Chapter Text
“You never wrote back.” He watched Hannibal slowly approach him. Only when the man reached out to brush the strands of hair hanging before his eyes aside could he finally see his features clearly. Lucas narrowed his brown eyes at the man before him. More prominent scars, a more natural disguise. A more vivid instinct for killing, a more imperceptible—
No. There was no death in those reddish-brown eyes. Not even a trace. After all, Hannibal Lecter was not Lucas Sforza. He would not be seized by those sudden, inexplicable urges toward self-destruction.
Lucas let his gaze trace the indistinct features of the man emerging from the shadows, reconstructing the face from memory. The face beneath the South American sun in the photograph tucked inside the greeting card. The face on the wanted poster. The face that had once pulled him over the gate of their own garden. The man’s hand supporting his was far warmer than his own skin, without dampness, without tremor, simply holding Lucas’s heavy, drowsy head steadily. Lucas pressed himself against his right hand and drew a deep breath—
Coffee, papaya, and cinnamon cream.
The smell of the kitchen.
The smell of home.
“Things lately have been taking up too much of my time.” Lucas rested his head against his brother’s palm and whispered to him, with the same caution they had once used for secrets murmured beside each other in bed as children. He narrowed his eyes at Hannibal’s, and, just as expected, found a trace of sly amusement there.
“Your brother has always believed he was your guardian.” The figure that emerged from the darkness behind him, blurred by the curtain of rain, was not some true creature of Lucas’s imagination cloaked in black feathers. The man with dark brown, half-length hair walked toward them one measured step at a time, rain stippling the surface of his black waterproof fabric like a night scattered across a clear sky. He stopped beside Hannibal and nodded at Lucas without offering his hand. “Will Graham. Sorry. Broke into your property before introducing myself.” He smiled somewhat awkwardly, without the same direct cunning in his eyes that Lucas saw in his brother’s.
Lucas blinked. This man seemed much more reserved than his brother, at least. He did not go wandering about dressed in the outward declaration of I like to kill people. If Lucas ignored the flash of blood in his eyes when he looked at Fanny beside him, he looked more like a mechanic, or some contractor who could appear at any house door without attracting a second glance. Perhaps that was precisely what made it the perfect human disguise, Lucas told himself. His brother’s husband not only cared very little for humanity, but cared a great deal about dogs. Lucas tightened his grip on the tool in his hand, and for the first time in a long while, a small sense of ease quietly filled him.
He was home.
-
Dinner was the best Lucas had had in years, even better than the meal at his bachelor party.
With the little food remaining in his house, his brother somehow managed to put together a feast. Meatball spaghetti, potato salad, and panna cotta. Lucas could not help but let out a somewhat excessive moan when he reached dessert, but fortunately Will, sitting across from him, made a similar sound at almost the same moment. “You really should have come to spend Folia de Reis with us earlier.” His brother patted Lucas’s empty hand after watching him devour the plate of panna cotta before him. “You would have loved my sweet bread.”
“That would be the best bread you’ve ever had.” The man across from him nodded, a little cream still caught along the edge of his beard, making him look younger than he really was, and making it even harder to imagine him as a wanted fugitive. That did not stop him from looking at Hannibal with an amused expression. “Though I’m certain no one could disapprove of your cooking, and you know that.” He said it with a wink toward the other wanted man sitting at the table.
His husband simply wiped away the trace he had not noticed with a napkin, offering no denial.
Sitting on the other side of the table, Lucas had already turned his attention back to his empty dessert plate when he saw his brother reach out, as if he was suddenly fascinated by the pattern printed upon it. He did his best to ignore the flash of smug amusement that crossed Will’s face, and equally hard to ignore the heat rising into his own cheeks. Around his brother, his self-control had always been particularly poor. He could never decide whether it was because he trusted his brother too completely in the role of family, or because in the presence of Hannibal and Will’s notorious perceptiveness, he knew there was nowhere he could hide.
Perhaps because this is home, he thought. Home is the womb of the mind. A person immersed in it is always naked.
From the dining room, he could see the bare patch of earth beyond the kitchen, exposed beneath the heavy rain. The earth where his little daughter lay buried, an incongruous blot of black against the gray backyard. When his brother set a cup of coffee before him, Lucas was imagining how the little insects Fanny had once loved to investigate would slowly consume fur and flesh and bone.
Dust to dust, earth to earth. Eventually, they would return to this dark, night-like wilderness.
“Is the taste in coffee hereditary too?” the man across from him asked, pulling Lucas back from the backyard and into his own dining room. He looked at the coffee his brother had placed before him—a milky white drink in which it was almost impossible to see any coffee—then at his brother’s husband’s cup. “Black coffee after dark will keep you awake.” The amusement had already entered Lucas’s voice before he realized it.
His voice trembled despite himself. It was only after saying the words that he realized how stiff his vocal cords had become. It had been so long since anyone had spoken to him properly. So long since anyone had treated him as a living person. If he had not noticed his nerves loosening since their arrival, he had now.
The other man merely blinked, giving him a half-smile through the steam rising from his coffee. It was an expression Lucas knew, though for a moment he could not remember where he had seen it before. “We may go out for a little while.” His brother sat down beside him, holding the same milky mixture whose caffeine content was impossible to determine. “It should not be long. Just a small but urgent matter to take care of.” His other hand rested on Lucas’s shoulder, moving in slow circles for a while, almost soothingly.
Lucas leaned toward him without thinking. His eyes followed the movement of Hannibal’s hand. His gaze travelled along the frightening scars on the inside of his brother’s arm until it reached his eyes. “But the rain will keep falling,” he said, trying as hard as he could not to sound like he was requesting them to stay.
He had lived here for more than thirty years and had never felt uneasy because of the woods stretching beyond the backyard. He knew there was nothing there. At this hour, in this weather, he would not even be able to see more than a few squirrels. But fear still hung above him like a suspended sword. He knew why. Everyone here knew where his fear came from. They simply did not speak of it.
“That is precisely why we need to go out in the storm.” The answer came from his brother’s husband. Will gave him that slightly awkward smile again. His most frequently worn human disguise, Lucas decided silently. Only now did he see the amusement buried beneath Will’s expression. It was so remarkably similar to Hannibal’s. A contempt for the world and everything in it, paired with an almost childlike curiosity. The amusement was not directed at Lucas. It was not malicious. But Lucas knew other people would call it something worse, a symptom of a conscience that had gone extinct.
He remembered what his brother had written in his letters. A profiler like an island unto himself. A friend who belonged to neither good nor evil. An equal adversary. A companion worth sacrificing freedom, or even life, to keep. Lucas looked again at the scars on his brother’s arm. They were marks only someone who truly belonged to the family could have left. Whether Will had done it himself or not, it was certainly his work.
He should have been angry. What surprised Lucas was that when he saw those marks with his own eyes, he felt none of the anger he believed he ought to feel. And when his brother looked down at his own hands, Lucas found no resentment in those red eyes, either.
Just as his brother had told him once: It’s all right. We are family. Family forgives.
Family. Lucas hid his face behind his coffee cup and tasted the word again.
“We’ll be home before breakfast tomorrow.” Hannibal’s hand remained against Lucas’s back, his body warmer now than when they had first met, almost shouting into Lucas’s ear that he was happy. He was happy about what awaited them outside later.
Family can forgive because we cannot lose family. We forgive those we cannot afford to lose.
And those we can afford to lose?
We lose.
He remembered Hannibal standing beside him in the kitchen of his home, this home, while Lucas was using a toothbrush to clean the branching antlers. He remembered what meat Hannibal was working a boning knife through. He remembered how many gunshots had sounded from the hills behind the house that morning, and how many dull thuds had followed as bodies fell into the snow. But it was alright. It was alright. Those were Hannibal’s preferences, and Lucas’s only concern was the enormous set of antlers before him.
Lucas decided not to ask what breakfast would be made of tomorrow.
The night rain would wash away the things he was still unwilling to look directly at.
-
They took the other set of keys from the cabinet by the door before leaving.
Lucas leaned against the crooked umbrella stand. The tie that should have gone into the washing machine long ago was clenched behind his back. He had promised to make the house as habitable as possible before they returned. “I haven’t seen a house this thoroughly bachelor-like in a very long time,” his brother said relatively diplomatically, while Will was far more direct. “He almost killed me for putting the bed outside the bedroom.”
“Really?” Lucas choked, standing in the middle of the wreckage and looking at the serial killers lowering their heads to button their coats.
“Not almost,” the older man answered. “I actually intended to.”
Lucas could not suppress the muffled laugh in his nose, and a tremor spread through the air between them. Hannibal’s favourite person to tease had always been him, whether to amuse his sister or simply when the two brothers were alone.
It was rare to see Hannibal toy with someone. Rarer still to see him so close to someone who was not bound to him by blood. Lucas was surprised to discover that it did not make him uneasy. He did not resent Will for what he had done to his brother, nor did he feel disgust at the intimacy between their bodies and lives. He did not even feel lost when Hannibal placed Will directly among them. Perhaps it was because this was someone that Hannibal could not afford to lose. Perhaps it was those impossibly blue eyes. Hannibal was confident they could get along, as family. Lucas decided to trust his brother, even as he realized that his gaze lingered on Will a little longer than it should.
They could try being friends. Lucas squeezed the silk in his hand and told himself this. Until he finds someone of his own.
Lucas had never imagined that the second half of his life would be lonely. He had had a family once, even if it had not worked out, and he did not believe that had been his fault, not according to his friends at least. His son came to stay at his house from time to time and would not object if Lucas found another partner. Occasionally, women around his age would sit beside him at a bar, and Lucas did not mind other people’s bodies drawing close to his, whether or not it ever became a kiss.
Lucas knew Hannibal had never intended to grow old with anyone. He had never dared to tell his brother so, but he had believed it was Hannibal’s problem. Or, in Hannibal’s own words, his own choice. Hannibal had decided there was no one in the world truly suited to him, no one who could see him clearly and still love the creature beneath it all. He and his brother had both believed such a person belonged to the realm of fantasy, until the younger man standing before them proved otherwise.
If his brother could find the person meant for him, why couldn't Lucas? He rubbed his thumb across the smooth silk. Plus, he never had his brother’s questionable hobbies. He was only an ordinary middle-aged man.
He watched Will straighten Hannibal’s coat, effortlessly, as though he had practiced it a million times.
There would always be a man or woman who appreciated him. Someone who would love him with the same devotion, all the way to the end of their lives. Lucas thought.
“You would have killed me for something much worse.” Under the brothers’ watchful eyes, the younger man leisurely fastened the final button. “Fortunately, I’ve always been rather good at dealing with your complaints with my excellent tongue and throat.” He winked at his husband, his voice deliberately loud enough to make sure his younger brother heard.
A pause.
Lucas, lost in his own hazy imaginings, suddenly crashed back into his body as though a fruit had fallen into a river and was being carried helplessly downstream. If he had managed even an hour of proper sleep during the previous twenty-four hours, perhaps he might have found a more dignified response to any of this, or at least a gentler one. Instead, all he could do was fall speechless when he understood what his brother’s husband had implied, then watch helplessly as they said goodbye, took the house keys, and walked out the door.
What?
The entryway light switched itself off.
His brother said nothing. He did not even look back at him. Lucas could feel sweat running down his spine.
The entryway before him lurched violently in his vision. The coffee he had swallowed half an hour ago crawled back up his throat like that little piece of bread from the morning. Again, he saw the hills where they had once lain in wait, the barn in which that farmer discovered them, the cave of the last emperor, the spruces, the squirrels, the river, the mountain wind—
The silk in Lucas’s hand was like an oxygen mask clutched before a crash, its tiny folds a final testament written without words.
Why?
“Why?” The light on the center console suddenly came alive, and Hannibal, seated on the left, turned to look at his husband on the right.
This time they were driving a family-sized Mercedes. When Hannibal had told the salesman he preferred white, his husband had stood beside him and paid no attention to his habit of deciding everything himself. It was a natural arrangement between them: outside the house, everything went according to Hannibal; at home, everything went according to Will. Hannibal particularly enjoyed this arrangement when other people were present. “He’s a shy child. Sometimes even more so than Lucien.” He said it as he drove onto the narrow lane leading to his brother’s house.
Lucien was the newest addition to their family, a beautiful Sheltie. Although Hannibal insisted that he had found Lucien at the end of an alley near the farmers’ market, even three-month-old Lucien would never have believed the nonsense. Will had no intention of blindly accepting Hannibal’s assessment of Lucas, either.
“He looked considerably more enthusiastic about me than you predicted.” Will pushed a small huff of laughter through his nose, ignoring Hannibal’s deliberately solemn expression as he studied the climate controls on the center console. “Don’t give me that look like this wasn’t your idea. Save it for when he points a gun at you.” He switched the ventilation from outside air to recirculation, then took one last look at the insulated container they had left in the back seat through the rearview mirror. “Which probably won’t be very far in the future.”
Hannibal, meanwhile, continued slowly down the road Lucas had once taken to the kindergarten and reached over to take Will’s left hand where it rested between them. “He won’t point a gun at me. I’m his brother,” he said, lowering his head to kiss the back of Will’s hand. “He won’t point one at you, either.”
“Because I’m his brother’s husband, or because he wants me?” Another small huff of laughter.
“Because you’re family.” Another kiss.
-
Three hours later, sitting beside the empty bookshelf, Lucas finally gave in to despair. There was absolutely no way he could conjure his brother’s home here before they returned. He could not even finish sorting this one bookshelf. His books, his son’s books, and the books belonging to his son’s mother. His own child psychology, introductory origami, and home gardening. His son’s pop art, comics with Batman on their covers, and forensic investigation. His son’s mother’s secrets of success, furniture maintenance, and an Italian fashion magazine.
It was hopeless. Lucas almost thought that keeping an introduction to forensic investigation here was a joke no one would ever laugh at.
It was not as though he was the sort of person who needed to please others. At least with his brother, he had never felt any obligation to do so. But what had happened three hours ago remained painfully vivid. Hannibal’s silence, Will’s amusement, his own bewilderment. The scene had replayed itself before his eyes for three hours, and predictably for the foreseeable future, without ever giving him an answer as to what it had meant. Was it by accident, or deliberate? If deliberate, had it been his brother’s idea, or Will’s? What had they intended? Were they testing the fragile remains of his moral boundaries, or offering him an indirect warning, telling him that whenever he looked at Will, he ought to remember that Will was his brother’s husband?
Despair. His limbs went slack, and he let gravity throw his body onto the sofa beside him like a fish cast onto shore.
The upholstery carried the scent of his favourite fragrance, the one Kirsten used to burn on the coffee table when she still lived here. Something between forest and almond. It had always brought him peace, even on the days when they fought. Now, sitting alone with his nose buried in the fabric, even the scent that had once soothed him most could not calm him.
Father had once said that even if Lucas were the last one left alive in the family, he would be proud of him. His brother had once said that there should always be at least one member of their family left in the world, no matter which one of them it was. Mother had left him Sforza. His sister had left him everything beyond the snow. The estate that had once been wealthy beyond measure became empty in a single day, at the very moment Lucas inherited everything he had now.
He had already been given everything. Everything his brother had never had. Everything his family had never had. And yet somehow, he still wanted more.
He was coveting what belonged to his brother. His brother’s most precious possession.
Greed. Lucas fought back his tears. This is what lies beneath his everything.
He remembered seeing his brother again in the backyard a few hours earlier, their outward similarities set against everything that was different within them. He remembered the intensity of murder in his brother’s eyes and the heavy weight of death inside his own. He remembered the scent of coffee beans, papaya, and cinnamon cream on his brother’s palm. They had eaten breakfast at home before coming here. They had shared the same dining room, bathed and dressed in the same bathroom, slept in the same bed. They were partners. No matter how similar Lucas and Hannibal’s features might be, he would never be the husband who slept beside Will.
He was not the Lecter who deserved to be blessed.
He was the Sforza who deserved to be cursed.
Lucas tilted his head back and looked around his large, empty house. Tears traced the too-familiar planes of his cheekbones and fell onto the cover of the gardening book in his hands.
Thou shalt not covet thy neighbour's house; thou shalt not covet thy neighbour's wife.
This could never become another home for his brother.
-
Lucas never finished the bookshelf. He placed the Italian fashion magazine in the most conspicuous position, then hid the most embarrassing books beneath the bed in the upstairs bedroom. There was almost nothing more he could do with the bedroom. All he could manage was to take the set of sheets from the wardrobe. It was far too soft for his liking. Now he could only use them to soften the omnipresent bachelor air. They were dark red, bought by his son’s mother during a mall sale. None of them liked silk bedding, but there had been no way to return it, so the sheets had remained in the wardrobe until the matter was quietly forgotten.
There. Another testament to good intentions exceeding ability. When Lucas heard the front door open, he did not even realize he was sighing.
He felt like a child who had reached the end of a weekend without finishing his homework.
When he entered the dining room, his brother was carrying the fruit they had bought at the morning market into the kitchen. His brother’s husband followed behind him and nodded to Lucas as he came through the door.
“Apple pie today.” He lifted the bag of fruit in his hand, unmistakably pleased. “I didn't expect there to be so many good ingredients in this weather. They even had apricots.” His eyes brightened as he looked at Lucas.
Lucas could only hope Will had not noticed the fists tightening at his side.
Fortunately, his brother had decided to make the Danish æblekage rather than the apple pie they used to have in the States. More fortunately still, Hannibal called him over to the sink. “There ought to be a Dane supervising me if we're going to show this dessert the respect it deserves.” Hannibal smiled as he handed him a bread knife. “You cut the bread. I handle the apples.”
When Lucas took the knife, he could almost feel Hannibal's warmth travelling through the metal handle into his palm, pumping along his veins into the rest of him. It had been years since he had stood beside his brother in a kitchen like this, since the day his brother had given him that enormous set of antlers.
Would there be opportunities like this again? Lucas felt the warmth of Hannibal beside him and wondered suddenly. His brother had a family now. Perhaps Lucas would have one again himself, before long. Ever since Hannibal found that he could not bring himself to use the word kill, he had never asked Lucas about his feelings toward killing again. Hannibal had accepted that he would never deliberately hurt another person. They were not so obviously alike in that regard. But Lucas did not know whether that meant his brother no longer wanted to share a kitchen with him.
Food was how they communicated. At least, it was how Hannibal communicated. Lucas never cared what kind of meat his brother placed on his plate, but closing his eyes and finishing whatever was put before him could not sustain the bond between them. Family cooked food for one another with love. Family felt happiness when the other ate what they had made. Lucas had received so much from his brother and had no way to repay the care behind it. He let his brother express his affection without ever offering his own feelings in return.
He remembered the letters he had never answered. The concern his brother had poured through the letter slot.
“I can whip the cream first.” He spoke before he realized what he was saying, but he did not look at Hannibal's hands as they folded the apple mixture with a spatula. His head remained lowered over the bread cubes. They were cut somewhat too finely. Hannibal seemed not to notice his unease. He simply placed the still-cold carton of cream in front of Lucas. “In a good mood today?” he teased when Lucas reached for it.
“I eat when I'm alone, too.” His younger brother's face reddened as he tried not to remember the empty pantry they had found when they came home.
“Then perhaps I should leave dinner to you.” Hannibal looked thoughtful. “We found some good quality meat.”
Even knowing he ought to accept the invitation hidden inside his brother's words, Lucas could only suppress his unease and lower his head. “I can take care of the vegetables.” He spoke almost in a whisper, his breathing too heavy in the narrow space between them. “Handling the meat at your table would be presumptuous.” His voice trembled on the final syllable. His molars ached from how tightly he clenched them.
Hannibal simply patted the arm pressed against his. “This is your table,” he said softly. “Ours.”
Family cooks food for one another with love. Family is happy when they eat what they have made.
The enormous antlers Hannibal had given him appeared before Lucas's eyes, along with the great stag he always saw, its coat black and glossy as raven feathers. The night rain was unable to wash the sin from it completely. But was it the real stag that had died beneath their guns, or something his mind had invented? If he were a faithful man, he thought suddenly, this would be the question he brought before God. What was he seeing? The antlers hanging above his bedroom, or the incarnation of the man standing beside him? And was that incarnation his most beloved brother, or the wanted criminal who regarded the living as livestock? What had kept him from preparing dinner for his brother all these years? His seemingly unshakable morality, or the stinginess he had never wanted to confront in himself—the stinginess he reserved for his brother?
Feeding and eating. Giving and answering. Offering and returning.
When he left his hometown alone in that carriage. When he used the key to open this door. When he walked among the mountain winds and spruce trees. When he watched movies with his wife and son. When he buried Fanny beneath that heavy earth. Everything he had enjoyed had been a gift from his brother. His brother could have taken his place on that carriage. He could have laid the death of their sister at Lucas's feet. He could have imprisoned him for the decades that followed and forced him to endure everything he believed he deserved. But he did not. His brother had been merciful as a god, and even after absolving Lucas of his sins, he had continued to give him his boundless care, year after year, decade after decade.
Everything he possessed was like those enormous antlers. His life. His thoughts. Every part of him came from Hannibal's grace.
“The rain stopped,” Hannibal said suddenly beside him.
Lucas looked toward the brightening sky. He did not look at his trembling hands again. What he owed his brother had never been his death or his defeat. He had spent more than thirty years as an apostate, ignoring his brother's devotion through all those thousands upon thousands of days, even when he could have answered it, even when all his brother wanted was a dinner prepared by his hands. A plate of properly cooked meat.
“Will there be a recipe that you like for the meat?” He heard his own voice echo beneath the vaulted ceiling.
When Christians give thanks at the table, which God do they imagine they are thanking?
He heard Hannibal's low laugh, reverberating through the sanctuary between them.
