the other portals, and dismissed it as unimportant, or just the wind. With his ears now the only thing he could rely on, the meaning of the sound had quickly clicked into place.
It had been frustrating then to find no portal anywhere on the ground. After a thorough search, he had wondered if maybe the he was hearing where the portal should be, and it really had been closed to them. The idea to use Óin’s ear trumpet was really an act of desperation, but it had turned out to be a stroke of genius. When he pointed the trumpet up, the sound got stronger, and it got weaker in every other direction. And so Bilbo had climbed a tree, and found the portal. How Gandalf had forgotten its’ location in such a place was a mystery.
“You’re going to have to climb up,” Bilbo called down. “The portal is up here!” He heard a chorus of groans in response, but it wasn’t long before Kíli had joined him in the upper branches.
He shrugged off Bilbo’s stare. “Kurdaz is a good climber, and some of the bigger dæmons are going to need to be hoisted with ropes. Might as well set it up.”
Bilbo was taken aback. “Is Kurdaz your dæmons’ name?”
Kíli realized his mistake immediately. “I shouldn’t have said that,” he exclaimed quickly, clapping a hand over his mouth.
“I won’t tell anyone,” Bilbo assured him, and Kíli relaxed fractionally.
“It means ‘of the heart,’” Kurdaz offered cheerfully, as if secrecy meant nothing to her. At least her name was explanation enough for why Kíli did most of his thinking after the fact.
“You’re not supposed to tell him that,” Kíli moaned, but Kurdaz swished her tail in unconcern.
“A dwarf would have known, but Bilbo is not a dwarf, so he must be told,” she replied obstinately, and the arrival of their older brother and sister ended that conversation. Between the three of them and some rope, they were able to pull the larger dæmons up the tree, though they had to go straight through the portal with their dwarf to avoid breaking the branches. Thorin ascended second to last with Gandalf following, waving away the rope and climbing with surprising agility, and Mingalaz practically hopped up to the top branch. Having never seen a mountain lion climb before, Bilbo found the sight a little unnerving.
With everyone accounted for, Bilbo stepped through the portal and instantly understood why it was called ‘the Golden Wood.’ They were surrounded by huge trees with brilliant golden leaves, with delicately curving stairs and platforms built around them. Bilbo barely had the chance to catch his breath at the sight before he realized an arrow was being pointed at his face, and the dwarves who had come through earlier were surrounded. It was only the Elves that reacted to them this way, he realized. The Men had been largely unfazed, and of course the goblins and orcs tried to kill them on sight. But they had Gandalf this time, and when he emerged at last, he saw a flicker of hesitation go through the Elves.
“Mithrandir,” one of them greeted him. “Are these dwarves your companions?”
And a hobbit, Bilbo wanted to correct him, but there were still weapons being pointed at him. And at Myrtle more specifically.
“Indeed,” Gandalf answers easily. “I had thought that the portal being open meant the Lady Galadriel was open to receiving visitors. Is that no longer true?”
The elves didn’t put their weapons away, but they at least lowered them, and soon the company was moving again. Bilbo tried to look everywhere at once. Everything felt healthy, and a little magical. It was completely unlike Mirkwood really, with its’ spiders and decay. Though Thorin had said Harad was a healthy world, there had been darkness shifting underneath, behind the scenes. Here, there was no darkness at all, and Bilbo was struck by how powerful the Lady Galadriel must be, to keep it at bay when every world they had visited so far had some trace of it.
There might be darkness hidden somewhere, he reminded himself, but it didn’t feel like there was. He couldn’t have explained it if asked, he just knew. For the moment, they were safe here. It made him slow his steps, and their escort exchanged looks of amusement over the enchanted hobbit. Some of the dwarves shared his awe, but some of them were a little preoccupied being high off the ground, Bilbo noted as they were led up one of the spiral staircases. Glóin in particular looked ready to wait at the bottom for them to return, but Óin continuing on, his deafness rendering him oblivious to his brother’s protests, convinced Glóin to swallow his pride and keep walking up the tree. Bilbo watched the scene with some interest. He’d never had siblings, while every dwarf there did. Just Myrtle.
While Bilbo was staring and wondering at the odd sibling dynamics that made Glóin overcome his fear of heights to stay with his brother, Bombur handed him a sausage.
“You looked a little lonely,” Bombur said with a shrug. “Never met a problem a sausage won’t fix. Unless it’s a pie problem.”
Bilbo was touched by the gesture, rather hobbity as it felt. He thanked Bombur gratefully and wolfed the sausage down. Something told him it wouldn’t do to be snacking when they reached the Lady Galadriel.
The knowing look in her eyes when she floated into the room suggested that the gesture was pointless. The Lady Galadriel knew all of their thoughts, all of their innermost secrets, and the names of all their dæmons. Bilbo couldn’t say why he was so sure of that, but he was. Just like he was sure that Lothlorien was not yet affected by evil.
The Lady of Lorien was tall, taller than anyone Bilbo had ever seen. He hadn’t met the Elvenking of Mirkwood, but he doubted he could match her. She carried herself with grace, like all the elves they had met so far, but it was different from the lethal grace of the Mirkwood elves. The difference was in their dæmons, he supposed. Captain Tauriel’s dæmon was some kind of raptor, but Galadriel’s was a swan, pure white, matching the pristine white of her raiment.
Bilbo did not know what to make of Lord Celeborn, the Lady’s husband. As he exchanged greetings with Gandalf, Bilbo thought that where the Lady was mysterious and aloof, though if her gentle smile was any indication, she was also kind, the Lord was closer to earth, and more accessible. His dæmon was an albatross, and Bilbo wondered at it, but said nothing under the Lady’s piercing eyes.
“I do not know where Gondolin lies,” the Lady was saying, drawing Bilbo from his silent reflections. “But I do know where you may find one who does know.” Galadriel did not make any signal that Bilbo could see, but a young elf-maid appeared then, her dark hair a sharp contrast to the almost glowing locks of the Lady. A nightingale perched on the elf-maid’s shoulder, and a memory stirred in Bilbo’s mind.
Luthien Tinuviel.
He shook his head. No, no, that was silly. She died a long time ago, according to his mother’s tale. And yet... she’d had descendants, hadn’t she?
“My granddaughter Arwen can guide you to Imladris, the hidden valley,” Galadriel was saying, and Bilbo felt a little guilty for losing focus again. “There, you should find someone who can help you.”
“We are grateful,” Thorin replied. “But, why…”
Galadriel laughed, and it was almost musical. “Why do I offer my help so freely? There are things in motion now that affect all worlds, Thorin Oakenshield. You know this.” She said no more, but Thorin’s eyes were fixed on her as if he couldn’t look away.
“She’s talking inside his head,” Myrtle whispered into Bilbo’s ear. “She did that to you before, about Luthien, but it was so quick you didn’t notice.”
“Has she been doing that to everyone?” he hissed, startled. Even if he had been paying attention, he was missing half of the conversation anyway. Only the Lady was hearing the the whole story.
“Looks that way,” Myrtle replied. “You can tell when she does it. They get dreamy-eyed and can’t look away, and then when she finishes they look kind of startled.”
Your dæmon is very perceptive.
Bilbo met the Lady’s eyes, startled. She simply smiled. She was still speaking aloud, but Bilbo couldn’t follow what she was saying over her voice in his head. How many thousands of years did you have to live to carry on two separate conversations aloud and in your head and not get confused?
What brings a hobbit so far from the Shire? Your world is protected, and until all other worlds have fallen, will remain protected.
Protected? How?
Have you ever been to the harbor? Bilbo shook his head lightly, and she continued. Your world is connected to Valinor, the land beyond the veil. From the harbor, the elves who tire of living in the mortal realm can go beyond the veil, and live in the immortal one. They protect your world, to protect the crossing. So why have you left?
That was a lot to take in, and as the Lady was waiting for an answer, Bilbo put off trying to process it all. Though he did let himself wonder how elves had been passing through his world for so long without being noticed.
I left because I was needed, he answered simply. No one needed me in the Shire.
He heard Galadriel laugh in his head. If only we could all answer duty so readily.
“That was a strange thing for her to say,” Bilbo murmured to Myrtle as they were lead to where they would spend the night. “Isn’t she helping us?”
“Did you see her eyes? I don’t think she was thinking about the here and now.”
