Chapter Text
After filling my stomach with smoked bacon and trail-bread liberally spread with salted butter, it was time to descend once more into the depths of the mountain and face the dragon for the second time. It was too early to tell whether my actions had managed to have any effect upon Thorin’s artificial gold-lust. I would simply have to proceed with my plan without his approval, but I had faith that he would see my reasoning – that it was our best option at the moment. As for Angmar, I had not yet made up my mind what I wanted to do about his subtle treachery. I did not know quite enough about him to decide on a suitable punishment. One advantage at least of this sojourn down the tunnel was the time it would give me to think. To think, and plan, and try and make the world fit into a mould of fate that would work out best for all of us.
I had not gone far along the passage before I felt again the upswell of earth-fire rising up around me, throbbing beneath my feet. Wary and keeping in mind the overwhelming power of it, the force that could not be fought and could barely be controlled by gentle, subtle persuasion, I reached out for it once more. I had been careful enough the first time, and I was more careful now. I did not so much call it up as sink down to meet it, like immersing myself in a warm bath – although the heat of this bath defied any description or comparison I could think to make.
Yet I could not stop my mind grasping for metaphors, trying to make sense of this primal force. Like a blanket, like baking, half-liquid mud clinging under my skin, I took the power of the earth-fire into me. I held myself back from it as much as I could, aware of the presence of the Ring purring on my finger, a link that allowed me to centre myself. It made a little more sense then, using it as a buffer against the mountain’s memory of its blood. It knew this power intimately, had been born in it, drew from it as easily as a dragon breathing its fire. It understood, and shared that understanding with me.
I refocused on the task I had come here to do. Parlay with the dragon, with Smaug the Terrible.
I tried not to let any fear into me as I walked the passageway to the treasury, slipping as I did so back into invisibility. I couldn’t afford to doubt what I was doing, or I would lose confidence and surely at the worst possible moment. Like any predator – and the Shire had enough of the ordinary kind that I felt right in thinking it – any sign or show of weakness would only tantalise the dragon’s instincts, turn me from stranger and unknown quantity into prey. Since I had no intention of being eaten, I couldn’t risk making that mistake.
Smaug was awake and alert when I began to silently descend the steps towards him. His head turned vaguely towards me, but by the scanning of his eyes over the maze of pillars and stepped platforms, I did not think he knew quite where I had appeared from. I was still wary enough to want to keep it that way.
“So, silent and cloaked one, you have come again,” the dragon said, his voice ringing and rolling like the chimes of a bell, filling up the vast hall. “You are either very bold, or very foolish.”
“Or I know enough about dragons to know to keep my word,” I replied, once I had reached the foot of the stairs and moved away a little to disguise my route. “I said I would speak with you again, and so here I am.”
“And do you have more riddles for me today? Perhaps the riddle of how Dwarf and Dragon may live side by side in peace?” He huffed out a short burst of rumbling laughter, dark smoke coming with it.
“I hope I can answer that riddle for you, Great Smaug,” I said. “But first I would pose to you another. What use to you is gold you can never touch, or jewels you can never see?”
“There is much of both in the bones of Arda and in the houses of Men, Elves and Dwarves,” Smaug replied. “I have taken what I can of that which is my right, and I would take more if the getting of it would not leave this trove unguarded.”
“It is the bones of this mountain of which I wish to speak,” I said. “Anyone would only have to look at the hopes of the Lake-men to see that the mines here must be far from depleted, even for all the treasure that I can see in this hall. It is beyond the touch or appreciation of any creature. Can you truly tell me that pleases you?”
“Better in the ground than leaving the mountain altogether, to go I know not where,” Smaug told me. “Though it is true enough it were better where I could see it. In days of old, so I am told, the orks, the goblins, the multitudes that followed Melkor’s banner all dug it for us, we favoured allies of that spirit of shadow who loved the fire. Do you suggest your dwarves would take up that task? Their pride would not allow it – you should know better.”
“That isn’t entirely what I am suggesting,” I replied. “Nor, I suppose, can I do more than suggest it just yet, for I will talk to Thorin only when there is at least some bare shadow of an agreement to present to him. But I would not want to become your enemy, O Fierce and Mighty Smaug.”
“No, you would not,” the dragon said, lowering his head towards me with the hint of fangs showing. “You amuse me, so I listen, but you do not bargain from strength. You have not the armies of Mairon or his might, little thief and imitation. Yet I have not spoken with another in many a long year, so speak on, youngling mortal.”
“And are you satisfied with your loneliness?” I asked, with more pique than perhaps was wise.
I was lucky – he seemed to find this amusing, rather than an insult and thus an excuse to eat me. “In two thousand years, I have become used to the inevitability,” Smaug said, curling back onto his hoard, no longer so threatening. “My kind was never numerous, and many have left these lands for others far stranger and further away than I suspect you can imagine. I have but cold-drakes for company now, curled in their caves far away north and east. I came south for this hoard when none of them were willing to risk the attempt. I cannot truly say I miss their company overmuch, although I shall have to visit them at least once in the next century or so.”
“Well wouldn’t you appreciate having more people around to talk to?” I asked.
“Dwarves you mean,” Smaug said, chuckling. “Unless they are all as interestingly bold as you, I doubt it. I am satisfied enough with my slumber and my memories.”
I am a forthright fellow by nature, and I had had enough of pussy-footing around what I wanted to say. It was not in the nature of Hobbits to make a deal out of haggling and bartering, and what was diplomacy but that on the scale of nations and powers? I decided to come and out and state my plan plainly. “My idea was this,” I said, “that the dwarves – and their kin from Ered Luin, also formerly of Erebor – would return to their lives here, and reopen the mines as well, and tithe you a certain amount yet to be agreed upon for your kindness and forbearance in letting them do so.”
I still do not know quite what it was that made this the last plate that breaks the table, unless it was the sheer perceived temerity of it. Smaug’s eyes narrowed, his wings mantled and billowed up stiffly, his lips drew back over his massive teeth and he reared up half-way onto his haunches.
“Do you think to turn my gaze away from your thievery with petty bribes?” he said in a voice like a great wind. Smoke billowed around his jaws, the bright light of flames rippling at the back of his throat. I reached out in alarm for the molten heat still running beneath my skin, letting it well up, and through, and over. “You speak thus to me? I am Smaug of the Line of Fire! My armour is as ten-fold shields, my teeth are swords, my claws spears, the blows of my tail are as the strikes of lightning! My wings are a hurricane and my breath is death itself!”
Smaug’s mouth stretched wide, a gaping maw, and from it spewed fire in a sticky torrent like a waterfall. It crashed down upon me, stealing my breath away in a wash of boiling air. Yet it did not hurt me. The dragon’s power was in his weapon, and that power resonated with the sorcerous song that underpinned the earth-blood, falling into a kind of harmony that let the two mingle and combine, one with the other and myself along with all of it. The Ring crowed with joy and exhilaration.
The fire stopped eventually as Smaug perceived that it was not burning me up as he had wished. I was left with my form outlined in flames, dripping from me in little spits to land and sizzle against the wash of melting gold that now churned about my feet. I glared up at the enraged dragon, shaking the remnants of his conflagration from me as I would water after a heavy rain.
I was more angry than frightened at his sudden attack, but still he was armed with more than his blazing breath. He bared his vicious teeth at me, seeing now where I was, and his neck curved backwards as though to make some serpentine strike towards me. I cast about me in alarm, realising just what serious trouble I was in. My gaze tracked over the jewel-encrusted mass of his belly. Then I saw it. A small bare patch upon the deep barrel of his chest just over his heart.
The Ring was crying out to me, offering its power freely. It had no desire to swim in a dragon’s belly for however long it took to be passed out again, even if the fires therein could not hurt it. Looking about for a weapon I came upon a sturdy spear, needle-tipped with steel. Spells I wound about it in a single drawn-out moment, a hurried and abbreviated strain of song, and then with witch-craft strength I sent it whirring up through the air to sit, poised and just penetrating, in the hollow of that single vulnerable spot.
Smaug froze. He looked down. Slowly he let his mouth close, his poised neck relax, his wings sink back down. The spear shuddered against his tender hide, the song that held it there a drawn-out soprano note that trembled with expectation of the melody to come.
“So are you done?” I asked with anger. “Are you prepared to be reasonable now?”
I was not expecting the dragon to laugh. It was a quiet rumble that rose up through his chest and grew to fill the hoard-hall. He regarded me with a look that seemed oddly fond.
“I have not been thus challenged in many centuries,” he said, half-purring. “I find I like it. Perhaps you have something of the mountain’s blood within you after all, rather than merely wearing it as a mask. Very well. I shall speak with the dwarves of this treaty of yours, and we shall see what the end result shall be. I have patience and time enough for it.”
“Thank you,” I said, feeling a flood of relief. “I appreciate your co-operation, I really do. I would hate for this to come to bloodshed.”
Again the dragon laughed. “Would you so?” he asked. “Force is a tool to be wielded to enact will, and by your boasting riddle-names you have made use of it in the past. You cannot deny this, nor make the world other than it is.”
I hesitated. “I do not believe,” I said slowly, “that violence, or making war, is always as necessary as you seem to think. Perhaps it is so for great kingdoms, but where I come from it is a rare and terrible thing. Although I have to admit that in all my travels outside of the boundaries of my home I have seen races come to blows often.” I turned the thought over in my mind. Yes, there were war and dark feelings aplenty in Middle-Earth; between elf and dwarf, between orcs and most others, and many a time between members of the same country or land. I could not pretend to understand the vast history that stretched back and soured things between these folk, the reasons that they feuded. It was still so alien to my upbringing and the culture of hobbits.
“Those who claim themselves the children of the light have always held darkness within them, much as they are loath to admit it,” Smaug told me. He lightly reached up and brushed the still-quivering spear from its place. The spells around it tore like fragile cobweb, and it clattered to the ground. A single bead of ichor welled up from the tiny wound. “Melkor sung duality into the world in its forming. He sung a symphony of morality so that it would not be a dull and lifeless place, an unchanging glass bauble preserved in ice as Eru Ilúvatar and his followers would have had it. Life and death, joy and pain. We his allies knew and acknowledged his gifts to us.”
“That doesn’t mean that there should be all these foolish wars and disagreements between everyone,” I argued. “People hating and killing each other over... what?”
“And would you prefer to exert your will and power to stop them?” Smaug asked, with the curve of a smile that showed no teeth.
“Perhaps that would be better for everyone,” I replied hotly. “I suppose if I had all of Mairon’s armies I would just tell everyone to be happy in their homes and stop going invading other peoples’, and to help out their neighbours when they need it, and to forget and forgive all these long ago grievances! Maybe things would be better if someone was willing to stand up and prevent all this fighting!”
“Now you speak as one who may be worthy of that Ring.” Smaug’s tail curled over and around on itself, languorously rubbing scale upon scale. Some foreign Ring-instinct recognised it as pleasure. “If that is your will for Arda, why not go forth and make it thus?”
“I confess I hadn’t thought much beyond regaining Erebor,” I said. “I suppose I thought I would just be going home, but of course with all that’s happened, with how much I’ve changed, that would be quite impossible.”
“Then shall we make this an addendum to our deal,” Smaug said. “For I would see what you do with your power. It would be a fine and glorious thing, a wondrous sight that has not been seen in these lands for centuries. For this I would be generous with my property, in honour of old bonds and allegiances.”
“I... I shall certainly give it some consideration,” I replied, struck with surprise. I had not expected this subject to come up, nor the dragon’s fierce interest in it. Perhaps he had not been entirely truthful when he claimed not to be lonely and bored. Perhaps I gave him the promise of novelty and entertainment. And I could not deny that there was a certain allure to the idea. It had vexed me much on our journey to see the discord in the lands outside the Shire, and surely since I had come into such power I had the responsibility to do some good with it?
I throw my support behind this idea, the Ring whispered to me. It pleases me much. This is the work I was made for, this is worthy of me.
I shall not be doing it on your behalf, but on the behalf of everyone hurt by pointless feuds, I replied. This did not seem to dissuade it any.
“So you will agree to meet with Thorin and discuss this system of tithe then?” I asked out loud.
“If you will have me play the role of a landlord then why not?” Smaug said. “Although it is beneath me.”
“Very well,” I said, more than a little relieved. Things had not exactly gone as I had planned, and it had been rather touch and go there for a bit, but in the end it seemed to have worked out. My overly audacious plan appeared to be coming to pass. I was preparing myself to leave, making sure that all the fire that clutched to my person had been extinguished or brushed off and that I could not be seen, when a sudden thought occurred to me.
“Before I go, I would ask your advice about something,” I said, “if that is amenable to you.”
“Whatever it is I may be assured that it shall be interesting,” the dragon replied.
I hesitated, but surely at this point it could do no harm. I did not intend on using the Nazgûl against him, and would not have risked them against the torrent of his breath even if there had been a need.
“There are a number of... servants, who came under my control when I took command of the Ring,” I said. “Perhaps you know of them?”
“The Nine, yes. My, what trouble could they have caused?”
“It was Angmar’s doing,” I replied, not appreciating his smugness. “A subtle treachery through a lie of omission. The trouble is that I do not know what way is best to punish him.”
The dragon hummed in his throat, a vibration I could easily feel from where I stood. “To truly hurt a creature,” he said, “you must find out what he values. What he fears. What causes a Wraith’s heart to tremble, little Ring-bearer? What will give him the greatest grief and anguish?”
“How am I to find out that?” I asked, annoyed. It was all very well to say, less simple it seemed to do.
“He is still bound to you, is he not?” Smaug pointed out. “Why, you must force him to tell you. What better way to start a punishment than for the offender themselves to set the terms of it?”
“Ah,” I said, seeing the sense of it. “Thank you, Great Smaug. I shall go and act on your advice.” I bowed, though he could not see it, and began to head for the stairs.
“I shall look forward to the next of our conversations,” the dragon called after me. “You are a most intriguing creature.”
----
I surfaced into the bright, warm light of early autumn. The earth-fire seeped slowly out of my limbs, leaving them trembling slightly. The effort of keeping that power under control had been substantial. The Company waited for me around the embers of the fire, the Nazgûl lurking in the shadows cast by the eaves of rock that sheltered the ledge. They turned to look at me, Angmar with a certain wariness. The dwarves followed their gaze, and saw me as I faded back into the mortal world.
“You have survived the dangers of the dragon again, Bilbo,” Thorin said, with a smile of relief. “I am glad to see you returned safely.”
I felt relief of my own; there was no avarice for the treasures below in his eyes. His concern was for me, and me alone, and it warmed my heart.
“All is well,” I said. “I have spoken with Smaug, and it seems diplomacy has won through despite the unlikelihood. I have the beginnings of an accord to present to you.”
“Are you sure that is entirely a wise move lad?” Balin asked. He was not the only one who looked at me with doubt.
“I do not think he is without honour,” I replied. “He seems to have some respect for me, or at least he finds me amusing enough to go along with what I want for now. The long and short of it is that he is formidable indeed, and I do not like our chances against him in battle.”
“What of a weak spot?” Dwalin asked. “Was there none of that?”
“A small patch on his belly,” I confessed. “But not easy to hit save with archery or thrown weapons, and when he is moving and using his fire and claws against us? Through the power of the Ring I have some immunity to his flame, but I could not stretch it to cover more than one other of us, and not even the Wraiths can stand against the terrible power of his breath.” It was true that I could have bested him not hours before if I had wanted, but he would not be so careless of his vulnerability again. I would not be given a second chance at it.
There was much consternation and grumbling at my news. Thorin particularly appeared deep in thought. I wondered in that moment how he had perceived his own resistance to the idea of an agreement the day before. Did he think it odd how fixated he had been upon the hoard? Or did he put it down to some quirk of tiredness, of the long journey, a weak moment when some baser instinct surfaced?
“Let us make no decision before we hear what sort of truce Bilbo has negotiated for us,” Thorin said at last, cutting through the various discussions.
“I think we may have to accept that the treasure of Thrór is lost to the dragon,” I said. “But the seams of Erebor are still rich, or so I believe, and Smaug will let you return here and work them if you tithe some amount to him, though there has been no agreement on the details. I know this is far from what any of you were hoping for, but as you have told it to me this quest was more about reclaiming your homeland than the hoard.”
“And for revenge, do not forget that,” Fili said, with force.
“What use is revenge when you die in the attempt and do not even manage to kill the object of your ire?” I asked. “I do not mean to force you into this position, but surely the only option is to be practical?”
“Do not think we can so easily abandon the memories of all those of our kinsmen the dragon slew when he came here,” Thorin said quietly, his arms folded across his chest. I could tell he was disquieted. “His crimes against our people are great. Nor does it sit easily within our hearts to abandon such a mass of gold that is rightfully ours. It is not in our natures.”
“And it seems wrong to come here and then be afraid to commit ourselves,” Kili said. “We are dwarves, aren’t we? We should not be afraid!”
“You would not say that had you seen him,” I replied, horrified visions of the young dwarves consumed in flames suddenly flitting across my mind’s eye.
“Perhaps we should,” Thorin said suddenly. “We shall have to think much on this proposition of yours, and in the meantime you said you could extend your protection across another. It seems to me best if I accompany you down next time and speak to the dragon myself.”
I had been intending to put this forward for him at some point, but I had not intended it to be so soon. I had wanted to keep him up here, safe and out of danger until I had the dragon’s word that he would not hurt any of the Company. But Thorin was right. This grievance was his more than any other amongst our number, and it should be he who bargained for terms that would affect him most of all.
“Yes, of course,” I said. “But I do not think it should be today. I think I rely in part on Smaug’s fascination with me, and I would not want him to grow too used to me else that lessens. I think once we have his word he will not break it, but before then I cannot say.”
“Then it shall be so,” Thorin replied with a decisive nod of his head. “We of the Company will discuss this amongst ourselves for the rest of the day, and then I shall go into the mountain with you on the morrow.”
“I need to speak to the Nine now in any case,” I said, happy with this plan. “Thank you for being willing to listen to my idea though. I know it is not exactly the role you intended for me when you first took me on as Burglar.”
“Roles change,” Thorin replied. “Certainly you have changed the most out of all of us.”
“And I hope it shall prove to be for the better in the end.”
“I believe it is,” he said, and I could see the warmth shining in his eyes. I would have stretched up to kiss him then if dwarven propriety had not still prevented it, and indeed it was hard to resist the urge. But instead I merely had to leave him with a smile, and the unspoken promise that the time was not long hence when we should be free to show our feelings for each other.
----
I led the Nine away from the hollow and onto the bare rock of the mountain’s shoulder. This was not a conversation I deemed it wise to have within earshot of the Company. They followed me silently, drifting over the rough terrain like the ghostly things they were. Angmar led them, back straight and proud. If he knew the reason for this, he gave no sign of it. I did not know how closely they were bound to the other Rings of Power; it was entirely possible he was aware that I had altered the Ring of Durin’s hold on Thorin, and equally so that he was not.
When I judged that we had gone far enough, I stopped and beckoned for the Nazgûl to gather around me.
“I have called you away like this to deal with a very serious matter,” I said. “I know I may not seem like I give it all the weight that you think I ought, but I am Master of the One, and you are all bound to serve me. I do not mean to be lenient in allowing those who break these bonds to go unpunished.”
“What do you mean, little lord?” Khamûl asked. “We have done nothing against your wishes.”
He seemed to be honestly confused, and I read the same from most of the others also, their emotions displayed openly through the links to their Rings. It was only Angmar who remained closed off to me. If he had not before, he knew I had found him out now. It was clear that he was the only one I had to blame though. The others were innocent of any crime.
“Most of you have not,” I told them. “But Angmar knows of what I speak.”
“I make no argument in my defence,” he replied, haughty and unashamed. “If you were a master worthy of us, you would have known the truth I did not speak.”
Eight heads turned to stare at him, but he bore the gaze of his kin easily. The nature of the Ring he bore may have forced him to obey the letter of my commands, but his spirit was his own, and he was too proud to easily bow the knee. It would have been a quality that I respected, save that it had resulted in harm to one I held most dear.
“And now your treachery is laid bare,” I replied. “And so you must be punished.”
I could see the sneer on his ghostly face beneath the shadows of his hood. He did not say it, but I could see he thought little of whatever torments I might think of. I imagine that Mairon must have been both cruel and imaginative in his retributions; it was not surprising that I seemed rather pitiful in comparison.
“Thus,” I said, “on the power of the One I command you. Tell me what it is you fear most. What penalty will most grieve and distress you?”
As I spoke I could feel my words resonate along the link that bound us together. Power spilled along the subtle chain, such that it could not be resisted. Angmar fought it, but this was simply another iteration of a mandate that he had never had a hope of resisting from the first day that he took his Ring into his possession. This was an echo of every demand Mairon had ever made of him. The words were forced out of him, past clenched teeth and a leaden tongue.
“I fear most of all death, after so many years of immortality. I fear having my power taken from me. I fear the memory of fire, though it hurts me not. I fear being forgotten, that no man should speak my name, be it in fear or in love. I fear loss of purpose. I fear that our cause, so many thousands of years and ages in the making, shall falter and die in the hands of one who does not fully understand it.”
I held up my hand to silence him. “That will be enough.”
Death, though it might have been his greatest fear, left something to be desired as an effective punishment. For one thing, it was rather hard to learn anything from the experience. For another, even with his disloyalty Angmar was too valuable a servant to sacrifice so easily. Even if he could never be trusted, he could still be unleashed against targets that roused his ire regardless of my feelings about them.
The other fears though, they held more potential.
What do you think? I asked the Ring. Which of these might be carried out?
The Ring must have decided that explaining with words would take too long, for instead it flooded my mind with knowledge. Spells of binding, spells to sap strength, spells to banish a wraith back to its grave – for indeed he had one, for the process that had brought him to the state he was in now had not been quick, as I now learned. He had worn human flesh for some time in the kingdom on Angmar, ‘til he was brought low at the battle of Fornost. That had been a blow for the Nine, much diminished without him, their citadel at Minas Ithil – renamed Minas Morgul – not yet entirely brought over to their power. The men of the North had interred him, weak and helpless, in a deep tomb in the High Fells. Where better to return him for a while, where the memory of his defeat would be thick in the air, his shame and his rage?
I reached for the power that the Ring gave me willingly, starting to weave and sing the spells into being. Angmar perceived what I was doing, his knowledge of witch-craft great, but this was punishment rightfully earned, and he could do nothing to stop me. The others of the Nine drew back with something close to fear.
The sorceries were complicated, but with the Ring to guide me soon they were complete. I let them free into the air to wrap around Angmar’s spirit, wrenching it cruelly through the aether. He was gone, sent back to his grave and bound there, unable to use his magic to free himself, unknowing of how long I would keep him there. He would hate it, and I could only hope it would teach him not to cross me in future. Perhaps the very cruelty of it would garner me some respect.
“There,” I said to the others. “It is done.”
