Actions

Work Header

The Hunt

Chapter 3

Notes:

"Apple sauce is yummy mud." - @project hail jilia

I have been thinking about this quote for weeks.
Hail random-bullshit-Will-Graham.

Chapter Text

He liked the taste of breakfast more than he had expected.

 

Hannibal was still seated to his right, and Will was still sitting opposite him. In the middle of the table were rye bread (Hannibal was very reluctant to admit that he had bought it from a shop), the dessert they made together, berries, and sausage with eggs. “The first time we met, he drove with this stuff for an hour to find me at the motel.” The man across from him gestured toward the sausage and eggs, teasingly, with the scent of black coffee hanging over the table. “Of course, he didn't tell me what kind of meat was in it.” He gave a little hum.

 

The man between them merely spread butter over his bread with unhurried precision. “I'm glad you eventually figured it out for yourself.” He raised an eyebrow at his husband, then turned to pat his brother's hand. “Though the sausage today was bought at the market. Forgive me for not having had time to prepare it myself.”

 

There was something almost lonely in the way he said it. Lucas choked slightly before lowering his head and offering an especially quiet It's all right.

 

Water pattered from the eaves over the backyard. By the time Lucas realized it was because he had neglected to clean the gutters for some time, Will had already taken a few steps toward the door after finishing his coffee. “The gutters?” The man still holding his mug looked at him, then gave a small hum when Lucas nodded sheepishly. “Do you have a ladder tall enough to reach them?” Will asked, glancing through the open back door at the height of the exterior wall. “At least four meters,” he murmured.

 

“I do—” Lucas stood too quickly, his knee striking the dining chair beside him. He choked in a sharp breath, immediately drawing the attention of the other two men in the house. “You hate others touching your things?” Will turned to face him, his voice carrying a restrained note of caution. “N-no.” Lucas groaned, clutching his injured knee. “It's just that I've never tried cleaning them myself.” His face grew reddish as he said it. He was always so humiliatingly helpless in front of Hannibal, always the weaker child. After all these years, somehow this had only become worse. Will raised an eyebrow at the gutters outside. “You're a big boy. You can handle these little chores yourself, can't you?” he asked, tilting his head at Hannibal's younger brother. When Lucas nodded again, face burning, Will set down his coffee. “Come on. Show me your tools.” His hands went into his pockets, his tone oddly reminiscent of the way Lucas coaxed the children into eating their fruit.

 

As they crossed the threshold between the kitchen and dining room, Hannibal's voice followed them from the kitchen. “I'll bring my boys some coffee and pastries later.”

 

Will let out a loud whistle ahead of him. “Yummy mud!”

 

Lucas could only lower his head and follow him outside, like a dog with enough self-awareness to know better.

 

-

 

The ladder had been left where the garden trellis was originally meant to stand. “So how did you clean the gutters before this? A maintenance company?” Will inspected the rust along the length of the ladder. It was obvious that no one had used it in some time, and even more obvious that its owner had never understood the point of maintenance. He decided not to tease the man behind him about it and simply waved Lucas over.

 

“Theo and Johan used to do it.” Lucas did not speak until they had extended the ladder and set it in the proper position, a sigh woven into his voice. “But after everything that happened, I don't think they'll be coming here anymore.”

 

They had been playmates since childhood. Johan was a few years younger than them, while Theo had been born the same year as Lucas. They had been best friends from the day Lucas moved here until only a few weeks ago. Lucas had once believed they would always be friends. He knew Theo had once believed the same. But was any of this because of him? This had been an entirely undeserved catastrophe for Lucas. Then was it Theo’s fault? Because a man who valued his family above everything had decided to protect his young daughter? That was even more absurd.

 

It was no one's fault. At least, it was not a tragedy anyone had intended. That was the saddest part.

 

“Do you resent them?” The man beside him spoke softly.

 

Lucas lowered his head and said nothing.

 

He had never imagined any of this happening to him. Yet when these things, these insults and acts of violence, had actually fallen upon him like hail, he still could not bring himself to blame them. If he had been in Theo's place, if a principal had called him one day to tell him that a teacher had behaved inappropriately toward his son, and that this terrible teacher happened to be the best friend he had known for decades—Lucas knew he would not have been able to stop himself from breaking the guy's nose. So if he could not restrain his own impulse, how could he demand that someone else remain calm in the face of such a crisis, let alone find room for compassion because of all the good Lucas had once done?

 

He could not find the words. But the man beside him turned to face him, with only the ladder between them. And when Lucas looked at him, he saw a grief in Will's eyes too intense to conceal. “They hurt your family,” Will whispered. Lucas knew what he meant. He knew what lay buried behind them.

 

“But—” Lucas drew a breath. He tried to release the reservations lodged inside him, but his throat seemed to constrict around the words, making his voice sound like a hinge left to rust for years. He had not expected Will to take another step forward, coming within arm's reach. In the dozen hours since they had appeared, they had never stood so close. Close enough for Lucas to almost smell the anger carried in Will's breath.

 

“What if it had been your son?” His voice held a coldness Lucas had never heard from him before.

 

Lucas froze.

 

Blood reached his amygdala before his mind could comprehend it, yet he still felt as though he could not draw enough air. The food that had entered his stomach an hour earlier twisted upward again beneath the spasms of his digestive tract, like the filling of a pie, or spirits in Hell searching for an exit, frightened and screaming and spending every last ounce of strength trying to escape. He could barely feel himself breathing. He couldn't—he would never allow anyone to lay a hand on Marcus. Even the thought of someone looking at his son with improper intentions was enough to awaken something murderous inside him, let alone—

 

“When you speak for them, don't forget Fanny.” The voice like melting snow passed through his ear again. “Don't forget that it could have been your son.”

 

Marcus appeared before his eyes, immersed in a pool of blood. His brown hair slowly disappeared into the red beneath him. His eyes, always following his father, became dim and empty. His nostrils fluttered, but only more crimson flowed from them. Lucas's breathing trembled. He looked at the man beside him—black feathers like a raven's, extending from the ends of his hair all the way to his shoulders, covering every piece of human flesh on his body as though they were truly feathers. He saw his own pale face reflected in their oily sheen. He saw features too much like Hannibal's trembling between the feathers, until even he could no longer tell which of the two he was looking at.

 

He had never asked his brother why they had been made to consume the flesh of those soldiers. He had never asked what they tasted like. He had never imagined what it would feel like to chew the flesh of men steeped in sin. He had never known this kind of catastrophic hatred, never known the suffocation of despair. But it was not because he had no feelings. Only now did he understand that he had never been indifferent to any of it. It was the reason disciplined by society, trained by morality, that had forgiven the sinners he should have condemned before he had ever been allowed to taste the flavour of his own hatred.

 

His hatred was a great tree standing on the mountain, silent and unmoving. Wind and rain passed through it, leaving behind nothing but the whisper of leaves. Only when you tore away its wall-like bark, when you hacked through layer after layer of restraint, watching the plant that had grown into a giant within its silence finally collapse with a force that shook the heavens and thundered through the valley, would people understand the hatred he truly carried. Only then would they understand its weight.

 

“That could have been you.” The half-beast beside him finally said it, then shrugged and withdrew his feathers.

 

Lucas looked into his blue eyes. The intense, naked grief that had been there before was gone, replaced by something pure, something he could not yet identify. Many, many years ago, there had been another creature who knew the shape of forbidden things, lying beside a human who had conceived a forbidden desire, persuading them to bite into the fruit heavy with juice.

 

Many, many years later, Lucas looked at the dark companion beside him and finally understood why their eyes had brightened after eating the forbidden apple, why they had never begged the gods for forgiveness after leaving the Eden that had once been paradise.

 

Only when you understand what you have lost in pursuit of something do you truly receive its corresponding reward. Restraint was no longer his obligation. Revenge would be his right. Before his eyes came the images again and again: the light fading from people's eyes, their breathing slowly ceasing, their bodies growing cold under his hands. He saw his true family beside him, wiping away his final tear, washing the blood from his hands, preparing a magnificent dinner for him.

 

They would feast upon the flesh of the sinful. They would use their own bodies to cleanse them of their sins, and with these hands, send them into Heaven.

 

-

 

The air after the rain carried a scent of melancholy. Lucas drew a deep breath through his nose, and the hand holding the end cap of the gutter trembled with it, dislodging a little of the rainwater still trapped inside. The wind passed through, bringing the wet cold against his face. Even though he had been born and raised in the north, he still disliked winter.

 

“Once you actually get your hands dirty, you find out it isn’t as complicated as you thought, don’t you?” Will, standing below and leaning against the ladder, took the garbage bag from him. His eyes were bright as though they had been washed clean by the rain. Lucas glanced at him and sniffed again. “That’s because I had an expert here.” He began climbing down slowly. “If I were alone, I probably would have called the company.”

 

Will gave a very audible sigh beside him. “Your brother will absolutely suggest that we stay here permanently because of that.” He caught Lucas’s unsteady elbow during the last few steps, holding him until he was steady, then made quotation marks in the air with his fingers. “Suggest.”

 

His exaggerated expression, combined with the scars on his face, made him look genuinely angry. But the levity in his voice was too obvious, like an excess of cream stirred into coffee, softening the unsettling aroma. Lucas covered his quietly warming elbow with one hand and merely shook his head, refusing to respond to Will’s teasing about Hannibal. He knew Will was watching him, which left him even more at a loss for words. “You don’t like going against your brother,” Will said again only after they had finished putting everything away. “He punished you when you were younger?”

 

“How would he—” Lucas blurted the words out before realizing it was bait. Will was still watching him from the other end of the fishing line, openly amused. “Of course he didn’t.” Lucas sighed. He began to understand more and more why his brother was so fascinated by this man. “It’s just that he was too perfect as an older brother. I never had any desire to oppose him, whether it was his ideas or his actions.”

 

“Even after he ate all those people?” They were standing close enough that Lucas could almost hear Will’s eyelashes flutter.

 

He had not expected Will to be so direct, but this subject was easier for him than the one they had discussed an hour earlier. After all, he had known Hannibal longer than he had known himself. He knew how to package Hannibal’s words and actions as elegantly as merchandise; he had rehearsed it in his mind for decades. “In his eyes, those people,” he lowered his head and thought for a moment, several possible descriptions surfacing before he finally settled on a gentler one, “were no different from the animals raised for meat in the sausage industry.” He paused. Hearing neither agreement nor disagreement, he continued. “Perhaps even less than animals. Animals have no distinction between beauty and ugliness. Humans do. Not one of the people he killed was anything other than what he considered ugly.” Lucas nodded at the empty air before him. “And consuming them was a way of cleansing their sins. An act of mercy.”

 

They stood beside the neglected flowerpots in the backyard. The rainwater collected inside them answered their gazes in silence. “And you?” the man beside him asked again, his voice revealing nothing. “When you chew the meat he serves you, what do you think about?”

 

The piece of shoulder they had once shared appeared before Lucas. The delicate meat that should have been venison shoulder. Rich juices spilling from the side of the cut. The dark red of blackcurrants slowly seeping through its surface, bubbling, creeping over the meat, the rim of the plate, until it spilled from the edge of the table and onto him—

 

“About him, or about the meat?” His voice was stiff. He had never discussed any of this with anyone else.

 

The man beside him blinked. “Is there a difference?”

 

The question seemed to drain every remaining ounce of strength from Lucas. His perpetually hunched shoulders suddenly fell, leaving only his hands clenched at his sides. When he had received his brother’s letter telling him that Hannibal had butchered and skinned those sinful soldiers and consumed their flesh, he remembered how bewildered he had been. He had not understood why revenge had to take the form of cannibalism, nor why his brother, the gentlest, most courteous gentleman he had ever known, could become such a demon. He did not understand it, and for a very long time he refused to try. When he finally forced himself to confront it, it took him even longer to accept that this was something inherent to his brother, rather than some evil that had grown upon him.

 

Could he have such a sinful birthmark within himself as well? Had his father and mother, beneath their dignified and immaculate appearances, ever wondered how best to kill, dismember, cook, and consume? And their most cherished sister, the most treasured thing in the world, would she too have discovered, somewhere within the happiness she should have had, an instinctive desire for killing and consumption? Lucas did not know. He still did not know how to answer those questions, much less the man standing before him.

 

The worry he had felt several hours ago, standing beside Hannibal, about whether his brother would ever want to share a kitchen with him again now returned. He knew only that he ought to repent of his greed, that he ought to give something back to his brother. Yet even after his reason and desires forced him to confront his instincts, after making him examine every locked drawer inside himself, pulling out every thought he had once been unwilling or too frightened to scrutinize and inspecting each one anew, he still could not find Hannibal’s reflection there. He did not—and could not—experience the sense of fulfillment Hannibal felt while chewing. They were pieces of a puzzle cut from the same box, close enough to resemble one another, but never capable of fitting together.

 

Because his desire was not to consume.

 

“You know, although he has probably told you about all the ways we are alike,” Will said softly, a faint smile in his voice, “not only because of my empathy, or all those years I spent with the FBI. It’s because we are similar at our core.” He raised the hand resting between them and rubbed at the stubble Lucas had neglected since before he came outside. “He always likes to insist that we are the same kind of creature by nature. That we like to slaughter, like to play God, like to turn impolite things into a platter of smoked meats.” He paused, giving a disdainful little huff through his nose. “But that is what he likes. That is what the Ripper likes.”

 

Will lifted his head toward the brightening sky after the rain. His voice seemed to come from somewhere beyond the clouds. “We aren’t that much alike.”

 

Lucas watched his eyes, so blue they were almost translucent. “And that doesn’t…make you sad?” He chose the gentler word again.

 

But Will shook his head without hesitation. “Of course not.” He continued watching the distant clouds. “What he wants and what I want is simply for the other person to see us. I have never found cannibalism meaningful to me. I understand how he sees it, but it was never my thought.” He shrugged. “Hannibal knows what I like, just as I know what he likes. Affection is the reason we cherish one another, not a reason to force ourselves to become one another.”

 

Will turned toward the man beside him, looking at his trembling eyelids and clear eyes as though watching a cocoon slowly split open before him, the moist, delicate wings within gradually filling and unfolding, blooming from a dark-gray shell. It was an unparalleled beauty. Reborn. His vitality shone like stars in the dying winter. “Even when a person’s desire differs greatly from God’s will, he can still give himself over to God,” he said softly. “Even God’s own child has had moments when his wishes differed from those of his Father, and that never made him lose God’s love.”

 

Inhale. Exhale. He heard the sound of wings emerging somewhere beside his ear. In those golden-brown eyes there was nothing of the familiar crimson he most often saw in another pair of brown eyes. Instead, there was something deeper, denser, like blood beneath moonlight, cold and heavy after losing the protection of living flesh. It was the colour of death. Not violence, not dismemberment and reconstruction, but simply the desire to take a life.

 

How beautiful. Will thought.

 

“Come on.” He finally released a pale sigh into the cold air between them. “Your brother is going to say it was my fault if you catch a cold.”

 

“I’m older than you. I’m supposed to be the one taking care of you.” Lucas followed him toward the house without thinking, his voice carrying the same quiet complaint it had when they first appeared here yesterday afternoon. Even they could not hear the change in him. But Will remembered the viciousness he had seen in those eyes for the brief half-minute just now. Cold viciousness, savoured the rich possibilities of the man before him, of them, and of all the games they might someday play across this endless field of snow… “One day,” Will smiled, “you’ll be the one taking care of me and your brother.” His hand settled on the doorknob. Before opening the door, he gave one last little huff. “But not today.”

 

-

 

Lucas was not surprised to find Hannibal in the kitchen, nor was he surprised to find him working with the ground meat. The excellent meat he had mentioned that morning. “What is this?” He walked over to his brother and placed both hands on his hips, unwilling to let Hannibal see that they were trembling. “Medisterpølse.” Hannibal’s voice rose slightly, unmistakably pleased by his brother’s initiative, as he lifted a sausage stuffer from where it had been sitting nearby and brought it toward him. “I found this in your pantry, although I suspect you’ve never used it.” He smiled smugly. “Wasn’t yours?”

 

Lucas could only nod, his face flushing. “Kirsten bought it. My son’s mother.” He sighed. “She said it was too heavy and useless, so she left it with me. As if it wasn’t bought with my credit card.”

 

“Should I say I’m glad you two are no longer together?” Hannibal tilted his head toward him, without even the slightest trace of guilt in his eyes. “You know you deserve better.” And there was not a trace of insincerity in the words.

 

“I’m not as lucky as you.” His brother shook his head against the counter. “Most people aren’t as lucky as the two of you.”

 

“That depends on how strongly you desire something.” His brother continued to tilt his head as he watched him, not missing the involuntary twitch in Lucas’s neck and shoulders at the words. “And how much you are willing to pay for your desire. Even how much you are willing to lose.”

 

Hannibal reached for another kitchen knife lying on the towel. Its beautiful silver surface flashed beneath the movement, leaving a dangerous suggestion across Lucas’s optic nerves. “There are always people who willingly surrender what they desire because someone else already has it, without first attempting to confront their own longing, much less confess their desire.” He placed the knife between himself and his younger brother, its point facing himself. The blade reflected the stunned expression on his brother’s face, while his own eyes remained fixed solely on Lucas. “An attempt is merely one form of asking. Rejection is not an inevitable outcome.”

 

Lucas’s instincts told him he should not take the knife before him, but those same instincts told him he should obey his brother without limits.

 

“And what if the consequence of rejection is dangerous?” he heard his own voice tremble.

 

His brother smiled at him, his tone as gentle as ever. “Then nothing dangerous will happen to you.” There was not the slightest falseness in his gaze. There never had been. He had always been Lucas’s older brother, his true brother, his only family. Whatever suffering Lucas might endure in the future, it would never come from Hannibal. He looked at the knife before him, at the still-visible scars on his brother’s inner arm, at the traces of the South American sun upon his skin. He knew that even if he took the knife, drove it into his brother with all his strength, wounded him, made him bleed, left him with a scar that could never disappear, his brother would forgive him.

 

Because they were family. Family was something they could not afford to lose. They forgave what they could not afford to lose.

 

His faith stood before him, offering him a weapon capable of taking his life, giving him food, giving him strength, giving him absolute power, giving him an opportunity he would never receive from anyone else: an opportunity to share. “Are you…” The words escaped Lucas before he realized he didn’t have a gentler word to use. Everything before him had violated every boundary, had violated even the word boundary itself. Every belief, every god, every moral code, every discipline, every reason for self-restraint.

 

What remains in their world once there are no boundaries left?

 

In his delirium, the man before him slowly grew long antlers, like a pair of enormous hands enclosing him, separating him from everything beyond. He could no longer feel the light or warmth around him. There were no longer sounds or air. His senses slowly went numb until darkness seeped over him like a gentle current, entering his pores and blood vessels, ink-black branches stretching all the way to the ends of his capillaries, forming another self within his body.

 

“Tell me, what is your desire?”

 

Hannibal’s voice seemed to come from somewhere beyond the horizon, and yet from directly before him, like the vaulted ceiling suspended above their sanctuary, like an echo reverberating between his ribs. Only now did Lucas understand that family was not something heaven decided for you. Family was what the heart decided. And only now did Hannibal truly become his family. The vow he had chosen for himself, the beginning of his endless forgiveness, his guardian angel for the rest of his life.

 

His desire.

 

Lucas stared into the darkness before him. He saw the valley and the farm. Half a slice of bread on the table. The cactus by the front door. His phone. The metal door of the interrogation room. The black garbage bag. The damaged corner of the wall. The antlers hanging in his bedroom. He saw the black-crow feathers. The sealed bags in his refrigerator. The pale-red water in the sink. The blood overflowing from his plate. The gun locked inside his cabinet.

 

He heard the death of the great tree echo through the valley. He heard Fanny’s unanswered whimper. He heard Marcus’s screams as Kirsten dragged him out of the house. He smelled blood. He smelled Hannibal’s breath as he emerged from the snow. He smelled Mischa upon him. He smelled the presence of his father and mother.

 

“Hannibal.” He heard himself call.

 

“Lucas.” He heard his family answer.

 

He had come home.