Actions

Work Header

Jest and Poison

Chapter 4: Stage and Marionette

Chapter Text

Will stepped closer as well. The body was covered in marks of abuse; the red ligature furrows at the wrists were especially pronounced. He stood still for a moment, then spoke abruptly.

'Strange... whoever the killer is, what he wants us to see goes far beyond the harm itself.'

The profiler's eyes moved across the gathering before settling on his own partner.

'Look at these marks. It's less that His Highness was subjected to abuse before death, and more... that he submitted to it willingly.'

'So it was a lover, then?'

Crowley draped a hand over Aziraphale's shoulder, though his gaze drifted towards the detective, who was eyeing him coldly.

'Clearly our killer had a profound fixation on the victim. Rather like you and John. John is your anchor. Lose him, and you'd collapse inwards — destroy yourself and everything around you. With John there, you can at least scrape by within the acceptable margins of society.'

The demon watched with satisfaction as the detective's expression darkened further, and pressed on. 'John is your tether, the sole reason you can function at all. You give nothing back, Sherlock. You're simply drawing whatever sustenance you require from the one person foolish enough to stay close to you.'

'Carry on like this, and one day that bond will simply be worn away.'

Sherlock drew in a sharp breath. The thread of his self-control was fraying dangerously; fury hovered on the brink of eruption.

'Sherlock.'

John's voice was calm — yet it stilled Sherlock with an almost uncanny effectiveness. The detective closed his mouth and returned his attention to the body before him.

A gleam of triumph flashed in Crowley's eyes. He was just gearing up to twist the knife further when the angel levelled a thoroughly limp glare at him.

'That's quite enough, Crowley.'

'...'

Reined in by his companion, the demon shut his mouth, however unwillingly.

The psychiatrist, who had taken in every last bit of this, turned to his own partner with a smile.

'They are rather entertaining, aren't they, Will?'

'Mm.'

Will nodded vaguely, having no desire whatsoever to pursue that line of conversation.

For a stretch, no one spoke. The atmosphere in the room turned abruptly stifling.

One minute. Three. Five.

Sherlock abruptly straightened up, his gaze cutting towards Hannibal with scalpel precision.

'You have shown absolutely no interest in the body, Lecter. Why?'

'I assumed that, with you present, examining the corpse was hardly my remit.'

Hannibal maintained his smile.

The detective's voice went several degrees colder in reply.

'A normal person, presented with a body in this gruesome state, would feel revulsion. In your eyes, there is only appreciation. What's more, from the moment we met, you have been performing. Every gesture, every expression — calculated.'

Hannibal did not rush to defend himself. His look turned deeply suggestive.

'So. Are you accusing me?'

'The detective isn't talking complete nonsense.'

Crowley piled in, as though the situation weren't fraught enough already.

'You're a psychiatrist, not a saint. No one needs to exercise that much restraint unless they're hiding something. So — what is it you're hiding beneath that polished veneer, Lecter?'

John and Aziraphale looked towards their respective companions with expressions caught somewhere between puzzlement and fascination. Will looked at Hannibal, and in his gaze there was, besides the confusion, a subtle, barely detectable flicker of worry.

Hannibal remained silent. The ghost of a smile tugged at the corner of his mouth — invisible to anyone not looking closely.

Sherlock began to sweep his eyes over Hannibal from head to toe, finally letting them rest on his hands.

'Calluses between the thumb and forefinger. You spend the better part of your day gripping something other than a fountain pen. Either you moonlight as a surgeon, or you're a chef — or a butcher.'

'Just like the person who committed this murder, you need an acolyte. Someone to place you on a pedestal and affirm your worth.'

The detective's gaze flicked, briefly, towards Will, who had gone inexplicably tense.

'You've guided him. Made him adapt to you, seek your counsel — even when he knows you are wrong and he is right. But it's far too late now. He's caught in the undertow and can't pull himself free.'

John followed Sherlock's line of sight and noticed, too, that the way Will was looking at Hannibal was distinctly unusual.

Sherlock's voice sharpened further.

'You need an obedient puppet. Will is merely a prop on your stage. You are forever performing. What, exactly, are you rehearsing for?'

Hannibal let out a low, soft laugh — indulgent, as though humouring a wayward child.

'Fascinating, Sherlock. But unverified conjecture has a way of transforming the perfectly ordinary into something grotesque.'

'Gentlemen, perhaps we might set this aside for the moment. There are rather more pressing questions at hand.'

Aziraphale was attempting to defuse the subject. Whatever problematic undercurrents existed between Hannibal and Will, they were hardly the current concern. The angel cast a look towards John, and John caught his meaning at once.

'Er — Aziraphale's right, Sherlock. Let's keep focused on the case. Whatever else is going on, Hannibal can't be the killer.'

The corner of Hannibal's mouth lifted in amusement. Sherlock caught the shift and answered with a provocative grin of his own.

'The killer clearly possesses medical knowledge. He wanted the tumours to be seen. But cancer doesn't simply appear out of nowhere and progress to a terminal stage in a matter of days.'

'It's a curse, great detective.'

Crowley rolled his eyes, with a complete want of dignity.

'It's hardly going to yield to your science. Perhaps our prince just ate something he really oughtn't to have. Full stop.'

The demon continued, his voice low.

'It's not complicated. The trigger for the curse may well be some species of Amanita. He shouldn't have crossed a witch. They can hold a fearsome grudge.'

Sherlock answered Crowley's theory with a contemptuous snort.

'You're right about one thing — amatoxin poisoning can indeed cause acute hepatic necrosis. That is likely the cause of death. However—'

The detective paused for emphasis.

'How do you propose to explain early-stage cancer evolving into a terminal condition within a single week? Metastasis cannot possibly complete itself over a handful of days.'

'Congratulations, Sherlock. You've finally landed on something useful.'

Crowley let out a bark of laughter.

'But you'll never see the truth of it, because you refuse to believe in supernatural forces. As I said — the mushroom was merely the trigger. His Highness, quite plainly, died of his own arrogance.'

'The prince was due to marry Princess Anna of Denmark in three months,' Will added quietly.

'Which means... the lover's motive was feeling betrayed by the prince?'

John spoke thoughtfully, and Sherlock gave a small, reluctant nod of agreement. The detective didn't accept the curse theory for a moment, but the toxic mushroom as the murder weapon, and a spurned lover's revenge as the motive — those he could fully endorse. In fact, having assembled all the available data, that was precisely where his own reasoning had led.

Now that they had identified the toxin, the killer and the motive, the case could be considered closed.

Sherlock was already itching to get out of this cramped little room and away from the people he loathed.

And then his partner was waylaid by Will.

'John, I wondered... if you're free, would you like to come to ours for dinner?'

Will's expression carried a trace of hesitation, but his tone was firm.

'Hannibal is an excellent cook. "Professional" would be nearer the mark, really. I think you'd both enjoy it.'

His gaze shifted towards the angel and demon on the other side of the room.

'You'd be most welcome as well, gentlemen.'

John blinked, then broke into a smile.

'That sounds lovely. I think Sherlock and I would be glad to come.'

'We'll come, too,' Aziraphale chimed in with a nod. 'I'm rather fond of good food.'

'Dinner?'

Sherlock's exclamation of sheer disbelief rang out as his eyes shot from Will to Hannibal. Comprehension dawned in an instant.

'Absolutely not!' (×2)

Crowley's refusal was every bit as vehement as his own. The demon fixed Hannibal with a glare cold and sharp as a blade.

At the very centre of the storm, the psychiatrist appeared preternaturally calm.

'I would be delighted to prepare dinner for you all. It would be my pleasure.'

'...'

The flame of obstinate refusal still burned in Sherlock's eyes. Crowley, however, after exchanging a look with the angel, let his head drop and sighed.

To Will, their silence meant acquiescence.

'This evening, then?'

—

By the time they got back to 221B, the hour was still reasonably early. John began sorting through his case notes. Even though he wouldn't be able to publish anything, given the royal connection, keeping a record had long since become habit.

At the same time, he spoke musingly. 'Sherlock, I think you're overreacting to those two pairs. Quite a bit.'

Sherlock stood at the window, his back to his friend.

'Overreacting? John, can you honestly not see it? That dangerous symbiotic relationship between Lecter and Graham! One of them is carefully cultivating; the other is willingly succumbing.'

'And what about Aziraphale and Crowley?'

'I detest that ill-mannered ginger git. He's absolutely going to hell when he dies.'

'Well, I'd say they're not so different from us. Everyone's got their own way of dealing with people.'

John stopped typing and let out a sigh.

'Are you still determined to object to Will's dinner invitation?'

Sherlock nodded, looking faintly agitated.

'I don't require a meticulously prepared dinner to prove anything. That Lecter... he strikes me as dangerous.'

'Perhaps they'd simply like to be friends, Sherlock,' John said gently.

Sherlock gave a derisive sniff.

'No, John. It was never simply about dinner.'

John watched Sherlock pacing the room, and then something clicked.

'You're worried about me?'

Sherlock stopped walking. He didn't answer — but the silence itself said everything.

'Oh, Sherlock!'

John broke into a smile of wondering delight.

'You never stop surprising me!'

He rose to his feet, crossed to his friend and took hold of his hand, drawing him towards the bedroom.

'Relax. It's only dinner. Nothing's going to happen. And right now, let's give a bit of thought to what we're going to wear tonight. Crowley had a point — that coat of yours may be very dashing, but you can't stick to a single style forever, can you?'

Sherlock: '...'

He didn't pull his hand away. In silence, he followed where the doctor led.

(The End)