Chapter Text
September through December is the best time for the hunt.
Lucas has never cared much for the idea of hanging antlers in his home. While he was alive, Father had little patience for such displays, dismissing them as “vulgar and self-important.” Father was always so quick to disparage Lucas’s tastes, once doing so in front of his friends, whose own rooms were decorated with entire walls of antlers.
“Your taste is considerably worse than everyone else’s in this family,” Father would say. But Lucas never argued with him. At least, never to his face.
And so the other people in town were always eager to take Lucas’s trophies off his hands. Theo had at least one wall that existed because of Lucas. His best friend was always telling him, whenever they sat drinking coffee in Theo’s kitchen, “You really ought to hang the biggest one in your bedroom.”
“I have one in my bedroom. The biggest one.” That was always Lucas’s answer.
They had had this conversation several times over these years, from the day Lucas moved into this long-abandoned house to all the years that followed, after they had become friends. At least once a month. Few people had ever been inside Lucas’s bedroom, but everyone in town knew about the enormous antlers in it. It was a small town, after all. It only took half an hour to walk from its eastern edge to its western one. Lucas knew everyone here, and everyone here knew Lucas.
“But you didn’t hunt that one.” Theo nudged the rim of his coffee cup, his tone carrying the mild reprimand of a father correcting his eldest son.
It was true. The antlers had been a gift. But Lucas liked them. He had always preferred his brother’s work. He was the more awkward child in the family, while Father and his brother seemed to move through the world with effortless ease.
But unlike Father, his brother had never once criticized Lucas’s tastes.
“What belongs to my brother can also belong to me.” So he blinked, drank down the last grounds of coffee from the bottom of his cup.
-
September makes the kindergarten golden. Not only the leaves carpeting the garden, but the children’s hair, urgently in need of tending before the snow comes.
When he opens the front door of the kindergarten, a strand of hair slips from behind his ear, forcing him to ignore the ambush on his left. Perhaps his own hair is overdue for a trim. “It’s a trap!” he cries, reaching out to catch the children winding themselves around his limbs, unable to keep the laughter from his voice.
Just another day with these little miscreants.
When Grethe calls for him, he is putting Thomas back onto the wooden horse from which he has just fallen. “Careful. Not so hard.” He waves to Thomas as he walks toward the office. “Try not to fall off and cry about it again.” He smiles.
“Thomas still loves playing with you,” Grethe says as she sits down.
There is something neutral in her voice, and when the man standing opposite her notices it, he straightens a little. “He likes riding his father around at home, too.” Lucas’s voice still held the laughter from playing with the children, until Grethe asks about Marcus. “He might come stay with me before the holidays.” Lucas nods toward the coffee cup on the desk. He has no intention of answering Grethe’s gaze. He dislikes eyes that search too deeply.
“In any case, one of the children reported a problem to me.”
A problem. He can hear the care in those words. The deliberate choice of them.
They rarely have conversations this formal. Even when Lucas applied for the position as a childcare worker here several months ago, they had spoken casually for a while. He remembers most of that conversation. Most of it had been about Marcus. About his son’s grades. About the relationship between father and son. About his mother’s persistence. About all the things Lucas does not like to discuss.
His right hand finds the faint pale around his left ring finger without conscious thought.
“They said you showed them some things that are meant to be seen by adults.”
The antlers in his bedroom flash before his eyes.
“Adult things,” he repeats.
The words come with difficulty. Only then does he notice there is no cup waiting for him on the desk. Grethe almost never offers him coffee or water when they meet, not since that conversation several months ago. The one Lucas had not particularly enjoyed. He has never attended one of the childcare staff meetings, whether because he is the only man here or because others have simply never considered him one of their own.
He does not know if everyone else finds an empty desk waiting for them when they sit in his place.
“I think we’ll find out exactly what they were talking about.” The director lifts her coffee cup, hiding the lower half of her face behind it. She does not meet his eyes. “Someone specifically assigned to this will speak with the children involved today or tomorrow. They may also try to speak with some of the other children…”
She hesitates. “But this does involve certain parts of the body—” Grethe gestures vaguely at the empty air, her eyes fixed upon the desk. She does not notice the man opposite her draw his brows together, then let them smooth again.
Oh.
He suppresses the sigh that rises instinctively.
“In any case, the investigation will not be directed at you immediately.” Grethe raises her coffee one last time.
Walking home along the golden path, Lucas thinks about the antlers in his bedroom. He thinks of Father. He thinks of the little lambs they kept when he was a child. He thinks of his brother. He thinks of the rifle Father gave to his brother, and his brother gave to him. He thinks of his lamb. He thinks of his brother telling him that next year he would become Father’s deputy. Telling him they would bring him beautiful antlers. When Lucas unlocks the front door, he is thinking of his little sister’s uneven ends. The ends he had cut.
-
He still remembers a morning just as cold, before the winter of that year, when he arrived with a backpack almost as tall as himself slung over his shoulders. Beneath the rug by the front door, he found the key Father had hidden there years ago, and formally became a resident of a town whose population numbered fewer than a hundred.
Sometimes Lucas wondered whether Father had purchased such a conspicuous property in a country they had never even visited as an indulgence for his own amusement, or as an act of foresight, preparing for a future he alone could see. When Lucas finally asked his brother about it in a letter, his brother enclosed, in the return envelope, the deeds to houses and other properties he had purchased under different names.
That was why Lucas sometimes suspected it might be hereditary.
But unlike the other men in his family, he had never felt the impulse to deliberately hurt another person. He knew his brother liked to romanticize his own actions. Lucas understood, nevertheless, that his prey never volunteered to become food. “The meat in your refrigerator didn’t volunteer to become our dinner, either.” His brother had said it while cutting a piece of shoulder meat, looking at Lucas with something like amusement.
Lucas could only lower his head over his own meal. “Technically, you’re the one who brought it home,” he complained, as he looked toward the kitchen, where the enormous antlers were still waiting to be properly finished. His brother followed his gaze. Together, they looked at the antlers.
Before dinner, Lucas had soaked them in warm water and scrubbed them clean. His brother had not approved of the toothbrush Lucas used to clean the grooves, but he had merely watched his fingernails disappear beneath the dirt before, when dinner was ready, taking him by the hand and leading him back to the sink. With his hands—the hands that had hunted deer—he carefully washed the hands Lucas had used to tend the antlers.
“You can’t even bring yourself to use the word kill.” His brother had sighed beside him that evening after eating the last piece of meat from his plate. And Lucas, still wearing his hair short then, did not contradict him. He knew his cheekbones were burning red, and so he said nothing.
He had never been able to contradict his brother.
It was on a morning much like that one that he brought Fanny home.
He gave the little dog an exceedingly thorough bubble bath, then took her around to visit the other dog friends. Fanny never developed much enthusiasm for playing with them. When he mentioned Fanny in his letters, his brother was conspicuously unimpressed. Lucas secretly found his brother’s aversion to animal hair rather amusing, but when he answered the letter, Lucas carefully checked both sides of the envelope for stray hairs before sending it.
He had also mentioned how much Klara loved Fanny.
Lucas could not say how many times he had written about Klara and the other children. He lay folded into the sofa, looking at the jacket hanging over the back of the dining chair, the jacket he usually pulled on when he went to the kindergarten. Perhaps, before long, he would discover exactly how often he had mentioned the children in his statement. He thought this as he took another swallow from the beer clenched in his hand.
Part of him imagined that the court would give him the innocence he was owed. That the voices whispering in shadows he could not see would never become testimony strong enough to send him to prison. Another part of him watched the silent front door. Watched the plates lying overlapped upon the dining table. And felt, with a small certainty he knew he should not possess, something opposite to fear.
He knew that the law and social morality were only partially overlapping things.
Even with his brother as a point of comparison, the crime they had placed upon Lucas was nearly a mortal one here. He could not tell whether he had simply drunk his beer too quickly or whether lack of sleep had made the room tilt around him. But when he imagined this community, where everyone knew everyone, convicting him for an accusation they all knew would never become true, placing a cross upon his back and exiling him to the end of the world, he somehow tasted something in his beer that was sweet and thick as blood.
They knew him. But was that his defence, or the reason he would die?
Where would they bury this guilty body? Lucas thought of the hills where they had once lain in wait to hunt roe deer. He thought of the farm where, as children, they had ridden upon one another’s shoulders to steal apples. He thought of the cave where they had voted Bent into becoming the last emperor.
He remembered the sound of little streams running over the grass of the hills in late spring and early summer. He remembered the natural scent of spruce needles and the soft rustling they made when the wind moved through the valleys. He remembered the streaks left in his vision when squirrels and hedgehogs darted past.
He remembered.
He remembered.
He remembered.
When the postman slammed the letter slot shut, Lucas did not hear the envelope strike the floor.
He was lost inside his own consciousness, before he could find a place in which to rest.
-
It was Fanny who pulled him from the sheets.
The little thing had grown stronger than Lucas. One of the front teeth they had accidentally knocked crooked during a game of tug-of-war the year before clamped onto his sleeve and dragged him onto his favourite rug. “Fanny, good girl. Next time you can just call Papa to wake him.” He rubbed his reddened elbow and shuffled toward the door.
Lucas stepped over pyjamas abandoned in the hallway on some forgotten day, half a piece of bread left on the dining table after a single bite, and a tie hanging from the umbrella stand. He opened the door. The early-winter wind swept across his knees, and only then did he realize he had forgotten his blanket. “Something wrong?” He asked.
The men standing outside showed him their police badges.
Suddenly, the question seemed as unnecessary as the blanket.
The way back to his bedroom was the same procession of forgotten things, except this time he ate the other half of the bread. The questioning would probably take a long time. His hands trembled as he buttoned his shirt, but not because of the cold beyond the bedroom door. His brother was always complaining in his letters about incompetent psychiatrists and lawyers, saying they were less perceptive than a kindergarten child.
Well. Kindergarten children really could accomplish quite a lot.
He found himself thinking this and, with some surprise, realized he still had enough room in his mind for a joke.
Perhaps it was hereditary. He left the room with heavy steps and, with the hand still dusted with bread crumbs, gave Fanny one last pat on the head. When they placed him inside the police car, Lucas looked back at his front door. Cold. Empty. Heavy. That half-dead cactus looked almost the same as it had when he moved in.
What kind of person thinks growing a cactus here is a good idea? He wondered this as he took the phone from his pocket and handed it to the officer on his right. The last message on the screen was one he had sent to Bruun, asking him to come by and check on his dog when he had time.
“You have another voicemail.” The officer idly scrolled through his phone. “No name. One-night stand?” He nudged Lucas in the shoulder with his elbow.
For a moment, the enormous antlers in his bedroom flashed before Lucas’s eyes. Lately, whenever he drifted between sleep and waking, he saw a stag standing in the doorway of his kitchen. Its coat was dark and glossy, like the plumage of a crow. It would simply stand there and look at him. Then Lucas would blink, and it would be gone. He remembered the stories his brother used to tell him as a child. Legends of men with antlers. He remembered his brother mentioning, in the letter, how much they had always loved that particular theme.
They.
Yes.
His brother and his other half.
In his last letter, his brother had written that they had settled in a small village somewhere in South America. He had even asked whether Lucas might come spend New Year with them.
What had Lucas written back?
Lucas stared through the window at the passing streets. The early-winter sunlight traced the silhouettes of trees across his optic nerves. From the shadows, sheets of paper seemed to take flight.
His brother had complained that Maryland winters were too long. Said his husband’s dogs might enjoy playing with Fanny. Said Lucas should bring Marcus and spend the summer with them. Said there was a tall cactus growing in their front yard.
He said. He said. They said. They said—
They said Lucas should write back.
“I’ve never had a one-night stand.” Outside the window, a forest path he had once loved slipped past. He knew the path ended at his favourite hill. He watched the gravel disappear beneath the branches and leaves. “My family only believes in lasting relationships,” he said at last. No one in the car heard him.
Suddenly, he missed the palms that had once held his hands while his brother washed them. Suddenly, he wanted to see the tall cactus in his brother’s yard.
-
The interrogation seemed to occupy a gray territory, much like theft. If you were the grand thief who stole the Incan crown, you would spend the rest of your life behind bars. But if you were a child barely into secondary school who slipped a packet of sandwich cookies from a grocery store, then even if someone noticed, the punishment would hardly be severe.
Interrogation was much the same. If you were drunk and accidentally pressed the accelerator hard enough to drive into your neighbor’s yard, the police might simply open another beer for you. But if you were an adult man who had used his position as a childcare worker to abuse several young children, what you were more likely to receive was an elbow driven into your stomach and five hours of the same questions, asked until the words became meaningless.
How long have you known these children? Since they were born.
How do you normally interact with them? I’m their childcare worker. I play with them.
Do you know the parents of these children? Yes. We’re friends.
He stared at the fluorescent tube above him, at the desiccated bodies of insects trapped inside it. They hung there like the elephant in the room, unresolved.
The bruise beneath Lucas’s ribs continued to burn faintly beneath his sweater.
So, you showed several children your genitals?
“What?” The word escaped before he could decide what the appropriate response might be. His brows twisted together like towels tangled in a washing machine. His brown eyes belonged to a fawn that had just heard a gunshot.
“It’s only a supposition. You can deny it—” The officer across from him narrowed his eyes. His tone was as careless as the teenagers in a bar who dilute their liquor with water. “—or you can confess. We could end this pointless tug-of-war a little sooner.” Again, he gestured toward Lucas’s chin. His hand moved through the air in the same vague motion Grethe had made in her office that day.
“How could I—”
“The children’s statements are very detailed.” The man suddenly reached across the table and caught Lucas’s trembling hands. His greasy thumb, accustomed to worrying the tip of a cigar, rubbed over the butcher’s knife scar on the back of Lucas’s hand. The implication in his voice was like an excess of elk fat, dragging at the little food remaining in Lucas’s stomach, forcing it upward without mercy. It took everything Lucas had not to vomit onto the table.
“They even remember the colour of the wallpaper in your basement.” The man leaning against the interrogation room door said it with smug satisfaction.
The spasm in Lucas’s esophagus abruptly stopped.
“Wallpaper.” He repeated the word. His voice had the uneven grayness of something weathered by years.
The officer across from him nodded. When he withdrew his hand, irritation thickened his voice. “We’ll collect information from your house after the interrogation.” He raised both hands toward Lucas one last time. “Whether or not you like what we find there.”
Lucas stared at his greasy palms. Within the range of his vision, something emerged from nowhere. As the haze receded, it became a stag taller than a grown man. The dullness in Lucas’s eyes softened suddenly, as though warmth had been pressed into it with an iron. “Why not go now, gentlemen?” He shook his head. “No one here believes my statement anyway.”
-
They did not find the legendary wallpaper.
“The blueprints show that the architects left no space for a basement level,” said the officer who had previously been leaning against the door, his voice dry. “At least, nothing larger than three square meters.” The other one’s gaze remained fixed on Lucas, cold and severe. “Certainly not enough room for the sofa bed they described.”
Lucas watched them drive across his front lawn and leave. The tire tracks would probably take until next summer to disappear. But he really couldn’t care less.
“Yeah. I was wondering if I should dig one myself.” He said it to Fanny, who was whining beside him.
The tie still drooped from the handle of the umbrella stand. The blanket stretched from the back of the sofa to the dining-room doorway. Between them lay mud and weeds tracked through the house by the officers as they searched. Lucas stood in the middle of his home, which looked as though a bachelor party had passed through it. For the first time, he could smell helplessness in his own house.
Fanny’s bowl was empty. So was his pantry.
The corner leading upstairs was wet and slick with mud. Three inches or so of wallpaper had been torn away from the wall. The scattered contents of the storage shelves seemed to have acquired the scent of strangers, sitting in silence as they looked back at him.
He saw the stag from his imagination standing among the clutter. It lowered its head to Lucas’s box of letters and sniffed. A heavy breath moved through its nostrils.
Perhaps a walk would be a good idea. He ignored the animal in the room and led Fanny toward the backyard. “Papa’s going to buy you your favourite treats. You wait here for Papa to come home, okay?” He said it, but he could not bring himself to let go of the warmth of Fanny in his hand. At least Fanny was still beside him. Later, when the verdict was finally announced, perhaps Marcus would have a chance to come and stay with him, too.
At least today, Fanny is here.
When everyone in the store began devouring what remained of his sanity with looks meant for a plague-ridden man; when the manager shouted at him and ordered him to leave; when the employee who had always adored Fanny struck him across the bridge of his nose with the very fist that had secretly fed his dog so many times—he kept telling himself: Just a little longer. Just a little longer. Fanny is waiting for him at home, waiting for him and the treats in his hands.
When Marcus’s mother threw a beer bottle at him, Fanny stood between them, barking furiously at Kirsten. When Marcus cried and begged Lucas to let him stay, Fanny seized Marcus’s backpack between her teeth and refused to let go. When teenagers passing the house in the early morning and late at night began throwing smooth stones into his front yard, Fanny ran outside and chased them away.
No matter what happens, at least Fanny will still be beside him.
-
His Fanny was not waiting for him.
What was waiting for him was a black garbage bag.
-
A torrential downpour is unusual in the mountains at the beginning of winter. Rain gathers in the mud before him, each drop sending rings across the surface. He cannot tell whether they are made by rain or by tears.
At their last supper, Father had said that when there was no guarantee everyone would survive, one person surviving was victory enough. When his brother helped him into the carriage all those years ago, he told Lucas that he had to carry the family name forward. Whether they ever reunited or not, there should be at least one of them left in the world. And now Lucas stands in the backyard of his own home, on property bearing his name. His son, whom the court has ordered to live with his mother, is preparing Christmas Eve dinner at the other end of the island. His friends, who were brothers without blood between them, have drawn the curtains over every window from which his house can be seen. And the daughter he brought home from a gas station five years ago lies soundlessly beside the mud, quieter than she has ever been.
At least one. Why does it sound so much like a curse?
He remembers Father placing the hunting rifle into his hands, telling him never to hesitate once his finger was behind the trigger. He remembers Mother giving him the name Sforza, telling him never to forget whose child he was. He remembers his brother carrying his sister from the estate. He remembers his sister, left forever in that winter. He remembers the laughter they once shared around the same dining table. He remembers the day the steward sounded the alarm, remembers how his sister clung to his shoulders and cried into his ear.
Brother won't let you touch the brick walls. He remembers carrying his sister into the passage that day.
Brother will come back for you. He'll take you all away. He remembers saying it as he climbed into the carriage bound for Denmark.
Wait a little longer. Until spring. Until morning. Until the war is over.
Wait a little longer. Until every death has been announced. Until the loneliness becomes something that cannot be escaped. Until there is no one left to carry the name, Sforza.
There had been another rainy day like this. Lucas had driven his Volvo to a gas station, intending to buy some chocolate from the convenience store for his son, who was refusing to speak to his mother because of his report card. That was the day he first saw his good girl, Fanny. It took him three minutes to decide to bring the furry, smelly little rag home. He forgot all about the chocolate.
There had been another rainy day like this, too. He had stood in the clinic corridor, anxiously biting at his thumbnail until the doctor finally opened the door and told him that mother and child were both safe. They placed the tiny bundle into his trembling arms. It was not until Kirsten reached up and touched his arm that he realized the towel around his son was soaked with his tears. “My parents and I were thinking of calling him Marcus,” his wife had said. “Good. Marcus. Good. Of course,” he had repeated through tears.
And there had been another rainy day when he carried his backpack into the house Father had left him. The furniture was covered in dust sheets. The kitchen and dining room were empty. The bedroom held a bed large enough for three. Beyond the bedroom window, the backyard was filled with tulips his sister would have loved. But Lucas stood alone in that room. He had less talent for arranging a home than Father. Less culinary imagination than Mother and his brother. Less skill with flowers and growing things than his sister.
He was only Lucas Sforza.
A deserter.
A traitor.
The least useful thing in the family.
A tear slipped from the end of his nose and fell into the mud beneath him. The puddle reflected a face almost indistinguishable from his brother's. Lucas remembered his brother's face on the wanted poster. Features sharper and more defined than his own, an expression far more composed, a family more deserving of everything that had been bestowed upon them. He would always remember that it was his brother who walked out of the snow.
Not him.
He remembered the year his brother rebuilt his life in Italy. He remembered the years his brother spent in the hospital. He remembered the letter telling him that together they had defeated the dragon. He remembered the day his brother wrote that they had been born again beneath those cliffs.
That was his brother. It had never been Lucas.
Perhaps the one who truly belonged to the past was not Fanny at all, but him.
Perhaps his sister's place in that winter had never been his to take.
Perhaps.
Perhaps—
“Hello, Lucas.”
He turned sharply.
A man stood in the rain behind him, holding an umbrella.
Same height. Same hair colour. Same features.
Different clothes. Different bearing. Different voice.
Another night of rain. Behind the man, Lucas saw the tall stag slowly emerge from the downpour, its coat black and glossy as a crow's feathers. Its eyes were dark as his brother's. They stared directly at him. At the emptiness in his eyes. At the violence he could feel gathering somewhere beneath it. As though it were merely observing. As though it had always been a participant.
“Hannibal.” He heard himself say it.
Chapter Text
“You never wrote back.” He watched Hannibal slowly approach him. Only when the man reached out to brush the strands of hair hanging before his eyes aside could he finally see his features clearly. Lucas narrowed his brown eyes at the man before him. More prominent scars, a more natural disguise. A more vivid instinct for killing, a more imperceptible—
No. There was no death in those reddish-brown eyes. Not even a trace. After all, Hannibal Lecter was not Lucas Sforza. He would not be seized by those sudden, inexplicable urges toward self-destruction.
Lucas let his gaze trace the indistinct features of the man emerging from the shadows, reconstructing the face from memory. The face beneath the South American sun in the photograph tucked inside the greeting card. The face on the wanted poster. The face that had once pulled him over the gate of their own garden. The man’s hand supporting his was far warmer than his own skin, without dampness, without tremor, simply holding Lucas’s heavy, drowsy head steadily. Lucas pressed himself against his right hand and drew a deep breath—
Coffee, papaya, and cinnamon cream.
The smell of the kitchen.
The smell of home.
“Things lately have been taking up too much of my time.” Lucas rested his head against his brother’s palm and whispered to him, with the same caution they had once used for secrets murmured beside each other in bed as children. He narrowed his eyes at Hannibal’s, and, just as expected, found a trace of sly amusement there.
“Your brother has always believed he was your guardian.” The figure that emerged from the darkness behind him, blurred by the curtain of rain, was not some true creature of Lucas’s imagination cloaked in black feathers. The man with dark brown, half-length hair walked toward them one measured step at a time, rain stippling the surface of his black waterproof fabric like a night scattered across a clear sky. He stopped beside Hannibal and nodded at Lucas without offering his hand. “Will Graham. Sorry. Broke into your property before introducing myself.” He smiled somewhat awkwardly, without the same direct cunning in his eyes that Lucas saw in his brother’s.
Lucas blinked. This man seemed much more reserved than his brother, at least. He did not go wandering about dressed in the outward declaration of I like to kill people. If Lucas ignored the flash of blood in his eyes when he looked at Fanny beside him, he looked more like a mechanic, or some contractor who could appear at any house door without attracting a second glance. Perhaps that was precisely what made it the perfect human disguise, Lucas told himself. His brother’s husband not only cared very little for humanity, but cared a great deal about dogs. Lucas tightened his grip on the tool in his hand, and for the first time in a long while, a small sense of ease quietly filled him.
He was home.
-
Dinner was the best Lucas had had in years, even better than the meal at his bachelor party.
With the little food remaining in his house, his brother somehow managed to put together a feast. Meatball spaghetti, potato salad, and panna cotta. Lucas could not help but let out a somewhat excessive moan when he reached dessert, but fortunately Will, sitting across from him, made a similar sound at almost the same moment. “You really should have come to spend Folia de Reis with us earlier.” His brother patted Lucas’s empty hand after watching him devour the plate of panna cotta before him. “You would have loved my sweet bread.”
“That would be the best bread you’ve ever had.” The man across from him nodded, a little cream still caught along the edge of his beard, making him look younger than he really was, and making it even harder to imagine him as a wanted fugitive. That did not stop him from looking at Hannibal with an amused expression. “Though I’m certain no one could disapprove of your cooking, and you know that.” He said it with a wink toward the other wanted man sitting at the table.
His husband simply wiped away the trace he had not noticed with a napkin, offering no denial.
Sitting on the other side of the table, Lucas had already turned his attention back to his empty dessert plate when he saw his brother reach out, as if he was suddenly fascinated by the pattern printed upon it. He did his best to ignore the flash of smug amusement that crossed Will’s face, and equally hard to ignore the heat rising into his own cheeks. Around his brother, his self-control had always been particularly poor. He could never decide whether it was because he trusted his brother too completely in the role of family, or because in the presence of Hannibal and Will’s notorious perceptiveness, he knew there was nowhere he could hide.
Perhaps because this is home, he thought. Home is the womb of the mind. A person immersed in it is always naked.
From the dining room, he could see the bare patch of earth beyond the kitchen, exposed beneath the heavy rain. The earth where his little daughter lay buried, an incongruous blot of black against the gray backyard. When his brother set a cup of coffee before him, Lucas was imagining how the little insects Fanny had once loved to investigate would slowly consume fur and flesh and bone.
Dust to dust, earth to earth. Eventually, they would return to this dark, night-like wilderness.
“Is the taste in coffee hereditary too?” the man across from him asked, pulling Lucas back from the backyard and into his own dining room. He looked at the coffee his brother had placed before him—a milky white drink in which it was almost impossible to see any coffee—then at his brother’s husband’s cup. “Black coffee after dark will keep you awake.” The amusement had already entered Lucas’s voice before he realized it.
His voice trembled despite himself. It was only after saying the words that he realized how stiff his vocal cords had become. It had been so long since anyone had spoken to him properly. So long since anyone had treated him as a living person. If he had not noticed his nerves loosening since their arrival, he had now.
The other man merely blinked, giving him a half-smile through the steam rising from his coffee. It was an expression Lucas knew, though for a moment he could not remember where he had seen it before. “We may go out for a little while.” His brother sat down beside him, holding the same milky mixture whose caffeine content was impossible to determine. “It should not be long. Just a small but urgent matter to take care of.” His other hand rested on Lucas’s shoulder, moving in slow circles for a while, almost soothingly.
Lucas leaned toward him without thinking. His eyes followed the movement of Hannibal’s hand. His gaze travelled along the frightening scars on the inside of his brother’s arm until it reached his eyes. “But the rain will keep falling,” he said, trying as hard as he could not to sound like he was requesting them to stay.
He had lived here for more than thirty years and had never felt uneasy because of the woods stretching beyond the backyard. He knew there was nothing there. At this hour, in this weather, he would not even be able to see more than a few squirrels. But fear still hung above him like a suspended sword. He knew why. Everyone here knew where his fear came from. They simply did not speak of it.
“That is precisely why we need to go out in the storm.” The answer came from his brother’s husband. Will gave him that slightly awkward smile again. His most frequently worn human disguise, Lucas decided silently. Only now did he see the amusement buried beneath Will’s expression. It was so remarkably similar to Hannibal’s. A contempt for the world and everything in it, paired with an almost childlike curiosity. The amusement was not directed at Lucas. It was not malicious. But Lucas knew other people would call it something worse, a symptom of a conscience that had gone extinct.
He remembered what his brother had written in his letters. A profiler like an island unto himself. A friend who belonged to neither good nor evil. An equal adversary. A companion worth sacrificing freedom, or even life, to keep. Lucas looked again at the scars on his brother’s arm. They were marks only someone who truly belonged to the family could have left. Whether Will had done it himself or not, it was certainly his work.
He should have been angry. What surprised Lucas was that when he saw those marks with his own eyes, he felt none of the anger he believed he ought to feel. And when his brother looked down at his own hands, Lucas found no resentment in those red eyes, either.
Just as his brother had told him once: It’s all right. We are family. Family forgives.
Family. Lucas hid his face behind his coffee cup and tasted the word again.
“We’ll be home before breakfast tomorrow.” Hannibal’s hand remained against Lucas’s back, his body warmer now than when they had first met, almost shouting into Lucas’s ear that he was happy. He was happy about what awaited them outside later.
Family can forgive because we cannot lose family. We forgive those we cannot afford to lose.
And those we can afford to lose?
We lose.
He remembered Hannibal standing beside him in the kitchen of his home, this home, while Lucas was using a toothbrush to clean the branching antlers. He remembered what meat Hannibal was working a boning knife through. He remembered how many gunshots had sounded from the hills behind the house that morning, and how many dull thuds had followed as bodies fell into the snow. But it was alright. It was alright. Those were Hannibal’s preferences, and Lucas’s only concern was the enormous set of antlers before him.
Lucas decided not to ask what breakfast would be made of tomorrow.
The night rain would wash away the things he was still unwilling to look directly at.
-
They took the other set of keys from the cabinet by the door before leaving.
Lucas leaned against the crooked umbrella stand. The tie that should have gone into the washing machine long ago was clenched behind his back. He had promised to make the house as habitable as possible before they returned. “I haven’t seen a house this thoroughly bachelor-like in a very long time,” his brother said relatively diplomatically, while Will was far more direct. “He almost killed me for putting the bed outside the bedroom.”
“Really?” Lucas choked, standing in the middle of the wreckage and looking at the serial killers lowering their heads to button their coats.
“Not almost,” the older man answered. “I actually intended to.”
Lucas could not suppress the muffled laugh in his nose, and a tremor spread through the air between them. Hannibal’s favourite person to tease had always been him, whether to amuse his sister or simply when the two brothers were alone.
It was rare to see Hannibal toy with someone. Rarer still to see him so close to someone who was not bound to him by blood. Lucas was surprised to discover that it did not make him uneasy. He did not resent Will for what he had done to his brother, nor did he feel disgust at the intimacy between their bodies and lives. He did not even feel lost when Hannibal placed Will directly among them. Perhaps it was because this was someone that Hannibal could not afford to lose. Perhaps it was those impossibly blue eyes. Hannibal was confident they could get along, as family. Lucas decided to trust his brother, even as he realized that his gaze lingered on Will a little longer than it should.
They could try being friends. Lucas squeezed the silk in his hand and told himself this. Until he finds someone of his own.
Lucas had never imagined that the second half of his life would be lonely. He had had a family once, even if it had not worked out, and he did not believe that had been his fault, not according to his friends at least. His son came to stay at his house from time to time and would not object if Lucas found another partner. Occasionally, women around his age would sit beside him at a bar, and Lucas did not mind other people’s bodies drawing close to his, whether or not it ever became a kiss.
Lucas knew Hannibal had never intended to grow old with anyone. He had never dared to tell his brother so, but he had believed it was Hannibal’s problem. Or, in Hannibal’s own words, his own choice. Hannibal had decided there was no one in the world truly suited to him, no one who could see him clearly and still love the creature beneath it all. He and his brother had both believed such a person belonged to the realm of fantasy, until the younger man standing before them proved otherwise.
If his brother could find the person meant for him, why couldn't Lucas? He rubbed his thumb across the smooth silk. Plus, he never had his brother’s questionable hobbies. He was only an ordinary middle-aged man.
He watched Will straighten Hannibal’s coat, effortlessly, as though he had practiced it a million times.
There would always be a man or woman who appreciated him. Someone who would love him with the same devotion, all the way to the end of their lives. Lucas thought.
“You would have killed me for something much worse.” Under the brothers’ watchful eyes, the younger man leisurely fastened the final button. “Fortunately, I’ve always been rather good at dealing with your complaints with my excellent tongue and throat.” He winked at his husband, his voice deliberately loud enough to make sure his younger brother heard.
A pause.
Lucas, lost in his own hazy imaginings, suddenly crashed back into his body as though a fruit had fallen into a river and was being carried helplessly downstream. If he had managed even an hour of proper sleep during the previous twenty-four hours, perhaps he might have found a more dignified response to any of this, or at least a gentler one. Instead, all he could do was fall speechless when he understood what his brother’s husband had implied, then watch helplessly as they said goodbye, took the house keys, and walked out the door.
What?
The entryway light switched itself off.
His brother said nothing. He did not even look back at him. Lucas could feel sweat running down his spine.
The entryway before him lurched violently in his vision. The coffee he had swallowed half an hour ago crawled back up his throat like that little piece of bread from the morning. Again, he saw the hills where they had once lain in wait, the barn in which that farmer discovered them, the cave of the last emperor, the spruces, the squirrels, the river, the mountain wind—
The silk in Lucas’s hand was like an oxygen mask clutched before a crash, its tiny folds a final testament written without words.
Why?
“Why?” The light on the center console suddenly came alive, and Hannibal, seated on the left, turned to look at his husband on the right.
This time they were driving a family-sized Mercedes. When Hannibal had told the salesman he preferred white, his husband had stood beside him and paid no attention to his habit of deciding everything himself. It was a natural arrangement between them: outside the house, everything went according to Hannibal; at home, everything went according to Will. Hannibal particularly enjoyed this arrangement when other people were present. “He’s a shy child. Sometimes even more so than Lucien.” He said it as he drove onto the narrow lane leading to his brother’s house.
Lucien was the newest addition to their family, a beautiful Sheltie. Although Hannibal insisted that he had found Lucien at the end of an alley near the farmers’ market, even three-month-old Lucien would never have believed the nonsense. Will had no intention of blindly accepting Hannibal’s assessment of Lucas, either.
“He looked considerably more enthusiastic about me than you predicted.” Will pushed a small huff of laughter through his nose, ignoring Hannibal’s deliberately solemn expression as he studied the climate controls on the center console. “Don’t give me that look like this wasn’t your idea. Save it for when he points a gun at you.” He switched the ventilation from outside air to recirculation, then took one last look at the insulated container they had left in the back seat through the rearview mirror. “Which probably won’t be very far in the future.”
Hannibal, meanwhile, continued slowly down the road Lucas had once taken to the kindergarten and reached over to take Will’s left hand where it rested between them. “He won’t point a gun at me. I’m his brother,” he said, lowering his head to kiss the back of Will’s hand. “He won’t point one at you, either.”
“Because I’m his brother’s husband, or because he wants me?” Another small huff of laughter.
“Because you’re family.” Another kiss.
-
Three hours later, sitting beside the empty bookshelf, Lucas finally gave in to despair. There was absolutely no way he could conjure his brother’s home here before they returned. He could not even finish sorting this one bookshelf. His books, his son’s books, and the books belonging to his son’s mother. His own child psychology, introductory origami, and home gardening. His son’s pop art, comics with Batman on their covers, and forensic investigation. His son’s mother’s secrets of success, furniture maintenance, and an Italian fashion magazine.
It was hopeless. Lucas almost thought that keeping an introduction to forensic investigation here was a joke no one would ever laugh at.
It was not as though he was the sort of person who needed to please others. At least with his brother, he had never felt any obligation to do so. But what had happened three hours ago remained painfully vivid. Hannibal’s silence, Will’s amusement, his own bewilderment. The scene had replayed itself before his eyes for three hours, and predictably for the foreseeable future, without ever giving him an answer as to what it had meant. Was it by accident, or deliberate? If deliberate, had it been his brother’s idea, or Will’s? What had they intended? Were they testing the fragile remains of his moral boundaries, or offering him an indirect warning, telling him that whenever he looked at Will, he ought to remember that Will was his brother’s husband?
Despair. His limbs went slack, and he let gravity throw his body onto the sofa beside him like a fish cast onto shore.
The upholstery carried the scent of his favourite fragrance, the one Kirsten used to burn on the coffee table when she still lived here. Something between forest and almond. It had always brought him peace, even on the days when they fought. Now, sitting alone with his nose buried in the fabric, even the scent that had once soothed him most could not calm him.
Father had once said that even if Lucas were the last one left alive in the family, he would be proud of him. His brother had once said that there should always be at least one member of their family left in the world, no matter which one of them it was. Mother had left him Sforza. His sister had left him everything beyond the snow. The estate that had once been wealthy beyond measure became empty in a single day, at the very moment Lucas inherited everything he had now.
He had already been given everything. Everything his brother had never had. Everything his family had never had. And yet somehow, he still wanted more.
He was coveting what belonged to his brother. His brother’s most precious possession.
Greed. Lucas fought back his tears. This is what lies beneath his everything.
He remembered seeing his brother again in the backyard a few hours earlier, their outward similarities set against everything that was different within them. He remembered the intensity of murder in his brother’s eyes and the heavy weight of death inside his own. He remembered the scent of coffee beans, papaya, and cinnamon cream on his brother’s palm. They had eaten breakfast at home before coming here. They had shared the same dining room, bathed and dressed in the same bathroom, slept in the same bed. They were partners. No matter how similar Lucas and Hannibal’s features might be, he would never be the husband who slept beside Will.
He was not the Lecter who deserved to be blessed.
He was the Sforza who deserved to be cursed.
Lucas tilted his head back and looked around his large, empty house. Tears traced the too-familiar planes of his cheekbones and fell onto the cover of the gardening book in his hands.
Thou shalt not covet thy neighbour's house; thou shalt not covet thy neighbour's wife.
This could never become another home for his brother.
-
Lucas never finished the bookshelf. He placed the Italian fashion magazine in the most conspicuous position, then hid the most embarrassing books beneath the bed in the upstairs bedroom. There was almost nothing more he could do with the bedroom. All he could manage was to take the set of sheets from the wardrobe. It was far too soft for his liking. Now he could only use them to soften the omnipresent bachelor air. They were dark red, bought by his son’s mother during a mall sale. None of them liked silk bedding, but there had been no way to return it, so the sheets had remained in the wardrobe until the matter was quietly forgotten.
There. Another testament to good intentions exceeding ability. When Lucas heard the front door open, he did not even realize he was sighing.
He felt like a child who had reached the end of a weekend without finishing his homework.
When he entered the dining room, his brother was carrying the fruit they had bought at the morning market into the kitchen. His brother’s husband followed behind him and nodded to Lucas as he came through the door.
“Apple pie today.” He lifted the bag of fruit in his hand, unmistakably pleased. “I didn't expect there to be so many good ingredients in this weather. They even had apricots.” His eyes brightened as he looked at Lucas.
Lucas could only hope Will had not noticed the fists tightening at his side.
Fortunately, his brother had decided to make the Danish æblekage rather than the apple pie they used to have in the States. More fortunately still, Hannibal called him over to the sink. “There ought to be a Dane supervising me if we're going to show this dessert the respect it deserves.” Hannibal smiled as he handed him a bread knife. “You cut the bread. I handle the apples.”
When Lucas took the knife, he could almost feel Hannibal's warmth travelling through the metal handle into his palm, pumping along his veins into the rest of him. It had been years since he had stood beside his brother in a kitchen like this, since the day his brother had given him that enormous set of antlers.
Would there be opportunities like this again? Lucas felt the warmth of Hannibal beside him and wondered suddenly. His brother had a family now. Perhaps Lucas would have one again himself, before long. Ever since Hannibal found that he could not bring himself to use the word kill, he had never asked Lucas about his feelings toward killing again. Hannibal had accepted that he would never deliberately hurt another person. They were not so obviously alike in that regard. But Lucas did not know whether that meant his brother no longer wanted to share a kitchen with him.
Food was how they communicated. At least, it was how Hannibal communicated. Lucas never cared what kind of meat his brother placed on his plate, but closing his eyes and finishing whatever was put before him could not sustain the bond between them. Family cooked food for one another with love. Family felt happiness when the other ate what they had made. Lucas had received so much from his brother and had no way to repay the care behind it. He let his brother express his affection without ever offering his own feelings in return.
He remembered the letters he had never answered. The concern his brother had poured through the letter slot.
“I can whip the cream first.” He spoke before he realized what he was saying, but he did not look at Hannibal's hands as they folded the apple mixture with a spatula. His head remained lowered over the bread cubes. They were cut somewhat too finely. Hannibal seemed not to notice his unease. He simply placed the still-cold carton of cream in front of Lucas. “In a good mood today?” he teased when Lucas reached for it.
“I eat when I'm alone, too.” His younger brother's face reddened as he tried not to remember the empty pantry they had found when they came home.
“Then perhaps I should leave dinner to you.” Hannibal looked thoughtful. “We found some good quality meat.”
Even knowing he ought to accept the invitation hidden inside his brother's words, Lucas could only suppress his unease and lower his head. “I can take care of the vegetables.” He spoke almost in a whisper, his breathing too heavy in the narrow space between them. “Handling the meat at your table would be presumptuous.” His voice trembled on the final syllable. His molars ached from how tightly he clenched them.
Hannibal simply patted the arm pressed against his. “This is your table,” he said softly. “Ours.”
Family cooks food for one another with love. Family is happy when they eat what they have made.
The enormous antlers Hannibal had given him appeared before Lucas's eyes, along with the great stag he always saw, its coat black and glossy as raven feathers. The night rain was unable to wash the sin from it completely. But was it the real stag that had died beneath their guns, or something his mind had invented? If he were a faithful man, he thought suddenly, this would be the question he brought before God. What was he seeing? The antlers hanging above his bedroom, or the incarnation of the man standing beside him? And was that incarnation his most beloved brother, or the wanted criminal who regarded the living as livestock? What had kept him from preparing dinner for his brother all these years? His seemingly unshakable morality, or the stinginess he had never wanted to confront in himself—the stinginess he reserved for his brother?
Feeding and eating. Giving and answering. Offering and returning.
When he left his hometown alone in that carriage. When he used the key to open this door. When he walked among the mountain winds and spruce trees. When he watched movies with his wife and son. When he buried Fanny beneath that heavy earth. Everything he had enjoyed had been a gift from his brother. His brother could have taken his place on that carriage. He could have laid the death of their sister at Lucas's feet. He could have imprisoned him for the decades that followed and forced him to endure everything he believed he deserved. But he did not. His brother had been merciful as a god, and even after absolving Lucas of his sins, he had continued to give him his boundless care, year after year, decade after decade.
Everything he possessed was like those enormous antlers. His life. His thoughts. Every part of him came from Hannibal's grace.
“The rain stopped,” Hannibal said suddenly beside him.
Lucas looked toward the brightening sky. He did not look at his trembling hands again. What he owed his brother had never been his death or his defeat. He had spent more than thirty years as an apostate, ignoring his brother's devotion through all those thousands upon thousands of days, even when he could have answered it, even when all his brother wanted was a dinner prepared by his hands. A plate of properly cooked meat.
“Will there be a recipe that you like for the meat?” He heard his own voice echo beneath the vaulted ceiling.
When Christians give thanks at the table, which God do they imagine they are thanking?
He heard Hannibal's low laugh, reverberating through the sanctuary between them.
Chapter 3
Notes:
"Apple sauce is yummy mud." - @project hail jilia
I have been thinking about this quote for weeks.
Hail random-bullshit-Will-Graham.
Chapter Text
He liked the taste of breakfast more than he had expected.
Hannibal was still seated to his right, and Will was still sitting opposite him. In the middle of the table were rye bread (Hannibal was very reluctant to admit that he had bought it from a shop), the dessert they made together, berries, and sausage with eggs. “The first time we met, he drove with this stuff for an hour to find me at the motel.” The man across from him gestured toward the sausage and eggs, teasingly, with the scent of black coffee hanging over the table. “Of course, he didn't tell me what kind of meat was in it.” He gave a little hum.
The man between them merely spread butter over his bread with unhurried precision. “I'm glad you eventually figured it out for yourself.” He raised an eyebrow at his husband, then turned to pat his brother's hand. “Though the sausage today was bought at the market. Forgive me for not having had time to prepare it myself.”
There was something almost lonely in the way he said it. Lucas choked slightly before lowering his head and offering an especially quiet It's all right.
Water pattered from the eaves over the backyard. By the time Lucas realized it was because he had neglected to clean the gutters for some time, Will had already taken a few steps toward the door after finishing his coffee. “The gutters?” The man still holding his mug looked at him, then gave a small hum when Lucas nodded sheepishly. “Do you have a ladder tall enough to reach them?” Will asked, glancing through the open back door at the height of the exterior wall. “At least four meters,” he murmured.
“I do—” Lucas stood too quickly, his knee striking the dining chair beside him. He choked in a sharp breath, immediately drawing the attention of the other two men in the house. “You hate others touching your things?” Will turned to face him, his voice carrying a restrained note of caution. “N-no.” Lucas groaned, clutching his injured knee. “It's just that I've never tried cleaning them myself.” His face grew reddish as he said it. He was always so humiliatingly helpless in front of Hannibal, always the weaker child. After all these years, somehow this had only become worse. Will raised an eyebrow at the gutters outside. “You're a big boy. You can handle these little chores yourself, can't you?” he asked, tilting his head at Hannibal's younger brother. When Lucas nodded again, face burning, Will set down his coffee. “Come on. Show me your tools.” His hands went into his pockets, his tone oddly reminiscent of the way Lucas coaxed the children into eating their fruit.
As they crossed the threshold between the kitchen and dining room, Hannibal's voice followed them from the kitchen. “I'll bring my boys some coffee and pastries later.”
Will let out a loud whistle ahead of him. “Yummy mud!”
Lucas could only lower his head and follow him outside, like a dog with enough self-awareness to know better.
-
The ladder had been left where the garden trellis was originally meant to stand. “So how did you clean the gutters before this? A maintenance company?” Will inspected the rust along the length of the ladder. It was obvious that no one had used it in some time, and even more obvious that its owner had never understood the point of maintenance. He decided not to tease the man behind him about it and simply waved Lucas over.
“Theo and Johan used to do it.” Lucas did not speak until they had extended the ladder and set it in the proper position, a sigh woven into his voice. “But after everything that happened, I don't think they'll be coming here anymore.”
They had been playmates since childhood. Johan was a few years younger than them, while Theo had been born the same year as Lucas. They had been best friends from the day Lucas moved here until only a few weeks ago. Lucas had once believed they would always be friends. He knew Theo had once believed the same. But was any of this because of him? This had been an entirely undeserved catastrophe for Lucas. Then was it Theo’s fault? Because a man who valued his family above everything had decided to protect his young daughter? That was even more absurd.
It was no one's fault. At least, it was not a tragedy anyone had intended. That was the saddest part.
“Do you resent them?” The man beside him spoke softly.
Lucas lowered his head and said nothing.
He had never imagined any of this happening to him. Yet when these things, these insults and acts of violence, had actually fallen upon him like hail, he still could not bring himself to blame them. If he had been in Theo's place, if a principal had called him one day to tell him that a teacher had behaved inappropriately toward his son, and that this terrible teacher happened to be the best friend he had known for decades—Lucas knew he would not have been able to stop himself from breaking the guy's nose. So if he could not restrain his own impulse, how could he demand that someone else remain calm in the face of such a crisis, let alone find room for compassion because of all the good Lucas had once done?
He could not find the words. But the man beside him turned to face him, with only the ladder between them. And when Lucas looked at him, he saw a grief in Will's eyes too intense to conceal. “They hurt your family,” Will whispered. Lucas knew what he meant. He knew what lay buried behind them.
“But—” Lucas drew a breath. He tried to release the reservations lodged inside him, but his throat seemed to constrict around the words, making his voice sound like a hinge left to rust for years. He had not expected Will to take another step forward, coming within arm's reach. In the dozen hours since they had appeared, they had never stood so close. Close enough for Lucas to almost smell the anger carried in Will's breath.
“What if it had been your son?” His voice held a coldness Lucas had never heard from him before.
Lucas froze.
Blood reached his amygdala before his mind could comprehend it, yet he still felt as though he could not draw enough air. The food that had entered his stomach an hour earlier twisted upward again beneath the spasms of his digestive tract, like the filling of a pie, or spirits in Hell searching for an exit, frightened and screaming and spending every last ounce of strength trying to escape. He could barely feel himself breathing. He couldn't—he would never allow anyone to lay a hand on Marcus. Even the thought of someone looking at his son with improper intentions was enough to awaken something murderous inside him, let alone—
“When you speak for them, don't forget Fanny.” The voice like melting snow passed through his ear again. “Don't forget that it could have been your son.”
Marcus appeared before his eyes, immersed in a pool of blood. His brown hair slowly disappeared into the red beneath him. His eyes, always following his father, became dim and empty. His nostrils fluttered, but only more crimson flowed from them. Lucas's breathing trembled. He looked at the man beside him—black feathers like a raven's, extending from the ends of his hair all the way to his shoulders, covering every piece of human flesh on his body as though they were truly feathers. He saw his own pale face reflected in their oily sheen. He saw features too much like Hannibal's trembling between the feathers, until even he could no longer tell which of the two he was looking at.
He had never asked his brother why they had been made to consume the flesh of those soldiers. He had never asked what they tasted like. He had never imagined what it would feel like to chew the flesh of men steeped in sin. He had never known this kind of catastrophic hatred, never known the suffocation of despair. But it was not because he had no feelings. Only now did he understand that he had never been indifferent to any of it. It was the reason disciplined by society, trained by morality, that had forgiven the sinners he should have condemned before he had ever been allowed to taste the flavour of his own hatred.
His hatred was a great tree standing on the mountain, silent and unmoving. Wind and rain passed through it, leaving behind nothing but the whisper of leaves. Only when you tore away its wall-like bark, when you hacked through layer after layer of restraint, watching the plant that had grown into a giant within its silence finally collapse with a force that shook the heavens and thundered through the valley, would people understand the hatred he truly carried. Only then would they understand its weight.
“That could have been you.” The half-beast beside him finally said it, then shrugged and withdrew his feathers.
Lucas looked into his blue eyes. The intense, naked grief that had been there before was gone, replaced by something pure, something he could not yet identify. Many, many years ago, there had been another creature who knew the shape of forbidden things, lying beside a human who had conceived a forbidden desire, persuading them to bite into the fruit heavy with juice.
Many, many years later, Lucas looked at the dark companion beside him and finally understood why their eyes had brightened after eating the forbidden apple, why they had never begged the gods for forgiveness after leaving the Eden that had once been paradise.
Only when you understand what you have lost in pursuit of something do you truly receive its corresponding reward. Restraint was no longer his obligation. Revenge would be his right. Before his eyes came the images again and again: the light fading from people's eyes, their breathing slowly ceasing, their bodies growing cold under his hands. He saw his true family beside him, wiping away his final tear, washing the blood from his hands, preparing a magnificent dinner for him.
They would feast upon the flesh of the sinful. They would use their own bodies to cleanse them of their sins, and with these hands, send them into Heaven.
-
The air after the rain carried a scent of melancholy. Lucas drew a deep breath through his nose, and the hand holding the end cap of the gutter trembled with it, dislodging a little of the rainwater still trapped inside. The wind passed through, bringing the wet cold against his face. Even though he had been born and raised in the north, he still disliked winter.
“Once you actually get your hands dirty, you find out it isn’t as complicated as you thought, don’t you?” Will, standing below and leaning against the ladder, took the garbage bag from him. His eyes were bright as though they had been washed clean by the rain. Lucas glanced at him and sniffed again. “That’s because I had an expert here.” He began climbing down slowly. “If I were alone, I probably would have called the company.”
Will gave a very audible sigh beside him. “Your brother will absolutely suggest that we stay here permanently because of that.” He caught Lucas’s unsteady elbow during the last few steps, holding him until he was steady, then made quotation marks in the air with his fingers. “Suggest.”
His exaggerated expression, combined with the scars on his face, made him look genuinely angry. But the levity in his voice was too obvious, like an excess of cream stirred into coffee, softening the unsettling aroma. Lucas covered his quietly warming elbow with one hand and merely shook his head, refusing to respond to Will’s teasing about Hannibal. He knew Will was watching him, which left him even more at a loss for words. “You don’t like going against your brother,” Will said again only after they had finished putting everything away. “He punished you when you were younger?”
“How would he—” Lucas blurted the words out before realizing it was bait. Will was still watching him from the other end of the fishing line, openly amused. “Of course he didn’t.” Lucas sighed. He began to understand more and more why his brother was so fascinated by this man. “It’s just that he was too perfect as an older brother. I never had any desire to oppose him, whether it was his ideas or his actions.”
“Even after he ate all those people?” They were standing close enough that Lucas could almost hear Will’s eyelashes flutter.
He had not expected Will to be so direct, but this subject was easier for him than the one they had discussed an hour earlier. After all, he had known Hannibal longer than he had known himself. He knew how to package Hannibal’s words and actions as elegantly as merchandise; he had rehearsed it in his mind for decades. “In his eyes, those people,” he lowered his head and thought for a moment, several possible descriptions surfacing before he finally settled on a gentler one, “were no different from the animals raised for meat in the sausage industry.” He paused. Hearing neither agreement nor disagreement, he continued. “Perhaps even less than animals. Animals have no distinction between beauty and ugliness. Humans do. Not one of the people he killed was anything other than what he considered ugly.” Lucas nodded at the empty air before him. “And consuming them was a way of cleansing their sins. An act of mercy.”
They stood beside the neglected flowerpots in the backyard. The rainwater collected inside them answered their gazes in silence. “And you?” the man beside him asked again, his voice revealing nothing. “When you chew the meat he serves you, what do you think about?”
The piece of shoulder they had once shared appeared before Lucas. The delicate meat that should have been venison shoulder. Rich juices spilling from the side of the cut. The dark red of blackcurrants slowly seeping through its surface, bubbling, creeping over the meat, the rim of the plate, until it spilled from the edge of the table and onto him—
“About him, or about the meat?” His voice was stiff. He had never discussed any of this with anyone else.
The man beside him blinked. “Is there a difference?”
The question seemed to drain every remaining ounce of strength from Lucas. His perpetually hunched shoulders suddenly fell, leaving only his hands clenched at his sides. When he had received his brother’s letter telling him that Hannibal had butchered and skinned those sinful soldiers and consumed their flesh, he remembered how bewildered he had been. He had not understood why revenge had to take the form of cannibalism, nor why his brother, the gentlest, most courteous gentleman he had ever known, could become such a demon. He did not understand it, and for a very long time he refused to try. When he finally forced himself to confront it, it took him even longer to accept that this was something inherent to his brother, rather than some evil that had grown upon him.
Could he have such a sinful birthmark within himself as well? Had his father and mother, beneath their dignified and immaculate appearances, ever wondered how best to kill, dismember, cook, and consume? And their most cherished sister, the most treasured thing in the world, would she too have discovered, somewhere within the happiness she should have had, an instinctive desire for killing and consumption? Lucas did not know. He still did not know how to answer those questions, much less the man standing before him.
The worry he had felt several hours ago, standing beside Hannibal, about whether his brother would ever want to share a kitchen with him again now returned. He knew only that he ought to repent of his greed, that he ought to give something back to his brother. Yet even after his reason and desires forced him to confront his instincts, after making him examine every locked drawer inside himself, pulling out every thought he had once been unwilling or too frightened to scrutinize and inspecting each one anew, he still could not find Hannibal’s reflection there. He did not—and could not—experience the sense of fulfillment Hannibal felt while chewing. They were pieces of a puzzle cut from the same box, close enough to resemble one another, but never capable of fitting together.
Because his desire was not to consume.
“You know, although he has probably told you about all the ways we are alike,” Will said softly, a faint smile in his voice, “not only because of my empathy, or all those years I spent with the FBI. It’s because we are similar at our core.” He raised the hand resting between them and rubbed at the stubble Lucas had neglected since before he came outside. “He always likes to insist that we are the same kind of creature by nature. That we like to slaughter, like to play God, like to turn impolite things into a platter of smoked meats.” He paused, giving a disdainful little huff through his nose. “But that is what he likes. That is what the Ripper likes.”
Will lifted his head toward the brightening sky after the rain. His voice seemed to come from somewhere beyond the clouds. “We aren’t that much alike.”
Lucas watched his eyes, so blue they were almost translucent. “And that doesn’t…make you sad?” He chose the gentler word again.
But Will shook his head without hesitation. “Of course not.” He continued watching the distant clouds. “What he wants and what I want is simply for the other person to see us. I have never found cannibalism meaningful to me. I understand how he sees it, but it was never my thought.” He shrugged. “Hannibal knows what I like, just as I know what he likes. Affection is the reason we cherish one another, not a reason to force ourselves to become one another.”
Will turned toward the man beside him, looking at his trembling eyelids and clear eyes as though watching a cocoon slowly split open before him, the moist, delicate wings within gradually filling and unfolding, blooming from a dark-gray shell. It was an unparalleled beauty. Reborn. His vitality shone like stars in the dying winter. “Even when a person’s desire differs greatly from God’s will, he can still give himself over to God,” he said softly. “Even God’s own child has had moments when his wishes differed from those of his Father, and that never made him lose God’s love.”
Inhale. Exhale. He heard the sound of wings emerging somewhere beside his ear. In those golden-brown eyes there was nothing of the familiar crimson he most often saw in another pair of brown eyes. Instead, there was something deeper, denser, like blood beneath moonlight, cold and heavy after losing the protection of living flesh. It was the colour of death. Not violence, not dismemberment and reconstruction, but simply the desire to take a life.
How beautiful. Will thought.
“Come on.” He finally released a pale sigh into the cold air between them. “Your brother is going to say it was my fault if you catch a cold.”
“I’m older than you. I’m supposed to be the one taking care of you.” Lucas followed him toward the house without thinking, his voice carrying the same quiet complaint it had when they first appeared here yesterday afternoon. Even they could not hear the change in him. But Will remembered the viciousness he had seen in those eyes for the brief half-minute just now. Cold viciousness, savoured the rich possibilities of the man before him, of them, and of all the games they might someday play across this endless field of snow… “One day,” Will smiled, “you’ll be the one taking care of me and your brother.” His hand settled on the doorknob. Before opening the door, he gave one last little huff. “But not today.”
-
Lucas was not surprised to find Hannibal in the kitchen, nor was he surprised to find him working with the ground meat. The excellent meat he had mentioned that morning. “What is this?” He walked over to his brother and placed both hands on his hips, unwilling to let Hannibal see that they were trembling. “Medisterpølse.” Hannibal’s voice rose slightly, unmistakably pleased by his brother’s initiative, as he lifted a sausage stuffer from where it had been sitting nearby and brought it toward him. “I found this in your pantry, although I suspect you’ve never used it.” He smiled smugly. “Wasn’t yours?”
Lucas could only nod, his face flushing. “Kirsten bought it. My son’s mother.” He sighed. “She said it was too heavy and useless, so she left it with me. As if it wasn’t bought with my credit card.”
“Should I say I’m glad you two are no longer together?” Hannibal tilted his head toward him, without even the slightest trace of guilt in his eyes. “You know you deserve better.” And there was not a trace of insincerity in the words.
“I’m not as lucky as you.” His brother shook his head against the counter. “Most people aren’t as lucky as the two of you.”
“That depends on how strongly you desire something.” His brother continued to tilt his head as he watched him, not missing the involuntary twitch in Lucas’s neck and shoulders at the words. “And how much you are willing to pay for your desire. Even how much you are willing to lose.”
Hannibal reached for another kitchen knife lying on the towel. Its beautiful silver surface flashed beneath the movement, leaving a dangerous suggestion across Lucas’s optic nerves. “There are always people who willingly surrender what they desire because someone else already has it, without first attempting to confront their own longing, much less confess their desire.” He placed the knife between himself and his younger brother, its point facing himself. The blade reflected the stunned expression on his brother’s face, while his own eyes remained fixed solely on Lucas. “An attempt is merely one form of asking. Rejection is not an inevitable outcome.”
Lucas’s instincts told him he should not take the knife before him, but those same instincts told him he should obey his brother without limits.
“And what if the consequence of rejection is dangerous?” he heard his own voice tremble.
His brother smiled at him, his tone as gentle as ever. “Then nothing dangerous will happen to you.” There was not the slightest falseness in his gaze. There never had been. He had always been Lucas’s older brother, his true brother, his only family. Whatever suffering Lucas might endure in the future, it would never come from Hannibal. He looked at the knife before him, at the still-visible scars on his brother’s inner arm, at the traces of the South American sun upon his skin. He knew that even if he took the knife, drove it into his brother with all his strength, wounded him, made him bleed, left him with a scar that could never disappear, his brother would forgive him.
Because they were family. Family was something they could not afford to lose. They forgave what they could not afford to lose.
His faith stood before him, offering him a weapon capable of taking his life, giving him food, giving him strength, giving him absolute power, giving him an opportunity he would never receive from anyone else: an opportunity to share. “Are you…” The words escaped Lucas before he realized he didn’t have a gentler word to use. Everything before him had violated every boundary, had violated even the word boundary itself. Every belief, every god, every moral code, every discipline, every reason for self-restraint.
What remains in their world once there are no boundaries left?
In his delirium, the man before him slowly grew long antlers, like a pair of enormous hands enclosing him, separating him from everything beyond. He could no longer feel the light or warmth around him. There were no longer sounds or air. His senses slowly went numb until darkness seeped over him like a gentle current, entering his pores and blood vessels, ink-black branches stretching all the way to the ends of his capillaries, forming another self within his body.
“Tell me, what is your desire?”
Hannibal’s voice seemed to come from somewhere beyond the horizon, and yet from directly before him, like the vaulted ceiling suspended above their sanctuary, like an echo reverberating between his ribs. Only now did Lucas understand that family was not something heaven decided for you. Family was what the heart decided. And only now did Hannibal truly become his family. The vow he had chosen for himself, the beginning of his endless forgiveness, his guardian angel for the rest of his life.
His desire.
Lucas stared into the darkness before him. He saw the valley and the farm. Half a slice of bread on the table. The cactus by the front door. His phone. The metal door of the interrogation room. The black garbage bag. The damaged corner of the wall. The antlers hanging in his bedroom. He saw the black-crow feathers. The sealed bags in his refrigerator. The pale-red water in the sink. The blood overflowing from his plate. The gun locked inside his cabinet.
He heard the death of the great tree echo through the valley. He heard Fanny’s unanswered whimper. He heard Marcus’s screams as Kirsten dragged him out of the house. He smelled blood. He smelled Hannibal’s breath as he emerged from the snow. He smelled Mischa upon him. He smelled the presence of his father and mother.
“Hannibal.” He heard himself call.
“Lucas.” He heard his family answer.
He had come home.
Chapter Text
The dinnerware they used was the only set in Lucas’s house that could reasonably be called fine, but he clearly saw Hannibal almost drop the plate in his hands when he heard him say Kirsten bought that. “Careful, unless you enjoy calling her to ask where you can buy another set,” Will teased from the same seat, entirely unconcerned with Hannibal’s murderous glare. “And I don’t think inviting her over for dinner would be a particularly good idea, either.”
Lucas swallowed from across the table. “Would you invite Kirsten to dinner?” He blinked behind his glasses, looking first at his brother beside him, then at his husband across the table.
“Not so soon.” Hannibal placed a hand against Lucas’s uneasy back. “Before that, there are several friends we must entertain.” His tone was gentle, which only confirmed what Lucas had suspected from their conversation. “You—” He caught himself, then corrected, “—we would eat Kirsten?” His eyes fixed on the two men before him, but there was neither fear nor disgust in them, only a sincere desire to understand, buried beneath the layer of unease that seemed to perpetually surround him.
Will saw a flash of satisfied crimson in Hannibal’s eyes.
“Do you have other feelings toward Kirsten?” The man supporting Lucas slowly withdrew his hand and sat beside him, leaning forward in the same manner they had once sat together in his office. Will only glanced at him, making no attempt to interrupt his husband’s enjoyment of his brother’s transformation.
Lucas shook his head, lowering his gaze to the plate before him, where the sausages they had prepared that morning lay beside thinly sliced tenderloin. The surface of the meat carried a faint silver-green sheen, making the bright red flesh resemble an exquisitely wrapped Christmas present. “I was only thinking that, supposing it was my son’s mother on the plate,” he said gently, his voice calm, though they could hear the insistence beneath it, “Marcus shouldn’t be sitting beside me, sharing the meat. He shouldn’t know. And he certainly shouldn’t be eating it without knowing.”
His Marcus was one of the very few people in the world who genuinely cared about him, still willing to worry about how he was doing even after everything that had happened. But Marcus was still too young. He did not even have a hunting license yet, and the rifle in his cabinet was still too heavy for him. Perhaps many years from now, Marcus would learn what his father was, what kind of creature he was, and what sort of cold-blooded cruelty ran through half his blood. But that was many, many years ago. Or more likely, Marcus would never know. The silent chrysalis inside him was better left unopened forever.
“Surely.” Hannibal’s voice was soft, though the crimson remained in his eyes. “Marcus is family. He would only ever sit here as family.”
Lucas nodded. He knew he did not need to explain his complicated feelings to either Hannibal or Will. He knew they would understand, but that had never been the point. There are no excuses for sin. Lucas looked up at everything spread across the table. The executioner of guilt sits opposite him. The messenger of the Gospel sat at his side. And himself between his family, facing the meal they had given him. Their sins. Their faith. Their creation. Their desires. Their future.
Lucas drew a deep breath, then let it out slowly. “Who is this?” he finally asked, voice barely trembling.
He saw the crimson in Hannibal’s eyes, but he also saw his gentle smile. There had never been anything absurd about Hannibal’s thoughts or actions. It had been Lucas who, whenever he looked at Hannibal, had never known exactly where he was supposed to look, or what he was supposed to see.
“Niels Hansen.” His brother blinked, looking from Lucas to the meat on the plate and back again. “Senior officer. Transferred here from the precinct three years ago. Responsible for investigations and interrogations.”
Lucas remembered the twisted face, almost able to feel the oily residue against the back of his hand. “His interrogation skills were terrible,” he said quietly, looking down at the remnants on his plate beneath the gentle attention of the other two. “His investigative skills were worse,” Will drawled from across the table, contempt filling his voice. “Even after he saw Hannibal’s face, he was still calling your name.”
“People are often too devoted to established logic, unwilling to confront facts beyond the limits of their understanding.” Hannibal raised his fork and brought it toward himself, studying the perfect piece of meat. “They pay for their foolishness and ignorance. We may as well enjoy the meal that comes of it.” He smiled as he began to chew. His husband nodded before taking a slice himself. “At least he was of some use in the end.”
Lucas continued staring at the plate before him. The greasy sensation he had remembered earlier was gone. What remained was the memory of Hannibal supporting his hand while they prepared the sausages. How much pressure to use. When to stop. How to bind. How to cook. His brother’s voice echoed in his ears with the same cadence he had used when reading Lucas bedtime stories.
Feeding and eating. Giving and receiving. Offering and answering.
This was his brother’s gift. This was their quarry. Their harvest. Their victory.
Lucas slowly cut into the sausage. The juices quickly seeped from the casing beneath the pressure of his knife and fork, spreading toward the edges of the plate. He could not help wondering whether the blood that had left Officer Hansen had been as abundant, whether his cries had resembled the sharp hiss of meat in a pan, whether his despair had been as sweet as the juices now gathering across his plate.
He could not help wondering.
He could not help chewing.
Fat and muscle separated beneath his teeth, then came together again on his tongue and in his throat. The meat, free of any trace of blood, carried a rich sweetness. There was no fear in it. No resentment. No final despair. There had been no prolonged suffering. Niels Hansen had died instantly. Even knowing how much harm he had caused Lucas, death had offered him no punishment beyond death itself.
Because anything else would have spoiled the meat. He heard Hannibal whisper it beside his ear.
Just as with a wild deer. You only get one shot.
He heard the echo of the great tree in the valley. Birds rising into the sky and spiralling into a storm. Leaves whispering in the wind. Beasts crying out. Life itself keening. He heard trickling streams gather into a great flood, roaring and consuming everything in the forest. A golden moon. A blood-red torrent. And through the catastrophe, the only thing that remained unmoved was the beast born from the deepest reaches of his imagination, cloaked in black-crow feathers, crowned with towering antlers, standing upon powerful animal paws as it watched him. Watched him. Watched him. It never cared how violently his world was collapsing, nor how completely he was transforming. It did not care about everything he had seen. It cared only about him—the self he had buried inside this body for more than forty years. The him who knew what he truly desired.
It was not a demon sent from Hell to watch over him. It was the mount sent by fate to carry him home.
“It’s delicious,” he heard himself say. “We should hunt more meat this good.”
He smelled on his own breath the fragrance he knew he would never forget.
The scent of freedom.
-
When Lucas was still standing by the bedroom wardrobe, trying to decide which blanket he should take downstairs to sleep on the sofa, Hannibal slowly closed the bedroom door behind him. He did not lock it, but Lucas still heard the quiet click. “We’ll be going out again early tomorrow morning.” Hannibal stepped away from the door and toward him, stopping between the door and the bed before extending one hand toward Lucas.
His brother stood one step away from him, with the door on one side and the bed on the other, and his most important family between them. He knew that if he reached for the bedroom door, Hannibal would let him leave and go downstairs to find his sofa. He also knew that if he did not reach for the door but instead took his brother’s hand, Hannibal would allow him to sleep in the bed, between the two of them. There are always those who willingly surrender what they seek because it already belongs to someone else, without first attempting to face their own desires, much less confess them. He remembered the knife his brother had offered him in the kitchen. He remembered Hannibal telling him that nothing dangerous would ever happen to him. He remembered his brother asking him, What is it you desire?
The water stopped running in the bathroom.
Hannibal’s hand remained extended before him.
Many years ago, Hannibal’s hand had been held out to him in exactly the same way, taking his dirt- and ash-covered hand and leading him to the sink. The dirty water gathered there was brown, black, but never red. Back then, Lucas had not understood how Hannibal could use the same kitchen knife to cut through the shoulder blade of a man and that of a deer, carving out pieces of shoulder meat that seemed almost indistinguishable, then placing them onto their matching plates in different colours. He had not understood why, to Hannibal, there was no difference between a person and an animal, why a person could be food. Back then, he still believed in the morality he had spent decades being taught. He still believed in the goodness of humanity, believed that people were more than collections of instincts. But after all of this happened, after the humans he had trusted chose to blindly follow the absurd moral principles he himself had once believed in, after he discovered that not a single person had truly seen what he was—not even what he had been pretending to be—he finally understood what Hannibal had meant: morality never existed. Humans were merely animals.
Lucas slowly extended his right hand and placed it over Hannibal’s warmer left hand.
“Who will it be this time?” He heard the tremor in his own voice, but it was no longer fear. Simply excitement.
“You decide.” And his brother only smiled, curling his fingers around Lucas’s hand.
When he had been cleaning the house twenty hours ago, he could never have guessed that three people would be on these sheets by now. Hannibal was on his left, Will on his right, and they had settled him in the very center of the dark red sheets, like a baptism they had performed together. The red beneath his body was the holy water bestowed upon him by the god of his faith. Thinking of this, he turned toward his brother on the left, and the arm beneath his head twitched. “What is it?” Hannibal looked at him with an expression far too gentle for a man sharing a bed with his only family.
Lucas studied the features so painfully similar to his own, the scars scattered across Hannibal’s face, the fine strands of gray in his hair. “I don’t know,” he whispered to his brother, lowering his head until his face was almost completely buried against Hannibal’s collarbone. “I don’t want to disappoint you.”
He remembered the soldiers Hannibal had hunted, disembowelled, and eaten. He remembered the seemingly endless names on the wanted lists. He remembered how they had found Niels Hansen yesterday without asking him anything at all, then turned him into sausages and steaks. He knew what they were capable of. Beside them, he was still a nestling desperately in need of feeding. “It’s all right.” But the other arm behind him slowly climbed up around his shoulder and neck, massaging the rigid muscles there, and the voice beside his ear was just as gentle. “He won’t be disappointed in you. And I made a much worse choice the first time.”
Hannibal spoke before Lucas could ask. “He decided to kill a psychiatrist who was having a relationship with one of his patients.” He reached over with his free hand and pinched Will lightly on the back of his hand. “Because that behaviour is absolutely unacceptable.”
Will, half-reclining behind him, nodded. “The worst.”
Lucas, enclosed between them, did not know whether he should burst out laughing or feel sorrow for it. He could only try to relax his body, still unused to the warmth of another person, and press himself as close to their heat as he could. “We can start with the earliest one and slowly work our way through the other possibilities.” Hannibal’s voice sounded above his head, slow and measured, as though he were reading a story. “I know you would not want to hurt that little girl.” He paused, and Will, whose chin rested against Lucas’s back, hummed and shook his head. “Children say the most astonishing things. But of course, such an exaggerated rumour could only spread because adults blindly believed it.” As he said this, he could not resist wrapping his other hand around Lucas’s hip and drawing him closer. His voice beside Lucas’s ear dropped lower, like thunder before a storm, resonating through his body. “Tell your brother. Tell me.”
Before Lucas was his all-powerful brother. Behind him was another merciless and ruthless killer. He was suspended in the safest place and moment in the world. No one would ever have another opportunity to hurt him, and those who had hurt him would soon pay for what they had done. Lucas sniffed, barely noticing the tears filling his eyes, and heard his own hoarse voice release two syllables: “Grethe.” He said it with more weight, more force, than he ever had before.
“Grethe.” The man behind him repeated it.
“Grethe.” The man before him agreed.
Lucas slowly closed his eyes, drifting in their embrace. His family’s warmth surrounded him. The scent of home filled his breathing. Their soothing voices murmured beside his ears as they discussed murder and cooking. Which parts were worth taking? Which recipes were worth using? Their whispers were like early spring rain, nourishing the parched ground inside him. He heard them calculating the people they were willing to kill for him, the dishes they would stew for him, as though counting sheep one by one.
In his haze, he saw the black-feathered beast again. But this time there were no cries from the forest, no howling flood. Everything was utterly still, and there were only he and his beast. When he wrapped both arms around its body, he heard the thunder between its ribs, deafening. Once. Twice. Repeatedly. Just like the steadfast and eternal hearts of the men holding him.
-
December in the forest was an endless, bone-deep cold. The morning mist hung around them like a thin veil, while the shadows of field mice and foxes flickered in and out of sight, the faint sounds of claws racing through dead leaves coming and going with them. This was not Lucas’s preferred time for hunting, but the point today was, of course, neither roe deer nor deer.
There was only Hannibal beside him. Lucas had not heard their plans for today clearly before he passed out the night before, but he knew that all he had to do was trust Hannibal and Will completely.
Experts. Lucas told himself, unable to stop a sound almost resembling a laugh from escaping through his nose.
“Will watered the cactus by your front door before we left this morning,” Hannibal said as they walked.
“I don’t know if it’s actually still alive.” Lucas thought about it for a moment. He genuinely could not remember whether the thing had grown any taller since the day he had first encountered it thirty-ish years ago. “But I’d be more surprised if it could stay alive this long in a country this cold.”
He had always wondered why anyone had decided to put a potted cactus outside in Denmark. It was not his, though technically it could be considered part of his father’s property. But Lucas had never thought of it as his, nor had he ever thought of it as belonging here. “Do you remember the botanical garden in our backyard I told you about in one of my letters?” Hannibal sighed beside him. “That is where it naturally belongs. Longer hours of sunlight, greater intensity, less rain, warmer temperatures, and a gardener who cares more about his plants than he does about his own husband.”
Lucas had the vague feeling that they were discussing more than just a cactus, but that did not mean he disliked the conversation. “I thought you were the most important thing to him.” There was a hint of awkwardness in his gaze when he looked at Hannibal, but Hannibal only used his little finger to brush the strand of hair hanging before his eyes aside, his voice calm and effortless. “I am. But even among the most important things, there are priorities. I am the least important of the most important.”
They talked about Lucien, whom they had adopted some time ago, all the way to the humus compost in the family garden, without bothering to avoid how much protein Lucien consumed or how much of their organic fertilizer consisted of humans and how much consisted of other animals. Freedom. Lucas told himself as he came to a stop beside his brother. After pretending, after believing himself to be a higher kind of creature, he finally had the chance to face his family in his true form. “I’m glad you know what you want now.” Hannibal’s voice echoed through the desolate wilderness around them, like the enchanted realm from the story of the man with the stag’s head he had read to Lucas decades ago. So vast. So primitive. So free.
Under Lucas’s gaze, Hannibal slowly raised the barrel of the gun in his hands. The cold metal gradually warmed beneath his grip until he aimed it at a pair of dark figures in the farthest distance they could see. Lucas followed the barrel of his own gun with his eyes. He knew what he was about to face before he could even make out what it was.
The black-feathered beast, with a trembling doe standing beside him. Even with dozens of meters in between, Lucas recognized them.
He was an experienced hunter himself.
As he aligned the sights with his target, he suddenly realized that neither Hannibal beside him nor Will standing on the other side knew which one he was aiming at. It could have been the willing doe offering herself as dinner, but it could just as easily have been the stag that had haunted him for so long. His finger pressed against the trigger. He knew Will carried a handgun, and Hannibal had at least one hunting knife in his pocket, but when he tilted his head to listen, he heard neither the whisper of a blade cutting through the air nor the click of another gun being readied.
Family. The word echoed in his ears.
Family cannot be lost. They share their sins. Their faith. Their creations. Their desires. Their future.
“Have you decided which cuts you want?” His index finger curled tightly around the trigger, but he did not pull it. His muscles nearly cramped from the strain.
He heard Hannibal’s breath pass beside his ear. “You’ll like it,” his brother said with a smile.
Bang.
The forest erupted into motion. Birds and animals fled in every direction. Feathers, branches, leaves, claws, teeth, rainwater, berries—all of it trembled beneath the single gunshot. He closed his eyes. Every sound and scent circling him poured toward his senses like filthy water rushing into a drain, brown, black, but never red, unable to enter his consciousness. He simply listened, ears straining. One, two—
Thud.
The breath Lucas had been holding finally burst from his lungs in a violent gasp. He struggled for air, still staring toward the shadows in the mist, but the black-feathered beast was no longer standing there. Instead, there was a motionless man, black-brown hair, blue-green eyes, half his body buried in the darkness thick as ink, the other half bathed in the gentle brightness of morning. Lucas stared at him, then at the empty mist beside.
“What’s for dinner?” he heard himself ask, his voice barely more than a whisper.
“Never ask,” the voice beside him replied. “It spoils the surprise.”
As they walked step by step toward the other man standing on the hill, Lucas heard the commotion of the forest gradually fall silent again. The screams and cries seemed never to have happened. The tears and blood seemed never to have spilled. The punishment he had once feared so terribly had never come. He was still breathing the morning air, still walking through the world over dead leaves and rainwater. His family was still beside him, and the one who had truly died was not the one who had pulled the trigger.
Perhaps God had never truly existed. When the quarry was served at the dinner table, when reunited families held hands and murmured words of gratitude, what they imagined their omniscient, omnipotent God to be, Lucas did not know. But he no longer cared. He reached out and took the hand beside him. He knew what his god was. He knew what he was. He knew what they would become.
Their sins. Their faith. Their creations. Their desires. Their future.
That Christmas Eve, their main course was roe deer tongue braised slowly in red wine. It had been an adult doe weighing roughly fifty kilograms, enough to feed three grown men after a day of hunting. Lucas ate happily, happier than he ever had been. When he climbed into bed, pleasantly drowsy from the wine, he was still nestled between his family, surrounded by their breath, their warmth, their voices, their love, with no explanation. Lucas looked back into their loving eyes, the sweetness of dinner still lingering on his tongue.
He did not know how many gunshots, how many tongues, it would take to repay everything they had given him. Fortunately, there was still time. There were still opportunities. There were still so many bullets left in his magazine.
He would have what he wanted.
After all, September through December was the best time for the hunt.
Notes:
hi hey hello
Thank you for reading! I had great joy designing this story and I hope you all enjoy it as well. Please leave a comment or find me on twitter. I haven't decided the contents (the filthy kinks) for the 3some continuation of this story. But I promise there will be one.
See you next time :)
