Actions

Work Header

To Find a Long Forgotten World

Chapter 11: The Mirror of Galadriel

Summary:

The mirror shows many things, but rarely pleasant ones.

Notes:

This chapter probably has the most straight from the book dialogue of any chapter so far... You can guess why based on the title. Starting next chapter, there'll be another POV, so look forward to that. Thanks again to Niffstral for not letting me ruin Galadriel's mystique with spelling errors.

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

Though Lothlorien was peaceful, and by all accounts should have been relaxing, most of the members of the company sat alone with their dæmons, quietly mulling over whatever the Lady had said to them. Even Fíli and Kíli, normally inseparable, were thoughtful, sitting on different sides of their little clearing. But Bilbo could only think of his short conversation with Galadriel for so long. He had learned there was good reason for the Shire to still be green and peaceful, and though he still had many questions, like why his world was apparently connected to the realm of the immortals, and why he had never seen an Elf if they passed through his world routinely, he could only sit and wonder for so long.

Bilbo took out his borrowed knife, running through one of Thorin’s drills while Myrtle practiced her footwork. He was halfway through the second drill when he saw Thorin stand up and start walking away, out of the clearing. Ordinarily this would not have been too strange. Thorin did what he pleased, after all. Except there was something strange about his gait, as if he were being drawn by a spell.

Bilbo followed on silent feet, and no one noticed, too preoccupied with their own problems.

Thorin disappeared down a small set of stone stairs, and Bilbo hurried a little to catch up. If he lost sight of Thorin now, he might never find him again, and why was he following him in the first place? Thorin wasn’t answerable to him.

“He looked like he had a spell on him,” Myrtle reminded him, and Bilbo redoubled his efforts.

When he reached the stairs, he saw that he needn’t have run: it was a dead end. Thorin was waiting at the bottom in front of a silver bowl set on a pedestal, and the Lady Galadriel stood across from him, smiling up at Bilbo mysteriously.

“It would appear that someone noticed your departure,” she observed, no displeasure or censure in her voice.

Thorin turned to look at him, his mouth slightly open, and maybe it was just the gentle light that covered Lothlorien, but Bilbo wondered how he’d never really noticed how handsome the dwarf king was. Well, not never. But he hadn’t fully appreciated it before.

“Because you were trying not to,” Myrtle muttered. Minty must have said something too, because Thorin nudged her with his foot.

“I-I’m sorry,” Bilbo stammered, pinned by their stares. “I thought- a spell-”

“Come down, Bilbo Baggins,” Galadriel said gently, and his feet moved down the stairs independently of his own will. “I was offering Thorin the chance to look into my mirror, and I offer you the same chance.” As she said this, she filled a pitcher with water from the nearby stream, and poured the water into the silver basin.

“You did not say what I would see,” Thorin said, a bit of an accusation in his voice. Minty sniffed the water gingerly. The swan dæmon pushed her back lightly with an outspread wing.

“Even the wisest cannot tell,” Galadriel admitted. “The mirror shows many things. Things that were, things that are, and some things… that have not yet come to pass. Will you look?”

Thorin was scratching his chin, looking a little unnerved. Bilbo wondered at it, when he already had an object that could do some of what Galadriel claimed the mirror could do.

“I will look,” Bilbo said, flushing a little when he realized that he had not yet been asked. “Er, if that’s alright.”

Galadriel and the swan both gestured to the mirror, and Bilbo stepped up to it hesitantly. “Do not touch the water,” the swan said, and then the water was no longer reflecting the moon and stars.

Bilbo saw a thin blade, too small to be a proper sword. He saw the wraiths (though he had never seen them before, he knew instantly they could be nothing else) tearing through the Shire, Lobelia trying to fight one off with her umbrella. He saw a land of ash and smoke. He saw a man who looked like Thorin die, his dæmon winking out of existence. He saw a great red dragon, unfurling its wings and filling the sky. He saw many things he couldn’t name or understand, but the last thing he saw would haunt him for many days to come.

He saw Thorin touching his dæmon, actually petting Myrtle. Thorin, breaking the taboo! And Myrtle, not clawing his face off in response! That could only mean one thing, and thinking about it brought a blush to his cheeks.

What did I see? Bilbo wondered.

A sampling of possible futures, Galadriel replied silently. And a little bit of the past.

The dying man, Bilbo knew immediately, and wondered how.

“What did you see?” Thorin asked insistently, and Bilbo nearly jumped out of his skin, bumping into Minty. “Was it that alarming?” Thorin just looked concerned now, making Bilbo feel a little guilty. But he couldn’t look at him! Thorin had been touching Myrtle!

“Ah, no, I was just thinking about what it all meant,” Bilbo hedged. It was not a complete lie. “I saw a lot of different things, but none of it really made sense.” He glanced over at the Lady, but she simply gazed back impassively.

What you see in the mirror is for you, she told him. You do not have to tell him.

Thorin apparently saw no harm in what Bilbo had described, because he took his turn at the mirror without further hesitation. It was interesting being on this side, Bilbo reflected. He could see nothing on the surface of the mirror except Thorin’s increasingly distressed face.

“I wonder what he’s seeing,” Bilbo muttered to Myrtle, who rubbed against Mingalaz comfortingly. Bilbo wished he could be so openly comforting, and where on earth were such thoughts coming from? It was just the light, he reminded himself. The light.

“Things that were,” Galadriel answered shortly, surprising Bilbo. She smiled. “He intends to tell you.”

Well wasn’t that the fastest way to make him feel guilty?

Thorin was stepping back from the mirror, a hand on his forehead. Bilbo hovered at his side uncertainly, but Thorin waved him off. “I’m fine,” he said roughly. “I just wish I had seen many things I didn’t understand.”

“What did you see then?” Bilbo asked hesitantly, and was surprised by the sudden flash of vulnerability in Thorin’s face. It vanished as quickly as it came, but he couldn’t just forget that he had seen it.

“I saw dwarves being tortured and mutilated, their dæmons becoming half-formed monsters, or worse,” Thorin related, a hard look in his eyes. “What does it mean, and why have I seen it?”

Galadriel turned to look at the sky, her dæmon taking flight. She waited until he vanished before answering. “Gandalf has told you of the cult of Men who created false dæmons, claiming that dæmons were evil creatures, created to lead us astray,” she reminded them, her voice calm as ever, though Bilbo thought he detected a note of anger. “Long ago, followers of that belief tried other experiments, seeking to find a dæmons’ true form.”

“But when a dæmon settles, that’s its true form,” Bilbo said, eyes wide. “Isn’t it?”

“Yes,” Galadriel agreed. “But they were not satisfied. The experiments affected different races differently. Elves became orcs and goblins. You have seen goblins, I believe.” They both nodded, and Bilbo suddenly felt parched. “With an artificial dæmon, Men became wraiths, the very creatures that haunt your world. Without an artificial dæmon they simply died. An artificial dæmon made Hobbits become like that creature you found in the goblin tunnels. But dwarves… dwarves were unpredictable.”

Bilbo found himself seeking Myrtle’s warmth, separating her from Minty and putting her in his arms. He noticed that Thorin’s hands were clenched tightly at his sides. Unpredictable was underselling whatever Thorin had seen, apparently.

“Our dæmons became monsters,” Thorin spat, completing the thought.

“Sometimes,” Galadriel allowed. “Dæmons were a gift given to the dwarves by Eru, to a people he did not create. He could not predict what would happen, adding them to Mahal’s creations. Some of your people were completely unaffected. You cannot say that about mine.”

 


 

Hours later, Thorin Oakenshield still did not know why the mirror had shown him what it had. Expecting a series of disconnected images, he had instead been thrust head first into the suffering of his people. It was horrific and deeply disturbing, but what did it have to do with his quest?

“Probably nothing,” Mingalaz yawned. “She didn’t say you’d see something useful. Just that you’d see something.”

“You know better than that,” he replied sourly. “It was a warning.”

“Don’t be paranoid,” Mingalaz scolded, but there was a note of fear in her voice that told Thorin not to press the issue. She was just as afraid, but wasn’t ready to face it.

Instead, he said, “You’re right,” and left it at that.

Absently, he consulted the compass, asking what they should do next, and the answer simply confirmed what they were doing: “Go to the hidden valley.” He should have been comforted knowing that they were finally making progress, but he wasn’t. The wraiths had been Men once. Had Gandalf really not known? Or was it just another secret being kept from him?

“There are some things you have to see to believe,” Gandalf said, startling Thorin. The wizard couldn’t hear his thoughts, not like Galadriel, but it was possible that he’d spoken aloud and not realized it. “It is true, I knew the wraiths were once Men. But what would you have done with that information? At the time, you did not even know what Men were.”

“You gave me a task and kept information from me,” Thorin replied doggedly. “Every step of the way you have concealed and lied. Why should I now believe that you are really helping us? That Gondolin really holds the key to our salvation?”

Gandalf’s bushy eyebrows vanished under the brim of his hat. “Tell me Thorin, do you think the Lady Galadriel is a servant of evil?”

“No,” Thorin answered immediately. “I don’t know how, but I am certain.”

“And when her guards saw me, did they not immediately grant an audience?” Gandalf continued. “Do you think, if I intended to lead you astray, I would be welcome here?”

Thorin clenched his jaw. “No.” He did not think the Lady was likely to be taken in by anyone’s lies, least of all Gandalf’s.

Gandalf nodded. “No. Your suspicion is understandable, but in truth, I don’t have all the answers, and the ones I have could complicate matters without helping at all,” he explained. “I had to be careful.”

“But not anymore?” For a moment, Thorin wondered if Gandalf intended to leave again, now that they were so close. But no, he still hadn’t said what they needed to do after Gondolin.

“You are in full mastery of the compass, for all intents and purposes,” Gandalf reminded him with a twinkle in his eyes. “No secret is truly barred from you if you know how the frame the question. Yet you have not asked it much.”

“Something tells me it wouldn’t answer if I just asked aimless questions,” Thorin admitted. The obstinate way it answered only some questions, withholding information… A lot like Gandalf, in some ways. “It can answer any question, but that does not mean it will. How did you come by it, Gandalf?”

“I was very fortunate,” Gandalf said, suddenly grim. “I encountered your father on the journey that took his life, and he entrusted it to me, to give to you. It is an heirloom of your line, kept secret until it is time to pass it on.”

Thorin’s heart clenched in his chest, and Mingalaz licked his hand comfortingly. Or it would have been anyway, if her tongue wasn’t so rough. “He was still… present enough, after being attacked?”

“I was able to drive off the wraiths, but too much of him had been taken,” Gandalf related sadly. “He passed on shortly after giving it to me.” The wizard put a comforting hand on his shoulder. “Soon enough you will be able to prevent your people from knowing any more of the grief these wraiths cause.”

Thorin’s eyes fell upon the sleeping forms of Fíli and Kíli. For a future where they could sleep without fear, like they were now, he would risk anything. Unconsciously, his eyes sought Bilbo next, who was tossing and turning fitfully in his bedroll. He wondered what troubled the hobbit, whose world was still green and pure, and made another silent promise to ensure their portal-finder had a home to return to, when all this was over.

The morning found them on the move again, weighed down with elvish field rations, and following Arwen deeper into the wood. Bilbo walked at her side, and the elf-maid matched his shorter stride thoughtfully. Thorin couldn’t hear the words, but he had little doubt that the hobbit was plying her with questions, and she didn’t seem to mind. But Bilbo seemed jumpy, and every time he glanced back at the dwarves, he’d meet Thorin’s eyes and look away quickly. It irritated Thorin. It made no sense, considering how quickly Bilbo had noticed he was gone and followed him the night before.

“Stop that,” Mingalaz scolding, swatting at his leg. “No brooding. We’re finally getting somewhere.”

Thorin bit back his retort that he wasn’t brooding, why would she say that? But it was still strange. Had he done something to make Bilbo avoid him? Crossed some line of Hobbit propriety that he wasn’t aware of? Not that Bilbo hadn’t been stepping all over dwarf propriety from day one, but still.

He resolved to approach Bilbo when they broke for lunch, a plan complicated by the fact that their lunch was Lembas, eaten while walking, and thus they didn’t stop. So he would have to pry Bilbo away from the elf. With the entire company no doubt watching and laughing behind their hands.

Strangely enough, it was Arwen who separated herself from Bilbo. “I need to speak to your king,” she said, her musical voice carrying across the distance as it hadn’t before. She wanted Thorin to hear.

“He’s not really my king, but-oh yes, alright,” was Bilbo’s faint reply, and then Thorin knew he had no choice but to change places with Bilbo, as Arwen was leading. He did not much care for being summoned by the elf-maid, but the irritation that spiked through him as he passed Bilbo and the hobbit averted his eyes convinced him that talking with Bilbo would not be terribly productive.

“What did you want to discuss?” Thorin asked politely. Mingalaz followed her nightingale off a way, scouting ahead.

“You are disturbed by what you saw in my grandmother’s mirror,” Arwen said with a gentle smile. “So is Bilbo. I have been talking to him to try and calm him down, but he is not easy. You saw only the past, but Bilbo saw the past and a possible future. Seeing the future is not without consequences. My father has such visions, and even he cannot say if by seeing a certain future, he has made that future impossible.”

Thorin mulled this over. “He saw my future,” he realized. “That is why he can’t look at me.” He saw my death, Thorin thought to himself. He had always suspected this venture would be fatal, and this was merely confirmation.

Arwen simply nodded. “I would not ask him about it. It is one thing for Bilbo to know a part of your possible future, but if you knew, it would certainly affect the outcome. Treat him as you always do, and he will forget his fears.”

They camped in the woods that night, the company cheerful and boisterous at the prospect of finally making progress in their journey. When Bilbo took out his dagger and started going through the forms Thorin had taught him, Thorin simply walked up and started fixing Bilbo’s posture again. The hobbit was initially startled, but they soon fell into a rhythm, and there was no more flinching or looking away.

“I think I’m starting to get the hang of this,” Bilbo panted after a successful parry. His eyes were gleaming with excitement, and Thorin swallowed heavily, his mouth suddenly dry.

“You have a long way to go,” he replied, shaking his head so that he didn’t have to make eye contact. “But that was a good parry. Again.”

It really was a miracle Mingalaz had settled on a form.

Notes:

In case anyone asks... I thought when talking to Thorin, Galadriel would use the dwarvish name for Aule, since she tends to be thoughtful that way, like with Khazad-dum.