Chapter Text
'I believe the perpetrator was intimately acquainted with the victim. Knew his state of health inside and out.'
Sherlock tapped his fingers impatiently against the tabletop, laying out his deduction.
'Family, or a friend? Perhaps a financial dispute, love turned to hatred, or merely a spur-of-the-moment impulse. Countless available motives.'
'I do not think this was a spur-of-the-moment act, Sherlock.'
Hannibal glanced once more at the crime scene photographs.
'This was a carefully orchestrated murder. The killer chose poison and took pains to stage the scene. He is telling a story. He is waiting for someone who understands him to uncover it.'
'Logically, it must be an intimate connection. Someone close enough to make the victim drink poison without suspicion.'
Sherlock repeated his deduction.
'Perhaps family. Who would be on their guard against their own blood? Such a relationship lowers one's defences. Poisoning becomes considerably easier.'
'Not that I'm desperate to contradict you, pretty boy,'
Crowley said, drawing the words out,
'but he was a prince. A prince so far down the line of succession it hardly bears counting. No direct benefit to killing him. And the news is hardly short on stories about his romantic entanglements and clandestine trysts. What about — oh, I don't know — membership of some very particular club? Perhaps His Highness had niche tastes that involved being suspended from things?'
The demon aimed a deeply suggestive grin at the detective.
'Why didn't you mention a lover? It's obviously far more likely. Maybe, in your view, "sex" is more of a textbook abstraction than a living, breathing experience.'
Sherlock's face darkened. His gaze flicked between Crowley and Hannibal.
'Indeed, firsthand participation does rather alter one's perspective, Sherlock.'
Hannibal's voice slid in smoothly.
'Inner desire is something that cannot be mapped out with cold data. A man with no lived experience of it cannot truly deduce what you are calling an intimate connection.'
'To put it simply, great detective—'
Crowley swung his legs up onto the table with an air of supreme ease, his tone unmistakably that of someone thoroughly enjoying the show, '—you sound like a virgin. No — you are one.'
'...What does my private life have to do with the case?'
Sherlock's expression soured further. It wasn't that the remark had struck true; it was the fact of being made the centrepiece of such a discussion that he found utterly repellent.
'Because this case demands the perspective of someone who has lived it,'
Hannibal replied, his smile soft and deliberate.
'You are obsessed with what you see as the details, Sherlock. I'm not dismissing your reasoning. On the contrary, I believe your line of thinking is sound. But you lack the visceral understanding.'
'Dr Lecter, if I may — that's all terribly poetic. Why don't we just cut straight to it?'
Crowley let out a short laugh.
'Sherlock, you've never been to bed with anyone, and your heart's not exactly thriving lately, is it? That's why you instinctively sidestepped the lover angle, even though you knew perfectly well it was the right one.'
Sherlock shot up out of his chair, like a cat that had just had its tail trodden on.
'Sex is a distraction. Emotional attachment means compromise. I require neither!'
'Look at you, great detective, categorising it all so neatly. I can't help asking — is this disdain some sort of strategy, or merely a shield to stop yourself from getting hurt?'
Crowley leaned in closer, grinning with unsparing delight.
'Look at him. He's so flustered. I'd wager his brain is working double time right now, scrabbling for an excuse, trying desperately not to blush.'
Sherlock opened his mouth, then snapped it shut. In that moment, whether he defended himself or held his tongue, both options felt equally, pathetically weak. Hah. This Crowley creature had just officially supplanted Anderson as one of the people he most detested.
Crowley's eyes glittered with the unholy glee of a prank well executed. He looked across towards John.
'John, have the two of you ever been on a proper date? Or does he tell you he's taking you out and then drag you to a crime scene instead, pointing at a corpse or whatever and waiting for you to offer up some sort of reaction?'
John said nothing. He simply felt rather awkward. Sherlock shot the demon a look that would have made a lesser man quail.
'Our relationship does not require your scrutiny.'
'That'll be a no, then!'
Crowley's smirk widened into a wicked grin.
'Not even once? That is genuinely staggering. You really are pure, Sherlock. At least Dr Watson here has had a girlfriend.'
Compared with the demon's blunt crudeness, Hannibal took a more circuitous route.
'That's enough, Crowley. Do stop teasing him. There is a unique charm in a person yet to be jostled by the vulgarities of the world.'
The two of them, playing off one another, had briefly unhinged Sherlock's reason. His mouth moved faster than his conscious mind.
'I don't see why you feel the need to mock me. My deductions hardly require that sort of... abandon!'
The tips of the detective's ears had gone faintly pink. Without quite meaning to, he glanced at the doctor, whose expression had turned rather peculiar.
'Since you both insist it was a lover, why don't you give me your reasoning? Taunting me yields no useful leads!'
'Relax, curly. It's all part of the game. And it helps us find the truth. Now — you can go and look into the prince's lovers. The killer is among them.'
Beside the demon, the angel let out a soft sigh.
'Crowley, please stop giving Mr Holmes a hard time,'
Aziraphale said, turning to the still-seething detective with a slight bow of the head.
'I do apologise for his... lack of decorum. Crowley simply refuses to comply with proper standards.'
'Rubbish. I know the rules. I just don't think they apply to me.'
Crowley shot back, then pivoted.
'Tell me, Azi, do those growths look more like a curse to you, or straightforward carcinoma?'
'I can't be certain.'
Without seeing the body in the flesh, Aziraphale could draw no conclusion.
As it happened, the door opened at that very moment, and Mycroft walked back in. The person following behind him wheeled in a gurney draped in a white sheet.
'Tsk. Just what you wanted, little angel.'
Crowley grinned, stepping forward first to pull back the sheet.
'A fresh corpse!'
